EP03 - True History of Mahabharata with Ami Ganatra Ji | The GyanJaraHatke Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 авг 2024
- Welcome to the Gyan Jara Hatke Show, where we delve deep into the intriguing world of ancient Indian epics, particularly the Mahabharata. Join us as we unravel the complexities and nuances of this timeless epic, exploring its characters, themes, and timeless lessons for the modern world.
In this podcast with our guest Ami Ji, we dissect various aspects of the Mahabharata, from its intricate plotlines to the motivations behind key characters' actions. From Bhismpitamah's conflict with Dharma to Draupadi's enigmatic persona, we leave no stone unturned in our quest for understanding.
We aim to make the Mahabharata accessible to all, while also challenging common misconceptions and myths surrounding this epic tale.
So, whether you're a seasoned scholar of ancient Indian literature or simply curious about the stories that have shaped our cultural heritage, tune in to the Gyan Jara Hatke Show for a fresh perspective on the Mahabharata like never before.
#Mahabharat #AmiGanatra #Shakuni #Mahabharata
Books:
Mahabharata Unravelled (English)
amzn.to/3T0wdZL
Mahabharata Unravelled (Hindi)
amzn.to/3UKMJhI
Timeline:
00:00:00 - Flashback
00:00:49 - Introduction to the Guest and Topic of the Podcast
00:02:00 - Why is Mahabharata so complicated as compared to the Ramayana?
00:07:50 - What is the Story of Bhismapitamah and his conflict with Dharma?
00:16:10 - What was Dhritrashtra’s significance as a King?
00:20:10 - What is the source of Duryodhan’s hatred towards the Pandavas?
00:25:24 - Was Gandhari failed to stop the rising difference between Duryodhan and Pandavas
00:26:52 - What were the characters of other Kauravas?
00:27:42 - How Draupadi was portrayed, as “Naari Shakti” or as an “Abla Nari”?
00:33:48 - Why do few historians portray Mahabharatha/Ramayana as Mysognist?
00:42:12 - What is the description of Shakuni in the actual text of Ved Vyas Ji?
00:55:20 - What is the description of Karn in the actual text of Ved Vyas Ji?
01:23:06 - Why did Arjun always require Shree Krishna’s ‘updates’ during the War?
01:30:14 - What role does Vidur play in the Mahabharata?
01:36:58 - What is the story of Dharmaraj Yudhishthira and Draupadi’s Vastraharan?
Subscribe to GyanJaraHatke Channel
/ @gjhshow
This is a sister channel of GyanJaraHatke. We provide Knowledgeable content in simple language with a touch of humour.
So follow us for that
/ @gyanjarahatke
Disclaimer:
Welcome to "The GyanJaraHatke Show"! Before we dive into our intellectually stimulating content, it's important to acknowledge a few essential points.
1. Personal Views of Guests: All views, opinions, suggestions, or instructions expressed by our esteemed guests on "The GyanJaraHatke Show" are entirely their own and independent. The host of the podcast, Saurabh Maheshwari, neither supports nor opposes the views, opinions, suggestions, or instructions provided by the guests. The show is a platform for diverse perspectives, and the views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the host or the podcast.
2. Fair Use Policy: "The GyanJaraHatke Show" adheres to the principles of fair use as defined in copyright law. We strive to ensure that our use of copyrighted material, including images, music, and other media, falls within the boundaries of fair use. If you believe any content on our channel infringes on your copyright, please contact us for resolution.
3. Copyright: We respect and comply with all content copyright laws related to RUclips. Any unauthorized use, reproduction, or distribution of our content without permission is strictly prohibited. If you have questions about the use of our content, feel free to reach out to us.
4. RUclips Policy and Community Guidelines: "The GyanJaraHatke Show" is committed to maintaining a channel that complies with RUclips's policies and community guidelines. We take great care to ensure our content aligns with the platform's standards. If you come across any content that you believe violates RUclips's policies, please report it, and we will address the issue promptly.
5. Strikes: We make every effort to avoid any form of RUclips strikes or community guideline violations. If you have concerns about our content or believe there has been an error, please contact us directly before taking any action. We are dedicated to resolving issues amicably and in compliance with RUclips's policies.
Thank you for being a part of "The GyanJaraHatke Show" community. Your support and understanding are vital as we navigate these guidelines and policies to bring you the best content possible. Stay engaged, stay curious, and let's continue this journey together! 🚀 
Развлечения
कर्ण के बारे में अगर अमी गणात्राजी के अलावा कोई और बोलता तो में विश्वास नही करता पर अमीजी बहुत ही ज्ञान से भरपूर है । बहुत कुछ नया सीखने को मिला।धन्यवाद सौरभ भाई इस पॉडकास्ट के लिए❤️❤️
Bhai vishwaas kisi ke bhi kehne pr mt karo jaake padh lo .bilkul sahi bol rahi hai .
She is stupid
Masta Pela Tha Arjun Ne Karna Ko Virat Yudha Me ❤❤❤❤
@@Parthasarathi_7106🤣 Mahabharat ke yudh me to abhimanyu,satyaki aur bheem se to 🏹me haar gya🤣
Mahabharat granth se bata rahi dyut sabha pe jis vajah se Yudhishthir ji DharmRaaj kehlaaye dyut ke baad bhi, padh sakte hai jaake :
1:39:53 Yudhishthir ji dyut khelne keliye nahi gaye the balki unhe Vedvyas ji ki bhavishyavaani yaad aai ki Pandav Kaurav me mahayuddh hoga jo na ho isliye ve prastav ko thukrake Kauravo ka apman karna thik nahi samjhe isliye gaye.. aur Yudhishthir ji dyut sabha me jaake bhi baar baar dyut ko adharm aur paap kahe Dhritrashtra aur sabhi rajao ko samjhane ka prayas kiye, ye bhi kahe ki unhe khelna hi nahi aata jispe Shakuni se lambi debate chali Yudhishthir ji ki jahan Shakuni pucha ki dyut ko adharm kyo keh rahe jispe Yudhishthir ji kehte hai ki shathta ka prayog hota hai isme aur shathta se sampatti rajya jeetna Kshatriya ko shobha nahi deta aur isse vinaash bhi hota hai isliye dyut me shathta hai isliye dyut adharm hai aur ispe Shakuni kehne laga ki Shathta ka prayog to Brahman bhi karte hai shaastrarth me ityadi..
Shakuni ke baat ko agar galat kehte to Yudhishthir ji ka tark jhutha aur ve swayam avishwas ke paatr hai siddh hojata aur unki baat jhuthi nahi thi.. Shakuni ke tark ko sahi kehte ya vahan se chale jate maun rehke to bhi Shakuni ka Brahmano pe aarop sahi sabit hota jisse samaaj me phoot padta, praja me ekta bani rahe aur Brahmano ki samman bani rahe isliye Yudhishthir ji dyut khelne keliye majburi me taiyyar hue varna ve to khelne se mana karke chale ja rahe the dyut shuru hone se pehle hi...
Praja ekta ki raksha keliye dyut khele jisme shuru me hi praja sampatti daav lagai gai jo unhe bhi lagani padi aur praja ke adhikaro ke raksha keliye apne bhaiyo khudko daav pe lagake haare aur vahan bhi uthke jaane lage tab Shakuni prastav diya ki Draupadi saubhagya hai un pancho ki to Draupadi ko daav pe lagake apna haara hua praja ke sampatti ko wapas jeet le jispe Yudhishthir ji sakuchatey hue maane..
Tab tak kisi Pandav ka apman nahi hua tha haare baad bhi to unhe kaise pata hoga ki Draupadi ka apman hoga? Fir bhi jab Duryodhan Draupadi ko bulane laga tab sabse pehle Yudhishthir ji hi Duryodhan ke mann ka bhaav samjhe aur apne kareebi doot ko Draupadi ki raksha keliye bheje... Ye hai poori baat, Ami Ganatra ko aadhi baat nahi kehni chahiye thi aur khudse aaklan nahi lagana chahiye tha ki dyut sab khelte the isliye khelne gaye kyonki Yudhishthir ji yuddh taalne keliye apman se bache isliye Hastinapur gaye aur praja ekta ke raksha keliye praja sampatti daav lagaye jiske raksha keliye kutumb ko daav pe lagaye jo ek Dharmraaj shreshth Raja ka gunn hai khudse upar praja ki sochna.. is poore sach ko pata nahi kyo Ami Ganatra bolti hi nahi hai jaisa saare Mahabharat grantho me spasht hai
May her books reach the hindi speaking people also and help them correct all the misinformation we been told for ages.
Great insight to hear !! Respect from Australia 🇦🇺
निःसंदेह नई पीढ़ी के लिए बहुत अच्छा और सटीक मार्गदर्शन है इस वार्तालाप में. विवाद बनाये गये हर विषय का बहुत उचित और सत्य सम्मत प्रतिउत्तर प्रस्तुत किया गया है... साधुवाद...
Ami ji aapka giyan studies vivechna adbhut hai. Sabhi ko mahabharat padhna samjhna sambhav nahi hai.aapne sanchhipt mai sabhi chariter ki viyakhiya ki hai.jisse ham inke bare mai kafee kuchh samajh paa rahen hain.
Aapka koti koti Dhanyabad Dhanyabad Dhanyabad Dhanyabad Dhanyabad
Awesome lady...i really salute her knowledge about the Mahabharat and Ramayan. Amiji...pranaam from Holland!
Yes really
So nice.. great improvement bhai.. we all are your family.. if we are advicing for improvements.. most of us.. want to see your growth.. this is for your good.. dont take it as criticism..😊😊😊😊😊😊
bilkul sahi kaha apne....
"He grasped his sharp sword and began to cut up his entire body. On seeing Karna cut up his own body, the gods, humans, danavas and masses of siddhas began to roar, because despite the pain, there were no distortions on his face. Celestial drums were sounded and divine flowers were showered down from above, at the sight of Karna, the brave man, smiling repeatedly as he cut up his own body with the sword. Having sliced off the divine armour from his body, while it was still wet, he gave it to Vasava."
Kundala Aharana Parva Chapter 591 BORI CE
1:08:53 Ami ji kavach kundal of Karn were not external attachments but part of his body like an organ so while putting it off he must have felt the same pain as one can imagine while cutting off his chest that too in living state we can't even imagine the loss of blood aur ap keh rahi hai ki wo thora sa weak ho gaya hoga😂
first ever podcast i watched in one flow,bus aisa lag raha tha sunte jao sunte jao
eagerly waiting for lord krishna discussion with ami mam
Koti koti Dhanyavad aap dono ko for enlightening us with true knowledge and facts. I have been following Ami ji since her first podcast on any platform.
Bhai bahut bahut shukriya aapka is broadcast ke liye
Iski vajah se bahut chijen meri Jo thi Mahabharat ke bare mein do chijon clear hogi
Jay Shri Ram 🙏🙏
Worth watching❤
Hare Krishna 🙏
Jai shree Ram 🙏
अमी जी को कोटी कोटी प्रणाम ।सत्य को सामने लाने के लिए ।सभी का चरित्र बहुत सुंदरता से बताया है ।नमन अमी जी आप को।
Best knowledgeable podcast
One more podcast with Ami Ganatra ji about mahabharat.....
❤❤
I am have watched amiji in a lot videos, but this video was one of them which I am going to remember. You asked a lot a questions which were not common. Thanks a lot for that. ❤❤❤
So nice of you ❤️😍🙏
Love this session.....see to see Amiji again....
Pleased to see you back sourab bhai...
Her knowledge of shastras is very deep.
Thank you 🙏🙏
I had no idea I was so ignorent regarding mahabharat. Love this podcast please make more like this ❤❤❤
Mahanayak Arjuna my inspiration 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Best of luck Saurabh bhai💐💐💐
1 Akshohini = 218700 (It is sum of 21870 Rath, 21870 Hathi, 109350 Sainik, 65610 Ghoda)
Ghoda nahi wo cavalry hota hai aur sainik nahi Infantry aur padatik bolte hai
Please do Podcast on Ashwatthama with Ami Ganatra
One more addition to the might of Arjuna- Arjuna obliterated 7 akshohini kaurav sena in a single day, killed karna’s son in front of him while searching for Jaydratha on 14th day of war after Abhimanu’s death , which no other warrior able to do, He was the most powerful warrior only equivalent to Bhishma.
Very intelligent and polite lady. Thanks for this Podcast
Perhaps I am misunderstanding the gravity of the dice game chaupar in their times, but clearly this is a lesson to learn for future generations. So it follows that Yudhishthira ji had done some wrong there. I don't think we are meant to see any character within the (hi)story of Mahabharat as one with no faults, even the great dharmaraja Yudhishthira. There is only one exception - Shri Krishna. Otherwise, all other characters made mistakes; after all, they were human.
Regarding Yudhishthira attaining Swarg after his death, it's pertinent to understand the basics of karma siddhant. Your karma registry/storage is essentially like a balance, where you attain positive reactions for your positive actions, negative reactions for your negative actions, and steps toward ultimate salvation for your neutral (or amãyik) actions. Neutral actions are those that are performed with no bondages of this world, and are done with the pure intention of pleasing God (and nothing else). Neutral actions (and therefore a neutral balance) are the only means of escaping the cycle of births and deaths. At a basic level, only strive for neutral actions, and at the least positive actions. Just some wisdom attained from scriptures, mandirs, satsang, and gurus.
🙏Aap dono ko Mera Pranam, Bhaut hi Sundaar aur Gyaan Vardhak Podcast Raha ye, Ami Ji Hamesha Nishpakshak Hokar Hamara ITIHAS Hamare Samne Rakhte hai Ye Bhaut hi Sundaar Anubhav Hota Hai Hamesha.
Amazing PODCAST...Congratulation to AMI JI and SOURAV JI......
बड़े - बड़े लोग यह सब समझा नहीं पाते जो इस छोटे से प्रसारण में आपने समझाने का प्रयास किया बहुत अच्छा लगा धन्यवाद्
Wah bhai sahb kya hi podcast bnaya h bhut bhut dhanywad
Please keep making more of these podcasts!! Astonishing to hear all of this ❤❤❤❤
I am in hastinapur right now
Sir , podcast aacha he , par channel Logo change karo!
Aap kuch accha sa suggest kar do 😊
Logo is good, kya useless suggestion hai yar
Logo Change karna chahiye, baki podcast aachha he
@@Banjara_k189 I think Similar To Gyan jara hatke channel Should be Look Batter 🤔
Agree 💯
Awsome informational podcast
Thanks for giving true knowledge
bahut axa, ati saral😊🎉
Jai Sri Radhe Krishna. Jai Sita Ram.
Ami ji, has no chill 😂 destroying all fake narratives one by one.
Thanks 👍
Bahot mahine k bad apko dekh rahu best of luck bhai❤
Great job to invite Ami ji on your podcast!!
Really Great ❤ Thanks for information.
Proud of you sourav bhai .... best podcast
Wow great broadcast ❤ well done
I am so happy to see you growing....Bhagwan kare aap aise hi aage badte raho
Supper jankari di aap dono ko bahut bahut sadhuwad
I love this episode 🙏
Fantastic work sir
Thanks for working on suggestions
Awesome pls maintain this purity always
Great podcast 🔥 big fan of ami ji❤
Welcome back brother 😁😊
Love from Nepal ❤
Karna was 50% asura the rebirth of dambhudbhav and 50% sun's part...that is why he had both qualities...😊
Amazing podcast👌👌👌😍
हमारे इतिहास की बहोत सारी मूल प्रते विधर्मियो ने जला दी थी मगर कई लोगो ने उनको कंठस्थ किया हुवा था बाद में जब समय अनुकूल हूवा तो उन्होंने दुबारा लिखने का प्रयास किया और उसमे सूरदास जी की वो चौपाई काम कर गई (जाकी रही भावना जैसी) और अपने मन से जो भी जोड़ना चाहा वह जोड़ दिया इससे भ्रांतियां उत्पन हुई
Time worth podcasts, keep it
Absolutely fantastic video ❤❤
Interesting perspective given on Mahabharat, it is eye opening, a lot of people try to glorify Karna but actually he is one of the villains of Mahabharat.
Chl htt be
Bahut kuch literally bahut kuch sikhne ko mila......thank you ❤ and keep doing
Dharmaraj went to swarg with his body he did not "DIE".. Refer Mahaprasthanika Parva second chapter initial shloka from Vyasa "Jaya"
Awesome saurabh ji
need more like this
Wow.. Good to see u here on podcast.. 😅
Good to see you back bro😊 great video 👍
Best wishes
need more content like this
sending love from Kathmandu Nepal
कर्ण : मैं सूत पुत्र हूँ |
अर्जुन : तो क्या हुआ?
कर्ण : मुझे कम मत समझो |
अर्जुन : किसने कम समझा हैं?
कर्ण : मैने खुदने ये उपहार स्वयं को दिया हैं | पर तुम मुझे सूतपुत्र मत बुलाना |
अर्जुन : पर बोला किसने हैं?
भीम : अर्जुन, जाने दो उसे.. पागल हैं वो |
दुर्योधन : (इसे दोस्त बना लेता हूँ ) ए सूतपुत्र कर्ण, इधर आओ |
कर्ण : हां बताओ |
दुर्योधन : दोस्त बनोगे?
कर्ण : पर मैं तो सूतपुत्र हूँ |
दुर्योधन : हां पर क्या दोस्त बनोगे?
कर्ण : हां!! चलो पांडव को जलाये |
😂 Bhai itna sach nhi bolna tha
Ek full episode on Dharmraj Yudhisthir please. We want to know the decision taken by him. People must know in detail, how he lost Draupdi and brothers. What were the hurdles he came across, while establishing dharm.
Thanks bhai really highly knowledgeable content with a great personality. If possible please cover a sort regarding eklavya also. Please. Thanks madam.
Aapke postcast achche hai. Ek suggestion, urdu ka prayog kam Kiya kijiye like itminan etc Khas karake postcast ke topics ke sath woh sunane mein achche nahi lagate
Bhai background ko toda simple rakho.. Bahot jayda items rakh diye h apne background me..
Please more part of Mahabharat
Bohut accha
Best ha Ami Grantra Ji my Favourite.
Sir main channel pr video kyun nhi dikh rehe ??? Maine aaj hi chek kiya,, kisiko koi idea hain ky ?? 👇
Assam old name was Pragjyotishpur during Mahabharata. The king of Pragjyotishpur was Bhagdutta son of Narakasur also son of King Janak (father of Sita ji). Bhagdutta was very good friend of Duryadhan, he was very well known yoddha on Elephant. Pragjyotishpur was in the same place now where Assam is situated. There're so many evidence here in Assam...
@@KirtanDeka-xs2wy Not true. Assam old name is pragyajyotishpur but it is not the same of mahabharata. Mahabharata pragjyotisha was north of Indraprastha (delhi). Arjun when starts his digvijaya first kingdom he fought is bhagadatta. So it tells that bhagadatta kingdom was near to delhi . Most probably a part of modern punjab was pragjyotisha
karna is just like PR merchant JUST like RONALDO,while ARJUN is like MESSI who is simply best
I ordered one
Heyyyyy bhai is back ❤
Ami ji is best
This is quite partial and lets think logically. 1. Blame on karan that he ran away during ghandarwa attack I think it was wise as both karna and Duryodhana were intoxicated so simply any person cannot fight if he is drunk he better to leave and come back once normal and this happens in all army strategies all the time armies retreat at certain point to reinforce better in other position or comeback. 2. Indra himself gave him weapon else it would have been disgraced as god so Karna asked in exchange correct but than your point got invalid that he did not think about Duryodhana also his loyalty was to fight for Duryodhana it doesn't mean he leave all his other dharma. 3. Caste was there always even if you look Ramayan ram eat fruits from shrudra lady and it was way before Mahabharata kal. Why Krishna tried to convince Karna when for Dharma he didn't even try to convince his own son Sambh Krishan tried to stop war before all the doors were closed and also to understand if he was mean he would have never gave his shield as he clearly know no weapon was kill him but he was knowing even after the shield he is at least equal to Arjuna if not better. Bhisma clearly told he cannot participate in the war so how he can be blamed if army chief don't want him and also he knows it is impossible to defeat Bhisma no one expected the tricks by Krishna. Only Shakuni points I agree also as Trunk reference for karna it can also be thought as tree strongest part is its trunk so maybe it is referred that karna is the strongest part of Duryodhana power I agree only with Shakuni parts in this video. Imagine a war is going on and you are talking it is so simple to change the chariot maybe all chariots destroy in the war and it was meant by destiny that karna act to take out chariot also Bhisma told Parshuram also to come on chariot if he want to fight the war as it is unequal it is common that anyone on better height has more chance
सनातन धर्म ही शाश्वत सत्य है जय श्री कृष्णा जय श्री राम 🚩🚩🚩
Dharma ka definition is - doing the right thing! Righteousness is exactly the meaning of Dharma.
Hindu/hindutva is based on Geeta and is all about doing the right thing all the time hence why Hindu is the ONLY dharma which is progressive and accommodative dharma on earth. Any human is Hindu if they follow the path of righteousness!
Jay shree ram
Karna actual villian he ye baat kis kis keliye shocking he
That's a fact .
JAI SHRI KRISHNA
Dusre channel ko kya ho gya
Waiting for next part🤞
Bhaiya long video ko 2 parts mai divide krdo jise video lambe na ho
No it's ok
❤
I love The way she use word kada chit in her chat ❤
Nice
❤👍👍👍
Bhai original channel pe new video dalate raha karo.
the podcaster has half baked knowledge of our Hindu Text........Ami Ganatra as usual is brilliant.........podcaster should start reading hindu granths in original Sanskrit.......if you donot know Sanskrit........start learning and then do a podcast on such topics at a scholarly level.
Gyan Jara Hatke kab se show ban gaya?
Lagta hai bht din bad aapki video dekh raha hoon
Duryodhana was embodiment of Kali(Yuga) and he was always under the influence of Kali, which is also mentioned in Vyasa "Jaya".. I wonder how this point was missed during this talk!!
Bhai ek suggestion try to bring up history of wars n geopolitics
Bhai Gyan Jara tak ke kyo band kar diya. Please bhai batao na