Before anyone else makes a huge misconception, The song was produced by b1a4's Jinyoung and had his labelmate OMG's Seunghee do the guide. It's not coincidence that they are singing this and encouraged by their management. b1a4's Jingyoung produced 3 girl group songs: Produce101's Same Place, Oh My Girl's (newest album with Liar Liar) - 1 Step, 2 Step, and Produce101's final episode - When the cherry blossom fades. we maybe seeing Oh My Girl & Produce 101 come out with a bunch of girlish pop songs made by the same person and be trying to compare...
얘네 처음 이거 불렀을 때 반응이 정확히 1. 얘네 누구냐 2. 소녀온탑(프듀1)이 낫다 이렇게 2개 였음. 심지어 저때가 liar liar활동 당시였는데 진영의 후속곡 한발짝두발짝이랑 최종까지 갔다가 결국엔 한발짝두발짝 나가리되고 liarliar로 활동했음. 근데 같은곳에서 가이드 승희가 부른거 하나로 liarliar행사 가면 같은곳에서 불러달라는 부탁 받음. ㄹㅇ 본인 그룹 노래 홍보하러 왔는데 딴 노래 불러달라는 아니러니;; 저 라디오도 똑같음. 당시에 프듀화제성 때문에 오마이걸 승희효정도 본인들 노래 홍보 더 하고 싶은데 저거 부른거. 뭐 저거 부르고 인지도 쌓을 수 있겠지 생각하다가도 당시 프듀팬덤이 깎아 내린거 생각하면 지금 살짝설렜어까지 올라온 게 ㄹㅇ 보통내기가 아닐정도. TMI : 그리고 liarliar활동 끝나고 한발짝두발짝 활동 아마 1주 하고 끝났을거임. 못해도 2-3주는 더 했어야 했는데 너무 활동 빡세게 해서. 유일하게 풀샷 잡은 게 mpd였나 엠카에서 흰색불라우스에 하늘색교복치마 같은거 그게 거의 유일한 풀샷. 그래서 한발짝두발짝이 정말 찐텐으로 아는 사람들만 아는거. 마지막으로 ㄹㅇ 요즘 오마이걸 많이 떠서 대견하다.
너무 답답해서 댓글 씁니다 애초에 연정이는 성량이랑 고음이 특징인 가수고 승희는 높은 목소리 톤이랑 감정이 특징인데 고음만 보고 연정이가 낫다고 하는건 좀 아니지 않나;; 딱 봐도 고음을 연정이가 더 잘 뽑아내서 소녀온탑이 낫다고 하는데 고음만 잘 뽑는다고 노래를 잘하는게 아니잖아요 전체적인 부분을 보면 승희 효정이 더 나음 그리고 저 때 효정이는 감기까지 있던 상태고 생 라이브였음 좀 알고 댓글 답시다 여러분^^
@@k-popmirrored4241 Yes, this song was produced by Jinyoung who was at their same company at the time, therefore asked them to record the demo. He also produced One Step Two Step for them, you should check it out, it has similar vibes.
I like both this version and the Produce 101 version. Seunghee did the original and I can see that it totally suited her voice. Yeunjung also sang amazing and did well following Seunghee's tracks. But honestly, why are people comparing a song sang by 7 people covered by only 2? Seunghee and Hyojung did amazing to cover the whole thing by themselves. Let's just be glad that WM family is receiving lots of love now due to this song.
Kotori Minami no, if you were trained you'll have ability to sing this even with only you...seunghee did fantastic as a solo with this song, hyojung is the only one messed up so it's not because of the song, it's because of hyojung's singing skill :)
Check out their two titles songs for their previous combacks, ️Closer & CUPID, you will fall in love with them, well produced songs, great vocals & perfect in sync while dancing. Of course, take a look at their recent comeback, Liar Liar.
For those who kinda disrespect OMG, do u guys even know that the song was originally sang by Seunghee and she helped Pd101 girls how to sing it? Ckckck
I don't think what a lot of people realize is the produce I0I version was not really 100% live. shows go in and tweak vocals, even go as far as having artists come into the studio to record the song if it sounds really bad. not to discredit got at all, I do think they sound better singing the song. keep in mind they also have the advantage of more members doing the song where as here its just hyojung and seunghee, covering an entire song with plenty of high notes, on live radio, . they probably also just threw this cover together ( I mean if you've listened/watched to any of their others, they're really great)
blablabla sing better blablabla. produce101 sing with 7people, with 7people who has different voice style. maybe only 2-3of them can sing this whole song and really suit thissong. but seriously, seunghee and hyujong*if i'm not wrong) sing so well. esp seunghee, her voice suit this song well T_T
악플 히키코모리님들아 본가수 곡 듣고 여기와서 언밀히 다른 사람이 부르니까 음색이 다르지? 당연한거 아니냐? 계속 듣던데 귀에 익고 새롭게 부른거니까 당연히 차이가 날수 잇겟지 근데 그걸 누가 더 낫고 누가 더 잘부르는게 아니라. 본곡을 듣다가 다른 음색이 들리니까 어색한거야 그리고 이분들이 가수지. 맨날 노래방에서 삑사리 내며 꽥꽥 소리지르다가 가는 니들이랑은 달라. 왜냐? 테스트에서 통과하고 수많은 경쟁자를 뚫고 올라올 실력이 됫으니까 근데 이분들을 맨날 집에 쳐 앉아 기기로 못한다라고 지들맘에 안들면 싫어요 누르는 니들보다 훨씬 대단하고 잘하는게 많으신 분들이에요. 뭐 지들은 얼마나 잘 판단하길래 맨날 드리누워앉아 기기로 댓다는 니들이 그렇게나 음색 판단에 소질이 잇으면 니들이 이름알리고 해봐요. 댓글로 누가 더 낫고 뭐 어떤점에서 못한다고 하지말고 그리고 소녀온탑 팬덤 분들과 타팬분들은 님들이 좋아하는 가수에 가서 그 가수 칭찬이나 하세요.. 타 그룹에와서 왜 그럽니까? 그리고 비교를 해도 님들이 비교를 할수없는 분들이에요. 뭔 연예인 빽으로 그러는건 모르겟다만 타그룹에와서 이 행위를 하는건 그쪽 그룹이더 욕먹는일 아니겟습니까? 그리고 노래 저작권은 그 가수 측에잇지 팬들이 따라부르지 말라고 그 저작권이 통하는게 아니란다 가수 들은 가만히 있는데 따라부르지 말라는건 팬인 님들이 님들이 좋아하는 그 가수를 무시하는것과 같네요. 타팬이라도 선플다시고 부디, 평가 하지마세요.
poor girls. seunghee sang the guide for this song and both of these girls are getting compared what even. i agree that P101 did better but hello this is the original please appreciate it.
You say you feel sorry for them because everyone keeps compaing them but you're just as bad. By saying "I agree that P101 did better..." You too are comparing like everyone else. When you say that someone or something is better than something else, you're comapraing.
SNYN 2 Let me clear this up. I feel sorry for Seunghee and Hyojung getting compared to P101 BECAUSE they are the original singers. They sang it their style and P101 sang it their style. I liked P101's ver better BUT i did not dislike Seunghee and Hyojung's. I respect the way they sang it - OH MY GIRL's style. It may seem to you that i am comparing but no, i am not. I am just saying that even though i prefer P101's ver, Seunghee and Hyojung should get compared and even get hate. They should be respected for singing the guide for it in the first place. Not to mention that P101's have a generous amount of autotune and you can't get beautiful vocals as raw as Seunghee's and Hyojung's version.
Stop comparing if u want to compare then lets make it in groups let omg pre recorder as well and lets see cause im so tired of people comparing them to produce101
Imagine one step two step, in the same place and when the cherry blossoms together which is the perfect album .I hope jinyoung compose more songs and give it to omg
@@나만의덕질채널 시즌1 시즌48 둘다 봤다 김세정 원픽으로 당시 계정 7개인가 8개 돌려가며 김세정 51표 투표했었음 막회때 ××××51표인가(? 6개 돌려서 42표였던거 같기도 하고 무튼)로 끝나서 저건 내표다했던 기억도 있네ㅋㅋ 김소혜가 보통 걸그룹의 서브보컬 수준으로 부르게끔 방송에 나왔는데 후보정 쩔었던건 맞지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
hey this song is so hard to sing you know？ girls on top have so many people to sing this but seunghee n hyojung just two of them！pls dont compare,respect all of them
The song itself is great. The demo of the song (sang by Seunghee) was even famous before recording of 5 concepts competion which is one of the reasons helped the song won No. 1. I understand that some people after getting used to P101 version think that Girls on Top can sing better. It's true that they delivered the song well, but please at least show respect to the girls helped the song famous even before official performance and listen to Oh My Girl sing live on other radio/show or their Mr. Removed M/V to know how well they can sing (Both of them can hit higher note than high note of this song ^^). And come on, comparing 7 to 2 is not fair. It's just they don't have time to practise this song perfectly ^_^ Peace and enjoy the music juseyo :)
its hard to tell,,, but i think if oh my girl came back with this song they would be daebak the same way as gfriend rose to fame. don't get me wrong liar liar is such a strongggg gem
+halla B i think if they did they would only be compared (like what is happening in this very video's comment section) to other girl groups tbh. that's why one step, two step isn't the title. otherwise they'd get hate thrown at them for "not being as good as group a" or "group b could've sung this better" or "total copy/trying to be group c" ;;;; so sticking with more their own style is best otl
to people who said pd101 did better than them its because they were like 7 of them right? thats why they can sing better bc they divide the parts meanwhile this is only two of omg member yet they slay this song.
Logically speaking, a 7-member team would sound better as they have various vocal ranges. But speaking in behalf of this video, Seunghee's vocals sounded good enough in this video, what more if the whole Oh My Girl created a cover of this song? Stop with the saltiness, both did a great job. P.S: Jinyoung guided them (Girls on Top) to sing ITSP, it was Seunghee who DIRECTED them (as chosen by Jinyoung).
I like both versions of this song ^_^ but I don't think it's fair to compare 7 people singing it to 2 people singing it. And also Hyojung's voice doesn't really suit the song as much as Seunghee. The people saying that Seunghee has a "cutesy" voice, i suggest that you watch her on King of Masked Singer. She's amazing and her voice does not sound "cutesy" one bit. ;)
Actually they both did a great job👍especially Seunghee❣😍I love her adlib because even Produce 101 trainees didn't (or couldn't) do that in live show.Actually when I am watching Girls on top live I wonder why some high notes are only in the background music and now I appreciate Seunghee for singing them and she really did a GREAT GREAT JOB!!!😍😍😍💗💗💗💗
@@antonmacapili9930 yeah I watched the pd101 performance for many times and I think what I meant was really some of the adlibs in the background vocals which Yeonjung and Sira missed out
I first listen to this during Produce 101 and first i didnt know that seunghee is the guideline but I feel this song fit Oh My Girl so much since I got the same feeling as One Step Two Step ❤️ Jinyoung Jjang!!! 👍🏻
smh,srsly the comments section is full of ppl comparing a song which was sung by 2 different groups.... first group had 7 ppl while the second group had only 2 ppl...ofc the first group did better because of having more people and the parts divided to each member whilst the second group tried their hardest as the parts were probably not properly distributed....smh
![20160326 Produce 101 - In the same place [Mirrored]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_Twtfek3mpw/mqdefault.jpg)
![20160326 Produce 101 - In the same place [Mirrored]](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG/CHN] IDOT members, B1A4 Jinyoung’s song recording day!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/x7yDVrCi4Hs/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MV] 오마이걸(OH MY GIRL) _ LIAR LIAR](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LNZKqhXCv5c/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Produce 101] A present from Jinyoung of B1A4! - ♬At the Same Place @Concept Eval. EP.09 20160318](/img/1.gif)
아직 여기까진 퀸덤이 침투하지 못했군
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
퓨쁘`《핳》 침투 완료..!
침투완료오..위즈원인데 이정도면 미라클 아닌가여..?
침투
왔다..!!!
원오원 애들은 녹음해서 제일 잘 나온걸로 쓰고 그걸로 평가를 받아야되기 때문에 그 노래만 며칠동안 연습했고 오마이걸은 가이드를 했다는 이유만으로 부르게 된거라 이 곡 연습이 많이 안 되있을건데 비교하면서 소녀온탑이 더 낫네 하는건 좀ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그런이유로 방어를 치는건 그사람들에대한 모독이죠
@@Blue_Archlve ????
음믕 ??? 뭔 소리지
하루 가이드 한지 이제 알앗어여
@@Blue_Archlve 무슨 말인지 이해를 못하겠네요. 방어라뇨?
인간적으로 승희 효정은 보컬실력으로 까면 안되지.. 다른거 아무 라이브나 하나봐도 실력나오는데
Before anyone else makes a huge misconception, The song was produced by b1a4's Jinyoung and had his labelmate OMG's Seunghee do the guide. It's not coincidence that they are singing this and encouraged by their management. b1a4's Jingyoung produced 3 girl group songs: Produce101's Same Place, Oh My Girl's (newest album with Liar Liar) - 1 Step, 2 Step, and Produce101's final episode - When the cherry blossom fades. we maybe seeing Oh My Girl & Produce 101 come out with a bunch of girlish pop songs made by the same person and be trying to compare...
Omg ithought all the songs were similar! No wonder
Jinyoung is an AMAZING composer, damnn. Those three songs are my three current songs XD i like this style
MYGAHD THANKS FOR THIS INFO
ikr
SAME
얘네 처음 이거 불렀을 때 반응이 정확히
1. 얘네 누구냐
2. 소녀온탑(프듀1)이 낫다
이렇게 2개 였음. 심지어 저때가 liar liar활동 당시였는데 진영의 후속곡 한발짝두발짝이랑 최종까지 갔다가 결국엔 한발짝두발짝 나가리되고 liarliar로 활동했음. 근데 같은곳에서 가이드 승희가 부른거 하나로 liarliar행사 가면 같은곳에서 불러달라는 부탁 받음. ㄹㅇ 본인 그룹 노래 홍보하러 왔는데 딴 노래 불러달라는 아니러니;; 저 라디오도 똑같음. 당시에 프듀화제성 때문에 오마이걸 승희효정도 본인들 노래 홍보 더 하고 싶은데 저거 부른거. 뭐 저거 부르고 인지도 쌓을 수 있겠지 생각하다가도 당시 프듀팬덤이 깎아 내린거 생각하면 지금 살짝설렜어까지 올라온 게 ㄹㅇ 보통내기가 아닐정도. TMI : 그리고 liarliar활동 끝나고 한발짝두발짝 활동 아마 1주 하고 끝났을거임. 못해도 2-3주는 더 했어야 했는데 너무 활동 빡세게 해서. 유일하게 풀샷 잡은 게 mpd였나 엠카에서 흰색불라우스에 하늘색교복치마 같은거 그게 거의 유일한 풀샷. 그래서 한발짝두발짝이 정말 찐텐으로 아는 사람들만 아는거.
마지막으로 ㄹㅇ 요즘 오마이걸 많이 떠서 대견하다.
그리고 한발짝 두발짝 많은분들이 그냥 수록곡으로만 알고있던데 선공개 곡 이었음... 라여라여 컴백전에 선공개로 멜론에 공개했었는데.. 그러다가 앨범 합쳐져서 선공개 흔적은 없어졌음 선공개 안하고 그냥 타이틀로 나왔어야 했는데 ㅠ
아이러니
승희를 보컬로 까다니.........
너무 답답해서 댓글 씁니다
애초에 연정이는 성량이랑 고음이 특징인 가수고 승희는 높은 목소리 톤이랑 감정이 특징인데 고음만 보고 연정이가 낫다고 하는건 좀 아니지 않나;; 딱 봐도 고음을 연정이가 더 잘 뽑아내서 소녀온탑이 낫다고 하는데 고음만 잘 뽑는다고 노래를 잘하는게 아니잖아요 전체적인 부분을 보면 승희 효정이 더 나음 그리고 저 때 효정이는 감기까지 있던 상태고 생 라이브였음 좀 알고 댓글 답시다 여러분^^
결론은 모두 잘하는거로..
오구오구 그러셨쎄요? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@송인찬-s1d 오구오구 다른댓글에도 이러더니 왜 이럴까ㅎㅎ?
송인찬 장애인이냐ㅋㅋㅋ 지 혼자 우쭈쭈 하고 있네
연정이 아끼는 사람입니다.
승희 효정씨도 노래 잘하는
가수라 생각합니다.우주소녀
오마이걸 모두다 화이팅
Omg chill. These girls were the demos for this song. They didn't do that bad. They have great voices as well.
only Seunghee did the demo song. But this live version of her with Hyojung is really great.
if IOI sings it live like this, probably they won't as good as Seunghee and Hyojung, notice it!! :)
but Seunghee has good skills too. She won 2nd place among 12 main vocal in Girl Spirit
U.Ji won the 2nd place
go googling 2nd place seunghee
오마이걸 선배b1a4 진영 이만든 거라 오마이걸승희가 가이드곡 녹음함
lmaoooo at everyone saying the original better when these girls right here literally did the demo
Wait what for realz?
@@k-popmirrored4241 Yes, this song was produced by Jinyoung who was at their same company at the time, therefore asked them to record the demo. He also produced One Step Two Step for them, you should check it out, it has similar vibes.
@@yoongified93 woah 0_0
@@yoongified93 and they didnt release the song as oh my girl for a REASON
@@soojincabello3409 it was really intended for Produce101. but Jinyoung asked OH MY GIRL to record it for the demo.
I like both this version and the Produce 101 version. Seunghee did the original and I can see that it totally suited her voice. Yeunjung also sang amazing and did well following Seunghee's tracks. But honestly, why are people comparing a song sang by 7 people covered by only 2? Seunghee and Hyojung did amazing to cover the whole thing by themselves. Let's just be glad that WM family is receiving lots of love now due to this song.
+aquareayla no hyojung messed up sira's part which is my favorite part =/=
Yes...people said they are bad while they sing 7 people's parts, it is too hard for them😯😯
Kotori Minami but both of them are main vocalist :/ and seunghee was the original version by herself so i don't see it's hard :/
+bum baby it is because they continue to sing several parts so they will out of breathe easily, especially it is live with no backtrack😣😣
Kotori Minami no, if you were trained you'll have ability to sing this even with only you...seunghee did fantastic as a solo with this song, hyojung is the only one messed up so it's not because of the song, it's because of hyojung's singing skill :)
I wish Jinyoung would release the demo version (Seunghee) of this song.
sameeeee
blackPinkLalice miracle i want to hear Hyojung's only version
승희 효정을 보컬로 까기엔 너무 양심들이 없는 거지 많은 인원수 걸그룹 노래를 둘이서 나눠 부르는 거라 숨은 당연히 찰 수 있는 거지
효정언니 감기 걸렸는데 저 정도면ㄷㄷ 엄청 잘하는거 아닌가?
I love both versions ^-^ Since Seunghee sang this song originally, her voice suits it so much ♡
I think so
+Junhyung Ulili Seunghee recorded this before Produce 101?
+Andrea Lopez Yes, the demo version
Who is seunghee?
+hyojinnie She's the one who sings the high note.
Did these people over here know the fact that seunghee sang the guide of this song tho? Stop comparing 😑
승희가 가이드할만 했네 ㅠㅠㅠ 너무 잘 부른다
난 효정 목 안좋은줄도 몰랐음... 목 안좋은대도 저렇게 부르는건 진짜 개쩐다... 둘이서 미쳤어.....
Can we atleast just appreciate this and not hate and compare?
we are all disgusting sometimes. omg -_____-
Good job to them!! They carried a song originally sang by 7. I think I might fall for these girls.
Check out their two titles songs for their previous combacks, ️Closer & CUPID, you will fall in love with them, well produced songs, great vocals & perfect in sync while dancing. Of course, take a look at their recent comeback, Liar Liar.
여기 댓글 한국놈이나 외국놈이나 다 개념수준차이 오지게나네 ㅋㅋ
이건 라이브고 저때 효정양 코감기걸렷엇고 프듀랑 비교하는사람 많은데 녹음으로진행됫으면 입1도못털어요 ㅋㅋ 에휴 이전에 실력보고 댓글싸지르든가해라 같은곳에서 가이드가 저기서 부르고잇는데 개념없이 행동하네 ㅋㅋ
흔훨팡 왜요? 누가 뭐라그러셨나요?
ㅋㅋㅋ 어구어구 그러셨세요?
@@송인찬-s1d 네 그러셨"세"요
원곡을 많이 들어보지 않았고 댓글도 읽지 않은 상태로 라이브 봤는데 잘한다는 생각만 드는데..? 원래 목소리가 깔끔하고 게다가 노하우도 있어서 목이 좋지 않다는 걸 커버한 느낌? 오마이걸 흥하자
승희 목소리가 잘어울리는듯
For those who kinda disrespect OMG, do u guys even know that the song was originally sang by Seunghee and she helped Pd101 girls how to sing it? Ckckck
효정이 목안좋은거 너무 눈에 보인다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
그러니까요 ㅠㅠㅠ
pd101 fans salty af without seunghee those girls wouldn't even be able to perform the song.
니네가 불러봐 이거 진짜 부르기개힘듬 숨차서 ;; 참고로 나노래배웠는데 이곡은 노래방에서 제일못부르겠더라 대단한고임진심
소녀온탑이 이 목소리 듣고 배웠다 할정도로 잘해요 솔직히 좀 불안정해 보이기는 하는데 승희 효정 노래 잘해요ㅠㅠ!!!!!
이 높은 곡을 감기 걸린 상태에서 그것도 7명이서 한걸 둘이서...? 오마이걸 오늘부터 나 미라클 합니다.. 사랑해요ㅠㅜ
우와 이거 본방에서 잠깐 나온 데모버전 듣고 궁금해서 찾아봤는데 오마이걸이었네..목소리 진짜 좋다
왜 다 소녀온탑이 더 낫다는 댓글뿐이지 .. 승희랑 효정도 그만큼 잘했다고 생각하는데
I don't think what a lot of people realize is the produce I0I version was not really 100% live. shows go in and tweak vocals, even go as far as having artists come into the studio to record the song if it sounds really bad. not to discredit got at all, I do think they sound better singing the song. keep in mind they also have the advantage of more members doing the song where as here its just hyojung and seunghee, covering an entire song with plenty of high notes, on live radio, . they probably also just threw this cover together ( I mean if you've listened/watched to any of their others, they're really great)
소녀온탑 노래 좋고 해서 많이 들었으니까 울 옴걸 승희효정노래가 익숙치 않아서 소녀온탑이 더 좋다는 분들이 많은거 같다
blablabla sing better blablabla. produce101 sing with 7people, with 7people who has different voice style. maybe only 2-3of them can sing this whole song and really suit thissong. but seriously, seunghee and hyujong*if i'm not wrong) sing so well. esp seunghee, her voice suit this song well T_T
No wonder seunghee is the demo singer of the song
tyrsm yes. She sing alone, rite? i cant imagine T_T she's so good
+Limvada Julianti u can find her performance on King of Masked Singer T.T some of their senior also cried cuz of her voice
악플 히키코모리님들아
본가수 곡 듣고 여기와서 언밀히
다른 사람이 부르니까 음색이
다르지? 당연한거 아니냐?
계속 듣던데 귀에 익고 새롭게
부른거니까 당연히 차이가 날수 잇겟지
근데 그걸 누가 더 낫고 누가 더
잘부르는게 아니라. 본곡을 듣다가
다른 음색이 들리니까 어색한거야
그리고 이분들이 가수지. 맨날 노래방에서
삑사리 내며 꽥꽥 소리지르다가 가는 니들이랑은
달라. 왜냐? 테스트에서 통과하고
수많은 경쟁자를 뚫고 올라올 실력이 됫으니까
근데 이분들을 맨날 집에 쳐 앉아
기기로 못한다라고 지들맘에 안들면 싫어요 누르는
니들보다 훨씬 대단하고 잘하는게 많으신 분들이에요.
뭐 지들은 얼마나 잘 판단하길래 맨날 드리누워앉아 기기로
댓다는 니들이 그렇게나 음색 판단에 소질이 잇으면
니들이 이름알리고 해봐요.
댓글로 누가 더 낫고 뭐 어떤점에서 못한다고 하지말고
그리고 소녀온탑 팬덤 분들과 타팬분들은
님들이 좋아하는 가수에 가서 그 가수 칭찬이나 하세요..
타 그룹에와서 왜 그럽니까?
그리고 비교를 해도 님들이 비교를 할수없는 분들이에요.
뭔 연예인 빽으로 그러는건 모르겟다만
타그룹에와서 이 행위를 하는건
그쪽 그룹이더 욕먹는일 아니겟습니까?
그리고 노래 저작권은 그 가수 측에잇지
팬들이 따라부르지 말라고 그
저작권이 통하는게 아니란다
가수 들은 가만히 있는데
따라부르지 말라는건
팬인 님들이 님들이 좋아하는 그 가수를 무시하는것과 같네요.
타팬이라도 선플다시고
부디, 평가 하지마세요.
Jinyoung's songs always seem to be easy but actually super challenging to sing properly
승희목소리랑 되게 잘 어울린다 굿
People are just too used to the Produce 101 version, so they think Hyojung and Seunghee did worse.
or maybe they just liked Produce 101's version better like me
Think so...
Megan this is so late but if this was released first, people would find p101 ver. strange
I wanna hear the whole of OMG singing this tbh
싸비 승희 목소리가 잘어울리는듯
가이드 녹음까지하고 같은 회사 선배 노래여서 부른건데 왜이리 토를 달아;; 왼쪽이 같은곳에서 가이드했고 불안정한것도 소녀온탑은 계속 연습하고 녹음을수없이 해서 젤 좋은걸 뽑은거고 승희랑 효정이는 생전 연습안한 곡을 감기걸린 상태로 라이브하니까 불안정하지;
poor girls. seunghee sang the guide for this song and both of these girls are getting compared what even. i agree that P101 did better but hello this is the original please appreciate it.
You say you feel sorry for them because everyone keeps compaing them but you're just as bad. By saying "I agree that P101 did better..." You too are comparing like everyone else. When you say that someone or something is better than something else, you're comapraing.
+dph4720 Jackie Qi Qi is saying that she/he feels sorry for the girls cause they're being compared to but she/he is comparing them too
SNYN 2 Let me clear this up. I feel sorry for Seunghee and Hyojung getting compared to P101 BECAUSE they are the original singers. They sang it their style and P101 sang it their style. I liked P101's ver better BUT i did not dislike Seunghee and Hyojung's. I respect the way they sang it - OH MY GIRL's style. It may seem to you that i am comparing but no, i am not. I am just saying that even though i prefer P101's ver, Seunghee and Hyojung should get compared and even get hate. They should be respected for singing the guide for it in the first place. Not to mention that P101's have a generous amount of autotune and you can't get beautiful vocals as raw as Seunghee's and Hyojung's version.
Jackie Qi Qi oh ok sorry it kinda seemed like you were comparing them in a bad way and then saying that they shouldn't be compared
do you know the meaning of original??? well seunghee is not the original because she was only singing it as a GUIDE. do you know guide? lol
솔직히 승희랑 효정이 더 잘하는듯
반박댓글없는거봨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 거 인정할거 인정할거면서 이상한댓글들 달지맙시다 으흉 옴걸만세
흠 그건 당연한거 아닌가유 소녀온탑은 (당시에) 전부 연습생이였는데? ㅇㅅㅇ
When people try to compare
I don't even can't sing any lines of this song
라디오 생방이라 보정도 안 되는데 진짜 잘하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 댓글보니까 심지어 감기걸렸었대 2명이서 이 곡을... 대단하다..
Seung hee and Hyojung sung the song so beautifully.
i just want jinyoung + seunghee + yeunjung collaborations forever and ever... those two girls' voices are perfect for jinyoung's style! ♥
So true because Seunghee slays in 'Step by step' and Yeonjung slays in 'In the same place'
T. L. exactly!!! ugh i'd love so much for them to make a unit ;u;
Stop comparing if u want to compare then lets make it in groups let omg pre recorder as well and lets see cause im so tired of people comparing them to produce101
tired too
sseung's highnote 🥺 love this so much
they slayed this, it's actually pretty good.
@@fkeis823krs 죄송한데 그런 말 우리 엄마한테 하지마세요. 혹시 몰라서, slay는 영어 급식체이에요 "무대 찢았다/진짜 잘했다"이라는 말이에요 오해하지마세요 저는 외국 미라클이에요 ㅠㅠ
효정 목소리 맘 아프다... 목 상태...
승희랑 효정 둘 다 라이브...
Imagine one step two step, in the same place and when the cherry blossoms together which is the perfect album .I hope jinyoung compose more songs and give it to omg
perfect Hyojung. she has a great voice. so sweet!
오마이걸은 라이브다 립싱크랑 비교하지 말자
소녀온탑도 라이브야
소녀온탑도 라이브야..
@@아이돌이슈가있유 주작돌이 왜나와요ㅋㅋ 소녀온탑이랑 상관 1도 없는 주결경 강미나가 나오네욬ㅋ 대가리에 든게 있으면 댓 안달텐데
현승 제가 언제 주작돌이라고했어요...
찔리나보네요
@@아이돌이슈가있유 어멋 댓 삭제하면 있던일도 없어지나봐요? 그쵸?
i cant pick who is better. seunghee and yeonjung both slay
+Rizky Saputra orang indo kan yak? :v
muhammad apriliansyah menurut lu aja
Rizky Saputra ya kan nanya doang:v fans omg jugaa kah?
muhammad apriliansyah banyak gua mah bukan omg doang wkwk
hidup penboy :v
seunghee's voice gives me goosebumps
퀸덤에서 도착한 머글인데 팩트는 소녀온탑은 후보정 오지게 받음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 프듀 48만 봐도 엠넷이 어느정도로 후보정 해주는지 답나온다 ㅋㅋ
ㄴㄴ 유연정이 진짜 잘해요 그리고 시즌1은 후보정 별로 없었어요
@@나만의덕질채널 시즌1 시즌48 둘다 봤다 김세정 원픽으로 당시 계정 7개인가 8개 돌려가며 김세정 51표 투표했었음 막회때 ××××51표인가(? 6개 돌려서 42표였던거 같기도 하고 무튼)로 끝나서 저건 내표다했던 기억도 있네ㅋㅋ 김소혜가 보통 걸그룹의 서브보컬 수준으로 부르게끔 방송에 나왔는데 후보정 쩔었던건 맞지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그리고 48을 시즌1에 비빌려는게 아니라 48나온 일본애들 보면 처참한 실력인데 그 애들을 시청자가 들을 수 있을만큼으로 보정 오지게 해줬기에 예시로 든거ㅇㅇ 당연히 실력은 비비면 안되지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ (+몇명제외)
seunghee's voice is really beautiful
Seunghee suits this song perfectly
well she did record the demo
목이 안풀린거같은데.. 단콘에서 꼭 오마이걸 단체로 춤추며 불러주길
The truth is... The two girls have amazing voice ~~
이 노래 사실 좋아하는데 언니들이 ㅜㅜㅜ더 좋아해야지..ㅜㅜ❤️❤️
If only OMG could cover this song as a whole.
hey this song is so hard to sing you know？ girls on top have so many people to sing this but seunghee n hyojung just two of them！pls dont compare,respect all of them
Dont forget that When Cherry blossoms fade vocal guide is recorded by oh my girl seunghee and is produced by jinyoung too
so proud that seunghee sang the demo of this song💓
The song itself is great. The demo of the song (sang by Seunghee) was even famous before recording of 5 concepts competion which is one of the reasons helped the song won No. 1.
I understand that some people after getting used to P101 version think that Girls on Top can sing better. It's true that they delivered the song well, but please at least show respect to the girls helped the song famous even before official performance and listen to Oh My Girl sing live on other radio/show or their Mr. Removed M/V to know how well they can sing (Both of them can hit higher note than high note of this song ^^).
And come on, comparing 7 to 2 is not fair. It's just they don't have time to practise this song perfectly ^_^ Peace and enjoy the music juseyo :)
+GI NA Let me love you for this comment. I'm crying. T____T
Don't cry please ^_^
***** regretfully they haven't released up to now, will send you if I find out ^_^
아니ㅜㅜ 이것만봐도 개오지는데ㅜㅜㅜ 완전체로 부르면 얼마나 이쁠까... 심지어 효정언니 목상태안좋았을때 라이브래ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 언니들사랑해 다해먹어ㅠㅠㅠ
when i hear this song in pd101 i tot this is oh my girl's song, glad they covered it!
tbh i like this version more... i feel like less voice variation in this song sounds better.
Seunghee is original :)))
Wow this girls sing perfect, I love Seunghee she is so pretty and her voice is amazing.
둘이 목소리 진짜 좋다👍👍
던던댄스로 입덕한 나, 침투해버렸다.. 5년만에 듣는 추억의 곡을 최근에 팬이 된 오마이걸이 부른다니..
So Seunghee originally sang this song?
+Marc Sevilla Seunghee guiding for Produce 101
When the Cherry Blossoms Fade also.
+minato808 She did When the Cherry Blossoms Fade demo as well? I wish WM would release those demos Seunghee recorded.
its hard to tell,,, but i think if oh my girl came back with this song they would be daebak the same way as gfriend rose to fame. don't get me wrong liar liar is such a strongggg gem
+halla B I KNOW! and they should have went with Jinyoung's 1step, 2step! >_>
+halla B i think if they did they would only be compared (like what is happening in this very video's comment section) to other girl groups tbh. that's why one step, two step isn't the title. otherwise they'd get hate thrown at them for "not being as good as group a" or "group b could've sung this better" or "total copy/trying to be group c" ;;;; so sticking with more their own style is best otl
stop the hate.. Who else out there is so proud of Jinyoung? :') his songs were so awesome! and he even choose his lblmate to do the guide song. omg :3
Gosh OMG is so talented
I GOT GOOSEBUMPS AAAAAH
그냥 두팀다잘했다!
굳이 누가낫고 누가못했다고 따져야하나?
원래 아오아팬이고 이번퀸덤에서 오마이걸다시봐서 예쁘고 실력있는그룹이라 관심가서 이영상까지 오게됬는데
댓글보다보니 너무속상하다
얘들이 누가나은지 평가해달라는것도 아니고 두팀다 너무 잘하는거 아는데 ...
이런댓글을 보게된다면 애들이 과연기뻐할까 의문이다...
모두 잘해요! 두팀다 응원합시다!
to people who said pd101 did better than them its because they were like 7 of them right? thats why they can sing better bc they divide the parts meanwhile this is only two of omg member yet they slay this song.
This song is so good.. I really love it.. They also sing it well.. as well as produce 101..
오늘 고등학교 졸업하고 갑자기 생각나서 들었는데 아ㅠㅠ 뭔가 더욱이 씁쓸한 느낌이 들면서 슬픈 느낌이 들어요 아직 나는 같은 곳에 계속 있는데 현실은 벌써 지난날로 기록되어서 다른 사람이 되어가는거 같고 참 기분이 새롭기도하고 한편으론 허전해요오.....
my dream came true!! i wished them to do this cover since it was supposed to their song!!!
so cool! my day is better after this. ♡
She nailed it. I love this version as well 💕
it's hard for hyojung, but it's suitable for seunghee
I prefer this version'💕💕oh my girl fighting
목소리 짱조아...
헐 둘이 같곳도 불렀구나 ㅠㅠ 너무좋다
Great cover from Seunghee and the leader Hyojung from Oh My Girl band.There are so daebak..Hihi.Fightinggg.#seunghee,#hyojung,#ohmygirl,#wmfamily.
This was really beautiful.
Logically speaking, a 7-member team would sound better as they have various vocal ranges.
But speaking in behalf of this video, Seunghee's vocals sounded good enough in this video, what more if the whole Oh My Girl created a cover of this song?
Stop with the saltiness, both did a great job.
P.S: Jinyoung guided them (Girls on Top) to sing ITSP, it was Seunghee who DIRECTED them (as chosen by Jinyoung).
I like both versions of this song ^_^ but I don't think it's fair to compare 7 people singing it to 2 people singing it. And also Hyojung's voice doesn't really suit the song as much as Seunghee. The people saying that Seunghee has a "cutesy" voice, i suggest that you watch her on King of Masked Singer. She's amazing and her voice does not sound "cutesy" one bit. ;)
Omo! They did great! I likeeeee it
They should make this song as their debut song, unfortunately it come to pr101... T.T . i think OMG will be well known right now...
seunghee high note beats the rest! so stable!!!!!
Actually they both did a great job👍especially Seunghee❣😍I love her adlib because even Produce 101 trainees didn't (or couldn't) do that in live show.Actually when I am watching Girls on top live I wonder why some high notes are only in the background music and now I appreciate Seunghee for singing them and she really did a GREAT GREAT JOB!!!😍😍😍💗💗💗💗
the Pd101 girls did some adlib too esp Yeunjung try watching IoI's perf of this song
@@antonmacapili9930 yeah I watched the pd101 performance for many times and I think what I meant was really some of the adlibs in the background vocals which Yeonjung and Sira missed out
목상태 안좋은거맞나요... 너무잘부른다♥
SEUNGHEE'S VOICE OMG
I first listen to this during Produce 101 and first i didnt know that seunghee is the guideline but I feel this song fit Oh My Girl so much since I got the same feeling as One Step Two Step ❤️ Jinyoung Jjang!!! 👍🏻
smh,srsly the comments section is full of ppl comparing a song which was sung by 2 different groups.... first group had 7 ppl while the second group had only 2 ppl...ofc the first group did better because of having more people and the parts divided to each member whilst the second group tried their hardest as the parts were probably not properly distributed....smh
preach, share and retweet