Technically he was telling the truth because Vader is Anakin. The light and dark, two sides of the same coin. Vader chose to save himself, his younger self. Which in turn saved the galaxy and brought balance to the force.
It definitely did, we’ve seen Vader “kill” Anakin multiple times in comics but he never truly could and finally Luke tipped the scales back into Anakin’s favour
Luke didn't just tip the scales, lol. He slammed his lightside fist down on the Darth Vader side, which gave Anakin the courage to accept all his previous failings, and in that one moment, redeem himself in the eyes of his son, even if only his Son ever knew.
What if Vader just left the empire, went awol and went on a dark side pilgrimage across the outer rim into wild space and possibly into the unknown regions?
That's what the guard was for they were there to monitor and take out Vader should he ever go awol. They reported directly to the Emperor, remember his master isn't stupid or foolish he always planned 10 steps ahead and made sure to have many backups for just in case.
I hope he makes your theory next. I would love to see that happen please dude make a theory on this and I agree with you. This should be a theory. You should make a really hope he does please if you’re listening make this theory happen, the best ever
I have the feeling that's time travel will be used in the future , a history like days of future past in the star wars verse will be dope , and ahsoka will be the time traveller that will change everything , she lived in the clone wars , empire and beyond , she wittnesses everything , so making her the one who will make the change will be the best choice
What if obiwan fled after seeing his master killed? Saving darth maul as Palpatine's apprentice for the start of the war and preventing Obi-Wan from becoming a knight due to not killing a sith.
Just a thought: Palpatine probably would’ve already recognized that it was somehow Anakin upon seeing him because of his armor… I highly doubt that he quickly designed that within the span of hours during the surgery…
@@jefferickson8493Well not entirely true...Mother Talzin still knew Maul her son was alive she would have somehow found him probably a lot of people forget this.
Not sure how this story would work, but what if the Jedi had been more proactive within the galaxy well before the Clone Wars? This what if was an interesting take. Too often time travel is used as a reset button (looking at you star trek) or as a mcguffin. This one worked for me.
In my opinion time travel stories are very complex very very complicated. Time travel can be very complex a timeline, and then when you travel from time to time butterfly effect in a whole new timeline, and I’m not gonna go any further.
Main complaint, he did bring balance to the force in the original movies. Legit, the jedi were overpowering the force, the Jedi were just to arrogant in thinking their way was the only way. Hence he would destroy the sith, but in reality, he was made to destroy the Jedi
Great story. I liked this one. Maybe a little longer. Maybe a bit more dialog between them. Maybe Vader said something to Anakin that he would know as a way of showing him that he is an older version of him.
This was so well done! Doesn't matter about the so-called aspects of time travel. I really appreciate this story. I could imagine the whole thing playing out. Excellent story writing.
Beautiful illustrations to provide for the narration of your story. Your story's are always creative, entertaining and above all captivating. Thank you for all your efforts!!
“The nightmares are Palpatine’s creation, fool!” -All the words that ever needed to be said to undo years of Palpatine’s careful scheming. Just wish SW What If writers could stop beating the dead horse of Palpatine escaping Windu to initiate Order 66. Every iteration of that plot device has been expressed. Interesting story, though.
Anikan/Vader is such a good character. Fighting between the light and dark. Wanting to rule the galaxy while trying to blind himself from the pain and regret of his past. While the light consistently breaks through to him
Personally love time travel stories I would love to see what if after Anakin died on the death Star his consciousness got sent back to his 9-year-old body the day before he left tatooine
Man this is the best fuckin story i think i have heard yet,even from the original.this would have been the greatest way the star wars sega could end.im totally blown away
awesome fanfic! i am a big time travel fan and well... if vader travelled back in time to stop himself turn to the darkside, then he wouldnt exist in the future so he would get erased from time. so that means no one ever told anakin wich means.. i have no idea what would happen though lol, like i said awesome fanfic
That was a very good story my wife even liked it we listened to it together and she's just now joining the Star wars train after all these years and we're older just put it to you like that but I was a good story man keep them coming. Remember this young people there's never a bad star wars story it's still a Star wars story because if they weren't being done then you would be wanting them just like I was all these years I've been wanting more Star wars hey look Disney's version wasn't great but I can honestly say it 50 years old at least it's Star wars I didn't love them but I enjoyed seeing Star wars so that's all I have to say about that keep them coming brother.
Impressive. Most Impressive. But, in every version of this idea played out, one thing I always thought would make things better, was if the public saw Sidious, using his red LIGHTSABER..and actively using the FORCE, in the fight/fights..suddenly being exposed for what he..the..SITH..he was.
"It doesn't matter who I am. You can already see it yourself. A sith, a monster, a fool. But to know who I once WAS, might be more important too you than anything else today. For if you know what fool, what utter and complete fool I was many years ago, you can avoid falling like I did. Failing in the one thing I tried to achieve." "My name was Anakin Skywalker. And I was the reason Padme Amidala died."
LEGO Star Wars Holiday Special has time travel as a major part of its plot, as Rey is guided to a Jedi Temple on the planet Kordoku. She finds a portal there that sends her on a journey of Non-Canon In a tale from Dark Horse Comics, Jedi Master Mace Windu traveled back in time to save an ancient society from extinction a Statue of himself was there
If Darth Vader went back in time to make sure he didn't turn to the dark side, once his mission is complete or if his past self is killed... that version of him ceases to be... (because the events that lead to him needing that "mobile Hospital" was altered.)
Bro that is a f ing good Fan Fiction! The "This is what You tube was made for" Level of f ing good! PS: If you allow an Idea... take this one as Basic Episode 3 rework and then redo the canon timeline , everything that happened and all the characters that came in this new Timeline... E4 with Anakin, Luke,Leia,Solo,Chewie,Ahsoka,Ezra,Sabine,Hera,Kanan,Mace,Rex,Bad Batch,Grogu,Din Jarin etc...
The events would've happened just like that. Though I doubt Vader would've been as careless, given his experience. Now what would happen...if the Clone Rebellion on Kamino succeeded?
Everyone assumes Sidious puts those dreams into Anakin's nightmares. NOT the case, it's called a self filling prophecy. Those dreams were meant as a deterrent to not go down the dark path, NOT choose it like crazy pants did. They were probably shadowed by Sidious and not complete due to dark side interference
Vader: Yo dude, the Dark Side is not chill!
My story in 2 seconds
Anakin: bet.
Then Anakin and Vader go to bully Palpatine.
maybe you should like, abandon the path
The dark side is not cash money
We cant use lightning that shit aint worth it
That was surprisingly compelling!
"Don't kill him. You're not that guy. *I* am that guy."
If Anakin killed Palpatine, ti would be tragic, if Vader did it, it was a Sunday
Vader: yea if I do it it’s just another day in the office but if U do it u would never be the same
"Anakin said that he, alone, chased after Sidious." What he said was the truth, from a certain point of view.
I see what you did there
Technically he was telling the truth because Vader is Anakin. The light and dark, two sides of the same coin. Vader chose to save himself, his younger self. Which in turn saved the galaxy and brought balance to the force.
@@ChrisTheGhostHunter That's the point of view I meant.
😂😂😂
@@ChrisTheGhostHunter That's a very interesting dichotomy
Vader: Was I always that handsome?
Getting lost in his own eyes
Past Anakin: sir? Are you alright?
😆
@@thestarwarsgalaxyproceeds to try and rizz up his past self
Anakin: "OMG A SITH LORD I KNEW IT!" Vader: "Wait me! I'm you!"
Skyfall plays
Anakin and Vader teaming up to kill Sidious? That is exactly what I wanted to see in the "What if" universe.
It'd be cool if we could get this animated somehow
at this point, this channel is the star wars what if series
@@quackers_and_miThat would be AMAZING!
@@Joe_Goldberg533🍑 💨
@@Joe_Goldberg533idk why I commented that 😂
Not just time travel. I imagine this duel happened many times over the years inside of Vader's mind until Luke tipped the scales in Anakin's favor.
It definitely did, we’ve seen Vader “kill” Anakin multiple times in comics but he never truly could and finally Luke tipped the scales back into Anakin’s favour
holiday special lego is question if was canon so is possible to have that rock
Luke didn't just tip the scales, lol. He slammed his lightside fist down on the Darth Vader side, which gave Anakin the courage to accept all his previous failings, and in that one moment, redeem himself in the eyes of his son, even if only his Son ever knew.
What if Palpatine LOST the election in The Phantom Menace?
Good idea
Then he wouldn’t be the Senate
@@LJC94512He would be the Senator
The election was rigged, fake news.
@@smokescreen100
"I am the senator"
"You are."
I love the idea that the force has a ghost of any light sider turned dark split between their personalities
Revan?
@@guilhermehank4938Kinda.
Anakin: you don’t have to do this. You will die.
Vader: Nothing... can stop that now.
Bro when i saw the title i just imagined vader saying "Yo dude the dark side is not chill!"😂
What if Dooku discovered the world between worlds and saved Qui Gon?
That sounds REAL GOOD!!
Oh, I love that theory 20 that’s also getting my fever right next to him along side, guess being inside of jar jar b
I would love to see that I've always loved dooku and being able to here a story where he saved his apprentice would be awsome
or discovered that magicla time traveling rock from lego holiday special
He would go back and time and tell himself, "you dont have the high ground!"
Excellent!!! A great redemption story. Anakin deserves a happy ending.
Let me finish this masterpiece!!
I really enjoyed this one man. It was very good. Vader’s Sacrifice, and Anakin’s Conflict. Man this was good
Thank you so much!!
Vader, Helping Anakin" I lead others to a treasure I cannot possess"
Of the countless "what if..."s I've watched/listened to, this one is my favorite. Well done.
What If Obi-Wan trained Barriss and Luminara trained Anakin
What If Padme didn't fall out of the Transport in Attack Of The Clones
What if Vader just left the empire, went awol and went on a dark side pilgrimage across the outer rim into wild space and possibly into the unknown regions?
Thrawn would be his personal guide and translator
Probably wouldnt be too good for his already rapidly deteriorated mental health
What if he found darth Marr from swtor and had him as his new master?
That's what the guard was for they were there to monitor and take out Vader should he ever go awol. They reported directly to the Emperor, remember his master isn't stupid or foolish he always planned 10 steps ahead and made sure to have many backups for just in case.
I'm surprised Vader didn't kill Anakin when he remembered he'd have another round at youngling hunting.
Ohhh mahhh gawdddd
😂
Idk why, the meme and jokes for this are always funny, even when they shouldn't be lol.
XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
I wonder why did Darth Vader never had the courage to turn back to the light side since he knew so well that the emperor was manipulating him
He had nothing left. At least not till he found out about Luke and Leia.
And he know that his Armor were no match for Sidious Powers and he had so much fear about the Sith-Lord.@@johnmartin122187
What if Darth Plaguis survived by becoming Jar Jar Binks' split personality that emerges every time Jar Jar falls asleep?
I hope he makes your theory next. I would love to see that happen please dude make a theory on this and I agree with you. This should be a theory. You should make a really hope he does please if you’re listening make this theory happen, the best ever
What the hell
The first rule of the Dark Side: you do not talk about the Dark Side.
some jekyll and hyde type shit
@@private_pyle684 dr jar jar and mr plagueis
I have the feeling that's time travel will be used in the future , a history like days of future past in the star wars verse will be dope , and ahsoka will be the time traveller that will change everything , she lived in the clone wars , empire and beyond , she wittnesses everything , so making her the one who will make the change will be the best choice
Love all your stories and how they always have a happy ending!
What if obiwan fled after seeing his master killed? Saving darth maul as Palpatine's apprentice for the start of the war and preventing Obi-Wan from becoming a knight due to not killing a sith.
what if Anakin went to save his mother on his own without Padme? Would he still go to geonosis? would he turn to the dark side?
Darth Vader / Anakin Skywalker Paradox. So cool . Bravo Master .
I like the use of that Portal from the Vader Comics. Almost forgot about that since the World Between Worlds was a thing.
Just a thought: Palpatine probably would’ve already recognized that it was somehow Anakin upon seeing him because of his armor… I highly doubt that he quickly designed that within the span of hours during the surgery…
He would have recognized his name
@@kanestalin7246 what?
@@prestonferry palpatine would have known Vader's name
@@kanestalin7246 I don’t think they said his name did they?
@@prestonferry They didn't
What if Savage Opress stayed Dooku’s apprentice until the end of the Clone Wars?
Maul wouldn't come back, and dooku and savage would make a grab at Sidious at some point. I'd like them to win, but we'll see!
I could see ventless and dooju going in all the way as genuine lovers in the dark side
@@jefferickson8493Well not entirely true...Mother Talzin still knew Maul her son was alive she would have somehow found him probably a lot of people forget this.
This is pretty good except that would mean that Savage doesn't find Maul. Do you think we will ever see a live action version of Savage Oppress?
Not sure how this story would work, but what if the Jedi had been more proactive within the galaxy well before the Clone Wars?
This what if was an interesting take. Too often time travel is used as a reset button (looking at you star trek) or as a mcguffin. This one worked for me.
He hates himself enough, its plausible. Would still have to force choke humble his younger self.
In my opinion time travel stories are very complex very very complicated. Time travel can be very complex a timeline, and then when you travel from time to time butterfly effect in a whole new timeline, and I’m not gonna go any further.
You’re my favourite What if Star Wars RUclipsr, you actually make each episode so entertaining and have so many unique ideas, keep up the good work!
Vader's sacrifice was so good, yet made sense! :D Congrats!
He was like: This is gonna be my second chance... What if I save myself...
I like the fact you had vaders soul split into the good anakin it should have been lore
I like how you made anakin into an almost quasi-revan at the end being split into 2 beings like that
Main complaint, he did bring balance to the force in the original movies. Legit, the jedi were overpowering the force, the Jedi were just to arrogant in thinking their way was the only way. Hence he would destroy the sith, but in reality, he was made to destroy the Jedi
Being a big star wars fan and a father myself I hate to admit this but this what if brought a tear to my eye
Exceptionally well written and presented. I would love to see it on the big screen.
Great story. I liked this one. Maybe a little longer. Maybe a bit more dialog between them. Maybe Vader said something to Anakin that he would know as a way of showing him that he is an older version of him.
This was so well done! Doesn't matter about the so-called aspects of time travel. I really appreciate this story. I could imagine the whole thing playing out. Excellent story writing.
What if Darth Vader went back in time to help Anakin kill obi wan.
Anakin would’ve became wayyyyyy more poweful
@@MR.Cristian19That would be wildddd
Obi wan solos both those bums. Ez dubs
@@rocketdogbradNo
Obin Wan Win, high ground baby
For a fan fiction, that wasn't bad! I wish it was longer!
Same
Beautiful illustrations to provide for the narration of your story.
Your story's are always creative, entertaining and above all captivating.
Thank you for all your efforts!!
“The nightmares are Palpatine’s creation, fool!” -All the words that ever needed to be said to undo years of Palpatine’s careful scheming.
Just wish SW What If writers could stop beating the dead horse of Palpatine escaping Windu to initiate Order 66.
Every iteration of that plot device has been expressed.
Interesting story, though.
Anikan/Vader is such a good character. Fighting between the light and dark. Wanting to rule the galaxy while trying to blind himself from the pain and regret of his past. While the light consistently breaks through to him
Personally love time travel stories I would love to see what if after Anakin died on the death Star his consciousness got sent back to his 9-year-old body the day before he left tatooine
This is a great idea!
That would soooo cool, oh gosh. Imagine how absolutely sassy teenage-Vader-Anakin would be. 😂
Or his 9 year old self the day he met quigon
That would be hell, be happy he's finally free
@@BSwims777YOU OWN ME NO LONGER WADOW force chokes wado wado dies😵💀
Man this is the best fuckin story i think i have heard yet,even from the original.this would have been the greatest way the star wars sega could end.im totally blown away
Thank you for this awesome story. Loved it.
What if Qui Gon Jinn lived to see the fall of his master & later confront him? (Thought it would be a neat parallel to Obi Wan & Anakin)
Ooooh. The reverse of that what-if you did a month or so back.
Yes! Hope you enjoy!
It never ceases to amaze me how much better people on YT or elsewhere can write a Star Wars piece than paid Hollywood writers.
Bro,this was amazing!!!!❤
I can imagine vader telling Anikin "if you continue down your path, I am your destiny"
GREAT JOB SLICKKK! FANTASTIC FAN FICTION!!
Dude I just wanna say you are one of the only sw fan fic makers I watch I love how u post everyday man keep it up❤❤
I appreciate that so very much, Ahsoka Tano
This was really well done!
What if Boba Fett was force sensitive?
No hate but boba fett is a clone
The craziest part of your videos is the visualization. Its like watching a movie in your head without forcing it
One of your best whats ifs ever man this one was f**king amazing
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
This was truly an amazing yet short story
Thank you!!!
awesome fanfic! i am a big time travel fan and well... if vader travelled back in time to stop himself turn to the darkside, then he wouldnt exist in the future so he would get erased from time. so that means no one ever told anakin wich means.. i have no idea what would happen though lol, like i said awesome fanfic
That was a very good story my wife even liked it we listened to it together and she's just now joining the Star wars train after all these years and we're older just put it to you like that but I was a good story man keep them coming. Remember this young people there's never a bad star wars story it's still a Star wars story because if they weren't being done then you would be wanting them just like I was all these years I've been wanting more Star wars hey look Disney's version wasn't great but I can honestly say it 50 years old at least it's Star wars I didn't love them but I enjoyed seeing Star wars so that's all I have to say about that keep them coming brother.
I wanna see this in a Star Wars “what if?”
Yes this would be awesome
I love these stories, my dude
This was great. Loved the detail
So far that’s the second time you’ve written the chosen one to have completed his duties that I’ve seen
Love this! Great job !
Bro this had me in tears 😢 AMAZING!!!!
Interesting concept, you did a good job telling it from your piont of view. Keep your mind and imagination sharp. The future needs you. 😉👍
Great story 🎉 love Darth Vader and Anakin chasing Sidious. Love the ending 😊
THIS WAS GREAT!!!
Impressive. Most Impressive. But, in every version of this idea played out, one thing I always thought would make things better, was if the public saw Sidious, using his red LIGHTSABER..and actively using the FORCE, in the fight/fights..suddenly being exposed for what he..the..SITH..he was.
Anakin skywalker: thank you for saving me other me
That was awesome great job writing this
Liked it dude. Only wished it was longer with more
"It doesn't matter who I am. You can already see it yourself. A sith, a monster, a fool. But to know who I once WAS, might be more important too you than anything else today. For if you know what fool, what utter and complete fool I was many years ago, you can avoid falling like I did. Failing in the one thing I tried to achieve." "My name was Anakin Skywalker. And I was the reason Padme Amidala died."
Well i'm certainly not crying 🤣😭🤣😭🤣 f@ck that was amazing,i loved it
LEGO Star Wars Holiday Special has time travel as a major part of its plot, as Rey is guided to a Jedi Temple on the planet Kordoku. She finds a portal there that sends her on a journey of Non-Canon
In a tale from Dark Horse Comics, Jedi Master Mace Windu traveled back in time to save an ancient society from extinction a Statue of himself was there
If Darth Vader went back in time to make sure he didn't turn to the dark side, once his mission is complete or if his past self is killed... that version of him ceases to be... (because the events that lead to him needing that "mobile Hospital" was altered.)
THATS not how quantum physics works
the grandfather paradox.
We will just disregard that for now.
I was waiting for something like, "You killed the sith lord, but we do not grant you the rank of master."
Ok, that was a good tale. Thank you.
I love this story. Anakin winds up the way he should have. Thank you for this!!
Vader looks around sees obi wan says KENOBOI
Timey-Wimey Ball, ACTIVATE! 😵💫
Idc what people might think, I LOVE time travel fics. For every fandom. But especially in Star Wars
Bro that is a f ing good Fan Fiction!
The "This is what You tube was made for" Level of f ing good!
PS: If you allow an Idea...
take this one as Basic Episode 3 rework
and then redo the canon timeline , everything that happened and all the characters that came in this new Timeline...
E4 with Anakin, Luke,Leia,Solo,Chewie,Ahsoka,Ezra,Sabine,Hera,Kanan,Mace,Rex,Bad Batch,Grogu,Din Jarin etc...
In my opinion I really like Star Wars cross over events. Oh by the weight can you do a my hero academia cross over with Star Wars.
How about in the spirit of Halloween and spooky season "What if Jason Voorheese became a force user" lol. That was a good one though.
"I've learned a terrible truth. I think Jason voorhees is a sith lord" "A SITH LAWD?"
The events would've happened just like that. Though I doubt Vader would've been as careless, given his experience. Now what would happen...if the Clone Rebellion on Kamino succeeded?
Praying this becomes a movie
This was a masterpiece it was beautiful. This video is amazing.
This could be a great short film the best" What if?" in Star wars history
Everyone assumes Sidious puts those dreams into Anakin's nightmares. NOT the case, it's called a self filling prophecy. Those dreams were meant as a deterrent to not go down the dark path, NOT choose it like crazy pants did. They were probably shadowed by Sidious and not complete due to dark side interference
Not really, the dreams actually were coming from the dark side to entice him whether or not it was palpatine
@@timesupea I believe this is most likely, since the dreams didn’t include anything about the dark side…
This needs to become a movie
Ngl this has to be one of my fav fanfics I've listened to
He should've stopped his past stupid-self from cutting Mace Windu's arm off, so there wouldn't be any Emperor Palpatine.