The quote that Anakin said, "I wish I could make you understand, but I'm not going back. Nothing can make me change my mind." was the exact quote that Luke said to R2 in The Last Jedi.
They were basically three confused spectacles about star wars-ish things, I even really liked some scenes and ideas but they just wandered around in circles and deus ex machina with a bunch of flashy fake feeling effects. I liked the cast too, they were not the problem at all.
Never forget, Anakin and Padme swapped droids as a wedding gift to each other. That droid is, in a roundabout way, a sort of marital symbol for the Skywalkers.
And it was a good way to redeem himself from the massacre he did even if he did survive its almost impossible to redeem yourself after killing thousands including children.
Anakin fulfilled his purpose of bringing balance to the Force, and kept his promises to his Mum and Padme; he didn't fail again. He learnt how to save Padme, and Luke and Leia would grow up knowing that their father freed the galaxy from two of the greatest evils in thousands of years, also killing three powerful Sith Lords. Giving his life to do it so they could live safe and happy lives. That's the Anakin we were expecting him to be at the end of A New Hope!
@@rachelprighel4409 Padme was one of the biggest threats to Palpatine's plan because she could've been the one thing keeping Anakin in the light side and he needed Anakin to turn to the dark side. she probably would've pulled him back to the light too if Obi-wan didn't follow her
This story was well written, albeit somewhat depressing at the end. Nicely done my friend. I had no idea which direction you would take it, it kept me on the edge of my seat. It was nice to see R2 play a role in the story as well.
Finally a story with, sad but happy ending.. Anakin Skywalker died but redeeming himself in the end, and Padme was forced to abandon the man she loved, so his sacrifice won't be in vain.. She lived with her children full filling a prophecy, that there would be balance to the force....
What if Padme was secretly trained by Grand Master Yoda and has been a Jedi Master for years? She shows up on Mustafar to confront Anakin. She reveals this to stop Anakin from Force Choking Obi-Wan.
I feel like the shuttle appearing so early was an extreme stretch. Palpatine had no reason to move up his time line in this and get to Mustafar earlier
What if, “Anakin,” killed, “-Wan,” used his full potential, used his powers to save, “Padmé,” then living with her and his kids, and becomes a, “Jedi,” again, as, “Obi-Wan,” becomes the evil, “Darth Vader..”
Agreed with everything. The only part that I disagree is that I strongly believe that Anakin should survive the clones attack at the final part. No matter how many clones the chosen should be powerful enough to take out most of them or even survive at least.
At least he died a hero, someone who Obi Wan can tell stories of to make his children proud, even if he cant forgive him Anakin did save the order, with or without him the clones would have annihilated the temple in Order 66
R2D2 is metaphorically equivalent to a K9 gsd or Malinois, alive and intelligent, but in particularly needed for it's above human abilities. In Star Wars it's astromech stuff, navigation, repair, rerouting, and analysis not detection, tracking and security but the allegory seemed clear to me. Of course R2D2 might have been perfect in approaching him because of that kind of relationship. R2 saw that and was sad and worried about his master without any judgment or reproach, the exact thing that hadn't been tried by others.
What If Kit Fisto went to Utapau with Obi-Wan and Mace Windu was sent to Kashyyyk instead while Yoda stayed on Coruscant What If Plo Koon trained Ahsoka and Anakin SkyWalker trained Barriss
did....did he just do halo reach's lone wolf mission in starwars? loved the story normally i dont these kind of endings but it was really good keep up the good work. also hearing the latter half of the episode my mind went directly to the last missions of halo reach, specially with his ending.
Ah yes. Your best friend walks into a day care center and deletes the lives of a dozen children and you're just gonna show up in a helicopter and say 'It's okay fam, I forgive you'. Uh-huh.
For a future what if, say after so much sacrifice in the wars the Jedi do something they wouldn't have consider before. They keep one or two Jedi in a position close to Palpatine. If the Sith Lord were to be revealed or some other circumstance demanded it, they would put an end to the Chancellors reign. Therefore removing a key player from the Sith. They understand going in that they were sacrificial lambs sent to save the Republic, and if discovered would be declared to be rogue Jedi by the Order. Or something like that.
really liked Anakin's sacrifice in the end. Well done, I do love R2 being the one to bring him back out of all creatures and droids our spunky little R2 unit did it
I love how Anakin dies. Honestly I think Anakin shouldn't get a redemption without either dying or losing someone he loves. He needs to have consequences for his actions like this one had him face.
@@ML-sc3pt when I say losing someone he loves I dont mean they have to die nor do i think Anakin needs to do. When I talk about him losing those he loves I mean that they could either die or they could abandon him because of how bad he royally screwed up. Also I think prison is a valid form of a consequence if it's him suffering alone
What if The Jedi led by Obi-Wan betrayed and murdered Anakin and Vader joined Palpatine. This is based on a deleted plot point in Star Wars Empire Strikes Back. This will change everything.
When he was rebuilt as a partial cyborg, Aniken died & Darth Vader was born. One person, two separate people in one body. Still, when he saved Luke from Palptine, he turned back to the light side of the force & I think that’s why he got to come back as a force ghost. May the force be with all of us,ALWAYS!!!
Darth Vader was born way before that. Darth Vader was a seed that was planted the moment that he met the Jedi. Darth Vader represents all of Anakin's pain and anger.
what if Obi wan Left the Jedi order for satine when he was stil a padewan in the Mandalorian Civil war between the new Mandalorians and the Mandalorian clans
I wish for his sake he would have. I would have loved to have seen him raise his family. Ah but because they had to be secret about it that was what was wrong in the first place. Would you not agree?
I'd love to know what the gunners on the Tantive were doing. There's not a good reason why a few clone LAATs should have been able to destroy the platform or even get near while the ship was there.
@@andrewortelli7631 Now, I'm not saying you're wrong and I'm right. Let me describe to you what my reasoning is: The Tantive has been seen taking hits from Star Destroyers in the movies. It could have interposed itself between the platform and the incoming transports and fired upon them with its weapons to force them to break off. The weapons on that ship are good enough to down fighters, it would be easier to track big LAATs. I'm also fairly sure their weapons outrange the LAATs, meaning they could have fired upon the incoming before they ever got into range. So, from my perspective, the Tantive has a range, firepower, and defensive capability edge over all ten of those LAATs, which are transport gunships meant to engage unprotected ground forces and ferry troops around. It would be like ten Blackhawks armed with hellfire missile pods attacking a guided missile destroyer. Yeah, they could do some damage, but the destroyer would knock them all out of the sky in the process and would still largely be functional when the fight is over.
@@andrewortelli7631 Now, I'm not saying you're wrong and I'm right. Let me describe to you what my reasoning is: The Tantive has been seen taking hits from Star Destroyers in the movies. It could have interposed itself between the platform and the incoming transports and fired upon them with its weapons to force them to break off. The weapons on that ship are good enough to down fighters, it would be easier to track big LAATs. I'm also fairly sure their weapons outrange the LAATs, meaning they could have fired upon the incoming before they ever got into range. So, from my perspective, the Tantive has a range, firepower, and defensive capability edge over all ten of those LAATs, which are transport gunships meant to engage unprotected ground forces and ferry troops around. It would be like ten Blackhawks armed with hellfire missile pods attacking a guided missile destroyer. Yeah, they could do some damage, but the destroyer would knock them all out of the sky in the process and would still largely be functional when the fight is over. Things may be different in Star Wars, or changed between Episode 3 and Episode 4 on the corvette, but still.
What if Anakin turned back to the light before the assault on the Temple? Order 66 has been issued, Mace Windu is presumed dead. But this is just too much. He can't slaughte the Jedi in cold blood. Attacking Mace had been an impulse, and one he instantly regretted. His confusion had left him week to Palpatine's manipulation, but faced with the enormity of this act, he realized he couldn't go through with it. As the 501st is mustering on the Temple steps, waiting for his order to attack, he realizes he has to stop this. But how?
Day 5 What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
@@seth3k Darth Talon is just like Darth Vader and Darth Maul. It's s title and a symbolic name, not a birth name. So, just like any other Sith could've been declared or become "Darth Vader" if Anakin never fell, I'm positive Aayla Secura could've become Darth Talon if Alema Rar didn't become Darth Talon and Secura fell to the dark side.
This would have been impossible because he would have been even more emotional and aggressive even if he turned back to the light he still would have been very emotional and aggressive it would be inevitable that he would kill ether way dark or light
also the star wars galaxy What If Anakin Skywalker Reached His FULL POTENTIAL In Attack Of The Clones was awesome anakin skywalker reaching his full potential becoming grandmaster and padme becoming supreme chancellor again amazing next what if plase make what if anakin went to the wellspring of life with yoda you know that one will work
Finally some love for the greatest Droid to ever exist. I loved how he was the one to bring Anakin back
I know. This is why R2 will always be “Best Droid” in the entirety of the Star Wars franchise.
@@alexander.tahtadjianmust be forgetting
GONK, GONK GONK GONK.
@@martialabyss7997darth gonker
The quote that Anakin said, "I wish I could make you understand, but I'm not going back. Nothing can make me change my mind." was the exact quote that Luke said to R2 in The Last Jedi.
Jake Skywalker and we don't mention that abominable mess of a trilogy
@@lapplandkun9273
I hope you were replying to someone who's comment was removed and you didn't just diss the Original Trilogy...
@@volksdude1970 No. I'm dissing the Sequels.
They were basically three confused spectacles about star wars-ish things, I even really liked some scenes and ideas but they just wandered around in circles and deus ex machina with a bunch of flashy fake feeling effects. I liked the cast too, they were not the problem at all.
@@lapplandkun9273🤓
Never forget, Anakin and Padme swapped droids as a wedding gift to each other. That droid is, in a roundabout way, a sort of marital symbol for the Skywalkers.
Shoutout to the OG, R2-D2. The greatest droid of all time.
Gotta love him
let's step back a few more scenes.
What if Anakin couldn't bring himself to kill the Younglings?
I feel that’s something that should’ve happened in the original film.
It would make sense, especially as his main motivation was to protect his wife, and unborn child
@@JEF_W Yeah Very interesting
I second this. This needs to be a video
Seems like an alternate ending could have been Skywalker jumping and Kenobi force-pulling him through the air, as we’ve seen on several occasions.
Yes, but some of the point of him staying was to try and hold back the reinforcements from reaching the Tantive iv
And it was a good way to redeem himself from the massacre he did even if he did survive its almost impossible to redeem yourself after killing thousands including children.
@@chrisaizen3678you youngling soup...the best excuse ever
Anakin: Obi-Wan...
Obi-Wan: Anakin... did you consume the Death Sticks again?
Anakin: Well, it calls DEATH for a reason.
Anakin fulfilled his purpose of bringing balance to the Force, and kept his promises to his Mum and Padme; he didn't fail again. He learnt how to save Padme, and Luke and Leia would grow up knowing that their father freed the galaxy from two of the greatest evils in thousands of years, also killing three powerful Sith Lords. Giving his life to do it so they could live safe and happy lives. That's the Anakin we were expecting him to be at the end of A New Hope!
12:20 Really missed the opportunity to say "The grandmaster, the chosen one, and the negotiator."
I love the fact that R2-D2 was a HUGE part of this.
R2’s the true hero of Star Wars
Born a slave but died a hero, Anakin wouldn't have had it any other way
Bail would become chancellor before padme as shown in the clone wars bail had the respect of almost every senator and padme was often seen as biased
Padme has always been a thorn in Palpatine's dark side.
@@rachelprighel4409 Padme was one of the biggest threats to Palpatine's plan because she could've been the one thing keeping Anakin in the light side and he needed Anakin to turn to the dark side. she probably would've pulled him back to the light too if Obi-wan didn't follow her
This story was well written, albeit somewhat depressing at the end. Nicely done my friend. I had no idea which direction you would take it, it kept me on the edge of my seat. It was nice to see R2 play a role in the story as well.
Finally a story with, sad but happy ending.. Anakin Skywalker died but redeeming himself in the end, and Padme was forced to abandon the man she loved, so his sacrifice won't be in vain..
She lived with her children full filling a prophecy, that there would be balance to the force....
Beautiful writing. Great work! Loved that story.
that was cool seeing a space ship from one of my favorite video games (Star Citizen) at 7:20
Anakin be like
Objective: Survive
Had that halo mission in mind
I actually really like this story. If Revenge of the Sith were written today, I could definitely see this being how it would have ended.
Another fine and well produced show. Very well done indeed.
I liked the retelling , keep it up
Wow! That was so good! I loved how Anikin dies, makes the whole scene feel more realistic!
I really enjoy this, Finally R2 is recognized for the hero he is.
What if Padme was secretly trained by Grand Master Yoda and has been a Jedi Master for years? She shows up on Mustafar to confront Anakin. She reveals this to stop Anakin from Force Choking Obi-Wan.
What if Anakin disobeyed Sidious orders to go to Mustafar and instead went around the galaxy hunting jedi?
I feel like the shuttle appearing so early was an extreme stretch. Palpatine had no reason to move up his time line in this and get to Mustafar earlier
It’s a fanfic
What if, “Anakin,” killed, “-Wan,” used his full potential, used his powers to save, “Padmé,” then living with her and his kids, and becomes a, “Jedi,” again, as, “Obi-Wan,” becomes the evil, “Darth Vader..”
A pleasing sacrifice, then Anakin became one with the force in the end.
So Anakin really WAS the Chosen One.
Agreed with everything. The only part that I disagree is that I strongly believe that Anakin should survive the clones attack at the final part. No matter how many clones the chosen should be powerful enough to take out most of them or even survive at least.
At least he died a hero, someone who Obi Wan can tell stories of to make his children proud, even if he cant forgive him Anakin did save the order, with or without him the clones would have annihilated the temple in Order 66
I hope you do this one what if Padme Amidala was secretly a Je'daii
R2D2 is metaphorically equivalent to a K9 gsd or Malinois, alive and intelligent, but in particularly needed for it's above human abilities. In Star Wars it's astromech stuff, navigation, repair, rerouting, and analysis not detection, tracking and security but the allegory seemed clear to me. Of course R2D2 might have been perfect in approaching him because of that kind of relationship. R2 saw that and was sad and worried about his master without any judgment or reproach, the exact thing that hadn't been tried by others.
R2D2, the real hero of Star Wars!
Somehow I feel like the chosen one would have been able to fight the clones or at least escape and hide away...
Can you do part two please also keep up the good work
Hold up your asking for a part 2 but the video just came out?
@@zoande83yep it is good
I enjoyed this ❤
He could've assumed Control of the Droid Armies for Himself
What If Kit Fisto went to Utapau with Obi-Wan and Mace Windu was sent to Kashyyyk instead while Yoda stayed on Coruscant
What If Plo Koon trained Ahsoka and Anakin SkyWalker trained Barriss
Pretty sure Anakin and Barris were the same age
@@KoolAid-o7gwasnt barris just barely older than ahsoka?
I have listened to a few of your videos and i concluded that there was only a small chance the empire would rise.
Waht if when he was told to take a seat with the jedi counsel. That he actually took the seat abd left
That was a good video, sad Anakin died, but loved it...
Not only did you kill Anakin but you killed c3po to 😂😂😂😂
did....did he just do halo reach's lone wolf mission in starwars?
loved the story normally i dont these kind of endings but it was really good keep up the good work. also hearing the latter half of the episode my mind went directly to the last missions of halo reach, specially with his ending.
But wouldn't one of them following the mom's footsteps and be a politician?
Alternate title: *What if Anakin had a IQ?*
Damn, he handed over the youngling slayer 9000???
He must really regret that
Ah yes. Your best friend walks into a day care center and deletes the lives of a dozen children and you're just gonna show up in a helicopter and say 'It's okay fam, I forgive you'.
Uh-huh.
I would love to see you do a few what ifs with Je'daii.
It is rare to the what if like that
Maaaaan an anakin last stand scene would be siiiiick
What of Anakin Skywalker killed palpatine when he discovered that he was the sith Lord
For a future what if, say after so much sacrifice in the wars the Jedi do something they wouldn't have consider before. They keep one or two Jedi in a position close to Palpatine. If the Sith Lord were to be revealed or some other circumstance demanded it, they would put an end to the Chancellors reign. Therefore removing a key player from the Sith. They understand going in that they were sacrificial lambs sent to save the Republic, and if discovered would be declared to be rogue Jedi by the Order.
Or something like that.
Edit: not kept close in the same way as Anakin. That wouldn't end well in any way.
really liked Anakin's sacrifice in the end. Well done, I do love R2 being the one to bring him back out of all creatures and droids our spunky little R2 unit did it
Star wars galaxy love your vids keep the good work up bud can you do what if Anakin was never born
This video should've just been titled What if R2 Turned Anakin Back to the Light
R2 should have talked some sense into him. He was trying to tell 3p0 in the original but he wouldn’t listen
9:10
Flowey would be proud
Good storytelling
R2 saving the day per usual
….what if yoda’s great grandfather had gotten a different result on that coin flip in whether to use a condom or not lol
I love how Anakin dies. Honestly I think Anakin shouldn't get a redemption without either dying or losing someone he loves. He needs to have consequences for his actions like this one had him face.
The consequences don't have to always be more death.
Prison, painful reform, the guilt of living with everything you've done, etc
@@ML-sc3pt when I say losing someone he loves I dont mean they have to die nor do i think Anakin needs to do. When I talk about him losing those he loves I mean that they could either die or they could abandon him because of how bad he royally screwed up. Also I think prison is a valid form of a consequence if it's him suffering alone
09:09
Flowey: YES
Great story.. What if ply koon survived order 66.. Please make a good long one please.. Thank You
What if the separatist council left mustafar before Vader arrived
one I want to see is if Buzz Lightyear of Star Command was in Star Wars
That would only work for the ones Disney made
catch me crying
What if The Jedi led by Obi-Wan betrayed and murdered Anakin and Vader joined Palpatine.
This is based on a deleted plot point in Star Wars Empire Strikes Back.
This will change everything.
When he was rebuilt as a partial cyborg, Aniken died & Darth Vader was born. One person, two separate people in one body. Still, when he saved Luke from Palptine, he turned back to the light side of the force & I think that’s why he got to come back as a force ghost. May the force be with all of us,ALWAYS!!!
Darth Vader was born way before that. Darth Vader was a seed that was planted the moment that he met the Jedi. Darth Vader represents all of Anakin's pain and anger.
what if Obi wan Left the Jedi order for satine when he was stil a padewan in the Mandalorian Civil war between the new Mandalorians and the Mandalorian clans
I wish for his sake he would have. I would have loved to have seen him raise his family. Ah but because they had to be secret about it that was what was wrong in the first place. Would you not agree?
R2 is the whole point of this video
Someone was playing Halo Reach before making this video
Anakin could Overpower Sidious the Longer the Fight Drags on even Faster with Yoda and Kenobi with him
9:07 Flowey moment
My good sir did u say jedi masters I recall a certain someone had to take a seat
Sidious coulda just let them leave and have the clones blast their ships.
What if Anakin survived this fan fiction?
So... is no one going to mention that C-3P0 also died? He was on Padme's ship.. so with that exploding/going into the lava... Yeah.. 3P0 is dead.
What if multiple clones inhibitor chips malfunctioned not just Tups
awww sad ending. amazing none the less.
what music do you use?
If I only Anakin survived
What if Malgus was preserved in stasis and woke up around the Phantom Menace?
I'd love to know what the gunners on the Tantive were doing. There's not a good reason why a few clone LAATs should have been able to destroy the platform or even get near while the ship was there.
I mean it wouldn't be able to take 10 LAATs out immediately.
@@andrewortelli7631 Now, I'm not saying you're wrong and I'm right. Let me describe to you what my reasoning is:
The Tantive has been seen taking hits from Star Destroyers in the movies. It could have interposed itself between the platform and the incoming transports and fired upon them with its weapons to force them to break off. The weapons on that ship are good enough to down fighters, it would be easier to track big LAATs. I'm also fairly sure their weapons outrange the LAATs, meaning they could have fired upon the incoming before they ever got into range.
So, from my perspective, the Tantive has a range, firepower, and defensive capability edge over all ten of those LAATs, which are transport gunships meant to engage unprotected ground forces and ferry troops around. It would be like ten Blackhawks armed with hellfire missile pods attacking a guided missile destroyer. Yeah, they could do some damage, but the destroyer would knock them all out of the sky in the process and would still largely be functional when the fight is over.
@@andrewortelli7631 Now, I'm not saying you're wrong and I'm right. Let me describe to you what my reasoning is:
The Tantive has been seen taking hits from Star Destroyers in the movies. It could have interposed itself between the platform and the incoming transports and fired upon them with its weapons to force them to break off. The weapons on that ship are good enough to down fighters, it would be easier to track big LAATs. I'm also fairly sure their weapons outrange the LAATs, meaning they could have fired upon the incoming before they ever got into range.
So, from my perspective, the Tantive has a range, firepower, and defensive capability edge over all ten of those LAATs, which are transport gunships meant to engage unprotected ground forces and ferry troops around. It would be like ten Blackhawks armed with hellfire missile pods attacking a guided missile destroyer. Yeah, they could do some damage, but the destroyer would knock them all out of the sky in the process and would still largely be functional when the fight is over.
Things may be different in Star Wars, or changed between Episode 3 and Episode 4 on the corvette, but still.
I thought R2 was gonna save anakin since he was also there with anakins star fighter but you knew that didn’t you
What if Anakin turned back to the light before the assault on the Temple? Order 66 has been issued, Mace Windu is presumed dead. But this is just too much. He can't slaughte the Jedi in cold blood. Attacking Mace had been an impulse, and one he instantly regretted. His confusion had left him week to Palpatine's manipulation, but faced with the enormity of this act, he realized he couldn't go through with it. As the 501st is mustering on the Temple steps, waiting for his order to attack, he realizes he has to stop this. But how?
These fanfictions are far better than the idiotic writing of ALL the movies.
Great story
Day 5
What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
i dont think the 2nd one would work cuz they are 2 different people.....
@@seth3k Darth Talon is just like Darth Vader and Darth Maul. It's s title and a symbolic name, not a birth name. So, just like any other Sith could've been declared or become "Darth Vader" if Anakin never fell, I'm positive Aayla Secura could've become Darth Talon if Alema Rar didn't become Darth Talon and Secura fell to the dark side.
don't think i didn't notice that cheeky little Star Citizen image you snuck in there.
Why do people make padme chancellor? Bail is a way more likely candidate than her. I don’t hate padme but she’d never be a chancellor
Excellent story
So R2-D2 is the only one who can save anakin
This would have been impossible because he would have been even more emotional and aggressive even if he turned back to the light he still would have been very emotional and aggressive it would be inevitable that he would kill ether way dark or light
What If Anakin/Darth Vader returned to the light side after finding out that Padme Died?
He'd be killed by Palpatine
Pretty awesome
AKA what if R2 was the best boy.
also the star wars galaxy What If Anakin Skywalker Reached His FULL POTENTIAL In Attack Of The Clones was awesome anakin skywalker reaching his full potential becoming grandmaster and padme becoming supreme chancellor again amazing next what if plase make what if anakin went to the wellspring of life with yoda you know that one will work
You messed up R2D2 and C3PO died on Padme’s ship when it was shot down yet R2 bonded with Luke pretty good story other than that
Mustafar? So this was still after he expertly performed the YMMs?