Mains Masterclass 1 | People FAIL MAINS because of *Pathetic Evaluation* |Open Challenge with Satyam
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июл 2024
- Please watch till the end and if you think i have wasted your time, dislike the video and don't come back to the channel ever again.
People invest 50,000Rs in Mains' test series with the hope of improving the quality of their mains answers but end up wasting it. Because the evaluation provided in these test series is nothing but waste and garbage.
Nobody speaks against this 400 crore mains test series industry.
People are just wasting years and years and gaining nothing out of it.
Here's the proof!!
00:00 An Open Challenge
01:48 Introduction
06:23 Proof 1 : Evaluator has No idea of Demand of question
12:33 Proof 2 : Evaluator has No idea of Structuring an Answer
17:30 Proof 3 : Coachings have No idea of Marking Scheme
19:55 Proof 4 : Enough content but no suggestion on presentation
24:22 Proofs from my Answer sheets
28:20 Why such Evaluation will decrease your marks in mains
32:00 Proof from my optional test series
33:25 Components of a good answer
35:00 Final Words
36:15 Appeal!
36:40 Whats ahead
t.me/UnderStandUPSC
t.me/UnderStandUPSC
@@krishanSharma.69.69f nahi. Please. M just a human being. And that too a very average one.
Sir what is way out??
Sir i have never seen any topper discussing the mains question paper which he / she has given... He never tells what he has written in his copy , never discusses his approach for that particular question....
This whole preparation process is turning good men into zombies. Thats how they become when other side of the competition.
@@UnderStandUPSC Sir, Now what should we do and how can we do answer writing? 🙏🙏🙏
what a courageous man he is...very rare..1st person I've seen in my 2yrs of prep with so much concern about an aspirant..salute to uh sir🤞
Not rare he is the only one .....that's why we r proud of him .
@@kirandhawan7466 It's great work. He is against misconduct of such giants who earned more than 1000 crores from looting to UPSC aspirants. It's very risky and courageous task. Satyam sir aap expose krte rho, hum apke sath hai. Jab Gandhi Ji ko mighty British empire nhi jhuka paya to ye kya kr lenge 1000 crores wale lootere.
'सत्यमेव जयते' - 'Truth alone triumphs'
OMG! I couldn't stop laughing! 😂
For this very reason, I've never spent a single penny on coaching stuff! A lot of quality free content already exists on internet.
This video deserves to go viral 😂
I am a serving bureaucrat, honestly I found this informative. (Nityanand Das, Deputy Collector, Jharkhand)
Keep it Up Buddy 😊
Thanku sir. Means a lot!
Sir guide me please also🙏🙏 I want to attempt prelims in 2024
Plzz sir 2024 walon keliy kuch btadijy
I am also from jharkhand...
❤❤❤
Ap jharkhand k naam Roshan krrhe ho sir
Sir please khuch aisa bataa dijiye jo hr kisi aspirant ko naa pata ho 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sir, we rarely find the pain in the voice of any teacher for students out there. Thankyou so much for this
Thanks and welcome
Better to be slapped with the truth than kissed with a lie. Thank you for your courage bhai.
Thanks to Shivin sir for sending me on your channel. Truly an eye opener video. Thank you so much sir. We need more honest people like you. Honestly speaking I was talking to a friend who is in coaching industry for copy evaluation. But now I have dropped the idea after watching your video. how can I evaluate the copies of others Jab m hi andhere m hu to oro ko kya guide karunga.. burden h money ki bcoz ORN m rehna is not cheap. But I can’t do this paisa kamane k lie oro k paise ka misuse kru jo ki mere sath b hua h. I’ve also spent more than 30k on test series. Thank u sir once again. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Now that's called integrity. Hats off
✋️
Hi there are you preparing for 2024 ?
Thank you sir for sharing very precious message I have been started my journey 2022 year like serious candidate and this 2023 is 2nd chance but I can't clear because of new type of question pattern... this video very usefull for me I hope your experience and your analysis very helpful for me and others aspirants for upcoming CSE 😊
Same here
Thank you very much for exploring them... I have got 245 marks in vision abhyas mains test series and in UPSC mains 2022 i have got 358 in GS . This is real truth.
Booklist for gs 2 brother please
@@shivshaktipathak3377 For Prelims: NCERT POLITY & Laxmikant
For Mains: Only ias notes for Polity, IR, Social Justice, vision current
I started my prep from last year june and I can concur with his opinion because one of my close friends got AIR below 100 (won't disclose his exact details) this year and he had said this exact thing about test series to me last year when I was trying to get an overview of all facets of preparation (coaching, test series, delhi me rekhe prep etc.). his exact words were "kya karega test series join karke, unko khudko kuch aata nahi tha isliye evaluator ban gaye". Hoping this video forces the test series industry to self-evaluate itself for once.
That's the truth
Is it worth going to Delhi?
@@petmaniac Only if you don't have any senior/successful aspirant to guide. This exam is about guidance and not coaching.
most of the material is simple enough to not require any kind of lecture and even if you find any topic difficult, there's high chance that there's a youtube video explaining it. Eg. geography's NCERT is absoutely rubbish for a beginner because there's no visualisation of the concepts but rajtanil mam's videos can help you with that and once you get the visualisation, you can read any extra topic of geography on your own.
@@dracula7000 if I have taken PW UPSC coaching online.. is it enough guidance? I hear alot about guidance but am clueless as to what it comprises of, no successful candidate is going to devote 100% time to me, if that's what it is, cuz I don't have anyone like that.
@@petmaniac guidance means whenever you have a doubt about any aspect of preparation, there's someone with whom you can clarify.
I think most middle class aspirants are not able to exit this UPSC preparation cycle even after years & years of attempts and realising it's difficulty because they have already invested lakhs of hard earned money of their parents.They somehow live with this guilt so they end up spending more on these coachings' specialised courses and the cycle continues. We needed mentors like you to give attempts with the right strategy and mindset and also to think cautiously before spending huge amounts on these coachings. THANK YOU Sir! For standing for us, with US.💛
perfect
Sunk cost fallacy
@@sheilakijawani2526 I was trying so hard to recall this term! 😂😂 Thanks!
Absolutely, it’s a hell loop, especially if you lose exam for 5-10 marks in mains exam, you get perception that you are made for it, so let’s invest one more year. But we all know that lakhs are lined up for one mark. And again a little lost consistency, a little self doubt, a little fatigue will ruin even that year.
This is an eye opener 😮 was about to start my preparation, glad I came across this and it has definitely given me a new perspective towards mains answer writing. Thank you
This is not the story of mains alone. Their prelims test series are also absurd. I scored 48.32, 48.3 and 29.6 marks respectively in three tests of vision abhyas series 2023. And scored 85+ marks in actual upsc exam despite a tough paper this year. Only bad thing happened with me that I couldn't clear csat because I was scoring sufficient marks in test series easily and took it lightly. 😢 Thank you for challenging the core of the coaching industry.
Truly said
same here 44 in final coaching mock
80 in upsc
Same here.
Same here
Same to me i scored in 99.56 jo mocks mai kbhi nhi aaye
I met a person recently who had written 2 mains. He'd get above 300/500 in PSIR mains test series with almost all coaching institutes. And in the actual exam he scored 160/500 in optional. It's been 2 years since he quit his preparation and picked up a private job. He still has no idea what went wrong !!
UPSC also thinks about village poor students. And without joining any coaching they clear the exam because they have there own thought process shaped by articles of newspaper. Thanks for clarity sir. I appreciate your efforts. Keep it up 😊
This prelims exam proved UPSC don’t really care much
i support your view but, Paper was current affairs based and mostly from newspapers. Cutoff doesn't go 200 out of 200. Questions were really tough but more than GS 1 , GS 2 is the determining factor in this year prelims. So even a student either from Rajendra Nagar or any town/Village, just simply following any newspaper with clear concepts from ncert and some standard books are able to score around 80-90 in GS 1 which is sufficient for qualifying. The Era of prelims test series propaganda has been destroyed by UPSC,bWhich will definitely benifit the students who can't afford such heavy price test series of various institutions.
Thank you so much sir for being here with us as a guide, mentor and big brother..literally nobody cares for the aspirant community in a way as you do..Thank you..
Finally someone has the courage to say this. I wrote an essay for the first time and ended up with 130 marks ( which is not possible) and after studying for 6 momths i still had the same marks... Goes to show what dirty game we all are in
More than your courage I am impressed with how you are bifurcating the questions in to the parts(demand) and discussing it’s various dimensions. Truly commanding.
This is brutally honest. Eye opening. Salute to your courage! This is the level of honesty the world needs.
Thanks for the video, sir.
Agreeing with every single thing you've said here. Kudos for coming up with this video for saving aspirants' precious time and hard earned money, and even saving them from the blind trust which probably each one of us did when we were in the initial aspirant's phase before becoming educators.
Apart from the money I've wasted, one major flaw I found was ( specially with a particular institute) that irrespective of how well you address the demand of the question, the feedback would be based on the model answer only. This is such a basic thing to understand that if everyone will write as per the model answer only, where will the uniqueness lie ?
The whole idea of test series these days have become only a pseudo satisfactory factor with absolutely no emphasis on what's actually needed , ie the demand of the question and an approximate word limit.
Thanku so much for writing this Arpita.
Coming from you, it's all the more authentic!
I respect you stance, I liked your honesty and truthfulness. And thank you, you changed my perspective of answer writing.
It takes grit and resilience to talk about these things...this preparation has become a rat race...nobody knows what they are doing and why they are doing...if any topper said they are doing everyone starts doing that...Toppers also have accountability to the aspirants to guide them to tell the truth but nobody speaks about that....Salute to you, brother...You have done this at a time when nobody gives a damn about it...Respect brother !!
Bilkul sahi kaha tyagi ji
This is so damn true.
I spent around a lakh on mains test series in 4yrs of my journey. 2022 was my 1st mains, while i cleared mains but couldn't make it to the final list. I was so devastated because i was getting good score in tests which didn't get reflected in the final result.
However, finding the right mentor is also difficult. That's why people spend hefty money on mains misguidance programs.
thanks for speaking up
Are you talking about mains guidance prog from forum? Could you elaborate on bad/good they are
@@esa9228 no, i don't have experience of that.
But in general, every test series is more or less the same. The video explains well with examples.
But who tells that who's a good mentor? Whom to follow? Why won't we wander here nd there..
@@saurabhyadav-pl9dl initially i had no other option than test series.. but now I can rely on self evaluation and peer review..
Toppers copies are also a great source to begin with.
Thank you for the eye-opening session
no doubt you're a great mentor
I CAN'T BELIEVE! I'M SHOCKED AND GRATEFUL. THANK YOU SOOOO MUCH🙏
Forever grateful for your courage and honesty sir. You are a blessing for us🙏
Thank you so much sir for being so genuine and honest!
the coaching mafia has made this exam an absolute drama...After 2023 prelims they have forced the narrative of Plan B and creating fear psychosis so that people will buy their course out of fear...An absolute drama going on.
This is very courageous. Thank you so much for this eye opener …extremely thankful
😮 it's a shocking eye-opener sir, I'm so blessed to have found you at the start of my prep, can't thank you enough 🙇
Eye opening session 🙌🏼 Thankyou so much for sharing your experience..
This was eye opening. Thank you for making this video.
Hats off to your honesty sir. Thank you so much for showing real concern about our dream:)
Definitely going to share and waiting for 2nd lecture eagerly. Thank you sir.
You are a blessing for me sir... I'll be forever grateful for your courage and honesty 🙏
Truly said...
I appreciate your courage to speak truth ❤
Coaching industry has ruined lakhs of lives...
Thanks... I've got some clarity of what's going around in this evaluation market... You've saved my money:)
Sir this is really eye opening session for me . This is too courageous of you to speak such truth , it takes a lot of guts and betrayal to come to this level that aap sach bol pao. This is the difference between you and others. Aapko pata hai, jabse im connected with your group (prelims ke 2 week pehle se) I didnt see one toppers talk , ek bhi video nahi dekha maine !!! Thats the level of devotion and trust you've gained.
What is the name of that group and how one can hoin it
Thank you so much sir....this was such an eye-opener for people like us who've had just one attempt and were shattered by the prelims.......we are fairly an easy target for them and probably we might have ended with exhausting our attempts.....but now at least I have some clarity regarding "kya nahi karna h"...
It is such a courageous step.....hats off to you sir🙏
Hello Satyam sir,
Just came to know *abt u in last one hour*, when this video popped up, and now I think I am grateful that it did.
Thank you very much for this EYE-OPENER lecture, means a lot.
In my UPSC journey i have found VERY FEW genuine people guiding aspirants and now you definetely deserve a place there.
After listening to you sound like KAPTAAN (Team GG) whom I am a fan of and now you made me yours as well.
Eagerly waiting for the upcoming Lectures on this platform.
And once again thank you for removing all the FOMO in this UPSC Market.
Regards
Yours Sincerely
Abhee
This has cleared all my doubts regarding these test series and reiterated my understanding of these evaluations. Thank you
I am first time commenting on any youtube video because your video made me write it . i was literally saving money to buy these test series your video literally saved me .this video proved to be an eyeopner for me ..thank you so much sir ❤️ you are doing a great job keep it up sir ....every student needs a mentor like you and I am lucky enough I could find you ....again thank you sir 🌸i am gonna follow your guidance religiously 😊
Thanks buddy for such informative video....i was also feeling the same way.....i knew that something definitely wrong with this kind of evaluation but never addressed it to myself upfrontly...
Please make more such videos about how we can improve our answers. The way you explained, what was wrong and what rectification one should make, was just amazing...
Really got so much insights from this video
Thank you for this video
I appreciate your initiative!
first of all thanks to Dr Shivin for suggesting your video.
This video is really an eye opener.I have also spend around 45k for mains test series.but after writing around 40 mains test series could not understand their marking scheme .There were huge differences of marks between two copy .In some copy I got good marks and in some very low in same subject's paper.I could not understand what to do which evaluators advise i should follow,one is saying to get improvement u have to mould your answer according to demand of the question and other saying good structure of answer no need to tweak the answers and keep writing.
Rightly said.. I secured 308 rank this year and the test series that I took used to give me 65-70 in gs4 and that too with no logical inference.. I secured 128 in the mains in gs4.. use test series wisely would be my advise..
Thanku himanshu bhai. Means a lot that u came forward to comment and share your experience.
Do connect with me on TG if you would want to guide aspirants further!
It requires next level courage to speak truth and you have plenty of that ..thank you bhaiya
Shared your video in my study group. Very honest explanation. Subscribed too!
Thank you for your honesty sir, I came here after Shivin sir recommended this video at his class at Ed Sarrthi today. You earned a subscriber
Truly an eye opening session 🔥🔥
I rarely comment on youtube videos.
Thank you for the detailed explanation Sir.
I just started my UPSC prep and this video is an eye opener to me.
I wish toppers talks/interviews contain such honest reviews.
Thanks to Shivin Sir for mentioning this channel in his video.
I appreciate you sir !! God bless you and it does takes courage to say all this . Keep it up !!
I came here after listening about you from Dr Shivin and I can't tell you what I have got . Such an eye opener analysis. Thank you so much sir 🙏🙏🙏
Huge respect to you Sir for displaying such straightforwardness and courage ❤
Thank you for de-mystifying such a core problem with which UPSC Aspirants are struggling, with their life and hard earned money on the line... Can't wait for the next Revelation/Guidance... Kudos!!!!
Thanks for eye opening content. I will truly reform my preparation now.
Respect Sir , subscribed.
Glad I found this channel.
I am very new in this journey & I was also thinking to join test series but this video is such an eye opening, people like you deserves very best in your life much much respect 👏❤️
Salute sir❤... really appreciate your courage ❤
you are like a big brother we all aspirants who are somewhere lost in this journey deserve❤ a big thankyou.
Thank you so much bhaiya also a huge thanks to shivin bhaiya aswell cause this video was in my recommendation but i ignored it but while watching shivin bhaiya's video i came back to this and i can't be more grateful to both of you for saving my money but more importantly TIME
Respected satyam sir , super duper hittt session... It is not told by the coaching institute how to fulfill the demand of the question..... Again koti koti naman aap ko bhaiya... Ese hi guide karte rahiye ... Esa lagta hai prabhu mil gaye ... The entire faculty ias corridor is gazabb.
We need this kind of people in beuraucracy who are doing good for the people without expecting anything 😇
Thank you so much sir. Its really an eye opening video for the aspirants. Keep candidates like us motivated. Please keep your good efforts on. Really liked it.
Eye opening... Thank you sooo much....🙏🙏🙏
I kid you not, this was absolutely perspective altering! You need to start your own thing for those who
1. Can’t afford those coaching institutes
2. Need actual guidance.
3. Have no clue how to go about structuring their answers.
So majority of us. And even if some of us are aware about structuring, the fact that you give it so straightforward, is something that everyone should look forward to and it’s quite refreshing!
Where can I enrol?🙈
I can imagine the kind of effort you would have put in to make this video... It should be spread across the community... 👍👍
truly an outstanding video
hats off man
Amazing ! Thanks for fixing the accountability . Right questions asked
This was a eye opening video sir. Thank you very much for telling us the dark truth of coaching institutes. Please guide us more so that we can break this vicious cycle and get out of it🙏🏻
I have not taken any single coaching institute's test series. I was planning to 😂 but you saved me. Thankyou sir. Forever grateful
Same yar
Same
Me too. Toady I was just about to confirm my payment. He saved me
Even I have not taken any single coaching's test series for answer writing (not even for prelims also). Instead I am planning to get my answer copies evaluated by University professor. Earlier I was in doubt whether I should approach him or not but now I am confident that this will be the best option.
@@alphaandomega2554 this is indeed the best option, because University professors only check those papers (as far as I know)
Such a wonderful guidence and your truthfulness, experience
Thank you sir for guiding us, it's really an eye opening video for answer writing evaluation
Thankyou so much Sir for your cear honesty, we aspirants need people like you so that we can actually understand the process of this examination and not fall on fake propaganda running by these so called coaching industries...they only want money and see aspirants as their investments in their coaching companies...Thanks for showing it with proof..i wish you will always get success and happiness in your life.
No words sir😶 we are just stuck in this loop thank u sir for making us realize and guiding us
Eye opening video
Thank you shivin bhaiya for recommending this video
Thank you for everything.. May God bless u
You are already an officer !! Bcoz u r already serving the vulnerable..thank u so mch sir for saving our time n money🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🫡
Thank you so much Respected Sir its an Eye opening video🙏after watching this video many aspirants including me will save there hard earned money.
It's an eye opener for every aspirant....well done👍
Very helpful Satyam... Hoping to learn more from you.
Wtf I mean!!! Idk Bhaiya who you're, I am only one to my parents, felt you as my big brother, the actual one who cares selflessly! I'm with you, no matter what happens like who so ever try to do anything against you just know that there's a little girl there to support you okay!? Thank you so much for holding our little hands, who's almost innocent but also would have to scribble in mud but you trying to hold!! Thank you so much Bhaiyaa😭❤️
I hardly ever comment on youtube videos. But having given 3 mains, spending a lot of money on substandard evaluations and seeing your courage to call out the facts, I agree with your assessment. This has been eye-opening for me and I am looking forward to your future masterclass suggestions for this attempt!!
thanks for coming out
Thank you for this eye opener ❣️
Thankyou so much sir, i m glad that i found your channel.
I rarely push like button for any video on RUclips, let alone about commenting. I have discussion with many people that there's something which is quite enigmatic and mysterious about this UPSC CS Exam which only those who have cleared, do understand. That "something" you have described that why if one person clears it everybody surrounding him and giving decent effort for this exam also clears it quite easily.
You have touched the right note of serious aspirants who are striving to improve their Mains Score and thereby their Ranks here. So very well done sir, salute to such courage and honesty. I would try to make u remember that u have gained "TRUST", so with great power comes the great responsibility. Hope u wont take ur steps back and would keep guiding and mentoring aspirants. Congratulations and huge Respect!!
Oh my god! You saved my hard earned money Sir. I was about to enrol in these test series! Thank you from the core, Sir!
Beyond brilliance and gut wrenching truth conveyed.
Thank you so much sir, for this eye opening video ...
Brutal awareness is really important just like behind the scenes of filming a movie , thankyou bhaiya i was never in favour of joining coaching and this was another vedio came to make me see the reality of the mains exam which is the most important part of civil services as it's the deciding factor. Thankyou once again please keep enlightening us 👍🙏
1. How to write answers yeTest series s nahi pata chalta
2. Evaluation nahi whan bas hum khudko Fake confidence dene jate hain
3. Evaulators ko khud bhi nhi pata UPSC kya chahti hai
4. Public service nahi Public Money transfer scheme hai ye ....... and How u CHALLENGED a 400Cr Industry. Ap ''ETHICS'' sirf padhate nhi ho... U live by it. HATS OFF .... #3 CHEERS FOR U.
thanku!!
Finally someone stood up.... More power to u man ❤
thank you so much sir please continue this series 😇
I am very grateful that your video is shown on my timeline, I am also planning to buy test series for my next attempt but you saved me. That's why I never join any upsc coaching for my GS subject, I thought I will join only the test series but now after seeing your video, I changed my plan. Please bring some insight on Answer Writing.
Thank you sir for your eye opening message you are right no body tells us these things no body ku kuki sbko apna paisa banana h na . You have shown how much guts you have sir , God always bless you sir keep going sir we all with you sir 😊
Thank you for taking this risk and exposing coaching industry.
This is an eye opener Sir!🙏🏻
Hats off to your dedication towards the aspirant community ❤
When I am seeing people asking to toppers in many groups about which coaching mains test series they should buy..I was feeling disheartened just because I can't afford those costly test series and I'll be writing my first mains this year..feeling really positive after watching this video..Thank you sir🌟
Right guidence at right time... thankyou sir for this
This is absolutely true.. After giving 2 mains and working day in and out for 2022 attempt, my marks didn't increase at all. I joined mains test series and used to get 95+ whereas in actual mains I got 80-90.Now I am getting the idea where I am lagging, and what needs to be improved
Thanks for the video!
thanks for coming out n sharing swapnil
Can you dicuss what went wrong ,if thave time .
Thanks!