US guaranteeing Israel’s truce commitments could get a deal done: Marwan Bishara
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 май 2024
- Al Jazeera’s senior political analyst Marwan Bishara highlights, achieving a ceasefire agreement remains challenging with Netanyahu's insistence on attacking Rafah, a stance Hamas adamantly opposes. Bishara emphasizes Hamas's demand for Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and suggests that US intervention, ensuring Israeli compliance, could facilitate a resolution, echoing Hamas spokesman Osama Hamdan's views.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Gaza #GazaUnderAttack #FreeGaza #PrayForGaza #GazaUnderFire #GazaWar #GazaUnderSiege #Israel #Palestine #StopTheWar
Today or tomorrow Palestine will be free. But world can see the hypocrites.
Of course, the Palestine will be free of the Islamist terrorists. Then Palestinians could live normal human life.
100%❤❤❤
The US not vetoing everything could get stuff done too !!! The US doesn’t want to !!!
Neither can it help, there's nothing that can stop Israel
@@User42214 What? The US could 100% stop Israel. The US doesnt even need to stop israel it just needs to stop protecting israel, and the neighboring countries would stop israel. Israel sucks, the USA military is keeping it alive.
@@User42214 A real threat to stop the weapon supply and full sanctions on the 700,000 Illegal Israeli settlers in East Jerusalem and the West Bank would stop Israel. No, I don't think this will happen anytime soon.
Doesn't want to and shouldn't either
@@User42214 If the US made a credible threat to stop all weapons supplies and sanction the 700.000 Israeli squatters on Palestinian territory it would do it. No, I don't think the US will do that in the next decade or two.
U.S./UK began this nightmare 75+yrs so now they must end this horror.
No, the Arabs blood thirsty regimes started the war 75 years ago.
AND AUSTRALIA...
It was just the UK
Then the UN
But they didn't force/ask Israel to do anything that they did.
The US government never ceases to disgust and disappoint.
Because it is not run by patriots to America, but to foreign nations.
stop war completely
why because Hamas is loosing?
Stop this crimes over crimes! Free Palestine!
Israel is a Welfare State 🤣🤣🤣
just like republican states
It’s also a Warfare State! Using its welfare for warfare…
They are a Warfare state too and use their welfare for warfare…
@@vanpeters9751 woke pink hair says what?
@rhetorical1488 I know the truth hurts but Israel always been like this .
There is nothing Jewish about genocide
There is nothing Jewish about ethnic cleansing
There is nothing Jewish about a brutal military occupation for 75 years
These people are not supporting Judaism they are supporting war crimes and brutalities…
and we will not let them get away with it ✊
- Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner
ABSOLUTELY, ABSOLUTELY, ABSOLUTELY.
Isreal is not run by Jews.
It has a Zionist Government who will stop at nothing to have the whole Region to itself.
It's about time the whole of the USA, UK, and Germany said 'Enough is enough' and ranked Zionism with Nazism.
short term truce is meaningless Netnyaaho wants to flatten raphal to eliminate all houisng and way of life
So, the organised crime is to guarantee what ?!?!!!?!?
Exactly.
How can the U.S., a sovereign nation, be asked to provide assurances for the actions of another sovereign nation?
As if the word or signature of either the US or Israel has ever been upheld
Especially, since the US is subservient to the other.
Right, because the US has never imposed their will on sovereign nations… what kind of question is this
Truce ? What about all the death they have caused ? This is not a football match wtf
Don’t worry. There will be no truce. The war will go on for months
You're right, there should be no truce, no ceasefire, no aid. You are 100% correct.
@@richardgillette5759you are criminally insane!
No one is above the law only God is.
Israel must pay reparations to Palestine.
🤦
You are funny!
Please do not twist the facts of Oct 7th which criminal hamas & palestinians started, with all their atrocities!
@@rafaelchan8497 No need to twist iy there is plenty of evidence that a lot of lies where told on the day.
Israel is blocking any attempt by the UN to investigate its alligations against Hamas. WHY?
Israel will force Qatar to rebuild Gaza
@@rafaelchan8497 Israel will not allow any formal body to conduct an investigation into the Oct7 attacks so as to formally convicy the perpetrator's.
Guarantees from America?😂😂😂😂 you poor poor poor man😂😂😂
The fox guarding the chicken coop?
HA HA HA
Thanks Marwan for your perspective!
I agree with you that the US has a crrlucial tole in bringing about a ceasefire in Gaza.
From my perspective, as a humanitarian, three things need to happen in Gaza immediately to end this genocide:
1.. A comprehensive and permanent ceasefire.
2. Unhindered access into Gaza for humanitarian aid as famine is already present in the north of the enclave and is spreading south, according to the head of the World Food Programme, Cindy McCain, speaking on Al Jazeera today.
(Israel is still blocking aid from entering and being distributed in Gaza by various means. A driver of a truck bringing aid to the north was shot dead by the Israeli military earlier this week, other drivers in the same convoy were injured as well as Palestinian people seeking aid.)
3. No invasion of Rafah under any circumstances at any time!!!!
Once the ceasefire is established, these things need to happen to make sure this genocide and violence in Israel-Palestine will never happen again:
1. .Cleanup and rebuilding of thr environment in Gaza.
2. A free and fair election of all Palestinians to elect their new Government which can make a plan for the establishment of a Palestinian State.
3.. All those people responsible for war crimes in Gaza, Israel, the West Bank and East Jerusalem need to be held accountable for their actions at the International Criminal Court.
Thank you!
Genevieve Forde
Aotearoa
Planet Earth
A hacker changed the spelling of "the" to "thr".
Genevieve Forde
What about Prisoners and Hostages.?
US guarantee? Anyone thinks it is worth anything.
No! I don’t trust any of it…. The United States will elect another President four years from now that can change today’s commitments. Look what Donald Trump did about Jerusalem. He declared it the capital of Israel and moved the American embassy there. Are we going to reverse those decisions? Will Americans have to “take to the streets” four years from now to ensure adherence to any commitments made today? And what about the rebuild of Palestine and reparations to the Palestinian people? Who pays the cost for the end of occupation?
Bishara goes hard trying to put favorable spin for its viewers. That's why he's the "senior political commentator".
Thank you so much Mr. Marwan Bishara and Mr. Cerrel for the updates on truce deals and great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤
ceasefire otherwise no exchange.
What then 50, 60, maybe 75 thousand after Rafah
This is US framing. Hamas has said that guarantees are only as good as US commitment to them. Just, do a journalism.
West of time they been playing this stupid game for 75 years
Why don't you say it's the US support that has to stop.
Americans need to be more critical of where their tax dollars are going. We shouldn’t subsidize what we don’t have in our own country. 😊
just shows how much you actually know.. you most likely go on throughout life thinking the exact thing to LOL
@@jfern6673 I’m actually very well educated on this issue. I don’t appreciate my US tax dollars that get taken out of my paycheck every month being funneled to kill people and subsidize another countries.
Best wishes
The RUclips censors are on it today
Fantastic analysis
US will never give such guarantee Marwan.
Peace needs to happen.
to acquire good manners
I respect Marwan opinion
❤
Happy Easter to any Orthodox Palestenians Christos Anesti Christ has risen.
Shouldn't all those tanks be up North that's where the real army is threatening.
Two state Solution is only viable Solution. At the end of day everyone will come back to that point. Only feeling sad for those who lost their life from both the side due to the ugly game played by the leaders.
This headline is just a * WISHFUL THINKING BY THE PRESS.
😭😭😭😭😭
You Tube Censorship 🤐
Both parties are helping each other to not end the war. Hamas requiring “time to think” about the cease-fire proposal is disingenuous (since they got what they wanted in the negotiations). Netanyahu immediately seized the opportunity to give Hamas a off-ramp (saying Israel will invade Rafah with or without a deal). We’re looking at a conflict both sides don’t want to see resolved. The rest of us are pulling our hair out, and are criticizing each other and oneself, but it’s time to call a spade a spade. Neither side is willing to resolve the crisis.
The dirty, ugly, poisonous system of democracy became known.
The dirty, ugly, poisonous system of democracy became known.
Al Jazeera provides a nice and fresh perspective from the other side but this Bishara guy is laughable
Hamas should not release the hostages! No matter what!
The hostages are probably gone lol, Gaza is a pancake
😂😂😂 you're such a wimp and a coward.. move yourself and your family to raffa Gaza and come back to post this nonsense knowing you and your family is about to join the dust...
Seems you're enjoying seeing children being killed every day because of foolish adults decisions like you.. Fool.
reasoning like that is the reason why peace can’t be achieved and the war is endless
You got less then 1 wk tough guy, then bye bye Rafah.
Rafah attack is imminent, these are mere delay tactics.
No cease fire no deal
How you can dieal and same American Israel are same peoples you are diel with so eney Garanteen US have get out eney diel
Palestinians will be free even without a deal
Can we trust the USA???????
The US government made nearly 400 international treaties with First Nations and systematically violated each and every single one of them, continuing to do so even today
Palestine 🇵🇸 Will 🇵🇸 Be 🇵🇸 Free
No food or cease fire please...#
No truce, no deal
No ceasefire, no aid
Nothing
☠
You're criminally insane!
Terrorist tactics are clever...but nobody is so naive to believe...ha..ha
Nethanyahu wants the war to continue. Once it stop, he go to jail.🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
Hamas divil
You started a war
Why crying for it to stop?
That ship has sailed
The zionists started the war in 1948 when they stole Palestinian land. The Palestinians want their stolen land back. The zionist entity (Israel) clearly wants to get rid of the Palestinian people and take over all of Palestine. Like any of us would, the Palestinian people fight back.
IN THE END ISRAEL WILL TAKE THEIR LAND FULL BACK🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪
Ha..ha..apostle of terrorits...ha
Bishara is a fuuulish analyst
The United States is not a party to the negotiations
It's a conflict between Israel and Hamas, and not between Hamas and the United States
Lol there is no negotiation with Hamas.. Hamas does not get to make demands.. Dream whatever dream makes you feel better..
Marwan ! And who's going to guarantee that Hamas will not attack and abduct hostages again?
A Palestinian state would guarantee that
Rockets and resistance arise because of ??? insufferable conditions, blockade, apartheid, occupation, military rule, a two state solution etc etc etc. Oct 7 didn't happen in a vacum
@@davidibrahim5175 Arabs rejected a palestine state already in 1948, why now!
Because back then getting half of what was already theirs was a daft thing to say yes to. Saying yes now, when the have nothing is a no brainer.
who is going to guarantee the idf wont commit genocide again?
No to ceasefire! No to food! No to Palestine!❤❤❤❤❤❤🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳❤❤❤❤❤❤
Hamans now wants guarantee 😂😂😂😂😂😂 they should have thought of it before October 7th
That notion might seem counterintuitive and yet, when it comes to Netanyahu himself, it is unexpectedly on-brand. Prime minister for most of the last 15 years, Netanyahu has been an enabler of Hamas, building up the organisation, letting it rule Gaza unhindered - save for brief, periodic military operations against it - and allowing funds from its Gulf patrons to keep it flush. Netanyahu liked the idea of the Palestinians as a house divided
- Fatah in the West Bank, Hamas in Gaza - because it allowed him to insist that there was no Palestinian partner he could do business with. That meant no peace process, no prospect of a Palestinian state, and no demand for Israeli territorial concessions.
None of this was a secret. In March 2019, Netanyahu told his Likud colleagues: "Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas...
This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank."
That catastrophic misjudgment alone should seal Netanyahu's fate. Taken from the Guardian.
@@dorothyleeuw8774 well I agree with you.... But do you really think Hamans cares about land and the Palestinians? Or they're just another jihad group sponsored by Iran while hiding behind Palestine..
@@dorothyleeuw8774 Spot on.
@@dorothyleeuw8774If this is true, then the Palestinians were dumb enough to fall for it. The real reason the Palestinians are divided is because they are tribal. It's their nature as is all Arab culture. Add in the mix religion and it becomes toxic. That's just the way it is.
idf is doing pest control 🙁
You have a sick mind
Paid agitator…..🥱
The Nazis would agree with your description of killing children.
I wonder how you manage to fall asleep
Zionist on board
From river to sea, Israeli flag 🇮🇱 is what you will always see 😊
And you can do nothing about it 😉
Fascist
😂
Israel has destroyed itself. The whole world is watching.
quella bandiera serve a una sola cosa pulire il c..o
ICP☺
Verify, but never trust.
FREE FREE PALESTINE!