The Lost Byzantine Harbour In Cornwall | Time Team | Timeline

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024

Комментарии • 173

  • @celinm6728
    @celinm6728 3 года назад +48

    Started to study archaeology because of this show, don't regret it a bit

    • @JuniorJuni070
      @JuniorJuni070 3 года назад +1

      Lucky

    • @Stelios.Posantzis
      @Stelios.Posantzis 3 года назад +2

      Hopefully you'll become a better archaeologist than this motley crew of fools.

    • @invisiblepants6477
      @invisiblepants6477 3 года назад +1

      That's what they all say until they awaken an ancient curse.

    • @yiannimil1
      @yiannimil1 3 года назад

      @@Stelios.Posantzis lol...motley!!!! LlllOL

    • @gowensbach2998
      @gowensbach2998 3 года назад

      Archaeology is an old profession

  • @youngscotsman
    @youngscotsman 2 года назад +4

    Great to see Discombobulated Archeaologists having a great time and spending the time to have fun while recording Human historical evidence for future generations

  • @vinnartaigh2076
    @vinnartaigh2076 3 года назад +29

    This is the most enjoyable history show "ever"

    • @michelleseager9782
      @michelleseager9782 3 года назад +1

      Time team also has their own channel

    • @phillipburke9522
      @phillipburke9522 3 года назад

      Ken Burns Civil War, or Baseball are both better, but yes it's damn good.

    • @Dal606BBN
      @Dal606BBN 3 года назад +2

      Time Team is coming back, Channels name is Time Team Official

    • @danisyx5804
      @danisyx5804 3 года назад +1

      Makes me wish archeology was this simple in the states

  • @NikosReegas
    @NikosReegas 3 года назад +9

    The Byzantium was the eastern part of the Roman empire that did not crumble "to you and I"!
    The empire did well for centuries after the fall of Rome.

    • @callanjamari9314
      @callanjamari9314 3 года назад

      i know it is pretty randomly asking but does anyone know a good website to watch newly released movies online ?

    • @ragael1024
      @ragael1024 Месяц назад +1

      impressive how we must always repeat this.

  • @kenshores9900
    @kenshores9900 3 года назад +3

    Another interesting dig. Always enjoy watching how these studies progress.

  • @Odonanmarg
    @Odonanmarg 3 года назад +31

    I think it’s a mistake to refer to artifacts as being from Turkey, when in fact they represented the Byzantine era. The Byzantines & Turks are political entities that both occupied the geographical entity of Asia Minor or Anatolia. Asia Minor (geographical entity) is what we call Turkey (political entity) today. The Turks began to occupy Asia Minor/Byzantium in the 11th to 13th centuries, well past Time Team’s focus.

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад +2

      It’s really quite a gaffe

    • @marcelovolcato8892
      @marcelovolcato8892 3 года назад +5

      It's a simplification. It's a TV show, not an academic paper.

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад +1

      @@marcelovolcato8892 not an excuse

    • @edwardfletcher7790
      @edwardfletcher7790 2 года назад +1

      How do you know they weren't referring to pottery from a specific Turkish region ?

    • @Eleina1951
      @Eleina1951 2 года назад

      Istanbul is Byzantium!!!!

  • @jrmckim
    @jrmckim Год назад +1

    41:31 Justinian Plague: Am I nothing to you?

  • @timdyer5326
    @timdyer5326 3 года назад +21

    My dad's ancestors are all from the Newquay and Perranporth area, just along the coast from Padstow. He suffers from hereditary diseases including Bechets. Bechets DNA is from the silk road and the middle east. My ancestors are possibly some of those Mediterranean traders mix with my Cornish ancestors. Newquay and Crantock also port worthy.

    • @yiannimil1
      @yiannimil1 3 года назад +1

      the best science here...!!!

    • @MrSimonmcc
      @MrSimonmcc 3 года назад +1

      'Mixed'. Why do people insist on writing the past tense incorrectly these days?

    • @goldmole1
      @goldmole1 3 года назад

      @@MrSimonmcc Way in the past thing were much better;-)

    • @jrmckim
      @jrmckim Год назад

      ​@@MrSimonmccA lot of people use their phones and it causes autocorrection problems. Also the smaller screens make it harder to see past mistakes and typos.

  • @morriganmhor5078
    @morriganmhor5078 3 года назад +4

    The problems of the 6th century Eastern Roman Empire, which were probably most dangerous (more than those said here) was the so-called Justinianic plague which went hand-in-hand with the Avaro-Slavic invasion in the Balkans. From that time on, with diminished population, and the impossibility to shift the troops from the Balkans to Syria and vice versa, the Byzantines really did have harsh times.

  • @wadeadkins4927
    @wadeadkins4927 3 года назад +1

    Tony i such a ball buster in this episode

  • @agent1821
    @agent1821 3 года назад +28

    Calling it "Turkish" is similar to saying an artifact from Louisiana, dating from the 11th century, is French-Creole. It's more like calling something from 9th century Mexico "Spanish" or "New Spanish"

    • @larryzigler6812
      @larryzigler6812 3 года назад +3

      Tony does his best !!!! He was off by only 1,000 years or so.

    • @Stelios.Posantzis
      @Stelios.Posantzis 3 года назад +7

      @@larryzigler6812 He should've known better than this when hosting a history channel.

    • @TheDomdabomb
      @TheDomdabomb 3 года назад +7

      I know it’s a big fU to the Greeks of Anatolia

    • @yiannimil1
      @yiannimil1 3 года назад +2

      @@larryzigler6812 1500!!!

    • @yiannimil1
      @yiannimil1 3 года назад +1

      @@TheDomdabomb romans of anatolia

  • @dgonthehill
    @dgonthehill 3 года назад +3

    thank you dan, love history

  • @Boric78
    @Boric78 3 года назад +10

    Phil Harding is the quintessential Englishman. You can just imagine his ancestor (who looked like him) at Aquincourt, squinting at the French Knights and telling his boss "Well I can hit them from here, but it will not kill them. Give it another 50 yards and its a different story."

  • @NickC-Ohio
    @NickC-Ohio 3 года назад +3

    25:00 props to the spindle animation 👏👏

  • @jrmckim
    @jrmckim Год назад +1

    Is it just me or does Phil look like Farmer Fran from the Waterboy in this episode??😅

  • @walterulasinksi7031
    @walterulasinksi7031 3 года назад +3

    In the middle of the sixth century, there was also the Justinian plague, which would have spread to Cornwall by the copper/tin trade routes.

  • @morriganmhor5078
    @morriganmhor5078 3 года назад +9

    Using the term "Turkey" is highly unscientific, as the first Turks (Seljuks) appeared in that region only in the 11th century AD. Geographically its Asia Minor, held by East Roman Empire up to the 12th century.

  • @justinehenricks3653
    @justinehenricks3653 3 года назад +2

    Love this show its my snuggle up show most nights hope they can make more thank you for posting this.

  • @granthurlburt4062
    @granthurlburt4062 3 года назад +20

    This is good because of Tony Robinson and Time Team. Nothing has since matched Timeline because of the personalities involved

    • @ArtHistorywithAlder
      @ArtHistorywithAlder 3 года назад +4

      Agreed, they really are unmatched

    • @Stelios.Posantzis
      @Stelios.Posantzis 3 года назад

      Except for the gung-ho attitude when it comes to to characterising findings.
      Hugely disappointing. A mockery of archaeology and scientific research.
      They're doing their audience a disservice with this lbullcrap.

    • @billie-jobenway8658
      @billie-jobenway8658 3 года назад +2

      Not sure if you know this but stating it just in case; Time Team showed on channel 4 in Britain for 20 seasons and Timeline purchased the episodes to post. It seams a lot of people mistakenly think this is a Timeline product. I have also seen that with many other documentaries they have purchased and reposted. This poster, Reijer Zaaijer, has all the regular episodes and some of the specials and has showed them for years. He even has the four episodes of the American version that did not succeed. Watch them and it's easy to see why.
      ruclips.net/video/yDScJahs4b0/видео.html
      Also Time Team members and the producer have been buying up and posting the episodes under their own site in HD so people can watch them freely and in order on either site. It's nice to have them labelled by season so you can watch not only the changing of time with the experts and others involved but also how archaeological information and methods have changed over the two decades it aired.
      ruclips.net/channel/UCvmEISc6e4tLwn8TyS14ncw
      They have even began taking donations to do other digs with the added benefit of more time to dig and accurately convey information about the site. So far they have funding for two digs and have one ready to go soon.
      ruclips.net/channel/UCvmEISc6e4tLwn8TyS14ncw
      ruclips.net/channel/UCDvcavTI2xgfXZdF9MaPKIQ

    • @Dal606BBN
      @Dal606BBN 3 года назад +1

      Time Team is coming back, channel name is Time Team Official

    • @jrmckim
      @jrmckim Год назад +1

      ​@@Stelios.Posantzisomg get over yourself. This show has brought archeology to the masses. If people want to learn more, than they are free to further their education. If you told people that you'd be watching a bunch of people dig around in the dirt for an hour, there wouldn't be a show.
      This show made lots of people passionate about archeology and some went on to become archeologists.
      Stop being so snobby.

  • @mrmainlobster
    @mrmainlobster 3 года назад +1

    Frances Pryor is a gas. His enthusiasm is catching!

  • @junkabella6324
    @junkabella6324 3 года назад

    Such satisfying stratigraphy!

  • @ArtHistorywithAlder
    @ArtHistorywithAlder 3 года назад +7

    So cool. Fun to watch the process of discovery

  • @nathangreer8219
    @nathangreer8219 3 года назад +1

    Will Phil's hat someday be placed with honor in the British Museum??

  • @morriganmhor5078
    @morriganmhor5078 3 года назад +2

    Byzantine Empire = Eastern Roman Empire; it "faded" only in the 13th century, its last and biggest city, Constantinople, being conquered by the Ottoman Turks in 1453.

  • @javavoicecafe6968
    @javavoicecafe6968 3 года назад +20

    Francis said sometimes iron age people placed hearths over ancestoral graves. Maybe that's where the phrase "over my dead body" comes from. 🤭

    • @eironwyman8157
      @eironwyman8157 3 года назад +1

      Ok....you're fired.

    • @emdaughtry2576
      @emdaughtry2576 3 года назад

      He actually said, "Hearths", but we know hw thinks they were making iron there.

    • @emdaughtry2576
      @emdaughtry2576 3 года назад +1

      I love your analysis, though :)

    • @peetyw8851
      @peetyw8851 3 года назад +1

      @@eironwyman8157 Good one!

  • @AnnaAnna-uc2ff
    @AnnaAnna-uc2ff 4 месяца назад

    Thank you.

  • @je710817
    @je710817 3 года назад

    Always a big fan! My favour TV programme on the Dutch tv

  • @tanias4877
    @tanias4877 Год назад

    Yay !! Baldrick ❤

  • @vinnartaigh2076
    @vinnartaigh2076 3 года назад +3

    Enjoy your amphora with the crew.

  • @loriolus
    @loriolus 3 года назад +18

    There was NO Turkey in the 5th-6th century!

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад

      NONE!! What is this?! Amateur hour?!

    • @agentzero323
      @agentzero323 3 года назад +1

      There most definately werent any "turks" in asia minor during Justinians reign, but i also dont like this hellinization of the empire during the reign of enperors who werent greek speakers. The empire became hellenophilic during the "macedonian" dynasty which is a few centuries after this!

  • @vinnartaigh2076
    @vinnartaigh2076 3 года назад +6

    It sounds like this place was part of the ancient Arms Trade.

  • @cookie4197
    @cookie4197 3 года назад +1

    The term Turkish is wrong because the turks lived in meddle east and they started their trading after 1453 when they conquered Constantinople

  • @kevincarrigan6348
    @kevincarrigan6348 3 года назад

    @44:20, It seems to me that the discussion is so preliminary, that the 3 men overlook the fact that the "Droveway" points also to the 'passage' towards the headlands. Inhospitable to humans, but maybe good graing pastures, for sheep & cattle, who are clad in permanent overcoats which protect them from harsh & powerful winds..... The human residents, could tolerate the conditions long enough to round up, & shepherd their livestock back to their nightly protected paddocks, near the 'village'......

  • @robbieevans6536
    @robbieevans6536 3 года назад

    Very interesting stuff, but I couldn't help but be distracted by the potential of surfing this place.

  • @The1davidb
    @The1davidb Год назад

    Ok, I’ve watched quite a few of these episodes now and what I’ve learned about archaeology is this, there’s a lot of guesswork, a lot of assumptions to get from point A to point B and finally it’s very very subjective. Nobody really knows.

  • @michellezenner
    @michellezenner 3 года назад

    The geofiz found Dragon Scale! This is an extrooordinary find! A well preserved dragon burial!

  • @benmak1039
    @benmak1039 2 года назад

    literally the only man in all of recorded history that used the term "droveway"

  • @andreasleonardo6793
    @andreasleonardo6793 3 года назад

    Nice video about lost byzantine hourbores how Archeological method in records history periods trust in studying...thanks for sending

  • @baroquejen
    @baroquejen 3 года назад

    Can't say they didn't have a great view!

  • @yiannimil1
    @yiannimil1 3 года назад +11

    you never seen it before re papaara!
    because it was not turkish 1500 yrs ago!!! amazing brainfizzz!
    Hadrianus was turkish too, like...hadrianoglou!

  • @gregedmand9939
    @gregedmand9939 21 день назад

    Never forget that the concept of ship captains making use of local pilots, has been around for millennia. Navigators have always highly valued any reasonably accurate charts of costal areas and trade points, as being worth a fortune. But a reliable pilot was worth his weight in gold. A place like this tiny estuary in Cornwall, would have had at least one. They would have some agreed form of communication from ship to shore, when a trading vessel approached the coast. The pilot would hop into a small boat and paddle, or be paddled, out to the ship. His local knowledge of tides and sand bars, would let the ship captain know when and where to safely anchor. How do I know they had this here? Because there is over a thousand years worth of evidence of international trade, in the ground. As for there being a busy small farming community with small similar size pastures: that's what you need to graze sheep. Sailors from the Mediterranean needed to resupply with food to carry their load of tinnand copper home. And they do love their lamb and mutton.

  • @admiralpercy
    @admiralpercy 3 года назад

    Do you have any videos or anything explaining exactly what you mean by "geophys"?

    • @davidthompson6710
      @davidthompson6710 Год назад

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geophysical_survey_(archaeology)

  • @firefox5926
    @firefox5926 3 года назад

    0:28 hey dont you tell me what to do im a big boy now im 30 i can choose were or i want to enjoy this show..

  • @youvebeengreeked
    @youvebeengreeked 3 года назад +4

    😗 TWH upload a video
    😲 It’s on Byzantine History
    🤩 Tony Robinson is presenting

    • @ade9597
      @ade9597 3 года назад +2

      You have a cunning coment

  • @davidglenchynoweth4902
    @davidglenchynoweth4902 3 года назад +2

    I love Timeline. Question though exactly how did ya all take your pottery shards and determine the difference between Turkish, African and Welsh pottery?

    • @Dal606BBN
      @Dal606BBN 3 года назад

      Time Team is coming back, channel name is Time Team Official

    • @georgedorn1022
      @georgedorn1022 3 года назад +2

      They can tell the difference from the form (shape, style and decoration) and fabric (type of clay and mineral inclusions) of the pottery sherds as these are often quite specific to certain time periods and geographical areas.

  • @jimtalbott9535
    @jimtalbott9535 3 года назад +3

    Another wonderful episode - but it’s midly bothersome that no one seems to understand that “Turkey”, “North Africa” and “the Middle East” were ALL essentially still Roman - just what’s correctly referred to as the Eastern Roman Empire.

  • @jrmckim
    @jrmckim Год назад

    After watching 20+ episodes of tt, ive come to realize how important ditches are.

  • @kevincarrigan6348
    @kevincarrigan6348 3 года назад

    Yes, I think that Stuart has got it backwards; & that the headlands SERVED the village, which was the 'politcal center'. There being no cropmarks on the headlands, to suggest permanent human presence in that area. In my past comment i meant to type GRAZING, not graing.....

  • @xyz8512
    @xyz8512 3 года назад +11

    There were no Turks in Anatolia in the 5th and 6th centuries so it couldn't be Turkish pottery.

    • @tecumsehcristero
      @tecumsehcristero Год назад

      That’s what I’ve been screaming at the screen too

  • @lindamavrikis2229
    @lindamavrikis2229 3 года назад

    Is Phil teary eyed,?

  • @letthepainremain
    @letthepainremain 3 года назад +3

    Baldrick?

  • @hutchracing4680
    @hutchracing4680 3 года назад +5

    I swear I have already seen this episode. I was hoping for a new one.

    • @michaelhenry1645
      @michaelhenry1645 3 года назад

      That's because it was posted on the Time Team Classics channel like 4 months back

    • @MjC7192
      @MjC7192 3 года назад

      @anonymous drone ...reijer zeijer has them all

  • @Taleton
    @Taleton 3 года назад +3

    5th century Turkish ???? Are you joking??? On the 5th century the Turkic peoples slept on there horses and drank out of skulls ...

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад

      All accurate

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад

      I’m so glad other comments are saying this

  • @alexk7973
    @alexk7973 3 года назад

    is it just me, or is the idea people could be cooking dinner on top of granny‘s grave a little strange? Interesting custom, though. Maybe a sort of blessing of the house?

  • @lindahughes2289
    @lindahughes2289 9 месяцев назад

    2024. Found a.missed one ! Tx TT

  • @beaujeste1
    @beaujeste1 2 года назад

    Not even a mention of a pasty!

  • @p.l.frederick
    @p.l.frederick Год назад

    Every time we try to watch one of these I hold out hope that the Time Team men have done something about their talons. Cleaned them maybe, or trimmed ‘em. Or stopped with the finger close ups. Nope.

  • @jasonschubel
    @jasonschubel 3 года назад

    That’s cool

  • @k.s.333
    @k.s.333 3 года назад

    0:30 - you're welcome

  • @markamcampbell6340
    @markamcampbell6340 3 года назад

    what is up with three days?

  • @claytontucker8179
    @claytontucker8179 3 года назад +3

    Gee that sounds interesting to me. My DNA from 23 and me. Shows slight amounts of south west Asia close to steppes of caucuses and North Africa. But mostly Brittany by 92%. Plus the most recent my grandparents come from south west Britain. At least for my male heritage

    • @vinnartaigh2076
      @vinnartaigh2076 3 года назад +1

      Yeah, we sailors get around. I have 2.5% from the city of Tyr. Could have been a slave though

    • @claytontucker8179
      @claytontucker8179 3 года назад

      @@vinnartaigh2076 yes I agree. I’m still trying to figure a lot of work out. It really is a life long project lol. We also had family in the navy and merchants.

  • @thomashernandez8700
    @thomashernandez8700 3 года назад

    The years 536-545, Climate Disaster; Plague of Julian reached SW England c 543 or so. No more Cornish trading.

  • @sharonfarris1282
    @sharonfarris1282 3 года назад

    Earlier tonight I watched this same episode referred to as..."Eastern Roman Empire riches buried in Cornwall". This was presented by Time Team-Odyssey. What gives?

  • @Thomas.Wright
    @Thomas.Wright 3 года назад

    Ancient Mariners? Did one of them have a rhyme?

  • @glendamears3618
    @glendamears3618 9 месяцев назад

    A Big trade center😊

  • @stevenrickett4333
    @stevenrickett4333 2 года назад

    Timeline seems to have a lot of documentaries that are very careless with facts. This one’s talks about “Turkish” when they mean Byzantine/Anatolian. The last one I saw about Mosquito aircraft talked about “Allied fighter command” when they should reference RAF. If history isn’t fact then it’s fiction. I can only conclude Timeline is not a serious channel.

  • @uncannydan
    @uncannydan 3 года назад

    I would suggest that area was prone to cyclones. A time period of natural disasters, fish scale pattern construction pulling back and rebuilding.

  • @Odo55
    @Odo55 3 года назад +1

    " Spectacular geo-phys "❗ know it's going to be a fun one.

  • @Jean-yn6ef
    @Jean-yn6ef 3 года назад

    💚

  • @SuchIsLife424
    @SuchIsLife424 3 года назад +2

    It's Greek not Turkish.

  • @greggiles7309
    @greggiles7309 3 года назад

    Water levels would have been meters lower in the period.

  • @BertMerlin57
    @BertMerlin57 3 года назад

    Not time to see the rest.... grabs a shovel and rjun out dig in the garden!!!

  • @1ntwndrboy198
    @1ntwndrboy198 3 года назад

    The Romans traded everywhere they went so everywhere they had been there were other things from all over their empire.

  • @lainecolley1414
    @lainecolley1414 3 года назад

    Have they ever found a chopstick?

  • @demitasse22
    @demitasse22 3 года назад +3

    Omg. Stop saying Turkey. It’s modern day Turkey. It was Greece then

  • @johnnyplatis
    @johnnyplatis 3 года назад +3

    Τurkish pottery from the 5th century? Hardly so.

  • @Merylstreep1949
    @Merylstreep1949 3 года назад

    Totally reminded me of Craggy Island and kept expecting to see Father Ted lol

  • @tommyestridge9301
    @tommyestridge9301 3 года назад

    Why the artificial time constraint of three days?

    • @billie-jobenway8658
      @billie-jobenway8658 3 года назад +2

      Many of those involved are either experts with day jobs on weekdays or diggers working other digs or in college. The idea behind Time Team from the start was to make archaeology accessible to the masses. Thus Tony, who asks the questions and voices the opinions many non- archaeologists at home would ask. The kind of archaeology they are doing is exploratory, finding out the basics, such as the age of a site, the size, what it is, such as an iron age farm or Roman villa, etc. This information is compiled in standard archaeological reports and often leads to further digs or listing of a site.

    • @yiannimil1
      @yiannimil1 3 года назад

      $$$$$$$$

  • @rejuvinatez347
    @rejuvinatez347 3 года назад

    3 days to find out.

  • @MikaelLevoniemi
    @MikaelLevoniemi 3 года назад +3

    It's not turkish, it's roman. This some kind of way to try to please modern day turkey? Turkey as a country is relatively young.

    • @yiannimil1
      @yiannimil1 3 года назад +1

      or toni fng with us!!

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад +2

      Well, Byzantine, so still Greek

  • @shaymayo6
    @shaymayo6 3 года назад

    Anthea Harris is definitely a very beautiful find

  • @storeheier93
    @storeheier93 3 года назад

    "no, i was 100% wrong". pigs will fly before we hear a high ranking politician say this....and mean it

  • @mdb1239
    @mdb1239 3 года назад +4

    Byzantine??? It is Roman. What's with Byzantine? It is Roman. Who began calling it Byzantine? When? Why?
    It is Roman as in part of the Roman Empire that ruled the entire Mediterranean Sea.

    • @Stelios.Posantzis
      @Stelios.Posantzis 3 года назад +1

      That's history revisionists for you. Happens every 10-12 years... or with every shift in the balance of global political powers.
      Almost like watching BBC!
      Of course this is to be expected when one hopes to learn history from TV - or worse, on youtube!

    • @charlenelundquist3512
      @charlenelundquist3512 3 года назад +1

      Byzantine was the Empire after Rome fell. It was moved to what became Constantinople.

    • @Stelios.Posantzis
      @Stelios.Posantzis 3 года назад +3

      @@charlenelundquist3512 The term "Byzantine" was coined much later after the fall of the empire. Throughout it's life it was called Roman empire and it's inhabitants Romans. Rome fell a few times. The first time it fell it marked the end of what then was the Western part of the Roman Empire. The Eastern part continued to exist for a lot longer. It's capital was the former city of Byzantium which was renamed to "New Rome" by great Constantine People, however, soon started calling it Constantinople or simply "Poli" which means "City".

    • @mdb1239
      @mdb1239 3 года назад +2

      @@charlenelundquist3512 You do know that under Justinian that they reconquered Rome. Unfortunately the Black Plague wiped out half of Constantinople so the ROMAN army was called back.
      ""The term “Byzantine Empire” came into common use during the 18th and 19th centuries, but it would’ve been completely alien to the Empire’s ancient inhabitants.""

    • @davidthompson6710
      @davidthompson6710 Год назад

      They spoke Greek in Byzantium

  • @ragael1024
    @ragael1024 Месяц назад

    the "byzantines" were ROMANS! Eastern Romans that survived the fall of Rome in 476. you guys treat it as if they were a whole different empire.

  • @David-zc6wq
    @David-zc6wq 3 года назад

    They were 'wreckers' not a harbour. Settlements often spring up around dangerous waters.

  • @geordimi
    @geordimi 3 года назад +3

    "Turkish pottery" was a very "Baldrick moment" .. Well, it doesn't matter that much, because this program is viewed by people that know a thing or two (probably more) about history, and not by the average dumbo. So they can distinguish the different historic periods and where each tribe resided.

    • @demitasse22
      @demitasse22 3 года назад

      More than I thought! Still don’t like it though

  • @kcsunshine4008
    @kcsunshine4008 3 года назад +1

    Ok OK, you’re all right, of course ….. The Byzantine Empire, Byzantium, Asia Minor, Eastern Roman Empire (Anatolia ?) would all be more accurate historically but……..He said “ This is Turkish” . As I understood it , he probably meant modern-day Turkey because it gave the viewers ( who didn’t have all the geo-political-historical knowledge many of you have) a more easily understood location. That’s precisely why the programme was so successful and popular - Tony was a TV actor, (not an archaeologist or historian) who presented the programme from the lay-man’s POV. Let’s not confuse popular TV with serious History Tomes from the library……

    • @stevenrickett4333
      @stevenrickett4333 2 года назад

      “Popular” is not synonymous with inaccurate. If a “foreigner” has a difficult name it’s not acceptable to call him/her Smith.

  • @GeSoS
    @GeSoS 3 года назад +3

    "Turkish pottery" ?? When this traiding post existed, Turks were IN MONGOLIA for God's sake !!! A dislike for this from me

  • @steveb1ish
    @steveb1ish 3 года назад

    tony asked naomi if he could come in her trench