Such a good review, Sofia!! Oof. I bought Myth (has not arrived) and instantly regretted it because I have Tom Ford Violet Satine. I obvs love my purples, but wow this was an unnecessary purchase. Lisa is so good at selling the fantasy, and we can really get wrapped up in that (plus the FOMO of her often limited stock). Thank you for always keeping it real! You are definitely one of the best on YT.
I have violet satine also and idk why but it fades on me and I use the rare beauty primer. The lower lashline disappears on me and the outer corner darker shades just fades Does that happen to you ? I’m leaning to returning it and keeping the myth instead.
@@makeupjunkie723 I can say I have had an issue with the Kaki palette fading. My lids are usually on the oily side so I feel like since the shadows are more on the creamy side they don't last as long 😞
@@makeupjunkie723 I have not had that issue with TF Violet Satine. I wonder if a different eye primer might help. I use the one from About Face, which is not sticky.
Hi Sophia. I’m skipping on this release. And after watching your very through, objective and awesome review I know I made the right decision. I actually ordered the Burberry palette instead and I love it so much. ( I know much higher price point) l😂😂😂One of the reasons I love your videos so much is because you have a way of keeping us grounded. You give us the good, the bad and different ways to look at things. Thank you for all that you do for us. You are appreciated ❤❤❤
Your review confirmed what I suspected from the swatches! I like more sparkly metallics/shimmers, (like those from PMG or makeup by Mario ethereal eyes ❤) and u confirmed that these shimmers r more lackluster imo. The main reason I buy a palette is for the shimmers so I’m glad I can pass on these expensive palettes! I also was interested in building my own custom palette as none of the premade color stories spoke to me 100% and I feel like with her emphasis on the customization aspect, it didn’t really make sense to not sell an empty palette LOL
Just got my Muse palette today. Love the colors! Lisa said the Muse is the most wearable and soft looking palette and that was excatly why I chose it. I want a beautiful everyday look with a bit of lux. And that is exactually what it is!
The fact that she isn’t selling a component is the only reason I’ll be passing on this. I want make my own perfect palette. I absolutely adore Lisa Eldridge and her work, but nothing in her line has intrigued me enough to to purchase. Thanks for being so thorough!!
@@polly1141 very true! But it’s not worth it for me personally to buy a magnetic palette in the mean time to only buy her empty palette later whenever she releases one. On the bright side it saves my wallet for right now 😅
@@MarniMedia probably because the shades in one palette are "curated". It's cheaper to buy a palette already ready to go vs. 6 shades for $98 vs. $68. I'm guessing it's labor intensive a logistic nightmare to fulfill every customized order. Idk. 🤷🏼♀️
That was a great video Sophia. Very comprehensive and informative as always but I especially liked the last few minutes. It’s easy to get swept away in the romantic way Lisa describes these palettes in her launch video. Having your voice of reason along with your opinion now that you have them in hand is really valuable advice. The looks you created do look beautiful on you and I’m glad I picked up a few single shades and a lipstick. My hope is that she will someday sell an empty palette so we can create our own color story. I’m definitely interested in a few more shades of the lipstick but they really are so expensive so I’ll wait.
@@SofiaSeesBeauty oh, what size are these pans?? I ordered a couple of singles that haven't shipped yet, and I'm wondering how they'll fit in an empty MUFE palette
I usually see youtubers with huge makeup collections justifying it to do their compairisons but at the end they always say the new palette is slightly different so we should buy it. I much prefer the way you do, being realistic that we may already have something close to the new palette and the tiny difference it may have doesn't mean a new purchase.
Thank you for your feedback Carolina! As much as I love makeup, if I wasn’t reviewing I would buy much less for sure. Not sure a lot of reviewers realize that many customers are looking at the 25 palettes released in a season and they are trying to get just ONE 😅
Thank you for doing tutorials on these beautiful products by Lisa Eldridge. I recently bought the "Myth", and "Sorcery", eyeshadow palettes and I can't wait to use them. I love the variety of looks, and different moods you achieved. It's so obvious that Lisa created these items with such imagination and love for her art. All the products you reviewed look beautiful on you. I have dark green eyes, and love green eyeshadow, so I was looking forward to seeing how you used the "Sorcery" palette. The look you achieved was gorgeous. I love purple eyeshadow too as it makes my eyes look very green, so I love what you did with those colours too. Looking forward to seeing what you'll review next. By the way, your cat is absolutely gorgeous.
Sofia you're giving way too good review, it's a blessing 🙏 every time I want a palette, I wait your video because I know you're going to give the best comparison, looks and reviews. 🥰
Your looks convinced me to purchase Myth! I love how these eyeshadows don't scream GLITTER as the others I've seen in the market. These look classier, more natural. All look beautiful on you.
All of these palettes are so pretty and thoughtful. I'm going to wait until there's a color story that makes my heart sing. I did the same with the lipsticks and in doing so it brought the perfect shades into my life.
my order still hasn't shipped even though I got everything and ordered 7 mins after launch. I am so disappointed and I wanted to get my video up too! So I am living vicariously through you :p
Such a helpful review!! You might be the first reviewer I have seen who isn't just hyping these collections. I loved that you were so detailed about the formulas, honest and considered it from different view points. Even though you didn't like the Myth palette, your review actually sold it to me - I'm new to eyeshadow, all I wear are neutral matte shades, but I love purple and I'm sparkle curious. So it's actually a good way for me to introduce some colour and shimmer without going too wild (tho I agree that topper is disappointingly lacking in pigment). Thanks again and you made a subscriber out of me!
Yay I'm so glad! I am never afraid to be honest and detailed because half the time my subbies decide not to get something and others (like you) are like wow I love this and decide to get it haha 😛 Myth will be really good to pair with your other neutral shadows too
As always, a well detailed appraisal of the new palettes. Thank you so much, Sofia. Your honesty is a breath of fresh air. I hope your mum enjoys her beautiful gift.
Loved this video, Sofia! This is probably the first objective review with excellent swatches and demos I've seen so far. This launch is a skip for me largely because the US price does not make sense. I haven't tried any of these sextets so I don't know for sure but I have a feeling that I'd still prefer my Guerlain quads over these. Thanks again for the awesome reviews! 😃
Love your hair (You look stunning as always) you are truly amazing, fun to watch and listen to, you could be an audio book reader. You are seriously entertaining. Have a great night Sofia.
Such a good review. I appreciate that you gave the type of detail that helps you know if these palettes are your style. I have Myth and TD Violet Satine and yes, very similar, but I love that color story so much that I'm not mad about it.
This review just made me crossing Muse and Myth in my list but adding Sorcery to the list. Hopefully they’ll restock it soon! You’re so great! Thank you ❤❤
This was so helpful! At first I wanted to get Sorcery, but after seeing all the swatches, I think I want that small one from Danessa Myricks! That looks amazing. I was really just interested in that one awesome duochrome in the LE ❤ thank you so much for all the work you put into your videos, your reviews are seriously the best!! Side note: if she ever lets us buy the packaging to put refills into, I might end up trying it and just getting the shades that interest me the most. I love Lisa and I want to support her brand. I think her videos are one of the reasons I got so into makeup in the first place!
The other issue is, as an American consumer, LE site is charging a huge surcharge for purchasing from American site. For example I attempted to purchase an order that was 124 in British lbs. My credit card would use the current exchange rate and it would cost me $146.30. But the LE sitewants to charge me $172. I touched base with LE and they say they won't change the currency rate to the current exchange rate. They charge a surcharge for buying from the states. So, it's a definite NO for me. :)
Thank you for such a comprehensive review with so many invaluable comparisons! I loved the Myth and Sorcery looks on you. Absolutely stunning 😍 Sorry your eyes were irritated though. I initially bought Sorcery, Myth and Vega with the Duchess lipstick and liner. After I saw more swatches and model pics with deeper skintones, I went back to order Cinnabar and Muse. These two colour stories sort of already exist in my collection, but I prefer how Lisa’s products look with my deeper skintone. I trust her more when it comes to creating flattering shades for a wider range of people. P.S. Minnie is absolutely adorable! 😻
Hi Sofia, Another great review! I ordered Muse and Cinnabar last week and will receive tomorrow. I like that the shadows in those 2 palettes look more daytime friendly and soft. The palette looks slim for travel also as it is a pain to take a ND or PAT McGRATH palette with you. I also like the replaceable individual colors because so often in a palette I use more of one or two shades and then when they are gone I have to throw the rest out. The sorcery palette look gorgeous, but at my age my a bit over the top and only for evening for sure. I bought the lipsticks with matching pencils in Velvet Rain and Velvet Pompadour. I love her lipstick formula. As far as cost I spend a small fortune on makeup and skincare every year ( I spent over a $1000 on the Sephora sale and that was after 20% discount 😂). All the looks you created are stunning! You are a natural beauty even without makeup. I look forward to your videos so morning and check every morning for your next one.😘
So I love the purple Muse scene setting "Lisa talked about discovering the look of royalty" followed by "I couldn't help myself, I wanted to go for something smokey and glamorous" followed by "cat walks into scene looking utterly unimpressed by anything human in the last several centuries to present trying to compete with its majesty." Personally I don't go for eyeshadow, but it feels like a nice release for a new brand even with overlap (every brand needs a pink palette). Maybe in the future Lisa could take advantage of the singles by offering "special" one off colors that are shinier or more potent and could be plugged into existing palettes to amp them up for the different customer base.
You convinced me to dip back into the Natasha Denona Lila palette, which seems close to the LE Myth color story. Also the combo of Viseart Violette, Cashmerie, and Bijoulaix. And I really, really appreciate your thorough review. Because I kept staring at the Sorcery palette (which is now out of stock). And fascinated that they are overpriced even for luxury. Plus you made me excited again for that PMG palette…thanks!!
I’m glad it was helpful! I know I wanted to show the Lila palette but before my RUclips days I took it apart to creat a custom palette during quarantine 😂😂😂
I have and love Sorcery but my goodness I need that Velvet Dutchess lipstick. I totally understand what you mean about red lipsticks and think it would be a great unique red for my collection. ❤
Thank you for considering other peoples preferences. It's good to have your own known and discussed as well but some reviewers think their preference is the only standard.
Completely agree! And for considering what might work better for different ages, lifestyles, skintones, abilities etc. I’m a huge fan of her channel because of this!
Thanks so much for the excellent review Sofia. I got my order today and I cannot wait to play with the eyeshadow palettes. Even though the price is ridiculous and the color stories are very much dupable I think I’m going to enjoy these palettes since I enjoy a more soft and sophisticated look.
Hi Sofia !! Yaaassss …you’re amazing! Great review!!! Totally appreciate all your hard work and thorough reviews!! And yes I do dream about makeup!! 😂💕🥰🥰Xx
Let’s be smart with our money! Sofia for the win 🏆 Sorry to hear your eyes got irritated with the myth palette, it was one of the 2 that I was considering after seeing your beautiful eye look but no more. I may pick up the sorcery one, we shall see.Minnie stole the show, she was adorable and wanted to be close to you and I couldn’t stop watching her 😀 Your content is always top notch, unlike any other!
I ordered Sorcery, Vega and Cinnabar and am excited to try them out (and Sorcery/Enchantment Lip). I definitely didn't need any of them, but I just love playing with different formulas and couldn't nail it down to a single choice! Lisa doesn't really disappoint in most of what I've tried so far, but agree that you do need to consider personal preference as her line definitely leans more every day 'wearable'. I think my tastes align pretty well with yours - I can go all in for the drama and am not afraid of colour, but it doesn't always fit into my every day, so there's still room for some softer more luxury versions! Since I ordered I've been eyeing up my Melt Cosmetics Smoke Sessions palette, as I'm fairly sure the top three green shades in the Sorcery palette might find dupes in there, even though it's being touted as the most unique, but hopefully the formula is a bit more forgiving than the Melt. I'm also hovering over the order button to pick a palette up for my mum for Christmas, they are stunning. Thanks for such a well rounded and balanced review, as always!
I loved reading your thoughts Sophie. I wonder if you could use the Melt palette as a companion palette. I like to use my Viseart matte shadows with palettes like Sorcery that have a lot of shimmers.
I also checked my collection for dupes. I notice that if you have all the ND and the divine rose series of PM; you will have those colors and finishes. It is also worth noting Olivia Palermo’s eyeshadows if anyone is interested with LE’s Sorcery and Vega.
Myth is STUNNING on you Sofia...you did good!! That's the one I'd be getting if I hadn't just bought the TF Violet Satine quad 💜💜💜 And cute cat behind your shoulder!! 😻
Hi Sophia, thanks for your review! It's so helpful to know more about the formulas/application and what to expect when trying to figure out which one is best for me or not lol. Btw I love seeing your adorable cat in the background❤
This will probably sound so weird but I saw your comment on Tara Lynn's channel and I was waiting for your review! Really looking forward to your thoughts on this palette, you always have such thoughtful and thorough reviews!
Hi Sofia, thank you for this very comprehensive & helpful review video... I may have already ordered all five palettes🙈 I should be getting one of them today... still waiting for the other orders to ship. I love all the eye looks you did and am really looking forward to trying them!🥰
Wow, such a wonderful and very detailed video, love the looks, comparisons, everything!!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩Bought the light pink toned one and the neutral brown ones, looking forward to them! Thanks for the beautiful video, have a wonderful day!!!!😘😘😘😘😘😘
This is such an amazing review! So informative and detailed. All the eye looks that you created were astonishing❤ Thank you for your honesty and wonderful review, this is truly a most in-depth review I could ever imagined
Wow - your reviews never disappoint! Thank you for all the time and attention to detail with these palettes. We all love LE and I respect your honest opinion of how you experienced these. One day 1 I bought Muse and Cinnabar as I wanted to softer color stories even though I have similar palettes.
I just subscribed. Love your review! I love Lisa and am tempted but I am going to hold off for now. I have most if not all of the color stories. In the end I probably will buy one, I am a collector of antique makeup and a succer for a beautiful compact, I’m hoping the sells an empty pallet that maybe I can create my own color story. but I’m going to see what comes out next. Thanks for that Reveiw ‼️‼️
Excellent thorough review, Sofia! Bravo! Well worth waiting for! I really enjoyed your comprehensive thoughts on Lisa’s eyeshadows. Thank you for your time and effort! It genuinely helps! Warmest wishes ~ Irinka
Thank you Sophia, this was SUPER helpful. I did not get any palettes because I'm more of a cream eyeshadow kind of woman but I do love Lisa and I do tend to be tempted by her storytelling. I love the colors but I have similar ones in my collection already. Thank you for this video I really really appreciate your take on Lisa's palettes :)
I made the exact same face when I applied Velvet Duchess for the first time! I also picked up Velvet Enchantment, which is (surprise) amazing and beautiful. Great review, like always!!
Also, I love top coat shades! I like putting on matt cream shadows and I would love to have just slight transparent shimmers on top. I've got skin tone, light brown, medium and dark brown creams so I'll get loads of use out of those!
Yay Minnie was supervising during the 2nd eye look! Hehe. Ahh I think I’m gonna wait for her future palette releases. None of these color stories for the price really sing to me soul lol. 😸 you did an amazing job on this review, as always! The most helpful review of these I’ve seen. I wish the metallic shades in palettes other than Sorcery were more sparkly!
Wow what an amazingly thorough review! Thank you! Shame the myth palette didn't work out because it looks so beautiful on you. I got Vega (wanted sorcery also but i missed out) and I was considering going back and buying all the others but thankfully you talked me out. Thank you for reminding me that I have those colour stores and I don't need them. P.s. would love to see the sorcery palette compaired to the ND metropolis (if you have it)
All these palettes look stunning on you! After seeing your comparison swatches, I agree with looking pretty similar to others. I ordered the Cinnabar and ca couple of lipsticks. The lipstick I wanted the most was the Sorcery but it sold out very fast. Womp womp. Thanks for the unbiased review! ❤️
Aw nooo! I am going to try and see if I can dupe sorcery because so many people missed out on it. Reminds me of when Velvet Affair sold out. I had to wait for that one 😁
Great swatches thanks! This was super helpful. I picked up the cool one and I can’t wait to receive it. Edit: Oh no I am sorry about the eye irritation. Let us know if it continues.
I couldn't wait for these palettes. But I am very disappointed that there isn't any beige/brown/gold palette. Maybe it's too basic/boring? I was really hoping to finally find my dream "boring brown/gold/beige palette", but it looks like I still have to keep looking...
New here, looking for how to wear these! I bought the same 3 palettes and the sorcery lipstick and liner, which all arrived yesterday, so am diving right in. Thank you, yay!!
Thank you for the great Review, i can 100% agree on everything you have said and mentioned! But first, i am impressed by your performance with every Palette, every look turned out so so great, I loved your Look with Myth and Sorcery!! Stunning! But i can share your thoughts about the little less "wow Effect", but over all and when you knwo what you are getting with the palettes, they are very nice to me, even if they are not that unique or super special except for some shades. I have the Vega one and feel that there are little diffenences between the two Matte formulas. I love the creamier ones so that is a plus for the Palettes. Thank you so much, loved everything about the Review!! :)
Wow what a fantastic in-depth review! I had a feeling these wouldn’t be all that fantastical as far as formula, but when I saw Sorcery it was just too enticing. It was the one I wanted to try. Even still I didn’t pull the trigger on launch day but I went ahead and purchased it yesterday and from what I can tell from reviews I think I’ll be pleased. They are indeed pricey, but as you’ve mentioned she is an Indie brand and higher end so it’s to be expected. I should have been quicker in picking up the Sorcery lipstick as that is such a ME color. I was able to get the lip liner for now.
Great video. Lisa’s intro did explain each formula thoroughly, just not with swatches. I picked up one palette and a single of the two formulas not included. Each palette has 3-4 formulas. Muse is the only palette with a lustre. I purchased that individual shade. One more note, the website lists some shade finishes incorrectly. I brought this to Lisa’s team. I am hoping they corrected the info. I also hope that they are correct on the palettes. This was a FAB deep dive. I just subscribed. Love your personality and the comparisons.
Oh that is good to know! I think they may have corrected the site! I felt like she did a good job describing the shades but I was watching and waiting for her to show us on camera 😅 I felt like her video was filmed a bit far too far to see the swatches and application
I really like your review for setting people's expectation. I like that you mentioned how LE is not positioning brand in the highshine bling artistic side but more of the grounded effortless day-to-day look. I think a lot of people go in expecting Pat McGrath's insane party colors but that is not what Lisa is selling at all. Great review!
Now I know where to go for reviews. You are an amazing reviewer, thank you! Really appreciate you, I'm not taking the eye shadows. They definitely nothing spectacular at least for me. ❤
Thankyou for a super thorough and honest review as always Sofia 😊 All your hard work really helps us all so much - you have already saved me from making a number of purchases this year that would have been disappointing. I have ordered myth and sorcery and like many others, I probably should have waited for reviews before buying these but I was completely sucked in by the packaging and beautiful look of the eyeshadows AND FOMO as the hype around these is very real. I have blond hair/hazel eyes and really love cool and purple tones in general. I do have TF Violet Satine - I can hopefully use this as a companion to myth (and that they are not just dupes). I am looking forward to playing with sorcery, I don’t have anything at all like this.
Hey Nicole! I know what you mean. A lot of times these releases sell out so fast so we have to panic-buy. I think Violet Satine is probably a bit softer. You’ll have to let me know if you think the formula is similar. I only have the 3 original Creme palettes that Tom launched
I really like the TF Creme’ formula. Naturally I gravitate to the Myth pallet. I am worried that the cranberry color in it may irritate my eyes as well. i had some irritation with the TF Violet. i love the Sorcery Lipstick on you...beautiful! thank you for working so hard to get this video up...great review & beautiful looks👏👏
Thank you for your detailed review, I am feeling much less alone with my palette ! I bought Sorcery and while the sparkly shade and the antique gold metallic are the standouts and are very pretty, the rest is very underwhelming, the audacity to call the teal matte seamless is unreal, one of the patchiest shades I used and it is not even a matte, it is a cream to powder ! On another note, I picked up the Chanel holiday collection after your review and have been loving it, true luxury experience !
Excellent and very thorough review. So far I've only seen people gushing about these. I ordered on Friday and received it on Monday (I'm in the UK) so I had a few days to properly test out Myth palette (the only one I ordered). I have similar thoughts to yours on the top coat shade - I expected more impact from it and feel somewhat disappointed. The metallic is more of a shimmer than a metallic. The velvet mattes are very nice, easy to blend with minimum fallout. Overall I think these eyeshadows aren't revolutionary and a bit overpriced, but will definitely appeal to people who are not so crazy into makeup like we are and love luxury.
Love the in depth video. I’ve been tempted by these but I heard that there may be some hefty duty in addition to ship/palette costs when importing them to Canada. I actually think the take away from this video is I might need the Guerlain quad. It’s a surprising conclusion;)
Very helpful!! Yeah, I’m all about the wet-look, foiled, sparklies galore… I probably didn’t NEED to order Myth, but I still love all the colors and will just have to pair it with some Pat Mcrath or something. Excited for it to arrive!
It sounds like maybe I would love this brand/line/formulas. However, I am not her demographic I don't think. It was hard seeing how they are customizable, but you can't order an empty palette (cry). This is out of my price range, but every once in a while I like to splurge or treat myself with something :) I would have purchased an empty palette, as well as some lipsticks (that velvet enchantment and velvet rain look divine ) had the empty palette been available to fill in. Who knows.. It sounds like the Charlotte makeup may also be something I would enjoy so I may just try that! I am just getting back into wearing makeup, and oh my goodness so many companies and brands now! It's quite exciting!!
I completely understand why people are frustrated that she didn't release an empty component. It makes the customizable element untrue seeing as you would need to buy an entire palette. WIth that being said, I have so many magnetic palettes that I can slip any extra shades into those. I know it's not ideal for everyone but it works for me. I picked up two on launch--Vega and Sorcery. Sorcery looks so unique and I do love a cool toned palette so Vega was a shoe-in. I have the rest of the shades in other palettes that I already own so didn't feel the need to pick those up (purples, warm tones, rosy tones). Anyway, can't wait to try her different formulas! I love how much thought she puts into her products. Thanks for the thorough review!
Hi Sofia. Great review and your comparison swatches are very interested. I have 3 of these: muse, cinnabar et myth. It's pretty yes it's pretty BUT I'm a little bit disapointed becaude you don't find colors in pans on your eyelid. I take a dark brown and on my eyelid it's not dark brown it's just light light Brown. I would have liked a little bit of more intensity in eyeshadows like metallics for exemple. Like you if I will have swatched...i won't have bought 3 palettes just 1 I think. It's expensive and I would have an empty palette for personalized it. Je t'embrasse 😘😘😘😘
Great review, love Lisa Eldridge and these palettes are so beautiful. Thank you for sharing, hope you're well and that you have a lovely holiday season. Best wishes!✨
![[Limbus Company - PV] Chapter.7 - Oblivion](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VUpkXPkvoxU/mqdefault.jpg)
The devil works hard, but sofia works harder👏🏻
😂😂😂🫶🫶🫶
Love the softer hues from Lisa. I don't think her stuff is meant to be super sparkly...but more subtle ; especially for mature eyes.
Exactly! I like leaving the disco ball look at home.
Yup! Its very unique because its verrrrrry hard to find shadows like that for people with very dry textured lids
Such a good review, Sofia!! Oof. I bought Myth (has not arrived) and instantly regretted it because I have Tom Ford Violet Satine. I obvs love my purples, but wow this was an unnecessary purchase. Lisa is so good at selling the fantasy, and we can really get wrapped up in that (plus the FOMO of her often limited stock). Thank you for always keeping it real! You are definitely one of the best on YT.
I have violet satine also and idk why but it fades on me and I use the rare beauty primer. The lower lashline disappears on me and the outer corner darker shades just fades Does that happen to you ? I’m leaning to returning it and keeping the myth instead.
I know don’t feel bad because we do this with all the brands 🙈
@@makeupjunkie723 I can say I have had an issue with the Kaki palette fading. My lids are usually on the oily side so I feel like since the shadows are more on the creamy side they don't last as long 😞
@@makeupjunkie723 I have not had that issue with TF Violet Satine. I wonder if a different eye primer might help. I use the one from About Face, which is not sticky.
Hi Sophia. I’m skipping on this release. And after watching your very through, objective and awesome review I know I made the right decision. I actually ordered the Burberry palette instead and I love it so much. ( I know much higher price point) l😂😂😂One of the reasons I love your videos so much is because you have a way of keeping us grounded. You give us the good, the bad and different ways to look at things. Thank you for all that you do for us. You are appreciated ❤❤❤
Omg Leazette I have a tab opened with that Burberry palette cause it’s on my mind 😂😂 thank you also for your kind feedback!
@@SofiaSeesBeauty Did you ever review the earlier Runway palette or the Glow palette?
@@SofiaSeesBeauty it’s an awesome palette. Hey It’s Jackeline did a great review on it if you want to check her review out .
Your review confirmed what I suspected from the swatches! I like more sparkly metallics/shimmers, (like those from PMG or makeup by Mario ethereal eyes ❤) and u confirmed that these shimmers r more lackluster imo. The main reason I buy a palette is for the shimmers so I’m glad I can pass on these expensive palettes! I also was interested in building my own custom palette as none of the premade color stories spoke to me 100% and I feel like with her emphasis on the customization aspect, it didn’t really make sense to not sell an empty palette LOL
Yes k know and the singles are $16 💀
Just got my Muse palette today. Love the colors! Lisa said the Muse is the most wearable and soft looking palette and that was excatly why I chose it. I want a beautiful everyday look with a bit of lux. And that is exactually what it is!
Perfect!! 💕💕
The fact that she isn’t selling a component is the only reason I’ll be passing on this. I want make my own perfect palette. I absolutely adore Lisa Eldridge and her work, but nothing in her line has intrigued me enough to to purchase.
Thanks for being so thorough!!
Thanks for your feedback Lindsey! I feel like she will have to add that eventually 🧐 might have been too hard to supply at first perhaps
They are magnetic so you can put in your own palette until she sells her own? Just a thought...
@@polly1141 very true! But it’s not worth it for me personally to buy a magnetic palette in the mean time to only buy her empty palette later whenever she releases one. On the bright side it saves my wallet for right now 😅
I agree! What's the point of selling each shade individually now if we can't make our own palette?!?
@@MarniMedia probably because the shades in one palette are "curated". It's cheaper to buy a palette already ready to go vs. 6 shades for $98 vs. $68. I'm guessing it's labor intensive a logistic nightmare to fulfill every customized order. Idk. 🤷🏼♀️
Sorry had to comment twice that Myth is INSANE on you! WOW! That makes your brown eyes pop.
Thanks! 🤩 yes when I watched the video back I really did love the way it looked!
That was a great video Sophia. Very comprehensive and informative as always but I especially liked the last few minutes. It’s easy to get swept away in the romantic way Lisa describes these palettes in her launch video. Having your voice of reason along with your opinion now that you have them in hand is really valuable advice. The looks you created do look beautiful on you and I’m glad I picked up a few single shades and a lipstick. My hope is that she will someday sell an empty palette so we can create our own color story. I’m definitely interested in a few more shades of the lipstick but they really are so expensive so I’ll wait.
Thanks Celeste 🥰 yes absolutely! I would have so much fun making a custom palette
Love love the Myth palette on you and the Duchess lipstick❤️
Thank you 😇
I love how thorough this review is and how many data points you gave to help us make informed decisions!!
I’m so glad! It’s what I love to do 😜
@@SofiaSeesBeauty oh, what size are these pans?? I ordered a couple of singles that haven't shipped yet, and I'm wondering how they'll fit in an empty MUFE palette
I usually see youtubers with huge makeup collections justifying it to do their compairisons but at the end they always say the new palette is slightly different so we should buy it. I much prefer the way you do, being realistic that we may already have something close to the new palette and the tiny difference it may have doesn't mean a new purchase.
Thank you for your feedback Carolina! As much as I love makeup, if I wasn’t reviewing I would buy much less for sure. Not sure a lot of reviewers realize that many customers are looking at the 25 palettes released in a season and they are trying to get just ONE 😅
Thank you for doing tutorials on these beautiful products by Lisa Eldridge. I recently bought the "Myth", and "Sorcery", eyeshadow palettes and I can't wait to use them. I love the variety of looks, and different moods you achieved. It's so obvious that Lisa created these items with such imagination and love for her art. All the products you reviewed look beautiful on you. I have dark green eyes, and love green eyeshadow, so I was looking forward to seeing how you used the "Sorcery" palette. The look you achieved was gorgeous. I love purple eyeshadow too as it makes my eyes look very green, so I love what you did with those colours too. Looking forward to seeing what you'll review next.
By the way, your cat is absolutely gorgeous.
Sofia you're giving way too good review, it's a blessing 🙏 every time I want a palette, I wait your video because I know you're going to give the best comparison, looks and reviews. 🥰
I’m so happy to hear that 🥰🤗🤗🤗
Your looks convinced me to purchase Myth! I love how these eyeshadows don't scream GLITTER as the others I've seen in the market. These look classier, more natural. All look beautiful on you.
Awesome! I am glad all the swatches and details helped! 🙌🙌🙌
All of these palettes are so pretty and thoughtful. I'm going to wait until there's a color story that makes my heart sing. I did the same with the lipsticks and in doing so it brought the perfect shades into my life.
That is such a wonderful strategy. If you aren’t sure, then it’s probably a “no”
my order still hasn't shipped even though I got everything and ordered 7 mins after launch. I am so disappointed and I wanted to get my video up too! So I am living vicariously through you :p
Such a helpful review!! You might be the first reviewer I have seen who isn't just hyping these collections. I loved that you were so detailed about the formulas, honest and considered it from different view points. Even though you didn't like the Myth palette, your review actually sold it to me - I'm new to eyeshadow, all I wear are neutral matte shades, but I love purple and I'm sparkle curious. So it's actually a good way for me to introduce some colour and shimmer without going too wild (tho I agree that topper is disappointingly lacking in pigment). Thanks again and you made a subscriber out of me!
Yay I'm so glad! I am never afraid to be honest and detailed because half the time my subbies decide not to get something and others (like you) are like wow I love this and decide to get it haha 😛 Myth will be really good to pair with your other neutral shadows too
As always, a well detailed appraisal of the new palettes. Thank you so much, Sofia. Your honesty is a breath of fresh air. I hope your mum enjoys her beautiful gift.
Thanks Kate! 😇
Loved this video, Sofia! This is probably the first objective review with excellent swatches and demos I've seen so far. This launch is a skip for me largely because the US price does not make sense. I haven't tried any of these sextets so I don't know for sure but I have a feeling that I'd still prefer my Guerlain quads over these. Thanks again for the awesome reviews! 😃
Thank you so much for your feedback! I definitely understand what you are saying 👍
Love your hair (You look stunning as always) you are truly amazing, fun to watch and listen to, you could be an audio book reader. You are seriously entertaining. Have a great night Sofia.
Aw thank you Tammy! 🥰🥰🥰 maybe I should moonlight as a voiceover artist 😂
Sofia you look absolutely stunning with all the three palettes! Insanely thorough review that I very much enjoy!!! Thanks a lot ❤
Thank you, I am so glad!!
Such a good review. I appreciate that you gave the type of detail that helps you know if these palettes are your style. I have Myth and TD Violet Satine and yes, very similar, but I love that color story so much that I'm not mad about it.
You’re very welcome! Yes sometimes I just love a color story so much I don’t care if I have something similar 😅
This review just made me crossing Muse and Myth in my list but adding Sorcery to the list. Hopefully they’ll restock it soon! You’re so great! Thank you ❤❤
I hope so too!
This was so helpful! At first I wanted to get Sorcery, but after seeing all the swatches, I think I want that small one from Danessa Myricks! That looks amazing. I was really just interested in that one awesome duochrome in the LE ❤ thank you so much for all the work you put into your videos, your reviews are seriously the best!!
Side note: if she ever lets us buy the packaging to put refills into, I might end up trying it and just getting the shades that interest me the most. I love Lisa and I want to support her brand. I think her videos are one of the reasons I got so into makeup in the first place!
Nice! I’m obsessed with that mini from Danessa! 😅
The other issue is, as an American consumer, LE site is charging a huge surcharge for purchasing from American site. For example I attempted to purchase an order that was 124 in British lbs. My credit card would use the current exchange rate and it would cost me $146.30. But the LE sitewants to charge me $172. I touched base with LE and they say they won't change the currency rate to the current exchange rate. They charge a surcharge for buying from the states. So, it's a definite NO for me. :)
Yes this is true! These are overpriced for overseas markets
Thank you for such a comprehensive review with so many invaluable comparisons! I loved the Myth and Sorcery looks on you. Absolutely stunning 😍 Sorry your eyes were irritated though. I initially bought Sorcery, Myth and Vega with the Duchess lipstick and liner. After I saw more swatches and model pics with deeper skintones, I went back to order Cinnabar and Muse. These two colour stories sort of already exist in my collection, but I prefer how Lisa’s products look with my deeper skintone. I trust her more when it comes to creating flattering shades for a wider range of people.
P.S. Minnie is absolutely adorable! 😻
Thank you so much for watching! Also love your feedback and input on the shades and how the colors have been working for your skin tone
Hi Sofia, Another great review! I ordered Muse and Cinnabar last week and will receive tomorrow. I like that the shadows in those 2 palettes look more daytime friendly and soft. The palette looks slim for travel also as it is a pain to take a ND or PAT McGRATH palette with you. I also like the replaceable individual colors because so often in a palette I use more of one or two shades and then when they are gone I have to throw the rest out. The sorcery palette look gorgeous, but at my age my a bit over the top and only for evening for sure. I bought the lipsticks with matching pencils in Velvet Rain and Velvet Pompadour. I love her lipstick formula. As far as cost I spend a small fortune on makeup and skincare every year ( I spent over a $1000 on the Sephora sale and that was after 20% discount 😂). All the looks you created are stunning! You are a natural beauty even without makeup. I look forward to your videos so morning and check every morning for your next one.😘
Aw you are so sweet thank you! Yes you have some very good points here about the colors and the packaging being so easy to bring on the go
So I love the purple Muse scene setting "Lisa talked about discovering the look of royalty" followed by "I couldn't help myself, I wanted to go for something smokey and glamorous" followed by "cat walks into scene looking utterly unimpressed by anything human in the last several centuries to present trying to compete with its majesty." Personally I don't go for eyeshadow, but it feels like a nice release for a new brand even with overlap (every brand needs a pink palette). Maybe in the future Lisa could take advantage of the singles by offering "special" one off colors that are shinier or more potent and could be plugged into existing palettes to amp them up for the different customer base.
Hahahahaha 😹😹 Minnie is the true monarch around here
I think special one-off singles is a really good idea!
You convinced me to dip back into the Natasha Denona Lila palette, which seems close to the LE Myth color story. Also the combo of Viseart Violette, Cashmerie, and Bijoulaix. And I really, really appreciate your thorough review. Because I kept staring at the Sorcery palette (which is now out of stock). And fascinated that they are overpriced even for luxury. Plus you made me excited again for that PMG palette…thanks!!
I’m glad it was helpful! I know I wanted to show the Lila palette but before my RUclips days I took it apart to creat a custom palette during quarantine 😂😂😂
I have and love Sorcery but my goodness I need that Velvet Dutchess lipstick. I totally understand what you mean about red lipsticks and think it would be a great unique red for my collection. ❤
Thank you for considering other peoples preferences. It's good to have your own known and discussed as well but some reviewers think their preference is the only standard.
Yes I know 😅😅 don’t want to yuck someone’s yum!
Completely agree! And for considering what might work better for different ages, lifestyles, skintones, abilities etc. I’m a huge fan of her channel because of this!
Thanks so much for the excellent review Sofia. I got my order today and I cannot wait to play with the eyeshadow palettes. Even though the price is ridiculous and the color stories are very much dupable I think I’m going to enjoy these palettes since I enjoy a more soft and sophisticated look.
Love that!! I am excited to give my mom her palette this weekend to head her thoughts also
Okay….the swatches 🤤. Also, your looks are STUNNING!! I love how the purple and the green palette looks on you 😍.
I did like the way that the purple look came out!
I think they all look beautiful on you !! You did a great Job.
Thank you Marie 😘
Hi Sofia !! Yaaassss …you’re amazing! Great review!!! Totally appreciate all your hard work and thorough reviews!! And yes I do dream about makeup!! 😂💕🥰🥰Xx
Thank you 🤗🤗
Your reviews are simply the BEST!!! Thank you for such a detailed review, comparisons and honest opinion. Love the looks 🥰
Thank you Cristiane! 🙌
This is the best, most in depth review on these new LE pallette's I have seen on YT so far! It's really helpful and I liked it! 🥰
Thank you so much 😇😇
I remember you from your hourglass holiday palette review this year! Didn’t subscribe then but after this, I’m sold :)
Welcome!!! 💕💕💕
Let’s be smart with our money! Sofia for the win 🏆 Sorry to hear your eyes got irritated with the myth palette, it was one of the 2 that I was considering after seeing your beautiful eye look but no more. I may pick up the sorcery one, we shall see.Minnie stole the show, she was adorable and wanted to be close to you and I couldn’t stop watching her 😀 Your content is always top notch, unlike any other!
Thank you Isabela 🙏 I think it’s so funny when Minnie just sits there and stares at me 😹
She is boring! Watching paint dry would be better!
I ordered Sorcery, Vega and Cinnabar and am excited to try them out (and Sorcery/Enchantment Lip). I definitely didn't need any of them, but I just love playing with different formulas and couldn't nail it down to a single choice! Lisa doesn't really disappoint in most of what I've tried so far, but agree that you do need to consider personal preference as her line definitely leans more every day 'wearable'. I think my tastes align pretty well with yours - I can go all in for the drama and am not afraid of colour, but it doesn't always fit into my every day, so there's still room for some softer more luxury versions!
Since I ordered I've been eyeing up my Melt Cosmetics Smoke Sessions palette, as I'm fairly sure the top three green shades in the Sorcery palette might find dupes in there, even though it's being touted as the most unique, but hopefully the formula is a bit more forgiving than the Melt. I'm also hovering over the order button to pick a palette up for my mum for Christmas, they are stunning.
Thanks for such a well rounded and balanced review, as always!
I loved reading your thoughts Sophie. I wonder if you could use the Melt palette as a companion palette. I like to use my Viseart matte shadows with palettes like Sorcery that have a lot of shimmers.
What a wonderfully thorough review! Bravo!
Thanks Jennifer!
I also checked my collection for dupes. I notice that if you have all the ND and the divine rose series of PM; you will have those colors and finishes.
It is also worth noting Olivia Palermo’s eyeshadows if anyone is interested with LE’s Sorcery and Vega.
Yes I was thinking the Olivia ones look similar!
👏👏👏 the most thorough review ever!! Thank you!
You’re welcome!!
Myth is STUNNING on you Sofia...you did good!! That's the one I'd be getting if I hadn't just bought the TF Violet Satine quad 💜💜💜
And cute cat behind your shoulder!! 😻
Thank you!!
Another fantastic review, Sofia. Seeing your cat in your videos give me so much joy, it makes me laugh every time! 😸
Hahaha aw thank you 😇 She's so cute when she pops into my background haha
Hi Sophia, thanks for your review! It's so helpful to know more about the formulas/application and what to expect when trying to figure out which one is best for me or not lol. Btw I love seeing your adorable cat in the background❤
I’m so glad!! Haha yeah Minnie is a star 😂
This will probably sound so weird but I saw your comment on Tara Lynn's channel and I was waiting for your review! Really looking forward to your thoughts on this palette, you always have such thoughtful and thorough reviews!
Why thank you Ivy!! 💕💕 Tara Lynn is one of my fave RUclipsrs
Hi Sofia, thank you for this very comprehensive & helpful review video... I may have already ordered all five palettes🙈 I should be getting one of them today... still waiting for the other orders to ship. I love all the eye looks you did and am really looking forward to trying them!🥰
Thank you! I am interested to hear what you think of your palettes!
Wow, such a wonderful and very detailed video, love the looks, comparisons, everything!!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩Bought the light pink toned one and the neutral brown ones, looking forward to them! Thanks for the beautiful video, have a wonderful day!!!!😘😘😘😘😘😘
Thank you Anne Marie!
myth looks great! and love the nails!
Thank you!!
This is such an amazing review! So informative and detailed. All the eye looks that you created were astonishing❤ Thank you for your honesty and wonderful review, this is truly a most in-depth review I could ever imagined
Thank you as always, Antonia 😊😊
Wow - your reviews never disappoint! Thank you for all the time and attention to detail with these palettes. We all love LE and I respect your honest opinion of how you experienced these. One day 1 I bought Muse and Cinnabar as I wanted to softer color stories even though I have similar palettes.
Thank you Shanee!! Tried to be detailed and fair since these are so new!
You create the most beautiful looks
Thank you Maria!!
THANK YOU! I really respect LE as an MUA, but these are just not attractive colors for my look and skin tone. I so appreciate your honest input Sofia!
You’re welcome!!
Your Myth look was my favourite 😍😍! Beautiful!!
Why thank you!! I think that one was my fave also
Love your thorough reviews! Thanks ❤
I just subscribed. Love your review! I love Lisa and am tempted but I am going to hold off for now. I have most if not all of the color stories. In the end I probably will buy one, I am a collector of antique makeup and a succer for a beautiful compact, I’m hoping the sells an empty pallet that maybe I can create my own color story. but I’m going to see what comes out next. Thanks for that Reveiw ‼️‼️
Thanks for subbing! Welcome! Yes you can def wait and slowly collect as I am sure she will come out with the empty palette and some more colors
Excellent thorough review, Sofia! Bravo! Well worth waiting for! I really enjoyed your comprehensive thoughts on Lisa’s eyeshadows. Thank you for your time and effort! It genuinely helps! Warmest wishes ~ Irinka
Thank you Irinka!!
thank you for this. i will wait when an empty palette is available because i want a truly customizable palette.
what a wonderful review and so much info and comparisons! So pleased youtube suggested your channel! I hope you will grow into a huge channel :)
Thank you so much! Welcome to the channel!!
Thank you Sophia, this was SUPER helpful. I did not get any palettes because I'm more of a cream eyeshadow kind of woman but I do love Lisa and I do tend to be tempted by her storytelling. I love the colors but I have similar ones in my collection already. Thank you for this video I really really appreciate your take on Lisa's palettes :)
Thank you so much! Appreciate your comment and glad I could be helpful
BEST, MOST THOROUGH REVIEW EVER! ❤❤❤
Why thank youuuu! 😁
I made the exact same face when I applied Velvet Duchess for the first time! I also picked up Velvet Enchantment, which is (surprise) amazing and beautiful. Great review, like always!!
She really gets me with the lipsticks because I just love that rich, saturated color.
Also, I love top coat shades! I like putting on matt cream shadows and I would love to have just slight transparent shimmers on top. I've got skin tone, light brown, medium and dark brown creams so I'll get loads of use out of those!
Yay Minnie was supervising during the 2nd eye look! Hehe. Ahh I think I’m gonna wait for her future palette releases. None of these color stories for the price really sing to me soul lol. 😸 you did an amazing job on this review, as always! The most helpful review of these I’ve seen. I wish the metallic shades in palettes other than Sorcery were more sparkly!
Thank you so much Holly 😊 haha yes Minnie was very into this release 😂
Wow your look with myth is so gorgeous. I got only sorcery-may need to go back for myth and vega. Great review!
Thank you!!
Wow what an amazingly thorough review! Thank you!
Shame the myth palette didn't work out because it looks so beautiful on you.
I got Vega (wanted sorcery also but i missed out) and I was considering going back and buying all the others but thankfully you talked me out. Thank you for reminding me that I have those colour stores and I don't need them.
P.s. would love to see the sorcery palette compaired to the ND metropolis (if you have it)
I love the metropolis palette! One of my fave palettes ever
All these palettes look stunning on you! After seeing your comparison swatches, I agree with looking pretty similar to others. I ordered the Cinnabar and ca couple of lipsticks. The lipstick I wanted the most was the Sorcery but it sold out very fast. Womp womp. Thanks for the unbiased review! ❤️
Aw nooo! I am going to try and see if I can dupe sorcery because so many people missed out on it. Reminds me of when Velvet Affair sold out. I had to wait for that one 😁
@@SofiaSeesBeauty That would be awesome if you can find a dupe for the Sorcery. I'm a new sub to your channel and I'm enjoying your videos. 😍🥰
Great swatches thanks! This was super helpful. I picked up the cool one and I can’t wait to receive it.
Edit: Oh no I am sorry about the eye irritation. Let us know if it continues.
Yay I hope you love it! 🙂
I couldn't wait for these palettes. But I am very disappointed that there isn't any beige/brown/gold palette. Maybe it's too basic/boring? I was really hoping to finally find my dream "boring brown/gold/beige palette", but it looks like I still have to keep looking...
Haha that’s a good point 🙂 I guess she did the Muse color story instead
Maybe she’ll do those colours for a bronze-leaning summer release? It’s also my number 1 go-to colour story 😅
New here, looking for how to wear these! I bought the same 3 palettes and the sorcery lipstick and liner, which all arrived yesterday, so am diving right in. Thank you, yay!!
Yay welcome Morgan!!
You look amazing in this vid! and your reviews are the best !!
Thanks!! 😝😇
Thank you for the great Review, i can 100% agree on everything you have said and mentioned! But first, i am impressed by your performance with every Palette, every look turned out so so great, I loved your Look with Myth and Sorcery!! Stunning! But i can share your thoughts about the little less "wow Effect", but over all and when you knwo what you are getting with the palettes, they are very nice to me, even if they are not that unique or super special except for some shades. I have the Vega one and feel that there are little diffenences between the two Matte formulas. I love the creamier ones so that is a plus for the Palettes. Thank you so much, loved everything about the Review!! :)
Thank you so much for sharing and for watching!
You did great. Each look is beautiful.
Thanks Mileva!!
Wow what a fantastic in-depth review! I had a feeling these wouldn’t be all that fantastical as far as formula, but when I saw Sorcery it was just too enticing. It was the one I wanted to try. Even still I didn’t pull the trigger on launch day but I went ahead and purchased it yesterday and from what I can tell from reviews I think I’ll be pleased. They are indeed pricey, but as you’ve mentioned she is an Indie brand and higher end so it’s to be expected. I should have been quicker in picking up the Sorcery lipstick as that is such a ME color. I was able to get the lip liner for now.
That’s great! The liners are so so good so you can fill in your lips with the color and mix with other nudes also
Yaaassssss, thank yoooou! You’re the best!
😁👍
Thank u sofia for your generosity...
As always ..perfect review...complete...
Sorcery lipstick seams to be a pinker and cooler version of cinabar...
Thank you Gina! Appreciate your comment
Great video. Lisa’s intro did explain each formula thoroughly, just not with swatches. I picked up one palette and a single of the two formulas not included. Each palette has 3-4 formulas. Muse is the only palette with a lustre. I purchased that individual shade. One more note, the website lists some shade finishes incorrectly. I brought this to Lisa’s team. I am hoping they corrected the info. I also hope that they are correct on the palettes. This was a FAB deep dive. I just subscribed. Love your personality and the comparisons.
Oh that is good to know! I think they may have corrected the site! I felt like she did a good job describing the shades but I was watching and waiting for her to show us on camera 😅 I felt like her video was filmed a bit far too far to see the swatches and application
Excellent work
Many thanks Mary!
My order is currently "out for deliver". So excited!
Soooon!
I really like your review for setting people's expectation. I like that you mentioned how LE is not positioning brand in the highshine bling artistic side but more of the grounded effortless day-to-day look. I think a lot of people go in expecting Pat McGrath's insane party colors but that is not what Lisa is selling at all.
Great review!
Yes exactly! Different styles 🙂
Now I know where to go for reviews. You are an amazing reviewer, thank you! Really appreciate you, I'm not taking the eye shadows. They definitely nothing spectacular at least for me. ❤
Thanks Anna! Appreciate your feedback 😊
Thankyou for a super thorough and honest review as always Sofia 😊 All your hard work really helps us all so much - you have already saved me from making a number of purchases this year that would have been disappointing.
I have ordered myth and sorcery and like many others, I probably should have waited for reviews before buying these but I was completely sucked in by the packaging and beautiful look of the eyeshadows AND FOMO as the hype around these is very real.
I have blond hair/hazel eyes and really love cool and purple tones in general. I do have TF Violet Satine - I can hopefully use this as a companion to myth (and that they are not just dupes).
I am looking forward to playing with sorcery, I don’t have anything at all like this.
Hey Nicole! I know what you mean. A lot of times these releases sell out so fast so we have to panic-buy. I think Violet Satine is probably a bit softer. You’ll have to let me know if you think the formula is similar. I only have the 3 original Creme palettes that Tom launched
I like your spicy take 😂 thanks for the video 😊
😹😹thanksss
I really like the TF Creme’ formula. Naturally I gravitate to the Myth pallet. I am worried that the cranberry color in it may irritate my eyes as well. i had some irritation with the TF Violet. i love the Sorcery Lipstick on you...beautiful! thank you for working so hard to get this video up...great review & beautiful looks👏👏
Thank you Jane!! I think the Sorcery lipstick is my fave thing I got. I love lipstick 😂😂
@@SofiaSeesBeauty It’s my weakness 💄💄💄
Thank you for your detailed review, I am feeling much less alone with my palette ! I bought Sorcery and while the sparkly shade and the antique gold metallic are the standouts and are very pretty, the rest is very underwhelming, the audacity to call the teal matte seamless is unreal, one of the patchiest shades I used and it is not even a matte, it is a cream to powder !
On another note, I picked up the Chanel holiday collection after your review and have been loving it, true luxury experience !
Oh yayyyy! I love it when people end up loving my recs 😅🥰
Excellent and very thorough review. So far I've only seen people gushing about these. I ordered on Friday and received it on Monday (I'm in the UK) so I had a few days to properly test out Myth palette (the only one I ordered). I have similar thoughts to yours on the top coat shade - I expected more impact from it and feel somewhat disappointed. The metallic is more of a shimmer than a metallic. The velvet mattes are very nice, easy to blend with minimum fallout. Overall I think these eyeshadows aren't revolutionary and a bit overpriced, but will definitely appeal to people who are not so crazy into makeup like we are and love luxury.
Thank you for watching! And also thank you for reporting on your thoughts so far 🙌
Love the in depth video. I’ve been tempted by these but I heard that there may be some hefty duty in addition to ship/palette costs when importing them to Canada. I actually think the take away from this video is I might need the Guerlain quad. It’s a surprising conclusion;)
Yay I am glad I could help! Thank you for always watching and commenting Amy
Very helpful!! Yeah, I’m all about the wet-look, foiled, sparklies galore… I probably didn’t NEED to order Myth, but I still love all the colors and will just have to pair it with some Pat Mcrath or something. Excited for it to arrive!
Yes I think you could use a pat McGrath astral shade to top it off!
It sounds like maybe I would love this brand/line/formulas. However, I am not her demographic I don't think. It was hard seeing how they are customizable, but you can't order an empty palette (cry). This is out of my price range, but every once in a while I like to splurge or treat myself with something :) I would have purchased an empty palette, as well as some lipsticks (that velvet enchantment and velvet rain look divine ) had the empty palette been available to fill in. Who knows.. It sounds like the Charlotte makeup may also be something I would enjoy so I may just try that! I am just getting back into wearing makeup, and oh my goodness so many companies and brands now! It's quite exciting!!
I totally understand! Apparently she announced that next year she is going to try and get the empty palettes (yay!)
Hello from Manila, Philippines! Ive been waiting for this. 💕💕💕 Thank you for all that you do!
Hello Sandy!! 🤗
Wow what a great video 👍🏻 Its so helpful, thank you so much 🙂
You’re welcome!
I like your Myth look the most. Your eyes really popped. I think the softer purples could work for everyday 😊
Thank you! When I watched it back I kind of thought the same
Thank you so much for the great review!
My pleasure!
Great video, Thank you ❤
you're very welcome!
I got myth and sorcery…most excited for,the greens!
Nice!! I live the shade Grotto
I completely understand why people are frustrated that she didn't release an empty component. It makes the customizable element untrue seeing as you would need to buy an entire palette. WIth that being said, I have so many magnetic palettes that I can slip any extra shades into those. I know it's not ideal for everyone but it works for me. I picked up two on launch--Vega and Sorcery. Sorcery looks so unique and I do love a cool toned palette so Vega was a shoe-in. I have the rest of the shades in other palettes that I already own so didn't feel the need to pick those up (purples, warm tones, rosy tones). Anyway, can't wait to try her different formulas! I love how much thought she puts into her products. Thanks for the thorough review!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Talya! Vega was definitely tempting 😅
Hi Sofia. Great review and your comparison swatches are very interested. I have 3 of these: muse, cinnabar et myth. It's pretty yes it's pretty BUT I'm a little bit disapointed becaude you don't find colors in pans on your eyelid. I take a dark brown and on my eyelid it's not dark brown it's just light light Brown. I would have liked a little bit of more intensity in eyeshadows like metallics for exemple. Like you if I will have swatched...i won't have bought 3 palettes just 1 I think. It's expensive and I would have an empty palette for personalized it. Je t'embrasse 😘😘😘😘
Severine thanks for sharing your thoughts on your palettes! For my preference, I feel the same way. I like a little more impact
@@SofiaSeesBeauty yes we're agree ! Great review, congratulations et always honnest
Great review, love Lisa Eldridge and these palettes are so beautiful. Thank you for sharing, hope you're well and that you have a lovely holiday season. Best wishes!✨
Thank you! You too!
@@SofiaSeesBeauty Thank you!