Antisemitism and the Qu'ran, Professor Reuven Firestone
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 фев 2021
- “Antisemitism and the Qu’ran”
Professor Reuven Firestone, Regenstein Professor in Medieval Judaism and Islam, Hebrew Union College, Los Angeles; Affiliate Professor of Religion, University of Southern California
Convener: Dr. Navras J. Aafreedi, Research Fellow, ISGAP
Antisemitism in South Asia in Comparative Perspective International Seminar Series
Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021
Muslims (Ottomans) saved some 270,000 Jews from certain death in the hands of the Spanish Christians in the year 1492. Ottoman Turks sent their navy to save them and allowed them full citizenship anywhere within their empire. Except in Jerusalem, where, to prevent religious conflicts, the numbers of the people belonging to the three religions were confined to families to take care of their respective religious shrines.
Fake propaganda. Ottomans never saved anyone. They only ra.ped, murdered, converted by force and took the lands and riches.
Otomans killed Armenians too.
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 Yes but they saved jews because judaism is more smilar to islam
The Qur'an is not anti-semetic it's anti disobedience to God. The history of the Israelites are lessons for all of humanity.
The corrupt israelites were "punished" many times by God, simply because they became corrupted in every sense of the word, they turned their back on their prophets, and went against God's law.
So now we are witnessing another "corrupt" israelites in the form of Zionist. 😊
Disclaimer: Corrupted israelites and righteous jews are different and distinct from each other.
Indeed.❤❤❤
Perfect example of islamic jew hate in this comment. Qoran is not antisemitic but jews are bad cause the qoran says so. Vile dumb islamonazi mentality.
All people are disobedient because all people do good and bad. The difference between Jews and your kind, you ra.pe, beheadings, murderer, thievs, the muslim world is a collection of disobedience starting with warlord mohamad. So you ahmed should look in the mirror to see a sinner. Muslims claiming to be holy is one pile of garbage propaganda. Islam is jew hate. When I look at the muslim world I see complete disobedience to Gd and human life. Muslims should look in the mirror instead of talking garbage about the jews. That's why jews never accepted islam because its garbage compared to Judaism and qoran is a toilet paper compared to the Torah.
There is only one Gd given holly book and its called the Torah. That's why Muslims hate the jews, because only Jews received a revelation from Gd.
@Criketkida yes indeed some donkey from arabia like you thinks he is the holliest man alive but in reality you a a nobody. There was a big difference between Itzhak and Ishmael. Itzhak was like Avraham but ishmael was a ra.pist and a murderer idol worshipper. Mohamad was the same and so are the arabs.
More like anti Satan also known as Allah. Read yoir quran and all the sahab books in their original language or find an honest person to translate for you. Save your soul before it is too late.
As what we know Arab are also Semitic then why we only consider Jews as Semitic not the Arabs as well? Just had a question ?
They are both Semitic peoples. However, what singles Jews out for mistreatment based on their racial characteristics is specifically referred to as anti-Semitism.
@@stephenconnolly1830 when is Arabs or other Semites are also singled out is it anti-Semitism too?
@@Klopp2543it’s anti-Arabism. More like Francophobia or dislike of some other nationality. AntiSemitism is closer to anti-Black racism, and closer still to antiGypsyism. Difference is, Arabs have their own countries whereas Jews until relatively recently did not. And of course the descendants of American slaves and the Roma/Sinai do not.
This is a good question that there is common misunderstanding about. The word “Semitic” refers to a branch of language, and not race or ethnicity. The term was coined specially to refer to racism towards Jews, to give it a more “scientific sounding” name. So while Arabs and Jews are distantly related, Semitic and antisemitic specifically refer to Jews.
@@joshmcneil1086 where you get your sources from saying Arabs and Jews are distantly related? what a joke...Arab and Jews are closely related as they are cousins.
First I would like to thank you. As a Muslim I agree, neither the Quran nor the Hadith promote antisemitism. The hadith you quoted it's about when the second coming of Jesus, were some of the Jews will side with the antichrist against Jesus.
The Quran doesn’t give a broad brush over Jews or Christians and doesn’t single them out without contextualising exceptions. It affirms good tidings to those who are pious, faithful, monotheistic, and worshipful. It protects the priests, the monks, their places of worship even in times of war. And you can’t be a Muslim without believing in the books before, essentially a Muslim isn’t a Muslim if he doesn’t believe in Christianity and Judaism.
Quran references the belief in true monotheistic christianity and Judaism.
Qoran is a cheap poor copy of the Torah mixed with mohamad bi polar character. When he needed jews and Christians to be his allies he wrote gooq about them in the qoran when he wanted to kill them he wrote bad about them. Qoran and islam is a garbage book and ideology
Very balanced lecture by a very knowledgable professor.
As a muslim, I love Rabai Reuben for all his beautiful, meaningful messages
Because he is out of context, and mohammed copied many stories from the Torah and New Testament. You don't call those similarities.
What prophecy did mohammed bring? None of the prophets were like him, neither deeds nor how they lived.
There are many prophecies . Just read the book forbidden prophecies ❤@@jobirbatti6713
Nice lecture and professor Reuven did great job being honest about portraying his understanding of the Quran.
Fantastic Lecture
Professor Reuven Firestone is the best Religious scholar I ever lesson to. If scholars like him increased in number in all Religious communities, the world will be much peaceful .
may the only melekh give paradise rabbi firestone,he is man who has wisdom from the 2 seas meeting
You are the best of the Jewish scholars on islams. However there is much short coming in your knowledge. The hadiths and quaranic verses must be taken in to contexts and when the were revealed and under what conditions they were revealed. The Hadith you read of the trees trllimg the Muslim to kill the Jews are story of the second coming of Jesus and the Jews will side with the dajjal. Much love and respect to you sir and I hope you will look for a mufti and do a bit more research and see if you agree with what I’m saying
This how a knowledgeble person talks. I like this rabi he is so Knowledgeble and respectfull
30:15 , the verse is not repeated in the Quran , and the numbers are wrong , that verse is Surat ( the cow ) number 62, not 69 .
Great lecture from professor Reuven. Totally different from the majority of non Muslim speakers when they describe what is in the Quran
if Allah allows something in the Quran, that means there is no Hadiths or Islamic scholars, who goes against the Quran, we should take into consideration. Whatever goes against the Quran, just ignore it.
⚠The Quranic terminology distinguishes between "the Jews [ Al Yahood] and "The Sons of Israel" [Banu Israel]
⚠"The Jews" in the Quran *applies only to 7th century Arabs* of the Israelite faith,
⚠The "Sons of Israel" *strictly concerns the believers in the divine message of from Jacob, Isaac, Aaron, Moses* may peace be upon them all
⚠Nowhere in the Quran can we find verses addressing Medina Jews as "Banu Israel"
Arabs are also Semitic people, just for those who don’t know yet.
Excellent presentation and discussion! Indeed, superb.
Submission to Allah/Yahweh/Adonai and the benefits that accrue from living "upright" is the heart of it.
The Qur'anic texts show that in a beautiful way seems to me.
The overall message. Submit. Torah.
The Last Day. Righteous living. Grace, Mercy. Justice----All are inherent to both these meaningful semitic monotheistic traditions.
Gotta read yourbooks.
@44:00 concerning the status of Jews under Muslim rule, it is instructive that the Muslim & Christian communities now find themselves 3rd class citizens under Jewish rule (i.e. in Israel).
you've seen Muslims and Christians being burned in the stake in Israel or forced to convert to Judaism in Israel?
Israeli arabs would not swap for anywhere else in the world...equal before the law in Israel...
The Zionist state does not represent Judaism though. It was founded by secular nationalists who considered themselves ethnically and culturally Jewish but were not religious. There have always been religious jews who opposed (continue to oppose) Zionism because it goes against Jewish ethics.
@@petercharles8306your people are brainwashed in Israeli propaganda
Muslims in Christian lands build mosques, practice their faith openly, and distribute Quran in the streets, can Christians return the favor?
When talking about the people of Moses/Aaron, the Quran never uses the term "oh you jews", rather "oh you sons of Israel "
This (stinger) is intended to criticize Islam only.
Quran is not like the interpolated Torah to create hatred between the human creation of Allah, because the Quran is revealed to the whole human beings and the Jins, and this doesn't mean it mustn't speak of the mistakes and the violence they do with our (Muslims) , Jewish messengers.
Please leave creating this differences
How come you show way less respect (and knowledge to the Honored Tawrat) than your own text? Baqara 2;4 do you know better than the Creator who guided the Torah?
When the Jews of Madinah found themselves out manoeuvred and their political position weaker because of the ascendancy of the Prophet and the Muslim community in that city they rebelled. Each of the 3 major Jewish tribes did so in succession without pretext, the last one committing treason by reneging on the pact/treaty/constitution of Madinah which they had signed voluntarily. The religious status of the Prophet was not the key factor in play, unlike the way it is painted according to Rabbi Firestone.
Correct. And a very crucial point.
Guys don’t forget , most of hadis and story of muhammed full of old christiyan converts tray to make make islam better ………
1) I challenge you to present a real example of the jewish tribes of medina "rebelling" against muhumad/muslims.
2) I challenge you to provide evidence that the banu qurayza had a treaty with muslims.
3) I challenge you to provide evidence that the banu qurayza acted against muhumad/muslims.
Hahaha😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@dtrez3866 in Surat El Ahzab, the Cor'an refers to a battle ( El Ahzab) of Moslems (which took place in Medina) against Arab idolaters who came from Mecca and where Banu Kuraidha sided with the ennemi and conspired against the Prophet Mohamed( PBUH).
But the Jews were still waiting for their messiah. The problem for them is that this prophet who could have been the messiah was not from the descendants of David peace be upon him. They forgot that only God chooses where to put his revelations. Also, Jesus was one of them , what was their reaction !
Was Shakespeare an antisemite when he mentioned Shylock as a main character in Merchant of Venice?
A good question. That's why *they BURIED Schylock of The Merchant of Venice under endless plays/movies/cartoons on Shakespeare's Romeo & Juliet*
Very clever, we have to admit
The verse orders Muslims to "fight" [armed men], not "kill".
Who is Semitic? Jews / Arabs.? Or Both? What does Semitic mean? To what community does Semitic refer to ? Will be good if you can define it.Thanks.
Semetic are not people but languages there is about 30 Semetic language like Arabic, Hebrew and Aramaic, antisemitic was used a lot of jews since Europe kept torturing them for 2000 years then it just became a victim card when anyone criticize Israel
In the Quran, the word "jew" meant Arabs of Judaic faith. Whereas, the term "sons of Israel " mostly indicates the people of Moses/Aaron long before Islam.
Id there any reference for this?
@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 Thanks for the interaction. Will answer you soon
@@onlignebridge4224 appreciated.
Next time, please invite Muslim scholars to understand the Quranic context and its meaning, You need to ask Muslim scholars in Quranic studies to understand it. I appreciate the effort but I think everyone agrees if we wanted to know about car engines, don't go to an accountant. The lecture contains so much flawed information.
Having someone outside of your comfort zone creates an opportunity to move away from the 'echo chamber", and promotes growth.
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 Understandable but it's gonna be fruitless discussion with so many misinformation. As I said, would you go to sea the mechanic for your health problem?. Is it justified to make former N*zi officers as the only panel member to discuss H0locaust? Let's be consistent here.
29:42 the verse quoted from AlBaqarah is wrong , its not like that in Qur'ān. Both its arabic and English are written wrong. I have memorized this part of Baqarah. I check it again its wrong .
I don't know from where did they got it.
The actual verse is this
Al-Baqarah 2:62
إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ وَٱلَّذِينَ هَادُوا۟ وَٱلنَّصَٰرَىٰ وَٱلصَّٰبِـِٔينَ مَنْ ءَامَنَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْءَاخِرِ وَعَمِلَ صَٰلِحًا فَلَهُمْ أَجْرُهُمْ عِندَ رَبِّهِمْ وَلَا خَوْفٌ عَلَيْهِمْ وَلَا هُمْ يَحْزَنُونَ
English - Sahih International
Indeed, those who believed and those who were Jews or Christians or Sabeans [before Prophet Muḥammad (ﷺ)] - those [among them] who believed in Allāh and the Last Day and did righteousness - will have their reward with their Lord, and no fear will there be concerning them, nor will they grieve.
Why do Jews claim that People of Ibrahim refers to them? Israel is Jacob who is the son of Issac who is son of Ibrahim. But prophet Ibrahim has also Ismail as a son. So people of Ibrahim is not exclusive to children of Israel
⚠Jews, Christians, pagans or Muslims, the Quran avoids generalizations. In some verses it *glorifies behaviors of the some People of the Book* , and in others it criticizes some Muslims.
⚠The Quran profusely employs phrases such as *"among the People of the Book; among the polytheists. among the believers, among Mankind, some of Jews, some of the polytheists..etc"* as well as *"the majority of ; most of them"*
It’s 2:am and auto play has landed on this recording. Slowly the Rabbi’s voice comes into focus. I start smiling because he reminds me of a high school student who has to give an oral book report, but has only read the book cover. He is making up his own version as he goes along… Hilarious To top it off he sounds like Adam Sandler. 😆😂😅
He’s very educated, though he isn’t Muslims and doesn’t view the Quran the way we do.
Misinterpretation of last :Stones"...
It talks about a future event ,prophecy not a command.
Who the Idolaters and hypocrites are is free to interpretation and therefore not really clear, which leaves us with the naming of one obvious enemy. So even if you reduce Islam teaching to the Quran, you receive an anti-Jewish text.
PBUU
أَلَمْ يَأْنِ لِلَّذِينَ آمَنُوا أَن تَخْشَعَ قُلُوبُهُمْ لِذِكْرِ اللَّهِ وَمَا نَزَلَ مِنَ الْحَقِّ وَلَا يَكُونُوا كَالَّذِينَ أُوتُوا الْكِتَابَ مِن قَبْلُ فَطَالَ عَلَيْهِمُ الْأَمَدُ فَقَسَتْ قُلُوبُهُمْ ۖ وَكَثِيرٌ مِّنْهُمْ فَاسِقُونَ (16) سورة الحديد
Problem is: there are TWO BOOKS that Islamic people sees as holy (The Quran and Ahadith) ..anything goes depends of what verse from what book they decide to use as a base for their actions and daily interactions. So yeah, you as academic scholar can conclude that Quran is not antisemitic, but at the end its the Muslim's personal views that turns into real actions.
I feel that rabbi is very knowledgeable and informed personal ,however, I really surprised that he took verses of chapter 9 literally and offensive without considering its context.
They should teach about anti arab racism thats in Isreal
Sabi were Jews who embraced John the Baptist (Yohanna / Yahya), but not Jesus (Yeshu / Isa)
Why are you wasting your intellectual, theological talent in RUclips then!😂😬
Aws and Khazraj were the two feuding tribes, some of the three Jewish tribes sides with one side of the other but also external Arab tribes like Bani Tamim allied with some of the Jewish tribes.
The turning point came when some of the Jewish tribes reneged on the treaty and sided with the invading Meccans.
Why does Quran sounds like Torah in condemning the arrogant jews? Rabbi Shalom, I am Muslim. Do you think of prophet Muhammad S.A.W as a true prophet but for the gentiles?
Why do you only mention the times Jews who fell into idolatry are mentioned? What about the beautiful stories of victory, covenant renewal, and love between God and his people? Rear the Torah for its own sake, it's a master piece.
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740
That is also mentioned in the Quran
A world without the three Abrahamic religions would be a more peaceful and less violent world.
Enough said.
The biggest murderous genocides and mass murders in human history were all done by secular atheist regimes
You fail
There is no need for inclusivity here since all three Jews, Christians and Al Mua'minoon are all Muslims in the eye of the one God. so the question is a false one..
Remember there is only one religion since there is one God but there are different Milla's .... The definition of a Milla is one group of people who do their rituals in one particular way in their house of worship.
There is no Anti-Semitism is Islam but there is such thing with the Al Mua'minoon who do not understand their very own Quran". Most of the Figh and hadiths are false and human made and are NOT holy thus cannot be follower....
The big 3 worship Abraham's god, that is undisputed..My problem Abraham's god is a POS murderer, demanding blood sacrifice,bipolar, jealous, vengeful, god that permits liars,thieves, invest from the characters we've been presented with...It's All made up fairy tales gruesome like Little red riding hood.... religion was created to control and divide look at these big 3 religions waring and hating on each other😮😮😮😮😮😮😮 it's all BS .. What do you think Noah was doing to his grandson that his son's had to cover up their fathers sins???
I am a follower of Jesus and would like to have the freedom to define myself in the way I believe God appointed for mankind
Surat Al Maidah 5:32-33 "Because of that, We decreed upon the Children of Israel that whoever kills a soul unless for a soul or for corruption [done] in the land - it is as if he had slain mankind entirely. And whoever saves one - it is as if he had saved mankind entirely. And our messengers had certainly come to them with clear proofs. Then indeed many of them, [even] after that, throughout the land, were transgressors. Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment,"
Professor, you might have forgotten this part.
the Quran lacks context for that you need to read it in light of the Hadeeth. Muhammad tried to win the Jews over but when he was rejected his tone changed.
⚠Some Medina Jews allied themselves militarily to Meccan pagans and tried to act as a Trojan horse despite their signature of a joint defense treaty with the prophet Muhammad.
⚠Did you know this?
By definition Semitic people or Semites is a term for an ethnic, cultural or racial group associated with people of the Middle East, including Arabs, Jews, Akkadians, and Phoenicians.
So when you say anti semitic
You mean anti all the above
The topic should be action and reaction
As a Muslim I would like to thank Prof. Reuven Firetone for the good lucture, but I would like to attract his attention to the 2 Hadiths he showed at 46:00. These 2 Hadiths talk about signs of the nearing of the day of judjment, which means after the return of Jessus, when the Israilets, and christians accept him and leave the changed scriptures in their hands and follow him. Those who remain and insist to disbelieve the Quran, the Injile, and the 2 prophets Jessus and Muhammed will not be considared people of the book afterwods. they will be considared the enemies of God and will be faught against.
In no mean does these 2 Hadiths refer to the jews of the prophets time, nore the Jews of noadays. I belive that we all agree that when Jessus come back and people see the proofs he presents and accept him, all the others should be considared disbelievers. They are called Jews in the two Hadiths because they akeep deferentiating themselves by calling themselves Jews rather than Musims, stick to their own relegion, and refuse the 2 messengers Jessus and Muhammed. In the Taurat any people refusing a prophet who has authority are punnished harshly.
The two hadiths do not mention christians, probably it is a sign that the christians will all believe when Jessus returns, or they will becom extinct befor that day. The hadiths also send an indication that human beings will have the means of making rocks send signals about people close to or hiding behind them, or perhaps will have a device which can see through rocks, by which they will be able to see the jews hiding behind the rocks. Again I remind you the term Jews in the 2 hadiths refer to those who will deny Jessus when he comes back.
So, we are named in your scriptures the People of the Book and the People of the Injil once, meaning that God gave us that name. But I am supposed to blindly accept two hadith and Muslims who claim that they know better than God and us and we are the People of the NON-Book... nowhere in the 30-plus references in the Quran to the Tawrat, Injil or Zaboor we are told to ditch our text. Judge for yourself who should we follow?
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 You are ordered to follow the books which the prophets revealed, not the books you rite and clame they are the words of God.
The word of God does not change.
@@Urarto Yes, amén the Honored injil, Tawrat and Zaboor that we have between our hands and so are you Baqara 2:4
@@Urarto your message is rather aggressive and uninformed. What do you know about me?
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 By "You" I mean People of the book. Not you personally. I meant that the books the Quran talks about are the books as the messengers received them not the changed books you have in your hands nowadays.
Are you already an imam or in the process of converting to islam? If not, tell them the truth.
30:21 bookmark
It is evident in western theological academia a generalisation of apocalyptic prophecy generalisation by over association of Christian and Moslem prospectives regarding this phenomena.
Although the statement of the following is near linguistically identical “ The difference between me and the hour is like these my two fingers while the announcer raises both index and middle fingers raised together’ is attributed to both Jesus and prophet Mohammad, one in the New Testament and another in the Hadith. Also the verse in the new testaments of Jesus telling his disciples that Gods kingdom is coming in this your generation’. And Mohammad rushing to prayer of solar eclipse fearing that the hour had arrived ( Kingdom come ), whereby some further considerations should be also brought to view. When we want to consider that Jesus isn’t erroneous we can value that Jesus said it in Aramaic the translation transfer of odium could have dis-included the objective meaning and dropped the need for the word “even”. In other words the Greek script should have been the following “ Kingdom will come even for this your generation. As for the Hadith that recounts that Mohammad rushed to have the solar eclipse prayer fearing that the hour had arrived ( kingdom come ) it isn’t part of the Moslem official Canon, not being multi source attested and of identical text ( Mutawatir). Despite that another Hadith of higher authentication called ‘when is the hour’ stating that Jibreel descended close to Mohammad, and Mohammad asked him when is the hour? Jibreel answered: the inquired ( Jibreel ) isn’t more knowledgeable on it than the inquirer ( Mohammad ). Also the Ayas Chapter Nazi’at 43, and 44: * they ask you when is the hour when will it anchor ( happen ) * in what are you from its knowledge (?)* ( you not having its knowledge ). Also that the concept of ions is brought in the Qur’an in Aya Alnaba’e 23: *staying in it for ions*, also many Ayas in the whole Qur’an which states *….eternalised in it forever*, both Ayas having equivalent meaning, should clarify to us the misconception of equating both concepts of inevitable and imminent apocalypse.
1 difference between u and I .
Upto infinity
No meaning to research bcoz
At the point you start u will be back at that point don't waste time
Prayers 5times and read quran pak
Direct without any think
I don’t see how the rabbi could claim to be a scholar of Islamic text and be using such a terrible English translation for his analysis and to the extent he uses Arabic, he is making mistakes in his reading of Arabic throughout the video.
Sound like a rather puny critique, what about engaging his arguments and lifting the bar to an intellectual level?
The withdrawel of jews was not on religious. matter
But on political. Agremente
Anti s emetic understanding come from christiyan converts and fake hadis from them ……….
Intersting and very good lecturer indeed
I only want to clarify 2 points
1. Wer in Quran has a condition that the other party start aggression and i qute
'And fight in the cause of Allâh those who fight and persecute you, but commit no aggression. Surely, Allâh does not love the aggressors
So if peapole of the Book starts aggression the war will ended with them paying Gizya as a bunshiment
Scound the verse about killing the idolaters, it has a context, they are form Quarish , the prophet tirp, while thet had a truth with th Muslims, they killed some in Makka , so the Quran give instructions to lunsh full scale war , yet when the muslems army enter Makka no blood werw spoiled
Thanks for the great content
False. 9: 5 and 9: 29 are both verses which permit offensive warfare.
9: 5 Then when have passed the sacred months, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and seize them and besiege them and sit (in wait) for them (at) every place of ambush. But if they repent and establish the prayer and give the zakah then leave their way. Indeed, Allah (is) Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
9: 29 Fight those who believe not in Allah and the Last Day and do not forbid what Allah and His Messenger have forbidden -- such men as practise not the religion of truth, being of those who have been given the Book -- until they pay the tribute out of hand and have been humiliated.
The topic and it’s key concept are baseless. The real and meaningful thesis is truth and ant-truth, not any races. There is always a pair of action and reaction, denying either of them and promoting the other is illogical.
⚠The Quran has multiple scenarios to deal with the oppressors:
⚠Offering *asylum to peaceful pagans* [read The Repentance/verse 6]
⚠Not fighting those *who don't kick Muslims out of their homes or don't ally themselves to the enemies* [Read The Repentance/verse 4]
⚠Fighting *armed men* ]strictly] in battle fields [The Repentance/verse 5].
Excellent talk.
"References to Jews in the Qur'aan" shown at the beginning, there is one name that referrers to Jews: 8 times the definite noun Al-Yahuud اليَهُودُ, and its nisbat = adjective denoting descent or origin or reference, Yahuudiyy one time, and verbally: allaḏiina " Haaduu " الَّذِينَ هَادُوا = those who Judaised or those who became Jews, 10 times according to the list.
Yahuud refers to the faith, not to the racial!
Aḥaadiiṯ أَحَادِيثُ (singular: Ḥadiiṯ حَدِيثٌ) are troubled hearsays of men's talk (whether considered sound or unsound) written down that have absolutely no connections, directly or indirectly, to Nabiyyu-Llaahi and Rasuulu-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ!
Sir True Muslim will never be anti Semitic but pseudo Muslims may have had antisemitic
At 26:00 Sura 9, GOD is talking about Jews and Christians who do not believe in GOD and do not follow their own scriptures, it's like they are Jews and Christians just by name, but they do not care about GOD, so they deserve to be humbled,
According to GOD the religion is one which is submitting to GOD (Islam), Jews, Christians and the new believers after Muhammad are all submitters (Muslims) and any one of them do not respect GOD he deserves to be humbled, that looks fair to me.
Many Quran verses compliment some jews and Christians.
Many Quran verses reproach or even admonish some Muslims. This is a not well known fact about the Quran.
One thing is clear the Qur'an is more inclusive than the Bible or the Torah.
Ephesians 2:14-18 New Century Version (NCV)
Christ himself is our peace. He made both Jewish people and those who are not Jews one people. They were separated as if there were a wall between them, but Christ broke down that wall of hate by giving his own body.
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740actually Christ says he only came for the lost sheep of the Jews, example he did not cast the demons out of the cananite women as she was not Jewish.
@@BambinoGambino1 Have you read the Gospels even once? The Jesus of the Gospels and the one you described are two different persons. Jesus came FIRST to the lost sheep of Israel. 2- At birth the angels announced that he was bringing Peace on EARTH, not to Jews only. 3_ Jesus healed the daughter of the Canaanite women, 4- reveled himself as Messiah to a Samaritan (non-Jew) and ministered to her whole community, and 5- healed the men in Capernaum (a roman city) and the servant of a roman centurion, Shall I go on? I encourage to read the Gospels and see how amazing is the life of the Messiah
Proof? More than Genesis 3:12 that announced that every family on earth would be blessed? More inclusive than the angels who said the Messiah was bringing Peace on Earth and Goodwill to men? More inclusive than every language, trien and people as portrayed in Revelation? Have you ever read the Bible to make such a statement?
Be Muslim to Please The God ALLAH Almighty
Folloe Jesus and get eternal life
Well ... This is fairly convincing but, objectively, Islam is not really as focused on the Quran as they like to claim. Sunni jurisprudence (but also twelver Shia) is based so much more on the hadith. And then there's the simple fact that the religion is so deeply entangled in a medieval empire based on conquest and subjugation - a civilization that is now both collapsed and stuck in it's own past - that the antisemitism is "baked in" to Islam. I dare say, much more so than Christianity (and I have no particular love for Christianity either.)
I have tried to reason my way out of this conclusion for a couple years feeling it must be unfair. But there's always another Hadith or another Islamic scholar who pops up and, once again, has written something antisemitic.
I have only found little corners of hope in the Islamic world - the modern Ibadis are surprisingly known for interfaith and inter-ethnic tolerance. The Nizari isnailis have departed from orthodoxy in the past couple centuries because their imamism tradition allows for heavy abrogation of past religious law. And the Ahmadiyya sect embraces a message of universal love and tolerance. But these are small sects - marginal.
I wish I could be more positive.
⚠Surprisingly for some people, *the Quran in verse 6 of Chapter The Repentance offers asylum to pagans if they claim it*
You forgot to put what happened after they reject Islam...
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 Hi Gabriela. The Quran has *multiple scenarios to deal with the oppressors* One of them is offering asylum to peaceful pagans and not fighting the idolators who do not kick Muslims out of their homes like in Gaza, Myanmar. Read verse 3 of chapter The Repentence.
@@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740 Forget the Quran for a while. Do you know who initiated the first 3 battles in the history of Islam ?
The Meccan pagans. 3 wars in 5 years.
They each time travelled some 50 miles to attack the new Muslims who found refuge in Medina.
The names of the battles are : Badr, Uhud, and the Trench .
How should normal people react to the pagan hordes? Give them cookies ?
@@onlignebridge4224 I’m familiar with Islamic history and the wars of Uhud, Badr and also the raids on the pagan caravans. Since I hope to create a solid conversation I will ignore the cookies comment … so the question is shall they defend themselves? The answer is yes. If you are familiar with the Torah you will find laws concerning wars so that even then the believers would act ethically.
@@onlignebridge4224 I’m familiar with those ayats. I see the need to make a distinction though between defending your land and home as Palestinians do right now and violence in the name of God over those who refuse to accept Islam or those Muslims who want out of Islam as brother Rachid and are told by an exCatholic converted to Islam that he should be killed according to the shariah. What happened there with no compulsion in religion ?
47 minutes
If the Hadith that says killed Jews hiding behind a stone is problem then many verses of the Torah where Hashem told the children of Israel to kill children and infants is a greater problem. The Hadith is talking about what will happen during a war that we still don’t know when it’s coming. Torah has two sets of laws, one for Jews and the other for foreigners living among the Jews. A Jew who stole should be made to pay what he has stolen back but a non Jews can get a capital punishment for the same offense.
reference?
No one will help you do your homework so look for references in public domain. Google is a good source just type kill infant and women and see results. Also google rabbi Yosef Mizrachi , he is one of the few rabbi who quotes the Torah as it’s.
I have never heard this ??? @@gabrielaprofetaphillips1740
BISMILLAHIRRAHMANIRRAHIM
I very much appreciate what you are doing and I am pleased.
Thank you.
However the real problem that is causing the antisemitism is that the Muslims don't realise that we are living in a polytheists ' world and we are living in polytheism.
Let me explain !
CONSTITUTION IS A RELIGION.
----------------------------------------------------- Constitution is a Religion.
---------------------------------------------
Always written by a forefather or ( s ) of a Nation. Or mainly copied by a father of a Nation from an existing and available another Nation. Which always excludes God and His Words and His Revelations. It is SECULAR written laws but not necessarily deny the existence of God. In fact the practice of the prayer and those practice of worship that are related to prayer in a place of worship are allowed but not the laws of legal matters pertaining to acts of Economics and relationship and inheritance and marriage and military.
So it is a way of life and thus it is a Religion.
----------------------------------------------------------
Especially the Islamic Revelations that deal with the above issues are much different to many Western Constitutions which have influenced the Muslim World. They contradict each other. So then there arise the question of which to choose. It is a war between faith × hypocrisy and polytheism.
The Glorious Qur'an calls it "SHIRK " : THE PARTNERSHIP TO GOD. and the people practice it are " MUSHRIKS " or " MUSHRIKOON " . : They are ASSOCIATORS TO GOD ; PARTNER GODS ; IDOLATORS.
Such is the example !
In the name of Allah, The Beneficent, The Merciful :
Romans , Chapter 30 , Revealed at Macca by the Holy Spirit ( Angel Gabriel ) to the Prophet Muhammed a.s peace be upon him, in the early 7th century ;
30. So set thy purpose ( O Muhammad a.s.) for Religion as a man by nature upright - the nature framed of Allah, in which HE hath Created man . There is no altering the laws of Allah 's creation. That is the right Religion. But most men know not -
31. Turning unto HIM only ; and be careful of your duty unto HIM , and establish worship, and be not of those who ascribe partners unto HIM ;
32. Of those who split up their Religion and became schismatics , each sect exalting in its tenets .
The Glorious Qur'an
Secularism is the split up
And
The Political Parties are the sects
And
Results in democratic elections are a win for their tenets .
WE ARE LIVING IN POLYTHEISM AND IN A POLYTHEISTS ' WORLD .
MUSLIMS ARE UNAWARE OF THIS.
------------------------------------------------------------
And unfortunately they are antisemitic.
That is the real problem causing antisemitism.
------------------------------------------------------------
Mmmm Shemite/Semite mmmm not Hamite.
Arabic a Semitic language.
Now do the Talmud, scrutinizing for general misanthropy please
Nothing Abrahamic about Islam.
What similarities are you talking about? It's copied and plagerized.
Is there anywhere in the quran that tells you what Israel or bet Israel means?
And what's the meaning?
It's annoying when you talk about Abraham, jacob, solomon, and all and check if the stories are related at all.
Unbelievable.
I don't believe belligerence towards individuals Jews has any legal basis in Islam. The Qur'an allowes marriage to Jews and the Qur’an says Allah has put love among a married couple. Prophets Muhammad's anger and reaction to his other wives when they called Safiya a "daughter of a Jew" in jest tells a lot. Even ridicule of a Jew on the basis of race is not sanctioned. One must also be cognizant of the "generalist" references in Quran and hadith. When it says "Yahudi" it doesn't necessary mean ethnic Jew but possibly adherents of Judaism. When it says "they say Uzair is son of God", I don't believe it's a blanket reference to all Judaists. See also how the Quran juxtaposes "Yahudiyan" and "Nasraniyan" (Christian) in reference to Abraham, saying he was neither. These are possible issues the professor should explore and possibly guide on improved rendition of words arising from mistranslations. I would be pleased if he takes the matter up with Darul Salaam publishers of hadith in English.
If Islam is considered as one of the semitic religions how one can even say that Quran is anti-semitic?
The question itself is oxymoron.
This is s fairly silly statement. Antisemitic became a word in Germany first where it was used for many decades to refer only to hatred against Jews. It does not refer to the other, earlier meaning of the word "semitic"
This is how words work in all languages. They acquire meaning through use over time.
Now please. Stop being obtuse.
(Did you know "obtuse" originally didn't mean thick-skulled and dull-witted. But now it does! How's that for another example!)
he should talk about antisemitism in the bible too. God was not kind towards the Jews in the bible because of their transgression and disobedience.
Non-sensical statement.
Before you speak the WORDS OF GOD....read, and understand them.....Quran is the third and last message of God, to humanity, his creation...it is the confirmation of the First message, the Torah, brought by OUR first messenger, Moses, the second being the Bible, brought by our second messenger, Jesus, and the last, being the Quran, by our Prophet Mohamed....The Quran , stresses, that we make NO DIFFERENCE between the messages....especially the laws of God...obviously, and we Muslims, consider all books ours, and prophets, EQUALLY OURS, otherwise, deviating from the words of God...now, that s FOR GOD S MESSAGES, AND MESSENGERS..lwe are ordered to live with the people of the book, in the perfect manner....
Don't read, wrongly the words of God to people and say, here is what....
NOTHING SAYS ANYTHING DIFFERENT FROM THE LAST PRECEEEING SENTENCE...period....
2 of the Twelve Tribes of Bani Israel ( House of Yacub/Yacub) Did NOT Enter the Promised Land, but Sayed in Arabia ( Mt Sinai IS I'm Arabia & Moses MARRIED & had 2 Sons with his MIANITE Bedouine Wife ( Midian 1 of the 6 more Sons born to Abraham After Sarah's Death & he Married Keturah ( Many Jewish Scholars BELIEVE Hajer Changed her Name to Keturah & had 6 MORE Sons with Abraham. *Abraham had 8 Sons. ( Not Only IshmaEL & Issac). Moses remained yhe Arabian Peninsula Until the Mount of Configuration with Moses, Elijah & lord Jesus Met Together Showing the Unity of the Prophets as Brothers & Members if the SamecFAMILY (Father Abraham)s Family) .GOD'S RELIGION ONLY 1 RELIGION. Moses Married & had Sons with the Bedouin Arabians. The 2 Jewish Tribes that Remained in Arabian Peninsula gave Muhamad a bit of Trouble. Muhammad Married a Jewish woman She had Feeling of bit of discrimination. He Told her: " You are a Daughter of Moses & a Wife of the Prophet" *High & Nobel Spirital STATUS of Great RESPECT
This has many holes, Ketura is NOT Hagar, be Torah refers to them as concubines (plural) thus there was more than one person. Moses remained in the Arabian peninsula? Moses was taken after death by God to heaven. God gave us one way of life, not a religion called Islam. At the transfiguration, God spoke of the superiority of Jesus, to whom the Law (Moses) and the Prophets (Elijah) were pointing to. The flattening of such revelation to the unity of prophets is to impose an outside lens to the clear story..
How can we trust any rabbi or priest or iman though? They are all actors cosplaying religion. All their scriptures came from the same scripture writing industry. Interesting topics sure but calling yourself a rabbi or priest or imam is narcissistic idiocy.
Judaism Says that humanity...must be.... his slave.....the enemy of the humanity ....his name is judaism...for ever
these haddith that mentions end of time and Jesus will come back are not true, they go against the Kuraan. As well as Jewish as second class citizens, Allah said if you judge between "PEOPLE" judge fairly, emphasize on the word People, not Muslims Jews Hindus Buddhist Christians...etc.
Wonderful session
One main point cleared
that Quran didn't order to kill the Jews in the Quran , the Hadiths do
Where ? False statement
@@manaratalumni6567he literally says it's in ahadith not Quran you 🤡
@@manaratalumni6567it's the famous Hadith that refers to the Gharqad tree. It's extremely well known. The PLO even quoted it a couple months ago in a press release.
@40:52 There is no prohibition for Muslim women to marry non-Muslim men, except in the case of pagans/polytheists. However, because of the possibility of tensions set up in a marriage between a Muslim woman and non-Muslim man it is not recommended. The Rabbi seems to be reflecting a particular, but by no means exclusive, legal opinion. But this is incorrect as well as being a partial/outdated view.
The only thing her promised is Muslim man marriage the people of the book woman but not other why their is prohibition to Muslim women marriage non Muslim man
Muslim women are not allowed to marry non Muslim men. Period Do not talk without knowledge.
Note that.... The Jews as well as the Christians ARE also Muslims by Quranic definition and thus Jews as well as Christians should be able to marry Muslims women . Remember that a Muslim is one who believes in the absolute oneness of God and the belief in the day of judgment and does good things ( the 10 commandments).
Islamic Figh is what is bad ever sine the mid 8th century and needs to be re written. So many false human opinions of what's in thee Quran
Nonsense
From what speak you !???
You are wrong it is not permitted (haram) for a Muslim women to marry anyone but a Muslim man (however if she does it is just a sin) as a Muslim man it is haram to marry anyone outside of the children of the book (Christian, Jewish, Muslim)
any conversation with any topics , just he wants to be professor for nothing , he said no revelation after bible canonization , who put this great principal ? you ? who are you to judge the revelation of God ? and who told you that Bahia's are true religion which were invented by British colonization , and who told you that Abraham was Jewish ? AlHamdulellah Muhammed peace be upon him showed us the truth , there is no true religion except Islam the religion of God , and the religion of Ibrahim and his sons , jews invented judaism , christians invented christianity , these are false religions taken from islam , there is NO true religion except islam , the people of the book who were mentioned in Holy Quran are the muslims who reverted from false religions ( judaism and christianity ) , Allah told the prophet to ask them about the stories of revelation of Quran if they are as they knew them or not cause he first time to know about these stories so your doubt gone , and know that you are messenger from Allah , YOU professor unfortunately BIG LIAR . sorry for that , but this is my opinion .
The Quran makes no sense. Lol.
Lol explain why
I'm inclined to think you don't have much more to say than the above ...
Be Muslim
It makes no sense to the deaf, dumb and blind.
Did you read it give it a shot read
@@samboy90 Well said. Comments like what @carmela Barujel said reflects more on herself than the subject she wants to insult.
When Were Jews Black Africans
How Muslims react to Baha'i is not comparable with Jews to Islam.
1: Muhammad s.a.w spoke his people language to bring revelation for his people. It is fundamental principle because his message must be understood by his people. Every messenger spoke his people language.
2. Muhammad s.a.w spoke to Jews and Christians because he only conveyed what Allah will speak to them. Muhammad s.a.w did not know who dzul qarnain, ashabul kahf (seven sleepers), Gog and Magog are. Jews knew them better. Jews have intimate relation with them instead of Arab. We know there were many Jews live in Arabia [around Mecca and Yathrib) and spoke Arab.
3. The new prophet after Muhammad s.a.w will oppose the Qur'an itself, but we can not prove the coming of Muhammad s.a.w oppose the previous books. Qur'an says the previous books even mention the coming of last prophet.
So, what Baha and Ahmadi spoke? Did their people know them well as truthful men?