Did weight loss affect Kelly Clarkson's voice? (vocal comparison | E3 - G5 - Eb6)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 июл 2024
- I didn't make any appointment, just want y'all to say your opinions.
00:00 Intro
00:13 Low notes
01:04 Belted/mixed notes
07:08 Upper register
08:44 Outro 
Видеоклипы
Her upper belts seem so much easier for her now and they’re a lot fuller!
yess
I feel like they’re less full but more effortless
Yes they are not so full any longer but it is still good! @@vocaleditz9483
Apart from the weight and the thickness of her voice, both slay, I love some chesty mid belts but also effortless high notes. Both Kelly’s slay ☝️🛺
“juicy” LMAO
Her voice is overall lighter, which will cause her to have more agility, more ease on the upper belts sounding a little headier in her mix, but also is gonna make her lower register sound "weaker" cause it has less volume although the support sounds unaffected
yess
Her voice is phenomenal.
she’s insane
@@doctorits Top 5 best performer of this era.
@@YDVDNVRR YES
Seemed like heavier Kelly's heart was crying out in her vocals with some unspoken burden and sadness, but she kept on with a brave smile for years. "Mine" spilled the tea.... jmho
divorce is never easy 🥺
Her voice is incredible!! Before the weight loss and still! ❤❤❤❤
yess 😍
maybe this is just by chance but her vibrato sounds a lot more even and consistent now!
i noticed it too, more controlled. maybe because of the possible xmas broadway she’s working
she slays everything omg
thank you 🫶🫶🫶
Kelly Clarkson will always be our favorite high soprano no matter what changes to her voice are had.
Also her range especially her belts are effortless, you can tell she starts to shine in the 5th octave. It’s insane!❤ also the F5 in her Florence + the machines cover is insane!
yeahh, vocal beast 😍😍
She slays every note ever but I think the weight loss made her tone so pure and clean it’s insane. Still amazing omg her high notes are unmatched. 😮
yeahhh 😍😍
She’s sounded incredible all along, regardless of her weight! 💙 There was someone last night that commented that she doesn’t have a great range and I’m like oh wow, you have no clue what you’re talking about hunny. 🤦🏼♀️
she has one of the widest ranges ever
I know! That person has probably heard like one or two of her hits and that’s all, I’m guessing. People really shouldn’t weigh in when they don’t know what they’re talking about. 🙄
@@kendrabryant4738 EXACTLY
I love Kelly in all her shapes and sizes.
One thing I only see is a woman just standing there, will not take even a single step but will continuously blow my mind.
What a supreme vocalist.
It's really amazing how her instrument just fits right into every song she sings.
yess
Her voice is just SOOOO PLEASANT TO MY EARS 😍😍😍❤️❤️! What a vocal monster ! She is ridiculously gooood !
yess
Yayyyyyyy I’ve been waiting on this video!!!!!!!!
I would’ve said yes instead of yay but I didn’t want confusion lol😂😂
hahaha thank youu
Just Damn ! God has blessed that girl with a voice that transcends reality !❤❤❤❤❤
Her upper register is more resonant recently than before and she feel more at ease hitting all those high notes. Regardless of her weight, she still amazing vocally!!! Thank you for this!!! Don't mind those haters!!!
yess, thank you 🫶🫶
They all sound like Kelly Clarkson
she is kelly 😭😭
Lmfao this comment has me rollin 😂😂😂😂
Crazy stuff
I would never know
Wow this really does highlight the difference! Less tightness / more fullness/depth/fluffiness to the quality of the notes now! Such a powerhouse always though 🥹
yess 😍
There are pros and cons in this. I think it makes the high notes sound more effortless. But the heavier sound before gives me more sense of heartbrokenness, the lighter voice now gives me more chills and using less chest voice makes it smoothier but less impactful because of the strength.
yess
Hi I love your videos I always get so excited when I see new ones pop up! I saw her live this past august in vegas and of course she didn’t disappoint! I was hoping we’d get to hear some of her 6th octave and we did! Anyway she sounded amazing before and she sounds amazing as ever now too. Tysm for your content❤
she’s always been a powerhouse 😭😭
It really does effect her voice... especially her upper belting registers
nice appointment
If anything it's easier for her
Umm I would say it's mostly a technique change for her that corresponded with when she decided to lose weight. I don't really hear a noticeable change in her actual vocal chords. Besides her first pregnancy in 2014 and her voice deepening in 09' I don't think she's had that many physical changes to her voice despite how much her weight may have fluctuated.
yeah, not a BIG DIFFERENCE. i noticed that her speaking voice is higher too, it was lower before the strike
Skinny Kelly took away the heavy sound of her belts, it’s giving “Honda Civic Tour Kelly” and I’m sooooo here for it!
LOL yess
She has some great mid belt moments past weight lost, I wouldn't say she lost anything or that much has changed aside from her upper belts getting seemingly cleaner and easier. She sounds great in both states !
yess, i think her D5s and C#5s are more resonant too
What I notice is she’s getting better in every song she sing no matter she lost weight or not…she win AI for a reason…she’s the vocal beast❤️❤️
@@appreciatethevocals7393 yess
It is a bigger difference then I thought! She had a more full, round tone before. Now it is more sharp and distinctive. She is still the best Singer in the World but she loses against herself before!
Interesting to get the comparizon like this and hear how big difference it is!
Kelly really said “supporting upper belts is for skinny people” 💀
LMAO I CAN’T 😭😭
I feel like this has been evident with not just kelly but also demi, christina, and a couple other singers who have more weight fluctuations. Idk if it has more to do with diaphragm engagement breathing.
yess
Great 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
thank you 💗💗
Her voice is incredible at any weight BUT it’s even better when she’s healthy, because her breath support is so much more effortless and that makes it easier for her to sing tbh
yess
I’m not gonna say weight doesn’t effect our vocal mechanism but to what extent is completely debatable. Her diaphragmatic breathing could be affected but not usually. If she wasn’t getting winded just standing up it wouldn’t have affected her singing most likely. But what ABSOLUTELY effects the voice is stress and the hormones it causes the body to produce. Fatigue and or sleep deprivation caused by stress. Not giving herself enough self care time including sufficient vocal rest time needed for recovery from chord over use via singing and talking. Which can be made worse if she happened to cry more than once for longer than a few minutes. I think the real test people should do is listen without watching and try to guess which version of Kelly you’re listening to. I think nobody wants to admit to themselves that we have some visual/aesthetic biases that are playing at least a small role in opinions on which version sounds better.
Without video nobody would be able to hear a difference
yess
Her voice is amazing regardless of her weight..
yes it is
Losing weight has made her upper belts a little brighter and less raspy and she seems more agile but that’s it. Don’t think it affected her that much.
i think she’s more agile now too
The whole voice seems to have lost some body everywhere, she has less presence the 3rd octave (especially lower than G3) and her falsetto seems to be thinner and more hooty. Her middle voice seems to be more rounded however and less throaty(raspy*) and more agile it seems. Extending into the higher middle is also evidently easier and more present.
Vocally speaking, when people lose weight, their vocal track also gets a bit more shallow. This causes them to sound a bit different.
yess
Nice, I like Kelly. Glad that she got control of her thyroid issue and lost the weight. She sounds fantastic and continues to be one of my favorite singers.
she sustained lower ranged notes better when she was heavier & her upper belts are better sustained now that she’s lost weight but her falsetto sounded better when she was heavier imo
😭😭
I think her voice sounds lighter now.
yess
She sounds better now
It seems that "now" is more effortless
yeahh
7:41 do you know what the other note here is? This is the polyphonic note, right?
B4
Where does her support lies? Because her notes sound so pleasant 🥰
she normally supports F3 - G#5 - C6 but consistently G3 - F#5 - Bb5/B5
@@doctoritsthank you so much for replying. Her support seems so extensive and impressive, I adore her ring and tone 😍✨🤍
3:50 song?
daylight and i would’ve loved you
Sim tem uma pequena diferença: antes da perda de peso a voz estava um pouco mais encorpada e depois de emagrecer naturalmente a voz ficou um pouco mais aguda! Tem essa diferença! Além da questão da respiração que também deve mudar um pouco: igual acho que ela teria mais dificuldade de encarar muito show seguidos se ela não tivesse perdido peso! É mais ou menos isso que eu acho! Porém Kellyzinha sempre plena e arrasando! ❤️🥰😍🎵🎼
A propósito, parabéns pelo vídeo e o tema interessantíssimo: aguça a percepção musical! Gostei demais!❤️🥰😍🎵🎼
exatamente adri!!
@@adrianadonascimento1833 aaaa obg 😍😍
The biggest change I see is it's just hilarious that that massive voice comes out of such a tiny person. It's so hard to compare single performance now in a single performance then and some of those I wouldn't say that she was that heavy and she's probably 16 different weights in these clips. I don't think her voice is different either way except by being less heavy clearly have a better lung capacity and functioning all of your organs do better so I would say that just her physical health gives her more control and power
I can not hear any difference at all! The belting are still the same (as good as expected) But recently I noticed that she’s more emotional and feeling the songs. So it gave more taste. Overall my queen was, still and will always be as good as ever regardless of weight she is in. She’s simply ICONIC!!! Nothing compares to her vocals. Period.❤❤❤🙌🏻👏👏👏
yess
There was truly no difference. Idk what anyone is talking about. These so-called "differences" people [think they] hear can be observed in both dichotomies. The quality depends on the day and condition of her voice, not her weight. She sounds THE SAME. No difference. If anything, her previous seasons showcased greater proficiency than the current. So again, I don't understand what it is people are claiming to hear. It's in their heads lol. This woman sounds like they excellent vocalist she's always been. My conclusion is as follows: this video disproves the notion that her change in weight altered the quality of her voice. Any other conclusion means people need to train their ears. I appreciate the video my friend 🙏
the biggest difference i noticed: she’s been supporting some G5s now
Possibly, but I don't think her weight had anything to do with it. Her recent HV executions have been poor, and her placement has been less consistent comparatively. Taking ALL of these observations into consideration, it just shows that it all depends on her condition that day. This video demonstrates that. Any improvements or lack thereof should be attributed to other factors
@@princexl2783 yeah and she once said that inflammation affects her range. in my head, i associated it to the overweight because when someone is obese, their whole body is inflamed inside
I think that she may feel more comfortable attempting certain notes now that she’s lost weight, but I can’t hear a ton of difference in the way her voice sounds, in general. I see a little bit of both points of view tbh.
5:17 you can clearly hear a difference in the brightness in her voice lol. She sounds healthy.
Weight loss does affect a person’s singing ability. Less fat pressing on all of your organs including your lungs and diaphragm. I’m glad she got rid of the excess weight (body weight AND her ex husband hahaha) and decided to focus on her health. She looks great and I’m sure she feels great.
yess
it's so jarring seeing her this small; i don't think she's been this thin since my december era? she still looks great either way, and she sounds just as wonderful as ever :) her upper belts seem easier, though, which might be because of breathing and stuff
yess, since breakaway i would say
I think the only difference i notice is that she is much happier now then before❤
Just seems more effortless and supported, she sounds healthy that’s the main thing , you can tell a singers health from the sound of their voice.
YES
Kelly beating her own self lol
LOL!
I don’t think it’s her weight, at least not entirely. She is much happier now and taking care of herself. Different foods and beverages have various impact on the voice.
The show isn't over until....
what??
Nope
No difference
do u think so?