What’s So Special About The South Africa Jackal? | South Africa v Wales & Scotland | Rugby Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- South Africa’s game plan is heavily defence dominated, but right at the heart of that defence is the way they approach the tackle area. The Jackal is the jewel in the South African defensive crown and provides them with the platform to play their game!
But, what’s the secret to the South African Jackal? Well, there’s more to it than meets the eye and in this analysis I provide some insight into the many aspects of play that revolve around the jackal. To do this the Autumn Nations Series matches against Wales and Scotland are drawn upon. Players like Siya Kolisi, Damien De Allende, Lukhanyo Am, Kwagga Smith, and Steven Kitsoff provide a number of excellent examples of how do it!
►Support my content on Patreon: / gddcoaching
►SUBSCRIBE for new video notifications: / geraintdaviesgdd
►Twitter / daviesgdd
►RUclips: / geraintdaviesgdd
The video match footage is not in any way owned by myself - credit goes to the Autumn Nations Cup.
I am in no way wishing to infringe copyright laws or the rights of the copyright owners. The videos are entirely educational and aimed to boost the public love and understanding of the game. All under the Fair Use law.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use."
Great analysis! Lukhanyo Am's rugby IQ is just off the charts. Such an intelligent player, especially defensively.
He's crucial in the try scoring too. Both tries in the world cup final went through his hands.
The brilliant no look pass to Mapimpi of course. But most people don't realise he is the one who picked up the turnover, gave it to PSdT, who in turn passed to Willie, who then passed to Cheslin.
I've been frustrated that he doesn't get the ball enough, but watching Geraint, Squidge, and WIbble break down sequences, has shown me how all of it is deliberate. Damien's job, and to a lesser extend Handre's, is to consistently attack near the breakdown/ in the middle of the field, drawing defenders, and creating that overlap/ mismatch/ split second chance where usually Willie comes in at the last second, redirects play to the side with the overlap, suddenly we're scoring.
@@monunyabidness5949 I watched an interview on that second RWC final try. He saw the ball come loose, saw Itoje about to pounce and deliberately paused before going for the ball. He knew in that split second that if Itoje had caught him with the ball he was toast. His delay caused doubt, Itoje played the wrong option and the rest is history. What a genius.
I met him shortly afterwards and he is so good to fans. What a great ambassador for the sport.
He's just incredible isn't he!
I genuinely believe he's the most intelligent centre in world rugby at the moment
No wonder the world rugby wants to get rid of Rassie Erasmus. Possibly the best coach and director the world has seen. Be afraid.
Rassie is number 1
He's got a pretty good CV at this point!
A lot of this came from Nienaber too. But you're right... Rassie was a loosie, and that's really where the jackal (and the dog) live on a rugby pitch.
Kolisi's breakdown work does not get the credit it deserves. He hits so many rucks not always as a jackler but a counter rucker and ruck slower downer
He's been so good all over the field and both sides of the ball. Absolutely love his work in the Mapimpi try!
This entire year he has been brilliant at disrupting the ruck. I have proclaimed to all who would listen that there is no one who is more destructive at the ruck than Siya Kolisi. Sure, Duane and Marx get more actual steals/ turnovers at the ruck, but Siya gets those AND counterucks to allow his team mates to get those steals.
He and deAllende are *superb* at doing the little things in the ruck that get you ball. Or make the other team commit defenders to the ruck to protect the possession. The side benefit of that is it allows your defense to set.
I'm glad i'm not the only one who noticed.
Listen he's had to step up because PSDT is injured. A good leader picks up the slack. Happy he has stepped up no doubt.
@@monunyabidness5949 It's amazing how South Africa have managed to balance partnerships, I initially didn't understand how Kolisi and Smith could work together but now I see it. De Allende an Am is the best midfield partnership in the world.
Siya is an unbelievable rugby player, hes a threat both on attack and defense really wish the rugby world gave him more credit not just for the off field stuff.
Might be Biased being a South African supporter but it's so very refreshing hearing a positive spin on our play. I admit it isn't this running Rugby NZL play but SA has always been known for their size and brutal play, so it's fantastic to see us playin to our strengths again
Agreed. I get so much pleasure out of the brutal way we approach the game. Not everyone can play like France.
💯👊 true story and to compound the opposition's problems when South Africa start running with ball in hand they become unstoppable
The Bokke have returned.
@@shaheempashua6924 agree 100%, if only we could do a 🤏🏻 bit more counterattacking
There's far too much negative press out there when it comes to different styles and the SA approach in particular gets real stick. I'm glad this video can shine a positive light!
To hear someone say that an aspect of our play was "a thing of beauty" actually brought a tear to my eyes. Great video.
About time it was celebrated, plenty to love 👍🏻
Excellent review of what is some of the smartest strategic rugby moves a team has ever put together
Jaco Johan
Thanks for taking a look, Chris. Definitely very clever rugby!
As a South African, this will truly be the 1st time I've heard and seen such a positive analysis given by someone. Mostly South Africa, the Boks are accused of only playing a kicking game but as your analysis has shown we play a very technical, well worked out game plan. You have just gained a new subscriber.
It's incredibly well planned and well executed. It's a shame that we don't see more of the rugby world celebrating rugby's many different approaches!
I've said it before and I'll say it again, the best game of the RWC in Japan (for me) was the SA v Wales semi.
Sure, it wasn't as flashy as some of the other matches, with tries flying in from all sides. But so what? This was titanic rugby, two top teams, well matched in ability, with game plans that very effectively nullified each other, going at it hammer and tongs with never a backward step.
_Proper_ rugby! Both teams could walk off that field standing tall with their heads held high.
I have just replied as well - only saw this today. Thank you Sir.
Wow! And people have been looking at the Boks as a stupid, one-dimensional team for so long. Go figure!
That “belief” is their superpower my friend.
They are far from that!
Thank you for taking the time, making the effort and being gracious enough to first analyse and understand... and then appreciate the springbok game. As a Bok fan, we're surrounded by a sea of sour grapes, bitterness and spite. We need more of you.
True fans of the game understand that what the Boks do is play *high IQ rugby.* Sure the box kick is tiring but when you understand why they do it, to maintain ascendency with defense, you begin to realise the genius at work in the Bok system.
They don't just spread the ball wide and throw it around. They deliberately use Handre, Damien and Duane to attack in the center of the field and suck in defenders, opening up space on the wings.
WIllie then comes into the picture at the last second redirecting play to the side with an overlap. The defense is fixated on Handre and has to mark near the ruck because he WILL run into that space. Willie's playmaking ability is highly underated. I'm not his biggest fan, but I understand WHY he is on the field.
Cheslin's try in the World Cup final went through two crucial sets of hands, Lukhanyo's at the turnover, and Willie immediately reading the overlap and attacking that space. Both Lukhanyo and Willie are underappreciated in try creation.
(Lukkhanyo gave the brilliant no look (he actually did look) assist to Mapimpi for the first try of course.)
Willie was crucial in Mapimpi's first try against Scotland as highlighted in the video. DeAllende and Kolisi had to do their part of course, run straight, hold the defender, pass at the last second.
Thanks, Ross. It's great to be able to celebrate what is an incredibly effective game plan. There's more than one way to play the game!
The decision making of the jackler also has to be precise. Its amazing how many times they get it right.
They don't just go for the steal everytime, that's an easy way togive away penalties. They wait for the perfect stiuation; a ball carrier with no immediate support, a strong or dominant tackle, ideally behind the gain line.
Support having to retreat to enter the ruck is a tiny little essential part of it.
For sure. Really good reading of the game is essential!
I’d like to see South African pundits praise other teams like this. Great vid. Love the lessons.
Maybe one day! Glad you liked it!
Don't hold your breath, Japan will beat the Boks before that happens.
Fantastic insights. Illustrates how much is actually going on in a rugby game.
Glad you enjoyed it, Vere. Thanks for taking a look 🙏
Watching a year old analysis video, with a fresh issuance of the Webb Ellis Throphy heading over the pond.....
Great analysis.
And in the words of Oom Boy Louw : "Check the scoreboard".
One point is all you need. Even in three consecutive tests, each of those "ones" count.
For me this is the primary reason almost every team looks so sloppy against the Boks on attack. The breakdown just makes it near impossible to build an attack through phases. This could explain why so many of the tries against the Springboks involved either first phase moves or great offloading game (like Australia and Scotland)
Yeah for sure. Really tough to build an attack with the kind of pressure SA put on the breakdown. The offloading game is almost essential to give any chance!
But... but.... but..... we're boring!! XD
....boring to fair weather fans of rugby
@@GeraintDaviesGDD But this is, in itself, means having to play much higher risk rugby to score against the Boks. The offload game is certainly a higher risk game, especially for teams that may not have the skillset for it!
@@evanblecher Very much so. It's a strength of the SA defence that attacks have to play higher risk rugby to get opportunities.
Just shows how many incompetent people criticise the Spring Boks..... I am proudly South African 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
No one with any sense criticises the Boks...they are a very frustrating team to play against...but that's down to defensive skill and ironcast set-play.
What annoys me - as an England fan - is the sh*thousery employed by Rassie off the field and the Boks if things arent going their way...and the lack of any humility from SA fans that I see on social media.
Edit: and I'm obviously sour because of the WC finals in 07 and 19...🤣
We don't care with their stupid criticism, we smash them, Go Bokkes
@Greg Kyle like the humility the England team demonstrated when they ‘so graciously’ removed their medals at the RWC?
Nobody’s perfect mate, we’re all just learning and hope to be better.
Be better.
@Greg Kyle yes I am buddy - you guys played very well today...
@@randyschwaggins You are entitled to your opinion like everybody else. Should you be in a position to point out without a shadow of a doubt that the issues South Africans are complaining about is unfounded, then by all means. I'm also very verbal when the Springboks play the English and an unfair call is made against the England team that is not fair and just. They work just as hard as any other outfit in world rugby and deserve the respect on the field. So, for me it's not jut a matter of complaining, but complaining for a reason.
I love our Springboks I'm proud to be a South African. Thank you for this it's a beautiful thing to see it broken down like this.
I love your analysis and must admit, as a South African I've never heard of the term "the Jackal" but that's because these days I hardly ever watch a live game.
Away in the Okavango on work lots of the time
🇿🇦 Thanks for this Geraint!
Ive noticed the difference in our defensive press depending on which part of the field the attack is coming from. Noticed but never understood.
I immediately understood what was going on as you explained it. I just needed someone to voice it out.
Truly appreciate this bru!
You, Wibble and Squidge have helped me understand my own team so much more than i would have alone.
That's really cool, thank you for commenting with such a lovely message!
Brilliant analysis, keep them coming for the bok games. Perhaps Rassie might shoot you a call or message. Rassie is a genius for going back to our strengths as South Africa.
Thank you! Rassie is always welcome to give me a shout!
Absolutely absorbing video. Clear and clean commentary and intelligent rugby knowledge. Thank you
Great analysis. Many people cannot see beyond the "boring" rugby SA plays. They miss the calculated plays on defense and at breakdown and the way SA does strike when the opportunity is there.
Great analysis mate. The Springboks actually play a *high IQ* style of rugby, all based on percentages. It's not very entertaining, and i'll be the first to lament that, but it's effective, and it's efficacy is evident when you, Squidge and Wibble break down the sequences to their nuts and bolts. I'd love to see you break down the Boks "shooter" (it's been Pieter Steph, Faf, and lately Eben) and how it destabilises/ disrupts offenses, and gives the defense the time/ opportunity to now get those jackals.
We know about the outside shooter (Mapimpi or Kolbe) on the wing cutting off the outside, but the inside shooter is the one no one seems to have talked about.
And don't forget...Kwagga isn't just a pretty face.
@@guystehlik8931 🤣🤣 had to laugh
Really pleased you enjoyed the analysis. It's certainly fair to say that SA have a huge rugby IQ! I'll do more on the SA game over time for sure 👍
@@guystehlik8931hilarious 😅
@@guystehlik8931 Everybody nose....thank you and good night!
Brilliant analysis, your insight of the Boks defense is spot on and showcase the intelligence in their game plan
Thanks for taking a look!
Great analysis, delivered with a wonderful accent! What amazes me is how these players make technical decisions when everything is moving so quickly.
Thank you, Walter 🙏 it’s incredible how they make these decisions. Highly trained!
Excellent analysis. Love that thick Welsh accent. Regards from South Africa.
Thank you, really kind of you!
Excellent analysis. I think another aspect of our "jackal" that contributes to its effectiveness is simply the shear number of players who have shown a knack for it at lower levels and carry that on to the test side. And its not just our loosies but across the centers and front row we have quite a number of turn-over merchants. Even Habana on his day was partial to having a go and its not unusal to see Kolbe or Mapimpi have a stab if the opprtunity presents itself out wide with little support.
That and Jacques Nienaber's studious and defensive approach to the game that has come all the way with him as he has moved up the ladder.
Heinrich Brussouw...the OG jackal.
What a player!
Mate....thanks for the insightful and balanced analysis, and for the time and effort it takes to make a video like this and put it out for us to enjoy. Very much appreciated. Full kudos to you.
That’s a really lovely message, thank you. I wish I had time to make more like this but they do take a while! Really pleased you liked it 🙏
Thank you for the time and effort you put into this. It makes the game that much more enjoyable being able to look out for these pointers in the next game.
That's lovely to hear, Garth! Thank you!
I have never played rugby but watch international matches on tv and so am grateful for this forensic analysis of breakdowns , rucks etc.
I should now hopefully be able to predict referee whistles and the reasons for it .
And the most importantly I can now appreciate the ‘evil’ boks clever moves whereas previously was very biased.
That’s great to hear! Sport is always more enjoyable when some of the details are clearer! 👍🏻
The only problem with this video is its not long enough!
Really good work, upvoted and subscribed!
Thank you, Graham!
Fantastic analysis!
Thank you kindly!
I am so proud of our boys and to hear our style of rugby get some recognition is greatly appreciated. Thank you for treating me to a very nice overview of the Springboks, i enjoyed it very much.
I'd love for you to do an entire video just in south Africa's defence
Fingers crossed I’ll be able to do one at some point!
@@GeraintDaviesGDD you better or else haha I like looking into it for my own team I coach
There’s bits on defence in some of the other videos I’ve made, but for sure I’ll do a detailed one 👍🏻
Really liked this video, and for more than just the jackal. I’ve often wondered how to structure a kick chase to be more efficiently and this video helped with that.
Glad you found it useful, Michael 👍🏻
Thanks for taking the time to make that for us
You’re very welcome! Really enjoyed looking at the quality of the SA contact work 👍🏻
Breath of fresh air finding this channel :) - Up there with Squidge in my books.
Really pleased you found my little corner of RUclips! Thanks for taking a look 👍🏻
Thanks for another great analysis. Last game I played the opposition tried to jackal constantly. Made a real headache for us!!
A pleasure, thanks for taking a look 👌🏻
Excellent again Geraint, thank you for the translation! I don’t personally like the fact that turnover penalties can mean 3 points on the board. I remember when you actually had to win posession. However, those are the rules and SA target the breakdown and win matches. You can’t blame them for it. They aren’t stupid, they put the effort where it’s needed.
They've really nailed this way of playing. I'm sure they'll now look to evolve as other teams start to adapt!
Great vid, thank you
Thank you!
Thank you for your detailed insights and analysis. You are a real rugby thinker.
Thank you, glad you liked it!
Brilliant analyses
Thanks so much for providing such valuable insights (with a great accent I might add) 🤩 greetings from Cape Town South Africa 🇿🇦
Thank you, really appreciate it!
Amazing breakdown of the defensive strategy. I always try explaining this to friends on game day while giving "couch commentary". So glad I can now just say"watch this video". Beautifully explained.
Really pleased that it was worth making!
This has been very insightful. Thank you for doing this analysis!!
A pleasure, thanks for taking a look!
wow, you taught me so much Boyo, thanks!!!
I grew up in NZ,Two weeks ago I placed a 1000 Au bet on the Boks to win
I admire them so much
Dupont is out but thats so sad, i do not want to win my bet this way, hope he can make the final, a tragedy
Beautiful analysis man! Would love to see more of these, especially on defensive schemes and also the gameplay of individual players, like Savea, Kolisi, or Etzbeth. Love it, great stuff!
More to come for sure! I don't produce all that often but hopefully worth the wait when I do!
@@GeraintDaviesGDD You certainly have given me something to ponder upon.
Nice analysis, apart from the aussies many teams have had problems with boks attack and defence. They all know what’s coming but just can’t crack it. Thanks for that presentation
Thank you for taking a look!
AB supporter here.. He's an absolute machine.. Greatest of Respect to our Springbok brothers..
🙌
Thank you - you are a great analyst of the game. Video was well paced with helpful explanations for newbies (like me). I learned a lot. And the power of a well - executed jackal IS a beauty to behold!
That’s very kind of you, thank you!
The best I have seen in a long time! Well done
That's very kind of you, thank you!
Love the analysis and loving your accent....melodic Welsh lilt. The Bok physical presence always thrills me be it, in the loose or set piece. Love rugby!!
Thank you, that's really kind of you!
That was really good. Cheers.
Thank you for taking a look!
Ah at last what were are named for, the Boks Kicks.
I must say I am impressed you did the video based almost entirely on the game that Wales lost. I take it you are Welsh which means if you are a rugby fan like me then this couldnt have been the easiest game to analyse. Although I suppose you dont see it like that but rather all the best parts of the game. And i appreciate how you saw the skillset of the Boks as a positive thing. Not "boring" like some have argued
Wow love the motion graphics and easy to understand breakdowns, thank you!
Thank you, really appreciate that👍
Jessie Kriel was an absolute monster on defence!! Well done Jessie.
He’s a quality player isn’t he. Very sharp.
Nah him and Willie have to go
This is such a good analysis, you nailed it. Keep up the good work.
Your analysis is almost as good as your accent bro!! Good work!
That’s very kind of you to say, thank you 🙏
It used to be called the Munster Wrap and Ireland have been using it for years very successfully
Thanks to RUclips's algorithm I've just found your channel. You've earned my subscription
It’s not easy to find my little corner of RUclips, welcome on board!
Great analysis Butt...that was well put together. It starts with a premise...pulls you in and then sets about explaining how starting with small steps (I find Squidge overwhelming--tries to cram much in)--and adds layers and by the end the best compliment I can pay you is that I can get up here and explain to someone exactly how SA's Jackler works and they'll get it. Well done--I'm subscribed
That's really lovely to hear, thank you! It takes rather a long time to make these so really cool when people enjoy them!
@@GeraintDaviesGDD Cool man...I've played (flyhalf) and coached at provincial level (in the 80's). These days rugby is far more tactical--then you played what was in front of view (1974 Lions were the best at this). Todays rugby when played intelligently is high impact stress chess....its easy to be tactical till you get hit by a Kolisi and a Etsebeth in a double tackle then its just survival. Whoever keeps their head best in that situation wins (Richie McCaw was a master at this). Which is why its difficult to play against SA when they are switched on. You might know what the tactics are supposed to be but there's a huge difference seeing the moves on a whiteboard in the shed and trying to execute them when you see a D'Allende in the corner of your eye lining you up with Smith or Marx behind them ready to Jackal. I could go on forever about rugby. When's your next video...AB French game?
100%. Playing out the plan is always different to the plan! I'm currently working on the next one and you've guessed the game correctly!
Loved the video! Couldn’t help but laugh when you tried those Afrikaans names 😂
Thanks, David! I do need to improve my Afrikaans!
Top Analysis from a SAFFA, keep going hope channel grows for you.
I like the detail in this video. I hate videos that don't have substance.
Keep it up boyo.
Thank you for watching, glad you enjoyed it!
As a SA'an I tend to criticize our players by kicking away ball possession, but you made me realize there is more to it. It's all about risk management and if such a strategy works more often than not, why not. At the end of the game it comes down to that one extra point. Love the sport. Love the tiny Island nations that brings it all and the British Isles (plus France) that raised the game again just that little bit more.
Bru that was a Lekker explanation of SA rugby for my Tuesday evening....
It makes we wanna braai...
Good analysis
thank you!
Welshman love our Rugby and South Africans love Welsh rugby ❤ it's a symbiotic synthesis 🙂
There has to an incredible anticipation from each of the players so as to get a second or two advantage over your opposition
Great analysis this, very insightful. Also I see this video isn't new so for a change youtube actually recommended something worth watching. Subscribed looking forward to more of your content
That's really good to hear! I wonder sometimes if RUclips sees my videos at all!
The last pass from Kolisi is Xmas dessert for you G. Lip-smacking!!
Just unreal wasn’t it. Delivered to perfection!
Brilliant, loved you analogy!
Great video...thanks!!!
Thanks, Mike. Appreciate it 👍🏻
Outstanding analysis! Thank you.
New viewer. Good Stuff! Will be watching your videos!
Welcome on board, very pleased you enjoyed it!
Thank you for this video, makes me appreciate my Bokke even more.
Great to hear!
Agree with Wayne. Never hear anything positive. Always maligned for our style. Never justified. Thank you for being objective
Thank you, glad you liked it!
Top notch analysis!
Thank you for taking a look! 👍🏻
Well explained
Thank you, glad it came across ok!
Great analysis thanks
Thanks, Charlie. Glad you enjoyed it 🙏
Really interesting! Thanks.
Thank you for taking a look, Sean!
Rugby, the only sport where absolute team coordination will establish victory.
South Africa is such a good example since no one or two players stand out but as a unit they obliterate.
Super comprehensive analysis. Thanks a lot! Great video
U win the breakdown U win the game good work bro
100%!
Wow, great breakdown!
Suoerb analysis and explanation. You have a gift simplifying complexity!
You have the coolest accent ever good sir! Great analysis so much more to the bok gameplan than what it gets credit for. A lot of kicking, forward and breakdown dominance yes- but have a look in the tries column at the end of every tournament, Boks are always up there with their killer backs too. Next years World Cup going to be epic at least 5 sides can win it!
this is such a great vid! your accent adds so much colour! As if your language wasn’t enjoyable enough! Thank you 🙏
Wow, thank you!
Great observation . But it’s been to close at RWC with the springboks just getting through on one point . Very stressful 😂
Love this! Great analysis, my friend.
Thank you!
Great insight and enjoyed the Welsh accent as a bonus! Subscribed and followed on Twitter. Looking forward to learn more from you.
Thank you, that’s very kind of you. Hope you pick up some useful stuff!
Excellent analysis 👏. Keep them coming. Even for me as a bok supporter u have highlighted a number points never noticed.
That’s great to hear, thank you 🙏
Great work, thank you. rey insightful.
From
South Africa
Thanks for taking a look! Really pleased you enjoyed it!
Kwagga Smith though... like a honey badger 💪
It was interesting to see how England 🏴 countered this with two players going into the tackle area going forward with the second player quickly wiping out the would be Jackalers
England did a really good job of quickly clearing the tackle before it became a contest. Scotland were pretty good at this too in fairness!
@@GeraintDaviesGDD yep spot on Butty
Fantastic analysis and accent.
Cheers!
Excellent analysis bro!
Thank you, Nigel Owens
Can you foresee how SA would use their defence as an attacking strategy? I think there have been glimpses of the potential for disruption, interceptions and counters. Could they turn attack into defence?
Great analysis
Thank you!
Great analysis really appreciate your superb commentary
Much appreciated