Now imagine having Ale sing lead and Dany has to switch to doing the backing part. This is one of the few songs in their catalog that Ale has sang lead on.
@@booradley8895Pau‘s name is the first one in the booklet of the CD forRiver‘s Soul. But of course all three Girls were involved in the composition. Years ago a Fan wrote on YT that Ale composed RS. I answered that Take Me Down was composed by Ale and he answered it was a mistake by him, he Mixed the two songs up. But afterwards many Fans wrote that RS was composed by Ale. Maybe that error also had the reason in the fact that it was the first Warning Song with Ale singing lead vocals.
One great thing about this song is apparently it predates XXI Century Blood - this is one of the earliest songs they wrote, and they revived it for the extended edition of XXICB. Can you imagine? It's such a freaking good song. They're such a freaking good band.
First, good luck with getting those future gigs set up in 2024! River's Soul and these early songs are so amazing and diverse. They were experimenting, learning, trying different things. To be that brave at that age, and then to actually release the songs? I'd love to hear them play some of their "classics" live, in chronological order. That would be incredible. Great reaction!
This is such a great song! Those people in the audience singing along were not their parents or family. They were what is known as fans!😜 I would love for them to bring this song back in a live show sometime.
Nice Reaction Guys! Pau said in an interview that some of these songs on 21st Century Blood were ones they wrote early on with the songs that are on their first EP Escape The Mind. You guys need to watch a documentary video they made of the making of the Error Album during the pandemic. They talk to the Producer and the Sound Engineer, their parents, Lava Record Execs, manager, but most of it is with them talking about themselves and the Album. It's called "The Warning Mayday in the Making." It has 6 parts and together is about 40 minutes long.
Polyphony is probably the term you’re looking for, though my understanding is that that term isn’t exclusive to vocals. If the two different vocal lines were offset and were singing the same thing, it would be called a round, but since it’s simultaneous and different wording, polyphony is the most accurate term.
Of course, at that time, the Villarreal sisters did not have the artistic abilities and artistic (and personal) maturity that they have today, and yet, it seems to me that what they did is really good. In some recent interviews (2022, 2023), I have the impression that the Villarreal sisters seem somewhat embarrassed by their first works. In my opinion, it should not be like that, because what they did, even with the flaws and defects that could be mentioned, is very good and should not be a cause for shame, but for legitimate satisfaction.
One of my favorite songs by The Warning, and one I would love to see them do now. The two different vocals could not have been easy, yet they did a great job with it.
Here's a link to a *River's Soul* where two things didn't go as plan. But the band must improvise the best they can. But to give up isn't in the plan. ruclips.net/video/AIQNe3WlAmg/видео.html Comment below of what you thought of this Warning video.
There's a possibly apocryphal story I read about Pau complaining to their father about their click track failing, and his answer was simply "deal with it", something they very quickly learned how to do. But this is the only one I recall seeing where they had two independent problems during the same song. I wonder what guitar Dany was using.
@@robertkrawitz8237 Their fIrst appearance at the whiskey. It looks like Pau responds by hitting even harder! ruclips.net/video/Wna9pjpuq0E/видео.htmlsi=HfKO8R_PZ4NCNF4s?t=14m26s
@@robertkrawitz8237 I saw another video where Dani lost the sound to her guitar and she goes down to her guitar pedal gear and is trying to fix the problem i felt so sorry for her but she smiled and got it fixed and they continued with the song the performance was in Mexico i don't know what state it could have been in their home stare/city.
Never seen that before - friggin awesome - Pau's smile with her escaping cymbal was great - but Dany's Nananana na right at the end was beautifully inserted and a masterful addition giving the issue :) Anyone who says they don't actually play live just need to see this :)
To hear the other side of Dany the Dany day midnight shows are great. Several Billie Eilish songs, Cavetown Home, Halestorm Break In ect ect. And some you get to see the best side, the goofball side.
Singing a 'round' is what we called it in elementary school. Also, I don't *think* those guys were family.. unless maybe extended family. They have released several 'aftermovie' videos .. behind the scenes stuff. Their family hardly react to the music. I've guess they've heard it a ton already. lol. Highly recommend those videos though. They're funny and entertaining.
That song takes you on a journey, kind of like a meandering river. And to think they had just a few songs prior to writing the songs from XXI Century Blood. In fact, they had written some of the songs from XXICB during their first foray into writing (early songs on the Escape the Mind EP). It really does show their song writing diversity from the very beginning.
What makes following The Warning an incredible experience is that their fascinating journey has been recorded by fans convinced about their talent for more than a decade. @16Lizards happens to be one of those patrons who had uploaded videos from their early shows that are invaluable in tracking the evolution of the sisters. Here are The Warning playing River's Soul in August 2015 just after completing their 5 weeks summer course at Berklee as per the description in video. ruclips.net/video/-SitoIbBNEg/видео.html The profundity of lyrics points towards Pau. As a 13 year old in 2015 she was already wise beyond her biological age in terms of poetry - Black Holes, River's Soul, Escape the Mind, Exterminated, etc. Unbelievable!!! Simply unbelievable!!! A generational talent.
That guy holding up The Warning sign was doing it for the entire show. Toward the end of the concert, Pau lost her grip on a drum stick and it went flying off in Dany's direction,, narrowly missing her and almost hitting that guy with the sign. Oops!
singing in the round.. “A round is a musical composition, a limited type of canon, in which a minimum of three voices sing exactly the same melody at the unison, but with each voice beginning at different times so that different parts of the melody coincide in the different voices, but nevertheless fit harmoniously together. Wikipedia”
Polyphonic vocals. Something I wish they'd use more; with three strong singers with distinctive yet complementary voices, they could do things that other bands just can't. They have a short polyphony in Hell You Call A Dream with Ale singing the counter-melody (*), but nothing like this. This is my second favorite song on XXICB behind only Survive, and definitely one I would like to hear live. Dave Ellefson, at Berklee, commented that the main riff has an Iron Maiden feel to him. (*) This may be the first vocal melody they actually wrote for Ale; we'll see what happens when the official version comes out, as all we have so far are fan videos. Everything thus far has been written for Dany or Pau, and most of them go too high for Ale's chest voice. She can sing this song, Red Hands Never Fade, and Hunter, but they all go high enough that it sounds unnatural for her. There are, of course, two lines in Choke that she sings live; they immediately follow a high melody by Dany, and she can't get down fast enough live (we've seen a couple of shows in Canada when Ale was sick, and Dany couldn't sing the first few words of it). The counter melody in HYCAD, however, sounds well within her tessitura, so she can sing it with power and authority underneath Dany's soaring vocal line. It's a smoky mezzo or perhaps even contralto voice, as opposed to Dany's soaring and raspy voices.
Danys dexterity makes me slightly concerned. It seems like she have hyper mobile finger joints, and if it is so she has to be very careful with stretching and playing around with those joints, else the joints can get overstretched and start to dislocate easily and that's no good for guitar playing.
I like you guys journeying back into their catalog. As many others have stated, they haven't published a bad song yet. I'm sure they have written songs that have ended up in the dumper, but that was their decision. There may be songs that you like more than others, but I still haven't heard anyone identify a "bad" song.
@@16ploog79 yeah i kinda didn’t think she did.. but they did write this way back during escape the mind in 2015… just like exterminated and our mistakes.. they just put all those on the 21st century blood album
I love the rift, but the rest of the song fails to keep up. They were still kids, so it is understandable. I do love the change of feel section. Thanks for sharing.
Bros, fans in the crowd singing along are NEVER their family. Their family are always in the wings managing stuff making sure nothing goes wrong. C'mon now, you know them well enough to know better. When the camera pans over to the audience, and you see people singing, those are PAYING CUSTOMERS. Dakota Bar is a real bar, with real adults, that serves real alcoholic beverages, these are real gigs, with real contracts, and real money, not talent shows where mom and dad and cousins come to mouth the words on camera. smh. 🤣
21st Century Blood is a really good album. Fan funded, composed by young teens ( and younger) in a second language. Incredible.
Only Dany can pull off butterflies and rock and roll.
That shirt is so cool.
🦋⚡🤘🔥
This is really a beautiful song. To me its a perfect example of The Warning's genius.
This is the song that Ale first ever sang lead vocals on live at Agua Fría.
Somewhat historical moment for the band.
Now imagine having Ale sing lead and Dany has to switch to doing the backing part. This is one of the few songs in their catalog that Ale has sang lead on.
Ale wrote this song. Think she was 8. I love when she sings this.
She was 10.
Ale wrote Take me Down from their EP. She didn‘t write Rivers Soul but it was the First song She sang lead.
@@16ploog79Are you sure she didn't write it?
@@booradley8895Pau‘s name is the first one in the booklet of the CD forRiver‘s Soul. But of course all three Girls were involved in the composition. Years ago a Fan wrote on YT that Ale composed RS. I answered that Take Me Down was composed by Ale and he answered it was a mistake by him, he Mixed the two songs up. But afterwards many Fans wrote that RS was composed by Ale. Maybe that error also had the reason in the fact that it was the first Warning Song with Ale singing lead vocals.
One great thing about this song is apparently it predates XXI Century Blood - this is one of the earliest songs they wrote, and they revived it for the extended edition of XXICB. Can you imagine? It's such a freaking good song. They're such a freaking good band.
First, good luck with getting those future gigs set up in 2024! River's Soul and these early songs are so amazing and diverse. They were experimenting, learning, trying different things. To be that brave at that age, and then to actually release the songs? I'd love to hear them play some of their "classics" live, in chronological order. That would be incredible. Great reaction!
Those people singing along are family like you and I are family. They've had their fans from their very beginnings. 🤩
This is such a great song! Those people in the audience singing along were not their parents or family. They were what is known as fans!😜 I would love for them to bring this song back in a live show sometime.
Yes i agree!
Nice Reaction Guys! Pau said in an interview that some of these songs on 21st Century Blood were ones they wrote early on with the songs that are on their first EP Escape The Mind.
You guys need to watch a documentary video they made of the making of the Error Album during the pandemic. They talk to the Producer and the Sound Engineer, their parents, Lava Record Execs, manager, but most of it is with them talking about themselves and the Album. It's called "The Warning Mayday in the Making." It has 6 parts and together is about 40 minutes long.
They're so creative already at this young age, it's just staggering.
Polyphony is probably the term you’re looking for, though my understanding is that that term isn’t exclusive to vocals. If the two different vocal lines were offset and were singing the same thing, it would be called a round, but since it’s simultaneous and different wording, polyphony is the most accurate term.
Of course, at that time, the Villarreal sisters did not have the artistic abilities and artistic (and personal) maturity that they have today, and yet, it seems to me that what they did is really good.
In some recent interviews (2022, 2023), I have the impression that the Villarreal sisters seem somewhat embarrassed by their first works. In my opinion, it should not be like that, because what they did, even with the flaws and defects that could be mentioned, is very good and should not be a cause for shame, but for legitimate satisfaction.
Thanks for this reaction I love The Warning playing live. DPA ⚡🤘🔥. Glad you had a great show at Ollie's Pub, just watch your video.
If you think the vocal would be confuseing just imagine when Ale sings lead and Dany does backing. And they still never miss a beat.
One of my favorite songs by The Warning, and one I would love to see them do now. The two different vocals could not have been easy, yet they did a great job with it.
Excellent reaction guys! The song writing this band has, even from the very beginning, very mature as musicians and as people!
Love their blend of Prog rock even in their grungiest sounding songs.
Here's a link to a *River's Soul* where two things didn't go as plan. But the band must improvise the best they can. But to give up isn't in the plan.
ruclips.net/video/AIQNe3WlAmg/видео.html
Comment below of what you thought of this Warning video.
I can even see third issue (Paulina's "untied" hair) 😮😅
There's a possibly apocryphal story I read about Pau complaining to their father about their click track failing, and his answer was simply "deal with it", something they very quickly learned how to do. But this is the only one I recall seeing where they had two independent problems during the same song. I wonder what guitar Dany was using.
@@robertkrawitz8237
Their fIrst appearance at the whiskey. It looks like Pau responds by hitting even harder!
ruclips.net/video/Wna9pjpuq0E/видео.htmlsi=HfKO8R_PZ4NCNF4s?t=14m26s
@@robertkrawitz8237 I saw another video where Dani lost the sound to her guitar and she goes down to her guitar pedal gear and is trying to fix the problem i felt so sorry for her but she smiled and got it fixed and they continued with the song the performance was in Mexico i don't
know what state it could have been in their home stare/city.
Never seen that before - friggin awesome - Pau's smile with her escaping cymbal was great - but Dany's Nananana na right at the end was beautifully inserted and a masterful addition giving the issue :) Anyone who says they don't actually play live just need to see this :)
Dani has covered some Billie Eilish songs in her midnight acoustic sessions.
Las diosas nunca han tenido miedo de crear música, lo ves es lo que tienes, pura calidad. Saludos
Rivers Soul riff has been my ring tone for a while now. Love it! 🔥🤘#NumberlyGarfs
To hear the other side of Dany the Dany day midnight shows are great. Several Billie Eilish songs, Cavetown Home, Halestorm Break In ect ect. And some you get to see the best side, the goofball side.
I may be wrong, but I seem to remember singing different parts simultaneously being called Polyphony.
Singing a 'round' is what we called it in elementary school. Also, I don't *think* those guys were family.. unless maybe extended family. They have released several 'aftermovie' videos .. behind the scenes stuff. Their family hardly react to the music. I've guess they've heard it a ton already. lol. Highly recommend those videos though. They're funny and entertaining.
Another cool song from young TW. So good.
That song takes you on a journey, kind of like a meandering river. And to think they had just a few songs prior to writing the songs from XXI Century Blood. In fact, they had written some of the songs from XXICB during their first foray into writing (early songs on the Escape the Mind EP). It really does show their song writing diversity from the very beginning.
What makes following The Warning an incredible experience is that their fascinating journey has been recorded by fans convinced about their talent for more than a decade. @16Lizards happens to be one of those patrons who had uploaded videos from their early shows that are invaluable in tracking the evolution of the sisters.
Here are The Warning playing River's Soul in August 2015 just after completing their 5 weeks summer course at Berklee as per the description in video.
ruclips.net/video/-SitoIbBNEg/видео.html
The profundity of lyrics points towards Pau. As a 13 year old in 2015 she was already wise beyond her biological age in terms of poetry - Black Holes, River's Soul, Escape the Mind, Exterminated, etc. Unbelievable!!! Simply unbelievable!!! A generational talent.
That guy holding up The Warning sign was doing it for the entire show. Toward the end of the concert, Pau lost her grip on a drum stick and it went flying off in Dany's direction,, narrowly missing her and almost hitting that guy with the sign. Oops!
River's Soul : Un tema que también puede ser interpretado por Ale, un gran tema de rock clasico un tema compuesto por Ale ,esto es rock
singing in the round.. “A round is a musical composition, a limited type of canon, in which a minimum of three voices sing exactly the same melody at the unison, but with each voice beginning at different times so that different parts of the melody coincide in the different voices, but nevertheless fit harmoniously together. Wikipedia”
That guitar riff/bass interplay always reminds me of Iron Maiden in style and I always find myself wanting another round of it at the end.
Love Ale singing this song.l Love Dany when she sings Billie. Can't believe Alw wrote this
Looks like a home-town crowd.
Polyphonic vocals. Something I wish they'd use more; with three strong singers with distinctive yet complementary voices, they could do things that other bands just can't. They have a short polyphony in Hell You Call A Dream with Ale singing the counter-melody (*), but nothing like this. This is my second favorite song on XXICB behind only Survive, and definitely one I would like to hear live. Dave Ellefson, at Berklee, commented that the main riff has an Iron Maiden feel to him.
(*) This may be the first vocal melody they actually wrote for Ale; we'll see what happens when the official version comes out, as all we have so far are fan videos. Everything thus far has been written for Dany or Pau, and most of them go too high for Ale's chest voice. She can sing this song, Red Hands Never Fade, and Hunter, but they all go high enough that it sounds unnatural for her. There are, of course, two lines in Choke that she sings live; they immediately follow a high melody by Dany, and she can't get down fast enough live (we've seen a couple of shows in Canada when Ale was sick, and Dany couldn't sing the first few words of it). The counter melody in HYCAD, however, sounds well within her tessitura, so she can sing it with power and authority underneath Dany's soaring vocal line. It's a smoky mezzo or perhaps even contralto voice, as opposed to Dany's soaring and raspy voices.
Glad you both made it through last night relatively unscathed, we want you to stick around for more reactions!
Great! Excelente reacción a esta espectacular presentación. Gracias
Danys pinky finger has great dexterity
Danys dexterity makes me slightly concerned.
It seems like she have hyper mobile finger joints, and if it is so she has to be very careful with stretching and playing around with those joints, else the joints can get overstretched and start to dislocate easily and that's no good for guitar playing.
One of my faves from 21st century blood along with black holes, everything Ale writes is just a bit different in a very good way!
I like you guys journeying back into their catalog. As many others have stated, they haven't published a bad song yet. I'm sure they have written songs that have ended up in the dumper, but that was their decision. There may be songs that you like more than others, but I still haven't heard anyone identify a "bad" song.
I think that this song was written by a 9-10 year old Ale , 🤯
yeah and take me down was written by her
No, River Soul was Not written by Ale. Why do so many fans repeat this wrong Information?
@@16ploog79 yeah i kinda didn’t think she did.. but they did write this way back during escape the mind in 2015… just like exterminated and our mistakes.. they just put all those on the 21st century blood album
@@Nolimitcam._ that‘s right
was written by all three of them Ale included.
I believe Row Row Row Your Boat is a round.
That’s correct, and that’s not what’s being done here.
@@PaleHorseShabuShabu Yes, that’s why I worded my comment the way I did.
Look up the Warning Dany days and she has covered a lot of songs including a few by Billie Eilish.
Love when she sings Billie
It's called singing in canon when another singer is following along few beats behind
🙋🔥🔥🔥⚡⚡⚡
🌟
Funny that you mention Billy Eilish, because Dany has some cover of her. .
I love the rift, but the rest of the song fails to keep up. They were still kids, so it is understandable. I do love the change of feel section. Thanks for sharing.
You are thinking of “rounds”. 😀
gr8 reaction ... brilliant @ such a young age ... r0ck 0n d00dz ... namaste ... twa ... \m/
It's called a rounda.
Creo que esta cancion la compuso Ale
Just wait till you get to see the Aqua Fria performance of this
Bros, fans in the crowd singing along are NEVER their family. Their family are always in the wings managing stuff making sure nothing goes wrong. C'mon now, you know them well enough to know better. When the camera pans over to the audience, and you see people singing, those are PAYING CUSTOMERS. Dakota Bar is a real bar, with real adults, that serves real alcoholic beverages, these are real gigs, with real contracts, and real money, not talent shows where mom and dad and cousins come to mouth the words on camera. smh. 🤣
I think that was her mom.
There are a few solo Billie Eilish covers by Dany on RUclips. Check 'em out!
Rounds ...
I guess Bass Players are just clumsy 🙄😂 ruclips.net/user/shortsjNwn_8eIyh8
oK pothead
8:40 Stacatto? 🤷🏻♂️