My father was an immigrant from one of those "sh*thole countries." He was a medical doctor who took care of veterans from four wars as well as other suffering U.S. citizens. Thank you for your story, Anand.
That is the thing I wish people would remember. Immigrants add to our country. They aren't taking away anyone else's dreams or opportunities. They bring skills and abilities to add to our society.
Please quit talking about successful and highly educated migrants; majority are medium and might even be hard-working struggling people whose English is so, so and that is okay. Some of us might even come from areas where dog eating is acceptable what do you think about that? But in Springfield, Ohio apparently this the cat, and dog story is just a lie that Trump and Vance spread around so comfortably. What else is new GOP?
@@Missusri Also and for this is worth, when I mention that my father was a doctor, I don't mean a plastic surgeon or someone in private practice. He worked in an inner-city hospital and a separate VA between 1971 and 2018. He was not in that field for the money. And he never retired. He worked until he got sick in that same hospital.
I am a grandchild of immigrants. It brings me to tears hearing him talk about the sacrifices immigrant parents make/eat so that their children and grandchildren can benefit/eat better years from now. Shame on anyone who disparages this sacrifice/act of love.
I have worked along side immigrants since the age if 12. The adopted me as a second daughter. They protected me from any older adults that did not always have the best of intentions. As I grew to an adult I still had hard working immigrants cross my path. I admire their hard work, ethics and devotion to family. Anyone that does not see this has missed a great culture that has enhanced this country.
Anand is an inspirational individual who speaks clearly, eloquently and sensibly about what it means to be the child of an immigrant in the greatest country in the world
If the USA were the greatest country of the world, it wouldn't have ended up with Trump as president in the first place, and he most certainly wouldn't be a contender for re-election.
I volunteer at a foodshelf and many are new arrivals from all over the world, from Ukraine, Turkey, Cuba, Venezuela, Philippines, Mexico, Russia, etc. I have seen people in tears in praise of their love and hope for their families. It’s such a privilege
Anand's Giridharadas's comments about "the 7 o'clock hour at countless US Embassies and Consulates around THE WORLD" made me rewind and listen not twice, but three times that part of this segment....and he's ABSOLUTELY correct!
I too listened to Anand describe American Embassies and Consulates around the world and I cried because I see how so many people around the world suffer and how they just want an opportunity to live in peace, dignity, have opportunities and raise their families to be the best they can be. Pay attention to what people from other countries are posting about our upcoming election. They know as America goes, so goes the world. WE HAVE NO CHOICE, WE MUST DEFEAT THESE WANNA BE FASCISTS. VOTE BLUE BECAUSE IT'S NOT JUST AMERICA, IT IS THE WORLD. 🙏✍💙🗽
This clip makes me miss Anthony Bourdain all over again. Bringing different cultures together over a meal. Good humor, good conversation, real issues, finding common ground. Miss him alot!!
For many people outside the US it is difficult to understand that a convicted criminal is allowed to run for president but a person who has finished their jail-time cannot vote.
I feel what this Indian American is saying. A direct descendent of slaves, I never thought about what immigrants have suffered. You have my admiration.
"Enslaved " the circumstances of the people. They were NEVER slaves. And every time they "other" immigrants know they are ALWAYS coming for African Americans. Nothing new. They mocked the African "super fruit " of watermelon that the genius enslaved Africans know was helpful in the hot dehydration sun they were forced to be in from sunrise to sundown!
Fortunately it's not the majority of us. But it will take work to convince everyone that their vote, no matter how the other side tries to suppress it, matters. Thank you Canada.
Thanks for having him on. He said more than a mouthful of truth! It boggles my mind how ignorant & vengeful the orange man & his running mate are. Vote Blue for effective change in the senate, GOP, & President.
I watched the virtual event last night with VP Harris and Oprah. The sight of people of different colors and backgrounds, different faiths and flavors was SO refreshing. Not like the stark white angry faces at Trump rallies, Trump and Vance included. Unless you are 100% Native American, you are an immigrant. I'd rather live in a country of immigrants than in a country of Trumps.
Anand, as an immigrant myself the quotes "they know that in America, in order to rise you must first fall," and "they eat cheap food from Costco because they can taste the food their unborn grandchildren will eat" made me cry. Truer words couldn't be said.
@@armandredman So would it help you if they started talking about the Latino community that way? How about they invent disgustin eating habits and make up whole cloth stories about strange Latino marriage customs and depict Latinos as dangerous and predatory and how Latinos are about to destroy the country and take everything over and burn it down? Woud that help you understand what is going on here? Gimme a break you should know better.
My blood line is Yavapai and apache. My families go back hundreds of years. The early settlers, immigrants took over the natives and incarcerated all of them, were are only taught misinformation. Trump's wife was an immigrant until she became first lady! And her family just became citizens, only because Trump was president! Did anyone ask them what they ate? Heavens my grandmother was born in Southern Arizona before it was Arizona. Her grandparents and their grandparents on and on only knew that this land was a gift to serve! Americans are all immigrants at some point!
Excellent response. Highly unlikely Joe's roots to go back hundreds & hundreds & hundreds of years, earliest settlers arrived in the 1600's and unless his family derives from Pilgrim Fathers stock his claim is dubious at best.
Joe injects himself in every conversation. He also touts his time in Congress. Don't forget, he was part of the tea party for which the heritage foundation bore them.... What a joke!;
Thank you Annan and Joe. Immigrants truly believe in the US. That this country is the ONLY ONE that offers everyone that is willing to roll up their sleeves and work hard,the great opportunity to succeed. And that is exceptional. Every one all over the world wants to experience this in spite of the the current situation.
Anand was delightfully cogent and enlightening on this topic. His perspective is clear, uplifting, and relatable and he really puts our bad actors in their place. He needs to be heard by more Americans.
It sounds so belittling when Joe says that he talked to “immigrants” instead of “people that immigrated here”. But anyway, Anand’s words were so powerful. He absolutely nailed it.
as a german i am watching the development in your country in disbelief. having learned about our history extensively in school i am wondering, have you not learned anything from our history? but then again witnessing populism rising in europe as well i guess its a global trend that we ALL together MUST defeat!!!!! on a side note indian food with its variety of spices is freakin awesome!!!!!
Anand is so brilliant, human, eloquent....he tells it like it is...Trump is a very little man......wheras this guy has class, brains and heart !!! Thank you !!!❤
Donald Trump’s mom is an immigrant from Scotland so he’s a son of an immigrant, too. His two wives are immigrants. His son then is a son of an immigrant. Yet he treats immigrants so horribly. Why? What Anand is saying makes so much sense.
Donald’s dad was an immigrant. Also he left his homeland because he did not want to serve in the war effort some years later he wanted to return to his homeland, but the government will not allow him to return.
Anand, you are priceless. You just said it all. Please Joe and Mika, let me speak for a minute on your show. I am an immigrant and it makes me sad that trump has been allowed to dehumanize immigrants. Go all over the world and see how people who has never traveled out of their countries talk good about this Country. Please get some of us on your show to educate trump and his MAGA followers. 🙏
My diet is Korean Asian. I'm Italian Irish American. Visited Seoul in May, 2022. Visited Busan, 2024, for the entire month. NEVER had ramyeon. Dined on VEGETABLES, beef and pork. Very LITTLE bread. Lots of bone broth & rice. Returned home 8 lbs lighter. Oh, WALKED a lot! I understand the Tuscany, Italy Food Tour is healthy and clean eating. Can't wait! Kudos to all my immigrant ancestors and present friends for giving me life and substance. 🥰🥰
An artist named Ren has a song called “Money Game”. In in it he says we are all immigrants or descendants of immigrants. He also says since when is freedom of speech a freedom to hate.
This is one of the best reports/broadcasts I have seen in quite some time. Such an important message and so eloquently put by, both, Joe Scarborough and Anand Giridharadas. Almost none of us native-born Americans has any idea about the lines at the embassies of which Anand speaks during this conversation. It's very enlightening. I have been a teacher for almost 30 years and have had the honor of families of different countries, origins, and cultures take me out to dinner or invite me to their homes to share a dinner that they have prepared, not only to welcome me and show me their appreciation but to share a little bit about themselves and their cultures. I have counted myself very fortunate to have had these experiences. Speaking of sharing, please share this video with everyone you can, so more people get this incredible message! 🙏💕
I worked at a research university. Many immigrant students had been brought to the US to take advantage of our education system. The parents sacrificed and the students typically had incredible work ethics. Too many citizens take all of this for granted. The families typically stay here and contribute greatly to our communities.
You would think that "I will blame the Jews" is a phrase that no one would say out loud, but of course DT would. Even in front of a room full of Jewish people and the people who care about them. That anyone gives him a platform or a vote makes me angry and profoundly sad.
Joe: "America is the land of opportunity, like no other land!" This type of American exceptionalism is part of the problem, leading Americans to also think "It can't happen here." Other countries are also lands of opportunity, in the same way and to the same degree. America is great, but it's not uniquely great.
I am an American today because years ago, I was one of the people standing in that line at 7:00 AM, waiting and hoping I would be one of the lucky ones who would receive a visa.
I wish you guys did a video on the Haitians in Springfield working all the jobs that the locals won’t work and it’s saving their city for them and adding a quarter million dollars to the city every year.
As a Chinese American who was born in Texas but with parents from Hong Kong I heard a lot of the same stuff growing up. This is why even though I'm an American citizen and my family came here legally this rhetoric still makes me very uneasy.
Over the last 10 years I have come to understand too well what my aunt in NYC meant when she got angry with the local media ''Elevating garbage to relevance.'' -that was her take on the NYC press and their tendency to gush over anything Trump.
You’re talking about immigrants, black American immigrants and the great migration black Americans built this country and contributed to every facet of our of our lives without their inventions we would still be in the dark ages. These are the immigrants of America and they should be recognized for their contributions and sacrifices and Acknowledgment of the atrocities that were attributed against them and so yes, America is the dream and I feel whoever don’t want to subscribe to that dream in America and it’s freedoms should leave this country and let the real Americans stand together and fulfill Martin Luther King’s dreams.
I recognize everything Anand talks about. I’ve experienced every example. My family and I had to flee political turmoil in a country when I was a kid. We didn’t end up in the U.S. but we still had the same experiences Anand describes.
I wish the media would DO THEIR JOBS and ask him what exactly is an infested country? What countries is he referring to as infested? Infested with what specifically?
I respect every lawful immigrant ever. The thought of having to leave my own country and my family and go to a whole different country by myself starting from scratch? Nightmare fuel. Respect.
Sadly, I saw this dehumanization even as a small kid from the 70s/80s, but in my area of Iowa, it was the Chinese that ate alternative proteins, never true.
This man is a world class thinker Trump has mashed potatoes For brains. It’s gotten to the point that when you hear someone who is clear and well spoken It’s a bit of a shock. Trump Vance MTG Boebert McConell And Many others Are ridiculously bad at communicating. And A large part of that is that are trying to fool you
THIS! I work in the medical field and I know so many people who immigrated to this country WITH PHDs but were forced because of licensing issues or college accreditation issues.
We have 127 million more people in America since 1980. Government grows to support all of us. 40% more people needs more innovation, more intergration, more surprise. Let us do this with Kamala
Counterpoint. Most of my family was here centuries before Columbus got lost or the Nords went a Viking & we don't have that same American Dream at all. Politicians like you Joe work very hard to other us, prevent us from voting & telling our story as that of savages & animals who need to be tamed. So your tale of the uplifting American Dream that "everyone came here from somewhere else" falls flat on me. The place my ancestors came from was paved in blood along a trail of tears. I am an American Citizen living in a very different America than yours Joe. And I really wish you hadn't interupted and talked over Anand explaining the nonwhite experience to you. You could learn a lot from him if you'd just hold your tongue long enough to listen.
Italian immigrants brought their recipes from the " old country". One of the best things that ever happened to this country. I don't have to go to Italy to get that food. I can actually get good versions of it near where I live.
If, heaven forbid, Drumpf becomes president again, i will be in line at the French Consulate - requesting a residence visa. America, as we know it, will cease to exist, and i cannot imagine living in it.
Of course the whole lie and aftermath of this ridiculous, most recent B.S. of the tRump/Vance team is deplorable. But I will add that when I watch Morning Joe, I wish Joe would learn to be more circumspect. He blab blab blabs and hardly lets his guests get their opinions out. We have to wait so long for Joe to rehash restate and regurgitate, as if his opinion is what we're waiting to hear. Sorry Joe, but Mika et al are much more succinct!
Wow when he said about his mother cooking pasta because of her new found freedom really got me. Something I take for granted never ever even crossed my mind of the freedom I was born with
" Trump is not mentally fit for any position, let alone the Presidency." Dr Bandy Lee Psychiatrist.
FJB
😂 says the people who put costumes on and read to kids at DQ story time
You're generalizing. That's an not every person who is Democrat participates in this story times. Do not lie@ziff1066
Truth he is unfit for dog catcher
@sherlockhomo-ph4su-g6o They are WEIRD huh???
Anand Giridharadas is such a brilliant man. He needs to be on more often. His intelligence, knowledge and wisdom are exceptional. 💯🇺🇲
He really is and that's why when I saw he was on Morning Joe, I tuned in.
he's a leftist
Not like that ignorant one on the Panel with Chris Wallace.
On top of all that, how about that really cool hair
Yes, the Right said the same thing about Vietnamese immigrants in the 70s.
My father was an immigrant from one of those "sh*thole countries." He was a medical doctor who took care of veterans from four wars as well as other suffering U.S. citizens. Thank you for your story, Anand.
Hi ! Thank you very much for your comments ! 🙏✌️🇺🇲
That is the thing I wish people would remember. Immigrants add to our country. They aren't taking away anyone else's dreams or opportunities. They bring skills and abilities to add to our society.
Immigrants around the world perform jobs that the citizenry don't want to do. Why is that rarely mentioned or respected?
Please quit talking about successful and highly educated migrants; majority are medium and might even be hard-working struggling people whose English is so, so and that is okay. Some of us might even come from areas where dog eating is acceptable what do you think about that? But in Springfield, Ohio apparently this the cat, and dog story is just a lie that Trump and Vance spread around so comfortably. What else is new GOP?
@@Missusri Also and for this is worth, when I mention that my father was a doctor, I don't mean a plastic surgeon or someone in private practice. He worked in an inner-city hospital and a separate VA between 1971 and 2018. He was not in that field for the money. And he never retired. He worked until he got sick in that same hospital.
I am a grandchild of immigrants. It brings me to tears hearing him talk about the sacrifices immigrant parents make/eat so that their children and grandchildren can benefit/eat better years from now. Shame on anyone who disparages this sacrifice/act of love.
I have worked along side immigrants since the age if 12. The adopted me as a second daughter. They protected me from any older adults that did not always have the best of intentions. As I grew to an adult I still had hard working immigrants cross my path. I admire their hard work, ethics and devotion to family. Anyone that does not see this has missed a great culture that has enhanced this country.
Anand is an inspirational individual who speaks clearly, eloquently and sensibly about what it means to be the child of an immigrant in the greatest country in the world
If the USA were the greatest country of the world, it wouldn't have ended up with Trump as president in the first place, and he most certainly wouldn't be a contender for re-election.
I volunteer at a foodshelf and many are new arrivals from all over the world, from Ukraine, Turkey, Cuba, Venezuela, Philippines, Mexico, Russia, etc. I have seen people in tears in praise of their love and hope for their families. It’s such a privilege
I love Anand! He always has excellent analysis!
anands comments and insight MADE me look him up. he is absolutely correct.
@libbycollins9349 as kamala said- she is so proud of her privilege to be an American
This was outstanding!!! Thank you Anand for giving us pause and for being so humble about it ♥️
Anand nailed it!!! These thoughts should be amplified.
Anand's description of what immigrants eat - pure glorious brillance...
Beautiful
Yes. It had me in tears.
Brilliant metaphoric analogies!
Anand Giridharadas is a beautiful soul and a brilliant writer.
Anand's Giridharadas's comments about "the 7 o'clock hour at countless US Embassies and Consulates around THE WORLD" made me rewind and listen not twice, but three times that part of this segment....and he's ABSOLUTELY correct!
100 percent.
I too listened to Anand describe American Embassies and Consulates around the world and I cried because I see how so many people around the world suffer and how they just want an opportunity to live in peace, dignity, have opportunities and raise their families to be the best they can be. Pay attention to what people from other countries are posting about our upcoming election. They know as America goes, so goes the world. WE HAVE NO CHOICE, WE MUST DEFEAT THESE WANNA BE FASCISTS. VOTE BLUE BECAUSE IT'S NOT JUST AMERICA, IT IS THE WORLD. 🙏✍💙🗽
@@lisamcbarron6047 I was literally reminiscing on my time standing in the line at 7:00.
@@patj5330
Brought me to tears, too
@@Plusty07
Aaaww 🙏💕
This clip makes me miss Anthony Bourdain all over again. Bringing different cultures together over a meal. Good humor, good conversation, real issues, finding common ground. Miss him alot!!
A meal of what?
Same ❤
@@RandyWatson-q2tFood. Internationally speaking. Apparently something you can't grasp.
@@track1949 cats and dogs are not food nor is human flesh. In my culture. Respect my culture
@@RandyWatson-q2t Cows are sacred beings. They are to be worshiped not eaten. Respect !
For many people outside the US it is difficult to understand that a convicted criminal is allowed to run for president but a person who has finished their jail-time cannot vote.
I'm in Iowa and I don't understand any of it we have to call out these people.
They don't care if we starve. They really don't.
True and horrific.
That there is a brain-twister.
If he wins America will be a laughing stock,and you can forget about being a democratic country
Yep, it's ridiculous and an embarrassment! 🇬🇧
I feel what this Indian American is saying. A direct descendent of slaves, I never thought about what immigrants have suffered. You have my admiration.
"Enslaved " the circumstances of the people. They were NEVER slaves. And every time they "other" immigrants know they are ALWAYS coming for African Americans. Nothing new. They mocked the African "super fruit " of watermelon that the genius enslaved Africans know was helpful in the hot dehydration sun they were forced to be in from sunrise to sundown!
I am Canadian and I don't understand how Americans can vote for someone who obviously hates their country.
Fortunately it's not the majority of us. But it will take work to convince everyone that their vote, no matter how the other side tries to suppress it, matters. Thank you Canada.
You could say the same about Trudeau and Singh. Both of them stand to lose 50% of their seats next election.
Oh tRump doesn't hate America. He loves WASP America especially when white men were in charge & untouchable.
Thanks for having him on. He said more than a mouthful of truth! It boggles my mind how ignorant & vengeful the orange man & his running mate are. Vote Blue for effective change in the senate, GOP, & President.
I watched the virtual event last night with VP Harris and Oprah. The sight of people of different colors and backgrounds, different faiths and flavors was SO refreshing. Not like the stark white angry faces at Trump rallies, Trump and Vance included. Unless you are 100% Native American, you are an immigrant. I'd rather live in a country of immigrants than in a country of Trumps.
Do Oprah explain why girls were SA in her schools There is a reason she stepped out of the limelight
Exactly. And what made them legal was a social security number that was handed out by a Democrat
@@lillianmatthew3880Do the Vatican explain why children are SA by priests for decades?
@@Prudence-i7uNot Exactly. Those people were invited by the Republican leaders in Ohio to take the jobs white people didn’t want. Now you know.
Natives are immigrants as well..they are Asians ...
Very poetic Anad. Well well said. Again, the uneducated remain suspicious and fear what they do not know.
Anan kinda had me choked up!! That was a real love letter to American Immigration. ❤🇺🇸✊🏽
Anand, as an immigrant myself the quotes "they know that in America, in order to rise you must first fall," and "they eat cheap food from Costco because they can taste the food their unborn grandchildren will eat" made me cry. Truer words couldn't be said.
I cried too.
@@RebekahCurielAlessi me too.
@@maryschmidt6128 ❤️
imagine having access to everything the world has to offer and you are still as small and angry as trump. what a weird world!
They want respect. But respect should be earned.
i wouldn't call him small.
300 pounds is pretty big.
Why don’t show Aaron heitke hearing at the house of homeland security ? So you can see the truth about immigration , I’m Latino by the way
@@armandredmanYou don't look like me, did you come here legal? Please show me your papers...
@@armandredman So would it help you if they started talking about the Latino community that way? How about they invent disgustin eating habits and make up whole cloth stories about strange Latino marriage customs and depict Latinos as dangerous and predatory and how Latinos are about to destroy the country and take everything over and burn it down? Woud that help you understand what is going on here? Gimme a break you should know better.
It’s really sad that the people who needed to hear this the most will never watch this but it was such a good segment
Bravo Anand Bravo!!!
It was so emotional
Anand is always right to the point. One of the best!
Thank you Mr. Anand! That was beautifully said. 💙💙💙
Anand, Thank you sooo much for your contribution this morning. Share that whenever you can, wherever you can.
My blood line is Yavapai and apache. My families go back hundreds of years. The early settlers, immigrants took over the natives and incarcerated all of them, were are only taught misinformation. Trump's wife was an immigrant until she became first lady! And her family just became citizens, only because Trump was president! Did anyone ask them what they ate? Heavens my grandmother was born in Southern Arizona before it was Arizona. Her grandparents and their grandparents on and on only knew that this land was a gift to serve! Americans are all immigrants at some point!
Excellent response. Highly unlikely Joe's roots to go back hundreds & hundreds & hundreds of years, earliest settlers arrived in the 1600's and unless his family derives from Pilgrim Fathers stock his claim is dubious at best.
Joe injects himself in every conversation. He also touts his time in Congress. Don't forget, he was part of the tea party for which the heritage foundation bore them.... What a joke!;
Thank you Annan and Joe. Immigrants truly believe in the US. That this country is the ONLY ONE that offers everyone that is willing to roll up their sleeves and work hard,the great opportunity to succeed. And that is exceptional. Every one all over the world wants to experience this in spite of the the current situation.
Sorry not every one.. Only people who origin from countries where their situation is worse than in the US.
@@femaleonthewatchExcept for the rich and/or famous
You have one sick puppy running for your highest office. WOW!
I know, cackling kamala is insane
Anand was delightfully cogent and enlightening on this topic. His perspective is clear, uplifting, and relatable and he really puts our bad actors in their place. He needs to be heard by more Americans.
Joe Scarborough and others often forget to mention Regan’s racism as things people don’t like about Regan.
Same with Nixon's racism.
And his lethal homophobia
"Blaming the Jews..." How original of him. 😮
Oh my gosh, that got lost on me. I reacted at first, then got subsumed. Exactly!
Every conspiracy theory becomes anti-Semitism if you leave it to stew long enough.
We are not doing 1930's Germany!! FDJT!!
It sounds so belittling when Joe says that he talked to “immigrants” instead of “people that immigrated here”.
But anyway, Anand’s words were so powerful. He absolutely nailed it.
Totally agree. That's Joe for ya, often his mouth gets in the way of his brains
great conversation, spot on... vote, vote, vote for Harris to enact the american dream
In my silence I pray for u , Agus
So lovely picking up his wife at 1 am evrynight for her work shift
Someone's lost at 1am also!🤣🤣🤣🔥🍰
as a german i am watching the development in your country in disbelief. having learned about our history extensively in school i am wondering, have you not learned anything from our history? but then again witnessing populism rising in europe as well i guess its a global trend that we ALL together MUST defeat!!!!! on a side note indian food with its variety of spices is freakin awesome!!!!!
Does America really want to hear Trump talk for four more years.
Kamala’s vocal cords are in her nose 👃
No
NO. Why though does Chief Justice Roberts have Trump's back? That truly baffles me. These justices won't live forever yet their decisions will.
I don't 😊
Nope
Anand is so brilliant, human, eloquent....he tells it like it is...Trump is a very little man......wheras this guy has class, brains and heart !!! Thank you !!!❤
I love all the comments. Well said Anand 💙💙💙
" Donald Trump is dangerously demented." Dr John Gartner psychologist.
FJB
😂 says the party of Gr mers and pdf files
@@ziff1066describes your wanna be dictator and many in his crew.
@@ziff1066 And DIDDY supporters.
Trump voters are dangerously demented, without voters Trump would be nowhere nor would have won in 2016. Blame the voters.
Donald Trump’s mom is an immigrant from Scotland so he’s a son of an immigrant, too. His two wives are immigrants. His son then is a son of an immigrant. Yet he treats immigrants so horribly. Why? What Anand is saying makes so much sense.
They're white
Trump only likes white immigrants. I think that’s been very obvious.
Donald’s dad was an immigrant. Also he left his homeland because he did not want to serve in the war effort some years later he wanted to return to his homeland, but the government will not allow him to return.
Maybe he doesnt think very much of them either...except they are related to him.
What a beautiful and inspiring interview.
Dont forget the USA had large Fascist rallies in the 1930s and sure its not gone away
And they tried taking FDR out in a coup like trump just tried.
He's perfected that Rush Limbaugh style of hating everyone he needs support from.
Anand is so brilliant and wonderful.
We need so many more “Anands”❤️❤️ Bring them on! Do you know anyone as metaphorically articulate on his feet? Joe..let Anand talk, for gods sake!
Anand, you are priceless. You just said it all. Please Joe and Mika, let me speak for a minute on your show. I am an immigrant and it makes me sad that trump has been allowed to dehumanize immigrants. Go all over the world and see how people who has never traveled out of their countries talk good about this Country. Please get some of us on your show to educate trump and his MAGA followers. 🙏
'' Wherever they burn books they will also, in the end, burn human beings.''
- Heinrich Heine
My diet is Korean Asian. I'm Italian Irish American. Visited Seoul in May, 2022. Visited Busan, 2024, for the entire month. NEVER had ramyeon. Dined on VEGETABLES, beef and pork. Very LITTLE bread. Lots of bone broth & rice. Returned home 8 lbs lighter. Oh, WALKED a lot! I understand the Tuscany, Italy Food Tour is healthy and clean eating. Can't wait! Kudos to all my immigrant ancestors and present friends for giving me life and substance. 🥰🥰
Thank you Amanda for being honest. I hope people will have some understanding.
Just trumps words are creating ugliness
Because that's what he is.
Every word he utters is ugliness.
An artist named Ren has a song called “Money Game”. In in it he says we are all immigrants or descendants of immigrants. He also says since when is freedom of speech a freedom to hate.
he is a amazing artist.
Donald just needs to be quite and leave people alone
We are NOT GOING BACK!
I want no harm to come to Trump or anybody. I'm a pacifist. I want to see him safe and sound where he belongs in prison.
When he expressed that parents taste what their grandchildren and unborn grandchildren will eat one day! Ohhh that was perfect.
This is one of the best reports/broadcasts I have seen in quite some time. Such an important message and so eloquently put by, both, Joe Scarborough and Anand Giridharadas. Almost none of us native-born Americans has any idea about the lines at the embassies of which Anand speaks during this conversation. It's very enlightening.
I have been a teacher for almost 30 years and have had the honor of families of different countries, origins, and cultures take me out to dinner or invite me to their homes to share a dinner that they have prepared, not only to welcome me and show me their appreciation but to share a little bit about themselves and their cultures. I have counted myself very fortunate to have had these experiences.
Speaking of sharing, please share this video with everyone you can, so more people get this incredible message! 🙏💕
This man is full on in dementia, my Mom is in a home already, and he is worse than she is…this is elder abuse
And almost half of the electorate will vote for him. Such primitive people! I have never been in that line and I will never be in that line.
Poor wittle donnie, given everything on a golden platter and he's so small in his soul.
Soul? You think?
@@libbycollins9349 No! Just kidding.
Thank You, Anand.
Just call him "ADOLPH".
Adolf .
Kamala grew up in a home that’s worth $18m right now
Hitler would have shot Trump and endorsed Kamala
His VP candidate did in the past.
FYI, Adolf.
I worked at a research university. Many immigrant students had been brought to the US to take advantage of our education system. The parents sacrificed and the students typically had incredible work ethics. Too many citizens take all of this for granted. The families typically stay here and contribute greatly to our communities.
You would think that "I will blame the Jews" is a phrase that no one would say out loud, but of course DT would. Even in front of a room full of Jewish people and the people who care about them. That anyone gives him a platform or a vote makes me angry and profoundly sad.
Orange Don needs to be behind bars, not in the oval office.
maybe other countries should have a Trump travel ban?
Yes.
Yes every countries should ban Trump from there country. I wish we could.
Joe: "America is the land of opportunity, like no other land!"
This type of American exceptionalism is part of the problem, leading Americans to also think "It can't happen here."
Other countries are also lands of opportunity, in the same way and to the same degree. America is great, but it's not uniquely great.
Thank you Anand for telling the beautiful truth.
I remember the first time I returned from Europe after my first trip, the agent looking at my passport finished by saying "Welcome Home".
Every time that happens, I want to get down and kiss the ground, no matter where I’ve just beeen!
@@libbycollins9349The ground is my Motherland
I am an American today because years ago, I was one of the people standing in that line at 7:00 AM, waiting and hoping I would be one of the lucky ones who would receive a visa.
I wish you guys did a video on the Haitians in Springfield working all the jobs that the locals won’t work and it’s saving their city for them and adding a quarter million dollars to the city every year.
Thank you Mr. Giridhadaras, that beautiful speech brought tears to my eyes.
As a Chinese American who was born in Texas but with parents from Hong Kong I heard a lot of the same stuff growing up. This is why even though I'm an American citizen and my family came here legally this rhetoric still makes me very uneasy.
Yup racists always use the same old tired tropes.
" My supporters are basement dwellers " Donald Trump.
I gotta know your gender for my thesis
Says the people who put costumes on and read to kids at DQ story time 😂
@@ziff1066 Oh Those They/Them sock puppets.
Kamala lied about working at McDonalds
@@RandyWatson-q2t Are you sure it's for "your thesis" or for your "Diddy-like" desire? The truth shall set you free, speak up!
Beautiful, practical, powerful.
Over the last 10 years I have come to understand too well what my aunt in NYC meant when she got angry with the local media ''Elevating garbage to relevance.'' -that was her take on the NYC press and their tendency to gush over anything Trump.
You’re talking about immigrants, black American immigrants and the great migration black Americans built this country and contributed to every facet of our of our lives without their inventions we would still be in the dark ages. These are the immigrants of America and they should be recognized for their contributions and sacrifices and Acknowledgment of the atrocities that were attributed against them and so yes, America is the dream and I feel whoever don’t want to subscribe to that dream in America and it’s freedoms should leave this country and let the real Americans stand together and fulfill Martin Luther King’s dreams.
Yep🦅🇺🇸🗽💙💙💙🗽🇺🇸🦅💯
The enslaved Black people were not immigrants. We didn’t flee some country. We were captured/kidnapped/sold and transported to these lands.
All about balance. Protect the border, but also protect the dream.
Brilliant.❤
I recognize everything Anand talks about. I’ve experienced every example. My family and I had to flee political turmoil in a country when I was a kid. We didn’t end up in the U.S. but we still had the same experiences Anand describes.
There is a Haitian family or business able to sue this man for PTSD. Just waiting for the inevitable
I wish the media would DO THEIR JOBS and ask him what exactly is an infested country? What countries is he referring to as infested? Infested with what specifically?
Regan started this modern day GOP racist mess, Joe.
I respect every lawful immigrant ever. The thought of having to leave my own country and my family and go to a whole different country by myself starting from scratch? Nightmare fuel. Respect.
7 a.m., the long lines outside the American embassies of the world. Joyful tears. 😊
Very insightful. Things I haven’t thought about but sure appreciate this insight. ❤
kind if amazed Anand is doing these mainstream shows now but its a great development. think mainstream media is smarter and more human as a result.
Sadly, I saw this dehumanization even as a small kid from the 70s/80s, but in my area of Iowa, it was the Chinese that ate alternative proteins, never true.
46 days until Trump is voted out at ballot box we will get dream back!
Democrats are going to cheat again. That's why the Supreme Court will be deciding this election.
Phew, when he said, some immigrants eat very little because they can taste what their grandchildren will eat", that got me a little choked up.
Imagine these lies for minimum 4 more years? And he is not even in office right now. Really, close your eyes and imagine it.
Goosebumps!! Thank you
Real wise words from Giridharadas. Wish Joe would not destroy the experience of a well-spoken young man.
Anand's very intuitive. I enjoy the interviews.
This man is a world class thinker
Trump has mashed potatoes For brains.
It’s gotten to the point that when you hear someone who is clear and well spoken
It’s a bit of a shock.
Trump
Vance
MTG
Boebert
McConell
And Many others
Are ridiculously bad at communicating.
And
A large part of that is that are trying to fool you
THIS! I work in the medical field and I know so many people who immigrated to this country WITH PHDs but were forced because of licensing issues or college accreditation issues.
We have 127 million more people in America since 1980. Government grows to support all of us. 40% more people needs more innovation, more intergration, more surprise. Let us do this with Kamala
Counterpoint. Most of my family was here centuries before Columbus got lost or the Nords went a Viking & we don't have that same American Dream at all. Politicians like you Joe work very hard to other us, prevent us from voting & telling our story as that of savages & animals who need to be tamed. So your tale of the uplifting American Dream that "everyone came here from somewhere else" falls flat on me. The place my ancestors came from was paved in blood along a trail of tears. I am an American Citizen living in a very different America than yours Joe. And I really wish you hadn't interupted and talked over Anand explaining the nonwhite experience to you. You could learn a lot from him if you'd just hold your tongue long enough to listen.
Italian immigrants brought their recipes from the " old country". One of the best things that ever happened to this country. I don't have to go to Italy to get that food. I can actually get good versions of it near where I live.
If, heaven forbid, Drumpf becomes president again, i will be in line at the French Consulate - requesting a residence visa. America, as we know it, will cease to exist, and i cannot imagine living in it.
Of course the whole lie and aftermath of this ridiculous, most recent B.S. of the tRump/Vance team is deplorable. But I will add that when I watch Morning Joe, I wish Joe would learn to be more circumspect. He blab blab blabs and hardly lets his guests get their opinions out. We have to wait so long for Joe to rehash restate and regurgitate, as if his opinion is what we're waiting to hear. Sorry Joe, but Mika et al are much more succinct!
Wow when he said about his mother cooking pasta because of her new found freedom really got me. Something I take for granted never ever even crossed my mind of the freedom I was born with