Discourse - Netaji and the INA: A Military Assessment

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 июл 2016
  • A discourse by Maj.Gen. G D Bakshi, Defence Expert & Military Historian.

Комментарии • 100

  • @briefstory2646
    @briefstory2646 6 лет назад +40

    Now HISTORY should revise..........Hats off to Bakshi ji and Netaji

  • @neilm9004
    @neilm9004 7 лет назад +56

    ## Had Bose been alive, he would have been the greatest leader of India. Gandhi & Nehru had eaten the fruits of all the hard work done by Netaji, Bhagat Singh, Veer Savarkar, etc. Together Bhagat Singh, Veer Savarkar & Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose would have been the most fatal combination against the Britishers. Our History books should be re-written giving due credit to Netaji, Bhagat Singh & Veer Savarkar. We all should start an online petition or a mass movement for getting it done.

    • @prasannadatta9171
      @prasannadatta9171 6 лет назад +1

      Neil M exactly

    • @rajakanojiya
      @rajakanojiya 5 лет назад +2

      Yes must do that !

    • @ritwikraj9
      @ritwikraj9 5 лет назад +2

      No need to add savarkar to that list ! this shows your complete ignorance of the knowledge ! please go and learn history and basic facts like bhagat singh was a extreme communist ! and netaji socialist and savarkar ( extreme right wing)

    • @ritwikraj9
      @ritwikraj9 5 лет назад

      @sky net dictatorship ? bhai logic gaand me daal liye ho? matlab he netaji was fighting to remove a dictatorship to establish another ? kya bola raha hai bhai? and nehru was a socialist not a liberal ( So was netaji .) kyu smart banne ki kosish karte ho yaar ? naa aand na gaaand ka aur gyan chodhenge brahmand ka .

    • @ritwikraj9
      @ritwikraj9 5 лет назад

      @sky net maine bjp vote kiya hai , shant hoja .

  • @neilm9004
    @neilm9004 7 лет назад +47

    ## Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Veer Savarkar, Masterda Surya Sen, Chandrashekhar Ajad- all these freedom fighters' portraits should also be there on Indian currency notes of different denominations.

    • @swarnamohanty3121
      @swarnamohanty3121 6 лет назад

      Neil M Sir the problem is India can't handle so many martyrs Naxalites, Maoists, Kashmir terrorists, in North east etc. So we do not recognize any terrorists had any role in creation of secular democratic India.

    • @SamvedIyer
      @SamvedIyer 5 лет назад +3

      @@swarnamohanty3121 Except, they weren't terrorists. Surprise, flatbrains!

    • @anglobhodaighosh6472
      @anglobhodaighosh6472 2 года назад

      @@swarnamohanty3121 you are trying to hide the real revolutioneries of India . Are you a British agent in India??

    • @chaitanyasharma812
      @chaitanyasharma812 2 года назад +1

      Who was veer 😂

  • @swatitambe4322
    @swatitambe4322 5 лет назад +11

    Salute....one man army (and his army)🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @KrishnaKumar-rc7tg
    @KrishnaKumar-rc7tg 5 лет назад +9

    I'm absolutely shocked by the facts that I just heard from you sir... I shall be ordering this book today itself...Thank you for sharing this revealing info of our great Netaji.

  • @riyasengupta1981
    @riyasengupta1981 5 лет назад +8

    since Atal ji a change started place in India, a change towards independence of thought, since last 20 years India as a nation had has been in the mode of transition, with the great popularity of Modi ji the change seems to have reached a new height and there is no going back now.... This is the moment which another great person Swami Vivekananda predicted more than a century back.... The rise if india...

  • @DrAnandRamanTiwari
    @DrAnandRamanTiwari 3 года назад +1

    Thanks a lot Maj Bakshi Sir... we the youth of India are proud of your efforts for our Netaji.....INA IS SOLE CAUSE OF OUR FREEDOM IN 1947

  • @bhaswatighoshhajra8894
    @bhaswatighoshhajra8894 3 года назад +1

    My regards to you. The patriot of patriots Netaji is the most neglected person in Indian history .Netaji and INA will be in our mind always
    .

  • @rameswarprasad6566
    @rameswarprasad6566 3 года назад +1

    Salute from Fiji island's God bless you.

  • @Rajendra4444
    @Rajendra4444 8 лет назад +8

    Interesting discourse !

  • @adarshupadhyay8738
    @adarshupadhyay8738 5 лет назад +3

    Big supporter of bakshiji

  • @AllamaMashriqi
    @AllamaMashriqi 5 лет назад +2

    Allama Mashriqi and Subhas Chandra Bose’s Historical Papers
    A few days ago, the West Bengal Government in India took the noteworthy step of releasing 64 files and other materials on Subhas Chandra Bose (Netaji). Even though Bose had serious political differences with Mahatma Gandhi, India recognizes Bose as a national hero. Indian newspapers and television stations as well as heads of state and government officials continue to highlight Bose’s struggle for freedom (as seen in the examples below):
    • In January of 2003, President Abdul Kalam visited Netaji Bhawan (on the eve of his birthday)
    • On January 20, 2013, Shri Pranab Mukherjee, the President of India, inaugurated Netaji's 116th birth anniversary celebrations
    • President Pranab Mukherjee and Prime Minister Narendra Modi honored Bose on his 118th birth anniversary in 2015. The Indian Express wrote, “Mukherjee paid a floral tribute at a portrait of Netaji at Rashtrapati Bhavan in the capital...Modi in a statement said: ‘His bravery, courage and patriotic zeal inspire us. On his birth anniversary, I bow to the proud son of India, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose…Subhas Babu’s organisation and leadership skills were exceptional. He was a phenomenal personality, for whom the good of the nation was paramount.’”
    By contrast, the Governments in Pakistan, India, and Britain have tried to bury Allama Mashriqi and the Khaksar Tehrik’s role in history, despite their tremendous sacrifices in bringing freedom to the sub-continent. Each Government seems to have its own reasons for suppressing Mashriqi and the Khaksars. In Pakistan, it is because of Mashriqi’s opposition to partition and political differences with Quaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah. In India, it is because of Mashriqi’s political differences with Mahatma Gandhi. And in Britain, it is because Mashriqi did not work with the rulers and fought to end their rule in India. Just because Mashriqi had differing views, however, does not mean that these Governments should be able to use it as justification for suppressing his pivotal role in the freedom movement. The Governments of Pakistan, India and Britain should follow the West Bengal Government’s example and publically release Mashriqi and the Khaksar Tehrik’s documents, pamphlets, booklets, newspapers, photo albums and other materials (which were confiscated before and after the partition of India in 1947). In addition, they should release information on Mashriqi’s trips to foreign countries and correspondence with world leaders and other prominent individuals.
    - Nasim Yousaf (Author & Mashriqi’s grandson), September 20, 2015
    Some interesting facts about Allama Mashriqi and Subhas Chandra Bose:
    • Both used militarism to liberate India
    • Mashriqi founded a private army of Khaksars in British India in 1930, whereas Subhas Chandra Bose became head of the Azad Hind Fauj in 1943
    • Both met Adolf Hitler, Mashriqi in 1926 and Bose in 1942
    • A large number of Bose’s followers, including Major General S.D. Khan, joined Allama Mashriqi’s Khaksar Tehrik (see Allama Mashriqi’s weekly newspaper, Al-Islah, from the late 1940s)

  • @biratzvlog6588
    @biratzvlog6588 2 года назад +1

    Great g d bakshi sir you are telling the real truth.gandhi and nehru was a real fraud.Netaji was a real patriotic person and visionary leader and youth icon.Netaji and INA sat India free.jai hind

  • @pavanshukla5418
    @pavanshukla5418 6 лет назад +13

    Great insight. Need to rewrite Indian History.

    • @advocatedaliyasaha188
      @advocatedaliyasaha188 6 лет назад

      Give some Contact who r well known abt Netaji Death Conspiracy, I want to start a REVOLT about Netaji . Pl.... dsanjoy36@yahoo.co.in / Sanjoy Kr. Das / TRIPURA

  • @firozfiroz4903
    @firozfiroz4903 6 лет назад +1

    Thanks you Bakhi sir.

  • @MegaAvimanyu
    @MegaAvimanyu 5 лет назад +2

    Thank you and Salute to you, Sir, for the truth, acutally gandhi and nehru don't had the political perceptions and foresight more over they were cowered, they blackmail people emotions only.

  • @maheshkrathi1645
    @maheshkrathi1645 6 лет назад +2

    who are we as a people, what depts we can sink to help our masters.. excellent words by col Bagchi...

    • @prasunpathak1912
      @prasunpathak1912 6 лет назад

      Mahesh K Rathi major general gd Bakhsi

    • @advocatedaliyasaha188
      @advocatedaliyasaha188 6 лет назад +1

      pl. give me some contact No. by which I can start a REVOLT about Netaji Death Conspiracy, please...... Sanjoyji/ TRIPURA. Mob. 9862017550

  • @swatitambe4322
    @swatitambe4322 5 лет назад +1

    Amazing.... Thanks

  • @radharamanmondal4722
    @radharamanmondal4722 4 года назад +1

    Major ji bravo spill fire facts about Netaji to the people of India as they need to know about the real facts and identify the people who delebrately suppressed this

  • @harishchandra9034
    @harishchandra9034 3 года назад

    Bakshi Saheb. Neta jee ek MAHAN Aatma hain AnamiMahaprabhu hain Aadhyatmik shakti hain Aaj bhi Zinda hain Panch Bhautik Sharir me hain Samay se Aayenge Tisara Vishva yuddha ke Samay Aayenge. Bharat Bhumi ki Raksha Lajja hai Bachai Santo ne lok aur Parlok Bane ye Yukti Batai Santo ne Hoga Akhand Bharat tab first Vishva-Guru Kahlayega

  • @purush4200
    @purush4200 2 года назад +1

    As an Indian, our countrymen must pressurise the govt. to know what happened to Netaji. At least we have a right to know about Netaji last days😥

  • @dralexanderroy5879
    @dralexanderroy5879 4 года назад +1

    We will never forget you..you are our true Hero. Jai Hind.

  • @AbhishekSharma-vf5xd
    @AbhishekSharma-vf5xd 2 года назад +2

    First PM of India Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

  • @abhisheknv8672
    @abhisheknv8672 7 лет назад +10

    he wasn't killed in Siberia boss. he was close friends with Stalin

    • @prasunpathak1912
      @prasunpathak1912 6 лет назад +2

      Abhishek Nv tu major gen se jyada janta h ?

    • @advocatedaliyasaha188
      @advocatedaliyasaha188 6 лет назад

      I want to disclose the TRUE HISTORY OF NETAJI, Pl. help me with some contact No. like BAKSI etc......

    • @SamvedIyer
      @SamvedIyer 5 лет назад +1

      @@prasunpathak1912 The Major General is just giving a theory, it seems. There's actually no evidence they killed him. Why would they?

    • @debiroy9470
      @debiroy9470 5 лет назад

      @@SamvedIyer no he has proofs of all this in his book

    • @SamvedIyer
      @SamvedIyer 5 лет назад

      @@debiroy9470 Could these proofs please be highlighted? Because if these are just hear-say accounts, it's not evidence. Usually, when a prisoner is sentenced to death, there's a proper procedure followed.

  • @banerjeesiddharth05
    @banerjeesiddharth05 5 лет назад +2

    Nice facts sir

  • @GauravSingh-hy8md
    @GauravSingh-hy8md 6 лет назад +1

    Great

  • @mayanksingh8652
    @mayanksingh8652 4 года назад +2

    Jai Hind!

  • @shivchander6454
    @shivchander6454 4 года назад

    याद रखिये सबसे बड़ा अपराध अन्याय सहना और गलत के साथ समझौता करना है.
    सुभाष चन्द्र बोस :
    महात्मा गाँधी :

  • @pabitranandan3114
    @pabitranandan3114 5 лет назад +3

    Gumnami baba was Netaji .

  • @ToThoseWhoVanished
    @ToThoseWhoVanished 5 месяцев назад

    Gumnaami is not Bose. Baba was not a tortured vegetable. He had a temper as per stories.

  • @jimmysammy1210
    @jimmysammy1210 3 года назад

    Can anyone please give link to the full programme

  • @ravichandel8690
    @ravichandel8690 6 лет назад +3

    more videos of netaji by general upload if any one have it. I really want to know the truth

  • @siddhartharay1835
    @siddhartharay1835 5 лет назад

    Where can I get that book,

  • @saketkumar7797
    @saketkumar7797 5 лет назад

    Jai hind

  • @padmabharali1306
    @padmabharali1306 3 года назад +1

    Why people look uninterested

  • @nishantraj3330
    @nishantraj3330 6 лет назад +8

    If Russian killed netaji they are first enemy ?????

  • @singhpraa3681
    @singhpraa3681 6 лет назад +4

    After plane crase he go to Manchuria

  • @uttam_5
    @uttam_5 Год назад

    Great! Poverty of India was result of deep political failure . Strong support of common people require to strong leader.

  • @DrGorachandGhosh2710
    @DrGorachandGhosh2710 2 года назад +1

    Your theory is wrong . Netaji died on 18 Aug 1945. General Tsunamasa Shidei died on the sopt of accident and his dead body was brought 5Yasukuni Shrine and his ceremony performrd there. Amazon books have resolved the death mystery of Netaji since 19 September 2017 having all sorts of proof all over the world.

  • @ankushthakur6938
    @ankushthakur6938 2 года назад

    DNA with out electrophorogram...a lot of experts confirmed hand writing match of netaji nd gumnami bawa

  • @anirbandas4524
    @anirbandas4524 6 лет назад

    What is the book name? Pls share

    • @sandy00915
      @sandy00915 6 лет назад

      Anirban Das The Indian Samurai

  • @pabitranandan3114
    @pabitranandan3114 5 лет назад +3

    8 dislike V kiya !!

  • @shaukatjahangir1396
    @shaukatjahangir1396 5 лет назад +1

    good, but why are against pakistan

    • @adityakumar-wd1xh
      @adityakumar-wd1xh 5 лет назад +1

      Ever since partition the politicians on both sides used the violence caused during partition as an excuse to antagonise each other, while I agree that excuse is justificable enough but instead of antagonising each other it makes more sense to blame the cause of it(Jinnah, Gandhi, Nehru) and work together to improve the dire condition both the countries are in, since there is no other probable approach remotely as productive.

  • @homemaintenance628
    @homemaintenance628 5 лет назад

    Bakhshi ji ab kya huwa chup ho ker baith gaye, abhi sirf trailer dikhaya hai tu gayab ho Gaye. Picture abhi baqi hai mere dost.

  • @vn4395
    @vn4395 6 лет назад +1

    some body would have lost his top job if he comes back.... ;)

  • @balendas4511
    @balendas4511 2 года назад

    Subhasisnotolnyindiaherobutalsoworldherotoday

  • @multiverse3342
    @multiverse3342 5 лет назад

    20 वीं शताब्दी की शुरुआत में जापान ने तेजी से औद्योगिकीकरण किया था, और फिर उन उपनिवेशों की तलाश शुरू की, जो पूर्व और दक्षिण एशिया में अपने उद्योगों के लिए कच्चे माल के स्रोत और स्रोत हैं। लेकिन ये क्षेत्र पहले से ही कब्जे में थे या यूरोपीय शक्तियों के नियंत्रण में थे। इसलिए इन क्षेत्रों से इन शक्तियों को बाहर करने के लिए जापानियों ने 1930 के दशक के शुरुआती दिनों में, साम्राज्यवादियों की तरह पूर्वी और दक्षिणी एशिया में बाजारों और कच्चे माल पर कब्जा करने के लिए आतंकवादी विस्तारवाद की राह पर चल पड़े। उन्होंने कोरिया, फिर मंचूरिया, चीन के कुछ हिस्सों पर विजय प्राप्त की, और पर्ल हार्बर, वियतनाम आदि के बाद इंडोनेशिया, सिंगापुर और बर्मा के रूप में दक्षिण की ओर जा रहे थे। बर्मा से जापानियों ने बोस और आईएनए की मदद लेकर अंग्रेजों से लड़ना शुरू कर दिया। क्या उन्होंने भारतीयों के लिए एक सामाजिक सेवा के रूप में या विशाल भारतीय बाजार पर कब्जा करने और कच्चे माल को अपार करने के लिए ऐसा किया था? यहां तक ​​कि ऐतिहासिक वास्तविकताओं और जापानी फासीवादी साम्राज्यवाद की प्रकृति का मामूली ज्ञान और ज्ञान यह स्पष्ट कर देगा कि उन्होंने ब्रिटिशों को हरा दिया था और भारत को जीत लिया था, बोस की उनकी उपयोगिता खत्म हो गई थी, और फिर वे या तो उसे टक्कर देंगे, या उन्हें एक कठपुतली 'राज्य प्रमुख' बनाया, जिस तरह से उन्होंने 'मनचुकुओ' के अंतिम चीनी सम्राट पु यी सिर को बनाया।
    1945 में जब जापान ने आत्मसमर्पण किया तो बोस ने भी अंग्रेजों के खिलाफ लड़ाई छोड़ दी। जिस तरह से चीनियों ने जापानियों के खिलाफ लड़ाई लड़ी, उसने अंग्रेजों के खिलाफ छापामार युद्ध क्यों नहीं शुरू किया? छापामार युद्ध में कोई भी शत्रु के शस्त्रों से लड़ता है, पहले उनसे वह छीनता है। तथ्य यह है कि वह नहीं दिखाता था कि आदमी में कुछ भी नहीं था।
    बोस जर्मनी गए और उन राक्षसों हिटलर और हिमलर (यूट्यूब पर उनकी तस्वीरें देखें) के साथ शौक़ीन थे और नाजियों के साथ सहयोग करने के लिए कब्जा किए गए भारतीय सैनिकों की एक सेना को उठाने की पेशकश की। इस प्रकार उन्होंने नाजी सहयोगी बनने की पेशकश की। कुछ लोग कहते हैं कि बोस को नाज़ियों के भयानक कामों का पता नहीं था। यह सच हो सकता है कि वह गैस चैंबरों के बारे में नहीं जानता था लेकिन वह 1941 में जर्मनी चला गया था, हालांकि हिटलर के सत्ता में आने के बाद से यहूदियों का घृणित उत्पीड़न 1933 से चल रहा था। नवंबर 1938 में नाज़ियों द्वारा क्रिस्टलनचैट (क्रिस्टल नाइट) का आयोजन किया गया था जिसमें हजारों यहूदियों की हत्या कर दी गई थी और उनके सैकड़ों आराधनालय जला दिए गए थे (देखें RUclips पर) यह सार्वजनिक रूप से किया गया था, इसलिए यह नहीं माना जा सकता कि बोस इससे अनजान थे। जब नाजियों ने उनकी शानदार योजनाओं में ज्यादा दिलचस्पी नहीं दिखाई, तो वे जापानी फासीवादियों के सहयोगी बन गए। फाल्ट की तरह अपनी तिजोरी की महत्वाकांक्षा को पूरा करने के लिए, उसने अपनी आत्मा को मेफिस्तोफेल्स को बेच दिया। वास्तव में उन्होंने इसे दो बार बेचा, पहले नाजी राक्षसों को, और फिर जापानी शैतानों को, जिन्होंने शंघाई, नानकिंग आदि में चीनी का नरसंहार किया था (देखें शंघाई और नानकिंग नरसंहार के बारे में यूट्यूब पर)।
    INA ने जापानियों द्वारा दिए गए हथियारों से लड़ाई लड़ी, और अगर बोस ने भारत को एक जापानी उपनिवेश बनाने के अपने उद्देश्य पर आपत्ति जताई थी, तो उन्होंने INA को हथियारों की आपूर्ति में कटौती कर दी होगी और यह INA का अंत होगा। बोस को इसका एहसास हुआ, और इसलिए उन्होंने अंडमान द्वीप समूह में जापानी अत्याचारों पर कभी आपत्ति नहीं जताई। अनुज धर का सिद्धांत कि जापानियों ने भारत को अपना उपनिवेश नहीं बनाया होगा क्योंकि यह बुद्ध की भूमि हँसने योग्य है। क्या फ़ासीवादी साम्राज्यवादी वास्तव में बुद्ध की परवाह करते हैं?
    यद्यपि युवावस्था में वे देशभक्त थे, उन्होंने आई। सी। एस। देश की सेवा करने के लिए, बोस बाद में अति महत्वाकांक्षी हो गए, और गांधी द्वारा कांग्रेस के अध्यक्ष पद से हटा दिए जाने के बाद, वह पूरी तरह से घबरा गए, और बेशर्मी से फासीवादियों के साथ सहयोग किया

    • @finalassault07oct42
      @finalassault07oct42 3 года назад

      Phir bhi agr Bharat ki leadership Neta ji ke pass hoti to aaj Bharat kahi aur hota. China ke logo ko Japanese be to maara hi thaa par maose Tung ne to apne peoples ko hi mardiya thaa 30 lakh around.

  • @ravichandel8690
    @ravichandel8690 6 лет назад +1

    top job is PM of india by nehru

  • @Papa-ti2ce
    @Papa-ti2ce 5 лет назад

    These kind of senile leaders have gotten into the habit of imagining alternate reality

    • @adityakumar-wd1xh
      @adityakumar-wd1xh 5 лет назад

      Stop trying so hard to live in denial, you're the one living in a convenient alternate reality, I wouldn't even argue with the likes of you, just Google 'how India actually got independence' once

  • @acharjyaji
    @acharjyaji 5 лет назад

    This is hypocrisy... GEN BAKHSHI says that there is no memorial of INA soldiers anywhere... Gen Bakhshi was a top rankings officer of Indian Army yet there is not even a single picture of Neta ji in any Army offices ... Army never made any memorial for INA soldiers ... Indian Government always respected INA soldiers that's why Nehru who was a part of a committee who were defending INA officers at the famous red fort judgment.

    • @adityakumar-wd1xh
      @adityakumar-wd1xh 5 лет назад +6

      Defending from who? Themselves?
      INA was disbanded and EVERY soldier lost their job because if Nehru and Gandhi hadn't done that then it would have been impossible for them to hide the actual fact and get credit for themselves while they deserved none.

    • @indiaworld3530
      @indiaworld3530 4 года назад +2

      Yeah. By striking down their pensions and refusing to reinstate them, Pigeru & co did a lot for INA.

    • @rj6169
      @rj6169 2 года назад +1

      In that period govt spied netaji family upto 20 years

  • @shoaibabdullah4769
    @shoaibabdullah4769 5 лет назад

    Psycho hy abnormal. He can't talk normally . He need a good psychiatrist . He always talk like a losee . He is frustrated

    • @parleseniortv2685
      @parleseniortv2685 4 года назад

      How dude or the same treatment is needed for u

    • @anglobhodaighosh6472
      @anglobhodaighosh6472 2 года назад

      Shoaib ji , don't get frustrated with the truth revealed !!!
      JAI HIND

  • @sharadowasdr
    @sharadowasdr 4 года назад

    90% emotional bluster 10% terrible non-analysis. This is "military assessment"? This is nothing ! WTH does Bose's alleged escape to Russia have to do with INA's military assessment ? Half the video is just speculation about Bose's disappearance !

  • @subhamagrawal8243
    @subhamagrawal8243 Год назад

    He was in ayodhya, As babaji