It's even funnier when you notice that while Michael is trying to escape with Edgar a sheep just walks into the hole and a wolf is at the door trying to get in. Ryan's house is a magnet for animals.
I think Micheal's original plan was to swap Edgar with the sheep . . . but then he gave up when he realized how dumb both the sheep and Edgar were. Regardless of which one might've ended up in the hole, they undoubtedly would be named Edgar XD
On a desk in the FBI field office in Houston, Texas there is a file marked "Ryan Haywood". I'm not saying it's a high priority, but it's there. It has to be.
I think animals are probably programmed to go to brighter areas during the night. Had Michael placed the door back, Edgar would not have been able to reenter.
Geoff killed Edgar. The original Edgar I mean. If you watch the video you see that Michael leaves Edgar in the cactus field. And later Geoff goes to the cactus field, finds a cow and killed it
This is one of the few moments I wish they all had face cams. I just want to imagine what Ryan's face looked like when he said those memorable words, "Edgar is the one in the hole." Followed by everyone else's reactions, before and after Ryan's famous line.
After a millennia stuck in the hole Edgar had forgotten the outside world. Not knowing what to do desperately tried to get back in it. But out of nowhere a bear showed up and pushed it to the outside world. And so began the real of adventures of Edgar Free.
Michael released a cow that was a shadow of its former self, bearing the scars from its confinement that will never heal nor shall it forget what had happened. But that just means Ryan is subjecting a new, innocent cow to its solitary confinement. Freeing "Edgar" only served to spread the madness... ...Why am I putting this as my comment? XD
MilesTailsProwerfan9 A rescue mission that was destined to fail, which caused another innocent cow to inherit the name and life of Edgar. And thus, it became "the one in the hole."
Edgar is the only one in the hole if i dies it just posseses a new body and only ryan can see the diference due to the madness constantly being upgrade to new levels of insanity due to the all knowing evil soul
So you have two people saying they are actively looking for leather and Edgar keeps trying to go back to the guaranteed safety of Kung Fu House. Who's the real monster here Michael?
Geoff: Ryan, where's Edgar? Ryan: .......... Geoff: Ryan, where is Edgar?!? Ryan: He's at home. Geoff: Oh...where does he live? (TomSka voice) In the hole. *dramatic sting*
I'd like them to do a let's play called "Tower of Edgar." Where it is them, The achievement hunters minus Ryan in a hole at bed rock trying to climb back up to the surface with nothing but their bare hands. All they would need is to press the button to make a hole, and then just climb out.
hey i am not supposed to see my subscriptions on other videos... its reminds me of when i would see my highschool teachers outside of school.... its feels unnatural.
Fucking hell the identity of Edgar is as complicated as the identity of Big Boss from MGS with like 10 people claiming to be the original BB. There's a Solid Edgar, Liquid Edgar, Solidus Edgar, Big Edgar, Big-Little Edgar, Fat ass Edgar. 😂
Played the original Metal Gear when it came out, and played the new one from last year. Those are the only ones I've played. I don't understand the timeline, or why solid snake is called big boss, or why the guys can fly and shoot fire. The first game was about spies and shit, the new one is about... Telekinesis?
+Joel Rayburn Solid Snake is the son of Big Boss, not Big Boss, Naked Snake is Big Boss x'D I've played all the games (well, only some of 4 but I've played all of the others) well, technically Solid Snake and Liquid Snake (he's Eli in Phantom Pain) are clones of Big Boss with EVA (Big Boss' lover in Snake Eater which is fantastic!) playing the part of Big Momma, though I think she was Solidus' mother.
+Shakko Okay. Naked Snake = Big Boss. Solid Snake and Liquid Snake = Big Boss' Sons/Clones. Eva = Big Momma? But who's the flying telekinesis person in the gas mask?
8:22 So if we followed the last video to that Jack being killed by Geoff we could actually figure out around the time that Ryan went and fixed the hole.
You missed a part. The original edgar that Michael set free is actually killed by Geoff later in part 60. They don't point it out in any of the videos, but it can be deduced from where Edgar is last seen and where Geoff kills one of the cows.
does anyone realize that in this let's play, Micheal leaves Edgar in the cactus farm and only a little while later Geoff finds a cow to get food from in the cactus farm and slaughters it...... sad day
So like... Did we ever find out /how/ Ryan made a hole with a glass ceiling without it showing up on camera? Because, exactly 5 years 1 month and 7 days later, that question still haunts my mind.
And thus ends the tale of the cow named Edgar and The Mad King Ryan... until next time... Lol, you should have added the part where Geoff killed the real Edgar.
I realise more how funny it is that Gavin who edits the videos didnt see ryan enclose the chicken and cow and they play in an office so its incredibly mysterious how he managed to log on and do it off camera
No he doesn't. Edgar is the one in the hole. If said Edgar is freed, it ceases to be Edgar. If you were a Minecraft player with them and you were in the hole, you will be Edgar.
I can imagine Edgar saying something like this to Michael while Michel is freeing him, "NO! I have to stay, if Ryan finds out I will be punished! I love Ryan! (Edgar shaking) Ryan protects me! I must stay! Please let me stay!" Kinda like a Sansa Stark with Geoffry "Baratheon" (Lanaster) thing, mixed with a Ramsay "Bolton" (Snow) and Reek thing, as Edgar is the one in the hole.
Kinda but these videos came out waaaaayy before the events happened, but i can see how this is a foreshadow and none of them even ryan knew what was to come
@Mendicant Bias Funny, you seem more mad than I am. I'm not particularly mad at Ryan, just disappointed and disgusted. Getting mad at it would allow it to affect me too much, and i dont even particularly like achievement hunter anymore. Or anything rooster teeth, for that matter.
You can't free Edgar. Edgar is the one in the hole! Whatever Ryan puts in the hole, it will become Edgar! Even if it is Michael or Ray or Geoff or Jack or Gavin, they will be Edgar.
Ray's reaction to seeing Edgar in the hole for the first time just kills me.
"Oh, you put-- you-- WHAT?"
I remember when I first saw Michael free him, I was expecting Ryan to freak out in the next part. Him silently repairing the damage was even better.
Yeah I know. I reacted like Michael did when Ryan said everything was fine when the King Ryan Let's Plays were out.
It's even funnier when you notice that while Michael is trying to escape with Edgar a sheep just walks into the hole and a wolf is at the door trying to get in. Ryan's house is a magnet for animals.
Don't forget that one Pigmen from a certain episode
Cooli167 which episode?
Also can't forget that pig on his roof at one point xD
That wolf fucked that sheep in the hole lol ;)
I think Micheal's original plan was to swap Edgar with the sheep . . . but then he gave up when he realized how dumb both the sheep and Edgar were. Regardless of which one might've ended up in the hole, they undoubtedly would be named Edgar XD
"Edgar is the one in the hole."
I need that on a t shirt.
YES. JUST, YES
Keep Calm
And know that
Edgar is the One in the Hole
Forget that. I need Edgar’s Hole as a Rug
What's funny is that when RT did a spin-off of "And Then There Were None", Ryan found himself in an Edgar hole XD
Yeah... I don't think this aged well
Even *Ray* couldn't find a single thing to say at "Edgar is the one in the hole!"
TheUpstart poor edgar
TheUpstart He said, "so if I'm in the hole then am I edgar"
...yes
His immediate reaction is "what the fuck dude."
On a desk in the FBI field office in Houston, Texas there is a file marked "Ryan Haywood". I'm not saying it's a high priority, but it's there. It has to be.
There is a file with redacted classified information. It's titled Edgar, but the rest of it, is unknown.
NialasDubh Oh I know, I live in Houston, I've seen it. 😆
IndianTelephone Really? All I got was "It's the one in the hole...."
NialasDubh E d g a r I s t h e o n e I n t h e h o l e
Oof...you may be right
the fact that edgar WANTED to go back into Ryans house...
its that Stockholm Syndrome bro
Brainwashing (drops mike)
Dude Michael had him like 10 yards out of that house and that mothering fucking cow BOOKED it back inside.
He knew it was for the other Achievement Hunters' safety
I think animals are probably programmed to go to brighter areas during the night. Had Michael placed the door back, Edgar would not have been able to reenter.
The edit of the screen shaking and turning red made it funny, but Geoff and jack's laugh completed it all
Geoff killed Edgar. The original Edgar I mean. If you watch the video you see that Michael leaves Edgar in the cactus field. And later Geoff goes to the cactus field, finds a cow and killed it
You dont understand, Edgar is the one in the hole
+Fireboy xD
this is true
No, you don't understand. EDGAR IS THE ONE IN THE HOLE.
Noooooooooooooooooooo.
I love how popular this became.
if only you knew...
*If only you knew…*
iF OnLY yOu knEW...
This is one of the few moments I wish they all had face cams. I just want to imagine what Ryan's face looked like when he said those memorable words, "Edgar is the one in the hole." Followed by everyone else's reactions, before and after Ryan's famous line.
gotta add to this. there's some nice quotes of "edgar isn't in the hole to be mean to edgar, he's in the hole to protect you guys"
After a millennia stuck in the hole Edgar had forgotten the outside world. Not knowing what to do desperately tried to get back in it. But out of nowhere a bear showed up and pushed it to the outside world. And so began the real of adventures of Edgar Free.
then killed by geoff!
Kami Sama It was sort of a short lived adventure as Edgar met a tragic fate.
The Real Adventures of Free Edgar.
Footage circa 2013.
When did Geoff kill Edgar?
At some point in the actual video Geoff kills a cow in the exact same spot Michael left Edgar.
I want to see Michael's face so bad when he realizes Ryan screwed him over :D
kicsiqki 😐
Well. You get to see it now.
"Ryan you are a disturbing individual." Hits diffrent with 2021 hindsight
ooh man it do.
Yup who knew
It really does.
ooh yeah it does
Why?
"I'm still in the hole!" - Edgar 2015
I am still in the hole
-Edgar 2016
Death Equals symmetry May Egdar's word be continued throughout the generations, even now, in next gen.
+Chase Hiltz The hole is still in the Edgar... wait wha-
"Still here'!' -Edgar 2016
+Adrian Towler 'I'm in a hole in a hole.' -Edgar 2016
Michael released a cow that was a shadow of its former self, bearing the scars from its confinement that will never heal nor shall it forget what had happened.
But that just means Ryan is subjecting a new, innocent cow to its solitary confinement.
Freeing "Edgar" only served to spread the madness...
...Why am I putting this as my comment? XD
Mother of God.... Michael... what have you begun?
MilesTailsProwerfan9 A rescue mission that was destined to fail, which caused another innocent cow to inherit the name and life of Edgar. And thus, it became "the one in the hole."
Nah Geoff killed Edgar shortly after he was freed
Edgar is the only one in the hole if i dies it just posseses a new body and only ryan can see the diference due to the madness constantly being upgrade to new levels of insanity due to the all knowing evil soul
"Edgar isn't in the whole to be mean to Edgar, Edgar is in the whole to protect you..."
-The Mad King
Ryan Haywood
hole*
yeah... hate it when that happens...
Thebagelwithcheese11 when people correct you or when you mistype it
Mistype, I'm glad someone told me.
@@Thebagelwithcheese11 Dam seven years ago, it sucks what Ryan was really doing all this time
So you have two people saying they are actively looking for leather and Edgar keeps trying to go back to the guaranteed safety of Kung Fu House. Who's the real monster here Michael?
I think my favorite part of this whole video are Gavin's squeaks when he and Michael realize that Edgar is back in the hole.
Seinor Quote: "Look, you dont understand, EDGAR IS THE ONE ON THE HOLE"
+Michael Yoo you are special
Michael Yoo FUCK! That’s better than mine. Mine was “YEAH TOAST! YEAH TOAST!@
Ten years, absolutely incredible. I remember watching these for the first time like yesterday
NO WAY IN, NO WAY OUT!!!
if only you knew...
Was that a reference to a movie
I, for one, welcome our Mad King. #FearEdgar
All hail the Mad King!
Screw him hail the idiot king Gavin
+Titan People like grapes.
All hail Mad King Ryan!
Geoff: Ryan, where's Edgar?
Ryan: ..........
Geoff: Ryan, where is Edgar?!?
Ryan: He's at home.
Geoff: Oh...where does he live?
(TomSka voice) In the hole.
*dramatic sting*
To this day i still love the fact that michael tried so hard to free edgar
Even after what happened
fuck I can't avoid watching this masterpiece
gotta say, the cherry on top was absolutely jack and geoff laughing
Man, remember when AH was good? Fun times.
Well, it was fun while it lasted.
The original Edgar is dead but as the mad king says "Edgar is the one in the hole."
there needs to be a friendly Grimm named Edgar in vol 4 XD
and Jaun befriends him
And Sun tries to save him from the oppression and enslavement of Port as Scarlet watches on
XD perfect
Cameron B 1
Maybe for _Chibi_...
I love how Michael is setting Edgar free as Ray is hunting cows for leather
And the tragic end to Edgar's story is when Geoff killed him after he had been set free.
Keep this video and don’t delete it keep it for the archives
0:57 *The* most glorious sound ever, of all time
I am one of maybe a dozen people that still enjoy Ryan's antics.
I choose to think that's a good thing.
i am going to miss em too
You're not alone. Honor him for the man he once was. Not the monster he has become.
O_O
As much as a fucked up person he is. He's still hilarious. Kinda like Cosby
@@AugustAutumnCome on. That's like cutting down a tree for giving one bad apple.
I'd like them to do a let's play called "Tower of Edgar." Where it is them, The achievement hunters minus Ryan in a hole at bed rock trying to climb back up to the surface with nothing but their bare hands. All they would need is to press the button to make a hole, and then just climb out.
every Gamer should know the saga of Edgar
This was a simpler time. 😔
Ray: "No way in. No way out. No way in. No way out."
XD
The worst part is that Michael freed the original Edgar, but then Geoff killed him. So…not so free anymore.
Geoffs laugh cured my depression
Seriously, when the hell did Ryan put Edgar in the hole?
i'm guessing while they built something for a lets play.
hey i am not supposed to see my subscriptions on other videos...
its reminds me of when i would see my highschool teachers outside of school....
its feels unnatural.
Jonathan Canfield You subscribe to human beings, human beings are free to comment on youtube videos.
Deal with it
Hannah Dutson - Calm down, he's not telling me to be quiet, he's expressing surprise/strangeness.
Venaloid Kind of stupid though
This makes a lot more sense now
Ryan: It puts the milk in the basket.
Like the quote, "It puts the lotion in the basket!"
+Harley Russell that's messed up
Or else it gets the bucket again
RIP EDGAR
RIP RAY
RIP OLD ACHIEVEMENT HUNTER
AND RIP THE GOOD TIMES
Rip our innocent childhood memories as well.
i like how edgar kept on trying to go back into the house
8:37 Even creepier at .5 speed.
8:37 you don't understand EDGAR IS THE ONE IN THE HOLE
Dude, so if I end up in the hole, I'm Edgar?
JackDManheim basically
Look, you don't understand! Edgar is the one in the hole. Best thing Ryan has ever said.
I love how Edgar 1.0 wanted to go back in the hole as soon as Michael set him loose.
Fucking hell the identity of Edgar is as complicated as the identity of Big Boss from MGS with like 10 people claiming to be the original BB. There's a Solid Edgar, Liquid Edgar, Solidus Edgar, Big Edgar, Big-Little Edgar, Fat ass Edgar. 😂
Played the original Metal Gear when it came out, and played the new one from last year. Those are the only ones I've played. I don't understand the timeline, or why solid snake is called big boss, or why the guys can fly and shoot fire. The first game was about spies and shit, the new one is about... Telekinesis?
+Joel Rayburn Solid Snake is the son of Big Boss, not Big Boss, Naked Snake is Big Boss x'D I've played all the games (well, only some of 4 but I've played all of the others) well, technically Solid Snake and Liquid Snake (he's Eli in Phantom Pain) are clones of Big Boss with EVA (Big Boss' lover in Snake Eater which is fantastic!) playing the part of Big Momma, though I think she was Solidus' mother.
+Shakko Okay. Naked Snake = Big Boss. Solid Snake and Liquid Snake = Big Boss' Sons/Clones. Eva = Big Momma? But who's the flying telekinesis person in the gas mask?
Joel Rayburn Psycho Mantis from the first game x'D he's the one you need to have a second controller for otherwise he knew your moves
+Shakko Didn't Snake kill him? Are you saying Phantom Pain is a prequel? THIS SERIES HAS PREQUELS NOW? Jesus.
so edgar just Mooooooo_ved in?
-_-
Goddamit Barb!!!
Evan Lomangino Barb Dammit Barb
+nick andhiscamera *(cups hands over mouth)* Boo!
No in the original video Geoff went to the cactus farm and killed a cow
2012 the year of gavin.
2013 the year of Ryan.
So far, 2014 is the year of Geoff but im not sure
2015 is the year of ray as of now
2012/13 was the year of michael, when Rage Quit was in its prime
thatguyyousawinasda eh I see where you're coming from but I was never really into rage quit. Even Michael said he would get tired of having to fake it
there are 2 meanings to the phrase "Edgar is the one in the hole". 1 is that it is Edgar's title, and 2 is that if you are in the hole, you are Edgar.
8:51 fight club reference. I like it.
8:22 So if we followed the last video to that Jack being killed by Geoff we could actually figure out around the time that Ryan went and fixed the hole.
theres footage of him doing it from his pov
This video was very well put together, thanks for making it!
You missed a part. The original edgar that Michael set free is actually killed by Geoff later in part 60. They don't point it out in any of the videos, but it can be deduced from where Edgar is last seen and where Geoff kills one of the cows.
Thing is, cows in Minecraft move.
A LOT.
Luke Beall not Edgar he just chills in his hole
Luke Beall actually, once you get a certain distance from them, all mobs stop moving.
You dont understand, Edgar is the one in the hole
That may be true, but that isn't how it was originally. Originally, Edgar was the one in the House.
Can't believe it has been four years since original Edgar's death
does anyone realize that in this let's play, Micheal leaves Edgar in the cactus farm and only a little while later Geoff finds a cow to get food from in the cactus farm and slaughters it...... sad day
One of the most iconic moments in Achievement Hunter history
Free Edgar 2013
So like... Did we ever find out /how/ Ryan made a hole with a glass ceiling without it showing up on camera? Because, exactly 5 years 1 month and 7 days later, that question still haunts my mind.
Anyone just come back to the videos? After all that's happened?
And thus ends the tale of the cow named Edgar and The Mad King Ryan... until next time...
Lol, you should have added the part where Geoff killed the real Edgar.
I realise more how funny it is that Gavin who edits the videos didnt see ryan enclose the chicken and cow and they play in an office so its incredibly mysterious how he managed to log on and do it off camera
So they Edit the video *after* they record it, firstly. Secondly, gavin can’t see Ryan’s screen from where he sits.
Geoff actually kills Edgar. If you watched it carefully Geoff walks around achievement city and kills a cow(Edgar) that is near a cactus garden.
No he doesn't. Edgar is the one in the hole. If said Edgar is freed, it ceases to be Edgar. If you were a Minecraft player with them and you were in the hole, you will be Edgar.
YES! I KNEW I WASN'T THE ONLY ONE TO NOTICE THAT!
+killjoys7000 No, you don't understand. *Edgar is the one in the hole.*
Geoff's laughter is so goddamn contagious
Michael's not too good at acting naturally,lol.
Ray’s subtle “What the fuck, dude?” made my day. I never noticed it.
Where?
Cows are probably one of my favorite animals and for edger to become a side character in the lets plays is awesome.
I was wrong, I was so wrong. They can't destroy Edgar or the Hole. It's imperative that Edgar never escapes!
is that a quote from somewhere?
Eventually, Edgar stopped thinking.
Well you know, Edgar is the one in the hole, so no one killed edgar
Viewing this video in October 2020:
"Okay, admittedly it's not like there were NO warning signs....." 😳
Still a better love story than twilight.
You don't understand.
Edgar,
Is the one in the hole.
( 8:38 )
"His name is Robert Paulson" best timing for a fight club reference ever
I can imagine Edgar saying something like this to Michael while Michel is freeing him,
"NO! I have to stay, if Ryan finds out I will be punished! I love Ryan! (Edgar shaking) Ryan protects me! I must stay! Please let me stay!"
Kinda like a Sansa Stark with Geoffry "Baratheon" (Lanaster) thing, mixed with a Ramsay "Bolton" (Snow) and Reek thing, as Edgar is the one in the hole.
Edgar is an analogy for Ryan's dark side and how if it ever got out it would destroy achievement hunter.
Kinda but these videos came out waaaaayy before the events happened, but i can see how this is a foreshadow and none of them even ryan knew what was to come
@@juan-mw2wv I feel like it was always kind of obvious in hindsight that ryan was a little distrubed, but we played it off as a funny shtick.
@@rinkutsuki3382 No it wasn't, you just like everyone else doesn't like to think you got tricked. Stay mad
@Mendicant Bias Funny, you seem more mad than I am. I'm not particularly mad at Ryan, just disappointed and disgusted. Getting mad at it would allow it to affect me too much, and i dont even particularly like achievement hunter anymore. Or anything rooster teeth, for that matter.
@@rinkutsuki3382 I'm more dissapointed that we won't see Ryan anymore my friend, i was mad when i made that comment, not anymore if thats something
Well this takes on a different hue in light of recent events.
damn. i watched this when i was 13. now i’m watching it again for some reason
the original Edgar is dead, killed unknowingly by Geoff.
www.change.org/petitions/ryan-haywood-free-edgar-2014#
SuperrichSpock I don't want Edgar to go free.... ALL HAIL THE MAD KING!
SuperrichSpock No, you need to fear Edgar.
He is truly, "A Disturbing Person." Alright
The best part is, is that in the episode Edgar was freed, Geoff killed him.
i dont think you understand, edgar is the one in the hole
yellowintheGhetto I mean Edgar 1. The original Edgar.
***** Edgar prime
Jacks laugh at 8:42 is one of the purest forms of entertainment
Ray's "no way in! no way out! no way in! no way out!" has been stuck in my head for a good 5 hours now
Did you ever hear the tragedy of Edgar the cow?
No.
I thought not, it's not a story rooster teeth would tell you.
Hearing Jack and Geoff losing it is icing on the cake
I don't know if it is episode 60 or 61 but the original edgar was unintentionally killed, by someone mistaking it for a wild cow.
You don't understand Edgar is the one in the hole
i think Michael should have hide Edgar in the ground that way he should have surprised Ryan.
You need to do a part two. Edgar has gone through so much now.
Lets start the campaign for "FREE EDGAR 2014"
You can't free Edgar. Edgar is the one in the hole! Whatever Ryan puts in the hole, it will become Edgar! Even if it is Michael or Ray or Geoff or Jack or Gavin, they will be Edgar.
damn you Ryan!
Free Edgar 2014 and Overthrow the Mad King!
I dont even know what is going on but thwir reactions are funny xD
Soon...soon...
do you have a minecraft account
"Edgar is the one in the hole" is such a legendary quote.
It puts the lotion on it's skin...
it puts the milk in the basket...
I finally got that. I feel dumb.
I really needed this.
I'm sorry too say that Geoff killed the original Edgar in episode 60