Some sources this same Cniva was defeat and killed by the Emperor Aurelian, but it is more likely it probably this was a different Cniva or probably his heir.
True and Emperor Aurelian was a keen observant that he watched every detailed battle so when his enemies attempt to reused or tricked him with different twist to lured him he was prepared and the battle was finally favored into Romans once again after series of defeats done Before him
Despite the strong brainwashing during my history studies with a specialization in ancient history, I identify with the Goths wholeheartedly. A part of their blood now flows in my veins and their holy places and burial grounds still exist around the place where I live.
Perfeita, Could you do a Dawnless Days battle of Erebor trying to recapture Khazad Dum/Moria? I've been watching your Third Age playlist lately and would like more LOTR videos
Face to face, man to man battle, using all your speed and strength, then going to your next enemy. Fatigue. Exhaustion. Fear, although some were fearless. These men were different from us.
Poor Boudica should engage the battle with the very same tactic like this one or Teutoburg Forest War. I am deeply saddened every time i remember how they lost around 100K warrior, including women, chilren, old people and even tha animal packs. Such a horrible and devastating end for such a chivalrous, brave act..
I believe the Germanic warriors learned from losing to better battle tactics … they figured what worked and what didn’t and then ADAPTED better strategy so that they eventually would WIN … wish I could go back and teach my people earlier so the Romans could experience great losses like we eventually did at Teutoburg Forest !!!
@@paprskomet… to illustrate that my Germanic people kept learning for over 200 years after Teutoburg AND by the 5th century sacked & pillaged Rome twice !!!
Goths learned lessons from earliar 9 AD from battle of tuterbergaveld in German forest, Herman of Cherusci (Arminias). skirmishing, and bottlenecking the roman army into small areas..
Il problema del tardo impero romano era soprattutto dovuto dal suo esercito, all' inizio i legionari erano soprattutto Romani e combattevano per Roma, poi come tutti gli imperi in decadenza, veniva fatto un uso spropositato di soldati mercenari che combattevano esclusivamente per denaro
Im dritten Jahrhundert bestand die Armee größtenteils aus Soldaten der Ilyrischen Provinzen. Das waren alles Römische Bürger. Erst am Ende des 3. Jahrhunderts b.z.w in der Spätantike hat man vermehrt auf barbarische Söldner/Feorderati zurückgegriffen. Da waren die Söldner an sich nicht das Problem solange diese Söldner bezahlt wurden. Sondern das die Söldner ab dem 5. Jahrhundert von fast nur noch von ihren eigenen Anführern Kommandiert und Entlohnt wurden. Die vornehmlich ihre politischen Interessen verfolgten. In Ostrom konnte man dieses Problem beheben und die Söldner wieder unter die dierekte Staatliche Kontrolle bringen. Das hat dann bis zum Ende der Muslimischen Expansion funktioniert. Weil zu dem Zeitpunkt nicht mehr genug Geld da war um ein großes Söldnerheer zu unterhalten.
“Including Decius who was the first emperor to be killed…”, not “whom was”. “Whom” is not just a fancy version of “who”. It is not called for in this instance.
English speakers generally find it impossible to pronounce non-English names or places correctly. Instead of learning the correct way, they insist that the "English way" is the right way.
Германские готы ? В книге Мауро Орбини 17 век ( псевдоним герцога Мария Франческа Дель Урбино) говорится , что готы славяне , в книге есть глава, она так и называется, о Готах Славянах
because the enemy usually retrieved them and launched them back and because they were taller with longer arms the javelins hit further into the Roman phalanx !!!
Vermutlich aus Balancing Gründen. Wenn die Römer in dieser Darstellung ihren ganzen Munitionsvorrat an Pila werfen. Erhalten die Goten so schwere Verluste das sie die Römer am Ende nicht mehr besiegen können.
How exavtly can talk about very diverse group of people(both Romans and emperors)as if they were all the same?Moreover defeat at Abriitus had nothing to do with some arrogance.
Вообще-то римляне не только тогда проиграли, они полностью проиграли! Германцы - это славяне, а возглавлял их князь Герман Арий. Да и не только Рим отгрёб, там много кто отгрёб. Да и римляне были никакими бойцами, по сравнению с германцами. Не надо расхваливать римлян-хэллин. Ладно даны были на стороне германцев. А франки причём? Это же иудеи как и римляне!
Sie haben ein sehr seltsames Geschichtsverständnis. Vielleicht sollten Sie noch einmal einige primärquellen lesen. Das wäre der erste Schritt um ein etwas ausgewogeneres Geschichtsbild zu erhalten.
@@paprskomet Даже переводить не буду! Мы своё Наследие помним! А вот вы за ваше поганое прошлое просто пытаетесь оправдаться, за проигрыши в войнах, за свою трусость, за то что никогда ничего построить не смогли и т.д. и т.д. и т.д.
Ersten waren es im dritten Jahrhundert nicht die Spätrömischen Legionen. Weil die Spätantike erst nach dem 3. Jahrhundert begann. Zweitens Waren die Spätantiken Legionen nicht 10.000 sondern eher 1.000 Mann Stark. Drittens handelte es sich bei den Legionen des 3. Jahrhunderts immernoch um die Einheiten die Seit der späten Republik etwa 5.000-6.000 Mann stark waren. Aber zu diesem Zeitpunkt in der Realität warscheinlich in verschiedenen Vexilatio die jeweils mehrere hundert Mann groß waren aufgeteilt wurden. Die wiederum auf mehreren Grenzabshnitten verteilt waren.
Too drawn out. I think you spent 5 minutes reiterating the fact that the Roman's were getting drawn into a trap while the listener listens to war noises. Super annoying
Fascinating uniform details. The face shields on the Roman horses the chain mail in gold. And yet why do I always get this empty feeling with video games. Where is the death of the Emperor? Interesting though.
Julius Caesar, Gaius Seutonius Paulinus, Scipio Africanus, Trajan, and Titus Manlius Imperiosus Torquatus must have been turning in their graves while watching this battle from the afterlife. Meanwhile, Boudica, Vercingetorix, Hannibal Barca, Mithridates VI Eupator, and Gellius Egnatius are laughing in their graves.
@ Except that those Roman commanders lived at a time when Rome was at the zenith of its power and influence, whereas during this historical era the Roman Empire and its successor state the Western Roman Empire were in terminal decline.
@@malgusvitiate7002 They were not in terminal decline by this point.If you mention "western Roman empire" why did you illogically left out eastern one?...well I guess I know why-because it don't fit to your narration of terminal decline. By the way there were not really any successor states called "western Roman empire" and "Eastern Roman Empire",both were simply the Roman empire,and that was also how Romans themselves viewed it-two parts of one Roman world. Terminology of western/eastern Roman empire,especially if propagated as two completely stand alone states is a huge modern over-simplification.
@@paprskomet Only the Western Roman Empire was considered truly Roman because they spoke Latin. The Byzantine Empire was Greek-speaking, which meant that it was (alongside the Carolingian Empire, Holy Roman Empire, Ottoman Empire, Principality of Moscow, Tsardom of Russia, and Russian Empire) not Roman. And yes, Rome was already in terminal decline by this point in time, because it kept losing to the barbarian peoples such as the Goths (and later the Visigoths and Ostrogoths after the Gothic people split into separate tribes), Vandals, Saxons, Alans, Huns, Lombards, Slavs, Proto-Vikings (the Danes, Geats, and Jutes), and Franks, amongst others.
@@malgusvitiate7002 you are happy that youtube error does not allow me reply as I want(each longer reply I wrote is not publically displayed becaose of this annoying error).All your assumptions are wrong and solely formulated from ignorance.Hope you will recieve at least this reply...
a great battle, I liked the new sound effects and the the roman battle cries.
Having the Romans chanting their cadence is motivating.
Early Romans: We only lost 80k in one day, we can still win this war.
Late Romans: We've lost 15k men, the empire is doomed!
lol so true
Out from the Roman ashes came the French, English, Spanish, Portuguese empires of Catholic Rome.
Theodosius- we'll call this policy "appeasement"....
Aurelian pukes in his grave
The late Romans had faced a series of plagues and famines which resulted in massive demographic collapse, so naturally there were manpower shortages.
@@zohebalikhan7404And the Goths and other “barbarians” didn’t have this?
Outstanding cinematics and love the new sound effects. Top notch as always. Cheers from Tennessee
Brilliant work as always, hope to see reconquesta battle's soon
Excelente video Bro🎉🎉🎉🎉 gracias por subirlo estuve esperando mucho tiempo para este video
Потрясающий синематик! Шикарно! Подписался! 👍
Epic battle! Well done sir!
These are so well done. Realistically bloody, horrifying and yet...fun to watch! 🤪
This was very well made .
Thank you sir❤
This was a good video ❤
King Chinva had matched Hannibal's cannae , cool
Imagine that steam roller coming towards you 😅
I like the sound effects very nice
Do you still take requests for Warhammer battles?
I would love to see hel fenn
I warned Decius that Cniva was a cunning capitulator but he didn't listen to me.
Awesome job 👍
Thanks 👍
Great work
Thank you! Cheers!
Its like your on the front lines, the sound effects are Uncanny
It makes me sad, make Claudius's victory Battle of Naisus please
Some sources this same Cniva was defeat and killed by the Emperor Aurelian, but it is more likely it probably this was a different Cniva or probably his heir.
ye i heard that too
True and Emperor Aurelian was a keen observant that he watched every detailed battle so when his enemies attempt to reused or tricked him with different twist to lured him he was prepared and the battle was finally favored into Romans once again after series of defeats done Before him
@@johnclintvillanueva1578 how do you know Aurelian was keen observant who watched every detail of battle?No source even claims this.
Wurde Cniva nicht in der Schlacht von Naissus von Claudius Cohticus besiegt?
@@marschallhistory3286268 ad.
Is there one of Spartacus v The Romans?
We humans have it so fucking easy today
I think this often mark … the ancient times of hardship shall come again the cycle continues for ever …
Excellent 😊
Really love your content. Can you do the battle of islandwana please.zulu wars.
excellent vid
Un vero piacere di vista 😊
Beautiful chanting
Despite the strong brainwashing during my history studies with a specialization in ancient history, I identify with the Goths wholeheartedly. A part of their blood now flows in my veins and their holy places and burial grounds still exist around the place where I live.
Superb bloodflow and gurgling.
Perfeita, Could you do a Dawnless Days battle of Erebor trying to recapture Khazad Dum/Moria? I've been watching your Third Age playlist lately and would like more LOTR videos
HELL NO!
thanks
did you use any mods for the sound effects
No I added them in myself
what you hawe what procesor what grapgic card ???
AVE A LEGIÃO 🏛🦅🛡🏹⚔
Today's kids couldn't even fight in any war, period. Can you imagine having to fight a war with swords and shields...?
Никто не хочет, чтобы дети воевали.Но украинским парням приходится защищать свою Родину,к сожалению.
I’d rather fight with swords and shields than getting blown up by a tank.
Face to face, man to man battle, using all your speed and strength, then going to your next enemy. Fatigue. Exhaustion. Fear, although some were fearless. These men were different from us.
I could. When I was a young man.....
What about you, shortstack?
Masacre Batlle 🗡️⚔️🛡️ 251 d.c
как называется игра?
Total war rome 2.
With dividet empire DLC .
And Mods.
@@marschallhistory3286 спасибо
Boys missed each other at Roman steam baths.
Poor Boudica should engage the battle with the very same tactic like this one or Teutoburg Forest War. I am deeply saddened every time i remember how they lost around 100K warrior, including women, chilren, old people and even tha animal packs. Such a horrible and devastating end for such a chivalrous, brave act..
It would be nice to see the battles of the seige of 1565 , the Knights of St John, Malta, against the Ottoman Turks.
I believe the Germanic warriors learned from losing to better battle tactics … they figured what worked and what didn’t and then ADAPTED better strategy so that they eventually would WIN … wish I could go back and teach my people earlier so the Romans could experience great losses like we eventually did at Teutoburg Forest !!!
...why the hell you have to mention Teutoburg as if that was the only big Germanic victory?Even Abrittus was bigger victory.
@@paprskomet… to illustrate that my Germanic people kept learning for over 200 years after Teutoburg AND by the 5th century sacked & pillaged Rome twice !!!
@@rjwintl... Which was not hard to do in 5th century.
gotta love the germanics, always beating the romans
Goths learned lessons from earliar 9 AD from battle of tuterbergaveld in German forest, Herman of Cherusci (Arminias). skirmishing, and bottlenecking the roman army into small areas..
Goths were most likely totally ignorant of Teutoburg.
Il problema del tardo impero romano era soprattutto dovuto dal suo esercito, all' inizio i legionari erano soprattutto Romani e combattevano per Roma, poi come tutti gli imperi in decadenza, veniva fatto un uso spropositato di soldati mercenari che combattevano esclusivamente per denaro
Im dritten Jahrhundert bestand die Armee größtenteils aus Soldaten der Ilyrischen Provinzen. Das waren alles Römische Bürger. Erst am Ende des 3. Jahrhunderts b.z.w in der Spätantike hat man vermehrt auf barbarische Söldner/Feorderati zurückgegriffen. Da waren die Söldner an sich nicht das Problem solange diese Söldner bezahlt wurden. Sondern das die Söldner ab dem 5. Jahrhundert von fast nur noch von ihren eigenen Anführern Kommandiert und Entlohnt wurden. Die vornehmlich ihre politischen Interessen verfolgten. In Ostrom konnte man dieses Problem beheben und die Söldner wieder unter die dierekte Staatliche Kontrolle bringen. Das hat dann bis zum Ende der Muslimischen Expansion funktioniert. Weil zu dem Zeitpunkt nicht mehr genug Geld da war um ein großes Söldnerheer zu unterhalten.
“Including Decius who was the first emperor to be killed…”, not “whom was”. “Whom” is not just a fancy version of “who”. It is not called for in this instance.
For those about to rock! Whom salutes you!
ローマ帝国は皇帝と言えども戦で戦死する事も有る。だから民衆がついて行くんだね
the besttttt
Onore a te legionario
Were the German Goths Christians at this point or no?
Cruelty of war is shoking
Rome aeterna
Watching this one has to conclude that europeans really like war
It took a long time for the cavalry to engage, and where were the Roman archers, slingers and pilums? What a doughnut Emperor.
Goths wearing a ridge and spangenhelm?
English speakers generally find it impossible to pronounce non-English names or places correctly. Instead of learning the correct way, they insist that the "English way" is the right way.
Германские готы ? В книге Мауро Орбини 17 век ( псевдоним герцога Мария Франческа Дель Урбино) говорится , что готы славяне , в книге есть глава, она так и называется, о Готах Славянах
Os romanos eram muito fortes eles São o berço dá nossa América latina e Itália, frança, espanha, portugal e Romênia
Roma caiu por suas várias guerras civis , sem isso eles teriam dominado muito mais territórios. Roma foi a maior potência do passado!
This Is total war ?
Конечно😊
Shades of Cannae
Why wont the romans use their javelins in history they throw javelins before they fight
because the enemy usually retrieved them and launched them back and because they were taller with longer arms the javelins hit further into the Roman phalanx !!!
@@rjwintlgoogle PILUM and you will see your comment is rubbish.
Vermutlich aus Balancing Gründen. Wenn die Römer in dieser Darstellung ihren ganzen Munitionsvorrat an Pila werfen. Erhalten die Goten so schwere Verluste das sie die Römer am Ende nicht mehr besiegen können.
✋️ Ave Roma ✋️
Rome tw 2 are pretty good now after many year :D
👀🤝👍💓🌟
Roma vs Cartagó plis🙏
Romans and especially their emperors had grown arrogant. Arrogance makes stupid.
How exavtly can talk about very diverse group of people(both Romans and emperors)as if they were all the same?Moreover defeat at Abriitus had nothing to do with some arrogance.
Jordanes píše Góti a Slovania boli jedno plemeno.Vandali,najväčšií slovanský kmeň.
Jordanes nic takového nepíše.
@paprskomet prečítaj si knihu Kráľovstvo Slovanov.
@@MiroslavSendecký odvolával jste se na Jordanese a teď najednou naznačujete že to máte úplně odjinud.
Some models used in this video are really nice while others not so much-especially Goths are shown in very, very anachronistic equpment.
Inwiefern ist die Gotische Ausrüstung Anachronistisch? Das interessiert mich wirklich.
Pretty humiliating, a Roman legion destroyed by barbarians.
🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃
🎃🎃🎃 GRIMÓRIO DE ATLÂNTIDA 🎃🎃🎃
🎃🎃🎃 ESCOLA DE BRUXARIA 🧙🏻♂️🎃🎃🎃
🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃
I never root for the Roman's
some people are just gay like that 🤷🏻♂️
@@greg_4201just like Roman fanboys lol
Faz uma batalha entre spartacus vs cossinius e furius
Вообще-то римляне не только тогда проиграли, они полностью проиграли! Германцы - это славяне, а возглавлял их князь Герман Арий. Да и не только Рим отгрёб, там много кто отгрёб. Да и римляне были никакими бойцами, по сравнению с германцами. Не надо расхваливать римлян-хэллин. Ладно даны были на стороне германцев. А франки причём? Это же иудеи как и римляне!
Sie haben ein sehr seltsames Geschichtsverständnis. Vielleicht sollten Sie noch einmal einige primärquellen lesen. Das wäre der erste Schritt um ein etwas ausgewogeneres Geschichtsbild zu erhalten.
Germanics were not Slavs.And I say that as a slav.
@@paprskomet Даже переводить не буду! Мы своё Наследие помним! А вот вы за ваше поганое прошлое просто пытаетесь оправдаться, за проигрыши в войнах, за свою трусость, за то что никогда ничего построить не смогли и т.д. и т.д. и т.д.
Pls stop to count late roman legion with 5000 men, it was much more, about 10.000
Ersten waren es im dritten Jahrhundert nicht die Spätrömischen Legionen. Weil die Spätantike erst nach dem 3. Jahrhundert begann. Zweitens Waren die Spätantiken Legionen nicht 10.000 sondern eher 1.000 Mann Stark. Drittens handelte es sich bei den Legionen des 3. Jahrhunderts immernoch um die Einheiten die Seit der späten Republik etwa 5.000-6.000 Mann stark waren. Aber zu diesem Zeitpunkt in der Realität warscheinlich in verschiedenen Vexilatio die jeweils mehrere hundert Mann groß waren aufgeteilt wurden. Die wiederum auf mehreren Grenzabshnitten verteilt waren.
A trans army sounds truly deadly 😅😅😅
very slow telling.
Rom defende europe from islam please
Too drawn out. I think you spent 5 minutes reiterating the fact that the Roman's were getting drawn into a trap while the listener listens to war noises. Super annoying
That’s the point of the channel “cinematic” in the title for a reason…
剺瀋屬
有關人士認為係數在同志⋯⋯他倆⋯⋯他們倆
Fascinating uniform details. The face shields on the Roman horses the chain mail in gold. And yet why do I always get this empty feeling with video games. Where is the death of the Emperor? Interesting though.
Julius Caesar, Gaius Seutonius Paulinus, Scipio Africanus, Trajan, and Titus Manlius Imperiosus Torquatus must have been turning in their graves while watching this battle from the afterlife. Meanwhile, Boudica, Vercingetorix, Hannibal Barca, Mithridates VI Eupator, and Gellius Egnatius are laughing in their graves.
Completely all of those Romans(perhaps minus Torquatus)lived in times where Rome suffered some huge defeat in battles.
@ Except that those Roman commanders lived at a time when Rome was at the zenith of its power and influence, whereas during this historical era the Roman Empire and its successor state the Western Roman Empire were in terminal decline.
@@malgusvitiate7002 They were not in terminal decline by this point.If you mention "western Roman empire" why did you illogically left out eastern one?...well I guess I know why-because it don't fit to your narration of terminal decline.
By the way there were not really any successor states called "western Roman empire" and "Eastern Roman Empire",both were simply the Roman empire,and that was also how Romans themselves viewed it-two parts of one Roman world.
Terminology of western/eastern Roman empire,especially if propagated as two completely stand alone states is a huge modern over-simplification.
@@paprskomet Only the Western Roman Empire was considered truly Roman because they spoke Latin. The Byzantine Empire was Greek-speaking, which meant that it was (alongside the Carolingian Empire, Holy Roman Empire, Ottoman Empire, Principality of Moscow, Tsardom of Russia, and Russian Empire) not Roman. And yes, Rome was already in terminal decline by this point in time, because it kept losing to the barbarian peoples such as the Goths (and later the Visigoths and Ostrogoths after the Gothic people split into separate tribes), Vandals, Saxons, Alans, Huns, Lombards, Slavs, Proto-Vikings (the Danes, Geats, and Jutes), and Franks, amongst others.
@@malgusvitiate7002 you are happy that youtube error does not allow me reply as I want(each longer reply I wrote is not publically displayed becaose of this annoying error).All your assumptions are wrong and solely formulated from ignorance.Hope you will recieve at least this reply...
Great stuff .
Watching this one has to conclude that europeans really like war