She is a pain in the ass and doesn’t take responsibility for keeping her cat safe he tried to work with her to coordinate times so that their cats wouldn’t come in contact and she refused he even paid one of the vet bills maybe she’ll learn when a different cat or even coyote attacks her cat
If your cat is elderly missing teeth which also means (unable to defend herself) and has been previously attacked, why wouldn’t you as an owner watch your cat when it goes out??? This was solely on her and she should be grateful the defendant payed her the 1st time.
True but her cat is being terrorized in her own yard. If your cat is causing damage then what? He needs to watch his bully cat. But I wouldn't leave my cat unattended either
@@ericablige9449 No, she needs to watch her old cat. The cat clearly cant defend itself so she needs to either work with the defendant or spend the time outside
I have 2 Cats that never leave my fenced in back yard, but other Cats easily climb the 7ft. fence and come in. Sometimes there's fights and it scares the crap out of my wallet.
100% agree it is the owners responsibility to look after her elderly cat. I do agree it is also defendant's responsibility to watch his cat but as a animal owner if you put your animal outside unattended cat lady r dog then you are sadly risking your animal. I have a 13 yr old labrador, fenced in yard, but she's never outside unattended. I don't mean you have to be the pets shadow but you should remain aware of what's going on while your animal is outside. I wish that having a enclosed area would mean that your pet is safe but sadly their are ALOT of irresponsible pet owners. I also believe that sometimes cat owners may treat a cat outside a little different than a dog. I have a neighbor who puts her kitties outside but puts a long leash and collar on them and they play outside while shes in her yard. I completely understand feeling like if your pet is in your enclosed yard they should be safe but their r IRRESPONSIBLE owners. Some cat owners just allow their cats to free reign the neighborhood and its easier for a cat to get into a enclosed area than a dog.
@@britney598 well I hope its the same deal if your bully cat get injured in my yard. Keep that same energy. You should have been watching Your cat. If someone complained about my pet I would do something out of respect. Ppl are mean. Your cat may not come back home.
Yeah me too I believe him I believe he was looking out for the health and welfare of his own cat because his neighborhood is teaming with wildlife that could hurt his beloved princess, she's the creep and the pink hair looks dreadful on her.
Finally someone that's sensible. People online think I'm cruel because I allow my cat it's freedoms to go in or out at will. I think it's cruel to lock a cat up all day, never experiencing freedom. But I'm also well aware that if my cat gets injured or attacked while outside, then that's my problem, no one else's. Be it by dog or any other animal, I accept full responsibility to pay for vet bills or anything else.
EXACTLY! especially when the defendant said there are coyotes and bobcats roaming around. When you allow your pet to go outside, you take your chances with their safety
I agree. She tried to set him up as having faulty character with the "binocular" story but he was very forthcoming and sincere. He might be a little eccentric but I don't think he's creepy like she painted him out to be.
I totally disagree. she shouldn't have to tell when her cat wants outside. especially since it stays on its own property. heneeds to fix the behavior or get rid of his cat
@@Fakecourt Same. I live in California and I’ve seen them at all hours. You never know, and also, how could you ever save your cat from a midday attack? It’s not like the majority of us have the reflexes for that.
He offered you a solution and you didn't take it. You don't HAVE to take up his solution, BUT if you also do nothing to protect your own property, then you're shit out of luck.
I understand her annoyance with this man and his cat but I would never have the audacity to blame it on someone else if my cat was unattended in the front yard where any animal could come
She’s being ridiculous! If she thought her cat was in danger then why put it out and close the door?! What if a coyote grabbed the cat? She gonna sue wildlife management in the area?
Interesting, I just saw almost the exact same case on judge Judy, and she made the cat owner pay the doctor bills. Judy said you’re free to not have your cat on a leash but you’re still responsible for any damage it causes. These types of inconsistencies make ”law” a sketchy business.
The Defendant was very reasonable and amicable. If it's fifteen minutes, twice per day, you stay and monitor your cat, especially in an area with bobcats and coyotes.
I live in coyote country, I NEVER let my cat outside, and he lived to be 19yrs old! We got him fixed when he was a baby, and he was blessed with perfect health his whole life, until about a week before he passed. THAT was a pretty good run! He only ate Chicken Soup For The Soul Dry Cat Food, drank lots of water and I made sure he got plenty of exercise. If your cat is young, I recommend getting a harness and leash training them if you'd like them to see the world and get fresh air. Or, they have strollers now, too! Mango was too old for that stuff, but I wish he'd had a stroller, that would've been neat.
I know your comment is a year old but just wanted to mention, if you haven't found one yet, there are some really nice catteries available online. I found one that hooks directly to the window so the cat can go in and out whenever they want. It's also designed to be able to put two of them together to make it a double for more room. Just a thought. God Bless!
💯 my cat LOVES the thought of going out & breaks out every chance he gets 😂 with me & his dog right on his tail. Hawks, owls, dogs, cars etc... DANGER! His best life IS in our house because I know he's ALIVE.
Especially since it's illegal in most states to let your cats roam at will. You can count on them eventually being killed by a car, antifreeze, a stray pellet, BB, trap, poison, etc...Just keep them indoors like you want dog owners to do.
You don't even need to confine your cats inside to keep them safe! I've always bought large cat runs, or fenced in pens. The cats can still enjoy outdoor time, fresh air, lie in the sun, etc. without being at risk of traffic, other animals, getting lost, and so on. Pens can be found very cheaply! It's illegal here for cats to be loose at night, and cat runs or pens are becoming far more common during the day.
My cats have always been indoor cats. They don't care. We have a large enclosed porch I can open the sliding door to fill the hummingbird feeders. The Tom's will stay 4' from the open door and watch me but won't get near it. I had one beloved cat years ago that was killed by a car. Since then all my cats live indoors. I even feed the feral cats on my little deck my cats love to watch them but it's never a problem. Our area is in the middle of state pine forest we have all the animals the gentleman described plus an 8' bear. Now all my cats live to over 20 yrs.
Cat's are going to be cats. Don't let your cats outside and expect them to come home in perfect condition. I am a very big cat lover and cat mom. Keep your cats inside.
I let my cat outdoors sometimes but I stand right next to him watching every move ...I also have a 8 month kitten and she doesn't go out cause she's got kitten brains and isn't predictable like my older one, it's not safe for her. people need to be responsible for their own pets
If you were truly a cat lover then you wouldn't be locking them in your house all day everyday. That's cruel. You're simply AFRAID that your cat might get hurt, but guess what, that's life. My kid can fall off his bike and break his neck that doesn't mean he can't ride a bike. You probably like to cry about animals in zoos, locked up in cages, but then you do the same exact thing to your cat. If you cannot ever let your cat outside to be a cat (hunt, roam, socialize) then don't get one.
@@groowanderer cats jump walls and fences and some don't return home. You can love your cat and keep them inside. Being outside can be dangerous for them . House cats are not wild animals that suffer from living indoors. They're safer in doors.
@@ellisisland4902 you missed my point I think. Yes you can love your cat by keeping em in, but you are doing that for yourself more than anything imo. A cat deserves to live a real life how its life was intended to be lived. People that keep em in are so busy acting like they're just concerned for their cat when in reality they're just alleviating their own fears. If a cat could talk they'd tell you they need nature, they need to roam, they need to hunt, they need socialization with other cats. They would not tell you "yes please keep me locked up so I can never never be in any danger". It's just how I feel about it, same as those that crate their dogs. I've heard some talk about building a cat run that goes outside and is big but not possible for the cat to escape. I guess that's some improvement from keeping them inside their whole lives.
@@groowanderer I understand your point but in your first line it looks like you're implying she doesn't love her cat because she doesn't her let her outside. That's what I was addressing. I let my cat out in the backyard because he loves being outside but I supervise him and don't let him wander where I can'tsee him. He's too important to our family. He lived outside before I adopted him and I know in his heart he will always be an outside cat. I'm a huge advocate for catios because yes they do deserve the outside just like we do and frankly I believe they appreciate it alot more.
You don't even need to confine your cats inside to keep them safe! I've always bought large cat runs, or fenced in pens. The cats can still enjoy outdoor time, fresh air, lie in the sun, etc. without being at risk of traffic, other animals, getting lost, and so on. Pens can be found very cheaply! It's illegal here for cats to be loose at night, and cat runs or pens are becoming far more common during the day.
yes!! I was just sharing this, my cat goes out occasionally but only with me and I don't leave his side. they have strollers backpacks ect no exceptions
I've wanted to do something for our cats but it's impossible. Between having two 20+ pound cats and a destruction demon spawn that graduated top of his class at Satan's School of Hellians, yeah it would not work.
My cat is leash trained and I never leave her alone outside. Things happen in a split second. This woman isn't responsible although she tries to paint a picture perfect owner.
I wanted to do that with my younger cat when I first got him but wasn't sure how to go about it. Don't know if he's too old for that now or he would have interest in going out. I let my cats go on my deck but I have no stairs for them to get into the yard. They enjoy themselves and no worries. I believe in leash laws cause I hate to see cats roam. They can get hurt by cars, weather, dogs, etc. And I don't think its right for cat to go on someone else's property.
@@SlashTheWeasel My cat was a rescue. At first she hated the harness. My learning mistake was taking it off/on. Once I started leaving it on she got used to it. She knows that I hook a long leash for her to be outside. The cat won't like it at first. Best of luck 😽💛
@@annsayger5842 All the cats I've had are rescue/shelter cats too. Is it possible to start with approx five year old boy cat? I fear the big outdoors may be too much for him.
@@SlashTheWeasel Sorry I didn't see your question until today. I believe just put the harness on and do not take it off. Probably within a couple of days put the leash on & go out side. I had it long at 1st. Do not take the harness off. Now at 1st he may not like it but leave the harness on. Slowly, probably in a month he will get use to it. My cat does not want to take off the harness when I replace it with a new one. Always keep an eye out for dogs. My cat travels in my vehicle too. Best wishes.
As a veterinarian it's not cruel to keep the cat safe and indoors. There are too many dangers out there including humans. My cat is quite happy being indoors. She has it made and is quite spoiled rotten. I can leave my door wide open and she will not run outside because she doesn't want to be outside.
@@bassdmin7436 sure, sure. You'd be the first to cry about a tiger kept in a cage though right? It's the same thing, keeping your cat from being the absolute furthest thing from what it's intended to be, a free animal. To me it's cruel. I live in the country, and yes there are predators (you realize a cat is one) and I've got my dog to take care of those. My cat serves a purpose. He keeps mice and other Rodents at bay, and out of my house and garden. I honestly feel that people in big cities shouldn't even have cats. Get a gerbil or something that doesn't have natural instincts to hunt, kill, explore...
This is why my cat is indoor only. I already know she can't handle herself outside with the local cats. Several years ago, a large feral cat broke through my window screen downstairs while I was upstairs napping. I woke up to my poor kitty being chased around my living room by a huge cat, which I was able to shoo with a broom into my downstairs bathroom until animal control came. My poor kitty was so traumatized. Her cat shouldn't be outside without her if there are known cats nearby. Cats will be cats and are way too territorial to take chances.
yeah she's a negligent owner. you have a cat that has lost some ability to protect itself and you know there are other cats about, then take the time to go outside with the cat . you would do it for children , why not the cat. her head is stuck in a "i have to be right' mentality in a situtation where she is dead wrong
I rescued a stray cat and it’s not a good inside cat and has always lived outside! She has been in a couple of cat fights, including one that landed her at the vet. Cats come in my yard all the time and most of the time my cat stays in my yard but cats do what cats do. She is responsible for her cat! I think the solution would be a cat door then she can unlock it for those 15 minutes twice a day so her can has a place of refuge.
I agree with posters that say… she should be outside with her cat to ensure it’s safety. “I’m busy!” - not an excuse. I feel so bad for that cat. Her twilight years deserve better than what she’s getting with her human Mom.
I have coyotes and i had a chihuahua get killed. I live on 22 acres of land. I used to let them run free. Now i am outside every time they go out and i watch every move they make. She is an irresponsible pet owner
@@monicabroussard840 I live in an urban area. I've heard a bobcat, there is a report of a coyote pack, and also a cougar with a few miles of my house. My dogs go into my fenced in backyard under supervision.
I had a cat, I loved my cat and when my cat got into fights with other animals, I took my cat to the vet... End of story! I didn't look for the owner of the other animal seeking retribution!
Same here. I have a cat who won’t come inside. I have a cat who won’t go outside. And one cat that’s both inside/outside. The two times it happened in the past, I’ve taken my cat to the vet & paid for it myself.
@@Jsarmy87124 Not having money isn't an excuse to not care for a pet.... Vets will allow you to sign over your cat if you don't want to go into debt over the bills. It's always required to do what's in the best interest of the animal even if that means giving it up.
she's right...you don't suture cat fight wounds unless the skin is hanging off. And even then you would put in a drain and leave a hole open for drainage.
My cats have times they spend on our screened in porch throughout the day with the door cracked. In the warmer weather, we put them in harnesses with a lead attached to a stake in the middle of the yard and they love it. Always supervised in some way though..I would never let them roam free! And I don't think they want to. They like feeling safe and having their home base they're familiar with inside and out.
I'm surprise by the ruling in general but I thinking the defendant did have a great argument. If the plaintiff cared about her cat, she would have also changed her routine no matter how annoying it would be. Both are responsible to not let this happen again. If it was true that the defendant offered his phone number to resolve this, that was a good plan. However, I can also see how ridiculous it might be to have to call ur neighbor 2 times a day. Then they should just agree that between certain times, they will let their cat out to avoid the other. It's not that hard. It is just something we deal with living in society...
Completely agree, if I had a cat that was being bullied and my neighbor asked to call him the 2 times a day I put my cat out I would do it. I know it may be annoying but honestly it would just be easier to do the call just to make sure my pet was safe. A cat is totally different than a dog, cats can jump fences and other enclosed areas easier than a dog. I would just do it to make sure my kitty was safe because that is easier than worrying about her/him being hurt. Just my opinion, cats will be cats and we r the 1's who need to be responsible and have ability to reason out things ALOT better than a animal. I know a cat can get over my fence so to be safe I'm going to be outside, especially if it's 4 a short time, while my kitty is having outside time.
@@michellet7013 do you know what episode? I want to look up the jurisdiction and see the facts because like JM said, defendants is only when he’s negligent (ie. he beached a legal duty he had).
The defendant was a lovely man. I wish he was my neighbor. Not the plaintiff who seemed most unpleasant and uncaring. It seems her lovely cat isn't worth a phone call or 40 minutes of her time a day. Will she try to sue a driver if her cat is run over?
All my kitties are indoor kitties. I had some before for years and years that were inside outdoor and we had a 6 ft fence. After 14 years one jumped the fence and the dog next door killed her. I never let the others out again. They can look out the windows and screen door at the birds or rabbits and squirrels.
Simple minded, yes. It's cruel to a cat to keep it locked up inside its whole life, never tasting freedom or being able to explore, hunt, all the things in its nature to do. I feel like if you can't handle a cat being a cat, then don't get one. Same people that lock their cats up inside their whole lives like to complain about animals locked in cages at zoos, and it's very hypocritical.
She appeared more intent on defaming his character than supporting her cat. He reflects someone she is which might make her more intent to distance herself from him.
When I was in my 20s I had a neighbor that walked her cat on leash. I thought she fell of her rocker and didn't recover. Now that I'm old she was being responsible
A water hose woulda solved that problem. She wouldn't've hurt the cat but it would be scared to approach the property again. I use a spray bottle with a stream to discipline mine. I had one female cat to stalk another female cat before. I think the stalker sensed fear in the other so occasionally they would fight for 10 seconds and stop or I'd shake the water bottle and they'd disperse. I love the Plaintiff's glasses 🤓.
We use the squirt bottle for our cats and dogs if need be. Our cats know what the bottle means, so now I just have to say the cats name and water. They stop and fast. Minus my boy Mowgli. He's just evil. Little 😈 that he is.
This is why I personally have indoor cats because I will never know nor be able to protect my cat from harm that might come to it.. Dog and cat or cat and cat fights.. getting run over by car just wondering and never coming back.. All risks when you have outdoor cats. Doesnt matter if the attack was in her backyard or down the street things like this are bound to happen sometimes. The man tried to give her a solution to their problem but she didnt like that idea, and now her cat paid the price for it but its not his fault it happened. She should have been thrilled he help pay for any of it at all and just let it go.
There are toppers that you can put on your fences to keep cats either in or out depending on which way they are installed. There are also motion detected sprinklers to keep cats to teach cats to stay in/out. Lots of humane options to fix this problem without going after your neighbor sigh.
She has life twisted. She said "he knew ..." BUT SHE KNEW, too. How does she expect this man to have a greater duty of care for her cat than she has? She knew that cat was vicious toward her own cat and just let it out to be prey.
Cats belong indoors! Cats will absolutely do all the things she stated. The vet will also do all the things stated. I was bitten by my cats twice inside while they were protected themselves. No fault to my cats. Defendant is absolutely at fault. Cats are property under the law. Cats use claws more than teeth btw. Also Domestic Cats are one reason wild birds are in major decline. If you truly care for all animals you keep your cat inside! Plaintiff is not at fault. I don't agree with Judge M! ✌
You can see JM is high key try harding hard not to crack up laughing at this foolishness. People that take cats so seriously are either awkwardly hysterical or outright annoying. And this is coming from someone who’s had cats for 20 years. 😹😹
I have had cats my whole life and am a super firm believer that ALL CATS should always be indoor ONLY!! All of this mess would be avoided if you always keep cats inside. If you want, you can cat proof your yard to keep your cat safe against your cats getting out and against anything getting into your yard. Please people, keep your kitties inside. And another thing: if there are coyotes and bobcats and all kinds of wild animals wandering around, WHY THE HELL ARE YOU LETTING YOUR CATS OUT DOORS?!?!?! 🙄
This my first time hearing a case with cats. I thought her case was won but then the defendant came in with such a compelling argument that you can’t argue the fact that he tried to do what was necessary for them both. Growing I’ve always prejudged people who I perceived as being weird but since I’ve grown up, something as simple as a “hi” or a hand wave changed my perception tremendously. Everyone is human and we shouldn’t jump to conclusions. The defendant is very well spoken and maybe if the plaintiff stopped going by word of mouth and speaking even if it was just to say hi, she would’ve known that he’s a reasonable guy.
My male cat was neutered at 2 months old, and stayed on our land. He was an outside cat that wouldn’t allow any humans to touch him except me. He was protective of his area, and didn’t like all the ferral neighbors cats coming onto his territory.
cats just need to stay indoors. they're domesticated, they aren't wild animals, they aren't meant to roam around a neighborhood. outdoor cats live between 3-5 years because of all the danger they are exposed to (animal attacks, venomous creatures, ingesting something toxic). cats that stay indoors can live up to 20 years. be responsible pet owners and take care of your animals.
I've had multiple cats live to 15 plus years, and they are outside/ inside cats. Don't get a cat if you're going to deny it it's freedoms. That's cruel.
@@groowanderer I tend to agree with you, if it's outside of the city. They may be domesticated animals but that doesn't mean their instincts or natural behaviors have been eradicated.
@@granitemoss1451 I feel so bad for animals inside large cities. No yards of their own, nowhere to run and play, not even any good views of nature outside a window. Just cramped inside small apartments in order to try and alleviate some humans boredom and needs to nurture.
lets face it cats can be dicks! Cats fight. If you do not want to risk you cat getting into a fight then keep your cat inside. Or make a big cat cage outside to keep your cat safe. Cats will pretty much fight anything in the right mood.
she should have called bylaw each time his cat attacked her cat outside her fenced in back door. they would have put it down and he would have had ample notice to keep his cat indoor.
She should have just kept her cat in or on a leash under supervision. The poor thing can't even defend itself yet she puts it out and walks away. You sound sick, to wish his cat put down instead of wishing for her to take some responsibility for her own cat's safety.
My cat likes to go outside for about 15-20 minutes a day but he is never outside without me. He actually even waits for me and looks to make sure I am there with him
Where was he when the cat was attacked? He keeps saying she shut the door but she saw the end of the attack and he had to be told about it. How was that missed 🧐
So if he let his cat out, it went onto someone’s else property and clawed someone’s eyes out…it’s the persons fault that it was attacked by the cat on their own property? Also, animals are considered property. His property damaged her property. He is responsible. This is ridiculous lol
This is why there are so many nightmare stories of people killing their neighbor's pets. People need to stop being so obsessed with how free their cats are allowed to be and think about how people will treat their cats when they roam.
2:26 Idk if these cats have been spayed, or neutered, but having that done can help animals to refrain from fighting as much. I will admit that it doesn’t keep them from fighting all together.
The judge saying that the defendant can let his cat go into her yard and it's no issue is so odd and frankly dangerous to me. I've heard so many 1st hand accounts of people whose cats (and sometimes dogs) got poisoned and killed because the neighbors didn't like them and didn't want them on their property. I kind of wish all states had laws about cats because at the end of the day, the cat is who is gonna be killed when a neighbor gets fed up and it's not fair for animals who don't understand property lines.
I have had cats my entire life. KEEP THEM INDOORS unless they are barn cats and have a specific purpose on the farm (ie rodent population control). Leaving a front door open to "protect" cat does NOTHING if the predator (coyote, raccoon, fox, etc) follow the cat inside. If your cat MUST go outside, you monitor and keep a leash on them. Problem solved.
I let my cats go inside, outside however they see fit. But then again I don't have predators, and if there ever were any my dogs would rip em to pieces to protect my cat. They're family.
Wow. I'd be so annoyed. No way I have to stand outside and babysit my cat but you get to relax inside while your cat runs around attacking other people's cats. And the gag is you know it happening!!
At first I was on her side a little bit, but at the end she's kinda unreasonable, the same way she doesn't want to coordinate the times, is the same way he shouldn't have to change his schedule to accommodate her schedule. My dog has certain times, but we also do random times too. I shouldn't have to be beholden to someone else's life schedule. Ridiculous. He paid the beotch. She needs to build him a cat tunnel and end this . She's kinda acting a little entitled. As if the laws don't have anything to do with her.
Coming from someone who is hard of hearing, I too block my one ear when I’m not wanting to hear something… In this situation, it is disrespectful. You filed the case… have respect to hear what she had to say since you’re taking her time. Lol taking out your earbud 😂
If her cat is only out for 15 minutes two times a day, she should stay with it to make sure it’s okay.
I never let my cat outside alone I always stand right next to him..It's irresponsible to leave them alone
Exactly 💯
She is a pain in the ass and doesn’t take responsibility for keeping her cat safe he tried to work with her to coordinate times so that their cats wouldn’t come in contact and she refused he even paid one of the vet bills maybe she’ll learn when a different cat or even coyote attacks her cat
@@alyssahamlett Not unless it is an outdoor cat, In America they are allowed to roam. Dogs cannot do that.
Exactly leashes exist
This is the first time I've ever changed my outlook on who is right in this case. This man has defended himself well.
👍🏿
i liked how he presented his case talking for 5 min and
the judge sat intently listening w/out interrupting as she usually does
If your cat is elderly missing teeth which also means (unable to defend herself) and has been previously attacked, why wouldn’t you as an owner watch your cat when it goes out??? This was solely on her and she should be grateful the defendant payed her the 1st time.
True but her cat is being terrorized in her own yard. If your cat is causing damage then what? He needs to watch his bully cat. But I wouldn't leave my cat unattended either
@@ericablige9449 No, she needs to watch her old cat. The cat clearly cant defend itself so she needs to either work with the defendant or spend the time outside
I have 2 Cats that never leave my fenced in back yard,
but other Cats easily climb the 7ft. fence and come in.
Sometimes there's fights and it scares the crap out of my wallet.
100% agree it is the owners responsibility to look after her elderly cat. I do agree it is also defendant's responsibility to watch his cat but as a animal owner if you put your animal outside unattended cat lady r dog then you are sadly risking your animal. I have a 13 yr old labrador, fenced in yard, but she's never outside unattended. I don't mean you have to be the pets shadow but you should remain aware of what's going on while your animal is outside. I wish that having a enclosed area would mean that your pet is safe but sadly their are ALOT of irresponsible pet owners. I also believe that sometimes cat owners may treat a cat outside a little different than a dog. I have a neighbor who puts her kitties outside but puts a long leash and collar on them and they play outside while shes in her yard. I completely understand feeling like if your pet is in your enclosed yard they should be safe but their r IRRESPONSIBLE owners. Some cat owners just allow their cats to free reign the neighborhood and its easier for a cat to get into a enclosed area than a dog.
@@britney598 well I hope its the same deal if your bully cat get injured in my yard. Keep that same energy. You should have been watching Your cat. If someone complained about my pet I would do something out of respect. Ppl are mean. Your cat may not come back home.
The defendant is well spoken. I don’t think he intended to be a creep. His intentions were honest in my opinion.
Yeah me too I believe him I believe he was looking out for the health and welfare of his own cat because his neighborhood is teaming with wildlife that could hurt his beloved princess, she's the creep and the pink hair looks dreadful on her.
I’m sorry, but if you have cats that go outside, you take your chances on what can happen to them. In this case, I believe the defendant is right.
Finally someone that's sensible. People online think I'm cruel because I allow my cat it's freedoms to go in or out at will. I think it's cruel to lock a cat up all day, never experiencing freedom. But I'm also well aware that if my cat gets injured or attacked while outside, then that's my problem, no one else's. Be it by dog or any other animal, I accept full responsibility to pay for vet bills or anything else.
I agree
EXACTLY! especially when the defendant said there are coyotes and bobcats roaming around. When you allow your pet to go outside, you take your chances with their safety
Creeper or not, the defendant knew his stuff and he seems like a reasonable guy. The plaintiff seems like the type to call the cops for no reason.
I thought the same, plaintiff is the prob here
I agree. She tried to set him up as having faulty character with the "binocular" story but he was very forthcoming and sincere. He might be a little eccentric but I don't think he's creepy like she painted him out to be.
I totally disagree. she shouldn't have to tell when her cat wants outside. especially since it stays on its own property. heneeds to fix the behavior or get rid of his cat
She’s whites with glasses and pink hair. Of course
The man tried to open up conversation with his neighbors and she shut it down then sued him. Miserable woman
If your neighborhood is teeming with wildlife, including coyotes and bobcats, why are you letting your cats out?
💯💯💯💯💯
This!!
100% !
Exactly
@@Fakecourt Same. I live in California and I’ve seen them at all hours. You never know, and also, how could you ever save your cat from a midday attack? It’s not like the majority of us have the reflexes for that.
He offered you a solution and you didn't take it. You don't HAVE to take up his solution, BUT if you also do nothing to protect your own property, then you're shit out of luck.
I understand her annoyance with this man and his cat but I would never have the audacity to blame it on someone else if my cat was unattended in the front yard where any animal could come
She’s being ridiculous!
If she thought her cat was in danger then why put it out and close the door?!
What if a coyote grabbed the cat? She gonna sue wildlife management in the area?
Can’t stand superstitious people I swear
@@versatileduplicity9313 Who’s superstitious?
@@tammypetruzzi9367 she is
@@versatileduplicity9313 I guess.
Because only pink haired fauna is allowed inside the house
Interesting, I just saw almost the exact same case on judge Judy, and she made the cat owner pay the doctor bills. Judy said you’re free to not have your cat on a leash but you’re still responsible for any damage it causes. These types of inconsistencies make ”law” a sketchy business.
Ikr
small claims is a whole different ballgame...especially the tv kind they're diff then actual small claims. I saw that judge Judy episode too
She contradicted herself in another ruling. She's wishy washy.
It could have been in a cat leash law state…
Different areas
The Defendant was very reasonable and amicable. If it's fifteen minutes, twice per day, you stay and monitor your cat, especially in an area with bobcats and coyotes.
If you let your cat outside it will get into fights
@@AndukeMTGEDH not if supervised.
no, keep your cat safe and that means inside!! defendant and plaintiff are both WRONG
My cat is indoors. I often fantasize about making his world larger by letting him out. But then stories like this case snap me out of it right quick
I live in coyote country, I NEVER let my cat outside, and he lived to be 19yrs old!
We got him fixed when he was a baby, and he was blessed with perfect health his whole life, until about a week before he passed.
THAT was a pretty good run!
He only ate Chicken Soup For The Soul Dry Cat Food, drank lots of water and I made sure he got plenty of exercise.
If your cat is young, I recommend getting a harness and leash training them if you'd like them to see the world and get fresh air. Or, they have strollers now, too!
Mango was too old for that stuff, but I wish he'd had a stroller, that would've been neat.
I know your comment is a year old but just wanted to mention, if you haven't found one yet, there are some really nice catteries available online. I found one that hooks directly to the window so the cat can go in and out whenever they want. It's also designed to be able to put two of them together to make it a double for more room. Just a thought. God Bless!
💯 my cat LOVES the thought of going out & breaks out every chance he gets 😂 with me & his dog right on his tail. Hawks, owls, dogs, cars etc... DANGER! His best life IS in our house because I know he's ALIVE.
The defendant actually seems nice and reasonable
I love cats and I know they like to be outdoors, but don't count on them living long if you let them roam.
Especially since it's illegal in most states to let your cats roam at will. You can count on them eventually being killed by a car, antifreeze, a stray pellet, BB, trap, poison, etc...Just keep them indoors like you want dog owners to do.
You don't even need to confine your cats inside to keep them safe! I've always bought large cat runs, or fenced in pens. The cats can still enjoy outdoor time, fresh air, lie in the sun, etc. without being at risk of traffic, other animals, getting lost, and so on.
Pens can be found very cheaply! It's illegal here for cats to be loose at night, and cat runs or pens are becoming far more common during the day.
My cats have always been indoor cats. They don't care. We have a large enclosed porch I can open the sliding door to fill the hummingbird feeders. The Tom's will stay 4' from the open door and watch me but won't get near it. I had one beloved cat years ago that was killed by a car. Since then all my cats live indoors. I even feed the feral cats on my little deck my cats love to watch them but it's never a problem. Our area is in the middle of state pine forest we have all the animals the gentleman described plus an 8' bear. Now all my cats live to over 20 yrs.
i literally my favorite cat this way. i agree.
My indoor/outdoor cat lived in northern Illinois to almost 25 years old…
Cat's are going to be cats. Don't let your cats outside and expect them to come home in perfect condition. I am a very big cat lover and cat mom. Keep your cats inside.
I let my cat outdoors sometimes but I stand right next to him watching every move ...I also have a 8 month kitten and she doesn't go out cause she's got kitten brains and isn't predictable like my older one, it's not safe for her. people need to be responsible for their own pets
If you were truly a cat lover then you wouldn't be locking them in your house all day everyday. That's cruel. You're simply AFRAID that your cat might get hurt, but guess what, that's life. My kid can fall off his bike and break his neck that doesn't mean he can't ride a bike. You probably like to cry about animals in zoos, locked up in cages, but then you do the same exact thing to your cat. If you cannot ever let your cat outside to be a cat (hunt, roam, socialize) then don't get one.
@@groowanderer cats jump walls and fences and some don't return home. You can love your cat and keep them inside. Being outside can be dangerous for them . House cats are not wild animals that suffer from living indoors. They're safer in doors.
@@ellisisland4902 you missed my point I think. Yes you can love your cat by keeping em in, but you are doing that for yourself more than anything imo. A cat deserves to live a real life how its life was intended to be lived. People that keep em in are so busy acting like they're just concerned for their cat when in reality they're just alleviating their own fears. If a cat could talk they'd tell you they need nature, they need to roam, they need to hunt, they need socialization with other cats. They would not tell you "yes please keep me locked up so I can never never be in any danger". It's just how I feel about it, same as those that crate their dogs.
I've heard some talk about building a cat run that goes outside and is big but not possible for the cat to escape. I guess that's some improvement from keeping them inside their whole lives.
@@groowanderer I understand your point but in your first line it looks like you're implying she doesn't love her cat because she doesn't her let her outside. That's what I was addressing. I let my cat out in the backyard because he loves being outside but I supervise him and don't let him wander where I can'tsee him. He's too important to our family. He lived outside before I adopted him and I know in his heart he will always be an outside cat. I'm a huge advocate for catios because yes they do deserve the outside just like we do and frankly I believe they appreciate it alot more.
The plaintiff is just another Karen who does not want to listen to the judge and is a pain in the ###.
Defendant is straight up awesome!! Everyone should be so lucky to have him as a neighbor!
If I was that guy I'd steer clear of her.. she's trouble
Why cant people just have a respectful convo and work things out like mature adults 🤦🏼♀️
*Some people
If they did that, we wouldn't have court shows.
According to the news, even that's a risk. People out here shooting people dead over the smallest issues. It's crazy.
Because people grow up with the parents that teaches them the world owes them something.
@@ButtonsCasey Well Id rather deal with civilized people than watch court shows. Some of these cases are petty af 🙄
You don't even need to confine your cats inside to keep them safe! I've always bought large cat runs, or fenced in pens. The cats can still enjoy outdoor time, fresh air, lie in the sun, etc. without being at risk of traffic, other animals, getting lost, and so on.
Pens can be found very cheaply! It's illegal here for cats to be loose at night, and cat runs or pens are becoming far more common during the day.
yes!! I was just sharing this, my cat goes out occasionally but only with me and I don't leave his side. they have strollers backpacks ect no exceptions
I've wanted to do something for our cats but it's impossible. Between having two 20+ pound cats and a destruction demon spawn that graduated top of his class at Satan's School of Hellians, yeah it would not work.
My cat is leash trained and I never leave her alone outside. Things happen in a split second. This woman isn't responsible although she tries to paint a picture perfect owner.
I wanted to do that with my younger cat when I first got him but wasn't sure how to go about it. Don't know if he's too old for that now or he would have interest in going out. I let my cats go on my deck but I have no stairs for them to get into the yard. They enjoy themselves and no worries. I believe in leash laws cause I hate to see cats roam. They can get hurt by cars, weather, dogs, etc. And I don't think its right for cat to go on someone else's property.
@@SlashTheWeasel My cat was a rescue. At first she hated the harness. My learning mistake was taking it off/on. Once I started leaving it on she got used to it. She knows that I hook a long leash for her to be outside.
The cat won't like it at first.
Best of luck 😽💛
@@annsayger5842 All the cats I've had are rescue/shelter cats too. Is it possible to start with approx five year old boy cat? I fear the big outdoors may be too much for him.
@@SlashTheWeasel Sorry I didn't see your question until today.
I believe just put the harness on and do not take it off. Probably within a couple of days put the leash on & go out side. I had it long at 1st. Do not take the harness off. Now at 1st he may not like it but leave the harness on. Slowly, probably in a month he will get use to it. My cat does not want to take off the harness when I replace it with a new one. Always keep an eye out for dogs. My cat travels in my vehicle too. Best wishes.
Keep Your Cats Indoors 😻
No. That's cruel to the cat.
@@groowanderer well then don’t be surprised when it goes to the pound
@@BeccasaurousRex270 the pound doesn't pick up cats in Idaho.
As a veterinarian it's not cruel to keep the cat safe and indoors. There are too many dangers out there including humans. My cat is quite happy being indoors. She has it made and is quite spoiled rotten. I can leave my door wide open and she will not run outside because she doesn't want to be outside.
@@bassdmin7436 sure, sure. You'd be the first to cry about a tiger kept in a cage though right? It's the same thing, keeping your cat from being the absolute furthest thing from what it's intended to be, a free animal. To me it's cruel. I live in the country, and yes there are predators (you realize a cat is one) and I've got my dog to take care of those. My cat serves a purpose. He keeps mice and other Rodents at bay, and out of my house and garden. I honestly feel that people in big cities shouldn't even have cats. Get a gerbil or something that doesn't have natural instincts to hunt, kill, explore...
Most cats have no road fear. Fighting and running the roads is a risk you take if you let them out alone. Crazy lady.
Something tells me , thats the cleanest corner of the pink haired lady's house.
It's called a CATIO! Build one! Jesus, they have houses and they still can't contain their animals. MY GOD!
they even have cat playpen type things on Amazon so ur cat can be outside but can't run off. or a leash, n like u said a catio! irresponsible owners
He seemed a very nice neighbor! She seems crazy
Until they find the bodies in the basement... Kidding 🤣
Just keep your elderly cat indoors. Problem solved.
This is why my cat is indoor only. I already know she can't handle herself outside with the local cats. Several years ago, a large feral cat broke through my window screen downstairs while I was upstairs napping. I woke up to my poor kitty being chased around my living room by a huge cat, which I was able to shoo with a broom into my downstairs bathroom until animal control came. My poor kitty was so traumatized. Her cat shouldn't be outside without her if there are known cats nearby. Cats will be cats and are way too territorial to take chances.
speaking facts! man those street cats r no joke..breaking and entering, crazy
Why if you love your cat so much you let them outside? My cats are indoor for life
Dude might have been a creeper,,, but daaaaaang he totally flipped this around and convinced JM!! 👏👏👏
yeah she's a negligent owner. you have a cat that has lost some ability to protect itself and you know there are other cats about, then take the time to go outside with the cat .
you would do it for children , why not the cat.
her head is stuck in a "i have to be right' mentality in a situtation where she is dead wrong
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼I absolutely agree with your comment.
Judge Milian: “Yeah what are you doing with binoculars? That’s creepy as hell”🤣🤣
I rescued a stray cat and it’s not a good inside cat and has always lived outside! She has been in a couple of cat fights, including one that landed her at the vet. Cats come in my yard all the time and most of the time my cat stays in my yard but cats do what cats do. She is responsible for her cat! I think the solution would be a cat door then she can unlock it for those 15 minutes twice a day so her can has a place of refuge.
I have cats roaming around my house all the time. Thats why my cat stays inside or goes out in the screen porch
I agree with posters that say… she should be outside with her cat to ensure it’s safety.
“I’m busy!” - not an excuse.
I feel so bad for that cat. Her twilight years deserve better than what she’s getting with her human Mom.
Plaintiff's cat is gonna be some coyote's dinner.
I have coyotes and i had a chihuahua get killed. I live on 22 acres of land. I used to let them run free. Now i am outside every time they go out and i watch every move they make. She is an irresponsible pet owner
@@monicabroussard840 I live in an urban area. I've heard a bobcat, there is a report of a coyote pack, and also a cougar with a few miles of my house. My dogs go into my fenced in backyard under supervision.
😢 I HAD A MALE GINGER CAT RIP OPEN A SCREEN. SADLY THE COYOTE'S GOT HIM. I'M STILL HEARTBROKEN 💔😢
@@Fakecourt lol that's a pretty heartless "fun fact". Do you also laugh at funerals?
She’s the creepy one
I had a cat, I loved my cat and when my cat got into fights with other animals, I took my cat to the vet... End of story! I didn't look for the owner of the other animal seeking retribution!
if she dont have any money at all ?
Same here. I have a cat who won’t come inside. I have a cat who won’t go outside. And one cat that’s both inside/outside. The two times it happened in the past, I’ve taken my cat to the vet & paid for it myself.
@@Jsarmy87124 Not having money isn't an excuse to not care for a pet.... Vets will allow you to sign over your cat if you don't want to go into debt over the bills. It's always required to do what's in the best interest of the animal even if that means giving it up.
So totally true!
@@Jsarmy87124 Then don't have a pet.
My question is if you keep seeing your cat getting attacked why do you keep putting her outside unsupervised? Make it make sense
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Well said! The creepy pink haired nut isn’t a responsible cat mom.
she's right...you don't suture cat fight wounds unless the skin is hanging off. And even then you would put in a drain and leave a hole open for drainage.
ok i like the defendant now. he is very wise and thought out his responses.
He’s so creepy and weird….
And wrong! No reason to let your cat outside when you know it is stocking other animals and when you claim you know the area is dangerous!
My cats have times they spend on our screened in porch throughout the day with the door cracked. In the warmer weather, we put them in harnesses with a lead attached to a stake in the middle of the yard and they love it. Always supervised in some way though..I would never let them roam free! And I don't think they want to. They like feeling safe and having their home base they're familiar with inside and out.
I can't keep the harness on, he's like Houdini! How do you keep it on?!
If your cat leaves your yard they will probably get into a fight. Don't let them outside if you don't want them to fight
This woman cannot be pleased. Looking for her "off" button.
I'm surprise by the ruling in general but I thinking the defendant did have a great argument. If the plaintiff cared about her cat, she would have also changed her routine no matter how annoying it would be. Both are responsible to not let this happen again. If it was true that the defendant offered his phone number to resolve this, that was a good plan. However, I can also see how ridiculous it might be to have to call ur neighbor 2 times a day. Then they should just agree that between certain times, they will let their cat out to avoid the other. It's not that hard. It is just something we deal with living in society...
You slow
Completely agree, if I had a cat that was being bullied and my neighbor asked to call him the 2 times a day I put my cat out I would do it. I know it may be annoying but honestly it would just be easier to do the call just to make sure my pet was safe. A cat is totally different than a dog, cats can jump fences and other enclosed areas easier than a dog. I would just do it to make sure my kitty was safe because that is easier than worrying about her/him being hurt. Just my opinion, cats will be cats and we r the 1's who need to be responsible and have ability to reason out things ALOT better than a animal. I know a cat can get over my fence so to be safe I'm going to be outside, especially if it's 4 a short time, while my kitty is having outside time.
Judge Judy legit said the opposite about cats and they both interpreted the law differently 😹
@@michellet7013 do you know what episode? I want to look up the jurisdiction and see the facts because like JM said, defendants is only when he’s negligent (ie. he beached a legal duty he had).
The defendant was a lovely man. I wish he was my neighbor. Not the plaintiff who seemed most unpleasant and uncaring. It seems her lovely cat isn't worth a phone call or 40 minutes of her time a day. Will she try to sue a driver if her cat is run over?
8:48 stalking Athena. She makes it sounds like the cat will bypass 50th cats to stalk or attack her cat.
Stalk
@@Childfree334 Damn, thanks!
This is why you get an indoor cat and call it a day to avoid situations like this. Folks are so difficult these days. Keep it simple
All my kitties are indoor kitties. I had some before for years and years that were inside outdoor and we had a 6 ft fence. After 14 years one jumped the fence and the dog next door killed her. I never let the others out again. They can look out the windows and screen door at the birds or rabbits and squirrels.
Simple minded, yes. It's cruel to a cat to keep it locked up inside its whole life, never tasting freedom or being able to explore, hunt, all the things in its nature to do. I feel like if you can't handle a cat being a cat, then don't get one. Same people that lock their cats up inside their whole lives like to complain about animals locked in cages at zoos, and it's very hypocritical.
@@cathyterrell6155 how very kind of you to tease your cat by letting it see nature but never experience it.
@@groowanderer it’s better than a coyote or hawk getting it. So F off!
Oh just shut up. I had an outdoor cat for 10 years.
This is the most CALIFORNIA case I’ve ever witnessed
She appeared more intent on defaming his character than supporting her cat. He reflects someone she is which might make her more intent to distance herself from him.
Right? Her constant he's creepy comments, and saying that many people in the neighborhood avoid him screams highschool mean girl energy.
Naaaaaaah Princess needs to stay out of other people's yards. No way you can WATCH your cat stalk another cat then put all the blame on someone else
The case of the crazy cat people. If you live in an area with bobcats and coyotes, and you let your cat you, you don't really care about your cat.
I have an old cat also. When he goes out either myself, my husband or my teenager stays right with him. Be responsible for YOUR pet!
When I was in my 20s I had a neighbor that walked her cat on leash. I thought she fell of her rocker and didn't recover. Now that I'm old she was being responsible
A water hose woulda solved that problem. She wouldn't've hurt the cat but it would be scared to approach the property again.
I use a spray bottle with a stream to discipline mine. I had one female cat to stalk another female cat before. I think the stalker sensed fear in the other so occasionally they would fight for 10 seconds and stop or I'd shake the water bottle and they'd disperse.
I love the Plaintiff's glasses 🤓.
I use the same thing!!! it's so funny both cats love to drink running water but u squeeze that spray bottle n they're out 😂 it works like a charm
We use the squirt bottle for our cats and dogs if need be. Our cats know what the bottle means, so now I just have to say the cats name and water. They stop and fast. Minus my boy Mowgli. He's just evil. Little 😈 that he is.
All she has to do,is stay in the yard..while her cat is outside..😂😂😂😂
Keep your cat inside. Not everyone wants to see your cat on their property.
This is why I personally have indoor cats because I will never know nor be able to protect my cat from harm that might come to it.. Dog and cat or cat and cat fights.. getting run over by car just wondering and never coming back.. All risks when you have outdoor cats. Doesnt matter if the attack was in her backyard or down the street things like this are bound to happen sometimes. The man tried to give her a solution to their problem but she didnt like that idea, and now her cat paid the price for it but its not his fault it happened. She should have been thrilled he help pay for any of it at all and just let it go.
Plaintiff needs to use a little negative reinforcement with princess. Scare that cat a few times and it will stay away.
Let your cat outside at your own risk.
There are toppers that you can put on your fences to keep cats either in or out depending on which way they are installed. There are also motion detected sprinklers to keep cats to teach cats to stay in/out. Lots of humane options to fix this problem without going after your neighbor sigh.
She has life twisted. She said "he knew ..." BUT SHE KNEW, too. How does she expect this man to have a greater duty of care for her cat than she has? She knew that cat was vicious toward her own cat and just let it out to be prey.
He sounds like a good neighbor
Cats belong indoors! Cats will absolutely do all the things she stated. The vet will also do all the things stated.
I was bitten by my cats twice inside while they were protected themselves.
No fault to my cats. Defendant is absolutely at fault. Cats are property under the law. Cats use claws more than teeth btw.
Also Domestic Cats are one reason wild birds are in major decline.
If you truly care for all animals you keep your cat inside!
Plaintiff is not at fault. I don't agree with Judge M! ✌
It annoys me when people let their cats outside then complain when attacked. Keep your pets indoors if you are not going to supervise them
Cats like being outside, its in their nature
The hair, the glasses, the cats, I see a future episode of hoarders for her.
“Cat leash laws, whatever” says the Plaintiff
I’m with grandpa. Cats are not dogs. She only wanted money not a resolution.
Isn’t there usually leash laws??? Even for cats!!!!!
No.
i totally disagree with the judge on this. he should be responsible for bills plus keeping his cat off her property.
Wrong. They're cats. Besides, didn't they say the attack happened in the street? That's neither of their properties.
You can see JM is high key try harding hard not to crack up laughing at this foolishness. People that take cats so seriously are either awkwardly hysterical or outright annoying. And this is coming from someone who’s had cats for 20 years. 😹😹
I take my cats seriously as well as my dogs. It's not wrong to do that.
She lying. She tried to prey on this old man
Karens will always use the I didn’t feel comfortable line lol
I have had cats my whole life and am a super firm believer that ALL CATS should always be indoor ONLY!! All of this mess would be avoided if you always keep cats inside. If you want, you can cat proof your yard to keep your cat safe against your cats getting out and against anything getting into your yard. Please people, keep your kitties inside. And another thing: if there are coyotes and bobcats and all kinds of wild animals wandering around, WHY THE HELL ARE YOU LETTING YOUR CATS OUT DOORS?!?!?! 🙄
This my first time hearing a case with cats. I thought her case was won but then the defendant came in with such a compelling argument that you can’t argue the fact that he tried to do what was necessary for them both. Growing I’ve always prejudged people who I perceived as being weird but since I’ve grown up, something as simple as a “hi” or a hand wave changed my perception tremendously. Everyone is human and we shouldn’t jump to conclusions. The defendant is very well spoken and maybe if the plaintiff stopped going by word of mouth and speaking even if it was just to say hi, she would’ve known that he’s a reasonable guy.
My male cat was neutered at 2 months old, and stayed on our land. He was an outside cat that wouldn’t allow any humans to touch him except me. He was protective of his area, and didn’t like all the ferral neighbors cats coming onto his territory.
cats just need to stay indoors.
they're domesticated, they aren't wild animals, they aren't meant to roam around a neighborhood. outdoor cats live between 3-5 years because of all the danger they are exposed to (animal attacks, venomous creatures, ingesting something toxic). cats that stay indoors can live up to 20 years. be responsible pet owners and take care of your animals.
I've had multiple cats live to 15 plus years, and they are outside/ inside cats. Don't get a cat if you're going to deny it it's freedoms. That's cruel.
@@groowanderer I tend to agree with you, if it's outside of the city. They may be domesticated animals but that doesn't mean their instincts or natural behaviors have been eradicated.
@@granitemoss1451 I feel so bad for animals inside large cities. No yards of their own, nowhere to run and play, not even any good views of nature outside a window. Just cramped inside small apartments in order to try and alleviate some humans boredom and needs to nurture.
Couldn't she just get a cat run to avoid all this? Safer for the cat, birds, and other predators outside.
Finally an intro that isn’t completely stupid 😊
lets face it cats can be dicks! Cats fight. If you do not want to risk you cat getting into a fight then keep your cat inside. Or make a big cat cage outside to keep your cat safe. Cats will pretty much fight anything in the right mood.
she should have called bylaw each time his cat attacked her cat outside her fenced in back door. they would have put it down and he would have had ample notice to keep his cat indoor.
Put the cat down for being a cat? What crime did the cat commit to deserve the death sentence?
She should have just kept her cat in or on a leash under supervision. The poor thing can't even defend itself yet she puts it out and walks away. You sound sick, to wish his cat put down instead of wishing for her to take some responsibility for her own cat's safety.
Happy Friday Everyone!!! Also Happy Good Friday to all my Christian✝️ siblings and Happy Passover to all my Jewish ✡️ siblings ❤️ 💙!!!
Same to you my sister in Christ.
Happy Friday All. What a Blessing it is to see Another Good Friday 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
Happy good Friday!! God bless you and keep you in Jesus name ❤❤🙏 and all the peoples court peeps! Lol ❤
Thank you. Peaceful Good Friday in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ amen.🙏❤️🇮🇪
God bless you!!
Just keep your cats inside. If your cat attacks it needs to be kept indoors!
My cat likes to go outside for about 15-20 minutes a day but he is never outside without me. He actually even waits for me and looks to make sure I am there with him
Where was he when the cat was attacked? He keeps saying she shut the door but she saw the end of the attack and he had to be told about it. How was that missed 🧐
why would that matter? His cat is an outdoor cat and they dont reside in a cat leash law state
@@britney598 why does his cat get to be the only outdoor cat where is his responsibility it’s still his cat so it’s his responsibility.
So if he let his cat out, it went onto someone’s else property and clawed someone’s eyes out…it’s the persons fault that it was attacked by the cat on their own property? Also, animals are considered property. His property damaged her property. He is responsible. This is ridiculous lol
This is why there are so many nightmare stories of people killing their neighbor's pets. People need to stop being so obsessed with how free their cats are allowed to be and think about how people will treat their cats when they roam.
He paid a vet bill🤔
So, if the cat had come into the yard and had attacked a human, would it have changed the ruling????
Good question... you send to Judge M and her husband to answer
Ya I don’t get this. I obviously love cats but I don’t see how it’s okay for your cat to roam on someone else’s property.
2:26 Idk if these cats have been spayed, or neutered, but having that done can help animals to refrain from fighting as much. I will admit that it doesn’t keep them from fighting all together.
The judge saying that the defendant can let his cat go into her yard and it's no issue is so odd and frankly dangerous to me. I've heard so many 1st hand accounts of people whose cats (and sometimes dogs) got poisoned and killed because the neighbors didn't like them and didn't want them on their property. I kind of wish all states had laws about cats because at the end of the day, the cat is who is gonna be killed when a neighbor gets fed up and it's not fair for animals who don't understand property lines.
I have had cats my entire life. KEEP THEM INDOORS unless they are barn cats and have a specific purpose on the farm (ie rodent population control). Leaving a front door open to "protect" cat does NOTHING if the predator (coyote, raccoon, fox, etc) follow the cat inside. If your cat MUST go outside, you monitor and keep a leash on them. Problem solved.
I let my cats go inside, outside however they see fit. But then again I don't have predators, and if there ever were any my dogs would rip em to pieces to protect my cat. They're family.
I blame the plaintiff 100%. Why did she let her cat outside? People, these are just one, of so many reasons you need to keep your cats indoors!
Good call!! I Love Judge M. This is a "Karen".. jeez!
This lady acts like she looks normal herself lol
REALLY OVER CATS 🐈 I KNEW WHERE IT WAS GOING FROM THE START THOSE FOLKS ARE HILARIOUS NEVER SEEMS TO AMAZE ME BOTH ARE WEIRD & NUTTY
Wow. I'd be so annoyed. No way I have to stand outside and babysit my cat but you get to relax inside while your cat runs around attacking other people's cats. And the gag is you know it happening!!
At first I was on her side a little bit, but at the end she's kinda unreasonable, the same way she doesn't want to coordinate the times, is the same way he shouldn't have to change his schedule to accommodate her schedule. My dog has certain times, but we also do random times too. I shouldn't have to be beholden to someone else's life schedule. Ridiculous. He paid the beotch. She needs to build him a cat tunnel and end this . She's kinda acting a little entitled. As if the laws don't have anything to do with her.
You’re only against her cause the judge was. That’s why you changed your mind. Stop lying
Coming from someone who is hard of hearing, I too block my one ear when I’m not wanting to hear something… In this situation, it is disrespectful. You filed the case… have respect to hear what she had to say since you’re taking her time. Lol taking out your earbud 😂
She sounds ridiculous saying that cats are stalking cats. lol
Agree totally..would you let your 5 year old play near a busy roadway unattended ??