The Song that struck Bob Dylan in Paris - Nick Cave's Joy

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 янв 2025

Комментарии • 22

  • @francemary1863
    @francemary1863 11 дней назад

    It' s beautiful for us to read this "exchange " between two great artists. Treasures.We read so mad, stupid purposes in our society, We need this so much. And Nick Cave with his site " red hand files" has created something unique, extraordinary. THANKS, THANKS. ( I was in this concert in Paris, an artistic, human beauty).

  • @slyeung6562
    @slyeung6562 25 дней назад +3

    Thank you Bobfan so much for sharing this wonderful song 🎉

  • @nissi.k
    @nissi.k Месяц назад +22

    Thank you Bobfan! l think it's so great that you shared this! I had read what Bob said and Nick's letter of response! So nice how one word from Bob means so much and especially an acknowledgement of agreement! Encouragement with love can really have a deep impact 🥰sometimes! Keep up the great work BF - it is much appreciated!

  • @HelianaSuper
    @HelianaSuper Месяц назад +10

    "... now it is the time for joy".... Since we can forget all sad things ever happen....🤔🤔
    But this is as a prayer... and It is wonderful.... Thanks, Neverending...🙏🙏🌻🌻🙌🙌

  • @ThomasOftheroof
    @ThomasOftheroof Месяц назад +12

    what a joy to read this. Perhaps both of them are readers of their elder W. S. Merwin, "There are so many words for sadness/ and for joy so few/ maybe none/ that can tell/ the sound of that secret spring"

  • @robertd8351
    @robertd8351 Месяц назад +6

    Well I am glad that both Cave and Dylan found some common ground in that song (or the concert as a whole ). I can relate to it myself I think. I am also glad that Warren Ellis is credited as co-songwriter because he has done a lot for Cave in the past many years.

  • @lawrenceprice4245
    @lawrenceprice4245 Месяц назад +1

    I once experienced joy after I took Ectasy and it has happened naturally but not often enough.Nick and Bob are the knights of constant sorrow it may even have improved them as artists and as exceptional human beings It certainty has deepened. them

  • @targarosko
    @targarosko Месяц назад +4

    ♥♥♥♥♥♥

  • @rvliver5725
    @rvliver5725 Месяц назад +3

    Such joy I never heard. Eh? thx

  • @Elisha-xy5gl
    @Elisha-xy5gl Месяц назад +4

    🎉

  • @michaelmcloughlin8237
    @michaelmcloughlin8237 Месяц назад +4

    Michael McLoughlin
    I thank you too Bobfan I thought this was great & to be praised by Bob Dylan
    has to be special. Just wondering have you heard Nick Cave & Shane Magowan
    singing "What a wonderful world" together-you'd like it.

  • @KREN12623
    @KREN12623 Месяц назад

    GLORY TO GOD HALLELUJA AMEN BLESSED BE 🌹YOU 🌹 ALL🌹 AMEN 🙏🔥🙏🔥🙏🔥🙏❤️💪💪💪💪AMEN🌈♀️🖤🌏🌊🐬💙🌍🌬️🦋💛🌎🔥🐝♂️🌈☮️♾️🌀✝️🌀♾️☮️🌈♀️⭐🌈🌟🌈✨🌈💫♂️☮️♾️🌀✝️🌀♾️☮️🙏💪🙏💪🙏💪🙏🌈☮️♾️🌀✝️🌹✝️♾️☮️🌈🖤❤️💛🤍🌈☮️♾️🌀✝️🌹✝️🌀♾️☮️🙏🙏🙏🙏 AMEN

  • @enzogiargia8857
    @enzogiargia8857 Месяц назад +1

    ❤🍇

  • @lorraineburton5840
    @lorraineburton5840 Месяц назад +2

    O my sweet love who stands at the door and knocks
    Oh my sweet love who stands at the door and knocks
    There is such Joy in our heart
    Such Joy in our heart
    To all who opens

  • @doncahooti
    @doncahooti Месяц назад +1

    because Bob Dylan dreams about walking through fire

  • @ZilleNo1
    @ZilleNo1 Месяц назад +1

    Bob is sad, unsatisfied and full of sorrrow. I met him in ERFURT/ KREUZGASSE at the 7th of octobre. Mr. DYLAN, if you read this, give me a sign, send me a message. By the way, this joy-song depresses you. I can't find joy in this song. HAVE MERCY ON ME

    • @ZilleNo1
      @ZilleNo1 Месяц назад +1

      @Mamablissios I agree with you, you are so right. He has to confess to Jesus. Before then, he is not allowed to leave this world. No offense, Bob. 😇 🎸

    • @brunosm.l2267
      @brunosm.l2267 26 дней назад

      Weird as* comment.

    • @freddynetwerk
      @freddynetwerk 24 дня назад

      ​@@ZilleNo1shut up

  • @SuperBingo96
    @SuperBingo96 Месяц назад +1

    Respect to an amazing artist but it sounds like a gin and razorblades song, not joy. IMO.

    • @francemary1863
      @francemary1863 11 дней назад +1

      For me it's more a prayer against misfortune, a desire to seek joy in spite of everything. And then, joy is not happiness...