I have not heard miss Streisand sing this song. Wow! Her own remdistion of the song, two great vocals Judy and Barbara, Judy once said when you sing a song make it your own and miss Barbara did. Great performance . Nothing else to say from this very very talented singer. One of the best we have ever had .
So well summed up to this version without selling Judy up the river. The Beaty of it all is have these two singer singing there own version and each being beautifully valid in there own right. That is called spoilt for choice. I appreciate you love for and there voices and the music.
When they worked together, Barbra and Judy discovered they shared a favorite composer: Harold Arlen (aka Hyman Arluck). He composed the songs for "The Wizard Of Oz" and a number of the songs, including this one, for Judy's version of "A Star Is Born" in 1954. Barbra appeared on the only album recorded by Arlen where he sang, 1966's "Harold Arlen Sings (With Friend)". She duetted with him on "Ding Dong, The Witch is Dead" and sang "House of Flowers". ("House Of Flowers" was a play based on a book by Truman Capote. Truman and Harold wrote they lyrics for the songs and, of course, Harold the music.) I don't know if it was the same night as this performance, but when Liza Minelli attended one of Barbra's concerts during her '93/'94 tour, Barbra said something to the effect, "this is for your mother, Liza". Barbra also did a dedication to Judy prior to singing "Over The Rainbow" during her 1986 fundraiser/concert "Once Voice".
Ms Streisand also did a cover of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" at a concert in 1986, also very different from the many versions Ms Garland has sung, that might interest you.
Two of my favorite singers. Judy and Barbra...where is all the talent? Aaahhh! We need more like them. Thanks for this. Please, please, please react to this. ruclips.net/video/5GUP7bsDPXg/видео.html
Would you do a video on Streisand's "Be Aware" from Burt Bacharach's television special in 1971? It's on RUclips. She does "Close to You" with Burt and then "Be Aware" on her own.
If you want to hear her tour de force song you have to check out Make It Like A Memory from the Guilty Album. She channels some Patti Labelle realness in that song. You will not be disappointed. Hardly anyone reacts to it but everyone that does has been blown away. Love your reviews and your content! ❤
Check out Cher's version of this song. Her entire Bittersweet White Light album is the finest recording she ever did. Listen to the whole thing and then tell me that I'm not right.
I love Cher. And she's a much better singer than even she seems to think. But that Bittersweet album is TERRIBLE. Cher is more than capable of singing those standards - and did many on her TV show - but the album arrangements are beyond awful. It's no accident that the album was a massive flop.
I like Judy's version better as she highlights the song as much as she highlights her own singing. Barbra's version is in some ways more about herself than about the song and the work of Harold Arlen. I find the same thing happens when I listen to some of Celine Dion's work. It's Dion first and the song second. My apologies to both divas if they are offended.
And "add on" to my comments: to me Barbra is one of the most wonderful vocalists of all time. I have a number of her albums. Celine is one of my country's greatest singers. "Oh Canada!" Judy was one of a kind, a product of her own age. All singers have their strengths and weaknesses and that makes the world of music all the more interesting. By the way, I managed to attend live performances of both Judy and Barbra. Yes, I am an old fart.
@joshsmith4560 there is no argument that Streisand has better voice no argument here, but no need to tell you that when someone mentions this song tittle "Tha man that got away" Judy Garland's version will pop up, just because this song alongside Over the Rainbow, Have yourself a very merry Christmas, Get Happy, among other tune's Judy Garland owes them, they belong to her and fortunately only her. It is like to say that nobody owns People, The way we were among many others nobody but Barbra Streisand. This is simply the way it is..!
@@SS-do3zv Rubbish. Her voice was a nasal whine with zero agility. Her strength was sustained note holding and piercing notes in her high range. But flat foot singing - chest belting - Barbara has nothing in Garland, Franklin, Houston etc..
@@markdrinkwater1508that’s insane Barbra’s voice is in stratosphere. Garland sounds like she’s trying to yell with short sloppy notes that sound loud and clunky trying to carry a note with too much vibrato. She can’t even sing a D5 lifted for 19 seconds. Get out of here with that nonsense. Barbra’s voice is clearer and way more dynamic.
Here we go again with Babs Judy comparison so I'll nix it with this: Babs is superb singer but on Man That Got Away only two words needed: Judy Garland
![Megan Thee Stallion - Bigger In Texas [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxTkZTLWdo4/mqdefault.jpg)
Barbra Streisand is simply the best 💝
Garland, Streisand two icons who are legendary. Thank you. ❤️
Love watching you love her like I do 😊
I have not heard miss Streisand sing this song. Wow! Her own remdistion of the song, two great vocals Judy and Barbara, Judy once said when you sing a song make it your own and miss Barbara did. Great performance . Nothing else to say from this very very talented singer. One of the best we have ever had .
Barbra is considered by many in the business to be the best female popular singer of our time.
Done live....LIVE! That's my Barbra
So well summed up to this version without selling Judy up the river. The Beaty of it all is have these two singer singing there own version and each being beautifully valid in there own right. That is called spoilt for choice. I appreciate you love for and there voices and the music.
Fantasiic, nuanced, inspired reaction and analysis!
When they worked together, Barbra and Judy discovered they shared a favorite composer: Harold Arlen (aka Hyman Arluck). He composed the songs for "The Wizard Of Oz" and a number of the songs, including this one, for Judy's version of "A Star Is Born" in 1954. Barbra appeared on the only album recorded by Arlen where he sang, 1966's "Harold Arlen Sings (With Friend)". She duetted with him on "Ding Dong, The Witch is Dead" and sang "House of Flowers". ("House Of Flowers" was a play based on a book by Truman Capote. Truman and Harold wrote they lyrics for the songs and, of course, Harold the music.)
I don't know if it was the same night as this performance, but when Liza Minelli attended one of Barbra's concerts during her '93/'94 tour, Barbra said something to the effect, "this is for your mother, Liza". Barbra also did a dedication to Judy prior to singing "Over The Rainbow" during her 1986 fundraiser/concert "Once Voice".
Barbra, in her Prime, was the BEST. She wasn't quite her "best" in the mid 90s..but still Transcendly Beautiful.
You should listen to the “live yentl melody by Barbra Streisand. It is one of Barbra’s finest moments.
In her NY concert performance where she sings this and where Liza Minelli was in the audience, she tells her "Liza, that was for your mom" 😢
That's so sweet,a nd I love that the Barbra & Judy connection is more than inspiration, they knew each other & have sung together.
The one she sang in nyc on the album is flawless.
Ms Streisand also did a cover of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" at a concert in 1986, also very different from the many versions Ms Garland has sung, that might interest you.
She sounds like every note she hits is right on.
Beyond exquisite à
Two of my favorite singers. Judy and Barbra...where is all the talent? Aaahhh! We need more like them. Thanks for this. Please, please, please react to this. ruclips.net/video/5GUP7bsDPXg/видео.html
Check out Barbra and Celine Dion duet, / TELL HIM/ IT'S A GREAT DUET❤
Would you do a video on Streisand's "Be Aware" from Burt Bacharach's television special in 1971? It's on RUclips. She does "Close to You" with Burt and then "Be Aware" on her own.
If you want to hear her tour de force song you have to check out Make It Like A Memory from the Guilty Album. She channels some Patti Labelle realness in that song. You will not be disappointed. Hardly anyone reacts to it but everyone that does has been blown away. Love your reviews and your content! ❤
Check out Cher's version of this song. Her entire Bittersweet White Light album is the finest recording she ever did. Listen to the whole thing and then tell me that I'm not right.
I absolutely will
I love Cher. And she's a much better singer than even she seems to think. But that Bittersweet album is TERRIBLE. Cher is more than capable of singing those standards - and did many on her TV show - but the album arrangements are beyond awful. It's no accident that the album was a massive flop.
I actually prefer hers to J’s.
Barbra Streisand has the ability to CONTROL the amount of VIBRATO in her singing...very hard to do‼️
👍
Glad you liked it. I didn’t care for it.
I like Judy's version better as she highlights the song as much as she highlights her own singing. Barbra's version is in some ways more about herself
than about the song and the work of Harold Arlen. I find the same thing happens when I listen to some of Celine Dion's work. It's Dion first and the song second. My apologies to both divas if they are offended.
And "add on" to my comments: to me Barbra is one of the most wonderful vocalists of all time. I have a number of her albums. Celine is one of my country's greatest singers. "Oh Canada!" Judy was one of a kind, a product of her own age. All singers have their strengths and weaknesses and that makes the world of music all the more interesting. By the way, I managed to attend live performances of both Judy and Barbra. Yes, I am an old fart.
Sorry Barbra, you are great, but this song belongs to Judy Garland and Judy Garland ALONE..!
Sorry. I think Barbra’s version is better.
@joshsmith4560 there is no argument that Streisand has better voice no argument here, but no need to tell you that when someone mentions this song tittle "Tha man that got away" Judy Garland's version will pop up, just because this song alongside Over the Rainbow, Have yourself a very merry Christmas, Get Happy, among other tune's Judy Garland owes them, they belong to her and fortunately only her. It is like to say that nobody owns People, The way we were among many others nobody but Barbra Streisand. This is simply the way it is..!
Garland was far better, a bigger sound - Streisand was too whiney, though Barbara's high notes - not exhibited here - were immense.
You obviously aren’t familiar with Barbra’s singing her vocal power would drown garlands.
@@SS-do3zv Rubbish. Her voice was a nasal whine with zero agility. Her strength was sustained note holding and piercing notes in her high range. But flat foot singing - chest belting - Barbara has nothing in Garland, Franklin, Houston etc..
@@markdrinkwater1508that’s insane Barbra’s voice is in stratosphere. Garland sounds like she’s trying to yell with short sloppy notes that sound loud and clunky trying to carry a note with too much vibrato. She can’t even sing a D5 lifted for 19 seconds. Get out of here with that nonsense. Barbra’s voice is clearer and way more dynamic.
@@SS-do3zv Utter tosh.
Here we go again with Babs Judy comparison so I'll nix it with this: Babs is superb singer but on Man That Got Away only two words needed: Judy Garland