49:45 reformation in Hindu community was possible not just by Lathi alone. It was possible because the back then the leaders as well as all celebrities (art and business ) were vocal about it. Tell me which leader and liberals celebrities including all movie personalities and business tycoon even mention this SC ruling - let alone call it historic verdict. Growing up I have seen so many movies calling all wrong things in Hindu community - caste / Dowry killings / female infanticide etc . I have not seen a single movie criticizing teen talaq - except Amitabh and Nargis movie
Hindu women in Nepal are more modern than Hindu women in India. This lathi argument is such a bogas argument. Nepal never had such laws but still they progressed more than Indian women.
@@npatel7775It's the same argument that colonizers used to give to justify colonialism. Yet many countries progressed better than former colonies without being colonized.
Lots of sympathy for the Muslim women. It is tragic but also it is their own community and elite Muslims who are biggest issues. I’m a Hindu feminist (not a man hater) and I’m just so disgusted by people like rana ayubb. I appreciate arshia ji for showing us the plight of Indian Muslim women
Man you would be amazed at the number of how many Muslim women from middle class and lower middle class backgrounds also supports the views of Rana Ayyub.
It would have been better if Nikhil stopped interrupting her so much that it gets annoying. It is about muslim women, let her complete her train of thought
If dowry is wrong so is alimony because it's just extortion, be an adult and find a job, you're not owed a lifestyle after divorce. There's no calculation on how much is fair and men become financially unstable.
@@AquarianMan it is. Like I mentioned there’s never a fair calculation nor a fair duration. Men are paying for their whole lives to an adult female. I can understand a few months to get her off her feet but after that the woman should get a job she’s an abled person.
True but only when there is parity between Muslim man and woman in India. Muslim women are in shackles when it comes to education, acquiring a job. They are treated as the man’s “Kheti” meaning farm. For breeding. When anyone is so regressive and bigoted the question doesn’t arise to go out and work. She will get beaten up by her husband, brother, and her father too. It is very different in Hindus and in US. Women are encouraged to education, build career etc.
As our society is largely patriarchal, the women in general put their career in the back burner or take up a lower paying job to take care of the house. It is in lieu of this that I feel it is morally right to pay alimony. 17:00 even husbands have recieved alimony.
@@Whatsinaname423 So the alimony should stop when the woman gets a job, or is re-married (or even live-in), or any situation where she can financially sustain herself?
Reform in Hindu community though lathi is such a bogas analogy. Hindu women in Nepal are more modern than hindu women in India. In Nepal, there was no such reformist law but still hindu women have better life than indian hindu women.
@Hindustan_life I have lived in Nepal as well as in India. And Modern don't mean non religious. Modern in the sense they know their rights and are not intimidated men. While in India majority women don't know their rights and are easy intimidated.
The simple issue is that Religion can't be forced on anyone. Forcing people to follow a particular 'Religious' law would be contrary to Article 25 of the Constitution. The concept that a person's religion is decided by birth is wrong and contrary to Art 25. ONLY laws made by a democratically elected body can be Enforced, Religious practices can ONLY be followed voluntarily, they can't be enforced. Religion is a Right, NOT a Duty. That is why ALL disputes have to be settled under Civil Law and NOT under Religious Law.
nobody forced to be muslim or christian without knowing the rules of them. It's their free expression and if u have problem with that, then don't be muslim or christian. I find the "so-called reforms" abhorrrent and horrible .First u become muslim or christian then cry over to change. Why did u become in the first place?
Bogus argument regarding supremacy of collective right over individual rights in Islam No power can snatch Muslim women right in property/power to remarry after divorce/Power to divorce husband/Widow remarriage/Power to say yes/no to marriage.
49:45 reformation in Hindu community was possible not just by Lathi alone. It was possible because the back then the leaders as well as all celebrities (art and business ) were vocal about it. Tell me which leader and liberals celebrities including all movie personalities and business tycoon even mention this SC ruling - let alone call it historic verdict. Growing up I have seen so many movies calling all wrong things in Hindu community - caste / Dowry killings / female infanticide etc . I have not seen a single movie criticizing teen talaq - except Amitabh and Nargis movie
Hindu women in Nepal are more modern than Hindu women in India. This lathi argument is such a bogas argument. Nepal never had such laws but still they progressed more than Indian women.
Reformation in Islam is not possible, because of apostacy and Blasphemy enshrined in the book itself, and the book itself can NEVER be changed.
@@npatel7775It's the same argument that colonizers used to give to justify colonialism. Yet many countries progressed better than former colonies without being colonized.
I wish this was fully in English so I can send this to some westerners who think Hindus spend their whole lives just oppressing Muslims
There are subtitles in english but they aren't fully correct.
Lots of sympathy for the Muslim women. It is tragic but also it is their own community and elite Muslims who are biggest issues. I’m a Hindu feminist (not a man hater) and I’m just so disgusted by people like rana ayubb. I appreciate arshia ji for showing us the plight of Indian Muslim women
Man you would be amazed at the number of how many Muslim women from middle class and lower middle class backgrounds also supports the views of Rana Ayyub.
This man Nikhil has hijacked the whole convo. Let the woman talk my boy, she has tons of knowledge to share. Keep your legal blah blah short.
It would have been better if Nikhil stopped interrupting her so much that it gets annoying. It is about muslim women, let her complete her train of thought
Let other people speak Nikhil
Its already in constitution
If dowry is wrong so is alimony because it's just extortion, be an adult and find a job, you're not owed a lifestyle after divorce. There's no calculation on how much is fair and men become financially unstable.
This isn't a proper comparison
@@AquarianMan it is. Like I mentioned there’s never a fair calculation nor a fair duration. Men are paying for their whole lives to an adult female. I can understand a few months to get her off her feet but after that the woman should get a job she’s an abled person.
True but only when there is parity between Muslim man and woman in India. Muslim women are in shackles when it comes to education, acquiring a job. They are treated as the man’s “Kheti” meaning farm. For breeding. When anyone is so regressive and bigoted the question doesn’t arise to go out and work. She will get beaten up by her husband, brother, and her father too. It is very different in Hindus and in US. Women are encouraged to education, build career etc.
As our society is largely patriarchal, the women in general put their career in the back burner or take up a lower paying job to take care of the house. It is in lieu of this that I feel it is morally right to pay alimony.
17:00 even husbands have recieved alimony.
@@Whatsinaname423 So the alimony should stop when the woman gets a job, or is re-married (or even live-in), or any situation where she can financially sustain herself?
Reform in Hindu community though lathi is such a bogas analogy. Hindu women in Nepal are more modern than hindu women in India. In Nepal, there was no such reformist law but still hindu women have better life than indian hindu women.
In what way are they modern.plz explain
@Hindustan_life I have lived in Nepal as well as in India. And Modern don't mean non religious. Modern in the sense they know their rights and are not intimidated men. While in India majority women don't know their rights and are easy intimidated.
The simple issue is that Religion can't be forced on anyone.
Forcing people to follow a particular 'Religious' law would be contrary to Article 25 of the Constitution.
The concept that a person's religion is decided by birth is wrong and contrary to Art 25.
ONLY laws made by a democratically elected body can be Enforced,
Religious practices can ONLY be followed voluntarily, they can't be enforced.
Religion is a Right, NOT a Duty.
That is why ALL disputes have to be settled under Civil Law and NOT under Religious Law.
Nakli mehra same time looks like Abhijit but real gora.
Kushal i can#r sharw your podcasts to engliah personw, because of gindi phraswd interpersed.
Nikhil bohot lecture deta hai
I thought after seeing the cover photo that Nikhil Mehra was AIM 😂😂😂
These mediocre idiots giving bad name to Mehra name. 😢
Constitution giveth and constitution taketh it away.
Perhaps you should get an ob-gyn to talk about health issues caused by the costume
nobody forced to be muslim or christian without knowing the rules of them. It's their free expression and if u have problem with that, then don't be muslim or christian. I find the "so-called reforms" abhorrrent and horrible .First u become muslim or christian then cry over to change. Why did u become in the first place?
Bogus argument regarding supremacy of collective right over individual rights in Islam
No power can snatch Muslim women right in property/power to remarry after divorce/Power to divorce husband/Widow remarriage/Power to say yes/no to marriage.
Sure, the stats too say more 5 times more Muslim women divorce their husbands than men doing talaq-e-hasan with their begums. More power to women!
What bogus argument.
Do u know more than a muslim women who suffered herself.Telle why it's bogus
Those that do not think UCC is not acceptable to them and are Muslim, then they have two neighboring nations where they can go.
change the constitution
I have to watch this I don't know how much time to understand it. Too much info in single video
Gharwapasi kyon nahi kar lete bhai?