How should Muslims Respond to Blasphemy? | Dr. Shabir Ally
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
- A couple of weeks ago, a #French teacher showed Charlie Hebdo cartoons mocking the #Prophet #Muhammad to his students as part of a lesson on freedom of expression. A few days later, he was killed. A viewer asked, “Why are Muslims so obsessed with blasphemy of their Prophet to the extreme that they can be instantly radicalized and moved to violence and bloodshed?” Dr. Shabir Ally and Dr. Safiyyah Ally discuss how Western liberal democracies don’t prioritize laws against #blasphemy. Dr. Shabir explains that classical interpretations of Islam make it a crime to criticize religion, but this is contrary to the way blasphemy is treated in the #Quran, where the #blasphemer has the freedom to blaspheme. The Quran doesn’t say that the blasphemer should be penalized in this life. Instead, the Quran repeats the insults and engages with them and correcting them. The violent person, Dr. Shabir explains, misrepresents the Prophet Muhammad and Islam.
#JeSuisCharlie #JeNeSuisPasCharlie
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks...
► SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.co...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Dear viewers, if you appreciate our content, please donate to help us continue our work. Visit www.quranspeaks.com and click donate. Thank you and may God bless you and your loved ones with the very best always!
@The Truth Exactly! Collectively, the Muslims have double standards! I'm a Muslim myself, but I'll admit to this fact. When something bad is done to them, they cry it's oppression, but when they themselves do it to someone else then it's their right! Allah hates the hypocrites!
Islam is a religions of peace, clearly not even Muslims believe that...
InstaBlaster...
This guy is always saying the correct stuff without fabrication, why don't most Muslim follow him. Everyone has freedom to believe or not. It very simple
yeah, if ever a miracle ever make all muslim follow these princoiple, the world would be safer for 5 billions pple on Earth.
The problem is not why Muslim doesn't follow him, why the Mass Media of the west doesn't invite him, relay his message ? Sometime I think that making Muslim angry was the goal by some western elites especially when election. Is near they use islam,Muslim card to attract sympathizer and to secure more votes for their election
I am a Christian and I highly respect you Dr Shabir Ally for your genuine and Honest answer
Dear Brother, I would not say that his answer is honest. But it is persuasive. It is meant for Western Muslims and Christians. Notice that he does not say that these practices need to change in Pakistan, where they occur almost every day.
Those violent follow the Qur'an more strictly (5:33 & 33:57) as well as the required hadiths.
Really, to be a sincere Muslim all branches require that you follow abrogation of the Qur'an and the hadith of their sect.
In contrast, Jesus is the Prince of Peace. To understand why his teachings are different from Islam, or to be able to explain his teachings to Muslims, see our RUclips videos or website: Christian from Muslim.
He says there is s choice, and thet the judgement does not belong to man but to god! People can do as they choose Pakistani Muslims are human like any other person. Some do good some do bad.What faith is any different? I lived with Pakistani Muslims. Because Im white and never told them my religion(Norse Heathen) they assumed Im Christian. They had no problem with this. Growing up here in Ireland,I have seen the worst excesses of christianity!
Finally someone came out to tell the common sense. Hats Off🙏
Nobody is listening
I love his videos. It’s easy just ignore those who commit blasphemy.
Brilliant response from a brilliant man ! He understands the intricate nature of this issue and approaches it in a very rational way. Much respect for this man .
@Muhammad Osama so u say Islam can’t coexist in democracy. So I wonder the Quran also says if you steal hands need to be but if lie tongues should be plugged I wander if it was so we would be looking at a lot of people with outa eyes, tongue, hands and legs. Why don’t you fight for such punishments on your own people. Just because it’s more controversial and debatable to punish your own believers in the prescribed ways then beheading a non believer.
@Muhammad Osama so you claim... Fight those who Fight ISLAM: Quran.
Where did you get that? Could you please quote the surah and verse numbers?
I am guessing something has been lost in translation of whichever surah/verse you are supposed to be quoting from.
why did you say "intricate issue?"
as a general rule something is classified as "an intricate issue" when one tries to appease 2 contradictory sources. however, "an intricate issue" will cease to be "intricate" when one eliminate the false from the truth. after all, a ship cannot have 2 captains nor can a slave have 2 masters.
salam.
@@shukriyusof2104 hi there word police , saving the world one word at a time 🙄
*Thank you Dr. Shabir Ally!* I'm a Christian and I really appreciate your view of the topic. We all have to answer to the great Lord/God/Allah/Creator of the universes one day and I think that until that day we really have to try to live together in the best way on this planet..
youre welcome amigo!
I agree with you we have live together and stop the hating from all sides.
People of all faith need to work together to protect our religous rights. Otherwise there will be laws in the future banning all religion like that movie "The book of Eli" May God protect us
Thank you for your kind words of support!
@Muhammad Osama fight those who fight islam ka mtlb he jb koi talwar ya gun se jang kre to un se jihad kro .
Surah 25 - Verse 63
The ˹true˺ servants of the Most Compassionate are those who walk on the earth humbly, and when the foolish address them ˹improperly˺, they only respond with peace.
Dr. Ali took the issue head-on and presented an introspective answer. Most other commentators spent 99% of their time criticizing the response of Macron. An honest and straight-forward address. This will definitely help the credibility and image of Islam, Dr. Ali and Muslim community.
Completely agree , this is the best response I have come across
Thank you, @Ramesh, for your kind message of support.
Why should one have to help the credibility or image of Islam? Why the need for apologists? No need, your way is yours, my way is mine.
The most reasonable statement of a Muslim I have heard in the last days
Most Muslims I as a Christian talked to about this issue did not understand the important points of it and denounced me as being racist and anti muslim
@Muhammad Osama Abe jaahil jaake Qur’ān padh pehle!
Moral :
1. NO MUSLIM HAS THE RIGHT TO TAKE MATTERS IN HIS OWN HANDS.
2. ALLAH SHALL TAKE CARE OF IT IN THE AFTERLIFE BY HIMSELF AND DOESN'T NEED ANY MUSLIM BELIEVER TO TAKE ACTION AGAINST IT IN THE NAME OF ALLAH OR AS HIS REPRESENTATIVE.
3. TO BELIEVE OR DISBELIEVE IS A CHOICE, NOT PENALIZED. A FREE CHOICE. NOT PUNISHABLE.
4. ISLAM IS PEACE. PEACE COMES WITH TOLERANCE. VIOLENCE IS OPPOSITE OF PEACE. INTOLERANCE IS NOT ACCEPTABLE BY ALLAH, AND MAKES THE PROPHET AND THE TEACHINGS OF ISLAM LOOK BAD.
5. EVERYONE THINKS HIS GOD IS THE REAL GOD AND OBJECTS AND REJECTS THE OTHER GOD, CRITIQUES THE OTHER GOD / RELIGION. THIS IS SAME FOR EVERY RELIGION. SO YOUR BELIEFS CAN BE BLASPHEMY FOR THE OTHER RELIGION AND VICE A VERSA.
6. KILLING ANOTHER MAN IS NEVER ACCEPTABLE. LET THE GOD TAKE CARE OF IT IN THE AFTER LIFE, LET THE MAN LIVE AS AND HOW HE WANTS TO LIVE.
7. IF YOU DON'T LIKE SOMETHING, IGNORE IT.
If there are more muslim scholars like Dr Shabbir Ally, then world would be a better place. Unfortunately majority of the muslims follow Dr. Zakir naik.
What? Dr Naik is ok. They agree about some of the same things.
@@Truth_Seeker1 Dr. Naik is king of presenting fallacies. He smartly twist the question and answer using fallacies. Dr Shabbir Ally is always on point and very logical.
@@nomadickunal9875 No he has different opinion Dr Naik is born in India so already he has different opinions. For example in India they think eating meat of Christian is haram, but Dr ally doesn’t agree.
@@Truth_Seeker1 you should see his video of where a guy asked "what if non muslims country treat muslims the same way Saudi Arabia treats people on giving up Islam"
@@nomadickunal9875 I haven’t heard it send me the link to it.
More people need to see this!
Thank you! Please help us to share it with others :)
@Apeman Commeth Couldn’t have said it any better! Totally agree your point on where we’re put is how we’re influenced as well.
Our prophet advised us, do NOT get angry!
@Muhammad Osama
Murder nahee karogei
U must be a Hindu then ...maybe ram said that about peace n ting
@Muhammad Osama were u named after osama bin laden innit ?
@@MyDavidlynch so anyone who says something you don't like is a hindu?
@Muhammad Osama so very decent of you to quote 2:190... but do you honestly think that "those who wage war against you" is somehow the same as "someone who insult you?"
furthermore, do you understand what is a "transgressor?" or the Arabic الْمُعْتَدِينَ
the root word "Ayn-Dal-Waw" also denotes something that is wickedly, unjustly, spitefully, wrongfully. now, with this in mind, you will be able to understand the meaning of this verse and why :
4:140 He has revealed to you in the Book that when you hear God's revelations being rejected, or ridiculed, do not sit with them until they engage in some other subject. Otherwise, you would be like them. God will gather the hypocrites and the disbelievers, into Hell, altogether.
as a human... the only reason one reacts violently towards an insult is because your ego/pride has been hurt/dented. hence, the tendency to react "wickedly, unjustly, spitefully, wrongfully." and, we all know where all that hatred/aggression/violence stems from, right? the devil will be shouting "victory" all day long when humans follow their "vain desires!"
perhaps, the greatest travesty of all is when one tries to justify protecting his own pride/ego to some "divine order!"
peace.
This group don,t represent majority of Muslim. We as Muslim around the world must and must tell those people who slashed innocent other people are not Islamic way. It is against god and Quran teaching. I as Muslim am very sorry for this barbaric actions. May god protect us and guide us all.
Read Surah 5:33
Thank you so much for your words from me as a Christian
I had a lot of discussions with Muslims in the last days
Alas few shared your thoughts
And did you hear in Europa in Vienna we had another Islamic shooting tonight
@H. I want to have a discussion with you on that. Maybe I'm wrong or you could be wrong. Are you will that we talk about it.
You seem to forget that Islam is not based on the Quran alone.
naya shams @ The cartoon guy insults the Prophet with his drawing so he’s not innocent...and the Muslim guy was impulsive in his defense for the beloved Prophet SAW...
Watched the whole thing and noticed :
1. Zero condemnation for the violence. Only shock.
2. Not saying, we muslims HAVE COME INTO a Christian country. Therefore if a muslim is offended they should go back to their country of origin.
3. Not telling muslims that since it is the muslim who came into a christian country then expect different values to be the order of the day and there is NO COMPULSION to stay in that Christian country
1.France is not a christian country its a secular state.
2. What about the muslims who were brought in frace 100 years ago as slaves they do not know any other country as home other than france.
Which country in Europe is Christian??? The Church is empty.
@@uhuru1713 maybe as such as muslim call their land " muslim land " and doesn t want other faiths there ? It s more Europe as a whole is traditionally/historically Catholic, but in real fact you re right, not such thing in Europe these days.
@@didierleonard9936 I am European...I have no problem living with different Faiths..Races..Cultures..people are people and it's interesting to meet them...I don't agree with the cartoons myself...I found it very petty and spiteful act tbh and also calling France Christian is a idiocy as if they were they would not approve of publishing images that are so insulting to Islam.
@@kankan5927 100 years ago there was no slavery in France
Alhamdllah an honorable teacher in Dr. Ally is able to represent the Muslim ummah in a manner which reflects true Islam and not the horrid tragedy of killing another human being. If the Qur'an states one has the right to believe or disbelieve (Surah Kahf), I don't care what anything else says and if a hadith contradicts the Qur'an. or any ayah of it, the Qur'an takes precedence as it is the word of Allah and the hadith are not all authentic. May Allah guide us all to make just and sound decisions which will lead to prosperous life in this world and a world of Jannah in the akhira.
You cannot blaspheme a false prophet 😂😂😂😂😂
@@goldengateministry9756 check 24:40 in the quran it's says that in the bottom of the ocean there is no light and in surah anbiya verse 31 or 30 it's says about the big bang and how the universe started to be created now please give me a clear answer about how on illiterate man this, who didn't know even know how to read ARABIC know about the state of the bottom of ocean and how did he know about the big bang theori and btw no one knowed those in that time so my logic says it's from god so can you explain To me this
Dear Captain J - have you not heard that 2/3 of the Qur'an, including all of the peaceful verses, have been abrogated? They are replaced by the later more forceful verses. Qur'an 2:106. All the branches of Islam teach this.
Devout Muslims know that verses have been abrogated, and that the hadiths are honored, and so they practice their faith forcefully and violently.
@@christianfrommuslim look i'm not gonna keep talking To you cause i have homework to do but that verse in surah baqara in chapter 2 verse 106 means that if we denie a verse or we delete it we bring a better verse or like it and here god is talking To our prophet peace be upon him ont to us,and you just maked the other things 'including peaceful verses' , and it was before the quran was complete, so from this meaning of this of this verse and from your lie, allah make even better peaceful verses or like them so what is the problem here, and if you think there are a lot of versions of quran tell why in all over the world there is one quran that people keep reciting and if you are truthful show me the other versions and don't tell me warsh or hafs: hafs and warsh have the same meaning just not the same prouncation example:يخدعون in hafs and يخادعون in warsh, go translate it and see if they don't have the same meaning.
@@oumaimaaittalbali5400 I am not the one who abrogates verses. Simply check the list from the sect of Islam that you follow, for example al Azhar's list if you are Sunni.
I guess there are only a handful 'ulama who bravely say this truth and touch this core problem as you do, Dr. Shabbir.. May Allah bless you.. Aameen..
But since the schools of Islam and trusted hadiths are against this interpretation, and the verses that he quotes are abrogated, how can we know if the is speaking his sincere belief, or merely taqeeya to calm the West?
@@christianfrommuslim Imho, any hadith which contradicts Quran should be reviewed, and the concept of abrogation is also problematic in itself. I personally trust the sincerety of Dr. Shabbir. Salam
@@erwinriadi3940 The hadiths have been reviewed. True Muslims must accept the "sahih" collections.
As you say, Peace.
@@christianfrommuslim the rulings of the schools of Islam are nil importance when they don’t correlate with Quran or Hadith. Even Abu Hanifa RA said we shouldn’t follow any of his rulings if they go against Hadith. Genuinely what actual Quran/Hadith are you talking about?
@@christianfrommuslim However I don’t believe these verses are abrogated or that there is even thought to be abrogated by most scholars as there is no contradiction to the idea in Quran or Hadith from all I have seen.
The only Hadith I have seen that may be used to support blasphemy laws 1.doesn’t encourage it only not charging a man for doing so 2.and probably more important has a narrator in the chain of questionable authenticity
I accept Islam as my religion. And alla as my true God..
MashaAllah
REVELATION 20:10
10 And the devil, who deceived them, was thrown into the lake of burning sulfur, where the beast and the false prophet had been thrown. They will be tormented day and night for ever and ever.
IT IS CLEARLY STATED ABOUT FALSE PROPHET AND THE BEAST.. IF U STUDY BIBLE AND THE TEACHINGS OF QURAN U WILL REALIZE THE FALSE PROHET STATED IN THIS BIBLE VERSE IS MUHAMMAD AMD THE BEAST IS ALLAH..
I FEEL SORRY FOR THE MUSLIMS. MUHAMMAD DECIEVED BILLIONS OF MUSLIMS.. AND DO U KNOW? MUHAMMAD COMMIT MURDER RAPED A 6 YEARS OLD AND MARRY HER? HE COMMITTED BEHEADINGS OF THE JEWS AND MANY MORE CRIME!?? AND YOU CALLED HIM PROPHET? THINK AGAIN...
@@mrbesinadventures1909 There is no God but Allah and Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) is his servant and final Messenger....He is the prophet of mercy for the mankind
@Alpha Dog im reading the bible.. and islam is not a religion. it is propehcied about the false prophet and the beast which i believe it is muhammad and allah the deciever
@Alpha Dog so what is your religion?
If you accept the concept of blasphemy being an act that deserves any sort of punishment, you are promoting the form of intolerance and totalitarianism that is theocracy.
Secularism in Sweden (where I live) means that the state does NOT consider any religion, worldview, or ideology holy. As a consequence rediculing or criticizing Islam is no difference than doing it to christianity, atheism, liberalism, or conservatism or indeed any other idea. All are equally open to criticism. Further, in the political discourse, arguments must be secular and/or based on voting meaning you cant use religious texts or religious dogma as an authority for political decisions. Religious people can of course be part of politics, and let their faith decide their political stance, but their arguments must be secular and not religious.
Words never killed anybody, but people do. To be offended is a choice
All due respect Mr ally from me as a Christian!
Alas not many Muslims I talked to are as reasonable as you
Im a muslim. Most of the muslims marry thier distant cousins and do not add any new Dna in thier genome which does not allow them to develop and have low Iq
Dear Jac - that is because they follow the Qur'an more strictly (5:33 & 33:57) as well as the required hadiths.
In contrast, Jesus is the prince of peace. Read his words in the Bible or watch our videos.
@@christianfrommuslim lie as much as you want facts will be facts also christians have killed more than any religion over 178 million people also Jesus said in bible kill those who don't believe in me
Thanks Dr. Shabir for your wise and true commentary.
Not truthful. REM clearly shows he is practising TAQQIYA
@@victormenon1403 there are trolls everywhere and than are KARENS (pardon to people named karen)- u wont understand the concept and that same concept of 5 allowed for them are all taught in first year of philosophy.
Maa sha Allah
Dr shabbir says it beautifully as always
I'm not a fan of shabir, but for this good advice, I salute you,
This episode must be widely circulated in Indian sub continent. Appreciated
Thank you! We would love your help to share it!
Punishment for robbery in the Qur'an is cutting the hands.
Qur'an is from God.
Indeed Allah is ever loving and merciful
They see the intention for stealing n it goes through court.
It sounds harsh but at least ppl don't walk into your house at gunpoint n steal what u worked very hard for
Bc theres a consequence for their action
Read the laws n understand it first
That's why drugs are soo prevelant all over Bc no consequences
But Malaysia law is strict on drugs
I was told plzz if anyone asks you to keep their bag or parcel refuse Bc the law on drugs found in your possession is death penalty
at around the 8min.46sec. mark Dr.Shabir said... "we have to confront that tradition..."
Yes... the time has come for us all to confront that tradition and Let the Quran Speak!
An Islamic government can easily have laws banning the critique. Just like many western countries ban critique of the President or the government or the Jews. Why can't everyone just accept these are all Ibrahimic faiths and shouldn't be mocked. As a matter of fact, no religion should be mocked. Why to incite anger and violence?
It's called freedom of speech, if you want to prove your religion, you don't need to behead people. You don't have to prove anything, God said to leave his creation (humans) to him. So leave everyone alone, God will guide them if He wants.
@@emicemi yes, u don't have to kill
. I agree. But freedom of speech is not in insulting others faith. Thats more like spreading hatred.
Western Countries allow mockery of their presidents and prime ministers it's not illegal or punished at all. It's part of the culture and welcomed in comedy. Look up the British show SPITTING IMAGE and Saturday Night Live in the US making fun of Trump.
@@alexojideagu But you are silent about the jews. Hypocrisy? Honestly, i like to see some holo cost cartoons in the us/uk.
@@cool92guy why does thequran call christians and jews the worst of all creautures? Thats pretty insulting.
Courageous and insightful analysis.
Islamic attack in Vienna today. Multiple sites, coordinated. You can't blame this on a lone wolf.
As the other attacks were proven to have non Muslim motives this will too
Don’t put blame Muslims without proof as the western media is doing
@@waseemzahoor3428 It has been confirmed. They yelled their famous battle cry.
@@waseemzahoor3428 Have you ever asked yourself why so many Muslims believe Islam instructs them to do these actions? The Quran claims to be clear, but many read it and take it as an instruction manual for murder and mayhem. Just what is it they are reading that you are not understanding?
So well explained and great subject as usual! Please speak more about this these subjects!Jazakallhu Khairan!
How should the world respond to Quran 98:6 ? Your book calling everybody who doesn't believe in your religion "worst of all creatures", is quite offensive.
If you read the context bro. It is NOT "for everyone"
I’ve read the tafsirs. The verse is talking about disbelievers from among the people of the scriptures (jews and christians) and idolaters who oppose Allah’s divinely revealed book and the prophets whom he sent i.e. people who thought Muhammad and the Quran were a pile of bs and weren’t having any of it i.e. non-muslims who do not accept Islam. We are lower than dogs. Clear cut and straightforward.
@Alpha Dog Any true believing Christians knows that Muhammed is a false prophet
1st John 4 vs 1-6, 2nd Corinthians 11 vs 11-13, Galatians 1 vs 6-9 . So if a Christian who believe the bible ( fun fact Muhammed also believed in our teachings ) can't accept the teachings of Muhammed, thus comming back to Quran 98:6.
@Alpha Dog I have seen enough for many life times what Islam does to the world. Your tell people that your book teaches peace though in practise it does the opposite. I pray you find Jesus, his teachings and way are worth following.
@@mangaranwow2543 so according to your dictionary AMONG THE PEOPLE OF SCRIPTURE =ALL???
@4:34 - Wrong. Muslims are not "Sensitive" to "criticism of God's Prophets. There are plenty of best-sellers and books written against Prophets. Muslims welcome discourse, discussion, conversation is part of Dawa'h. However, muslims are and will always be sensitive to outright impugning the Prophets or their companions by making caricatures and images...
That still doesn't justify murder or violence. Although I think non Muslims should respect not insulting for the sake of insulting.
I commented that muslims have a right to protest peacefully within limits, but they keep on deleting my comments. Apparently, all they want is muslims to become saints and keep quiet. Good luck with that!! Theoretical people can never understand practical aspects. Meanwhile, I like to see some holo cost cartoons as freedom of speech.
I just guive up on you. Please check the history of muslims of turkey of the 13th to the 16th century. Also please check the still existing tradituon in Iran.
Have we seriously considered that, at its core, Islam is violent, calling for the murder of critics or those who leave Islam for other faiths? The empirical evidence seems to provide proof .
I love you so much Dr. Shabir Ally in the sake of Allah. You are a beautiful light to us in these difficult times. May Allah protect you and give you good health 🌹🌹
Ameen to your wonderful dua. And thank you for your heartfelt support. We will pass on your message to Dr. Shabir!
Times are not difficult. People have become stubborn & out of touch with reality whether it is right-wing or the liberals. Violence is also a class issue... I want to know the economic and social background of the people who did the violence in France.
The growing extremism is both saddening and angering. Criticism of religion is part of da'wah, ridiculing religion is a simple result in different culture. People need to be logical and sensible and use common sense approach rather than the most extreme one.
Prophet allowed challenge and criticism, when allowed to good Muslims to clear misconceptions
God bless Dr. Shabir , we need more like him to teach Muslim youth the right ways
"Watch out for false prophets. They come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves.
Matthew 7:15
Completely agree with Shabir, Islam needs a reform to educate young people about not taking action into their own hands. Blasphemy is OK.
Jazakumullahu khair and may Allah increase you in knowledge
Exactly! The muslim world all condemned this cowardly murder!
Islam has to be reformed for the welfare of humanity
I appreciate this man’s attempts to bring Islam to a more peaceful place. He is walking a very thin and dangerous line, where he could easily be denounced for blasphemy himself and killed if he’s not careful. That said, he cannot be totally honest and still pursue his mission. Eg.the peaceful Koran versus he quoted were all abrogated by later violent verses. And in general hadiths are commanded to be adhere to in the Quran, where it says to honor the teachings of Mohamed and his companions, whose words are recorded where? That’s right, in the hadiths. Even the requirement to pray five times per day comes from the hadiths, so to dismiss them en mas is blasphemy. Unless, of course, he's just practicing takiya...
Bring war is different that someone critiquing it
I am pleased to hear Shabir promote peace and acknowledge that the west is critical of it's own god, jesus etc. For most in the West these criticisms are certainly not singling out Islam.
An incredibly difficult subject, as are all subjects involving a value Judgement by one Human upon another. As a Muslim I have been exposed to terrible slanders to the Prophet (pbuh), insults to the Quran, ridicule of Islam and even challenges to the very existence of God (swt). For myself, I will not add to these travesties by assuming God needs my intervention to set these conditions aright. I have all I can do to avoid my Own sinful behaviors and thoughts. God knows the hearts and motives of all, is able to accomplish all things and is absolutely Just. Compared to this, who am I? Alhamduillah.
A false prophet cannot be blasphemed 😂😂😂😂
@Muhammad Osama Not sure that is an accurate rendering of the Holy Quran. Please tell me what Surah and Ayat that is found in. Help?
@@goldengateministry9756 In my humble belief there is no such thing as a "false prophet". All happens according to the Will of God. Nothing God does can be false as Humans know it. God who is most Merciful and Generous determines how we shall be guided and in what direction we are to develop. Our job is to do our best in aligning ourselves with God's Will. FWIW.
@Muhammad Osama Many thanks. Best Wishes....
@Muhammad Osama You are being more honest than the great leader, Brother Shabir. But as a great leader, he has much scrutiny upon him. He is allowed to twist the facts to make them presentable to Western Muslims, as well as Christians.
I am saddened by all the violence and deception. We all need the Prince of Peace - Jesus Christ - Isa al Mesih, al Akbar!
Brilliant....to spread the message from dr Ally far and wide to save the ummah from more catastrophe for which we r solely responsible
I really enjoyed this discussion. It was enlightening.
Shocking? Unexpected?
How many times has this happened before?
Those are strong words which avoid saying "wrong and evil."
I have great respect for Shabir Ali. However, I don’t think he is being intellectually honest when he says the Quran doesn’t support punishment for blasphemers. Does the Quran say, or does it not say….?
Indeed, those who reject the message after their belief and then increase in disbelief - never will their [claimed] repentance be accepted, and they are the ones astray (Quran, 3:90).
Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment (Quran, 5:33).
O you who have believed, do not take your fathers or your brothers as allies if they have preferred disbelief over belief. And whoever does so among you - then it is those who are the wrongdoers (Quran, 9:23).
Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued (Quran, 9:29).
Make ye no excuses: ye have rejected Faith after ye had accepted it. If We pardon some of you, We will punish others amongst you, for that they are in sin (Quran, 9:66).
He who disbelieves in Allah after his having believed, not he who is compelled while his heart is at rest on account of faith, but he who opens (his) breast to disbelief-- on these is the wrath of Allah, and they shall have a grievous chastisement (Quran, 16:106).
Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah ; and those with him are forceful against the disbelievers, merciful among themselves (Quran, 48:29).
My observation is this. Where Muslims are in the minority i.e. in a western or non Muslim country they speak the way these two have spoken and teach a more peaceful Islam. (I’m guessing they live in the US).
But try teaching that interpretation in a Muslim country .... It would be a very different story then. There is no “let those who believe do so and those who do not have the freedom not to”. No - if you leave Islam in those countries there is a strong chance your head will leave your body.
Taqiyyah??? Hmmmmm
@@CherylTamer-gb1gk
I think you are confusing Islam to Christianity. Read history books. There are more churches in Turkey than Mosques in any Western countries.
@@CherylTamer-gb1gk You are correct.
You are correct. Plus - the peaceful verses have been abrogated, and the hadiths of each sect MUST be followed to be considered a Muslim by that sect.
Christian from Muslim oh? Now THAT is very interesting
Dr Shabir thank you for your stance and for pointing out the Quran allows criticism and blasphemy without physical retributions. What concerns me is that the Quran has severe directions for punishments in regards to adultery and stealing. Do you think we should deal with these transgressions in the manner the Quran espouses?
It’s about historical context
Thanks Allaha, still few muslim having common seance. Love your jugement.
Mashallah Dr. Shabir May ALLAH GIVE YOU THE HIGHEST RANK IN JANNAH❤
Wow i was searching for this video since the France president has been doing blasphemy against Holy prophet Muhammad (PUBH) you cleared the concept. And we leave it on the day of judgement Allah will surely determine and will punish them accordingly.!!
"Shocking and Unexpected" are the words repeated in this commentary for violence against blasphemers in Europe; not "wrong " or "evil."
I like that Dr. Shabir's interpretation states violence misrepresents Islam. He seems to be following the Qur'an only trend often presented to unbelievers in the West. But how can he say this in the light of the sahih hadith being required for being Sunni or Shiite? Or an interpretation of "Surely those who offend Allah and His Messenger are condemned by Allah in this world and the Hereafter. And He has prepared for them a humiliating punishment." Quran 33:57
Devout students of Islam know that the tolerant verses in the Qur'an have all been abrogated by trusted scholars of all branches of Islam (Qur'an, al Baqarah 2:106).
Dear Brother Shabir, please convince the Muslim authorities, like al Azhar, and the powers of Pakistan and other Muslim nations that they should stop killing people for blasphemy.
Dear Muslims, please see the truth - that Islam is not a religion of peace. Follow the Prince of Peace, Isa al Mesih - Jesus Christ. Read his words in the Injeel. He will bring you peace with ALLAH peace in your HEART and peace with OTHERS.
For more information on Jesus and his peace, watch the videos on our RUclips channel or website - "Christian from Muslim."
Im an ex Muslim,, Muhammad says, you should correct them by words or you correct them in your heart,, or you ignore them,,you shouldn't punish someone for insulting muhammad,,, people always insult Almighty God but Muslims never protest,,why protest when someone insult muah med,,I was a Muslim scholar and I understand everything this doctor said here,,you should change your mindset,,, you are the sinner here because you go against muhammad command
There is criticism and there is flagrant mocking. It's possible to criticize someone without mocking them. Same approach should be taken about serious topics and religion is VERY serious to alot of people even if there are others who think religion is made up and silly. I can think someone else believes something silly and still not mock them.
Its bad I agree but those who mock u don’t kill them rather educate them
This guy is best spokesperson, I follow dr zakir, I have leaned towards this guy, he doesn’t blindly believe the Hadith and takes his approach from Quran.
Dr Shabir Ally takes the bull by the horns and speaks to the heart of the matter. This is leadership!
There needs to be a review of how one teaches loving the Prophet and speaking about "his honor" and things of this nature. It is potentially booby trapping youngsters that can then be misused by others.
He is saying what we want to hear. The violence is done because they follow the Qur'an more strictly (5:33 & 33:57) as well as the required hadiths.
In contrast, Jesus is the prince of peace. Read his words in the Bible or watch our videos.
Who here puts mohammad before allah? Commits blasphemy?
You are shocked by the beheading of a teacher who defamed the Holiest of all the Prophets but you do not feel SHOCKED on the actual defamation caused to the Holy Prophet of Islam Peace be upon HIM. I am shocked.
Well said. Very Very saddening. That's what happens when pleasing people becomes your priority
By reading the comments-which are as worthy as Shabir's explanation of his topic-one realises how much more valuable he is to Islam; than, say, Muhammad Ali ever was.
However Pakistani Bangladeshi Iranian clerics etc will strongly disagree with this. This means we have two opinions, one is the opinion coming from those living in the West where Western laws exist and where they are in a minority and a different opinion coming from those living in countries where they are in a majority.
He beheaded the schoolteacher a60yrs women beheaded in church
By being violent in this matter a person is doing the Devil's work. Muslims responsibility is to convey the message not send people to Hell. That is what the devil wants more people in hell.
If Tommy Robbinson spoke to Shabir Ally I'm confident he'd either convert or cure him of his hatred
Totally unexpected? Are you joking? Everybody was expecting it!!! We’ve seen it so many times!
What is the reference to the verse in Quran where the blasphemer was allowed to blaspheme?
Manoj. there is no such text so you will not be getting any direct references nor an answer.
25:63
4:140
28:54-55
7:199
73:10-12
9:74
50:45
@@gjwagner1856.
There are verses of the Quran does say there is no blasphemy
Takbeer!!
How should a Christian respond, when a racist Islamist simply come and say Bible is wrong to a Christian , because of this day by day problem are increasing.
Debate is ok but mocking is bad, dialogue and presenting your religion is different
He did not say the word “unacceptable “.
Several time he said unexpected but not acceptable. What a shame
Qur'an says not to talk to Prophet in a loud voice,how can it allow blasphemy of the Prophet.
Allah knows best.. Allah is there to punish..to allow..to not allow..
Not you and I
We are ordered to take care of our own sins first
@@ayushi9662 Do you actually know what happened during Prophet صلله عليه وسلم time to those who blasphemed him. if you don't, I don't think you are in position to comment on such issue with all due respect
Quran said to the Sahabas of Muhammad S.A.W.W. Please for Allah's sake dont misinterpret Quran Verses for your own sake. PLEASE.
My understanding is that on that day Allah will show us where we differed, I am sure glad that is Allahs job and not mine.
I am a christian but Dr. Ally is a good muslim man. if all muslims would be like him the world will be peaceful place.
And what about your Christian imperial and capitalist powers America,France and UK etc who areon daily killing innocent people in ways,how can we stop them too?
Thank you for reaching out, Joe! We appreciate your support. Let's all work towards making the world a more peaceful place.
Allah will deal with it inshallah he knows the evil
Blasphemy is a victimless crime.
Wah such noble words Indeed if Muslim beleive in Allah they should wait and rely on Allah judgement and not become themselves judge and give punishment. but it seems Muslim are not following their own Quran
there is difference between criticizing and mocking and insults and drawing disgusting cartoon about the most loved person on earth......
we can criticize someone with out insulting him or mocking why cant you get that.....
Wait?. "Person"
So it’s ok to criticise Mohammed?
To kill someone, to take another life, is worse than someone mocking or making fun of your Allah.
Most loved by whom exactly?
I guess Jesus is most loved, as both Muslims and Christians, and some others too love him.
intorlerace. And lack of LOVE for humanity causes some psychopaths to kill somebody for God. If you LOVE you don't kill....
Knowledge is power. God bless you, Dr
You can only respond to blasphemy in an islamic way! Any response outside the parameters set by Islamic framework of Qur'an and/or Sunnah in this regard will count as a sin!
Burden for Humanity......
Plz get lost from this world & let everyone else live peacefully....
You should never judge whether a certain people practise their religion the way Muslims do. I say this because only God knows the heart of each soul. The most faithful will be known when your faith is tested.
He got me when he said "totally unexpected"
I mean , really!!!!!!
You are that naive to not expect this from muslims.
Great comment.
Very educational
Thanks for thoroughly exposing Islam.
Could someone explain why every time prophet’s name is mentioned the Muslims say “please be upon him?”
How is this going to benefit or be of “respect” by saying PBUH 1,400 years after he passed away?
In Christianity Jesus said give honor unto honor is due. That means we should not blasphemy anything of God, yet we should realize that when a Muslim speaks of Mohammad (PBUH) they may blasphemy Jesus in the manner in which they speak or write. Therefor such a statement should ne overlooked, just as when a Christian speaks or writes of Jesus it may do likewise to Islam and they should do the same. It is one thing for one religion to contradict another but something totally different to speak in a manner which belittles or mocks another religion. I enjoy your manner of speaking even though some things do blasphemy Christianity but I overlook that because of the sincerity of your teaching. That sincerity shows no aggravated desire to blasphemy but to teach your faith in a sincere manner. May God bless.
We should teach what we believe in a humble manner with no contempt to another religion, and if such causes an unintended blasphemy it should be overlooked. But blasphemy done maliciously is another story. In Christianity we forgive both but I personally can understand a sincerity for God that would anger a Muslim to act. I enjoy your videos. May God bless.
Thanks Dr shabir 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Thanks a lot for your explanation 🍁🙌
Wow. So much love and respect given to scriptures and dead people, than any concern or damn given about living human beings who have their lives in danger, including the Samuel Patys of the world and their families shame shame sham on humanity. Disgraceful
“Whoever wants, let them believe. Whoever wants, let them disbelieve.” (Quran 18:29).
“There’s no coercion in religion.” (Quran 2:256). “Do not insult those (gods) they invoke other than Allah; lest they insult Allah in enmity without knowledge.” (Quran 6:108)
The Quran gives a non-Muslim person freedom to choose Islam or stay on their religion. No one can be forced to convert to Islam. They will be responsible in front of God on the Day of Judgment for not choosing Islam, the religion of truth.
HOWEVER, this freedom to choose Islam was never understood to mean that a person is free to commit treason, sedition, hate speech (blasphemy), or desecrate or insult the sacred. No one has the right to insult any religion and gods.
What one does inside their homes is their own business. It may or may not negatively impact public health and safety, but, in general, it is between them and God. Publicly, however, no religion, god, prophet, or anything sacred should ever be publicly insulted, derided, or mocked. Any morally upright human being would avoid such behavior.
The Quran forbids Muslims from insulting other people’s false gods (Quran 6:108).
This does not mean we’re not allowed to disagree or express opinions based on logic and facts. This does not mean we Muslims are not open to academic challenges. Respectful disagreements are always welcomed in Islam. In fact, the books of theology and law are full of academic debates where the scholars disagree with each other on details. The more knowledgeable I became as I studied classical theology and Islamic legal theory, the more tolerant I became of other scholars’ principled opinions.
Historically, apostacy meant treason. And treason meant apostacy. Committing apostacy meant committing treason. Committing treason meant committing apostacy. As such, both were punishable by death. When a person left Islam historically, they almost always joined the enemy. Hence, the treason that results in death penalty.
Muslims being the follower of Prophet Muhammad need to behave the way the beloved Prophet would have done. He forgave his critics at large and went to war when it was necessary. All great did the same. Rama and Krishna who happen to be holiest figures in Hinduism did the same. On the other hand we all should respect the Prophet for his stature and wisdom. And derogatory cartoons of the Prophet or any great men is by and large wrong. May sense and peace prevail....Ameen...😊
Kudos. Surprising and refreshing honesty in this video. The biggest challenge is the Sunnah, especially sahih hadiths like the following:
Sahih Bukhari (59:369) - This recounts the murder of Ka'b bin al-Ashraf, a Jewish poet who wrote verses about Muslims that Muhammad found insulting. He asked his followers, 'Who will rid me of this man?' and several volunteered. al-Ashraf was stabbed to death while fighting for his life.
Sahih Muslim (1801) - "The Messenger of Allah said: Who will kill Ka'b b. Ashraf? He has maligned Allah, the Exalted, and His Messenger"
It's time for muslims to accept that Hadiths are the work of Sheitan
@Fuzail Ahmed There are alot of even worse Hadiths that tend to "describe" the doings of our beloving prophet Muhammad. We were given an example of Jesus and how people made from him his own religion and own history. Now Muslims are doing the same by following hadith and not what God has send down to us.
@@emicemi The Sunnah has been practiced for 1400 years. To abandon it would be to completely transform Islam. lol
@@Sonicboom238 I think it's time.
All branches of Islam require that you must accept their authentic hadiths in order to be Muslim. Qur'an only is not a valid option. Besides, the branches of Islam have abrogated up to 2/3 of the Qur'an - everything peaceful. Strict Muslims know all of this.
A very good response thanks, Jazakalahu Khayr
Cause we think it’s ok to make fun of our sacred figures. Idk I like my Muslim friends just don’t like the superstition or idea that anything Is protected from criticism.
As an ex-muslim i respect shabyr for his honesty here. Respect👏👏
Killing one person is like killing the entire creation
This verse doesn't apply to unbelievers
@@alexiboat2009 it does it applies even including non believers
Thanks a more peaceful and liberal Muslim. That still hold to some conservative Muslim values.
Blasphemy laws need to be scraped in all countries. All people should be free to citicise religion in every nation. While I don't agree with insults, people should be free to logically criticise God, Mohammad or the companions freely without threats of violence.
Most of you guys jump to killing the blasphemer, which in a way shows how weak your faith and belief is. If you truly felt Allah you wouldn’t need to silence the blasphemer.
Ideas were meant to be criticized.
I think Muslims should respond to blasphemy and criticism in the same way Muhammad responded. The question is, how did Muhammad respond to blasphemy and criticism?