The story of Heather Mason will have less impact without telling the story of Alessa Gillespie first. Silent Hill 1 Remake would be the right choice for the next remake to take on board the new fans about the mysterious powers of the town and its cult following. Further, Harry Mason death will take no emotional toll on the players if they are not aware of his role in SH 1.
I agree but I do kinda still hope they do three though next the amusement park and mall in unreal five oooo I'd rather four than any of them but three would be my next Choice
@@akaunderdog4223 Capcom Released 2009 a Remaster of the Remake for Steam, Playstation3/4, Xbox and later for the Nintendo Switch. You can play the Game on Modern Platforms
Yeah, both 2 and Downpour branched off from the main storyline of the history and overall impact that the series gave and gave us the stories of two people who helped shape the game to see its true terror in the situation. It would feel less story-driven if they just released 2 without one because new players wouldn't know the whole story of why the second happened the way that it did. They could redo it to where we play the mom in the movie adoption if necessary or polish and design the older models into even scarier monstrosities while adding more to the lore and scare factor within the game exploration without breaking the serenity of it.
You seem to be lacking on your information. Resident evil 1 was already remade so don’t know where you got the idea that they started with 2, the 1st remake is what even popularized remakes. And Konami started with silent hill 2 because it was a solo game that didn’t rely on another and bloober team were better at making psychological horror, 2 was their better game for their style. Most likely they’ll remake 1 and then 3 after to keep it connected
Honestly Silent Hill 4 would make a lot of sense, it's a stand alone game that has a lot of nods to Silent Hill 2, plus it could use it, the story is amazing and could benefit from tweaking the escort mission style into an amazing game, which it already is but a remake of 4 would be great
The younger generation definitely talk about The Room more than any other title - save PT. It has the most intriguing premise and is social media essay friendly.
They’ll most likely do born from a wish dlc, then depending on if sales are good enough they’ll move forward with 1 and 3. I think 1 would come first but they’ll probably do some pre-production and map out both games.
I was hoping for OG Silent Hill being next on the remake list and given the same treatment as Silent Hill 2 Remake. It has been stuck in the PS1 era for so long and never got an upgrade (Shattered Memories doesn't count since it deviated from the OG story and its more of an alternate sequel). Though if they do remake Silent Hill 3, unlocking Princess Heart.
Born from a wish will be a tough challenge for bloober team, prob they will re-imagining the story fit into remake version. Just hope it will be a good dlc
Totally agreed. They will surely make Born from a Wish a DLC first and Konami will see how the remakes sales goes and decide whether to go forth for the next remake of SH3
chya GL wif tat shit....irdk ytf chu all keep tinking on such good thoughts and ideas wen altho ik were as gammers are in the right by all means...but chu all seem tu fail tu relize tat corpal greed in these DEVs eyes ish WTF comes 1st tuu tem...and mostwy all tey do ish relese shithole half baked garbage tat ruines w.e game its for and tey sell tat as DLC...suu wif tat being said wth makes chu tink tis will be any diff? 😔
Sorry but you’d be crazy to think they’d do 3 before 1, they’re a collective story. I’d like a remake of 4 as it would be peak horror, but I acknowledge they should do 1 then 3, finally 4. Not to discredit your opinion of course, but by this logic they could do 4 next because they’re connected just as easily. I think we should just sit back and wait it out knowing they’ll do great regardless of the next title.
I do think SH3 will be remade but I’m hoping SH1 will be next, honestly I think they remade SH2 first because it’s the most standalone of the Team Silent created games (it’s also arguably the most popular) So I really think they were going for farthest reach in the fandom and it’s the easiest to jump into (storywise) for new players who want the experience of Silent Hill without the lore dump of 1,3, or even 4. I think Bloober Team also knew if they nailed Silent Hill 2 they could have the best chance of doing the rest. I do think Silent Hill 1 is next (I wouldn’t base it off Resident Evil due to the fact that RE1 had been remade already, however that’s now considered old but had a remake already nonetheless)
I agree with most of what you just said, except for the part "The makers of resident evil ALSO skipped the first game." No, they didn't. The resident evil 1 remake has been out for a while now. I think it originally came out for the gamecube if I'm not mistaken. Other than that, great content! Looking forward to trying to get all of the Silent 2 remake endings.
The mentioning of Walter Sullivan in the remake is no hint to the 4th game bc you can find the same newspaper article in the og,too - it's where you find the coin in the trash in Woodside Apartments. And if I remember correctly,the gravestone of W.S. is also in the og,but I'm not sure...
I think they need to remake the first one first and then do the third since it's a 2 part story, whereas the rest of the games are mostly stand alone stories with minor bits that connect them all to the same world. and I think that's why they remade SH2 first, outside of it being the favorite of most series fans, it's stand alone story allowed them to test the waters of remakes without having to fully commit to multiple games, and since it's a massive hit, now they know people like what they're doing and they can proceed with more remakes.
It'd make sense to make sh2 first instead of sh1, as chronologically of the four main games, the main events of sh2 take place first. Chronologically, its James, Henry, Harry, Heather. Overall, its the kids in the arcade, SH Forte's majn, James, Travis, Henry, Harry, Heather, Murphy, Anita,
It has to be the 1 one to get to 3. Born from a wish most likely will come, but i hope they don't try to cashgab that! Would be perfect for a free gift to keep people happy. Because it's not much content but interesting.
thay say that capcom didn't do re1 remake only because it's already remade twenty years ago, and that konami chose to remake sh2 to avoid repetition with the movie series. sh2 has the most independent story by comparison.
Born From A Wish DLC is huge possibility based on Maria's dialogue and objects in front of it. I want to see Baldwin Mansion inside and hoping to hear a bit of expanded story of Ernest and Amy. If we get to see remakes of other Silent Hill games I so want to see Midwich Elementary School to have some elements from the film, like the general feeling of abandonment, damaged interiors, and it's Otherworld version. Other places I would love to see are Alchemilla Hospital, Lakeside Amusement Park (since the billboard can be seen in West South Vale like Lakeview Hotel one), Central Square Shopping Center, Hilltop Center, Apartment World and if Origins gets remake then Cedar Grove Sanitarium, Artaud Theater and Riverside Motel
Imo silent hill origins is forgotten about way too much. It’d be one of the best options for a remake especially since content can be added ( it was originally a psp game so only so much memory was available at the time)
Another nod to 3 is after the hospital when you are going towards the historical society there are areas with the the grating on the floor and you see the enemies (closer) from 3 underneath
@@kellysixsmith4273 I don’t remember them…I guess SH3 is more fresh on my mind maybe, but I see the difference between the two and I didn’t remember them in hotel but there were also a different enemy in original correct?
@ericwerdann2269 The Mandarin's appear in the grating after the hospital, the labyrinth and the hotel. They do look very similar to the Closer's from SH3 though. Mandarin's have mouths on their arms.
How is Silent Hill 1's story telling outdated, compared to the rest of them? The plot is crazy sure but no more than the others. I like SH1's more abundant use of occult symbols/imagery, it's a lot grittier. Anyway, as long as they remake 1,3 and 4 then I'll be over the moon
Problem is silent hill origins, silent hill 1, and silent hill 3 are kinda like a trilogy with ongoing story. SIlent hll 2, and silent hill 4 are like self contained side stories.
Hopefully they don't do this Silent Hill 3 was the beginning of the end for the franchise. The game sales were not good. Its very niche and honestly doesn't need a remake. The game that is in badly need to a remake is silent hill 1 plus is the scariest in the franchise.
It would make zero sense to remake SH3 before SH1, first of all for story reasons and second of all because the first game (which IMO is still the best horror game made to this day) is from an older generation and it needs a remake much more than any other game in the series. I can understand they went for SH2 first because it is the most popular among fans but to do SH3 next would be a huge disappointment and very weird since there is a particular event in the game that won't have the same impact without playing SH1 first.
If sh2 gets any dlc. It should be the PT demo. Not everyone has got a pc, or got the chance to experience the PT demo before it was removed from the store.
@@mrplayfulshadebecause a lot of people never experienced it. Because it's still talked about and referred to. Because to play it now on a ps, you need to spend hundreds of pounds purchasing the media device it's stored on, or a pc. That's why
Remaking a prequel game in sh3 before the main game in sh1 is not wise and it will make sh1 remake pointless after playing sh3, remake so make sh1 remake FIRST!
5:53 old & outdated? How about just kinda burnt out from Ubisoft and plus remedy’s Alan wake 2. Props to silent hill for being the original OG cult horror game. But I see what they didn’t start from 1. And I kinda appreciate it.
The story of Heather Mason will have less impact without telling the story of Alessa Gillespie first. Silent Hill 1 Remake would be the right choice for the next remake to take on board the new fans about the mysterious powers of the town and its cult following. Further, Harry Mason death will take no emotional toll on the players if they are not aware of his role in SH 1.
Exactly, it makes no sense to remake 3 before 1
SH1 is in DIRE need of a remake and a further detailed more telling story of Alessa, the order, etc.
@@restlessfae2407it's about licensing issues for 1
I hear everything you’re saying. But I still want 3 next. Workarounds would be to either release an official master collection or somehow combine 1&3.
I agree but I do kinda still hope they do three though next the amusement park and mall in unreal five oooo I'd rather four than any of them but three would be my next Choice
Capcom didn't skip Resident Evil 1 Remake. A Remake already exists of the first Resident Evil Game.
On GameCube. Visually was impressive for 2002. Haven't played it tho
@@akaunderdog4223 Capcom Released 2009 a Remaster of the Remake for Steam, Playstation3/4, Xbox and later for the Nintendo Switch. You can play the Game on Modern Platforms
Remaster. Not a complete remake but yeah they did do re1. Wish they'd give it another remake
@@bradleylogue9207 No. The Gamecube version is a Remake done in 2002. Then, we have a remaster version of that for PC/PS/Xbox.
tbh i would love that sh 1 & 3 have a remake because they are all important to the series & i believe have the best & solid stories😊
Yeah, both 2 and Downpour branched off from the main storyline of the history and overall impact that the series gave and gave us the stories of two people who helped shape the game to see its true terror in the situation. It would feel less story-driven if they just released 2 without one because new players wouldn't know the whole story of why the second happened the way that it did.
They could redo it to where we play the mom in the movie adoption if necessary or polish and design the older models into even scarier monstrosities while adding more to the lore and scare factor within the game exploration without breaking the serenity of it.
Resident evil didn’t skip remaking the first resident evil as it already had a remake in 2002.
I hope it won't take them too long to remake SH1...I'll be in the Otherworld by then....🙃
You seem to be lacking on your information. Resident evil 1 was already remade so don’t know where you got the idea that they started with 2, the 1st remake is what even popularized remakes. And Konami started with silent hill 2 because it was a solo game that didn’t rely on another and bloober team were better at making psychological horror, 2 was their better game for their style. Most likely they’ll remake 1 and then 3 after to keep it connected
Honestly Silent Hill 4 would make a lot of sense, it's a stand alone game that has a lot of nods to Silent Hill 2, plus it could use it, the story is amazing and could benefit from tweaking the escort mission style into an amazing game, which it already is but a remake of 4 would be great
I agree!!!
The younger generation definitely talk about The Room more than any other title - save PT. It has the most intriguing premise and is social media essay friendly.
@@fisherj5087 I'm not the younger generation and 4 was my favorite
Totally agree it's so creepy too I feel like there going to do three though which would still be pretty sweet
They’ll most likely do born from a wish dlc, then depending on if sales are good enough they’ll move forward with 1 and 3. I think 1 would come first but they’ll probably do some pre-production and map out both games.
Remaking the third game instead of the first would be complete bullshit, the first one begins the story that continues in the third.
I’d love to see Bloober maybe expand on eddy or Angela’s story. I think there is some room for expansion there.
Sometimes less is more. Fleshing them out further would only cheapen their characters imo
I was hoping for OG Silent Hill being next on the remake list and given the same treatment as Silent Hill 2 Remake. It has been stuck in the PS1 era for so long and never got an upgrade (Shattered Memories doesn't count since it deviated from the OG story and its more of an alternate sequel). Though if they do remake Silent Hill 3, unlocking Princess Heart.
Born from a wish will be a tough challenge for bloober team, prob they will re-imagining the story fit into remake version. Just hope it will be a good dlc
I wouldn’t be surprised if they’ve already made it and will release it in a few months time.
👉👈 I hope it has classic outfit as an unlockable.
Totally agreed. They will surely make Born from a Wish a DLC first and Konami will see how the remakes sales goes and decide whether to go forth for the next remake of SH3
Yeah, most likely :) especially after this success
chya GL wif tat shit....irdk ytf chu all keep tinking on such good thoughts and ideas wen altho ik were as gammers are in the right by all means...but chu all seem tu fail tu relize tat corpal greed in these DEVs eyes ish WTF comes 1st tuu tem...and mostwy all tey do ish relese shithole half baked garbage tat ruines w.e game its for and tey sell tat as DLC...suu wif tat being said wth makes chu tink tis will be any diff? 😔
@@shadowdragonx07it took me at least 6 minutes to try to decipher your monstrosity of a comment
@@icewallowcome8086 1 more insulting comment wike tat again and chull lose chur acct...arogent dumbass -.-
Plz take your medicine @@shadowdragonx07
Sorry but you’d be crazy to think they’d do 3 before 1, they’re a collective story. I’d like a remake of 4 as it would be peak horror, but I acknowledge they should do 1 then 3, finally 4.
Not to discredit your opinion of course, but by this logic they could do 4 next because they’re connected just as easily.
I think we should just sit back and wait it out knowing they’ll do great regardless of the next title.
I do think SH3 will be remade but I’m hoping SH1 will be next, honestly I think they remade SH2 first because it’s the most standalone of the Team Silent created games (it’s also arguably the most popular) So I really think they were going for farthest reach in the fandom and it’s the easiest to jump into (storywise) for new players who want the experience of Silent Hill without the lore dump of 1,3, or even 4. I think Bloober Team also knew if they nailed Silent Hill 2 they could have the best chance of doing the rest. I do think Silent Hill 1 is next (I wouldn’t base it off Resident Evil due to the fact that RE1 had been remade already, however that’s now considered old but had a remake already nonetheless)
I agree with most of what you just said, except for the part "The makers of resident evil ALSO skipped the first game." No, they didn't. The resident evil 1 remake has been out for a while now. I think it originally came out for the gamecube if I'm not mistaken. Other than that, great content! Looking forward to trying to get all of the Silent 2 remake endings.
If they do 3, they have to do 1 first…and you are forgetting that they already remade RE 1 before they did 2
...the challenge is on how they will adapt SH1 story and gameplay to the modern era without drastically "re-imagining" it....
Yeah isn't the whole Indian burial ground trope looked down on nowadays?
It wasn't built on an indian burial ground@@PretzelSage
The mentioning of Walter Sullivan in the remake is no hint to the 4th game bc you can find the same newspaper article in the og,too - it's where you find the coin in the trash in Woodside Apartments. And if I remember correctly,the gravestone of W.S. is also in the og,but I'm not sure...
Yes it is in the og
At the moment sh remake is selling phenomenal! All over the world! I'm quite sure sh3 remake is doable!!!!!!
its realy good remake .
5:04 is that arthurs hat on that chair?
dude it actually kinda looks like it 😮
maybe a silent hill 3 reference either or its dope
I think they need to remake the first one first and then do the third since it's a 2 part story, whereas the rest of the games are mostly stand alone stories with minor bits that connect them all to the same world. and I think that's why they remade SH2 first, outside of it being the favorite of most series fans, it's stand alone story allowed them to test the waters of remakes without having to fully commit to multiple games, and since it's a massive hit, now they know people like what they're doing and they can proceed with more remakes.
What do you think guys?
It'd make sense to make sh2 first instead of sh1, as chronologically of the four main games, the main events of sh2 take place first. Chronologically, its James, Henry, Harry, Heather.
Overall, its the kids in the arcade, SH Forte's majn, James, Travis, Henry, Harry, Heather, Murphy, Anita,
It has to be the 1 one to get to 3. Born from a wish most likely will come, but i hope they don't try to cashgab that! Would be perfect for a free gift to keep people happy. Because it's not much content but interesting.
thay say that capcom didn't do re1 remake only because it's already remade twenty years ago, and that konami chose to remake sh2 to avoid repetition with the movie series. sh2 has the most independent story by comparison.
Born From A Wish DLC is huge possibility based on Maria's dialogue and objects in front of it. I want to see Baldwin Mansion inside and hoping to hear a bit of expanded story of Ernest and Amy. If we get to see remakes of other Silent Hill games I so want to see Midwich Elementary School to have some elements from the film, like the general feeling of abandonment, damaged interiors, and it's Otherworld version. Other places I would love to see are Alchemilla Hospital, Lakeside Amusement Park (since the billboard can be seen in West South Vale like Lakeview Hotel one), Central Square Shopping Center, Hilltop Center, Apartment World and if Origins gets remake then Cedar Grove Sanitarium, Artaud Theater and Riverside Motel
Imo silent hill origins is forgotten about way too much. It’d be one of the best options for a remake especially since content can be added ( it was originally a psp game so only so much memory was available at the time)
I would love a SH3 remake
🙌
Another nod to 3 is after the hospital when you are going towards the historical society there are areas with the the grating on the floor and you see the enemies (closer) from 3 underneath
Aren't those just Mandarin's?
@@kellysixsmith4273 I don’t remember them…I guess SH3 is more fresh on my mind maybe, but I see the difference between the two and I didn’t remember them in hotel but there were also a different enemy in original correct?
@ericwerdann2269 The Mandarin's appear in the grating after the hospital, the labyrinth and the hotel. They do look very similar to the Closer's from SH3 though. Mandarin's have mouths on their arms.
@@kellysixsmith4273 thank you I gotta replay the original it’s been years!
Lowkey care more about the room being remade than the first 3
Same )
agreed
I did not hit her it's bullshit I did not hit her I DID NAWWWT. Oh hi Mark!
Last three minutes of this video are totally unnecessary!
I think the next thing they do is Born from a Wish Dlc for SH2 .If they also strech playtime by making it bigger i will buy that 100%
I'm hoping there'll be dlc outfits, like james and maria in their og outfit. Or harry mason's outfit
Absolutely not. They have to do silent Hill 1 first before 3 makes any sense.
*Plot twist*. Bloober team will make their own game first then they will make SH 1 Remake with SH 3 as dlc because SH 3 is short :)
They need to do The Room first
1 and 3 have to come in order
agree with you full heartedly beside I'm a huge sh4 fan
Considering Born From a Wish ws a thing from the original then yeah there will probably be a Maria DLC...
Ideally this remake would sell well enough to just allow bloober to just remake 1 and 3 and 4 and maybe even less popular stuff like origins.
How is Silent Hill 1's story telling outdated, compared to the rest of them? The plot is crazy sure but no more than the others. I like SH1's more abundant use of occult symbols/imagery, it's a lot grittier. Anyway, as long as they remake 1,3 and 4 then I'll be over the moon
Problem is silent hill origins, silent hill 1, and silent hill 3 are kinda like a trilogy with ongoing story.
SIlent hll 2, and silent hill 4 are like self contained side stories.
1>3 makes more sense
They gotta remake the 1st. Set up the order leading into Wacky Sullivan lol
Taylor Hawkins in the thumbnail
Maybe the first game is already developed by a different studio. There whre rumors about a intern konami studio amking remakes and new titles
uhhh. i got a feeling it won't because they don't want a woman weilding a gun
In my opinion they should remake sh1 first because this game has graphics that are very outdated.
Resident evil 1 remake exist. IT Is just older then the other remakes.
Wait… isn’t SH: Shattered Memories already the remake of SH1?
Most likely it will be the first game because doing three first makes no sense they did two first because it's the most popular
Hopefully they don't do this Silent Hill 3 was the beginning of the end for the franchise. The game sales were not good. Its very niche and honestly doesn't need a remake. The game that is in badly need to a remake is silent hill 1 plus is the scariest in the franchise.
It would make zero sense to remake SH3 before SH1, first of all for story reasons and second of all because the first game (which IMO is still the best horror game made to this day) is from an older generation and it needs a remake much more than any other game in the series. I can understand they went for SH2 first because it is the most popular among fans but to do SH3 next would be a huge disappointment and very weird since there is a particular event in the game that won't have the same impact without playing SH1 first.
Finalizei 4 sh 1 digo sh 1 e digno de remake ele top
I found the liquid idk what to do with it😢
first let them put sh 2 together then let them do other games 😅
Tanto pra fazer remake depois ate tem o SH origins
If sh2 gets any dlc. It should be the PT demo. Not everyone has got a pc, or got the chance to experience the PT demo before it was removed from the store.
Lmao why tf would that be a DLC for SH2
@@mrplayfulshadebecause a lot of people never experienced it. Because it's still talked about and referred to. Because to play it now on a ps, you need to spend hundreds of pounds purchasing the media device it's stored on, or a pc. That's why
@@ptaylor81it has NOTHING to do with part 2. Stop it
Remaking a prequel game in sh3 before the main game in sh1 is not wise and it will make sh1 remake pointless after playing sh3, remake so make sh1 remake FIRST!
I disagree Silent hill 1 is the best of the series, i really hope they remake 1 then 3 since it is a follow up.
I disagree I dont think 1 is the best
@@sharkslayer0000 for me it is! :)
@@papawithgaming I dont blame you I loved 4231 in that order but everyone has their own opinions:)
@@sharkslayer0000 i love 1-2-3-4 in that lovely order haha, all of them are epic and very unique. I played #4 recently since it had been a while.
@@papawithgaming not a bad pick at all and I've got 2 copies of all the originals 1 unopened and 1 used so I agree I love this series
This game doesn’t sell so no games
ты зочем на англиском разговариваешъ?((((
5:53 old & outdated? How about just kinda burnt out from Ubisoft and plus remedy’s Alan wake 2. Props to silent hill for being the original OG cult horror game. But I see what they didn’t start from 1. And I kinda appreciate it.