Piet Arion sounds amazing. The comments that compare Piet and Dimash directly are irrational, mean spirited and cultish, this coming from both extremes on either side. Not all types of voices sound the best in big open areas, not all singers fluent in the language the sing in. This version was engineered to be delicate and nuanced close to the mic to showcase Piet's strengths. Same for Dimash's version which was made to be heard from a mile away.
Exactly! Both versions are tailored for each individual and they both sing it incredibly well. I just don't understand why people can't just appreciate both Dimash's and Piet's version as they are both incredibly talented and sing the song incredibly well.
¿Por qué ofenden? No deberían. Podrían buscar vídeos de Piet Arion, queson muchos, comparar ambos cantantes, y elegir aquien más le guste. Pero no olviden que la técnica no lo es todo, la emoción con la que se interpreta una canción es muy importante, también. Este alemán emociona porque pone su alma en cada nota. Dimash no siempre lo hace, aunque su voz sea prodigiosa e inigualable. 🤷♀️
I cannot listen to Piet singing this without experiencing near emotional breakdown. I’ve listened more times than I can count but my reaction is the same every time - tears, tears and more tears. For me, perfectly executed and with such colour and emotion. It feels like someone is ripping out my heart. I can’t possibly get my head around how he manages to do this! 😭
Hello, everyone! I have been in a voice conference all day (online, of course) and did not have a chance to check on this video! I apologize! I have removed Dimash's name from the title. I copied it verbatim from Piet's original video. Using the original title is what I always do. I did not think a thing about it for this one. I did not mean any offense to Dimash fans or to Dimash himself. Peace and blessings.
I watched this video a long time ago. It is not live, but I suppose it has to be his real voice and notes. He is unfortunately suffering comparison to Dimash, but I salute his talent in it's own right. There is no need for anyone to be disrespectful, anyway. RUclips is a place for people to showcase what they do.
You can react on one of his first songs which is a raw live recording and contains also a very high whistle tone: ruclips.net/video/5H75zXXenSU/видео.html ? Or absolutely stunning cover of I Dreamed A Dream from musical Les Miserables: ruclips.net/video/KIyCoSoIDJg/видео.html or cover of Oh Holy Night: ruclips.net/video/qegpq8OvLe0/видео.html
....and the doubters think Piet Arion is a fraud! What a great insult to the young man's talent, a very special gift. Vitas and Dimash version is harder, not softly appealing but this kid just grabbed you with that voice! More power to him!
This Man’s voice is amazing and he sings this with gentle beauty that is incomparable. I also listen to Dimash whom I love, however I believe this is a better version.
@@sskarides9863 also if you mean AUTO TUNE, the only auto tune even present is the echos which means all the singing is his real voice. And they can be compared dumbshit. Like it or not they can. BOTH CAN SING EXTREMELY WELL AND CAN EVEN HIT WHISTLE NOTES. Boom just compared them now go cry if you still disagree.
Piet is absolutely astounding, he doesn’t need his voice doctored none what so ever. He is a super star as far as m concerned. He does have that whistle tone a G7 I think. He’s also looking for someone who can help him further his career. ❤️❤️❤️
Así es. Yo le sigo, hace tiempo. Alcanza ese whistle tone sin problema. Tiene un rango vocal muy extenso, desde maravillosos graves a impresionantes agudos. Además es elegante y pone un gran sentimiento en cada una de sus interpretaciones.
Some of you so-called Dimash” “Dears” are such hateful fanatics that Dimash Himself would be very very displeased with you if he met you and he would tell you to stop the criticism. Piet loves Dimash and also loves Morissette, Mariah Carey, and Billie Eilish and does tribute songs. to these artists that he admires. The hate spewed by your reactions are shameful. There’s this one Italian fanatic who when I responded to a Dimash song with “ Dimash is the best male pop-op vocalist in the world.” but also mentioned another vocalist who I considered as good in love/love ballads only ripped me for daring to even mention another artist. “ I only listen to Dimash and no one else!!” I understand his love but when he started to call me a fake “ Dear” and used expletives, His hate would really have made Dimash very ashamed at this fanatic. When Piet performed Morissette “Akin Ka Na Lang” he mentioned at the outset he loves her technique. His rendition garnered over 22,000 Likes and over 4000 positive comments 99% were “ Wow! Amazing! Speechless” Very few dislikes and no hateful comments. You who call yourself “ Dears” be respectful and humble-like Dimash and like Piet. All love in isolation, Al
The haters aren't worthy to be called "Dears" when they spew hate. They don't represent real Dears who don't spew hate and are respectful to other sincere artists. So don't call them Dears. Peace
@ al fogel The real issue is how he named the song sos and Dimash in the title and did a b7 where dimash stops at d6 that kinda felt like mocking to his fans when ppl started comparing him to dimash.. Well tbh he is no where near dimash his cover is so freaking auto tuned and studio manipulated like u can clearly hear the cuts the tuning and the the last part Is digitally remastered.. If u wanna check for yourself go and speed up the video little by little and the pitch increases every change it gets higher and higher.. IT'S SO DISRESPECTFUL TO COMPARE DIMASH TO THIS FACTORY MADE GARBAGE
Dimash refers himself to other artists, their voices and their interpretations, NOT to tech like auto tune that makes out of my dogs barking a Caruso voice. This at best mediocre singer is a poor fake with no noteable voice in real life, no own interpretations and no knowledge of vocal technics at all. Why do you think you will not find a live performance on a stage with audience? Why do you think his “voice” has no development after 10 years? The man is poor fake, the Milli Vanilli of our days, but without their stage presence and charisma
He learned this song in French explicitly for this song. Piet is a shy person he is some what deserved. But music brings his emotions to life through his music. 🌹🌹
Piet Arions version gives me more chills than Dimash. Dimash is good. He sounds more like an opera singer, but this guy's interpretation gives me chills because of the way he effortlessly moves from high to low to mid range like a feather lifting up on air. His soft inflection exudes emotion and the angst of emotional urgency portrayed by this song. Without knowing the words it still drove me to emotion to understand this was "SOS d'un Terrien en de'tresse (Sos of an earthling in distress). Note that the translation is off in the first phrase of this song. It should read: (French Lyrics: Poquoi je Vie porquoi je Meur. Porquoi je reir porquoi je pleur) means Why do I live why do I die? Why do I laugh/smile why to I cry. It is the song of someone dying and not feeling comfortable in his own skin while he is here on earth. Stating that life is more beautiful while looking from above and if he could reverse the heaven and earth or juxtapose the two how beautiful it would be.
This version is more appropriate to "Starmania," the rock opera for which this was written. Further, Arion'd pronunciation is correct; Dimash made a number of pronunciation errors, chief of which was mispronouncing "haut" (rhymes with "oh") as "hwat." Near the end, Piet does sub "crie" for "ris," but that supports the underlying despair. As a display, Dimash is a smorgasbord of voices and styles; but, even if its lines were unscrambled, it wouldn't fit into "Starmania." Piet Arion could stand in for Daniel Balavoine.
Cristinafrom romania is writingplease do not be cruel withthis sensible and so complex genuine beautiiful wonder child piet aŕion!do you want to çhange this angel into a demon?he is my treasure!
Using your approach I say to you to stop telling her what to do. Piet is honored to be compared to Dimash though he is not trying to be Dimash. Piet has his own art and is inspired by Dimash and others just as Dimash has his role models. Peace
Thank you so much for your analysis! I know a lot of people compare him to Dimash, which I find unnecessary and unfair (to both of them). Piet, himself, has said he's does not want to be compared to him. Yes, this is a studio version and yes, there is autotune. But you know it's not more than any pop song recorded today, probably less actually, so I don't see the point in attacking Piet for choosing to do this in the studio. He has PLENTY of covers sung without autotune and, frankly, I wish more voice teachers checked out something other than SOS. He does all these things with less or no tuning in other songs, so the whistle is real, the belts are real, and the low chest is real-it is just studio appropriated, like any other studio recording.
Piet Arion, a capella, en una simple habitación, sin instrumentos, sin trucos. Búsquelo. Yo ya me tomé la molestia, hace tiempo. No me gusta prejuzgar. ¡Me quedé impresionada! 😅
Dragă doamnă profesoară!Cristina Neagu din România vă scrie: Ce contează ce face Piet în studio din punct de vedere electronic,dacă rezultatul este așa de interesant și emoționant! Problema dureroasă este că acum el nu mai este ce a fost,de când cântă rock pe scenă,i s-a schimbat vocea din angelică în dură, aspră și figura lui dulce, delicată ,chiar frumoasă e de nerecunoscut ,s-a schimonosit, nu-l suport nici să-l văd, nici să-l aud și socot că s-a nenorocit din toate punctele de vedere! Era unicat că solist,dar a devenit un rocker banal,chiar jalnic și asta mă doare nespus! Ce se poate face pentru el? Eu i-am scris mult, am făcut tot ce-am putut,dar el trebuie să se vadă așa cum îl vede Dumnezeu și nu cum îl lingușesc puținii fani fără minte!ACUM e mare, nu mai e adolescent,are o foarte mare responsabilitate, fiind așa de talentat! Vă rog mult ,ocupați-Vă de drama acestui fost artist autentic și atât de original!Vă mulțumesc din suflet,eu l-am iubit că o mamă creștină și l-am sfătuit căt am putut și plâng în inima mea pentru el!
Hello dear teacher i am Cristina from Romania and i love more gospel qwiet songs than any others but i told many times in many comments thatPiet Arion was for me a revelation and he can sing in his studio all his life if he wants ido not want to see him live on astage he is my dear child and now i suffer a lot knowing he now sings demonic violent wild rock!Maybe you and others musicians would do something to conving him to turn to his divine style from the beggining ! Thank you very much please listen Radio Voice of Hope with its divine music real for the glory of God!
I´m so happy to see and hear so many wonderful male and female singers with extraordinary voices, stunning! In our world are so many gifted and talented singers - we have to listen to them and not to judge who is better! The reason ist, that all of them are unique and we have to thank that we can listen to them because of our worldwide working internet. I wish that we "normal" people can listen their wonderful voices and are interested in following the music! Music is a language for all of us, your personal language isn´t nessessary to understand! Piet Arion an Austrian singer living in Vienna is one of this singers who ist hard working with his voice and shares his gift with us. Very special thanks to Piet!
LOL "that's like dolphins singing", I LOVE your reaction, you literally smiled through the whole song!! My first time seeing this video and hearing this song today and I absolutely LOVE Piet's version, SO BEAUTIFUL and cuts right through my soul like an angel singing!!💖💖💖🙏🏼
Hes never sang anything live because he cant. Hes been asked to numerous times and turned it down. Just shows how great someone can be in a studio with today's tech and daws/plug ins. You can pitch anything up and make it sound great on a laptop.
That’s false. Dimash stans are the worst people my god. Sure there’s some alterations but that’s mostly his natural voice. Editing can’t do that much. Piet is amazing, his control over his whistle is incomparable
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 Sorry. I know Piet for 7+ years, He never sang live, not even once. He is a good singer, but he can't hit this notes, it's fake. The voice in this one is so artificial it's painful to listen to. Emre did a reaction to him and it took him less them a moment to call him out on faking. It's so clear that it's fake like 6:17 when he closes his vocal tract by looking down and pulling up his shoulders. Nothing in this performance show any good singing technique. The notes he hits don't match the position his body should be in to hit them. His mouth shape doesn't match the type or register he is going for. This whole video is a huge BS. Idk how she can call herself a vocal coach when it's so obvious that it's fake.
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 Editin can easily do that. And it is obvious. And you are a nasty person, you are well known already. You are obsessed with hatred and always try to harm Dimash. Greetings to your sect leader Matheus
I really enjoy your reactions... Thank you! There are many videos and some go back even 12 years where you can see that this young man has natural ability and an absolutely phenomenal range. When he was younger he sang The Beatles Long and Winding Road and more recently. No Time to Die and also Morissette's Akin Da Na Lang... I also really enjoy his version of Oh Holy Night These videos give you a pretty good idea of his rare gift. I would love to know your opinion on these songs... I hope one day this young man will find a sponsor who will help him and give him some of the advantages that other artists have. It has been a long and winding road for this boy and I wish him the best!
Hi Christi, I so enjoy tuning in to your channel, you are delightful to spend some time with. I also appreciate your analysis of the singers voice. Today I watched S.O.S. By Piet Arion. I am Piet’s manager and the owner/CEO of Obelisk Records. I have signed Piet to a recording contract and currently I am finalizing distribution for his upcoming albums. He is truly an amazing singer and person, he has a big heart. His song writing is also very good and original, he has his own sound. People keep comparing him to Dimash and I would like to say that, they each have their own unique voice. The only thing that they have in common is that the both have a big heart and give 100% of themselves in every song they perform. The are both authentic, generous and humble. Just prior to the launch, I will send to you a copy of Piets first release if you like. If you want to do a first reaction, then you can announce that you are the first to react to it prior to its release. It will be interesting because your followers will be having their first reaction to the song/video as well. Of coarse, this is great publicity for Piet, once a manager, I guess always a manager🤷♂️. But I do think it would be fun to share an exclusive with folks like yourself. You get suggestions from your followers, this time you could flip that around. Just a thought, let me know how you feel about this. On another note, I have to say that the haters follow him around RUclips and wherever they find him they say awful and hurtful things. I advise Piet to ignore them and I try to do the same but today, I read a comment below be Heinz Timmer and I can’t let that go as it is slanderous and career damaging. So please forgive me but I am about to write a comment about this and set the record straight. Thanks for understand, Dana Allen
@@TheVoiceLoveCo thank you for replying Christi. I am sorry that you found yourself under attack! These Dimash people are hateful and they seek out Piet singing this song and say awful things. Piet has a wonderful voice and got a bit depressed by all of this negativity. He was excited to sing this song because he liked it. I think this will die down with the release of his own songs. A freind of mine, Nathan Wang, composes all of the music for the Jackie Chan films and a year ago, December 2019 Nathan recorded Dimash who sang a song for this latest Jackie Chan film. He said that Dimash is truly a nice and very kind person. Nathan said that Dimash doesn’t like that some of his fans can be so mean. I look forward to Piet and Dimash meeting. They are both very kind. Perhaps they will record something one day. Please touch base with me by the third week of this month, April. I will send you the video. I only ask this because I don’t want this to slip by me, as you can imagine, it’s rather hairy around here with all that is taking place as I prepare to put Piet out there , on or about May 1st. I got this idea at the moment I told you about it. It’s not something I had planned but, I like this idea and I am pleased that you like it as well. Is it possible for you to play the video in such a way that it can not be copied as I wouldn’t want anyone putting it elsewhere as that would not be good, until we formally launch. Then of coarse, I will want it everywhere! Go figure, marketing stuff 🤷♂️
Buenas tardes. Le escribo desde España. Estoy suscrita al canal de Piet Arion. Empecé a seguir su trayectoria hace 1 año, aproximadamente, tras escuchar esa versión de la canción SOS (por cierto, que mucha gente atribuye a Dimash esta composición porque están absolutamente desinformados. Hay mucha ignorancia. Deberían escuchar la original). Mi apoyo absoluto a Piet Arion. Posee un gran rango vocal, a pesar de su tesitura aguda, muy buen afinamiento, bonito color de su voz de pecho, tremenda voz de cabeza, con un whistle tone excepcional, elegancia y mucho sentimiento en todas sus interpretaciones. No permita que Piet se rinda. Ya somos muchos, en distintos países del mundo, quienes sabemos valorar con justicia y objetividad a Piet. ¡Ánimo! Un cordial saludo desde Madrid. 🇪🇦 🤗
i love Piet Arion his songs are amazing, i dont care if hes used a bit of enhancements, the overall song in the end is beautiful, and if its something i really enjoy listening to then whats the problem, too much hate comments
No, it's not real. All of his videos are heavily edited studio recordings with a lot of autotune and his 6th and 7th octave notes sre digitally pitch shifted, like many vocal coaches (e.g. Emre Yücelen and Caleb Coles) have already pointed out. And he has been refusing to sing a single note live for more than 7 years now
@@KajiVocals The 6th/7th octave in this recording is definitely pitch-shifted, also confirmed by e.g. Emre Yücelen and Caleb Coles on YT, both vocal coaches who own a recording studio.
I'm glad we can see many Dimash performances live and know he can do what we hear. I don't know if this is sung without aid of technology, nevertheless his voice is grating on my ears. Not soothing or beautiful to me. If he is hitting those notes without trickery, then good for him. Time to work on tone.
Tonal quality is subjective. I personally do not like the inconsistency of Dimash’s tones - but he is a technical marvel of a singer. Piet’s tone is very angelic, pure, and more sincere, gentle and delicate. In this piece, he is nasally - but it makes his French sound clear. Also, Piet has been around since before Dimash, and he has been whistling a long time. I think comparing tonal qualities is unfair because they are subjective. You can compare techniques, but Piet is not singing in the style of Dimash. He is singing in his own style, with his own technique, and singing an arrangement similar to Dimash’s.
Listen to several of live versions of Dimash No doubt he is amazing and that operatic voice is a killer But please listen to all SOS versions There are effects and he’s echo /reverb live on certain notes . Piet is not a fake . Auto tune is not going to fix a bad.voice The kid has a beautiful voice
Digital pitch-shifting by someone who collabs with Matheus Diaz (and the Matheus associated Fedsax channel), Matheus is one of the most evil persons in the whole YT vocal community and should be in jail imo
I really like both covers, piet has an amazing control in his whistle notes and dimash has a really great range, they are all incredibly talented. I dont get why people keep comparing others, i mean could u do better? Even with autotune it would suck if u cant sing.
Amazing voice but I can’t help Dimash sounds more pleasant in my ears. I think I must listen to Piet with a song that Dimash didn’t sing, to be able to appreciate his voice in that way it definitely deserves.
I agree with that but also don't forget his partner in this great duet ( the sound engineer ) I'm sure if they worked on a different song it would turn out great
muito bacana a maneira através da qual vc reagiu a esse verdadeiro fenÔmeno lírico!!!uma mistura de surpresa a cada nota,uma sensação que não dá explicar!!!
I've watched his video over many times, and really think his whistle register is genuine. As he hits those two incredible notes, you can see his shoulders more back as he releases his body from the notes. Is he by chance the ninth wonder of the world? I think so :)
Oh, poor you. Someone sang it better than your idol, no? Hot higher notes twice, no? And all you could do is declare the performance enhanced. You lot are so predictable and moronic, it's entertaining.
Hello dear distinction beautifull teacher!iam cristina from romania and iam sad to see so much lack òf ĺove insome oppiñions!piet is ă ďivne artist andmy treasure i donot need operistic show but a nătural voice sò tendèr anď uñique strange personalîty!angel figure voice and all he has fròm ģod!i love hîm a lot!
Its me agaiñwith my poor english!idid see some videoaudio with piet and indeed he was not likè in the studio!maybe he has not courage or is afraid on the ștage!but his big artistic talent is the same unique!really i do not lyke rock and ihope he will return to his angelic styĺè!kisses!
Thank you love for your description . Definitely on point . My most beautiful but a simple and little comparison from Piet to Dimash , is i love them both but am an operatic power enthusiast but Piet singing sos and oh holy night is just Perfection of course the vocal modulationship . But most important comparison is his diction and pronunciation is butter. Hence his ability to portray colour and texture. Topping off all over everything else is his annunciation. I don't speak French but yes felt lyrics but had a more understanding of it without translation. Is it a sad song or happy love or not. Life or death. I think all the above but his perspective made feel moved and made feel like my spirit hovering among the mountains . Xx
Piet is not trained. All you are seeing is raw talent. I recall reading somewhere that he said being professionally and/or classically trained was a financial impossibility for him. I'd love for someone to recognize this young man for the talent he truly is and invest in him and allow him to discover the power and capability of his instrument.
yes, he is not singing live and he is lip syncing his pre-recorded version but people here keep ignoring the fact that live performances are using a lot of filters as well. this kid has talent and he can whistle that's for sure.
There is no comparison though. He couldnt reproduce half of this live, doesnt matter what filters and mic effects you give him. The whole whistle sequence is autotuned, he would be all over the place live. Obviously this guy is gifted with a big range and if anything he has great sound editing skills, but the attempts to pretend this isnt a "studio only" feat are simply silly.
The only reason Piet says he likes and says he is a fan , is so all Dimash Dears well watch him ,And he has the nerve to ask you to give him paypal money.If he is that good why don't he sing live on stage .If he is that good a singer i am sure people would pay to go and see him. But he can't sing live . I am not saying he can't sing .But not in the same class .So do not put His name in the same sentence as Dimash's name . And when you ask why don't Piet sing live Piet trolls become rude and troll you .
According to his former "manager" (who he cheated out of money), he's lying when he says he's a fan of Dimash. In reality he calls Dimash nasty names and mocks him.
This actually has shown me that his weaker registers are produced. How do these guys say he is better than Dimash or any male singer? Beats me. Btw I also read through the allegations.
@@user-rm4fu3sc2h Please don't bother with these clowns ,, we all know what Dimash can do without digital enhancements or studio editing or music or even a fucking microphone. And we saw and heard industry legends & hall of fame members & best selling artists & Grammy award winning songwriters & world class famous composers & the prisedent of the Chinese pop musicians association & the director of the Astana Opera state theater & the great Andrea Bocelli , all give him high praise and compliments . Add to that more than 20 vocal coaches from all corners of the world analyzing his performances and all of them gave him the highest praise I ever saw a singer get from them . This Piet guy is nothing but an amateur like Marcelito Pomoy not worth anything but some local fans singing their praise . He is even worse than Marcelito because Marcelito at least sings on talent shows and small local stages acting like a parrot good for nothing but imitating other singers but this dude is worse because he hides behind his sound engineer and studio editing trying to reach a level light years higher than his actuall talent would get him .
Something is not right about your recent reactions. You gave the impression that Dimash's D8 note in "Unforgettable Day" was microphone feedback. But you praise a completely manufactured performance here. You are one of, if not the most pleasant reactor on You Tube. But I have little or no confidence in your analysis of what you are reacting to.
Dimash is just one more cover of this song. This french song was first sung for Grégory nd his unique charme. There are many covers. Enjoy them . Don”t mix them
@The Voice Love Co. Wow, I'm native French, and Piet nails the difficult pronunciation. Very impressive! The lyricist for this song is from my hometown: Luc Plamondon. He has written so many poignant songs. Even for global superstar Québécois star Céline Dion! I'm so proud to hear English speakers being inspired by this 70's French-Québécois musical "'Starmania" set in an Orwellian decadent society where this character "Johnny Rockfort" is gasping for the air of freedom. It is, thus, the S.O.S from an earthling in distress. Original singer is Daniel Balavoine, a very talented singer too, sadly deceased. You may want to check another song by him "Tous les cris les S.O.S". (Coincidental S.O.S. LOL) Music is truly a language that knows no borders! Thank you for considering music outside the the English-American cultural sphere. Thank you. Merci beaucoup! :D
Thank you for your graceful reaction Christi. A lot of hate going around in the comments. I must admit I am a bit skeptical of this as well as he was, literally, in the dark (what's he hiding?)! Also his head/neck position while executing some of those notes... Like you, I will reserve my biases until I've researched him more in detail. Blessings!!
@@TheVoiceLoveCo I feel bad for you, if I'd known...I would have warned you of the venom, it's very real. Dimash fans, can be very ugly...unless you are touting their beloved.
@@Practicerecordings O do be quite .There is no Venom here ,so don't act like holy then thou . People have a right to comment .That is why this video is called a reaction and has a comment section .
@@mollyb4332 Who the hell has the audacity to tell someone to be quiet(quite?), while simultaneously saying people have the right to comment? ...oh, that's right, Ruh Sky, contradicting, hypocrite extraordinaire. Sheesh, people like you...are why people like me, are misanthropic. >.
Internet users must understand and know that the dimash version or any other are only revisited versions. The original version comes from a French singer from the 70s/80s
One important difference is that Piet Arion is pronouncing perfect French. Dimash is a prodigy but the language barrier is making him develop his career in oriental Asia, in countries like China and, of course, Kazakhstan. Piet has an incredible range. Pretty impresive, though it is very difficult to make these ultra-high notes work in song in a way the final sound is coherent.
Can you please untag Dimash? This has nothing to do with him. Oh and there are much better covers around than the horrifying mess that is this over-produced song.
His name has been removed. Thank you for letting me know. I truly had no idea using the original title from the video (like I always do) would produce this much emotion. My sincerest apologies.
@@TheVoiceLoveCo Thank you so much. I think peeps are a bit sensitive towards this cover because it got a lot of attention but is so heavily produced, compared to other covers that didn't but are these singers' actual voices. I highly recommend Caleb Coles' version of this song because not only is it his voice but he made an English version and adapted the song for his own voice which cannot go as high as Dimash's. It is brilliant but alas didn't garner half the attention that this produced fakery did.
@@subidubiduda5293 When you prove the cover is heavily produced then you should make your litigious statements. And also, Dimash's performance is a cover of an existing song written 20+ years ago for a French singer. It never was a Dimash original. It's embarrasing posting gnorant, slanderous moronisms like yours, but I suspect you lot are simply incapable of feeling embarrasment.
@@AA-lu5gp Почему бы Вам не ответить на комментарий JasminGardenia, который является более аргументированным? И с чего Вы взяли, что кто-то утверждает, что песня СОС Димаша является оригинальной? Всем прекрасно известно, что это кавер. Вы высасываете из пальца повод для гнева. ////////// Why don't you respond to JasminGardenia's comment, which is more reasoned? And what makes You think that someone claims that SOS of Dimash is original? Everyone knows that this is a cover. You suck the anger out of your finger
I am finding the comments fascinating. Especially those from those who for some reason seem unable or unwilling to let in the multiple times through this reaction when you'd said that you were not sure what you were really seeing or hearing, including how much of that is live and/or processed, and how interesting it would be to hear him sing this 'live', etc. I don't think I'd ever heard you say it quite so many times in one video, which should be saying a lot about what you are picking up on. It is the first time for me to hear him perform and it is unmistakable that there's talent here. That he is not Dimash is unmistakable, too. But that is okay. He is himself, with his style, be it 'live' or not. He's an artist. A performer. Like you, I WOULD be interested in hearing him sing live, yes, but it is still an interesting performance. I'm not sure why people are offended by the tagging of Dimash (I believe it is a copy from Piet's own title), even though it is very much a 'Dimash style' cover. Perhaps there can be an amending of the title to 'in the style of', but the level of reactivity is interesting to see. Can we accept that people are unique, and one person's talent (with or without auto tune or other means and however they create their performance) does not detract from another person's obvious talent. Is it all a competition? To me this is an interesting exposition on Dimash's cover of that song, which does not take away from Dimash's mastery. FWIW, parts of it indeed did not all feel natural to me, and I wonder how much here is a marriage of human voice and machine processing ... with some notes being almost certainly machine manipulated. Still, the composition remains interesting to listen to and there's plenty of talent there. Of course, people don't have to agree with me. Thank you for the reaction, Christi. Clearly some covers bring up strong emotions in fans ... and are still worthy of listening to IMO.
See the problem is that one of his former friends ( and manager as well ) told people he hates Dimash with passion but on his channel he says Dimash is his idol !!! Also , it's not just auto tune in some parts , what's more dangerous is digital pitch shifting which someone like Vitas has been using for Moe than a decade . Some vocalists online said there's at least an octave shift up in this arrangement . Meaning if I was singing B6 it will be shifted to B7 . At last , it's ridiculous to do a cover for one the most difficult French songs and after one of the best ( if not the best vocal technicians on the planet ) elevated it to a higher level , with the intention of doing the song justice and making your idol proud , but you choose to hide yourself behind digital enhancements and pitch shifting while some singers like the Indonesian girl ( I think her name is Lamar ) was invited by Dimash himself to sing with him on a grand stage in front of a huge crowd & he congratulated Leo Cantro ( a small youtuber and an amateur singer ) for doing covers of his songs . Also people like Caleb Coles & Emi Pelligrino made excellent covers and Caleb did the 22 seconds note with runs and riffs from Sinful Passion as best as he could just to show people that if he did it then Dimash surely did it .
People are unique. And the people that are giving their opinion are worthy too. It's funny how your opinion rises above the rest. Whether by design or by accident, this video reaction is "pulling" in Dimash fans. His name is in the TITLE. But you can't understand how this may be a problem with Dimash fans? Or why Dimash fans (you know, the ones that were practically LURED here by the title) might be upset that a "Vocal Coach" is giving kudos to a manufactured performance. You are either VERY good natured, or easily fooled.
@@donny1960 Oh, that's easy. I'm VERY good natured. :) As for others' opinions, I'd be curious to know where you understood me to say others' views were not worthy, or why you think my opinion rises above the rest. Have a lovely rest of the weekend!
@@kolgerrard1964 I don't know him or his manager so I cannot speak for either of their opinions of Dimash (who, by the way, is an amazing singer, as we all know). I think that looking up to someone doesn't need to mean idolizing them in all matters or hating them (or envying them or aspiring to be like them) in all matters. People are so much more complicated than that, IMO. People may do covers for all kinds of reasons and use all kinds of means as artistic measures. I'm not sure it ought to be a competition or be seen as being permitted only to those who use no auto-tune/mixing/pitch-shifting. Granted, I like natural voices the best, but I also know many singers use technical processing to enhance/dampen/filter/whatever, especially in recordings. Why is that offensive? Like I said, this is my first time listening to him, so I don't know him. Did he ever claim to use no auto-tune etc.? BTW, I'm not sure I understand what is "dangerous" in using digital pitch shifting. I'm not aware that it is harmful.
Oh my! I've been in a voice conference online all day and only just got on to check the comments. I've removed Dimash's name. (Yes, that was a copy from the original title, which is what I usually do.) I had NO IDEA there was this much emotion going on around this performer. Wowza!
È così al di fuori della voce umana, che mi sembra impossibile. Vorrei vederlo cantare dal vivo, come fa Dimash. Comunque mi chiedo dove dovrà spingersi un cantante per attirare l'attenzione, in un mondo così pieno di grandi talenti.
Piet has never really sung live, but if you want to know what he sounds like without much editing listen to his older songs. His songs from 6 to 10 years ago are MUCH less edited than his newer stuff.
I mean he has but still, the man can sing. Plus in this song the only auto tune present (could be him just being good with mic) is the echos so its not auto tune. Dunno why people think it is. Its really annoying when people don't use their brains.
Dumbasses the only auto tune present is the echos. Hell you can argue he isnt using it at all. He could be very good with making the mic echo. He also sang live so stfu it's auto tune bc its not. You can go look at his old vids and though it doesn't sound as good, he can still hit very high notes.
Curious to your thoughts on Giulia Falcone's take on this piece. I was not aware of the song until I heard her version. Not being a trained vocalist I'd like to think she is 'real' -- but similar to your reaction on the whistle tones by Piet Arion, some of her songs just seem 'too good'. Almost all of her posts from a video perspective are pretty simple without much effect, but the sound seems quite produced. ruclips.net/video/fyMkoB29INQ/видео.html
The only thing that I don't like (from the perspective of a classically-trained vocalist) is that his voice in the lower register sounds like a different person from the upper registers. For those who are not trained singers, an element to classical singing training is that one's voice in all registers should sound like the same person singing. Now, you might think that a singer may do this to sound unique, but the reality is that it isn't unique. It's far more difficult to sound like the same singer through all registers of one's voice. Ok, let me then come back and say that Piet Arion is supremely gifted and talented. My critique was from a technical standpoint and not in any way saying that he is not one of the most gifted singers on the planet. What I am pointing out has more to do with training style and nothing to do with talent. Actually, I really believe that right after recording this version, he could record a version where his voice does sound like the same singer through all registers. I think it is a stylistic choice to not sing in this way. It's actually a popular introduction to modern pop music.
Really puzzled by your comments "what am I really seeing," as if he was faking or using digital tricks to sing the song. Refrain from such snide comments and just critique his vocal range, intimate relationship to the listeners, and unbelievably high whistle tones, higher than Dimash, he produces. He deserves no less from vocal coaches.
Lol... I keep coming back to this. I believe this is probably the most beautiful rendition of a song that I have ever heard. A masterpiece. Thank you
Piet Arion sounds amazing. The comments that compare Piet and Dimash directly are irrational, mean spirited and cultish, this coming from both extremes on either side. Not all types of voices sound the best in big open areas, not all singers fluent in the language the sing in. This version was engineered to be delicate and nuanced close to the mic to showcase Piet's strengths. Same for Dimash's version which was made to be heard from a mile away.
Exactly! Both versions are tailored for each individual and they both sing it incredibly well. I just don't understand why people can't just appreciate both Dimash's and Piet's version as they are both incredibly talented and sing the song incredibly well.
Don't tell to people what they can or can't do.
@@NeoNikosis Your silly. It's a four year old post.
¿Por qué ofenden? No deberían. Podrían buscar vídeos de Piet Arion, queson muchos, comparar ambos cantantes, y elegir aquien más le guste. Pero no olviden que la técnica no lo es todo, la emoción con la que se interpreta una canción es muy importante, también. Este alemán emociona porque pone su alma en cada nota. Dimash no siempre lo hace, aunque su voz sea prodigiosa e inigualable. 🤷♀️
I cannot listen to Piet singing this without experiencing near emotional breakdown. I’ve listened more times than I can count but my reaction is the same every time - tears, tears and more tears. For me, perfectly executed and with such colour and emotion. It feels like someone is ripping out my heart. I can’t possibly get my head around how he manages to do this! 😭
Hello, everyone! I have been in a voice conference all day (online, of course) and did not have a chance to check on this video! I apologize! I have removed Dimash's name from the title. I copied it verbatim from Piet's original video. Using the original title is what I always do. I did not think a thing about it for this one. I did not mean any offense to Dimash fans or to Dimash himself. Peace and blessings.
He dedicated it to Dimash, he's a huge fan.
I watched this video a long time ago. It is not live, but I suppose it has to be his real voice and notes. He is unfortunately suffering comparison to Dimash, but I salute his talent in it's own right. There is no need for anyone to be disrespectful, anyway. RUclips is a place for people to showcase what they do.
@@Arkhangael ...indeed. :)
You can react on one of his first songs which is a raw live recording and contains also a very high whistle tone:
ruclips.net/video/5H75zXXenSU/видео.html ?
Or absolutely stunning cover of I Dreamed A Dream from musical Les Miserables:
ruclips.net/video/KIyCoSoIDJg/видео.html
or cover of Oh Holy Night:
ruclips.net/video/qegpq8OvLe0/видео.html
@@ivoounpuu1062 Lovely. :)
....and the doubters think Piet Arion is a fraud! What a great insult to the young man's talent, a very special gift. Vitas and Dimash version is harder, not softly appealing but this kid just grabbed you with that voice! More power to him!
This Man’s voice is amazing and he sings this with gentle beauty that is incomparable. I also listen to Dimash whom I love, however I believe this is a better version.
Piet is Amazing 😮😮😮😮
Non piet est une meilleure version car on comprend mieux ce qu'il dit.
The execution of his voice from D7 to B7 is extremely perfect if not excellent.
Piet is more closed to the french original, but he save his personality. I like his version.
piet did not sing the song with her own voice and created a sound with the computer trick, no matter what piet dimash can not be compared
@@sskarides9863 funny bc im pretty sure HE sang live so stfu it isn't real. It isn't unrealistic considering dimash can hit notes like that.
@@sskarides9863 also if you mean AUTO TUNE, the only auto tune even present is the echos which means all the singing is his real voice. And they can be compared dumbshit. Like it or not they can. BOTH CAN SING EXTREMELY WELL AND CAN EVEN HIT WHISTLE NOTES. Boom just compared them now go cry if you still disagree.
i guess I am quite randomly asking but does anyone know of a good website to watch newly released series online?
@Orlando Idris I use Flixzone. You can find it on google :)
Piet is absolutely astounding, he doesn’t need his voice doctored none what so ever. He is a super star as far as m concerned. He does have that whistle tone a G7 I think. He’s also looking for someone who can help him further his career. ❤️❤️❤️
Así es. Yo le sigo, hace tiempo. Alcanza ese whistle tone sin problema. Tiene un rango vocal muy extenso, desde maravillosos graves a impresionantes agudos. Además es elegante y pone un gran sentimiento en cada una de sus interpretaciones.
Some of you so-called Dimash” “Dears” are such hateful fanatics that Dimash Himself would be very very displeased with you if he met you and he would tell you to stop the criticism. Piet loves Dimash and also loves Morissette, Mariah Carey, and Billie Eilish and does tribute songs. to these artists that he admires. The hate spewed by your reactions are shameful. There’s this one Italian fanatic who when I responded to a Dimash song with “ Dimash is the best male pop-op vocalist in the world.” but also mentioned another vocalist who I considered as good in love/love ballads only ripped me for daring to even mention another artist. “ I only listen to Dimash and no one else!!” I understand his love but when he started to call me a fake “ Dear” and used expletives, His hate would really have made Dimash very ashamed at this fanatic. When Piet performed Morissette “Akin Ka Na Lang” he mentioned at the outset he loves her technique. His rendition garnered over 22,000 Likes and over 4000 positive comments 99% were “ Wow! Amazing! Speechless”
Very few dislikes and no hateful comments.
You who call yourself “ Dears” be respectful and humble-like Dimash and like Piet.
All love in isolation,
Al
The haters aren't worthy to be called "Dears" when they spew hate. They don't represent real Dears who don't spew hate and are respectful to other sincere artists. So don't call them Dears. Peace
For me your right
for "Dears" you dont have a right to say his name
@ al fogel
The real issue is how he named the song sos and Dimash in the title and did a b7 where dimash stops at d6 that kinda felt like mocking to his fans when ppl started comparing him to dimash..
Well tbh he is no where near dimash his cover is so freaking auto tuned and studio manipulated like u can clearly hear the cuts the tuning and the the last part Is digitally remastered..
If u wanna check for yourself go and speed up the video little by little and the pitch increases every change it gets higher and higher..
IT'S SO DISRESPECTFUL TO COMPARE DIMASH TO THIS FACTORY MADE GARBAGE
@@kunal4697 Yes, auto tuned a lot. Good ears
Dimash refers himself to other artists, their voices and their interpretations, NOT to tech like auto tune that makes out of my dogs barking a Caruso voice. This at best mediocre singer is a poor fake with no noteable voice in real life, no own interpretations and no knowledge of vocal technics at all. Why do you think you will not find a live performance on a stage with audience? Why do you think his “voice” has no development after 10 years? The man is poor fake, the Milli Vanilli of our days, but without their stage presence and charisma
this is the best and most complete reaction you can hear from Piet Arion. Thanks!!
I love this rendition… Incredible… 👏🏻👏🏻
He learned this song in French explicitly for this song. Piet is a shy person he is some what deserved. But music brings his emotions to life through his music. 🌹🌹
Respect this person because he is so talented......I'm blowing away...he is amazing ...
Piet Arions version gives me more chills than Dimash. Dimash is good. He sounds more like an opera singer, but this guy's interpretation gives me chills because of the way he effortlessly moves from high to low to mid range like a feather lifting up on air. His soft inflection exudes emotion and the angst of emotional urgency portrayed by this song. Without knowing the words it still drove me to emotion to understand this was "SOS d'un Terrien en de'tresse (Sos of an earthling in distress). Note that the translation is off in the first phrase of this song. It should read: (French Lyrics: Poquoi je Vie porquoi je Meur. Porquoi je reir porquoi je pleur) means Why do I live why do I die? Why do I laugh/smile why to I cry. It is the song of someone dying and not feeling comfortable in his own skin while he is here on earth. Stating that life is more beautiful while looking from above and if he could reverse the heaven and earth or juxtapose the two how beautiful it would be.
Dimash is dry and whiny.
This version is more appropriate to "Starmania," the rock opera for which this was written. Further, Arion'd pronunciation is correct; Dimash made a number of pronunciation errors, chief of which was mispronouncing "haut" (rhymes with "oh") as "hwat." Near the end, Piet does sub "crie" for "ris," but that supports the underlying despair. As a display, Dimash is a smorgasbord of voices and styles; but, even if its lines were unscrambled, it wouldn't fit into "Starmania." Piet Arion could stand in for Daniel Balavoine.
Totalmente de acuerdo. 👍👍
Cristinafrom romania is writingplease do not be cruel withthis sensible and so complex genuine beautiiful wonder child piet aŕion!do you want to çhange this angel into a demon?he is my treasure!
French is my native language and I can those words fit PERFECTLY to his mouth.
So he's a real singer and stop comparing him to Dimash
Using your approach I say to you to stop telling her what to do. Piet is honored to be compared to Dimash though he is not trying to be Dimash. Piet has his own art and is inspired by Dimash and others just as Dimash has his role models. Peace
Thank you so much for your analysis! I know a lot of people compare him to Dimash, which I find unnecessary and unfair (to both of them). Piet, himself, has said he's does not want to be compared to him. Yes, this is a studio version and yes, there is autotune. But you know it's not more than any pop song recorded today, probably less actually, so I don't see the point in attacking Piet for choosing to do this in the studio. He has PLENTY of covers sung without autotune and, frankly, I wish more voice teachers checked out something other than SOS.
He does all these things with less or no tuning in other songs, so the whistle is real, the belts are real, and the low chest is real-it is just studio appropriated, like any other studio recording.
Thank you for your intelligent dissection of the performance. I, too, would love to hear a live performance. I’m certain Piet would not disappoint.
Piet Arion, a capella, en una simple habitación, sin instrumentos, sin trucos. Búsquelo. Yo ya me tomé la molestia, hace tiempo. No me gusta prejuzgar. ¡Me quedé impresionada! 😅
Dragă doamnă profesoară!Cristina Neagu din România vă scrie: Ce contează ce face Piet în studio din punct de vedere electronic,dacă rezultatul este așa de interesant și emoționant! Problema dureroasă este că acum el nu mai este ce a fost,de când cântă rock pe scenă,i s-a schimbat vocea din angelică în dură, aspră și figura lui dulce, delicată ,chiar frumoasă e de nerecunoscut ,s-a schimonosit, nu-l suport nici să-l văd, nici să-l aud și socot că s-a nenorocit din toate punctele de vedere! Era unicat că solist,dar a devenit un rocker banal,chiar jalnic și asta mă doare nespus! Ce se poate face pentru el? Eu i-am scris mult, am făcut tot ce-am putut,dar el trebuie să se vadă așa cum îl vede Dumnezeu și nu cum îl lingușesc puținii fani fără minte!ACUM e mare, nu mai e adolescent,are o foarte mare responsabilitate, fiind așa de talentat! Vă rog mult ,ocupați-Vă de drama acestui fost artist autentic și atât de original!Vă mulțumesc din suflet,eu l-am iubit că o mamă creștină și l-am sfătuit căt am putut și plâng în inima mea pentru el!
Hi dear!--I love your comments about this ammmmaaziing PIET ARION!!!
Thx sooooooooooooooooo much about Piet react's !!!!
Friendly kisses from France my Dear...
Piet was Best, period
Hello dear teacher i am Cristina from Romania and i love more gospel qwiet songs than any others but i told many times in many comments thatPiet Arion was for me a revelation and he can sing in his studio all his life if he wants ido not want to see him live on astage he is my dear child and now i suffer a lot knowing he now sings demonic violent wild rock!Maybe you and others musicians would do something to conving him to turn to his divine style from the beggining ! Thank you very much please listen Radio Voice of Hope with its divine music real for the glory of God!
I´m so happy to see and hear so many wonderful male and female singers with extraordinary voices, stunning! In our world are so many gifted and talented singers - we have to listen to them and not to judge who is better! The reason ist, that all of them are unique and we have to thank that we can listen to them because of our worldwide working internet.
I wish that we "normal" people can listen their wonderful voices and are interested in following the music! Music is a language for all of us, your personal language isn´t nessessary to understand! Piet Arion an Austrian singer living in Vienna is one of this singers who ist hard working with his voice and shares his gift with us. Very special thanks to Piet!
LOL "that's like dolphins singing", I LOVE your reaction, you literally smiled through the whole song!! My first time seeing this video and hearing this song today and I absolutely LOVE Piet's version, SO BEAUTIFUL and cuts right through my soul like an angel singing!!💖💖💖🙏🏼
Piet is the man!!!!!! 🙌🙌🙌🙌
He is divine.
After watching so many of ur vids i finally decided to suscribe to ur Channel. Just love the way u analyse a singer.
Thank you so much @Jean Louis TEMAKE. That means the world. THANK YOU!
Hes never sang anything live because he cant. Hes been asked to numerous times and turned it down. Just shows how great someone can be in a studio with today's tech and daws/plug ins. You can pitch anything up and make it sound great on a laptop.
Correct
Sam Geee you are 100% right
That’s false. Dimash stans are the worst people my god. Sure there’s some alterations but that’s mostly his natural voice. Editing can’t do that much. Piet is amazing, his control over his whistle is incomparable
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 Sorry. I know Piet for 7+ years, He never sang live, not even once. He is a good singer, but he can't hit this notes, it's fake. The voice in this one is so artificial it's painful to listen to. Emre did a reaction to him and it took him less them a moment to call him out on faking. It's so clear that it's fake like 6:17 when he closes his vocal tract by looking down and pulling up his shoulders. Nothing in this performance show any good singing technique. The notes he hits don't match the position his body should be in to hit them. His mouth shape doesn't match the type or register he is going for. This whole video is a huge BS. Idk how she can call herself a vocal coach when it's so obvious that it's fake.
@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 Editin can easily do that. And it is obvious. And you are a nasty person, you are well known already. You are obsessed with hatred and always try to harm Dimash. Greetings to your sect leader Matheus
30 years what ?! Jesus you look amazing 😍😍
yes she's so beautiful : )
I really enjoy your reactions... Thank you! There are many videos and some go back even 12 years where you can see that this young man has natural ability and an absolutely phenomenal range. When he was younger he sang The Beatles Long and Winding Road and more recently. No Time to Die and also Morissette's Akin Da Na Lang... I also really enjoy his version of Oh Holy Night These videos give you a pretty good idea of his rare gift. I would love to know your opinion on these songs... I hope one day this young man will find a sponsor who will help him and give him some of the advantages that other artists have. It has been a long and winding road for this boy and I wish him the best!
Hi Christi, I so enjoy tuning in to your channel, you are delightful to spend some time with. I also appreciate your analysis of the singers voice. Today I watched S.O.S. By Piet Arion. I am Piet’s manager and the owner/CEO of Obelisk Records. I have signed Piet to a recording contract and currently I am finalizing distribution for his upcoming albums. He is truly an amazing singer and person, he has a big heart. His song writing is also very good and original, he has his own sound. People keep comparing him to Dimash and I would like to say that, they each have their own unique voice. The only thing that they have in common is that the both have a big heart and give 100% of themselves in every song they perform. The are both authentic, generous and humble. Just prior to the launch, I will send to you a copy of Piets first release if you like. If you want to do a first reaction, then you can announce that you are the first to react to it prior to its release. It will be interesting because your followers will be having their first reaction to the song/video as well. Of coarse, this is great publicity for Piet, once a manager, I guess always a manager🤷♂️. But I do think it would be fun to share an exclusive with folks like yourself. You get suggestions from your followers, this time you could flip that around. Just a thought, let me know how you feel about this.
On another note, I have to say that the haters follow him around RUclips and wherever they find him they say awful and hurtful things. I advise Piet to ignore them and I try to do the same but today, I read a comment below be Heinz Timmer and I can’t let that go as it is slanderous and career damaging. So please forgive me but I am about to write a comment about this and set the record straight.
Thanks for understand, Dana Allen
@Dana Allen I would love to! Please send it to me voiceloveco@gmail.com 💖
@@TheVoiceLoveCo thank you for replying Christi. I am sorry that you found yourself under attack! These Dimash people are hateful and they seek out Piet singing this song and say awful things. Piet has a wonderful voice and got a bit depressed by all of this negativity. He was excited to sing this song because he liked it. I think this will die down with the release of his own songs. A freind of mine, Nathan Wang, composes all of the music for the Jackie Chan films and a year ago, December 2019 Nathan recorded Dimash who sang a song for this latest Jackie Chan film. He said that Dimash is truly a nice and very kind person. Nathan said that Dimash doesn’t like that some of his fans can be so mean. I look forward to Piet and Dimash meeting. They are both very kind. Perhaps they will record something one day.
Please touch base with me by the third week of this month, April. I will send you the video. I only ask this because I don’t want this to slip by me, as you can imagine, it’s rather hairy around here with all that is taking place as I prepare to put Piet out there , on or about May 1st. I got this idea at the moment I told you about it. It’s not something I had planned but, I like this idea and I am pleased that you like it as well. Is it possible for you to play the video in such a way that it can not be copied as I wouldn’t want anyone putting it elsewhere as that would not be good, until we formally launch. Then of coarse, I will want it everywhere! Go figure, marketing stuff 🤷♂️
@@danafreddy email me and I believe we can get it worked out.
Buenas tardes. Le escribo desde España. Estoy suscrita al canal de Piet Arion. Empecé a seguir su trayectoria hace 1 año, aproximadamente, tras escuchar esa versión de la canción SOS (por cierto, que mucha gente atribuye a Dimash esta composición porque están absolutamente desinformados. Hay mucha ignorancia. Deberían escuchar la original). Mi apoyo absoluto a Piet Arion. Posee un gran rango vocal, a pesar de su tesitura aguda, muy buen afinamiento, bonito color de su voz de pecho, tremenda voz de cabeza, con un whistle tone excepcional, elegancia y mucho sentimiento en todas sus interpretaciones. No permita que Piet se rinda. Ya somos muchos, en distintos países del mundo, quienes sabemos valorar con justicia y objetividad a Piet. ¡Ánimo! Un cordial saludo desde Madrid. 🇪🇦 🤗
Ask him to do it live, his fanclub said that he will do it last year but until now that never hapen
I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT YOU ARE SO PRETTY!
i love Piet Arion his songs are amazing, i dont care if hes used a bit of enhancements, the overall song in the end is beautiful, and if its something i really enjoy listening to then whats the problem, too much hate comments
“ a bit of enhancements “ - you made my day 😂 The man is poor fake ...
No, it's not real. All of his videos are heavily edited studio recordings with a lot of autotune and his 6th and 7th octave notes sre digitally pitch shifted, like many vocal coaches (e.g. Emre Yücelen and Caleb Coles) have already pointed out. And he has been refusing to sing a single note live for more than 7 years now
Not true, most of his videos are recorded in his house...he's been recording since he was a teenager from his home, his recordings go back to 2010.
How do you know
I heard acoustic things from Piet before. It’s his voice. Not ‘pitchshifting’.
@@KajiVocals The 6th/7th octave in this recording is definitely pitch-shifted, also confirmed by e.g. Emre Yücelen and Caleb Coles on YT, both vocal coaches who own a recording studio.
JasminGardenia Well, you’re wrong as I know Cile who is his vocal teacher and he himself has confirmed Piet is doing all the notes.
I'm glad we can see many Dimash performances live and know he can do what we hear. I don't know if this is sung without aid of technology, nevertheless his voice is grating on my ears. Not soothing or beautiful to me. If he is hitting those notes without trickery, then good for him. Time to work on tone.
Tonal quality is subjective. I personally do not like the inconsistency of Dimash’s tones - but he is a technical marvel of a singer. Piet’s tone is very angelic, pure, and more sincere, gentle and delicate. In this piece, he is nasally - but it makes his French sound clear.
Also, Piet has been around since before Dimash, and he has been whistling a long time.
I think comparing tonal qualities is unfair because they are subjective. You can compare techniques, but Piet is not singing in the style of Dimash. He is singing in his own style, with his own technique, and singing an arrangement similar to Dimash’s.
Listen to several of live versions of Dimash
No doubt he is amazing and that operatic voice is a killer
But please listen to all SOS versions
There are effects and he’s echo /reverb live on certain notes .
Piet is not a fake . Auto tune is not going to fix a bad.voice
The kid has a beautiful voice
Perfection ❤
very rare that it does not have live videos, very suspicious, for me that the voice is more arranged than a birthday table
The computer called. It wants its sounds back or at the very least, it wants to be given credit for making these sounds.
Your brain called to go find it, somewhere in the woods.
So please record a video using whatever computer and autotune u like, but make sure to sound like this, as long as is that easy!
Digital pitch-shifting by someone who collabs with Matheus Diaz (and the Matheus associated Fedsax channel), Matheus is one of the most evil persons in the whole YT vocal community and should be in jail imo
I totally agree with you.
Is there any reason for that? I'm sorry. I'm new to the high singing community
Mattheus has nothing to do with Piet lol.
That is hateful and evil of you to tie Piet to that guy. Why don’t you get a YT channel, you could send yourself hate comments.
I really like both covers, piet has an amazing control in his whistle notes and dimash has a really great range, they are all incredibly talented. I dont get why people keep comparing others, i mean could u do better? Even with autotune it would suck if u cant sing.
He just blew dimash out of the waters...😮with those delicately pure voice and that super high high whistles n lo notes..in my opinion😮😮
Amazing voice but I can’t help Dimash sounds more pleasant in my ears. I think I must listen to Piet with a song that Dimash didn’t sing, to be able to appreciate his voice in that way it definitely deserves.
I agree with that but also don't forget his partner in this great duet ( the sound engineer ) I'm sure if they worked on a different song it would turn out great
@@kolgerrard1964 How about you prove it? No? Didn't think so. Begone.
both sound amazing but piet did do a very good job off of dimash's song. He'd be proud.
@@DJ82611
This is not a Dimash song, LOL - Dimash just covered it. Daniel Balavoine wrote the song originally
@@augustjoseph629 yes but Dimash did this song more popular because of his cover and kind of people think that it's his song sadly
he has a team of sound engineers and scientist in the booth working harder than him trying to sing.... he is not even a singer he is a book keeper
He has nothing, he is a poor guy from Austria...who mostly records in his house.
Y’all are doing too much the man sounds good he doesn’t have to be better than dimash.
“A book keeper”? Aren’t you clever, how long did it take you to make that up?
Just out of this World!.....
muito bacana a maneira através da qual vc reagiu a esse verdadeiro fenÔmeno lírico!!!uma mistura de surpresa a cada nota,uma sensação que não dá explicar!!!
I've watched his video over many times, and really think his whistle register is genuine. As he hits those two incredible notes, you can see his shoulders more back as he releases his body from the notes. Is he by chance the ninth wonder of the world? I think so :)
yes Clare i am with you 100% 🥰
"Vocal Coach reacts to autotune computer program singing SOS (feat. Piet Arion)"
You killed me with that comment man !! Jesus Christ , have some mercy on the poor man and his fans LOL .
bloke i can hit that note in my sleep
@@kolgerrard1964 ))))
Vocal coach discovers Meldoyne
Oh, poor you. Someone sang it better than your idol, no? Hot higher notes twice, no? And all you could do is declare the performance enhanced. You lot are so predictable and moronic, it's entertaining.
Hello dear distinction beautifull teacher!iam cristina from romania and iam sad to see so much lack òf ĺove insome oppiñions!piet is ă ďivne artist andmy treasure i donot need operistic show but a nătural voice sò tendèr anď uñique strange personalîty!angel figure voice and all he has fròm ģod!i love hîm a lot!
Its me agaiñwith my poor english!idid see some videoaudio with piet and indeed he was not likè in the studio!maybe he has not courage or is afraid on the ștage!but his big artistic talent is the same unique!really i do not lyke rock and ihope he will return to his angelic styĺè!kisses!
Omg guys I am a fan of Dimash but don’t compare,if it is auto tune or not who cares it’s just a reaction
His the long & winding road next for your take will be great
Beautifull
I prefer Dimash's range, strength in his notes. Let the other guy sing live first before I can rate him.
Agreed.
@@TheVoiceLoveCo As for me, I want to sing low like Geoff in Voiceplay's Oogie Boogie song.
@@Perktube1 Me too and I'm a girl😆
Thank you love for your description . Definitely on point . My most beautiful but a simple and little comparison from Piet to Dimash , is i love them both but am an operatic power enthusiast but Piet singing sos and oh holy night is just Perfection of course the vocal modulationship . But most important comparison is his diction and pronunciation is butter. Hence his ability to portray colour and texture. Topping off all over everything else is his annunciation. I don't speak French but yes felt lyrics but had a more understanding of it without translation. Is it a sad song or happy love or not. Life or death. I think all the above but his perspective made feel moved and made feel like my spirit hovering among the mountains . Xx
Рiet Arion автотюн
Piet is not trained. All you are seeing is raw talent. I recall reading somewhere that he said being professionally and/or classically trained was a financial impossibility for him. I'd love for someone to recognize this young man for the talent he truly is and invest in him and allow him to discover the power and capability of his instrument.
I like ur explain it but i prefer dimash coz he sing live
yes, he is not singing live and he is lip syncing his pre-recorded version but people here keep ignoring the fact that live performances are using a lot of filters as well. this kid has talent and he can whistle that's for sure.
There is no comparison though. He couldnt reproduce half of this live, doesnt matter what filters and mic effects you give him. The whole whistle sequence is autotuned, he would be all over the place live.
Obviously this guy is gifted with a big range and if anything he has great sound editing skills, but the attempts to pretend this isnt a "studio only" feat are simply silly.
I love it ❤ ❤Beautiful 🎉voice ❤❤
The only reason Piet says he likes and says he is a fan , is so all Dimash Dears well watch him ,And he has the nerve to ask you to give him paypal money.If he is that good why don't he sing live on stage .If he is that good a singer i am sure people would pay to go and see him. But he can't sing live . I am not saying he can't sing .But not in the same class .So do not put His name in the same sentence as Dimash's name . And when you ask why don't Piet sing live Piet trolls become rude and troll you .
According to his former "manager" (who he cheated out of money), he's lying when he says he's a fan of Dimash. In reality he calls Dimash nasty names and mocks him.
@@Snarky_Tart you're right, and he really wanted to surpass Dimash in this one.
@@Jane.S600 surpass Dimash !! With digital pitch shifting & auto tune !!! What a clown .
This actually has shown me that his weaker registers are produced.
How do these guys say he is better than Dimash or any male singer? Beats me.
Btw I also read through the allegations.
@@user-rm4fu3sc2h Please don't bother with these clowns ,, we all know what Dimash can do without digital enhancements or studio editing or music or even a fucking microphone. And we saw and heard industry legends & hall of fame members & best selling artists & Grammy award winning songwriters & world class famous composers & the prisedent of the Chinese pop musicians association & the director of the Astana Opera state theater & the great Andrea Bocelli , all give him high praise and compliments . Add to that more than 20 vocal coaches from all corners of the world analyzing his performances and all of them gave him the highest praise I ever saw a singer get from them . This Piet guy is nothing but an amateur like Marcelito Pomoy not worth anything but some local fans singing their praise . He is even worse than Marcelito because Marcelito at least sings on talent shows and small local stages acting like a parrot good for nothing but imitating other singers but this dude is worse because he hides behind his sound engineer and studio editing trying to reach a level light years higher than his actuall talent would get him .
Something is not right about your recent reactions. You gave the impression that Dimash's D8 note in "Unforgettable Day" was microphone feedback. But you praise a completely manufactured performance here. You are one of, if not the most pleasant reactor on You Tube. But I have little or no confidence in your analysis of what you are reacting to.
Thanks for your feedback. I will try to do better in the future.
Have some respect. She's a vocal coach and well qualified to speak about the subject at hand
Dimash is just one more cover of this song.
This french song was first sung for Grégory nd his unique charme.
There are many covers. Enjoy them . Don”t mix them
Piet’s arrangement is gorgeous! ❤
@The Voice Love Co.
Wow, I'm native French, and Piet nails the difficult pronunciation. Very impressive!
The lyricist for this song is from my hometown: Luc Plamondon. He has written so many poignant songs. Even for global superstar Québécois star Céline Dion! I'm so proud to hear English speakers being inspired by this 70's French-Québécois musical "'Starmania" set in an Orwellian decadent society where this character "Johnny Rockfort" is gasping for the air of freedom. It is, thus, the S.O.S from an earthling in distress. Original singer is Daniel Balavoine, a very talented singer too, sadly deceased. You may want to check another song by him "Tous les cris les S.O.S". (Coincidental S.O.S. LOL)
Music is truly a language that knows no borders! Thank you for considering music outside the the English-American cultural sphere. Thank you. Merci beaucoup! :D
So cool to read a comment like this. Thank you so much for your contribution.
have you ever listened to the original singer sing this song? just curious
Only .... Woooow wooooooow wooooooooooow
You’re such a lovely lady pours out of you & your analysis succinct thank you
Thank you for your graceful reaction Christi. A lot of hate going around in the comments. I must admit I am a bit skeptical of this as well as he was, literally, in the dark (what's he hiding?)! Also his head/neck position while executing some of those notes... Like you, I will reserve my biases until I've researched him more in detail. Blessings!!
Hi, Kelvin! Yes, I had no idea the can of worms I would be opening. I appreciate you taking the time to comment. Peace.
@@TheVoiceLoveCo I feel bad for you, if I'd known...I would have warned you of the venom, it's very real.
Dimash fans, can be very ugly...unless you are touting their beloved.
@@Practicerecordings O do be quite .There is no Venom here ,so don't act like holy then thou . People have a right to comment .That is why this video is called a reaction and has a comment section .
@@mollyb4332 Who the hell has the audacity to tell someone to be quiet(quite?), while simultaneously saying people have the right to comment?
...oh, that's right, Ruh Sky, contradicting, hypocrite extraordinaire.
Sheesh, people like you...are why people like me, are misanthropic. >.
Thank you for helping us appreciate
Internet users must understand and know that the dimash version or any other are only revisited versions. The original version comes from a French singer from the 70s/80s
One important difference is that Piet Arion is pronouncing perfect French. Dimash is a prodigy but the language barrier is making him develop his career in oriental Asia, in countries like China and, of course, Kazakhstan.
Piet has an incredible range. Pretty impresive, though it is very difficult to make these ultra-high notes work in song in a way the final sound is coherent.
Can you please untag Dimash? This has nothing to do with him.
Oh and there are much better covers around than the horrifying mess that is this over-produced song.
100% agree with you , Caleb Coles & Emo Pelligrino along with other singers made good Dimash covers unlike this mess .
His name has been removed. Thank you for letting me know. I truly had no idea using the original title from the video (like I always do) would produce this much emotion. My sincerest apologies.
@@TheVoiceLoveCo Thank you so much.
I think peeps are a bit sensitive towards this cover because it got a lot of attention but is so heavily produced, compared to other covers that didn't but are these singers' actual voices. I highly recommend Caleb Coles' version of this song because not only is it his voice but he made an English version and adapted the song for his own voice which cannot go as high as Dimash's. It is brilliant but alas didn't garner half the attention that this produced fakery did.
@@subidubiduda5293 When you prove the cover is heavily produced then you should make your litigious statements. And also, Dimash's performance is a cover of an existing song written 20+ years ago for a French singer. It never was a Dimash original. It's embarrasing posting gnorant, slanderous moronisms like yours, but I suspect you lot are simply incapable of feeling embarrasment.
@@AA-lu5gp Почему бы Вам не ответить на комментарий JasminGardenia, который является более аргументированным? И с чего Вы взяли, что кто-то утверждает, что песня СОС Димаша является оригинальной? Всем прекрасно известно, что это кавер. Вы высасываете из пальца повод для гнева.
//////////
Why don't you respond to JasminGardenia's comment, which is more reasoned? And what makes You think that someone claims that SOS of Dimash is original? Everyone knows that this is a cover. You suck the anger out of your finger
Too bad nobody talks about the original performance from Daniel Balavoine .A great singer with beautiful songs.rip.
Wait till he hit's the B7 note ! Will you think he did it or was it electronics ?
As a Dear, I think Piets version is so unique and BEAUTIFUL... His voice is just perfect for this song
I am finding the comments fascinating. Especially those from those who for some reason seem unable or unwilling to let in the multiple times through this reaction when you'd said that you were not sure what you were really seeing or hearing, including how much of that is live and/or processed, and how interesting it would be to hear him sing this 'live', etc. I don't think I'd ever heard you say it quite so many times in one video, which should be saying a lot about what you are picking up on. It is the first time for me to hear him perform and it is unmistakable that there's talent here. That he is not Dimash is unmistakable, too. But that is okay. He is himself, with his style, be it 'live' or not. He's an artist. A performer. Like you, I WOULD be interested in hearing him sing live, yes, but it is still an interesting performance. I'm not sure why people are offended by the tagging of Dimash (I believe it is a copy from Piet's own title), even though it is very much a 'Dimash style' cover. Perhaps there can be an amending of the title to 'in the style of', but the level of reactivity is interesting to see. Can we accept that people are unique, and one person's talent (with or without auto tune or other means and however they create their performance) does not detract from another person's obvious talent. Is it all a competition? To me this is an interesting exposition on Dimash's cover of that song, which does not take away from Dimash's mastery. FWIW, parts of it indeed did not all feel natural to me, and I wonder how much here is a marriage of human voice and machine processing ... with some notes being almost certainly machine manipulated. Still, the composition remains interesting to listen to and there's plenty of talent there. Of course, people don't have to agree with me. Thank you for the reaction, Christi. Clearly some covers bring up strong emotions in fans ... and are still worthy of listening to IMO.
See the problem is that one of his former friends ( and manager as well ) told people he hates Dimash with passion but on his channel he says Dimash is his idol !!!
Also , it's not just auto tune in some parts , what's more dangerous is digital pitch shifting which someone like Vitas has been using for Moe than a decade . Some vocalists online said there's at least an octave shift up in this arrangement . Meaning if I was singing B6 it will be shifted to B7 .
At last , it's ridiculous to do a cover for one the most difficult French songs and after one of the best ( if not the best vocal technicians on the planet ) elevated it to a higher level , with the intention of doing the song justice and making your idol proud , but you choose to hide yourself behind digital enhancements and pitch shifting while some singers like the Indonesian girl ( I think her name is Lamar ) was invited by Dimash himself to sing with him on a grand stage in front of a huge crowd & he congratulated Leo Cantro ( a small youtuber and an amateur singer ) for doing covers of his songs . Also people like Caleb Coles & Emi Pelligrino made excellent covers and Caleb did the 22 seconds note with runs and riffs from Sinful Passion as best as he could just to show people that if he did it then Dimash surely did it .
People are unique. And the people that are giving their opinion are worthy too. It's funny how your opinion rises above the rest. Whether by design or by accident, this video reaction is "pulling" in Dimash fans. His name is in the TITLE. But you can't understand how this may be a problem with Dimash fans? Or why Dimash fans (you know, the ones that were practically LURED here by the title) might be upset that a "Vocal Coach" is giving kudos to a manufactured performance. You are either VERY good natured, or easily fooled.
@@donny1960 Oh, that's easy. I'm VERY good natured. :) As for others' opinions, I'd be curious to know where you understood me to say others' views were not worthy, or why you think my opinion rises above the rest. Have a lovely rest of the weekend!
@@kolgerrard1964 I don't know him or his manager so I cannot speak for either of their opinions of Dimash (who, by the way, is an amazing singer, as we all know). I think that looking up to someone doesn't need to mean idolizing them in all matters or hating them (or envying them or aspiring to be like them) in all matters. People are so much more complicated than that, IMO.
People may do covers for all kinds of reasons and use all kinds of means as artistic measures. I'm not sure it ought to be a competition or be seen as being permitted only to those who use no auto-tune/mixing/pitch-shifting.
Granted, I like natural voices the best, but I also know many singers use technical processing to enhance/dampen/filter/whatever, especially in recordings. Why is that offensive? Like I said, this is my first time listening to him, so I don't know him. Did he ever claim to use no auto-tune etc.?
BTW, I'm not sure I understand what is "dangerous" in using digital pitch shifting. I'm not aware that it is harmful.
Oh my! I've been in a voice conference online all day and only just got on to check the comments. I've removed Dimash's name. (Yes, that was a copy from the original title, which is what I usually do.) I had NO IDEA there was this much emotion going on around this performer. Wowza!
Don't you just love this version yet love Dimashes version too. Both are excellent 👍🏼 love Your review!
Приветсвтую. Кто по Вашему мнению(для Вас)лучше,душевнее исполнил эту замечательную песню? Спасибо за ответ.
Неужели учитель по вокалу не слышит автотюн.
Because there likely isn't any. Oh, and there could well be autotune when singing live, you moron.
È così al di fuori della voce umana, che mi sembra impossibile. Vorrei vederlo cantare dal vivo, come fa Dimash. Comunque mi chiedo dove dovrà spingersi un cantante per attirare l'attenzione, in un mondo così pieno di grandi talenti.
he is one of the best what i ever hear from S.O.S.
How did I miss you did this?
Piet has never really sung live, but if you want to know what he sounds like without much editing listen to his older songs. His songs from 6 to 10 years ago are MUCH less edited than his newer stuff.
I mean he has but still, the man can sing. Plus in this song the only auto tune present (could be him just being good with mic) is the echos so its not auto tune. Dunno why people think it is. Its really annoying when people don't use their brains.
Dimash uses reverb quite a bit in his live versions of SOS !
He can sing so amazing without it but there is no doubt he has an engineer
Camputers sings sooo well , woow 💖
Your insecurities are showing.
Hol up whats a camputer did you mean like computer bec of outotune? I mean he could have but hey! You have to hit a close note to autotune it😌.
Nicola Sedda: *laughs*
@@jonathanmartinez6012 why? Isit like he auto tunes more or sth? Idgi
Dumbasses the only auto tune present is the echos. Hell you can argue he isnt using it at all. He could be very good with making the mic echo. He also sang live so stfu it's auto tune bc its not. You can go look at his old vids and though it doesn't sound as good, he can still hit very high notes.
He is like Russian singer VITAS.
Singing in live performance can not compare with singing in the studio or in a room
Curious to your thoughts on Giulia Falcone's take on this piece. I was not aware of the song until I heard her version. Not being a trained vocalist I'd like to think she is 'real' -- but similar to your reaction on the whistle tones by Piet Arion, some of her songs just seem 'too good'. Almost all of her posts from a video perspective are pretty simple without much effect, but the sound seems quite produced.
ruclips.net/video/fyMkoB29INQ/видео.html
If he sounds this good in the studio and has the vocal range he has, I'm sure he would be better live than 90% of modern pop stars.
The only thing that I don't like (from the perspective of a classically-trained vocalist) is that his voice in the lower register sounds like a different person from the upper registers. For those who are not trained singers, an element to classical singing training is that one's voice in all registers should sound like the same person singing. Now, you might think that a singer may do this to sound unique, but the reality is that it isn't unique. It's far more difficult to sound like the same singer through all registers of one's voice.
Ok, let me then come back and say that Piet Arion is supremely gifted and talented. My critique was from a technical standpoint and not in any way saying that he is not one of the most gifted singers on the planet. What I am pointing out has more to do with training style and nothing to do with talent. Actually, I really believe that right after recording this version, he could record a version where his voice does sound like the same singer through all registers. I think it is a stylistic choice to not sing in this way. It's actually a popular introduction to modern pop music.
Thank you very much for your interesting and detailed reaction.!
Desde costa rica el tiene mas canciones y muy buenas buscalas
Really puzzled by your comments "what am I really seeing," as if he was faking or using digital tricks to sing the song. Refrain from such snide comments and just critique his vocal range, intimate relationship to the listeners, and unbelievably high whistle tones, higher than Dimash, he produces. He deserves no less from vocal coaches.
It's very hard to sing 2 hours 20 minutes concert on the stage as Dimash
I love him and his voice but when he hits that whistle note it hits different
Hopefully he discovers something he is good at.
Dimash did a similar off-the-piano dolphin note at the "Unforgettable day" at Gakku.
If you want to hear someone sing Dimash's songs incredibly well, check out Eset Alzhan.
All fake and digitised he has never sung before. Surely you can tell its so heavily edited and enhanced.