That’s a cautionary tale for two things “never bite the hand that feeds you” meaning Gabriel was literally the anchor for Elise and with out him her world fell apart. The other thing is “appreciate what you have before it becomes what you had” meaning Gabriel was the only guy that treated her right yet she treated him like crap but ended up regretting finding out that it was his kidney that was given to her not his brother’s
there is also a lesson of not keeping secrets, like for real, how can she even reach that conclusion and how can he keep it from her? In her mind he did nothing since obviously she attributed it to his brother.
Karma is a bitch or so they say, which in this context it's true. The only good point about Elise is that at the end she truly realise how good was Gabriel toward her but accepted that he deserve better than her which is commendable
Yeah. At least at the end, she got a character development. She admit her mistake, let go of MC, and wish him happiness. She even admit that MC’s loved for her in the past timeline will not be toped by anyone, realizing that she didn’t know what she have until she lost it.
While in a vacuum this is good enough for a revenge story, I wish it was deeper. The only takeaway from the regression was to not be a simp. More plot twists would've been great. Would've loved a sort of redemption arc around Elise where she resolves to be a better person to Gabriel after realizing how good she had it. Regressed and finds out he regressed too and staying the hell away from her and then focusing the story on her changing and becoming a better person and both of them finding love amidst all that hardship and previous betraya. But alas. AI stories still have their limitations.
24:20 "Misunderstanding" Dude, you kept what you did a secret and let her think for 15 years that your brother gave away his kidney. I swear the secrets people keep to stay humble is what ruins too many marriages.
I'm sorry but that shouldn't make a difference. People are allowed to do things for the ones they love just because they love them not for any reward. If she loved him the same the rest makes no difference. She didn't need to know, just be grateful. If she really wanted to repay just live your life well. If she truly loved him she wouldn't have been ambiguous with her feelings.
@@TeresaRosser-ov8zd you do realize that actions affect perception of people and that it also affects emotions? She had been feeling guilty thinking that he died because of the kidney donation, which combined with her feelings amplified them which can cause resentment to fester. secondly keeping secrets and expecting a reward are two very different things, and them being married is icing on the top since he kept his medical record hidden from her
@@TeresaRosser-ov8zd oh no, I agree she was shellfish and an awful person, still I think he has a small part of the blame for her treatment since he kept thing hidden from her while marrying her. He was a simp/enabler for her.
Finally a story without a vicious ending the ex gets to live and build a new life knowing how to appreciate life and hopefully not make the same mistakes
Elise wasted her 2nd life chasing and trying to regain what was once hers. She should have invested time looking for a kidney replacement instead of betting on David to give her the kidney on his death day. I could understand Gab having a 2nd life, but why was Elise also given a 2nd life?
Gotta love return to the past couples edition. Great story, interesting progress, the evil FL was a lame villain, but other than that a story worth listening. Will be watching it again.
Homeboy should have filed a restraining order on that scrub: Elise. Still going full Chad mode and breaking her ego down with no uncertain direct confrontation when approached is extremely satisfying.
Its the mc fault in the first place not telling everything to her... and also the girl has a problem ignoring her own husband for someone she really likes
@@hellfiremain9204but bro misunderstanding is a different problem and not loving/ caring is different thing but she literally said she loves his brother to him who is about to die i mean what audacity
she assumed it was the brother and had a medical chart with one kidney. even if he did, she would assume he was lying. besides he probably thought she knew it was from him and just didn't appreciate it and never brought it up until he was about to die. I'd say it's on her for not mentioning it and communicating until his deathbed.
I just love how she describe everything around 25:15 .... I mean girl... What you want is a Nanny/Butler not a husband. Get lost. Edit : coming back after finishing, even at the end it's still the same, it's about HER, how SHE is treated, although MC always tried to avoid her and cut short any convo she never even tried to apologize for how she and her parents treated him for all those years... Aside from that, i wished we had a tiny pov from her at thr end, like why she was so cruel on MC's death bed or why she treated him like that etc(I mean, ok she loved the brother because of a misunderstanding, whatever, but even if she doesn't love MC is that a reason to treat him badly? Not like he killed his bro...)
At the start he says that the brother gave the kidney and a few sentences later he said it was his. Also what was the reason of his death, and is it something avoidable or will he die in a few years.
the wife thought it was the brother, but it was his kidney. he died from kidney failure after donating his kidney to her. as he didn't do it in the new timeline he will not die from it. you're welcome
While the story is nice, but it makes you wonder, without rebirth, how would you be smart So, what's the lesson really... Is it don't be a simp Is it investigate the beloved
These stories are always uncomfortable. On the one 6 understand not wanting to travel down the same road, but on the other hand, pushing the blame on a person that has turn into that person yet seems kind of weird.
It’s because of trauma. Even if the other one isn’t doing anything wrong on the second timeline, the MC was scared of what that person did on him/her in the past timeline. That’s why there are many readers who hate the controversial novel and manhwa named “The Abandoned Empress”.
@thelonewolf3582 I get you point the issue is often or rather the question is towards the direction of the narrative in most cases. Having a situation where the mc change and levels up doesn't directly mean that the old girlfriend has to become broken. There is the potential for a peaceful route for everyone involved. Don't get me wrong in some of the stories. The transition is when both characters have already gone down the path to tragedy and having the mc return moment before their last chance is different. For example, the one where the childhood friend is in love with a troubled person leading to the mc's death. In that case, nothing will the friends future I talking about ones where the relationship hasn't even started until later in life. In these cases, ideally, everyone could end up happily.
@emeralh9415 In this case, yes, but in some of the stories, I can understand the former love interest being frustrated. There are situations and misunderstandings that have yet to take place but are still held against them. Additionally, in some stories, the Mc could change the outcome or prevent certain situations, but either let's them happen or simply get angry despite knowing the outcome. I'm not sure if you have seen the movie minority report, but it is the situation presented in that movie.
@@sashwing7726 The issue is that the person generally trays the MC TRULY HORRIBLY. While it’s true that they have not yet done those things, that’s not going to make the MC magically forget their trauma and not hold against them to at least some degree. They don’t want to be nice to them or help them because they are disgusted by what they went through, by what that person showed they were capable of. So they just want nothing to do with them. Which is their right.
Gabe's brother didn't give her kidney but elise thought he did because she saw his medical reports, where it was mentioned he only had one before he died, after she got kidney..........i don't know how to discribe it but it seems she thought it's some tragic love story where the guy saved the girl he liked by donating his organ, she didn't bother to check if her husband had two kidneys or not , i mean if she can thought that a fairy cleaned all her clothes and trash just disappeared magically what can you expect.....she was living in her own tragic love story life........only after MC's death doctor told her the reason of MC's death but she still was doubtfull and it got cleared in 2nd lifetime
25:16 blud explaining that she's lost a house assistant, not husband. 🤣
That’s a cautionary tale for two things “never bite the hand that feeds you” meaning Gabriel was literally the anchor for Elise and with out him her world fell apart. The other thing is “appreciate what you have before it becomes what you had” meaning Gabriel was the only guy that treated her right yet she treated him like crap but ended up regretting finding out that it was his kidney that was given to her not his brother’s
My motto: don’t chase two rabbits bc you won’t catch either
there is also a lesson of not keeping secrets, like for real, how can she even reach that conclusion and how can he keep it from her? In her mind he did nothing since obviously she attributed it to his brother.
Karma is a bitch or so they say, which in this context it's true. The only good point about Elise is that at the end she truly realise how good was Gabriel toward her but accepted that he deserve better than her which is commendable
Yeah, but then again, that was about her, like you said she realized only him would treat her like that, but not how she herself could treat him
Yeah. At least at the end, she got a character development. She admit her mistake, let go of MC, and wish him happiness. She even admit that MC’s loved for her in the past timeline will not be toped by anyone, realizing that she didn’t know what she have until she lost it.
What she really wanted is that kidney to live
Loved it❤ and it's great that the brothers have a good relationship as well ❤
A tricycle? He was almost murked by a tricycle?
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
funny innit😂
Likely a mistranslation for three wheeled motorcycle.
Those tricycles are deadly, mate lmao
Truck kun is too tired on his isekai delivery job that he needed a break so he called Tricycle kun for temporary substitution.
While in a vacuum this is good enough for a revenge story, I wish it was deeper. The only takeaway from the regression was to not be a simp. More plot twists would've been great. Would've loved a sort of redemption arc around Elise where she resolves to be a better person to Gabriel after realizing how good she had it. Regressed and finds out he regressed too and staying the hell away from her and then focusing the story on her changing and becoming a better person and both of them finding love amidst all that hardship and previous betraya. But alas. AI stories still have their limitations.
24:20
"Misunderstanding"
Dude, you kept what you did a secret and let her think for 15 years that your brother gave away his kidney.
I swear the secrets people keep to stay humble is what ruins too many marriages.
I'm sorry but that shouldn't make a difference. People are allowed to do things for the ones they love just because they love them not for any reward. If she loved him the same the rest makes no difference. She didn't need to know, just be grateful. If she really wanted to repay just live your life well. If she truly loved him she wouldn't have been ambiguous with her feelings.
True lies and secrets will only lead to misunderstandings
@@TeresaRosser-ov8zd you do realize that actions affect perception of people and that it also affects emotions? She had been feeling guilty thinking that he died because of the kidney donation, which combined with her feelings amplified them which can cause resentment to fester.
secondly keeping secrets and expecting a reward are two very different things, and them being married is icing on the top since he kept his medical record hidden from her
@@smokyHR let's just agree to disagree. I found her selfish. Period
@@TeresaRosser-ov8zd oh no, I agree she was shellfish and an awful person, still I think he has a small part of the blame for her treatment since he kept thing hidden from her while marrying her. He was a simp/enabler for her.
Finally a story without a vicious ending the ex gets to live and build a new life knowing how to appreciate life and hopefully not make the same mistakes
Elise wasted her 2nd life chasing and trying to regain what was once hers. She should have invested time looking for a kidney replacement instead of betting on David to give her the kidney on his death day. I could understand Gab having a 2nd life, but why was Elise also given a 2nd life?
She was given a 2nd life so she could suffer. So she could watch slowly how every good thing she had faded away
Gotta love return to the past couples edition. Great story, interesting progress, the evil FL was a lame villain, but other than that a story worth listening. Will be watching it again.
Homeboy should have filed a restraining order on that scrub: Elise. Still going full Chad mode and breaking her ego down with no uncertain direct confrontation when approached is extremely satisfying.
Which adult thinks their clothes magically get cleaned and folded into their cabinets? 😂😂😂
In this multiverse their fate still intertwine
I think it's elies canon event
Its the mc fault in the first place not telling everything to her... and also the girl has a problem ignoring her own husband for someone she really likes
Even if MC did tell her, would she have believed him right away??
@Dante999000 you have a point
@@hellfiremain9204but bro misunderstanding is a different problem and not loving/ caring is different thing but she literally said she loves his brother to him who is about to die i mean what audacity
she assumed it was the brother and had a medical chart with one kidney. even if he did, she would assume he was lying. besides he probably thought she knew it was from him and just didn't appreciate it and never brought it up until he was about to die. I'd say it's on her for not mentioning it and communicating until his deathbed.
@RageKage987 yeah.. what a plot
I just love how she describe everything around 25:15 .... I mean girl... What you want is a Nanny/Butler not a husband. Get lost.
Edit : coming back after finishing, even at the end it's still the same, it's about HER, how SHE is treated, although MC always tried to avoid her and cut short any convo she never even tried to apologize for how she and her parents treated him for all those years...
Aside from that, i wished we had a tiny pov from her at thr end, like why she was so cruel on MC's death bed or why she treated him like that etc(I mean, ok she loved the brother because of a misunderstanding, whatever, but even if she doesn't love MC is that a reason to treat him badly? Not like he killed his bro...)
How would she not see the damn scar from the surgery? What is it with these couples living in separate rooms as well?
y the heck are you even outside? you should've waited until an hour after the accident's time to let your gaurd down🤦
What a happy ending 😢😢❤🎉
At the start he says that the brother gave the kidney and a few sentences later he said it was his. Also what was the reason of his death, and is it something avoidable or will he die in a few years.
the wife thought it was the brother, but it was his kidney. he died from kidney failure after donating his kidney to her. as he didn't do it in the new timeline he will not die from it. you're welcome
Karma is a bitch!!
The best revenge ever❤
While the story is nice, but it makes you wonder, without rebirth, how would you be smart
So, what's the lesson really...
Is it don't be a simp
Is it investigate the beloved
True, but still simps do exist
agree, it makes me wonder personally how will we learn our lesson if we die from a mistake.
These stories are always uncomfortable. On the one 6 understand not wanting to travel down the same road, but on the other hand, pushing the blame on a person that has turn into that person yet seems kind of weird.
In some of those reborn stories yeah, but here since she also came back she's exactly that same person who even tormented him on his death bed...
It’s because of trauma. Even if the other one isn’t doing anything wrong on the second timeline, the MC was scared of what that person did on him/her in the past timeline. That’s why there are many readers who hate the controversial novel and manhwa named “The Abandoned Empress”.
@thelonewolf3582 I get you point the issue is often or rather the question is towards the direction of the narrative in most cases. Having a situation where the mc change and levels up doesn't directly mean that the old girlfriend has to become broken. There is the potential for a peaceful route for everyone involved. Don't get me wrong in some of the stories. The transition is when both characters have already gone down the path to tragedy and having the mc return moment before their last chance is different. For example, the one where the childhood friend is in love with a troubled person leading to the mc's death. In that case, nothing will the friends future I talking about ones where the relationship hasn't even started until later in life. In these cases, ideally, everyone could end up happily.
@emeralh9415 In this case, yes, but in some of the stories, I can understand the former love interest being frustrated. There are situations and misunderstandings that have yet to take place but are still held against them. Additionally, in some stories, the Mc could change the outcome or prevent certain situations, but either let's them happen or simply get angry despite knowing the outcome. I'm not sure if you have seen the movie minority report, but it is the situation presented in that movie.
@@sashwing7726 The issue is that the person generally trays the MC TRULY HORRIBLY. While it’s true that they have not yet done those things, that’s not going to make the MC magically forget their trauma and not hold against them to at least some degree. They don’t want to be nice to them or help them because they are disgusted by what they went through, by what that person showed they were capable of. So they just want nothing to do with them. Which is their right.
What’s the name of this manga?
Women can be scandalous frfr
Mom for the win 29:04
Novel name??
16:20 wow the cops was a judge all allong
At one point, mc brother gave the wife the kidney then later mc says i won't give you a kidney this time 🤔
Gabe's brother didn't give her kidney but elise thought he did because she saw his medical reports, where it was mentioned he only had one before he died, after she got kidney..........i don't know how to discribe it but it seems she thought it's some tragic love story where the guy saved the girl he liked by donating his organ, she didn't bother to check if her husband had two kidneys or not , i mean if she can thought that a fairy cleaned all her clothes and trash just disappeared magically what can you expect.....she was living in her own tragic love story life........only after MC's death doctor told her the reason of MC's death but she still was doubtfull and it got cleared in 2nd lifetime
W mother
The pictures all dude, I thought Emily is tomboy girl wearing boy uniform 😂😂
Edit: Ah finally, girl pics 😂
Elise is the perfect representative of feminism.😂😂
at-least u can help her to get a kidney
Kidney matching is hard
A Tricycle……
Soooo you guys are already reusing old story plots now huh lol
What are you saying he was born with no magic but will be come the strongest!? ;P
P
E
N
I
2025😮😢