Enjoy these types of videos? Please give it a like Support this channel: www.patreon.com/eternalised RUclips Member Perks: ruclips.net/channel/UCqos1tl0RntucGGtPXNxkkAjoin Donate a Coffee: ko-fi.com/eternalised Official Merch: eternalised.creator-spring.com
11:00 - I like how you touched on the repetitiveness of human life. Looking back on my atheistic journey, one of the first things I threw out was the belief that scheduling and planning your life down to the minute was fruitful. I've always had insomnia (specifically, it took me maybe 1-2hrs of lying in bed to actually fall asleep, and if anything disturbed it and awoke me, it was impossible to fall back in again, so I never slept more than 3-4 hrs). Eventually, I decided that if I wish to place meaning in a meaningless schedule, the only one that matters is my own. 12 years later, I'm a self-employed farmer and programmer. Best of all when I sleep, I actually dream. Took a while to realize that what prevented me from sleep was the anxiety associated with trying to fit into a box I didn't want to be in, and the simple solution was... don't.
Dear stranger, I find inspiration in your story. Just out of curiosity for all things tech related, what does your job as a programmer entail, and how did you gather the necessary knowledge and experience?
Camus must be the one of the most important philosopher if not the most important, at least in my life. Everyone should read the myth of Sisyphus once in their lives. The idea of realizing that life is meaningless is easy and natural, but the resolve to live against it and not commit suicide or die a philosophical death is what makes his thoughts really a masterpiece. He was a genius of man made by his circumstances, and if you're reading this do yourself a favor and read his works, trust me. As for me, I've done my work here. Great video, salute my friend. I really wanted to know the history of this spectacular mind and you cleared it all and also related him to his books. And for that I thank you.
Life being meaningless or meaningful is a human mental construct…Camus’s quest for freedom is the freedom from his mind which was shackled ironically by his mental brilliance…Camus is over rated Let’s stop discussing whether something has meaning or not, both meaning and meaninglessness are quests to find meaning…meaning in meaningless and meaning in meaningfulness Real freedom lies in liberating oneself from the mind and creating, producing, doing, being, rather than the inertia of thinking about it. You are, whether you think about it or not
I have read many books on science, fiction, politics, philosophy and history. But when a drop of existentialism damped on my tongue! It amazed me with an unknown pain, the pain just tore me into pieces. And it all starts when I read "The Fall", a book by Albert Camus. After getting much deeper into Camus's books, I suddenly met with a change. I don't know why all my tears were converted into well-known laughs. I just want to share only a quote by Albert Camus “At a certain level of suffering or injustice, no one can do anything for anyone. Pain is solitary.”
We studied fragments from The Fall in our French pragmatics class and they were so intriguing. I read The Stranger, but it wasn't as good as I expected. Hopefully, after reading his other works, my view on him will change. I really liked his ideas, though, and we're both fans of Dostoevsky, so maybe, we'll become firends soemday. He seems to be a cool guy! Great video!
I am also listening to "The plague" and his thoughts are intriguing and I find him fascinating.. Will sure explore him more! Thanks for this cool Intro though!✨
Always felt so curious about Camus but haven't read anything yet. After watching this I reckon I will read ''The fall''. Super interesting video!! Thank you for sharing
3:09 Write all of those immoralities in a book and release it. And act like the others and adapt to them so they will notice you are a stranger 7:41 10:00 Working the same job everyday
Would really recommend reading the original french translation for l’Étranger if you can read french. The intricacy of meursault’s character and of Camus’ writing is lost in translation, so you can only really go skin deep into the philosophy of the novel when it’s written in English. Still a good book to read nonetheless, one of my favourites regardless of the language it’s written in.
One of my friends read that and he says he is like mersault. He says he'll be however he wants and the world shouldn't bother him or ask him why he is like that. Some people are just straight up shooting the book to their ego. They think being an emotionally distant prick is some ideal. Being like that is different from aspiring to be that.
Very interesting! I'm looking into Camus for the first time. I too feel that life is absurd and meaningless. But I cannot believe in the Absurd Hero or a Happy Sisyphus, I think that in order to be happy the individual must perform an act of self delusion which is on a par with religious faith or optimism. That is not something I would be willing to do. Fleeting moments of contentment are fine as long as we recognise them as such, I enjoy such moments myself, but I never lose sight of the fact that life is a meaningless horror.
Camus hated driving or being driven... He had a fear of dying in something as absurd as a car crash. After the car accident- two train tickets Camus was supposed to have used by himself and his wife were found in his pocket.
All great deeds and All great thoughts Have a ridiculous beginning. A journey of 10000 miles Begins with 1 single step. The first step is das hardest: How to remember de Miao Dao in my head And to express it with my hands ?
I had an Algerian friend who immediately decided that Camus must be a racist. in law, a good lawyer could make a case for self-defence, regardless of what Meursault himself says.
The question of the meaning of life or whether life is worth living is born of human arrogance. We assume our intellect should afford us some great station in the universe. To be able to question everything is our greatest attribute but we must balance it with the act of living each day.
In college I of course was intoduced to Camus and Kafka. I hated both passionately. In class I found myself hostile. I was in expensive college… I was paying big bucks for this Camus crap? I was not interested in any kind of personal enfranchisement. As a handicapped person I already learned from parents , others I ain’t nothing. I had gotten used to this feedback where ever I went. What was I to do? Cast aside years of acquiescence to my situation and find a new existence, a new self? Oh BS! All folks had to do was look at me to completely demolish any smart ass idea about myself in the universe. Screw that crap. I know the profs would say I had already found myself as living a life if she!!t. I had already adapted Camus without realizing it and proved Camus wise. I am not impressed.
Loving absurdity and accepting absurdity of life is another form of philosophical suicide like religion. Rebellion is only answer to the absurd even if it means tearing everything down.
Just like Sysiphus, I perform acts of meaninglessness and futility every day of my life. Life has no meaning, but, ironically, that is the meaning. Revolt against the absurdity!
Camus's denial of the Algerians' right for independence is a colonial stand..... The unsed train ticket found in Camus's pocket after his death in that accident is the equal stand for the right of independence for all nations which he denied for the Algerians
"FROM EVOLUTIONIST TO CREATIONIST "BY PROF WALTER VEITH POWERFUL POWERFUL WATCH ⌚️ TRUE AMAZING STORY FROM SOUTH AFRICA ENJOY UNMISSABLE WATCH GOD IS LOVE FOREVER ❤AND EVER ❤
Camus was like the "Sigma Grindset" meme for philosophy and existentialism, "life has no meaning? yeah but at least it can be worth to live it!" type of view on human life.
In humans history, the philosophers are the biggest waste of space as far as I'm concerned. Some ancient ones I have time for but classics no Just in case you've been leaving on another planet how exactly these people make us better? We are sicker, fatter, greedier, lazier, and stupider than ever in our history not to mention we might be at beginning of a extinction that we created so I ask you again how exactly these philosophers improved humanity?
@@Raghgghhhaaahhhhhhas Just in case you've been leaving on another planet how exactly these people made us better? We are sicker, fater, greedier, lasier, and stupider than ever in our history not to mention we might be at beginning of a extinction that we created so I ask you again how exactly these philosophers improved humanity?
@@chitskirits They're contemporary thinkers and the very reason people still suffer are their own. Those who want fufillment seek it be it religion/pyhlisophy or modern BS you see on the news/internet. Then your making a poor generalization which could infer you have a poor understand of how it actually benefits the self. Humans are their own destroyers. The masses redicule and judge anyone who opposes the common belief system yet seek guidance. Understanding why we as whole suffer isn't an easy anwser aside from my personal belief; We're fucking stupid. You cant just call it useless or stupid because YOU dont understand it. That belief is flawed itself.
These French modern philosophers who ignore the canon of philosophy are very boring - angst even. They write about isolation because they have isolated themselves. They won't be in the canon of philosophy after it is no longer fashionable to be atheist.
Enjoy these types of videos? Please give it a like
Support this channel: www.patreon.com/eternalised
RUclips Member Perks: ruclips.net/channel/UCqos1tl0RntucGGtPXNxkkAjoin
Donate a Coffee: ko-fi.com/eternalised
Official Merch: eternalised.creator-spring.com
I also appreciate your videos.
“The only way to deal with an unfree world is to become so absolutely free that your very existence is an act of rebellion.”
- Albert Camus
Camus saved my life in highschool. “Live your life to the point of tears” my friends and family, life is as scary as it is silly.
"In the depths of Winter, I finally learned that within me, there lay an invincible summer."
11:00 - I like how you touched on the repetitiveness of human life. Looking back on my atheistic journey, one of the first things I threw out was the belief that scheduling and planning your life down to the minute was fruitful. I've always had insomnia (specifically, it took me maybe 1-2hrs of lying in bed to actually fall asleep, and if anything disturbed it and awoke me, it was impossible to fall back in again, so I never slept more than 3-4 hrs). Eventually, I decided that if I wish to place meaning in a meaningless schedule, the only one that matters is my own. 12 years later, I'm a self-employed farmer and programmer. Best of all when I sleep, I actually dream. Took a while to realize that what prevented me from sleep was the anxiety associated with trying to fit into a box I didn't want to be in, and the simple solution was... don't.
Dear stranger, I find inspiration in your story. Just out of curiosity for all things tech related, what does your job as a programmer entail, and how did you gather the necessary knowledge and experience?
Incredible, thank you for sharing your experiences. I find it truly inspiring.
This makes sense 🤔 ur on ur own schedule
"If you want to be a philosopher, write a novel." - Albert Camus.
Or compose a good peice of dark sarcastic tragic comedy ..
@@Multicellunaire you missed the point - Albert Camus
Source?
Could you elaborate cuz im interested@@joruss443
That’s what I did:) twice.
Camus must be the one of the most important philosopher if not the most important, at least in my life. Everyone should read the myth of Sisyphus once in their lives. The idea of realizing that life is meaningless is easy and natural, but the resolve to live against it and not commit suicide or die a philosophical death is what makes his thoughts really a masterpiece. He was a genius of man made by his circumstances, and if you're reading this do yourself a favor and read his works, trust me. As for me, I've done my work here. Great video, salute my friend. I really wanted to know the history of this spectacular mind and you cleared it all and also related him to his books. And for that I thank you.
Death of suicide
Myth of sisyophus
Breath-- the last one
Width of our life span
@@ravisekharreddy9783 that sounds cool!
Life being meaningless or meaningful is a human mental construct…Camus’s quest for freedom is the freedom from his mind which was shackled ironically by his mental brilliance…Camus is over rated
Let’s stop discussing whether something has meaning or not, both meaning and meaninglessness are quests to find meaning…meaning in meaningless
and meaning in meaningfulness
Real freedom lies in liberating oneself from the mind and creating, producing, doing, being, rather than the inertia of thinking about it.
You are, whether you think about it or not
@@Williamb612 read the myth of sisyphus
Its a tough book to read. After struggling thru the first half i searched the second half on RUclips so someone could explain it.
I have read many books on science, fiction, politics, philosophy and history. But when a drop of existentialism damped on my tongue! It amazed me with an unknown pain, the pain just tore me into pieces.
And it all starts when I read "The Fall", a book by Albert Camus. After getting much deeper into Camus's books, I suddenly met with a change. I don't know why all my tears were converted into well-known laughs. I just want to share only a quote by Albert Camus “At a certain level of suffering or injustice, no one can do anything for anyone. Pain is solitary.”
“He champions life and ask us to live it to the point of tears” So powerful and beautiful ❤️
I did (after reading his epic book about Sisiphos) and did NOT regret a single n a n o second !
Your content is phenomenal, I'm so glad I found this channel.
How does this only have 40k views? This is top tier content I am watching that's not supposed to be free.
Best video on Camus i've seen!
Loved this video, I need to watch it again to digest the concepts. I am definitely going to pick up one of his books.
My favorite existentialist author ever. Love this video.
He is the only one that I have read. I agree with much he has to say.
Hey there Raskolnikov, how are things going in Siberia?
Mine too,he is immense. It's a very deep insight into such a phenomenal being.
Currently reading The Myth of Sisyphus, what an excellent read! Great video.
Yeah, and after this read I recommnend "Zarathustra" ( Fred Nietzsche) and "Whats new Adam ?" (Osho) -> REAL game changers !
This channel deserves way more views. Keep up the great videos.
We studied fragments from The Fall in our French pragmatics class and they were so intriguing. I read The Stranger, but it wasn't as good as I expected. Hopefully, after reading his other works, my view on him will change. I really liked his ideas, though, and we're both fans of Dostoevsky, so maybe, we'll become firends soemday. He seems to be a cool guy! Great video!
I love how Camus calls the Nazis "psychopathic dandies"
I never thought much of his existentialism. However, I still liked his novels, even if they oozed Existentialism, they were still a good read.
I am also listening to "The plague" and his thoughts are intriguing and I find him fascinating.. Will sure explore him more! Thanks for this cool Intro though!✨
Great video ❤ thank you for taking the time to put it together
Extremely well structure video. Congratulations.
Always felt so curious about Camus but haven't read anything yet. After watching this I reckon I will read ''The fall''. Super interesting video!! Thank you for sharing
‘The Fall’ is a classic and worth the energy and time. Judge Penitent what a writer and a sad loss at 44 a great lucid mind,
As for essays "the rebel' is fascinating; as for novels 'the pest' is great too, especially in pandemic times.
excellent work, thank you for this video
Thank You very much for the outstanding video! It was very informative and provoked many thoughts. I can’t wait to read all of his works.
thanks! great talk!
Wonderful work. Thank you
Between being more depressed and relieved, I'm glad that I'm not the only one who suffers to bond with society.
Adore Camus, and loved this 🖤 Excellent 👏
Camus philosophy is very interesting & reading his works is on my agenda ... if absurdities are meaningful then inner conflicts may find relief?!
Excellent is the word for this video. More than thanks.
nice video, thanks!
The Plague sounds very interesting. I've to read it now!
Definitely a great read! It has sold lots of copies since the start of the pandemic, I'm glad more people read Camus.
Worth the time; decency and we are all special cases.
Yep. Especially under the world wide Corona-regime !
I love that last image of Camus, smiling with his finger uplifted, pointing up.
wonderful !! thanks ~~~ have you considered to do a segment on Rudolf Steiner ..??...
3:09
Write all of those immoralities in a book and release it.
And act like the others and adapt to them so they will notice you are a stranger
7:41
10:00
Working the same job everyday
#1 for me. His thought is admirably simple in a discipline that venerates complexity.
Would really recommend reading the original french translation for l’Étranger if you can read french. The intricacy of meursault’s character and of Camus’ writing is lost in translation, so you can only really go skin deep into the philosophy of the novel when it’s written in English. Still a good book to read nonetheless, one of my favourites regardless of the language it’s written in.
One of my friends read that and he says he is like mersault. He says he'll be however he wants and the world shouldn't bother him or ask him why he is like that. Some people are just straight up shooting the book to their ego. They think being an emotionally distant prick is some ideal. Being like that is different from aspiring to be that.
Brilliant and inspiring human❤️
FYI, the second statue of a Roman Emperor was Augustus, not Caligula
You're totally right! Thanks.
well done, good voice.
"Calígula"'s really fascinating
Very interesting! I'm looking into Camus for the first time. I too feel that life is absurd and meaningless. But I cannot believe in the Absurd Hero or a Happy Sisyphus, I think that in order to be happy the individual must perform an act of self delusion which is on a par with religious faith or optimism. That is not something I would be willing to do. Fleeting moments of contentment are fine as long as we recognise them as such, I enjoy such moments myself, but I never lose sight of the fact that life is a meaningless horror.
A fire makes brightness from whatever is thrown at it😉🔥✌🏻
What book/text, source(?) is the quotation from 03:10 in the video; (?) He wrote’:
Hope to hear from you.
That'd be Albert Camus's Notebooks 1951-1959
@@Eternalised Thank you!
Camus hated driving or being driven... He had a fear of dying in something as absurd as a car crash. After the car accident- two train tickets Camus was supposed to have used by himself and his wife were found in his pocket.
All great deeds and
All great thoughts
Have a ridiculous beginning.
A journey of 10000 miles
Begins with 1 single step.
The first step is das hardest:
How to remember de Miao Dao in my head
And to express it with my hands ?
Alber Kamy is fantastic to read resaoing absurd and to see painting existence the Myth of graetist Philosopher🙏
i would like to ask you for your art collection if you have one, becuase the art in the background of your videos is exceptional.
Obviously changed the western philosophy . Hats down ..
I feel alive with a purpose of living as i contemplate this utterly amazing realisation that all is absurd and meaningless.
As he stared at his feet and said “this is funny” lol Doc Holiday is my huckleberry.
I rebel therefore I am....
Highest truth...it's different for everybody. Sooner our later, you might have to keep it a secret and live amongst the crowd..
I had an Algerian friend who immediately decided that Camus must be a racist.
in law, a good lawyer could make a case for self-defence, regardless of what Meursault himself says.
FYI, there is a filmed version of L' Etranger by Visconti, with Marcello Mastroianni !
Who is far too handsome to play Meursault!
If everything means nothing, than everything means something.
If 0 mean nothing, then 0 mean something.
The question of the meaning of life or whether life is worth living is born of human arrogance. We assume our intellect should afford us some great station in the universe. To be able to question everything is our greatest attribute but we must balance it with the act of living each day.
"The comment section is better than me" - Albert calm down.
"THE BATTLE OVER BRITAIN "BY PROF WALTER VEITH POWERFUL POWERFUL WATCH TRUTH ALWAYS WINS ❤
If you want to be a philosopher, be a chillosopher.
-kharb
Gombrowicz is needed when it comes to existentialism
Camus lives on with his good looks and philosophical blah blah...
Today is my birthday 💔
Happy birthday 🎂
"THE MYSTERIES OF THE SUN "BY PROF WALTER VEITH POWERFUL POWERFUL WATCH TRUTH ALWAYS WINS GOD SEES EVERYTHING KNOWS EVERYTHING ❤
🖤
There is a difference between being an existentialist and existentialist philosophy
In college I of course was intoduced to Camus and Kafka. I hated both passionately. In class I found myself hostile. I was in expensive college… I was paying big bucks for this Camus crap? I was not interested in any kind of personal enfranchisement. As a handicapped person I already learned from parents , others I ain’t nothing. I had gotten used to this feedback where ever I went. What was I to do? Cast aside years of acquiescence to my situation and find a new existence, a new self? Oh BS! All folks had to do was look at me to completely demolish any smart ass idea about myself in the universe. Screw that crap. I know the profs would say I had already found myself as living a life if she!!t. I had already adapted Camus without realizing it and proved Camus wise. I am not impressed.
Featured on top 10 videos of the day on walnut.tv/science
Loving absurdity and accepting absurdity of life is another form of philosophical suicide like religion. Rebellion is only answer to the absurd even if it means tearing everything down.
Just like Sysiphus, I perform acts of meaninglessness and futility every day of my life. Life has no meaning, but, ironically, that is the meaning. Revolt against the absurdity!
Camus's denial of the Algerians' right for independence is a colonial stand..... The unsed train ticket found in Camus's pocket after his death in that accident is the equal stand for the right of independence for all nations which he denied for the Algerians
"FROM EVOLUTIONIST TO CREATIONIST "BY PROF WALTER VEITH POWERFUL POWERFUL WATCH ⌚️ TRUE AMAZING STORY FROM SOUTH AFRICA ENJOY UNMISSABLE WATCH GOD IS LOVE FOREVER ❤AND EVER ❤
The Plague was about plague (not a virus)
You mean a bacteria. Plague is usually bacteria.
He nerver mentioned he is a philosophor
Meaningwave exists
Camus was like the "Sigma Grindset" meme for philosophy and existentialism, "life has no meaning? yeah but at least it can be worth to live it!" type of view on human life.
like the picture of jesus broing down with satan
In humans history, the philosophers are the biggest waste of space as far as I'm concerned. Some ancient ones I have time for but classics no Just in case you've been leaving on another planet how exactly these people make us better? We are sicker, fatter, greedier, lazier, and stupider than ever in our history not to mention we might be at beginning of a extinction that we created so I ask you again how exactly these philosophers improved humanity?
Didn’t get it can you elaborate ?
Waste of time you mean? Then i think you are a crack of shiet jf
Such a vague opinion, care to elaborate?
@@Raghgghhhaaahhhhhhas Just in case you've been leaving on another planet how exactly these people made us better? We are sicker, fater, greedier, lasier, and stupider than ever in our history not to mention we might be at beginning of a extinction that we created so I ask you again how exactly these philosophers improved humanity?
@@chitskirits They're contemporary thinkers and the very reason people still suffer are their own. Those who want fufillment seek it be it religion/pyhlisophy or modern BS you see on the news/internet.
Then your making a poor generalization which could infer you have a poor understand of how it actually benefits the self.
Humans are their own destroyers. The masses redicule and judge anyone who opposes the common belief system yet seek guidance. Understanding why we as whole suffer isn't an easy anwser aside from my personal belief; We're fucking stupid.
You cant just call it useless or stupid because YOU dont understand it. That belief is flawed itself.
What if suicide seems absurd?
comments get points! comment comment comment...
Devastating Pandemic???
▪️
CattIe Pretendemic of 2O2O.
BOOGEYMAN-I9.
⬛️
What? "devastating virus of 2020?"
▪️
BOOGEYMAN-I9.
CattIe Pretendemic.
⬛️
हिंदी मे बताने का कट्ट करे
Did he commit suicide?
Nope. Severe traffical accident (Bad car, bad road-conditions, bad tyres)
These French modern philosophers who ignore the canon of philosophy are very boring - angst even. They write about isolation because they have isolated themselves. They won't be in the canon of philosophy after it is no longer fashionable to be atheist.
why do you speak like that?
Cause and effect.the rest is bulshits
Luciferin nonsense.
Oh he was french. Pass.
Good for you
เราเชื่อในเเนวทางที่เลือกเรียนรู้ทางที่ดีกว่าเป็นเป้าหมายของความขีวิตที่ดีด้วย☮️เรียบร้อยหากาิ่งดีที่สุดนั้นราคาถูกจริงหรือไม่คิดค่าในเรื่องดีจริงทีดีต่อมวลมนุษย์ชาติที่ไม่คิดค่าแต่เป็นการให้ฟรีๆแม้แต่ให้มาแล้วที่เป็นความดีที่ให้เลือกเองคนที่เลือกได้เท่านั้นจึงจะเข้าใจ คำว่าเลือกได้สิ่งดีที่ฟรีนั้นเป็นแค่บทเรียนและภาพประกอบเสียงสื่อบรรยายอย่างได้ความเข้าใจใครรัยดีนั้นได้ถือว่าระบบรับสื่อระบบการศึกษาหรือรับรู้นั้นต้องดีพอเท่านั้นจึงจะสามารถเข้าห้องเรียนที่มีคุณภาพสูงมีคุณสมบัติที่มีค่าที่หาอะไรทานเปรียบไม่ได้เพราะคสาทดีที่เป็นเรื่องที่สื่อมาให้เราหรือใครๆก็สามารถรับได้เท่าๆกันแต่จะเข้าใจไหมเท่านั้นเพราะคสาทเชื่อและเคารพศรัทธาความรู้จริงๆนั้นมาจากผลงานและสำคัญพื้นฐานของสายเลือดเลือกแต่สิ่งดีที่ชอบที่รักที่ใช่ที่สุดมาฝึกฝนให้ได้ความสำเร็จตามใฝ่ฝันดีๆนี่เองพวกใฝ่ดีมาจากตระกูลเท่านั้นจะรู้ดี ที่เขาเรียกว่าสายไหนเส้นทางสายนั้นจริงๆ ของดีจริงๆมีฟรีให้กับทุกคนว่าแต่จะรับได้หรือเข้าใจไหมก็เท่านั้นของดีมีฟรีทั่วโลกยุคนี้มีแล้วค่ะอย่างเวลานี้เราได้ฟังคำชี้แนะคำบรรยายสื่อให้เห็นว่าที่มากว่าคนจะสร้างผลงานสร้างสรรค์สรุปได้ว่าดีจริงมาให้เราได้เข้าผ่านรุ่นต่อรุ่นเสี่ยงได้มากว่าความดีจะโผล่นำมาให้ชมกันและจะมีกี่คนจะเข้าใจความดีที่มีที่มาเช่นนี้เอาหละไม่แค่เเนวคิดและตัวอย่างจากผลงานของผู้เจริญรุ่งเรืองนะมีดีกว่านั้นคืออาหารที่ดีที่ขาดไม่ได้ที่ราคาถูกจนเกือยจะฟรีก็มีให้มาเเล้วค่ะแต่ยอกไม่ได้กลัวจะขึ้นราคาค่ะนี่แหละคนจนเงินจะไม่มีปัญหาถ้าไม่จนสื่อสัมผัสกับการเรียนรู้รับรู้ขอให้อย่าจนปัญญาเท่านี้อยู่ที่ไหนก็สวยสง่าเหมือนเดิมเชื่อเลยค่ะไม่จำเป็นกับเรื่องนอกกายที่ไม่จำเป็นเพราะที่เขาว่าอยู่ที่ไม้เเขวนจริงๆคนสวยคนหล่มาจากที่ไหนบ้างให้เรียนรู้ให้รู้จักจริงๆนะค่ะตะแต่ความเจริญรุ่งเรืองค่ะ