I love this version... The way she sang it with that cracked voice like she wants to cry make me feel more the meaning of the lyric. I can feel all the pain, all the sadness and my heart is melted.
everyone has their own ver of this song, we should not compared it.. hyorin did a great job too.. why compared her with sohyang.. sohyang is a legend.. hyorin once said that sohyang is on another level.. lets support everyone
i love hyorin and Ailee, they are very good , each one have their own way to sing , you told that before and agree with you so hyang is a legend and i love her too ..but i dont know what sohyang cause on me , she makes me cry when i hear her sing
I don't think comparing them is wrong, but people have to understand that singers all have different qualities. Having a preference is fine, but saying one is worse than another just because of that is stupid.
Hyorin is such a great singer! She is so amazing like she can bring my emotion even if I am not Korean and I do not understand the meaning of the song.
Danielle Clarese Baldopena watch So Hyang's version of this song... just amazing. These two versions of this song are amazing. Each one emotionally hits you in just the right spot.
Actually is not about the lyrics, is all about her emotions. You won't get touch if the singer sing without an emotion even if you could understand what she sing. That's the art of music and song.
2:55 That's Hyolyn's mom!!! This was an amazing performance 2022 still listening to it. I wish she didn't get eliminated but she got a lot of hate for being the only idol and a lot of people say she didn't deserve to be a part of this show but let me tell you. She deserves it and more. Her voice is even more better now 12 years in the industry. She gets better year by year. Her voice was so strained here but now her voice is literal perfection. She sounds even better. I hope to see her in more singing shows. She deserves it!!
her mother doesn't seem too moved....eliminated and participating - everything is only move with artists like in queendom and it it not fair but what expect from business 😥. but she gave incredible performance and did anyone notice how she was shaking?
Her mom is one of her biggest fan and always supports Hyolyn. Her mom bought Hyolyn her first Mariah Carey CD and that is one of the reasons why she ended up learning how to sing. They are literally best friends and talk to each other like they're friends. Soyou has mentioned that Hyolyn's mom is really easy-going.
Hyorin is raw, sounds like she's speaking out loud with a melodic voice Sohyang is a clean, rock-ballad lullaby storytelling song. In this case Hyorin is the character singing and sohyang is that song that plays in the background narrating the story. Both are BEAUTIFULLY AMAZING in their own ways.
@What If Vocalz I didn't say she doesn't mix tho? I just said she didn't in her "Fate" performances. Also, don't trust what singers say about themselves lol, Mariah said she's an alto 💀
@What If Vocalz she didn't mix that E5 wth, literally it sounds the same as the Eb5 which was belted, do you even know the differences between laryngeal mechanisms and how they work and SOUND?
To say Sohyang didn't sing with emotion is a joke because she did. Hyorin sang with emotion as well. Two different artist who have different ways of conveying emotions. Sohyang tends to showcase emotions through her voice and not so much body language or facial expressions. Hyorin showcases emotions through her voice kind of but also through body language and facial expressions. If you close your eyes and just strictly listen you can't say that there isn't emotion in sohyang's performance. Because of that was the case no one would have cried like they did. Sohyang is someone hyorin looks up to and has admitted it. So I don't see why people are trashing Sohyang when I personally feel both of them did an AMAZING job.
Aish rang I know Hyolyn is not as good of a vocalist as Sohyang (even though Hyolyn is still good) there was no where in my comment I said she was able to
when people saw that she did AMAZING and they couldn't critisize her skills they said ''the original is better" all i can say is to each their own ^^ i personaly prefer hyorin's version!
shaishai minho I'm the one who need to say thank you.. Even I don't Understand korea but Hyorin Voice and her feeling is so deep that it's always make me cry..
Fucking shit. Even though she was the first to be eliminated, she has proved us more than necessary with her talent, vocal abilities, and the perfect delivery and capture of emotions that she has definitely gained a soft spot in all the audience's hearts. You can see this by looking at those people' tears streaming down their faces due to being very touched. She was eliminated but people have to realize that she was THE ONLY IDOL participating there against all these old school recognized veteran singers. So like, yeah, it's a pretty big deal, honestly. I listen to Kpop mainly but I have learned to appreciate Korean old songs/ballads once I was introduced to Sistar and from there, I've loved Hyorin. For me, she is the best singer out there in Korea. I personally don't think that people could compare Ailee and Hyorin because Ailee has not received such praise from veteran singers and others. There must a reason why Hyorin has been chosen to go on so many singing TV programs. Very proud of you, girl! Keep going
I don't like sentimental songs anymore, but she sang with so much emotion that I could feel it. She even made a man cried. Amazing singer. Not all amazing vocalist could sing a very emotional song and make you feel the emotion and you cried even you are good in holding your emotion.
hyorin has this thing in her voice that conveys emotions when she sings these types of songs. she should really sing more songs like this. her vocals and expressions made me cry. sohyang's performance blew me away. both performances made me cry. but hyorin really tugged my heart. this song is just too beautiful
So Hyang version was indeed more powerful vocally but Hyorin's version was much more emotional. So it depends on which you preferred. Regardless Hyorin did outstanding.
lol, the surface of my eyeball became wet after seeing the woman with her face full with tears. The song itself is very special, very good. Hyorin fighting
Sohyang version is so melancholic and soft like saying goodbye to ur love in a peaceful way meanwhile Hyolyn’s version is powerful expressing sadness and sorrow in the singing like saying to her love she is in so much pain for their goodbye 😭😭
Hyolyn's voice is truly a gift.. I've watched it so many times, yet I'm still left in awe each time. The kind of voice so beautiful it makes you stop everything you're doing, just to listen. I can only imagine what it'd be like to be one of the people who seen this performance live! I bet it's an experience they'll never forget. She has the voice of an angel. She's so talented and versatile, she can do songs so emotional and gripping like this, yet fun sexy songs like Dally too. Her talent and versatility is unmatched!
it sounds like they arranged it for her voice to fit perfectly into it. i love the original more because it's more like a ballad and a lullaby.. more smoother too.
Only the fact that she is singing it acapella at 3:43 shows that she has lots of potential. Like they have always said, if you still sounds good acapella, you definitely can sing.
I love how Hyorin adds in speed and different tempos to the song. 'Fate' already has dynamics and depth to it, so when she adds in the different tempos, it gives me the impression that she is trying to tell a timeline as how the lines are portrayed. When Hyorin sings the part where she will stay with her partner (whomever) forever, she speeds up the lyrics as compared to the end where she makes a slow and long dramatic effect. I feel this is Hyorin's type of making her special feature of the song.
She's singing a song about a couple. The husband/wife had passed away. And they're sending a message to heaven:s "Even after a thousand years have passed and my body is no more, I wish us both happiness on the road ahead. For you were a gift, my precious love. You and I can be no longer in this world. However, when we are born again into the next, I wish to see you again. Ah, will a beautiful day such as this one ever be seen again? When we turn back from the long road we've been walking, meeting, please don't forget who I was." At least, this is my rough translation of the song
+OrangeSoda my ex boyfriend who is Korean told me that too. He said the song is extremely sad because it was written about losing a loved one and sending them a message. You can hear the pain in hyorins voice. She did such a great job of covering it
You guys will have to agree with me that Hyorin version sounds like a woman who is dying of the painful memories. So Hyangs vocal of course be better! She is the best singer in Korea, who can get over her? But Hyorin make this song way different =))) She got people in tears just by listen to her version. The original or even So Hyangs version is similar, is smooth enough to feel the pain of the song but make less people into tears. Well, it just my opinion =)))))
If you guys have goosebumps for this, please check out the original singer of this song and you'll feel what a women of 50 years can make you. #LeeSunHee #RealKoreanDiva #Legend
batata: I know, and that only adds even more significant at the song. But if you listen her other songs you would realize the amazing singer she is, because she makes you feel in any of her songs (perhaps it's just me Idk).
+Airen Latinas I have to say, although nothing usually compares to the original I admit this comment is a tad bit rude to direct people to another perf. Everyone has their prefs; however, we need to keep it there and be respectful to the singer and rendition here. Hyolyn did an outstanding job for someone so young, she has yet to fully grasp evoking and conveying emotion; however, she did it here and she's a lot younger than both Lee Sun Hee and Sohyang.
Thats true that So Hyang is in another level that Hyorin. Both Version are Amazing, but Hyorin has really emotional and beautiful voice. If i must choose, I will choose this Hyorin's version. She has something in Her voice WHAT make this song wonderful.
I really like Hyroins version. But yeah, So Hyangs voice really fits the song to a T. But that doesnt mean Hyorins version is bad. This is the great thing about covers; you get to hear different interpretations. First of all, I dont know what the song is about, but I'm guessing something was lost and the singer is sadly singing about it. I feel that So Hyangs version is in the stage of new/recent sadness which makes you weak, while Hyroins is more of a memories of the sadness and therefore stronger because she's started to move on. Like; So Hyang just recently got dumped or whatever, while it's been some time in Hyroins case. (as i said, i dont know the meaning of the song). So yeah, it's the same song and the same origin, but in different timelapses, and so it has different sounds (of course it's two different singers too). Therefore I find both of them amazing. In my opinion anyway.
Don’t talk about sohyang here. This should only handle about hyolyn. She‘s an amazing vocalist with a lot of emotion and really painfully emotion. This was incredible.
it means about two person who fall in love but because of the fate they end up separating. they then make a promise if they meet in the future they will not leave each other
I have been following SISTAR ever since 2010 when they debut. Hyorin has always shined more than the other members and has improved a lot through the years. Her stage performance gets always better and better every time, and I enjoyed them a lot. To gets a hole package from dancing to singing it's amazing by its self, but to rock a stage by wearing a simple dress with a simple hairstyle and makeup, and making alf of the audience to fallen tears is incredible. This performance was totally worth it. I have never heared such a clean and soulful stage performance of her, but she totally slay it! That's what a call a queen of stage #TheQueenOfStage ❤️
That would be because It's Lee Sunhee's song and Kyuhyun is her fan and they ehy are great together. But still nobody can put the emotion in it like Lee Sunhee
@@vihmoura8169 I know right ahaha a lot of people have said that when they see hyorin mom in different shows, you can see her in I live alone when Hyorin stared in it, they have such a loving bond
Megabix yes but so hyan sing like more voice but Hyorin is more sentimental and her voice give feeling and love. I saw before so hyang version but I like more Hyorin she made me cry so Hyang not.
Mmmmmm Hyolyn's technique was almost flawless given she's singing in her chest voice most of the time lol... what are you even talking about? Could everyone stop comparing performances? That'd be great
Breana M It wasn't almost flawless. Hyorin's showed a lot of recession (only now is she getting back on track) and this is not one of her best performances even with that recession. She wasn't singing from her chest voice, she was using a chesty mix, which only helps proves my point. And I simply made that comment because a lot of people in the comments are saying Hyorin sang better than Sohyang when it isn't true, from a technical point of view. That's it.
+Megabix okay but this comment isn't helping people with the comparing? It's adding to it? And given the emotion she put into the performance, her technique was not lacking at all. Of course, I don't typically discuss vocal techniques outside of my Music Theory class, and that's mostly choral.
I don’t understand why anyone argues about this. When I hear Lee Sun Hee sing Fate, I cry. When I hear So Hyang sing Fate, I cry. When I hear Hyolin sing Fate, I cry. They each have their own style, but what they all have in common is that they are all three, absolutely exquisite vocalists & give us 3 heart-rending renditions of this incredible song. All three ladies are world class singers. Lee Sun Hee is already pretty much a Korean National Treasure & the other two are going to be.
For those of you who enjoyed this performance, I'd suggest looking up So Hyang's version as well. The two singers have their own styles and conditions, but both portray the song very very beautifully. So Hyang's version brings out a different side of the piece, and it's definitely worth your time.
For me, the original is the sadness of the one who tell the story; Sohyang’s ver is the sadness of anger; and Hyorin’s ver is the sadness of hopelessness. They’re all sad, but differently. Everyone understands the lyrics by their own way, so they have different ways to express. Anyway, as a listener, I love all☺️
In my opinion, Hyorin's vision is very attack my heart whether I understand Korean .She still very touch me.Now,she is a good singer in korea in my heart.Hope she can get a great development in 2017.^_^
Hioryn canta con un sentimiento tan unico que te hace vibrar cada membrana del cuerpo, su increible voz tambien es digna de reconocimiento. sistar son unas leyendas por sus potentes y unicas voces.
hyorin made me love this song i became a fan of lee sun hee when i watched this! mama hyorin is looking good she never ages at 2:52!!! they look like twins! i love sistar star1 forever!
La mujer llorando me representa totalmente,si juntas la canción que es preciosa y muy triste y la apoteósica voz de Hyolyn más el sentimiento que le pone al final es lo que consigues,emocionar a la gente que escucha yo al menos no puedo escuchar a esta mujer cantar sin llorar
There is NO Music Video as Perfect as this video !!! Hyolyn is Perfection The most breath taking performance ever this is AWESOME on a higher level than any one in the world !!!
Seriously, I've been in love with this song for years! And now Hyorin's voice made me so in love with it more. I can't hold my tears from both the lyrics and Hyorin's amazing voice. This is late, but Hyorin is really the best!
Hyorin version and Yoon Min Soo ft Shin Yong Jae were to me the best. The huskiness of Hyorins voice portrays the emotion perfectly. and it chills me. I really can feel the pain. Both version truly moved me.
although i don understand the language the song she is singing....but her melody of her voice really can touched my heart! it really can absorb into my soul...the ways she sings....really can described the pain, sadness and brings out lots of meaning .....i cried . Thank you for your beautiful voice....May God always bless u....Hyorin...love u from Malaysia.
![SISTAR(SoYou & HyoLyn) - Hurt(Christina Aguilera) [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_1pLhdWe2xo/mqdefault.jpg)
2024 and I still come back to this😢
She has so much talent and Korea isn’t giving her the attention she deserves!!!
😀
😃
😂
😂
I love this version... The way she sang it with that cracked voice like she wants to cry make me feel more the meaning of the lyric. I can feel all the pain, all the sadness and my heart is melted.
RT
Yessss
Yas!
@@natty05 there were but its fine it makes the song nice soo yeah
@@natty05 there were cracks and i feel amazing because she able to continue sing well after crack voices.
everyone has their own ver of this song, we should not compared it.. hyorin did a great job too.. why compared her with sohyang.. sohyang is a legend.. hyorin once said that sohyang is on another level.. lets support everyone
exactly.. I love the way the put the song their to match their voice😂
i love hyorin and Ailee, they are very good , each one have their own way to sing , you told that before and agree with you so hyang is a legend and i love her too ..but i dont know what sohyang cause on me , she makes me cry when i hear her sing
I don't think comparing them is wrong, but people have to understand that singers all have different qualities. Having a preference is fine, but saying one is worse than another just because of that is stupid.
daebak
hyex
you can't deny: hyorin has one of the biggest voices on kpop industry.
@What If Vocalz sohyang not kpop babyb
@@kitty.miracle Rose singing better than Hyolyn? In your dreams lmfao
@@kitty.miracle funny
@@kitty.miracle lamooo i can't
@@kitty.miracle no hate but even if rose train a 100 years she will still be below Hyolyn's worst performance lol
2020 still here...who with me?
Me, we stan art 💜
Me
Me✨
2021...
2021 XD
Hyorin is such a great singer! She is so amazing like she can bring my emotion even if I am not Korean and I do not understand the meaning of the song.
Danielle Clarese Baldopena I know. I'm crying and I don't even understand. :')
weareyesconnect Me too.
Danielle Clarese Baldopena watch So Hyang's version of this song... just amazing. These two versions of this song are amazing. Each one emotionally hits you in just the right spot.
Danielle Clarese Baldopena Same here. It's like I can feel her words.
맞아요
i did not understand what she sing. But her emotion make me feel gonna cry
Jennifer Chong Chai Joo you can enable english subtitles
Feelings don't know a language.
the ong is about a love that cant make it in this life, so the hope is in the next one, when the singer dont let her love go away
Actually is not about the lyrics, is all about her emotions. You won't get touch if the singer sing without an emotion even if you could understand what she sing. That's the art of music and song.
Lord same 😂😭
After watching Girls Planet 999, I remembered Hyorin singing this song. That's why I came back here.😭💖
me too😭
what performance of girls planet was it?
@@drewadrianuyangurin1812 it was a dance performance
2:55 That's Hyolyn's mom!!! This was an amazing performance 2022 still listening to it. I wish she didn't get eliminated but she got a lot of hate for being the only idol and a lot of people say she didn't deserve to be a part of this show but let me tell you. She deserves it and more. Her voice is even more better now 12 years in the industry. She gets better year by year. Her voice was so strained here but now her voice is literal perfection. She sounds even better. I hope to see her in more singing shows. She deserves it!!
i agree with you
her mother doesn't seem too moved....eliminated and participating - everything is only move with artists like in queendom and it it not fair but what expect from business 😥. but she gave incredible performance and did anyone notice how she was shaking?
Her mom is one of her biggest fan and always supports Hyolyn. Her mom bought Hyolyn her first Mariah Carey CD and that is one of the reasons why she ended up learning how to sing. They are literally best friends and talk to each other like they're friends. Soyou has mentioned that Hyolyn's mom is really easy-going.
Ana Rocio García Domingo si. 20
but typical Hyolyn, people who hates her WILL loves her , they cant deny her talent even an a bit
Hyorin is raw, sounds like she's speaking out loud with a melodic voice
Sohyang is a clean, rock-ballad lullaby storytelling song.
In this case Hyorin is the character singing and sohyang is that song that plays in the background narrating the story.
Both are BEAUTIFULLY AMAZING in their own ways.
agree 👏👏😤😤
@What If Vocalz nah, Sohyang on Imas2 belted all the song
@What If Vocalz I didn't say she doesn't mix tho? I just said she didn't in her "Fate" performances.
Also, don't trust what singers say about themselves lol, Mariah said she's an alto 💀
@What If Vocalz she didn't mix that E5 wth, literally it sounds the same as the Eb5 which was belted, do you even know the differences between laryngeal mechanisms and how they work and SOUND?
裁判他他在韓國他在大大馬路澎湖破壞紅綠燈害我你現在開始要傷害我知道我都害我以前他不會紅綠燈要害我以前害我到現在了
The best voice idol in Korea for me.
totally agree
La número 1!! La reina
Same here. Even better than Ailee, IMO.
solji 1st or baek ji young before hyolyn
@@jwt1035 Prime hyolyn is neck to neck wirh ailee but now no
For everyone's knowledge, the woman in 2:53 is her mom ❤
To say Sohyang didn't sing with emotion is a joke because she did. Hyorin sang with emotion as well. Two different artist who have different ways of conveying emotions. Sohyang tends to showcase emotions through her voice and not so much body language or facial expressions. Hyorin showcases emotions through her voice kind of but also through body language and facial expressions. If you close your eyes and just strictly listen you can't say that there isn't emotion in sohyang's performance. Because of that was the case no one would have cried like they did. Sohyang is someone hyorin looks up to and has admitted it. So I don't see why people are trashing Sohyang when I personally feel both of them did an AMAZING job.
Raini Kim Emotion is subjective so your point is moot
Demitri that's pretty much what I kind of said.
No it's not you made it seem as if everyone HAS to agree that there was emotion in Sohyang's performance
Demitri ah okay. Sorry you feel that way.
Aish rang I know Hyolyn is not as good of a vocalist as Sohyang (even though Hyolyn is still good) there was no where in my comment I said she was able to
Hyorin is such a gift to us mankind. That voice is such an eargasm. This version is way beyond comprehension. Ow, it's 2021.
hyorin the bully
@@unskillfullymasterful I bet you're a bully too 😂😂
Is she the same person who sang Dally?!!! if she is then Wtffff?!! This is talent overload😵
Yes she is 😂
If you like Hyorin/Hyolyn ballad song try search "Hyorin-Crazy of You" I bet you gonna love her more 😜
check out her other songs and covers you will be more surprised
She is a really versatile singer, love her
New kpop fan detected.. lol
Shes can rap, dance and sing powerful a total package indeed . You can listen to her some drama OST its really good.
when people saw that she did AMAZING and they couldn't critisize her skills they said ''the original is better" all i can say is to each their own ^^ i personaly prefer hyorin's version!
also when she sang when the beat stoped my heart stoped :o!
Yes this is the best version
+Asylgul Aydaralieva its lovely but i still love the original.
same. .. I love hyolyn's version way more than the original
her version is amazing tho
Jesus I need a studio version of this nooooow. I can't tell you how many times I've rewatched this performance.
Watch the original video please
ChimChimSekushiDesu Same here
shaishai minho where is the original?
It's on MBC channel .... Just type Hyorin I am a singer MBC... Thank you so much
shaishai minho I'm the one who need to say thank you.. Even I don't Understand korea but Hyorin Voice and her feeling is so deep that it's always make me cry..
Fucking shit. Even though she was the first to be eliminated, she has proved us more than necessary with her talent, vocal abilities, and the perfect delivery and capture of emotions that she has definitely gained a soft spot in all the audience's hearts. You can see this by looking at those people' tears streaming down their faces due to being very touched. She was eliminated but people have to realize that she was THE ONLY IDOL participating there against all these old school recognized veteran singers. So like, yeah, it's a pretty big deal, honestly. I listen to Kpop mainly but I have learned to appreciate Korean old songs/ballads once I was introduced to Sistar and from there, I've loved Hyorin. For me, she is the best singer out there in Korea. I personally don't think that people could compare Ailee and Hyorin because Ailee has not received such praise from veteran singers and others. There must a reason why Hyorin has been chosen to go on so many singing TV programs. Very proud of you, girl! Keep going
idkEly YES TO EVERYTHING YOU SAID!
i saw audience cry in almost any performances
Are you actually kidding ailee shits all over hyorin vocally don't even start
@@chickthatlikesmusic not when Ailee said "you can't beat Hyolyn in most music" in Good Girl.
Hyolin really gave her all for this song.
Viewers and listeners, you don't need to compare singers. That's their art.
Her voice really suits songs like this best. It's husky, deep, brings out the sadness, strong, soulful, perfection.
I don't like sentimental songs anymore, but she sang with so much emotion that I could feel it. She even made a man cried. Amazing singer. Not all amazing vocalist could sing a very emotional song and make you feel the emotion and you cried even you are good in holding your emotion.
hyorin has this thing in her voice that conveys emotions when she sings these types of songs. she should really sing more songs like this. her vocals and expressions made me cry. sohyang's performance blew me away. both performances made me cry. but hyorin really tugged my heart. this song is just too beautiful
So Hyang version was indeed more powerful vocally but Hyorin's version was much more emotional. So it depends on which you preferred. Regardless Hyorin did outstanding.
십년이상 듣는 효린무대중 한곡 그녀의 노력과 재능이 가슴으로 와닿네요
섹시이미지에 저평가 받는 정말 매력적인 목소리... 효린 화이팅. 멋져부러
There's something about the breathing as and huskiness of her voice that portrays the emotions perfectly. I continuously find myself coming back here
If you've read the translation of the song, you'll approve Hyorin's version is better. All emotions on the song (for me) have been positioned well.
finally someone that agrees with me :D!
Yeah finnally even her prononsiation is better than So Hyang Quenn Hyo.(sorry for bad english)
to be honest, hyorin's version really hit me in my heart. it's so touching. her voice is superb
This version is still the best 😭😭
The BEST PART was when the instruments stopped and HYOLIN KILLED IT ACAPELLA! She's incredibly underrated.
lol, the surface of my eyeball became wet after seeing the woman with her face full with tears. The song itself is very special, very good. Hyorin fighting
LOL but it's a soothing song to listen song and it's sad
Im i the only one whatching this with me mouth open, its finish and my mouth is still open. Hyorin is amazing.
Dandan Danelia She is soooooo amazing! I love her!
Dandan Danelia me too lol
Dandan Danelia don’t let the bugs fly inside
Wow, so effortlessly emotional. Didn't know she sang this well, besides all the other mv.
you should check out her solo album Love and Hate. Falling and Closer are such jams.She's a good vocalist.
Leah Light Everything she does is better than good!
Sohyang version is so melancholic and soft like saying goodbye to ur love in a peaceful way meanwhile Hyolyn’s version is powerful expressing sadness and sorrow in the singing like saying to her love she is in so much pain for their goodbye 😭😭
Hyolyn's voice is truly a gift.. I've watched it so many times, yet I'm still left in awe each time. The kind of voice so beautiful it makes you stop everything you're doing, just to listen. I can only imagine what it'd be like to be one of the people who seen this performance live! I bet it's an experience they'll never forget. She has the voice of an angel. She's so talented and versatile, she can do songs so emotional and gripping like this, yet fun sexy songs like Dally too. Her talent and versatility is unmatched!
I like So Hyangs version a bit better, but damn Hyorin gave it everything. Both versions are great and touching.
it sounds like they arranged it for her voice to fit perfectly into it. i love the original more because it's more like a ballad and a lullaby.. more smoother too.
+Setoshi kunn dont worry im not hating i love hyorin from sista.
hacgonh
Agree
have been listen to this song over 5 hours... can't stop
who's with me
me . hyorin is my idol . You should watch her video more . IF I'D LOVED YOU ONLY A BIT , this song will make you more suprised than here !
Rachel Lee step up your game, child. I've been listening to it for 5 days straight
Only the fact that she is singing it acapella at 3:43 shows that she has lots of potential. Like they have always said, if you still sounds good acapella, you definitely can sing.
The year is 2024 and I still haven't gotten over this version.
I love how Hyorin adds in speed and different tempos to the song. 'Fate' already has dynamics and depth to it, so when she adds in the different tempos, it gives me the impression that she is trying to tell a timeline as how the lines are portrayed. When Hyorin sings the part where she will stay with her partner (whomever) forever, she speeds up the lyrics as compared to the end where she makes a slow and long dramatic effect. I feel this is Hyorin's type of making her special feature of the song.
I have no idea what words she's singing but just the raw emotion she puts into her performances touches the heart. Her voice is phenomenal!
She's singing a song about a couple. The husband/wife had passed away. And they're sending a message to heaven:s
"Even after a thousand years have passed and my body is no more, I wish us both happiness on the road ahead. For you were a gift, my precious love. You and I can be no longer in this world. However, when we are born again into the next, I wish to see you again. Ah, will a beautiful day such as this one ever be seen again? When we turn back from the long road we've been walking, meeting, please don't forget who I was."
At least, this is my rough translation of the song
OrangeSoda Oh wow, that just made me all teary eyed. That's so beautiful :')
+Morgan Swain yah, it is. Even sadder when one reads it with the music on. But it is a very beautiful song.
+OrangeSoda my ex boyfriend who is Korean told me that too. He said the song is extremely sad because it was written about losing a loved one and sending them a message. You can hear the pain in hyorins voice. She did such a great job of covering it
+rachrex it is a beautiful song sung by a beautiful woman
You guys will have to agree with me that Hyorin version sounds like a woman who is dying of the painful memories. So Hyangs vocal of course be better! She is the best singer in Korea, who can get over her? But Hyorin make this song way different =))) She got people in tears just by listen to her version. The original or even So Hyangs version is similar, is smooth enough to feel the pain of the song but make less people into tears. Well, it just my opinion =)))))
Hoàng Anh Lê In sohyang's version, many people cried too
Wao người việt nè
2:53 Hyorins mommy :D! She looked like a proud mama!
I was about to comment "is that hyolynnie's umma" xD
+HitStep08 we can easily say they are sisters instead of mother and daughter ;)
anyone know her nick facebook Hyorin was. thank you
omg her mom looks so young
anyone know her/Hyorin facebook account is? Chính xác b hãy hỏi như v có lẽ nếu sai ngữ pháp nước ngoài cũng hiểu nha :)) j mà her r còn Hyorin rồi từNick Facebook chắc VN mình sd nhiều á :))
.
Đi vào vấn đề chính là
- K tìm thấy account FB nào của Hyolyn nhưng mọi thứ đều đc up trên page của Sistar
- Bã chỉ có insta: xhyolynx
이 노래를 듣다가 아직 울고 있어요 😭
7개월이 지났는데 아직도 울고 계신가여?
I was never a sistar fan but I've always respected Hyolyn. She is more than kpop. The emotion in her voice. You can't deny it, it's a GIFT! 🥲
I agree... she is queen😢😢
If you guys have goosebumps for this, please check out the original singer of this song and you'll feel what a women of 50 years can make you.
#LeeSunHee #RealKoreanDiva #Legend
+Airen Latinas because she write the song about her husband that why you can feel more emotions in the original version I think
batata: I know, and that only adds even more significant at the song. But if you listen her other songs you would realize the amazing singer she is, because she makes you feel in any of her songs (perhaps it's just me Idk).
+Airen Latinas Check out So Hyang's live version too! Simply Wow.
I saw, and she is amazing. But still I prefer the original version, maybe I'm old style or idk LOL I just love Lee Sun Hee, her and her voice.
+Airen Latinas I have to say, although nothing usually compares to the original I admit this comment is a tad bit rude to direct people to another perf. Everyone has their prefs; however, we need to keep it there and be respectful to the singer and rendition here. Hyolyn did an outstanding job for someone so young, she has yet to fully grasp evoking and conveying emotion; however, she did it here and she's a lot younger than both Lee Sun Hee and Sohyang.
Thats true that So Hyang is in another level that Hyorin. Both Version are Amazing, but Hyorin has really emotional and beautiful voice. If i must choose, I will choose this Hyorin's version. She has something in Her voice WHAT make this song wonderful.
I really like Hyroins version. But yeah, So Hyangs voice really fits the song to a T. But that doesnt mean Hyorins version is bad. This is the great thing about covers; you get to hear different interpretations. First of all, I dont know what the song is about, but I'm guessing something was lost and the singer is sadly singing about it. I feel that So Hyangs version is in the stage of new/recent sadness which makes you weak, while Hyroins is more of a memories of the sadness and therefore stronger because she's started to move on. Like; So Hyang just recently got dumped or whatever, while it's been some time in Hyroins case. (as i said, i dont know the meaning of the song).
So yeah, it's the same song and the same origin, but in different timelapses, and so it has different sounds (of course it's two different singers too). Therefore I find both of them amazing. In my opinion anyway.
The original singer is lee sun hee and here's a link to the english translation :) lyricstranslate.com/en/fate-fate.html
Thank you, haha! I redid my comment while you commented this I think ^^ I'll go check it out! :3
+iGNONERA ahahah ok!
Agree!!
iGNONERA turn on the SUBS!!!wtf???
Don’t talk about sohyang here. This should only handle about hyolyn. She‘s an amazing vocalist with a lot of emotion and really painfully emotion. This was incredible.
Honestly I don't know the meaning of the song, yet I'm still crying 😭
it means about two person who fall in love but because of the fate they end up separating. they then make a promise if they meet in the future they will not leave each other
@@rozychan402 wrong
the letter will make you cry so much….
I have been following SISTAR ever since 2010 when they debut. Hyorin has always shined more than the other members and has improved a lot through the years. Her stage performance gets always better and better every time, and I enjoyed them a lot. To gets a hole package from dancing to singing it's amazing by its self, but to rock a stage by wearing a simple dress with a simple hairstyle and makeup, and making alf of the audience to fallen tears is incredible. This performance was totally worth it. I have never heared such a clean and soulful stage performance of her, but she totally slay it! That's what a call a queen of stage #TheQueenOfStage ❤️
Stole my heart again with her voice
2023 and I still go back to this whenever I am in a ballad music zone.
The best version of fate❤
Love you 누나 🤍
인연을 노래하는 최고의 가수는 효린인데 다시한번 감상해보세요 섹시걸 효린씨 최고
One of the most expressive singer in the industry. She sang from her heart & her eyes show it all ! Awesome vocal range. Fighting ! Saranghae HyoRin.💜
Kyuhyun + Lee Sun Hee in Fantastic Duo, is the best presentation of Fate...
That would be because It's Lee Sunhee's song and Kyuhyun is her fan and they ehy are great together. But still nobody can put the emotion in it like Lee Sunhee
Yep, maybe that :v
The way she sing is really hurt . This version make me cry so much . I just listen but I can feel everything in this song .
Came back in 2020, I love it how Hyorin's mom was there to watch her sing too :(
Who is her mom??
@@vihmoura8169 She''s at @2:53
@@Sxintless She looks so young
@@vihmoura8169 I know right ahaha a lot of people have said that when they see hyorin mom in different shows, you can see her in I live alone when Hyorin stared in it, they have such a loving bond
No doubt, she is one of the best vocalist in Korea
These is really heartbreaking. I don't understand korean but the way she sings, I can feel what the message says. 😪
Obviously Sohyang sang better from a technical point of view but you can't deny Hyorin's version of this song is more emotional
Megabix yes but so hyan sing like more voice but Hyorin is more sentimental and her voice give feeling and love. I saw before so hyang version but I like more Hyorin she made me cry so Hyang not.
Marian Guerrero did you even read my comment lmao
Mmmmmm Hyolyn's technique was almost flawless given she's singing in her chest voice most of the time lol... what are you even talking about? Could everyone stop comparing performances? That'd be great
Breana M It wasn't almost flawless. Hyorin's showed a lot of recession (only now is she getting back on track) and this is not one of her best performances even with that recession. She wasn't singing from her chest voice, she was using a chesty mix, which only helps proves my point. And I simply made that comment because a lot of people in the comments are saying Hyorin sang better than Sohyang when it isn't true, from a technical point of view. That's it.
+Megabix okay but this comment isn't helping people with the comparing? It's adding to it? And given the emotion she put into the performance, her technique was not lacking at all. Of course, I don't typically discuss vocal techniques outside of my Music Theory class, and that's mostly choral.
This performance had me in tears. I love her version, honestly. Damn, she can sing!
이토록 청아한 허스키한. 러브레터한 짚은 호소력은 가슴속에 뭉쿨함을 날려버리듯 더없이 아름다움을 멜로디 의 높은음계를 예술로. 승화시킨 최고의 노래를 최고의가수가 이것은 예술을 표현하는것 예술입니다 더없이 아름다움을 리드하는것은 여자만의 타고난 얼라이브의 최고의 디너입니다 너무나 뜻깊게. 귀전에 맴도는 노래의 파티는 듣고 또들어도 감사합니다 좋은영상 최고예요 👍 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I don’t understand why anyone argues about this. When I hear Lee Sun Hee sing Fate, I cry. When I hear So Hyang sing Fate, I cry. When I hear Hyolin sing Fate, I cry. They each have their own style, but what they all have in common is that they are all three, absolutely exquisite vocalists & give us 3 heart-rending renditions of this incredible song. All three ladies are world class singers. Lee Sun Hee is already pretty much a Korean National Treasure & the other two are going to be.
*Still cry everytime I watch this,,, so deep,... She have a great voice.*
So cute seeing hyorin's mum in the audience. Stunning performance!
***** 2:54
For those of you who enjoyed this performance, I'd suggest looking up So Hyang's version as well. The two singers have their own styles and conditions, but both portray the song very very beautifully. So Hyang's version brings out a different side of the piece, and it's definitely worth your time.
Faye Wang
៊
I don’t even understand the korean language but I could feel her power and feel the song… It made me shed a tear… beautiful voice
I love this version that acapella part really break my heart , my tears fall
i dont know who i love the most, hyorin or my mom lol
omg 😂 lol
lol so true XD
same!!
I like hyorin but NO ONE can replace my mom lol
+Sally Bae Thank you!!Same here...
I listened to 3:34 for 6 times in a row and I got goosebumps. Every. Single. Time.
Hobi's Epic Leg Kick In Boy Meets Evil BAHAHAHAHAHAHA SAME
I like your username
The silent music part with just her voice singing was exceptionally heart touching.
they have this performance downloaded on a usb and preserved for future generations to watch. it is literally THAT timeless
최고 중의 최고!!
omg her voice is so beautiful. I've heard a few versions of this song and this song is impossibly beautiful.
she is fucking awesome.. beautiful voice.. lovely high notes.. one of the best singer..
her voice is amongst the legend. HYOLIN DAEBAKKKKK !!!
save ur hate for people who can understand it
+Jakey what do you mean hate. i love her
This made me cry. I miss my mother so much. I hope to see her again.
For me, the original is the sadness of the one who tell the story; Sohyang’s ver is the sadness of anger; and Hyorin’s ver is the sadness of hopelessness. They’re all sad, but differently. Everyone understands the lyrics by their own way, so they have different ways to express. Anyway, as a listener, I love all☺️
In my opinion, Hyorin's vision is very attack my heart whether I understand Korean .She still very touch me.Now,she is a good singer in korea in my heart.Hope she can get a great development in 2017.^_^
Hyorin still make me cry when i see this special perform video ❤😢
這首歌我重複聽了上百次，非常感人。
She sounds amazing. Full of raw emotions. Made me cried. Absolute perfection.
Bruv!!! Her voice is ethereal! Some people have beautiful voices, and some are good at singing, but she has both. My heart...
Hioryn canta con un sentimiento tan unico que te hace vibrar cada membrana del cuerpo, su increible voz tambien es digna de reconocimiento. sistar son unas leyendas por sus potentes y unicas voces.
I swear no one is near her in Kpop when it comes to vocals, tones, technique and delivery oh gawdddddd
hyorin made me love this song i became a fan of lee sun hee when i watched this! mama hyorin is looking good she never ages at 2:52!!! they look like twins! i love sistar star1 forever!
La mujer llorando me representa totalmente,si juntas la canción que es preciosa y muy triste y la apoteósica voz de Hyolyn más el sentimiento que le pone al final es lo que consigues,emocionar a la gente que escucha yo al menos no puedo escuchar a esta mujer cantar sin llorar
There is NO Music Video as Perfect as this video !!! Hyolyn is Perfection The most breath taking performance ever this is AWESOME on a higher level than any one in the world !!!
No one can sing it better than the original singer, Lee Sung Hee, but she did a wonderful job for sure.
Seriously, I've been in love with this song for years! And now Hyorin's voice made me so in love with it more. I can't hold my tears from both the lyrics and Hyorin's amazing voice. This is late, but Hyorin is really the best!
Hyorin could make stones cry with the beauty and conviction of her singing. Just amazing.
my whole body is cover with goosebumps
THE MOST PERFECT MUSIC VIDEO IN THE WORLD "THAT IS A FACT !!!!
One of the things i love about Hyolyn is that she sings with her heart and soul in it
Hyorin is amazing.. damn
Hyorin version and Yoon Min Soo ft Shin Yong Jae were to me the best. The huskiness of Hyorins voice portrays the emotion perfectly. and it chills me. I really can feel the pain. Both version truly moved me.
Hyorin makes me heavily cry. I can feel what shes feeling when singing this song.
When you thought this song can't get any more emotional but then Hyorin happened. 😭😭😭😭😭 it's so beautiful queen hyorin. I literally cried. ❤❤❤❤❤
although i don understand the language the song she is singing....but her melody of her voice really can touched my heart! it really can absorb into my soul...the ways she sings....really can described the pain, sadness and brings out lots of meaning .....i cried . Thank you for your beautiful voice....May God always bless u....Hyorin...love u from Malaysia.