You really helped the hot banger guy, he only had 14 reviews on the release of this video now he has over a 100 thank you for doing that... It is NOT me btw, I just like the fact that you helped him so much 👍👍💪
Well you gotta relies that if he is too harsh people might comment bad comments not only that you might make the maker of the beat not wanna upload beats anymore.
Last beat the bass is not out of key, he played a different mode than yours from E. He or she basicly made your chord progression sound as extension chords to his bass. One of the coolest beats.
You usually get what you pay for, and while I don’t think any of these are spectacular, I do at least three of them probably all worth more than five bucks. Props to those guys for finding a way to monetize what they do. But man, I do think it’s sad to see beatmaking so commoditized. People throwing together a few loops for five bucks definitely devalues the industry as a whole.
@@anxiousmindmusic for a lot of new sellers on fiverr it's the only way they can stand out among the competition, reel in buyers with small prices and gradually increase as you get ratings and impressions, speaking from experience...but it really does suck that there will be fiverr pros who produce entire soundtracks for $5... and they'll keep it that way caus they definitely don't use this as an income source but still have time on their hands.
Then people complain how there is no money in music. Well ofc, when you charge 5$ for original full production. Then other people need to lower prices so they can get a job, and in the end everyone is charging 5$ because no one is crazy enough to pay the same thing 100$. You cutting yourself short guys, even 50$ per produced minute of song it's cheap for that kind of work.
Well how much money are you making? These guys are just tryna make some money and the producing scene is over saturated to shit. People upload free beats all the time
yeah i wouldn't be surprised if it's just midi loops too.... things have truly become complex but this isn't the only industry....photo editing has been hit similarly by programs that made everything super simple and negated the need to learn a skill.
Yeah but if it wasn't for that cheap price, he would have less customers and he would've never been in this video. I'm sure when they get stablished they will charge more
Interesting how Ed seems to think the best things are the generic ones. The most creative were the last two in my opinion. But nobody created a counter harmonic feeling to create a different vibe. Shame.
Alejandro Martínez Not sure what you are saying... but to me it’s never about the money. Five dollars or five hundred dollars shouldn’t make a difference to one’s professional and creative integrity. Just sayin.
@JTR Hockey Productions has nothing to do with being good or great in life if you want quality you have to pay for it this has been true since the dawn of time you want better pay more or just finish the beat yourself
Honestly kind of seems like you were looking for cookie-cutter production style rather than something unique/creative. The one you liked the most was the super typical, predictable, trap style. Even "waiting for the drop" is now so rote that it seems inconceivable for a beat to omit that formulaic element. Not that the other beats were so professional but they were better than the first one IMO. To me, aside from some lack of attention to detail, they were more impressive in terms of originality-even though they're not "radio-ready" at all. Someone like Kendrick will hear a beat like that and turn it into a classic, because he looks for a template for originality. As a producer I understand the ears get refined to anticipate the familiar, but it's sad that the entire game is getting locked in this box and there is no breathing room for innovation.
Couldn't agree more. The culture is fucking boring, and wildly un-original. Its just the none-sense. People never switch up the textures of the bass, as new interesting harmonies, its just the same 808's, same drums, same everything. And people actually watch this and say that FIRE BRUH, its not fire its fucking shit and boring. lol
I just started making beats and I'm starting from scratch it's pretty tough with melodies but I'm still learning piano. Trying my very best fr. But awesome vid Bro flute Gang!!!
you have to be bad ass at your instrument to survive in this industry, there is no shortcuts. Good music and musicians are timeless never goes out of fashion.
Seen the notification on Discord and went straight on youtube to watch this, great video 🔥🔥🔥. I can't believe no one thought about making a slow dreamy lofi with the piano sample.
I had this same video idea yesterday and wrote it down! Didn’t even see you did it same day. The first beat was definitely the best, I love the tempo change drop.
Last to me had the best sound but first was best "following the rules" deffff see how last didnt do the most in terms of flippin it but the end result was the most vibez imo. First viddd I've seen by you man and love it ! Subbed x10 !!!!
Ed , I loved the sample flips but if you don't mind where can i find your original sample u gave to these producers ? I also want to flip the sample for fun !!
Yo its KolbeBallard! thanks for reviewing my beat! Really appreciate it. I've watched a ton of your vids but never subbed, well... i'm subbed now. Wish I would have put more work into the beat...
1st id like to say its so fun & exciting to see the different outcomes of what a producer can do with your idea!! The last 1 got my head really boppin! I like the slower tempo, richer bass & Ahh sample. The 1st track came in 2d place. Nice video!!! @EdTalenti
Can't believe i'm in this video !!!
Thank you Ed !
Yours was fire bro
fire
@@rakzbeats7499 thanks man !
@@Josher447 thanks bro !
Great job with the beat
You really helped the hot banger guy, he only had 14 reviews on the release of this video now he has over a 100 thank you for doing that... It is NOT me btw, I just like the fact that you helped him so much 👍👍💪
Just imagine what you can do irl with only $5, and you get a nice amateur instrumental like that...
Idk bro kinda sus
@@abstrakt_thought_ "its not me btw" lmao
John had the best one, especially since it's 5 dollars, the guy that charged 20$ was a basic beat anyone could've made in 10-15 minutes
3 minutes
LITERALLY!
@DJ LeechCraft you right it could've been quicker
Fr
@@TheDarkCrownRecords If that
3:45 Looks at his watch*
“It’s been like 4 days”
some whatches have the day on it
I was checking the date on the watch lmao 😂😂
Apple Watch can have all kinds of data for you at a glance lol
He prolly got a day date
it's 2020 my man, you need to check new watches they are different than 1980's watches
06:00 Ed is so full of positivity, looking for the good things to say, instead of trashing people. Respect
Last beat made more sense
I agree. It was the most well-rounded and what I would think of if someone said "professional".
you're being too nice man..lmao
Fax 💀
yeah
Well you gotta relies that if he is too harsh people might comment bad comments not only that you might make the maker of the beat not wanna upload beats anymore.
These guys literally just put a few drums over it lol
When you're only making $5, then I wouldn't wanna be putting in a heap of effort either.
Last beat the bass is not out of key, he played a different mode than yours from E. He or she basicly made your chord progression sound as extension chords to his bass. One of the coolest beats.
Ed you gotta do a melody competition! I would love that
There's one running right now! Link in description 💪💯
@@EdTalenti Oh ahah my bad! Expect a submission from me :D
@@EdTalenti bro,the link for the contest is not working
People would cheat and send samples
Hello other isaac
The last beat so much better than all the rest. It's not even close
kolbeballard coming thru with the Cymatics Empire drum loop from the free Cymatics Empire Hip Hop Sample Pack
Hey bro its KolbeBallard:) bro i use Cymatics for a ton of my projects, they're amazing. Damn I wish i spent more then 5 min on this beat lol
@@kolbeballard2914 thats not how you should be treating your art, let alone art people are paying you to make, smh
Kolbe Ballard your pretty much scamming people... you should spend more time if people are paying you
@@ryadmane wait, you dont like Cymatics?
@@prod.greyspace they're paying $5... i only get 5 stars, explain that.
10:14 i thought this man was about to start rapping about the layers
Lil Eddie
LOL I m dying
10:12 Sounds like he is rapping on this beat.
Lmaoooooooo
Ed: The drum sound selection could have been a lot better.
Info card: Get these exact drums here!
You usually get what you pay for, and while I don’t think any of these are spectacular, I do at least three of them probably all worth more than five bucks. Props to those guys for finding a way to monetize what they do. But man, I do think it’s sad to see beatmaking so commoditized. People throwing together a few loops for five bucks definitely devalues the industry as a whole.
Definitely - If the beat took longer than half an hour it's less than minimum wage in the UK.. this one left me with a bad taste if I'm honest.
@@anxiousmindmusic for a lot of new sellers on fiverr it's the only way they can stand out among the competition, reel in buyers with small prices and gradually increase as you get ratings and impressions, speaking from experience...but it really does suck that there will be fiverr pros who produce entire soundtracks for $5... and they'll keep it that way caus they definitely don't use this as an income source but still have time on their hands.
Well the 3rd beat the guy used a cymatic fm drum pattern. -_- that's why the kick had so many.
Thank you for putting the waveform on screen in real time!
11:00 this beat is so beautiful I can hear trippie redd on it
Those lights set the mood
Then people complain how there is no money in music. Well ofc, when you charge 5$ for original full production. Then other people need to lower prices so they can get a job, and in the end everyone is charging 5$ because no one is crazy enough to pay the same thing 100$. You cutting yourself short guys, even 50$ per produced minute of song it's cheap for that kind of work.
I was thinking the same thing
Well how much money are you making? These guys are just tryna make some money and the producing scene is over saturated to shit. People upload free beats all the time
yeah i wouldn't be surprised if it's just midi loops too....
things have truly become complex
but this isn't the only industry....photo editing has been hit similarly by programs that made everything super simple and negated the need to learn a skill.
@@dathunderman4 feels like whatever you do... World is saturated with... Music, video, pictures, painting,travelling... At this point...
Yeah but if it wasn't for that cheap price, he would have less customers and he would've never been in this video. I'm sure when they get stablished they will charge more
Dude that second melody was so fire!!
You’re actually goated🔥
Hey man thanks for doing things like this. It a different form of motivation
They did really good! They all had pretty unique styles! Its cool to see what different producers can do 👌🏾👌🏾
Hey sagala. Lul
Haha U here!
12:40-12:42 - Someone needs to make a beat around this!
I definitely love the last one for sure!! Great VIBEs!!
7:54 I cannot describe it, cant even understand it, but I got goosebumps LOL
Man that's crazy how u improve quality with every video! Keep it up
Thank you so much man 🙏
9:08 Next up 'Anass' that ain't what I heard 😂
Bruh😂😂😂why u gotta do that to Ed
😂😂
I'm in love with the last beat, that vocal sample man, fire! Grande Ed bel video!
When he said “Ifdyageyesinjoieddisvigeodontfurgedtohitdasubscribebuddon”, I felt that.
Haha😐
wow
Yeah I watched this all the way through. You’re onto something good job 👍🏾
Interesting how Ed seems to think the best things are the generic ones. The most creative were the last two in my opinion. But nobody created a counter harmonic feeling to create a different vibe. Shame.
Alejandro Martínez Not sure what you are saying... but to me it’s never about the money. Five dollars or five hundred dollars shouldn’t make a difference to one’s professional and creative integrity. Just sayin.
@@kelvynification you get what you pay for who is putting all there creative juices into a beat that only cost $5
@JTR Hockey Productions has nothing to do with being good or great in life if you want quality you have to pay for it this has been true since the dawn of time you want better pay more or just finish the beat yourself
i loved the first track! 🥰 they were all quite good, the tips were 100% accurate!
great work buddy keep it up 👊🏽
ooooooooh that second melody hit me right in the heart! soooooo smoth
Those fiver producer need to monopolize the game and set the standard at 50 dollars.
I like your commentary, it helps people come up with their own music theory
People have reinvented music theory? What are you talking about?
THat 3rd track was nice, he sorta swings a dubstep vibe with it dope!
I just came across this channel and i really love this guy idk what it is he's so chill
The "help me pay my bills" in 0:20 sounds exactly like davie504 videos lol
more vids like this please! was awesome
Honestly kind of seems like you were looking for cookie-cutter production style rather than something unique/creative. The one you liked the most was the super typical, predictable, trap style. Even "waiting for the drop" is now so rote that it seems inconceivable for a beat to omit that formulaic element. Not that the other beats were so professional but they were better than the first one IMO. To me, aside from some lack of attention to detail, they were more impressive in terms of originality-even though they're not "radio-ready" at all. Someone like Kendrick will hear a beat like that and turn it into a classic, because he looks for a template for originality. As a producer I understand the ears get refined to anticipate the familiar, but it's sad that the entire game is getting locked in this box and there is no breathing room for innovation.
i feel you but then again what you expect for a few $ Id like to hear what you'd come up with? Unless you charge for that lol
Couldn't agree more. The culture is fucking boring, and wildly un-original. Its just the none-sense. People never switch up the textures of the bass, as new interesting harmonies, its just the same 808's, same drums, same everything. And people actually watch this and say that FIRE BRUH, its not fire its fucking shit and boring. lol
I just started making beats and I'm starting from scratch it's pretty tough with melodies but I'm still learning piano. Trying my very best fr. But awesome vid Bro flute Gang!!!
Kolbeballard use cymatics drum loop i think! 👍
you have to be bad ass at your instrument to survive in this industry, there is no shortcuts. Good music and musicians are timeless never goes out of fashion.
WOW! Really love the first melody I think it fits a Trance melody pretty well! :D
0:15
I'll never financially recover from this
Seen the notification on Discord and went straight on youtube to watch this, great video 🔥🔥🔥. I can't believe no one thought about making a slow dreamy lofi with the piano sample.
Ayyyye yeah that's what I was expecting too with that melody!
This just lets you know how different producers are.
He’s the boss to be like “so, I called you into my office, hehe, your fired, hehe”
Hahahaha
Nice vid Ed! Next time please do a finish version of your beat to show us at the end !
I had this same video idea yesterday and wrote it down! Didn’t even see you did it same day. The first beat was definitely the best, I love the tempo change drop.
Last to me had the best sound but first was best "following the rules" deffff see how last didnt do the most in terms of flippin it but the end result was the most vibez imo. First viddd I've seen by you man and love it ! Subbed x10 !!!!
Yo the Intro "This Is not sponsored, Imma bout to get broked" 😂😂😂
EdTalenti : Not a huge fan of that
Chuki Beats : Ayyy this fireeee!!!!
knew about the upload from the discord
Samee
FLUTEGANG!
That second melody was so hard
I literately ordered a beat from hot banger, a great Russian rapper as well
the last one is fire for real!
Is it just me or did Ed have a face of excitement when it came to the ending transition, the sliding one
Always dope content!!! 💪🏿🤙🏿
Thanks bro!
Send me the first melody I’ll murder it🔥
Producers, charge more for your beats!
Ed , I loved the sample flips but if you don't mind where can i find your original sample u gave to these producers ? I also want to flip the sample for fun !!
Try RUclips to mp3 converter and just sample it.
Yo bro you know if you keep up wit this work I see you being the go to for a voice in in production and mix community ‼️
That last one had a TIGHTTT 808 and snare though
How can you not love Ed? Jeeeeez
That last beat was the best one
YOU ARE GOOD TOWARDS THE NOOB PRODUCERS U R ENCOURAGING THEM
That clap on the first beat was cleaner than a nun's mouth lol
The loop u played and sent makes mostly sense for a lofi beat. First one wasnt bad either in hip hop style.
ayy , great idea . always want it to hear fiverr producers .
Support beat makers/producers!
I love that second melody man that was beautiful 😩
my girlfriend texted me she was home alone and this is the exact message i send back to her:
aye
you: *spams link to Ed's new video*
girlfriend: aye
ight
more like AAAAAYYEEEEE
*girlfriend texted, he SMOL PP
girlfriend: aye
Should have texted “Ifdyageyesinjoieddisvigeodontfurgedtohitdasubscribebuddon”.
That 1st beat is fire. Clean mix
John itm was FOR SURE MY FAVORITE!!
Yo its KolbeBallard! thanks for reviewing my beat! Really appreciate it. I've watched a ton of your vids but never subbed, well... i'm subbed now. Wish I would have put more work into the beat...
Don’t you think you should’ve spent more than 5 minutes on a beat for an actual client? No hate, but a little unprofessional lmao.
i mean it was a pretty good beat. plus ive only ever got 5 stars so i put $5 worth of work into it and make my costumers happy:)
i just got an ad on this video for a midi pack with subtitles. i don’t think a deaf person could use a midi pack
I actually liked the snare in the second beat
Yo this is my favorite RUclips channel! Keep up the good work!
That means a lot man thank you so much 🙏
Good stuff!! Great reactions bro! I was laughin
Will you ever do pop music reviews, like of your fans?
Loving the content!
Also, this isn't my artist name XD
the first one was a banger
The prices hurt me, years of learning to do what i love on professional level and im broke, it fucking hurts
1st id like to say its so fun & exciting to see the different outcomes of what a producer can do with your idea!! The last 1 got my head really boppin! I like the slower tempo, richer bass & Ahh sample. The 1st track came in 2d place. Nice video!!! @EdTalenti
you're very talented bro
I like the ominous vibe too
John's one rmeinds me of oldschool Nelly for some reason. Pretty dope!
I wish I wasn't out of office on my fiverr account. I would have done it for free for you Ed. Keep it going bro
That last beat was definitely worth
dude this video is awesome!! love the positivity too! if you ever do a video reviewing rappers music videos I'd love to submit!
Kinda love These fiverr vids haha idk why 💥💯😂
They're fun to watch and they're super fun to make!
Great Melody. I like making the more depressing stuff for some reason.
Flute gang growing everyday!!! Don't stop
AYYYEE
I like the HotBanger one
and dang, you're the nicest person ive ever known
When are you going to announce the top 16 people in the contest
After the voting round on Discord!
It took me so long to realise the first beat is basically THE SCOTTS
Loved this video. Subscribed.
Hotbanger's beat is actual fire! Insipired me to get a DAW trial and try making something for myself
The last one was 🔥
ayyyyyyee ed back at it again
💯