Im siding with the directors on this. Not knowing that Duke was Noah and that granny was Allie made the movie that much better. It created a better story when you had to connect the dots on your own. I appreciate the directors respecting the audience's intelligence here.
I’m pretty sure this scene is supposed to come after we know who they are/Allie remembering and then freaking out. That’s why the dr is checking on Noah and talking about the disease causing patients to get scared at night a lot. You can also tell by the way Noah talks about how that was the first time she had remembered him in months, and also he collapses in this scene and in the movie, he is unresponsive and being rushed away as he’s not well the night after Allie remembers. I personally think this one was a good one to leave in, it’s the scene where Duke/Noah is telling the dr that she remembers when he reads to her and her playing that same tune on the piano that makes it so obvious who they are, even though it’s a really sweet one!
Watched The Notebook over and over and over again maybe 16+ times and will more than likely watch it many times more. But what I couldn't piece together is why Nick Cassavetes or casting didn't make Rachel McAdams and Ryan Gosling made up to look older. Makeup and hair would've worked. Why Garner and Rowlands? Oh btw Gena Rowlands is Cassavetes' wife in real life.
This all makes sense now for some reason I thought Noah wrote the book and published it I didn’t know she wrote it down and wanted him to read it to her
At the end of the movie they show a note Allie left inside the book it says “read it to me when I can’t remember”. You need to learn to fully and correctly watch a movie. It does make sense because it explains it you just don’t pay attention
To people saying that this scene should've been in the movie cause it shows that Allie wrote the book- there was already a scene where in the front of the book it said 'Read this to me to help me remember,' indicating that Allie definitely wrote the book. But apparently a lot of people didn't catch that, or even realized that the old couple is Noah and Allie?? Also, I feel like there were many signs that Allie wrote the book throughout the movie.
It wasn't until close to the end of the movie that I even realized that the narrator and the old lady were actually Allie and Noah. Also there was a time when you didn't know whether Allie was going to come back to Noah or go ahead and marry the rich guy. But I think they must have had many happy years of marriage before she started getting the Alzheimer's, because they raised children together and had grandchildren. But once she forgot who he and the children were, it was like losing her again just like he did in his youth.
I had doubts that they were actually Noah and Allie Like the stories matched so much and it made sense.But at the ending when she forgets him again and panics and Noah is left their crying,it broke my heart.
I knew he was reading to remind her of who she was. The children visit in the movie and I think he introduced them as his children, but spoke to them away from her and they called her mom or something. Not sure how anyone could be surprised that the old pair is anyone other than Noah and Allie
There’s quite a few deleted scenes... they should have kept them all... I would have enjoyed a longer version of this movie The chemistry is amazing from both Ally’s & both Noah’s
They shouldn't have deleted this scene, it is actually very important for those who didn't read the book to understand why Noah reads the book to Allie... :/
It had already showed that when her memory comes back it only lasts a few minutes so by the time he crawled in bed with her she would have started freaking out and they would not have just went to sleep and died together so what happened is he saved up several of his strong heart pills by missing a dose here and there by letting the pill go under his tongue and pretending to swallow it at the medication window.And while she was all there they both agreed to pop the pills and check out together.He had planed to do it when they had the romantic dinner and thats why she made reference to all his pills which he should not have had because all medication was distributed at the medication window.He was not able to carry out his plan at the dinner because when her memory came back this time it did not stay as long as he had hoped but he was persistent and finally was able to carry out his plan. You can't think of it as bad for what he did because it had got to the point where her memory coming back was less frequent and was staying for less time when it did come back and he knew when it stoped coming back she would be off limits to him and she as well as him would soon die away from each other. Once you know the whole story the ending makes sense but there were several reason why they could not write the details in but left it to the audience to figure it out but a lot of people never caught the slight hints and to this day have never understood the ending as it really happened.
@@SerenaHSerena77Elvis2 I've seen Somewhere In Time a few times and it was perfectly cast becausr Jane Seymour has always been a classic and timeless beauty.
Why the heck did they deleted this part.?. Its kind of an important scene to.. Im this scene makes it all sense.. Well not the parr of this scene tho..
It was so easy to get caught up in how they met, fell in love and had to part ect. that you momentarily overlook.that the story is really about them in the present and it's so heartbreakingly sad and horrifying. as well.. You lose things along the way. But then you start to lose people and worst of all is losing your Love ! Rowlands and Garner were magnificent in playing the older Allie and Noah finding and losing each other day by day ! From experience, I know and you are never quite the same !
This is just a movie afterall. In reality, doctor doesnt want to spend alot of time with their patients, or cant afford to with their time restriction. Sometimes the patient is not yet finish talking and the doctor already prescribing medication or writing referral for other specialist.
if THIS is the scene that lets you know it’s Noah and Allie and not just context clues then that’s sad. who else would be the old couple? like how is is THAT important
This is clearly not a good scene. If you're not dumb you understand by yourself that they're Allie and Noah. Guessing by yourself is what makes the magic of the film
Ok not romantic but they could have recorded using a camcorder when Ali assigned the reading thing to him. Watching the video could have helped Ali remember or realize?
This is my favourite delated scene should have it in the movie would have more sense first I watched I he was duke and realise till very end he Noah the whole time they have him having the heartattack and replace it with this him having the heart attack have a delated scene and replaced with this one
I siding with Allie not the Directors of the movie I may ask for her to come find me if you please have her see me if Allie can have a choice to take that chance to recognize me and to acknowledge me if the movie crew and co directors to take my side and to agree with me
I am connecting the dots because I am asking for answers that I could be a easier help for Allie if you and the crew would offer it to me as a nice jester will you guys agree to send me there if you guys give me a chance to try please 🙏
@@tatyanaharmon7566 It was in the version I initially saw when the movie was first released on DVD years ago, but when I re-watched it in 2022 on TV it wasn't. The ending on TV did show them passing away together, and I have been told there is a version with birds flying over a pond instead of that scene. How many versions are there?
Im siding with the directors on this. Not knowing that Duke was Noah and that granny was Allie made the movie that much better. It created a better story when you had to connect the dots on your own. I appreciate the directors respecting the audience's intelligence here.
I’m pretty sure this scene is supposed to come after we know who they are/Allie remembering and then freaking out. That’s why the dr is checking on Noah and talking about the disease causing patients to get scared at night a lot. You can also tell by the way Noah talks about how that was the first time she had remembered him in months, and also he collapses in this scene and in the movie, he is unresponsive and being rushed away as he’s not well the night after Allie remembers. I personally think this one was a good one to leave in, it’s the scene where Duke/Noah is telling the dr that she remembers when he reads to her and her playing that same tune on the piano that makes it so obvious who they are, even though it’s a really sweet one!
Same
@@siobhanx89yes this scene was supposed to happen after her freaking out on him
Watched The Notebook over and over and over again maybe 16+ times and will more than likely watch it many times more. But what I couldn't piece together is why Nick Cassavetes or casting didn't make Rachel McAdams and Ryan Gosling made up to look older. Makeup and hair would've worked. Why Garner and Rowlands? Oh btw Gena Rowlands is Cassavetes' wife in real life.
Gena Rowlands was previously married to John Cassavetes †, who is the father of Nick Cassavetes (director of The Notebook)
This all makes sense now for some reason I thought Noah wrote the book and published it I didn’t know she wrote it down and wanted him to read it to her
Shmooboogie Harper it's at the end of the movie, he's reading it and the words on the front page shows you..
At the end of the movie they show a note Allie left inside the book it says “read it to me when I can’t remember”. You need to learn to fully and correctly watch a movie. It does make sense because it explains it you just don’t pay attention
At the end you can see in it written in the front page "read it to me and I'll come back to you"
The book says her name on it. "Read this to me and I'll come back to you"
To my love Noah Read this to me and I will come back to you.
That was beautiful what she told him on the porch.❤
Best part, would be nice if she draw on the porch
@@hoangpham7371 😂😂
A lot of these deleted scenes fill in the blanks. I really appreciate them.
To people saying that this scene should've been in the movie cause it shows that Allie wrote the book- there was already a scene where in the front of the book it said 'Read this to me to help me remember,' indicating that Allie definitely wrote the book. But apparently a lot of people didn't catch that, or even realized that the old couple is Noah and Allie?? Also, I feel like there were many signs that Allie wrote the book throughout the movie.
Simply one of the best love storys of my generation. Love it
I wish they never deleted this scene because it’s very interesting seeing Allie while her mind is still sharp writing the notebook for Noah.
It wasn't until close to the end of the movie that I even realized that the narrator and the old lady were actually Allie and Noah. Also there was a time when you didn't know whether Allie was going to come back to Noah or go ahead and marry the rich guy. But I think they must have had many happy years of marriage before she started getting the Alzheimer's, because they raised children together and had grandchildren. But once she forgot who he and the children were, it was like losing her again just like he did in his youth.
I had doubts that they were actually Noah and Allie
Like the stories matched so much and it made sense.But at the ending when she forgets him again and panics and Noah is left their crying,it broke my heart.
I knew he was reading to remind her of who she was. The children visit in the movie and I think he introduced them as his children, but spoke to them away from her and they called her mom or something. Not sure how anyone could be surprised that the old pair is anyone other than Noah and Allie
It's so sad yet sweet when they just lie down and die in the nursing home bed , holding each others hands
I love this scene...even though it wasn’t in the movie I’m glad they filmed it so I can watch it now 😢🥰
That last part gave me a heart attack too!! Intense!!
WOOOOOOW, now it feels like the story fully connects!!
True love, two hearts and one soul. ❤❤
They deleted too many good scenes out this movie
This is an amazing scene. It should have been squeezed in.
One of maybe 5 movies that can make my dad cry, especially if my mom is there
I want a guy that would dedacate hes whole life to making me remember him every day
Unless he's a stalker tho..😁✌ be careful what u wish for.
I was going to say, unless he's a stalker. You can take mine, please?
Awe and she remembered that was great idea to write it all down
Pretty important scene to have deleted. But funny how you still “get it” without this.
cause it’s not important
this should have been in the movie
There’s quite a few deleted scenes... they should have kept them all... I would have enjoyed a longer version of this movie
The chemistry is amazing from both Ally’s & both Noah’s
They must have put the deleted scenes in the version they show on TV.
Those are the scenes missing from some versions shown on TV.
It is only with the heart that one can live forever.
This movie is the best love story
OMG!! they shouldn't deleted this sceeeennneee!!!
I know it. Why did they delete it?
Do you know God?
They shouldn't have deleted this scene, it is actually very important for those who didn't read the book to understand why Noah reads the book to Allie... :/
Agreed
Belen Navarro but it makes the ending all the better when the audience realises
Natalie Hdz now i understand the moive
If you are tooo stupid to realize the end then idk what to say
I've never read the book and I thought it was obvious
Does love like that really exist? I think it's rare
It's a movie geez 🤨
It had already showed that when her memory comes back it only lasts a few minutes so by the time he crawled in bed with her she would have started freaking out and they would not have just went to sleep and died together so what happened is he saved up several of his strong heart pills by missing a dose here and there by letting the pill go under his tongue and pretending to swallow it at the medication window.And while she was all there they both agreed to pop the pills and check out together.He had planed to do it when they had the romantic dinner and thats why she made reference to all his pills which he should not have had because all medication was distributed at the medication window.He was not able to carry out his plan at the dinner because when her memory came back this time it did not stay as long as he had hoped but he was persistent and finally was able to carry out his plan. You can't think of it as bad for what he did because it had got to the point where her memory coming back was less frequent and was staying for less time when it did come back and he knew when it stoped coming back she would be off limits to him and she as well as him would soon die away from each other. Once you know the whole story the ending makes sense but there were several reason why they could not write the details in but left it to the audience to figure it out but a lot of people never caught the slight hints and to this day have never understood the ending as it really happened.
I remember seeing this when I watched on the tv version so maybe they only deleted on the movie?
So sad they cut this scene! That's why in the night the nurse tells him "take it easy you just had a heart attack" 😮
So allie wrote the book OMG....😭😭😭😭😭
The Notebook : Come back to you
Somewhere in Time : Come back to me
Can you pls explain
Chris Silva If you seen the movie somewhere in time it’s about a man from the present going to the past to meet a woman Who he falls in love with
Exactly right about that and I've watched both of those movies.
@@SerenaHSerena77Elvis2 I've seen Somewhere In Time a few times and it was perfectly cast becausr Jane Seymour has always been a classic and timeless beauty.
I wish they kept it I read the book but I will think it is important
MY HEART IS SHATTERED INTO 1,000 PIECES AT THE DEATH OF GENA ROWLANDS AGE 94 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
And this is love.
My son Robbie is in need of his mothers love here. It's all waiting right here.
Omg why did this get deleted?! They should have kept this in!
This scene is in the book
Why oh why did they delete this scene! It was very important to the movie!
I have a Notebook with piece and pieces back in 2011
Why the heck did they deleted this part.?. Its kind of an important scene to.. Im this scene makes it all sense.. Well not the parr of this scene tho..
This is the scene of the show
LOVE GENA ROWLANDS WITH ALL MY HEART AND ALWAYS WILL 💕💕💕💕💕
I wish this scene had made it to the final cut....
great acting in these scenes, but im glad these werent added in the movie. Made for very perfect surprise int he movie.
I knew he was Noah before it was revealed he was Noah I know it when he was reading the book to her
QUE MARAVILLOSA PELÍCULA,CON UN GRAN GUION Y UNA INTERPRETACIÓN REAL MENTE EXTRAORDINARIA,,
It was so easy to get caught up in how they met, fell in love and had to part ect. that you momentarily overlook.that the story is really about them in the present and it's so heartbreakingly sad and horrifying. as well..
You lose things along the way. But then you start to lose people and worst of all is losing your Love !
Rowlands and Garner were magnificent in playing the older Allie and Noah finding and losing each other day by day !
From experience, I know and you are never quite the same !
this scene should never have been deleted.
Can someone add these deleted scenes in the movie...😭...I badly want to re-watch the notebook with these deleted scenes
This is just a movie afterall. In reality, doctor doesnt want to spend alot of time with their patients, or cant afford to with their time restriction. Sometimes the patient is not yet finish talking and the doctor already prescribing medication or writing referral for other specialist.
You have been to some really crappy doctors.
i believe that i'll come back to you
How could they delete this scene it is the most important one
I wish they kept this in the movie
I wish they at least included in the movie that she wrote the book
how we love ech other
Should have left this in
Wait, the most important scene in the movie is a deleted scene?!?
if THIS is the scene that lets you know it’s Noah and Allie and not just context clues then that’s sad. who else would be the old couple? like how is is THAT important
@@Mh-xe1zhthis is literally after we find out its them. it is the most important bc it shows how and why the notebook is even here
This is clearly not a good scene. If you're not dumb you understand by yourself that they're Allie and Noah. Guessing by yourself is what makes the magic of the film
Essa história de amor é 1000 VEZES melhor que a (droga) de Romeo e Julieta.
Ok. My question has been answered. Thanks to this vids.
But why they deleted this scene?
this is the important Part of the old part of them.
I just saw this segment on TV and was confused because I have never seen it before. I prefer the movie without this segment.
Same here, last night - I thought I was losing MY mind as well! Lol
i’m glad this scene was deleted, it made the movie prettier by showing the notebook’ title page at the end, it’s a mind twist
My god,,,, leave the deleted scene in the movie...
thank you baby l love you you are full of surprises oxxooxoxoxoxoxo
Why the fuck was this deleted????!
Ok not romantic but they could have recorded using a camcorder when Ali assigned the reading thing to him. Watching the video could have helped Ali remember or realize?
Perfect angle and idea!
WHY WOULD THEY DELETE THIS 😭
♥️
This would ruins everything
They really shouldn't have deleted scenes. It spoiled the movie
Why did they delete this scene?!!!
I promise you.
This scene is deleted what the hell...
Where did Allie’s beautiful southern accent go? The older actor doesn’t have it anymore
This is my favourite delated scene should have it in the movie would have more sense first I watched I he was duke and realise till very end he Noah the whole time they have him having the heartattack and replace it with this him having the heart attack have a delated scene and replaced with this one
Excellent job deleting the scene. The Tittle say it all, you need to figure out..
I mean why is Noah on haldol that's a powerful antipsychotic
تشبه حبوبتي الله يرحمها
Why??.. this should have been left in the movie..!!
ما شاء الله مثقفين
I siding with Allie not the Directors of the movie I may ask for her to come find me if you please have her see me if Allie can have a choice to take that chance to recognize me and to acknowledge me if the movie crew and co directors to take my side and to agree with me
ПОЧЕМУУУУУУ ЭТО ВЫРЕЗАЛИ
I am connecting the dots because I am asking for answers that I could be a easier help for Allie if you and the crew would offer it to me as a nice jester will you guys agree to send me there if you guys give me a chance to try please 🙏
Why did he faint?
Jaclyn Schilt heart attack
Heart failure
@@peaceman4u so it was deleted cuz that wasnt how he was supposed to die yet?
why do i feel like that was in the movie. idk ehy
What did disease did noah have?
Heart trouble. he loved Allie 2 hard no just kidding
Noah didn't have any disease .. He stay there for allie so she wouldn't be alone.. Noah love her too much to let her go.
Uhhh ..This was in the movie
No it wasn’t
@@tatyanaharmon7566 It was in the version I initially saw when the movie was first released on DVD years ago, but when I re-watched it in 2022 on TV it wasn't. The ending on TV did show them passing away together, and I have been told there is a version with birds flying over a pond instead of that scene. How many versions are there?