I have heard this piece played so many times; this is the rendition that has always played in my own mind. The compassion with which Ms Osetinskaya approaches Bach is breathtaking.
I agree with you. Polina's version is by far the best, most meaningful and most appropriate that captures the music and lyrics. Not showey at all like the rest of the other performers playing the same piece. May God bless you Polina🙏🏿♥️
Yes, I *think* this could be my new favorite reading and performance of this. A nice, expressive tempo, yet just a bit slower that what I've heard in other performances - though I *like it* - she gets a couple of extra notes in the trills this way, while still sounding so elegant.
It is an amazingly serene experience for us, esp. In these turbulent times. I can't help but think how a newborn or child would react to this. It would be the most peaceful and perfect lullaby. Polina has a deep understanding of Bach music.
Polina, I don`t know you ever will read this, but I want to say thank you from the bottom of my heart for all the hours I listend to many music interpretations played by you. You make a difference!
@@polinaosetinskaya127 Loved the Chaconne of Bach for your teachers. And then I think I would like to ask you : what are the circumstances or feelings that the interpretations of other times are really different, Anyway I like them all!!
I remember this Bach piece from my oh so distant past (I am 57)...I knew I loved it then. Miss Polina...you have made it sooo special. I am in tears at this moment. Music so helps the soul...
Такая музыка поддерживает и дает силы жить. Бах одарил все человечество на многие века. А вы, Полина, даете жизнь этой великой, вечной музыке. Я часто вас слушаю. Спасибо вам
Полина, у Вас уникальная манера исполнения Баха - лучшая из всех которые я когда либо слышал. Вы одна из немногих пианистов, которые не кривляются во время игры и это выглядит со стороны очень красиво, гармонично и естественно.
4 года назад+18
Indeed. No affectation whatsoever from her. She just lets Bach flow.
Can there be more exquisite music in the universe? This pianist has the perfect touch. Truly Masterful playing! So calming and relaxing to hear. Thank you, thank you beautiful Polina!
Once I had enough Russian to negotiate the Streets of Petersburg, but not enough to say in her own language what I feel and think as she plays. I am revisiting Russian in the hope I could even approximate but my Russian will never be equal to my estimate of her as a person, as a musician. Had I known she existed earlier I would have been more assiduous in my Russian. But I will work at it, just so my words are not an empty gesture or mere flattery.
Созвучна с Вами!Прочла то,что хотела бы сказать сама."Овечки могут пастись спокойно.Бог охраняет их" примерно так звучит текст этой арии из Охотничей кантаты.
@@nataliafomina5846 по глубинно сути -это хорал ... органная хоральная прелюдия... и играть ее надо легче, вокальнее , облачно....веря в Бога. у нее только в конце похоже...
Какой величественный звук, удивительное звучание, словно колокольное, и вместе с тем мягкое, умиротворяющее, умиротворенное. Песнь миру. Гимн миру. Благословение людям. Спасибо и всего самого благословенного Вам!
It must take a lifetime to play Bach in such musical perfection. Such nuance, such emotion, such incredible taste. Please record more Bach. I would also love to hear your version of Beethovens Hammerklaviersonata.
Это просто потрясающее исполнение... Звук, артикуляция, голосоведение, настолько всё точно, тонко и гармонично, что просто невозможно оторваться ни на секунду... Слушаю каждый день и каждый раз слышу по новому... Спасибо огромное Вам Полина... Ждём от вас новых шедевров....
A pianist of real integrity:a probing intellect balanced by feeling devoid of sentimentality and showiness.She reminds me of the great Maria Tipo,now sadly neglected.
Thought I'd say thanks, Andrew. Had never heard of Tipo and on your recommendation, clicked a random track of her playing a Chopin ballade. Holy Cow!! She's absolutely mind-blowing.
So true Andrew...too many other showy pianists on youtube today, even amongst those playing this piece- some body movements seems inappropriate n seems to be for showy display only.! However Polina does not do that in this piece. There are other body movements and hand movements that are totally appropriate while playing the piano tho😊. Polina expresses it all Beautifully in this piece.
The visual should not intrude into one's appreciation of music but I confess that this elegant figure, alone at the keyboard, in a simple black dress [she always seemms to wear a black dress for public recitals and concerts] adds to the limpid beauty of her music. It is difficult, visually, as well as aurally, to resist her infinite charm of presence as well as er consumate musicianship. It is so exquisite and restful. Just the conditions to listen to Bach.
Thank you. I love this pianist, I cannot think of ay other pianist except perhaps Hélène Grimaud who seems so emotionally immersed in her performance. The Sicilianna is also exquisite. Good listening she rewards it.@@Tony.Hokkaido
Это точно лучшее исполнение, из того что я слышал, до этого слушал эту же транскрипцию в другом исполнении, не буду говорить какой пианистки, и после того исполнения, исполнение Полины показалось просто божественным Насколько то исполнение приземленное, настолько это возвышенное и очищенное от всего от страстей я бы сказал и даже в некотором роде эмоций... Браво Полина! Невероятно мягкое и гармоничное во всем звукоизвлечение! Эта запись будет со мной до конца жизни! Спасибо за это виновнику всех благ - Богу! Ну и потом конечно Баху и Вам!
How come I only find out about you today Polina? after listening to classical music for the last 30 years.... was stunned while listening to your Bach Concerto 1 in D minor and luckily that I found you here....thank God and RUclips AI, you are a great opening for my 2021 classical music journey, and I will not miss your play again moving forward... thank you for setting your own channel ...
Oh my god Polina, how can you not love yourself? Your delicacy is similar to a hummingbird as it enters a flower, your fingers the flapping of wings. You are of infinite sweetness. Grazie Polina, benvenuta in Italia❤️😘✨🌹
@@polinaosetinskaya127 It was a way of saying that it is absolutely natural to love you as soon as you see yourself playing the piano. Finally I can admire you in person when you play with the violinist Maxim Vengerov. Thanks for the reply. Ciao Polina
We wait impatiently for Polina in London and can only hope that she soon will record the F Minor Concerto and so be the veritable heir to Edwin Fischer and Lukas Foss. Maybe autumn 2021 will be a better year and you can come....this is so measured and perfect just like your playing of BWV 1052 - the best!
After listening to Osetinskaya performing several Bach pieces I'm left with an unexpected impression. I have the feeling that she allows the music to play itself, and she iis just the carrier of it. She doesn't impose herself on the piece. I love a lot of Bach renditions by others, but in them I feel as if the pianist is showing his or her interpretation. With Osetinskaya, it's the music.
Para mi es la que mejor toca en el mundo , su claridad y limpieza al tocar cada nota, además ella siente la melodía hay otros pianistas muy mecánicos, rápidos pero no trasmiten nada, !!!!! Felicidades y gracias Polina !!!!!👋🏻👏🏻🙌🏻🇲🇽🙌🏻👌🙌🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👋🏻👋🏻
A truly philosopher of the piano, who goes the deepest down. The music is invoked more than played (the first time I perceive this in a painist). We love the self-living music you play and its own identity, because it's not just special, it's unique 🌹God lives within your music (more of course when it comes to Bach pieces ^^), and we wish wholerheartedly that he gives to you Polina a long life full of Grace 💗🙏
As a pianist, I can really appreciate the difficulty in making those mid range voices so clear when you're also playing chords with high notes. The polyphony is not lost on me. Truly one of the most difficult aspects of the piano, and she does it effortlessly. Great tempo control, as well.
J'ai découvert cette pianiste sur le concerto n°1 de Bach 1052. Depuis, je n'arrive pas à m'en remettre. L'émotion est toujours aussi grande même après avoir écouté ces morceaux à plus de vingt reprises. Je rêve de la voir en France. Un jour peut-être ? Vive la sainte Russie et vive la France.
Beautiful play! The grand piano has a nice warm soubd. Bach helps me through the day, especially in these difficult times. Bach deeply believed in god and so his music is spiritual.
Bravo 🙏🙏🙏 I am very touched and feel the tranquility tempo of the sheep grazing . The tempo is appropriately set according to the word” Safely grazing “ , this is the impact of the performance and feeing safe .
Благодарю сердечно! Наилучшее исполнение! Нежно, звонко, трогательно, космически уносит в высшее измерение. Музыкальное произведение - это межпространственый корабль, умелый музыкант - это Водитель и Проводник туда, куда стремится дух и душа человека, в гармоничное сияющее пространство Творчества и Красоты, и совершенной Гармонии с миром.
Видеоклипы
Magic
She is simply one of the best pianist today
Absolutely. Perfect tempo too.
I have heard this piece played so many times; this is the rendition that has always played in my own mind. The compassion with which Ms Osetinskaya approaches Bach is breathtaking.
I agree with you. Polina's version is by far the best, most meaningful and most appropriate that captures the music and lyrics. Not showey at all like the rest of the other performers playing the same piece. May God bless you Polina🙏🏿♥️
@@jenniferjoyner112o
Támbien estoy plenamente de acuerdo con los otros melómanos del hiper genial BACH.
This is the best interpretation of my favorite Bach melody that I've ever heard.
Yes, I *think* this could be my new favorite reading and performance of this. A nice, expressive tempo, yet just a bit slower that what I've heard in other performances - though I *like it* - she gets a couple of extra notes in the trills this way, while still sounding so elegant.
Nice to hear a rendition of this where it doesn't sound like the pianist is late to catch a train.
It is an amazingly serene experience for us, esp. In these turbulent times. I can't help but think how a newborn or child would react to this. It would be the most peaceful and perfect lullaby. Polina has a deep understanding of Bach music.
Polina, I don`t know you ever will read this, but I want to say thank you from the bottom of my heart for all the hours I listend to many music interpretations played by you. You make a difference!
Thank you!
@@polinaosetinskaya127 Loved the Chaconne of Bach for your teachers. And then I think I would like to ask you : what are the circumstances or feelings that the interpretations of other times are really different, Anyway I like them all!!
I remember this Bach piece from my oh so distant past (I am 57)...I knew I loved it then. Miss Polina...you have made it sooo special. I am in tears at this moment. Music so helps the soul...
Такая музыка поддерживает и дает силы жить. Бах одарил все человечество на многие века. А вы, Полина, даете жизнь этой великой, вечной музыке. Я часто вас слушаю. Спасибо вам
One of the best piano recordings I've heard in a long time!! Beautiful interpretation of the music.
Полина, у Вас уникальная манера исполнения Баха - лучшая из всех которые я когда либо слышал. Вы одна из немногих пианистов, которые не кривляются во время игры и это выглядит со стороны очень красиво, гармонично и естественно.
Indeed. No affectation whatsoever from her. She just lets Bach flow.
Let Bach may safely flow!@
Can there be more exquisite music in the universe? This pianist has the perfect touch. Truly Masterful playing! So calming and relaxing to hear. Thank you, thank you beautiful Polina!
Once I had enough Russian to negotiate the Streets of Petersburg, but not enough to say in her own language what I feel and think as she plays. I am revisiting Russian in the hope I could even approximate but my Russian will never be equal to my estimate of her as a person, as a musician. Had I known she existed earlier I would have been more assiduous in my Russian. But I will work at it, just so my words are not an empty gesture or mere flattery.
Polina should be inducted into the Steinway Artist Hall of Fame and be sponsored by Deutsche Grammophon.
Какая прелесть,мир,любовь и покой!
Так не хватает этих чувств в наше время,а Бах нам дал это услышать.
Полину обожаю! Браво! Брависсимо!
Созвучна с Вами!Прочла то,что хотела бы сказать сама."Овечки могут пастись спокойно.Бог охраняет их" примерно так звучит текст этой арии из Охотничей кантаты.
@@nataliafomina5846 💯
@@nataliafomina5846 по глубинно сути -это хорал ... органная хоральная прелюдия... и играть ее надо легче, вокальнее , облачно....веря в Бога. у нее только в конце похоже...
Какой величественный звук, удивительное звучание, словно колокольное, и вместе с тем мягкое, умиротворяющее, умиротворенное. Песнь миру. Гимн миру. Благословение людям. Спасибо и всего самого благословенного Вам!
послушайте Адама Джоржи, есть здесь тоже....и потом сравните:) зчем колокольное?:)) Это же имитация органа или голоса... это хорал!
Heard this piece and bought album, no questions asked. I knew she was going to be profound about her Bach!
The world is worth living more with such music played by such an excellent artist.
Amazing quality. The old Bach would be proud.
It must take a lifetime to play Bach in such musical perfection.
Such nuance, such emotion, such incredible taste. Please record more Bach.
I would also love to hear your version of Beethovens Hammerklaviersonata.
Это просто потрясающее исполнение... Звук, артикуляция, голосоведение, настолько всё точно, тонко и гармонично, что просто невозможно оторваться ни на секунду... Слушаю каждый день и каждый раз слышу по новому... Спасибо огромное Вам Полина... Ждём от вас новых шедевров....
Лучшее исполнение Баха, что я слышал и видел. Спасибо Вам!
Безгранично благодарен судьбе, что живу и слышу эту мелодию в великолепном исполнении Полины Осетинской. Спасибо Вам!
Die Arie sollte man dem Putin und anderen Diktatoren jedes Morgen vorsingen.
Маэстро Полина, вы такое чувство влагаете в свою музыку!! Вообще Невероятно
Спасибо Полина! За яркость красок, за позитив, за красоту и полет в космос которые вы передали! Музыка которую хочется слушать много раз!
Полина спасибо за нелегкий труд музыканта и за то что играете Баха! Жизнь в которой есть Бах благословенна.
So true Olga
A pianist of real integrity:a probing intellect balanced by feeling devoid of sentimentality and showiness.She reminds me of the great Maria Tipo,now sadly neglected.
Thought I'd say thanks, Andrew. Had never heard of Tipo and on your recommendation, clicked a random track of her playing a Chopin ballade. Holy Cow!! She's absolutely mind-blowing.
So true Andrew...too many other showy pianists on youtube today, even amongst those playing this piece- some body movements seems inappropriate n seems to be for showy display only.! However Polina does not do that in this piece. There are other body movements and hand movements that are totally appropriate while playing the piano tho😊. Polina expresses it all Beautifully in this piece.
@@jenniferjoyner112 Totally agree Jennifer.
Такое теплое, светлое, кристальное исполнение. Браво.
When you combine beauty and nice playing, simply heavenly
The visual should not intrude into one's appreciation of music but I confess that this elegant figure, alone at the keyboard, in a simple black dress [she always seemms to wear a black dress for public recitals and concerts] adds to the limpid beauty of her music. It is difficult, visually, as well as aurally, to resist her infinite charm of presence as well as er consumate musicianship. It is so exquisite and restful. Just the conditions to listen to Bach.
…. “limpid beauty of her music” - exactly! Well said,poet.
Thank you. I love this pianist, I cannot think of ay other pianist except perhaps Hélène Grimaud who seems so emotionally immersed in her performance. The Sicilianna is also exquisite. Good listening she rewards it.@@Tony.Hokkaido
@@benedictcowell6547 For those not familiar with the musical term: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siciliana
Это точно лучшее исполнение, из того что я слышал, до этого слушал эту же транскрипцию в другом исполнении, не буду говорить какой пианистки, и после того исполнения, исполнение Полины показалось просто божественным
Насколько то исполнение приземленное, настолько это возвышенное и очищенное от всего от страстей я бы сказал и даже в некотором роде эмоций...
Браво Полина!
Невероятно мягкое и гармоничное во всем звукоизвлечение! Эта запись будет со мной до конца жизни!
Спасибо за это виновнику всех благ - Богу!
Ну и потом конечно Баху и Вам!
Любимый Бах в исполнении любимой Полины!
Это точно !!!! Красивая и божественная
Полина, Сердечно рад и благодарен Вам за очередную встречу с Вашим неповторимым, чудесным исполнением музыки Великого И.С. Баха.
Like in heaven!! I love and enjoy the way you play Bach ! превосходна ❤️
How come I only find out about you today Polina? after listening to classical music for the last 30 years.... was stunned while listening to your Bach Concerto 1 in D minor and luckily that I found you here....thank God and RUclips AI, you are a great opening for my 2021 classical music journey, and I will not miss your play again moving forward... thank you for setting your own channel ...
I can have a bad day at work or something but this makes me melt like warm butter.
Love this woman!
Greetings from Wisconsin, USA!
Снесибо Полина ханум! Прекрасно! Влюбился в ваше исполнение после концерта 1052... ваш кумир из Баку 🤩
Храни Вас Господь! 🙏
Тут все прекрасне! Так майже не буває, а виявляється є!
Невозможно словами выразить красоту этой божественной музыки. Брависсимо!
..какая красивая и чувственная женщина!🤔
You show a masterful reddition of all the lines each with high sensitivity. We listen to an orchestra. We're in heaven of musicians.
Wunderbar vorgetragen, bitte noch mehr! Vielen herzlichen Dank. Es ist Balsam für die Seele!💥🕯💚🙋♀️
Очень нежно и душевно
Supremely serene - this is truly magnificent. Thank you forever, Полина!
Oh my god Polina, how can you not love yourself? Your delicacy is similar to a hummingbird as it enters a flower, your fingers the flapping of wings. You are of infinite sweetness. Grazie Polina, benvenuta in Italia❤️😘✨🌹
Maurizio Bui why am I not love myself?) will be playing in Milano on May 19-th and Torino on May 27
@@polinaosetinskaya127 It was a way of saying that it is absolutely natural to love you as soon as you see yourself playing the piano. Finally I can admire you in person when you play with the violinist Maxim Vengerov. Thanks for the reply. Ciao Polina
Bravo, Polina ! You and Grigory Sokolov are the only hope, the Russians know how to play Bach...
Perfect interpretation, I appreciate the relaxed tempo - allows the music to breathe.🎹🌹💜💕🎵
Полная идиллия: красивая(гениальная) музыка, красивая пианистка, красивая подача материала - что ещё нужно для счастья?
Немного бласт-бита. Но не всё сразу!
Słuchałam różnych wykonań ale to jest NAJPIĘKNIEJSZE ! Rosyjska dusza .
Realmente diferente
Thank you for such a beautiful recording! Pure joy.
We wait impatiently for Polina in London and can only hope that she soon will record the F Minor Concerto and so be the veritable heir to Edwin Fischer and Lukas Foss. Maybe autumn 2021 will be a better year and you can come....this is so measured and perfect just like your playing of BWV 1052 - the best!
Das ist traumhaft schön!! Ruhe und himmlischer Frieden stellen sich beim Zuhören ein ...
With 4 inches of rain today, and my old roof leaking, this piece saved me today. Thank you *SO* much.
Какая красивая Полина Осетинская!
After listening to Osetinskaya performing several Bach pieces I'm left with an unexpected impression. I have the feeling that she allows the music to play itself, and she iis just the carrier of it. She doesn't impose herself on the piece. I love a lot of Bach renditions by others, but in them I feel as if the pianist is showing his or her interpretation. With Osetinskaya, it's the music.
Semplicemente favolosa, a parte il fatto che Polina è bellissima, ma questa esecuzione mi fa letteralmente volare tra le nuvole!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Как всегда, божественна...
Everyone deserves serenity like this.
Слушаю и слезы льются....
Куда льются?
Por mucho, la MEJOR versión de esta obra de Bach.
¡Saludos desde México!
Класс, стиль, порода!
Para mi es la que mejor toca en el mundo , su claridad y limpieza al tocar cada nota, además ella siente la melodía hay otros pianistas muy mecánicos, rápidos pero no trasmiten nada, !!!!! Felicidades y gracias Polina !!!!!👋🏻👏🏻🙌🏻🇲🇽🙌🏻👌🙌🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👋🏻👋🏻
She certainly knows how to make this piece speak. Absolutely beautiful. One of my favorite works of art.
You never fail to bring the tears. From the heart, god bless you. And the sound team, my god, such a fantastic job, the quality is breathtaking.
Very beautiful rendition of Bach’s wonderful music! Thanks for posting! 🌹🥰🦋🪴💐🎹🎶🎈👍😀🦋
First English comment! That was lovely, I am always happy when you play Bach.
I totally agree!!!
Que bom.
First Scottish comment.....I also love your Bach Keyboard Concerto
Оставлял комментарий еще до миллиона подписчиков!
Браво!!! такава изящност,такава красота!!!
Beautiful ❤
The voicing is challenging for me, but hers is absolutely gorgeous!
Полина молодец, как кораблик, плывущий по облакам, получилось - очень здорово
Feeling a gentle breeze, listening this soft sound, sewing
hem of my trousers,
noticing that i'm happy.😊
Thanks to Polina
Why does this melody touch my heart so? I feel emotional and close to tears. Love this piece.
Merci Polina pour cette très belle interprétation (Спасибо, Полина, за эту прекрасную интерпретацию)
Just beautiful.
Gracias Polina ¡ saludos y abrazos desde Chile. Paz, Armonía y Luz para tí.
By far the best performance I've heard of this piece.
A truly philosopher of the piano, who goes the deepest down. The music is invoked more than played (the first time I perceive this in a painist). We love the self-living music you play and its own identity, because it's not just special, it's unique 🌹God lives within your music (more of course when it comes to Bach pieces ^^), and we wish wholerheartedly that he gives to you Polina a long life full of Grace 💗🙏
Thank you so much!🙏
Awesome. A sensitive and delicate rendering with impeccable timing and phrasing
Бриллиант!❤
So so beautiful....tears in my eyes.
Beautiful ! Gorgeous middlevoice colourings !
Incredible, n'est-ce pas???? She just follows those inner voices.... as her predecessor Tatyana Nikolayevna did long ago.
This song is melancholy and at once also hopeful...
This Is really collorfull, its just crazy that Bach can sound like This
As a pianist, I can really appreciate the difficulty in making those mid range voices so clear when you're also playing chords with high notes. The polyphony is not lost on me. Truly one of the most difficult aspects of the piano, and she does it effortlessly. Great tempo control, as well.
When Beauty meets Bach, everything becomes right with the world... Fear vanishes.
J'ai découvert cette pianiste sur le concerto n°1 de Bach 1052. Depuis, je n'arrive pas à m'en remettre. L'émotion est toujours aussi grande même après avoir écouté ces morceaux à plus de vingt reprises.
Je rêve de la voir en France. Un jour peut-être ?
Vive la sainte Russie et vive la France.
Beautiful play! The grand piano has a nice warm soubd. Bach helps me through the day, especially in these difficult times. Bach deeply believed in god and so his music is spiritual.
Bravo 🙏🙏🙏 I am very touched and feel the tranquility tempo of the sheep grazing . The tempo is appropriately set according to the word” Safely grazing “ , this is the impact of the performance and feeing safe .
The utmost mastery. Polina, you are the music and the music is you. Warmest regards and simply, thank you.
Heavenly piece and playing. Bach is the best.
A smashing studio recording - both performance and engineering.
What a beautiful and sublime melody!!!
Greetings from Colombia. ✋
Beautiful interpretation
Excelente performance.
Полина, это шедевр, спасибо за такое исполнение!
I am dumbstruck...what absolute beauty!
A profound Osetinskaya admire. There is something intimate but shared and with profound conviction. She commands attention and reception.
Благодарю сердечно! Наилучшее исполнение! Нежно, звонко, трогательно, космически уносит в высшее измерение. Музыкальное произведение - это межпространственый корабль, умелый музыкант - это Водитель и Проводник туда, куда стремится дух и душа человека, в гармоничное сияющее пространство Творчества и Красоты, и совершенной Гармонии с миром.
Bravissima. Mi hai toccato il cuore. Un collega che ti stima.... grazie....
Великолепно!
Чудесно!!!
С Новым годом Вас, Полина!
С Новым счастьем!❤
👏👏👏👏💐💐💐💐🧡🧡🧡🧡Божественно!!!Благодарю Полина я сама пианистка и многому учусь слушая Вас🧡🧡🧡