Estes dois vocalistas são praticamente Deuses dos Vocais Melódicos e minha grande fonte de inspiração. Querer comparar os dois é até um sacrilégio heiuheheiaeh, cada um tem a sua tesitura vocal e alcances, características e tudo mais! Os dois são fantásticos!
andre matos es un gran cantante....pero es que la voz de kiske es impresionante,muy pocos cantantes se pueden comparar a su voz....kiske aparte de que tiene mejor voz la tiene mas limpia y sus agudos son impresionantes con su timbre de voz.....a pesar de su edad....no se como ara para mantener esa voz...incrible.
"" ANDRÉ MATOS... R.I.P.. A MÚSICA FICOU MAIS TRISTE.. COM SUA PARTIDA REPENTINA.... DESCANSE EM PAZ GURREIRO... QUE SEU LEGADO IRÁ PERMENECER... ENQUANTO O VERDADEIRO ROCK EXISTIR"""
André Matos é fenomenal! Fez ótimos trabalhos com Viper, Angra e Shaman. Técnicamente é o melhor vocalista brasileiro de Heavy Metal. Não cabe aqui ficar fazendo comparações. André Matos and Kiske are amazing! No comparison!
Eu já penso diferente, digo que poderia escrever exatamente o que você escreveu apenas invertendo os cantores. O timbre do Kiske, mesmo em notas altíssimas, não perde a cor e o brilho. A voz dele em músicas mais pop como as do álbum 'Kiske' é uma das mais belas vozes da música popular.
Ambos son buenos, pero Micheal Kiske es el más legendario y el que tiene la mejor voz, toda una inspiración. They are both great, but Micheal Kiske is the most legendary and the one with the better voice, quite an inspiration
Kiske demolishes Matos here! Sorry to say so but Andre doesn't have the power to be compared to Kiske on any of the tracks. Even on Sign Of The Cross, which was originally sang by Matos, Kiske sounds much better. Nice video.
Não tem como comparar. Apesar das "notas" (tons), e agudos de ambos, são estilos diferentes. Colocação da voz, impostação é diferente. Eu prefiro Kiske (Keeper I e II), e Andre Matos (atual).
Kiske is godos. Simple y llanamente no hay punto de comparación, tanto en la calidad del vibratoria como al alcanzar notas más altas... No por nada André solo cubre a kiske en Avantasia y no viceversa...
Very nice comparison. I think 'Reach out for the light' needs lots of power and of course Kiske is doing this much better. In 'Shelter from the Rain' Matos is singing quite well too. Future World is of course another track designed for Kiske's voice and power.
Trying to demerit Andre by putting a long difference in the years of the lives being that both are good. But it's like they said there, it would be lovely to watch the Kiske run out singing Fairy Tale and Carry on.
@philipmichelduarte I believe that you don't fully understand what a 4 octave range means. Andre's and Michael's highest full voice (not falsetto) note is a G5, making their high end equal, but Kiske can also go lower - meaning he has a wider vocal range. Anyways, Heiman is a great vocalist.
Very good video! Andre Matos sings very well, but of course I prefer Michael Kiske, who sings a lot better and, till these days, he sings in the same way as the original songs
Both are gods. We can agree that André Matos sings Kiske's song on the same level. Is the reverse true? How would Kiske sing Carry On, Over Your Head or Letting Go? I have no doubt that he would do great, but on the same level that André can sing his songs? Withouth knowing this, it's impossible to decide.
Andre sings very beautiful and Angra have much better songs than Helloween, but Kiske, ahh, he is much more true and natural, it's like we're watching a god singing.
Viper started out as an Iron Maiden influenced band. They changed their sound after 1988, which was the period when Helloween had managed worldwide acclaim. I believe that no one can argue that Helloween created the European power metal (or power metal) sound, before Keeper I there was no album with a similar sound/style. If you want to generalize Iron Maiden, Judas Priest & even Rainbow were responsible for the birth of the power metal sound, but still Hellowen perfected it & made it famous.
@KingsBanshee Hahaha, I don't even know in which ludicrous claim of yours I should reply. Let me just remind you 1 thing, Matos first sang for Viper (a band inspired by Iron Maiden) and then for Angra (a band inspired by Helloween)
Yeah, I always tough that, since Viper had wrote most of Theatre of Fate songs in the end of 1987, and the lyrics themes and instrumentals are similar to helloween's keeper I & 2, wich the first part came at the same year. I can tell you that Angels Cry is the improvement of Theatre of Fate, so Angra was never meant to be a band inspired by helloween, Angra was a heavy metal band with a lot of classical influences too, wich always wanted to create new style of sound in each new album .....
@luizeduardolef yes, maybe you're right, but in the original song the part "in your miiiiind" is not sung by Kiske, it is sung by Sammet I've heard several songs where Kiske is not the original singer, but he sings similar or even better than the original singers, for instance: "Gamma Ray-A while in dreamland", "Avantasia-Lost in space" or when Kiske was younger "Ride the sky" or "Victim Of Fate" I mean, not always the original singer is better, but in this comparison I think Kiske is better
The power style in Angra comes from Matos himself, the two viper albuns recorded 87 and 89. And child matos with viper was inspired in Iron Maiden , Europe, stuff like that. The truth is helloween and viper starts the power metal (now I'm screwed) viper 1989 watch?v=eEId0KnLxZU Andre at age of 14 with viper watch?v=U1SgACOmifA Andre at age of 16 with viper watch?v=rNTXnqu5lPQ Viper now 05-2012 watch?v=RFNz5cde6FI
@mpaoxi No, he haven't got crazy opinions. Banshee doesn't say about the band style , he say about the way of sing. And yes, Matos has got a rare voice, he is tenor legguero and got a white voice, so 90% is not falseto, is head voice. Different of kotipelto, Michelli Lupi and others who sing 90% of time in falseto.
Matos has better range but the felling of Kiske is unbelivieble, both are wonderful but I prefer Midnight (joke)!kkkkkkkk Kiske and Matos are very diferent Matos can sing kiske's song but Kiske can't sing Matos' song!
No. Matos was not only inspirired by Bruce but by Geoff as well, I saw an interview he gave for Wikimetal where he says that he could not understand how guys like bruce and tate could hit those high notes so easy and that he wanted to be like them. If you just listen to matos's style in angra band you'll notice that he was more like tate's style than bruce's. that's why in the beginning of his carrer his style was related to kiske's style, which was related to tate's style. He said that in that interview either... I could give the link of the interview if you want to.
Renata Nunes Ohhh cool PM the Link I'd like to read the article, well Dio's voice is difficult to mimic to begin with although all the singers you've mentioned are low tenors accept for tate he's a Baritone. Andre Matos is a tenor though, but I've seen his new videos at shows and his voice is straining nowadays :(. There are plenty of other great vocalist he could've taken after like Steve Grimmitt whose also a tenor such a voice!
@mpaoxiWell, about use falseto, i'm not saying that is bad or not, but Matos does not use this too much. You can see it here watch?v=4x-WUmAmBXc, obviously in the highests notes it is 100% falseto like at 1:30, it is easy to see it becouse when someone hold a higher note,it is supposed that the power increases.But here clearly the most(about 90%)are not falseto,is natural voice,if you paid attention in the power, colorato and brightness, and see that he back to a chest voice without any trouble.
Jajajaa sisi claro y te puedo creer ya que en las giras ellos se desgastan mucho y no creas que andre es la excepcion asi que tu comentario no esta bien claro te falto poner que andre tambien lo hace y no es malo te lo dice alguien que conoce de canto
@KingsBanshee You 've got some crazy opinions. So Angra were not inspired by Helloween and its band members didn't even like them? So why did Angra play European power metal, a sub-genre created and spread by Helloween and why in the hell did they cover Helloween's Eagle Fly Free? No need to reply.
@AresKiske yes, maybe .......... but I'm not choosing based on sound quality, I am choosing based on how they sing, for example: Matos at minute 1:07 to 1:24 is not comparable with Kiske at minute 1:31 to 1:49, because Matos can breathe several times while he was singing "in your miiiiiiiiiiiiiind", and Kiske sings the same phrase continuously, for me It's more difficult singing like Kiske
Não é por favoritismo nem nacionalismo, mas eu acho que em questão de voz, o Andre Matos Humilha o Michael Kiske! eu gosto dos dois, mas o Andre se destaca mais!
Humilhar é um termo forte e impreciso. As notas do kiske são mais encorpadas, as vogais mais cheias. Matos vai mais agudo porém, seus agudos soam espremidos, sem contar que o Andre recorre ao mix falsete/voz de cabeça, com maior frequência que o kiske. Não que seja demérito. Mas isso mostra que o kiske, mesmo sendo autodidata, tem melhor controle de sua tessitura (principalmente pra cantar limpo) do que Matos. Ambos são gênios; Matos tem mais recursos, porém o kiske reina nesse estilo de canto não só pelo que já citei acima mas também por conseguir manter a qualidade do timbre intacta ainda que esteja em E5, F5 e as vezes até em G#5. Em termos de identidade vocal, Kiske é absurdo nessas regiões. Andre ia RIP, até além dessas notas, mas não chegava num F5 com a mesma qualidade, mantendo o timbre intacto como o Kiske nem a pau.
@@luiscarlosbmonteiro8619 bom não sei onde que vc tirou isso, bom acorde e veja o kiske tentar cantar carry on/speed/Fairy tale/nothing to say hein???bom FOI O QUE PENSEI.
@@lucaslonski você ao invés de contrapor meu argumento com alguma coerência apenas fez comparações pedindo pro Kiske cantar músicas. Eu heim! Volta e lê novamente.
Oh ok. Matos has a nice voice and yes he is a tenor and can thus do the high staff with more ease. On the other hand, he does use a lot of falsetto and he unfortunately has a thin voice. For proof check this "The Vocal Range Of Andre Matos" watch?v=ZMphb11fVfQ. I personally prefer Kiske because he sounds fuller in all ranges, more powerful and possesses other important vocal traits like great tone and very good phrasing. All this is obvious on this video.
Estes dois vocalistas são praticamente Deuses dos Vocais Melódicos e minha grande fonte de inspiração. Querer comparar os dois é até um sacrilégio heiuheheiaeh, cada um tem a sua tesitura vocal e alcances, características e tudo mais! Os dois são fantásticos!
andre matos es un gran cantante....pero es que la voz de kiske es impresionante,muy pocos cantantes se pueden comparar a su voz....kiske aparte de que tiene mejor voz la tiene mas limpia y sus agudos son impresionantes con su timbre de voz.....a pesar de su edad....no se como ara para mantener esa voz...incrible.
KISKE!!!!!!!!!!!! ES EL MEJOR VOCAL DE TODOS LOS TIEMPOS
Kiske 1992...😱😱😱.....Perfect!!!
"" ANDRÉ MATOS... R.I.P..
A MÚSICA FICOU MAIS TRISTE.. COM SUA PARTIDA REPENTINA.... DESCANSE EM PAZ GURREIRO...
QUE SEU LEGADO IRÁ PERMENECER... ENQUANTO O VERDADEIRO ROCK EXISTIR"""
O Kiske é o melhor, sensacional a voz dele, sempre limpa!!!
KISKE - is the VOICE!
Duas vozes maravilhosas, pena que André nos deixou...tão jovem
Vídeo ótimo!
Eles tem timbres muito parecidos, o mesmo alcance. Enfim, um pode facilmente fazer cover do outro. Dois monstros!
I would like to see Kiske singing "Carry On" or "Fairy Tale". André sings Kiske's songs... But can Kiske sing Andre's songs?
Matheus Zanine shure
Probably better than andre
I really really don't think so...
Sure! Andre is very good singer, but, in this style Kiske is the best .
Kiske >>>>>
André Matos é fenomenal! Fez ótimos trabalhos com Viper, Angra e Shaman. Técnicamente é o melhor vocalista brasileiro de Heavy Metal. Não cabe aqui ficar fazendo comparações. André Matos and Kiske are amazing! No comparison!
A voz do Kiske me agrada
A voz do Andre me arrepia
Parece q o André transmitia mais sentimento nas músicas do que todos os outros vocalistas.
Penso o mesmo
Geoff Tate
Eu já penso diferente, digo que poderia escrever exatamente o que você escreveu apenas invertendo os cantores. O timbre do Kiske, mesmo em notas altíssimas, não perde a cor e o brilho. A voz dele em músicas mais pop como as do álbum 'Kiske' é uma das mais belas vozes da música popular.
Kiske toda una vida...
Michael Kiske vocal king
Kiske, sin lugar a dudas
Kiske all the way.
Particularmente eu curto demais o Michael Kiske desde pequeno, mas não vou negar que dá uma briga boa...hehehe...dois monstros do heavy metal
OMG both are wonderful :D
kiske kicks his ass!!!!!!!!!!!!
KISKE THE GREAT
André Matos good.
Michael kiske Amazing!!!
BOTH are really amazing ❤
Los dos son magníficos pero Kiske es natural.
André Matos siempre será el mejor
Kiske >>> all
I like both , so it's hard to choose . My two weaknesses
Put kiske to sing some Matos songs, then you can compare.
you are right
agree!! at least let me know if kiske can sing wuthering heights as well as matos
put aslo matos sing kiske songs...
Matos can sing it.. he proved already, you guys wants matos to imitate the voice of kiske? How come! thats childish.
Lloyd Benedicto not imitate, but see if hes can reach kiske vocal range, vocal range, not screaming range...
Kiske is god!
But I don't see this comparison as 100% fair: those are all songs/bits written FOR Kiske's voice.
André MAtos madou bem de mais nessas músicas. Ambos são ótimos no que fazem!
Both are great vocalists ever I love to hear
Que grandes voces siempre serán unas auténticas leyendas del power metal. Solo hay que disfrutar a estas leyendas las comparaciones sobran. 🤘🤘🎸🎤
. kiske 100 %
Kiske
both are great
Ambos son buenos, pero Micheal Kiske es el más legendario y el que tiene la mejor voz, toda una inspiración.
They are both great, but Micheal Kiske is the most legendary and the one with the better voice, quite an inspiration
KISKE rules
Kiske is God!
The both are amazing. I can't choose.
Kiske!!!
seria um sonho realizado ver um dueto desses dois caras
Kiske is WAY better. Thanks for this montage!
Kiske demolishes Matos here!
Sorry to say so but Andre doesn't have the power to be compared to Kiske on any of the tracks. Even on Sign Of The Cross, which was originally sang by Matos, Kiske sounds much better. Nice video.
kiske
A great comparison video. Well done!!
even after those years Kiske still Kicks Ass!
Não tem como comparar.
Apesar das "notas" (tons), e agudos de ambos, são estilos diferentes. Colocação da voz, impostação é diferente.
Eu prefiro Kiske (Keeper I e II), e Andre Matos (atual).
Kiske is godos. Simple y llanamente no hay punto de comparación, tanto en la calidad del vibratoria como al alcanzar notas más altas... No por nada André solo cubre a kiske en Avantasia y no viceversa...
Very nice comparison. I think 'Reach out for the light' needs lots of power and of course Kiske is doing this much better. In 'Shelter from the Rain' Matos is singing quite well too. Future World is of course another track designed for Kiske's voice and power.
Do you love more Mam or Dad?
A tu hermana :v
Michael Kiske, no doubt.
Los dos son chingones!!!! Cada quien tiene su estilo propio!!!!
Trying to demerit Andre by putting a long difference in the years of the lives being that both are good. But it's like they said there, it would be lovely to watch the Kiske run out singing Fairy Tale and Carry on.
Andre Matos is the best, Kiske is just a JUDAS of metal, Andre Matos live is the best metal singer ever!
kiske's vibrato is not comparable
sorry for any english mistake from my part, I hope you'll understand what i'm trying to tell you
@philipmichelduarte I believe that you don't fully understand what a 4 octave range means. Andre's and Michael's highest full voice (not falsetto) note is a G5, making their high end equal, but Kiske can also go lower - meaning he has a wider vocal range. Anyways, Heiman is a great vocalist.
Very good video!
Andre Matos sings very well, but of course I prefer Michael Kiske, who sings a lot better and, till these days, he sings in the same way as the original songs
Both are gods. We can agree that André Matos sings Kiske's song on the same level. Is the reverse true? How would Kiske sing Carry On, Over Your Head or Letting Go? I have no doubt that he would do great, but on the same level that André can sing his songs? Withouth knowing this, it's impossible to decide.
Andre sings very beautiful and Angra have much better songs than Helloween, but Kiske, ahh, he is much more true and natural, it's like we're watching a god singing.
Viper started out as an Iron Maiden influenced band. They changed their sound after 1988, which was the period when Helloween had managed worldwide acclaim. I believe that no one can argue that Helloween created the European power metal (or power metal) sound, before Keeper I there was no album with a similar sound/style.
If you want to generalize Iron Maiden, Judas Priest & even Rainbow were responsible for the birth of the power metal sound, but still Hellowen perfected it & made it famous.
Andre Matos is the best, ever!!
Andre is known for a great carrer, kiske for two albums that Kai and Weikath wrote for him to sing
Accurate!
Andre >>>>>>>>>>>>> All
@KingsBanshee Hahaha, I don't even know in which ludicrous claim of yours I should reply. Let me just remind you 1 thing, Matos first sang for Viper (a band inspired by Iron Maiden) and then for Angra (a band inspired by Helloween)
Alls I know is that the future life will be glorious, come with me, Futureworld!
Quero ver o Kiske cantando Over Your Head.... huehuehue
Yeah, I always tough that, since Viper had wrote most of Theatre of Fate songs in the end of 1987, and the lyrics themes and instrumentals are similar to helloween's keeper I & 2, wich the first part came at the same year. I can tell you that Angels Cry is the improvement of Theatre of Fate, so Angra was never meant to be a band inspired by helloween, Angra was a heavy metal band with a lot of classical influences too, wich always wanted to create new style of sound in each new album .....
hey you forgot viper also for andre matos
Kiske by far..
both kick ass
@luizeduardolef yes, maybe you're right, but in the original song the part "in your miiiiind" is not sung by Kiske, it is sung by Sammet
I've heard several songs where Kiske is not the original singer, but he sings similar or even better than the original singers, for instance: "Gamma Ray-A while in dreamland", "Avantasia-Lost in space" or when Kiske was younger "Ride the sky" or "Victim Of Fate"
I mean, not always the original singer is better, but in this comparison I think Kiske is better
The power style in Angra comes from Matos himself, the two viper albuns recorded 87 and 89. And child matos with viper was inspired in Iron Maiden , Europe, stuff like that.
The truth is helloween and viper starts the power metal (now I'm screwed)
viper 1989 watch?v=eEId0KnLxZU
Andre at age of 14 with viper watch?v=U1SgACOmifA
Andre at age of 16 with viper watch?v=rNTXnqu5lPQ
Viper now 05-2012 watch?v=RFNz5cde6FI
@mpaoxi
No, he haven't got crazy opinions. Banshee doesn't say about the band style , he say about the way of sing. And yes, Matos has got a rare voice, he is tenor legguero and got a white voice, so 90% is not falseto, is head voice. Different of kotipelto, Michelli Lupi and others who sing 90% of time in falseto.
Just search for Angra - Don't Despair
Matos has better range but the felling of Kiske is unbelivieble, both are wonderful but I prefer Midnight (joke)!kkkkkkkk
Kiske and Matos are very diferent Matos can sing kiske's song but Kiske can't sing Matos' song!
2 sons of the great Geoff Tate... keep on trying boys! rsrsrs
2 masters.
Nope kiske is inspired by Geoff While matos was inspired by Bruce Dickinson.
No. Matos was not only inspirired by Bruce but by Geoff as well, I saw an interview he gave for Wikimetal where he says that he could not understand how guys like bruce and tate could hit those high notes so easy and that he wanted to be like them. If you just listen to matos's style in angra band you'll notice that he was more like tate's style than bruce's. that's why in the beginning of his carrer his style was related to kiske's style, which was related to tate's style. He said that in that interview either... I could give the link of the interview if you want to.
And he included Halford among them as an inspiration. And said that he admired Dio, but didn't want to sing like him.
Renata Nunes Ohhh cool PM the Link I'd like to read the article, well Dio's voice is difficult to mimic to begin with although all the singers you've mentioned are low tenors accept for tate he's a Baritone. Andre Matos is a tenor though, but I've seen his new videos at shows and his voice is straining nowadays :(. There are plenty of other great vocalist he could've taken after like Steve Grimmitt whose also a tenor such a voice!
sorry it's not an article, it's a podcast in portuguese. do you want it anyway?
André Matos. The Best Ever
@mpaoxiWell, about use falseto, i'm not saying that is bad or not, but Matos does not use this too much. You can see it here watch?v=4x-WUmAmBXc, obviously in the highests notes it is 100% falseto like at 1:30, it is easy to see it becouse when someone hold a higher note,it is supposed that the power increases.But here clearly the most(about 90%)are not falseto,is natural voice,if you paid attention in the power, colorato and brightness, and see that he back to a chest voice without any trouble.
@mpaoxiWell And also if you want to compere in a trustable way, you need to put Angra songs there.
Kiske especialista en playbacks... No dudo que es un grande y q tuvo una voz privilegiada pero ya se le ha descubierto haciendo playback
Jajajaa sisi claro y te puedo creer ya que en las giras ellos se desgastan mucho y no creas que andre es la excepcion asi que tu comentario no esta bien claro te falto poner que andre tambien lo hace y no es malo te lo dice alguien que conoce de canto
@KingsBanshee You 've got some crazy opinions. So Angra were not inspired by Helloween and its band members didn't even like them? So why did Angra play European power metal, a sub-genre created and spread by Helloween and why in the hell did they cover Helloween's Eagle Fly Free? No need to reply.
Compare both in 90´s live todays they are old
@AresKiske yes, maybe .......... but I'm not choosing based on sound quality, I am choosing based on how they sing, for example: Matos at minute 1:07 to 1:24 is not comparable with Kiske at minute 1:31 to 1:49, because Matos can breathe several times while he was singing "in your miiiiiiiiiiiiiind", and Kiske sings the same phrase continuously, for me It's more difficult singing like Kiske
claramente Michael Kiske, no se le puede comparar el la gran voz del Power
Não é por favoritismo nem nacionalismo, mas eu acho que em questão de voz, o Andre Matos Humilha o Michael Kiske! eu gosto dos dois, mas o Andre se destaca mais!
Humilhar é um termo forte e impreciso. As notas do kiske são mais encorpadas, as vogais mais cheias. Matos vai mais agudo porém, seus agudos soam espremidos, sem contar que o Andre recorre ao mix falsete/voz de cabeça, com maior frequência que o kiske. Não que seja demérito. Mas isso mostra que o kiske, mesmo sendo autodidata, tem melhor controle de sua tessitura (principalmente pra cantar limpo) do que Matos. Ambos são gênios; Matos tem mais recursos, porém o kiske reina nesse estilo de canto não só pelo que já citei acima mas também por conseguir manter a qualidade do timbre intacta ainda que esteja em E5, F5 e as vezes até em G#5. Em termos de identidade vocal, Kiske é absurdo nessas regiões. Andre ia RIP, até além dessas notas, mas não chegava num F5 com a mesma qualidade, mantendo o timbre intacto como o Kiske nem a pau.
@@luiscarlosbmonteiro8619 bom não sei onde que vc tirou isso, bom acorde e veja o kiske tentar cantar carry on/speed/Fairy tale/nothing to say hein???bom FOI O QUE PENSEI.
@@lucaslonski você ao invés de contrapor meu argumento com alguma coerência apenas fez comparações pedindo pro Kiske cantar músicas. Eu heim! Volta e lê novamente.
@@luiscarlosbmonteiro8619 Você tem conhecimento e é sansato., meu bom amigo! 😎🖒
Estan locos
esto es............ para demostrar que KISKE es mejor que Matos?
ya lo sabia, pero de todas formas gracias :)
Resumindo, os dois são foda!!!!!
Oh ok. Matos has a nice voice and yes he is a tenor and can thus do the high staff with more ease. On the other hand, he does use a lot of falsetto and he unfortunately has a thin voice. For proof check this "The Vocal Range Of Andre Matos" watch?v=ZMphb11fVfQ.
I personally prefer Kiske because he sounds fuller in all ranges, more powerful and possesses other important vocal traits like great tone and very good phrasing. All this is obvious on this video.
Matos Rules!
@AresKiske That true
Faltou eagles fly free.....a melhor versão da musica que o Heloween nunca irá tocar.....Shaman e Matos eternos.
that HAS to take its toll on anyones's vocals. over the years
@Benizha2011 I'm Brazilian, but I vote for Kiske! hahaha
grande parte do andré no avantasia tobias ta cantando junto
Andre Matos 🫶🏻
cant compare this to,i rly love avantasia and andre,but kiske is way better singer
Kosta Talbic wtf no
Andre Matos no doubt man
Los dos son bien buenos alv compa
os 2 são fodas!