Pop Artists VS Metal Singers 2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 окт 2020
- POP SUCKS! and here is prove of that. I understand many of this people are rapers or whatever you want to call them,seams like they are just pretending to be singers.
On the first part I got a lot of comments saying how stupid my video was but I think some people are more stupid for listening this sort of music, everything they talk about is "wet p*ssy" trying to brain wash you so they make more money.
Lets give a chance to real artists in the music industry. Whatever those artist are and whatever type of music they play.
![Kpop vs Sabaton [Flashing Images]](/img/1.gif)
Minute 1:34 is Marco Hietala singing one of his solo album songs. Pyre of the Black Heart.
Awesome! 😎
keep marco and floor away,they are not comparable 🤣
I literally came to the comments looking for this song name. Thank you
Sooo good. Amazing album
I’m gonna miss marko 🥺🥺😔😔
Kanye trying to cover Queen made my ears bleed
It was sacrilege
Same lol Oh and if you haven't heard Puscifers cover, I suggest you do.
Who let him do that? They need to be fired,
Out of a cannon.
I've heard better Queen covers on Karaoke night.
I puked blood heard to that shit
Not all pop singers can sing metal
but all metal singers can sing pop
so
Absolutely
exactly
supluety
+100500
Yep - but they won't 😁
Metal doesn't play fair they have Marco and his magical beard
Beards are my weakness
They also have Macro
i respet u
respect?
...and Maynard, a man (might be an alien, probably an alien) who has a body mass consisting of 75% sheer lung capacity.
It is a fact that most metal musicians are more musically talented than pop artists, try and change my mind
Hi there. I'm not going to change your mind.
@@yuyirv6764 Sounds good lol 👍
@@disturbiafromthebay Heard to many great heavy metal vocalists to have my mind changed as well.However,there are some great pop vocalists,like unforunately late Whitney Houston and Marie Fredriksson-when you hear them sing,it's out of world experience.Shame we'll never get singers like them ever again.
@@hillclimbracingfan5821 Yeah, there are definitely some great pop singers, but I think I’m general, most of the time especially now, Metal singers are better
@@disturbiafromthebay Might be,but i don't think any of female metal vocalists can touch Whitney or Marie and you have to be really crazy to put down high quality vocal,regardless of the genre,in favour of metal vocalist just because you think they're better than others.Every genre has great and bad vocalists and that's the way it is and while i do agree that metal vocalists are talented,there are some pop vocalists who can sing in way metal vocalists can't and other way around.Coming from metalhead and rocker in soul and i definetely won't put down high quality pop vocal,especially someone who can sing with emotion and is damn good.
I've never heard a worse version of Bohemian Rhapsody
My ears are literaly bleeding🤯
I've never cringed so bad in my entire life
The crowd was better than Kanye
@@johnnyutah482 whoever goes to one of his concerts voluntarily can hardly have a good taste in music
@@orion7067 I hear ya
"I've never heard worse version of Bohemian Rhapsody"
Me: Allow me to introduce myself
"We don't need Autotune" Really? Because it sounds like it.
That was super embarrassing lmao
where that was?
Just see this shit, if one of your favorite artists sings like shit for any reason you won't still complaining about it but if one of the other ones do it better you're just trying to make noise saying whatever you can to offend them
@@EliSpectwo Doing whatever I can to offend them? Hm, then I'm curious about what you're doing... and my favourite artists never sing like shit because I choose to listen to artists who can actually sing. Without autotune.
Bieber is ok for a pop singer, he’s actually able to sound ok unlike a lot of male pop singers.
I guess to put it another way, if you threw Bieber in my ears my complaint would be the lyrics/music rather than his vocals.
Holy shit, why would someone butcher Queen’s song like that?
That was Kanye and idk why he did it
To much ego, nowhere near enough skill.
He didn't quite butcher it; if he can't hit the notes he will let the audience sing it. Cheap "talent."
Mama, I just killed a song...
JUST LET THE CROWD SING IT DEWD, sounded sooo much better *_*
being honest I like some pop songs and artists, but come on, metal music is my weakness, metal music makes me feel powerful, like if I'm in heaven
whenever I listen a metal song that I really like, it feels magical, specially Gothic or Symphonic metal, I believe that anyone who likes this kind of music can understand this, and it's an experience that I wish everybody can have
simply amazing!
I agree and that's why you should check the metal cover videos I am making. Let's make pop great again by turning those music compositions into metal lol.
I'm so glad to hear you say that. Symphonic and Gothic Metal are hands down my top two favorite genres. And Cristina scabbia and Simone Simons are my top two vocalists.🤟🏾
Same
Me and bfmv
Pure "metal" i never cared for and still really don't want any part or, and symphony can easily sound boring; however put those 2 together....wow
You have no idea the happiness I received when Tatiana from jinjer popped up! YES!!!
i was about to say the same thing... i was hoping she would have been the metal side from the first video when katy perrys hear me roar was on it hahaha
Jinger sounds good but i do prefer Arch Enemy..With Alissa White Gluz..
you prefer the growl? because i did not hear much else
Actually the best female metal singer seems to be unknown to many: Anneke van Giersbergen. Example: ruclips.net/video/Y46Lft_BZxo/видео.html
@@Hy-jg8ow correct me if I'm wrong, but that name I thought, belonged to a different face. Did this singer though join Sharon & Within Temptation once?
Pop-singers are sometimes pathetic in their megalomania.
*always
You meant to say all times*.
I feel they just add in the dancing, and backing dancers just to mask the fact that their singing is just okay
Metal singers are so much better!!
@XVPhenix 39 absolutely
People with actual talent
Pop singers = earrape. Metal Singers = Gold
Absolutely 🖤
Probably bc their Voice is more needed since there is literally no Autotune
That was the worst Queen cover ever!I will take Metal for the win,Alex!
I don’t think pop ( the genre itself)suck, I think singers are the problem , they need more preparation, technique and compromise
The Metal singers, look so profesional and prepare with good vocal technique
Also I didn’t know some of the some of the songs/ singers in this video
Thank so much for include them
I completely agree!
Agree as well. I noticed that (the) pop singers in this vid seem to cramp with their whole body when it came to higher notes. Bad mistake, even I know that. If I do so, I always must cough. Yes, it sounds ok or even good but it isn't good at all, neither for the body nor for the voice.
no, pop is sucks!
Problem with pop is it doesn't give the vocalists room to show skill and power like metal does because its too processed and generic. Thats what sells though.
@@residentevildeadspace5729 that you do not like a type of music, does not mean that it really sucks, you just don’t like it, and that’s all
Yeah!!! We have Floor Jansen!!
And next to her Tatiana Shmayliuk
And Tarja Turunen, Sebastian Bach, Anneke van Giersbergen, Marco Hietala, Johannes Eckerström, Anders Friden, Dianne van Giersbergen, Cammie Gilbert, James Hetfield, Alissa White-Gluz, Tatiana, Vicky, Jari, Annette... I could keep going forever.
@@l.hendriks93 don't left out Fabio Lione maaan
@@dalia1598 she is more like a valkiria
And Tarja Turunen, Sharon Den Adel and Simone Simmons
There's ton of great pop singers and tons of shitty ones just like there's ton of amazing metal vocalists and tons of bad ones. The difference being in metal, the bad ones don't get recognition like the bad pop ones do.
The most underrated singers who are genuinely beautiful but never receive recognition are folk artists, particularly Irish folk.
Because pop is based off aesthetics and what sells.
Kanye's singing, without exaggeration, made me double and scratch the wall in pain. I actually panted in pain a bit afterwards. I had no idea sound could cause such a reaction on my body x_x
What i love best about this video is the fact that as far as I am aware all of the pop singers first languages are English whereas the metal singers are mostly European and may not be native English speakers and yet seem to have a better control of the language while singing than the pop singers do. That is why I love rock/metal music
Not just singing. Writing too.
Foreign accents work better with vowel shapes.
It’s funny, I’m not a professional at all, but I’m looking at these pop singers and noticing really basic technical mistakes. It might just be a stylistic choice, but some of those mistakes can really hurt their voice.
Its because they think they can sing all those notes without any issue
That's part of what hurt Britney.
They can't sing
The good singers came in the 80's, these days pop singers are wannabes who have no talent what so ever
There are also metal singers with those problems. The problem with this kind of videos is that they chose bad pop singers or bad moments and incredible metal singers.
There are good and bad singers in pop, metal or any other genre
@@oscarprado8813 yeah, I’m one of those bad singers in metal😅
Fair play to Floor for muting herself, she doesn't want to make anyone look bad
"at least you have Beyonce....you can keep her....We have Floor Jansen"
The Queen Valkyrie!!!!!
What??
we have Floor Jansen and Tarja Turunen ❤️
Beyonce is vocally better, can Floor Jensen sing while dancing and throwing herself on the floor ? Can she perform perfect riff in a minute with such creativity ? Can she create a whole discography with such diversity in style and technique ?
Obviously no.
@@haiga9290 she doesn’t sing and you both don’t listen to good music because I can tell that you both love pop
@@doomguyfaz3recon797 ruclips.net/video/RyQe4Yn9V08/видео.html : pregnant, dancing and on hills, JF could never.
ruclips.net/video/Jj1T7uHdBcY/видео.html : perfect riff and completely different from her regular style
ruclips.net/video/B48xjp-VQt4/видео.html: Really good operatic technique, performed on live while on her knees and bending and body (thus reducing breath suppport)
ruclips.net/video/nnReaaJwloI/видео.html : Pregnant again, this lady can rock
I could add so much more.
Honestly, i dont really get why yall are so mad against pop ? Some could argue that metal is a poor musical genre with few diversity in it, basically construct with loud backsound, screaming and some randoms singing in a musical theater style
5:05 the sound is muted, but I can tell you that is the final vocal line of Ghost Love Score live at Wacken 2013. Yes, I have watched that video enough times to not even need to check, and yes, it is that good to be a final unanswerable argument for this video.
Floorgasm!
already played that finally in my mind while reading your comment
instant Floorgasm
Watch the new live performance of her Single "Fire". Don't know what's happening with Nightwish, but glad to see Floor has found her drive again to being writing her own stuff.
Why is Floor muted, too much ambarassing for the pop singers?
@@jandebakker604 RUclips copyright is touchy. As that source video gets a lot of traffic on RUclips it probably recognized and flagged that clip, which is one of the longer ones in this video.
Glad to see FINALLY Anette is included as a metal singer
Of course I mean she sang with NW for so many years and now being so successful with the Dark Element. If that is not a metal singer then idk what is ;)
@@metalground212 I know but reviewers usually forget Anettes Era...
Even if you think Annette falls short of the glory of Floor, it's quite obvious she absolutely smoked every single one of the pop singers in this video.
@@metalground212 She was to weak for NW, lol. Wtf, dude, half of pop singers in your compilation can beat her. She sounds nasal. Generally, you compare classical singers with pop singers. Opera singers can't be better 'cause it's just a different type of vocal. Every time you take some of the best pop singers, they can sing and they do it perfectly. But yes, Tatiana from Jinjer can beat everyone of them.
@@xenpredator9157 but floor can do pop... scream... opera... metal... everything 😂😂 and shes a metal singer
Yes: most metal singers are A LOT better and more competent than most pop singer.
Yes: most metal music is A LOT more complex and articulated than most pop.
Did you ever wonder why people listens to pop more, despite that?
Because pop is prosy by its own nature, and people don't always want to experience what is best but rather what is familiar for them.
There is no harm in that, let people enjoy what they like, even if it's not the best, ok?
- a big metal fan \m/
Pop is literally "popular" aka more advertised and forced into your view while the singers dont have enough talent to carry themselves more than maybe a decade while metal singers literally go on for more than 50 years on their own just by word of mouth from fans.
I'm still going to RIP Justin Biebers-Lonely everytime my coworker plays it. That song is a disgrace to all music and deserves nothing less lol.
@@Dreeza68955 no thats baby, its literally 3 verses. With 90% being a single lyric
@@redragon1990 I've actually avoided that song my whole life some how. The only exposure I've had to it was in South Park when Cartmen had Cthulu pop his head 😂
@@redragon1990 That song is insult to music,along with Despasito.
Nils has been such a huge upgrade for Amaranthe
You know, I used to not care for him in the beginning but now I'm just like "wow, this dude is fantastic"
Could easily squeeze Lzzy Hale in these. There's live show of "It's not you" where she gets a really high not at the beginning
This voice from Elize...she's literally like the Angel of Metal
Yes she is, I love Amaranthe...
Pop music is about image....Metal musicians are undoubtedly much more talented, and they write their own material!
This is more like American VS Europe singers
And Europe eins xx: 0.and the last.yes, we have Floor Jansen..Dont missunderstand me, Beyoncé or Pink, Adele are great Singer, But in the Metal Genre, we have awesome Singer.
But USA also got some epic metal bands like Slipknot, Cannibal Corpse
@@ralfmeyer9086 and Tatiana Shmayliuk,, she is one of a kind
@@cooltechnician hallo, you are right, i have one"problem 🤗" i am FLOORED.
true.. alot of really good metal bands do come from mainland europe. i've yet to figure out why due to some of them coming from places where there isn't alot of snow.
2:00 MY EARS ARE BLEEDING 😓
I'm here because I saw tatiana
Same,, she’s so amazing!
Same she is one of metals valkyries
Same
Honestly im a metalhead but i don't really think we can really compare those two kind of styles, even if i rly don't like Justin Bieber or Kanye West
You know it's a pop artist if it sounds like whining
God i fucking love metal singers so much. Thank you dad for getting me into metal bands and horror bands at a very very young age
I feel sorry for Freddie Mercury with such a talent, an incredible voice, has to listen in heaven Kanye West making a cover of him, singing really bad and fucking up with the song 😢
Today we have learned Marco has left Nightwish 😭🥺 1/12/2021
I know 😭 that's so sad
Anneke Van Giersbergen from "The Gathering" -> all pop singers
“But at least you have Beyoncé” is sending me
🤪
What??
😂😂😂😂 that was hilarious!!
Adele is good
@@bipultamang7061 she is bad but for you she is good
Great video, and having Dynasty being the opener was well worth the badassery!
wait is that song on spotify i can't seem to find it there
Let's consider as well Roy Kan, one of the best clean male voice of metal world.
Marcela Bovio, Anneke Van G. too and there are so many more amazing voices.
Total agree 🙌🙌
Love Roy. Saw him as part of kamelot live
@@kevinpiacente3456 if you don't know Roy is back to his old band Conception and the last album is 😍🤩
@@Ita_Metal_Playlist I didn't know that. Thank u for the info
+ for Anneke! But in male vocals I would vote Karevik and Russell Allen.
From a musicians point of view:
I only care about who has better tonality and overall control. I've plenty of good singers that have shit tonality and constantly change pitch mid song or hell mid key which really fucking drives me mental.
As long as they can sing on key, on pitch, and have clear punctuation and I enjoy they're music then I'm good.
I think timbre and tone is very important in hard rock and heavy metal. Lyrics are really almost secondary.
While I will agree that in general metal is vastly superior to pop, especially modern pop, it doesn't hurt your case that you picked some especially atrocious "pop" performances to pair up against some great metal performances. Someone could just as easily make a similar video making the opposite argument.
Not just to pair up great metal performances for the sake of it, but to show how it should have been performed. I understand your point but this is more fun than making a video about bad metal singers vs good metal singers. 🤷🏽♂️
Totally agreed
@@metalground212 people like pop for no reason, it's so generic
@@abelbavdaz6823 why do you like metal then?
@@metalground212 where is the video of greatest pop performances vs greatest metal? Why are metal fans so short sided. Most pop fans like multiple genres while metal only listen to metal and shut on people who don’t like/ or like other genres than metal.
I regret not discovering this genre of music before 🙃
pop?
@@nickmilo932 there would be no regret if it was pop
@@doomguyfaz3recon797 hahaha actually true
Never to late to jump into the wonderful world of metal
I mean just look at when crowds sing, pop versus metal, pop artists think they deserve they crowd sing for them, metal artists always bask in the crowds glory when they sing for/with them! So many metal artists are so humble.
Floor and Marko alone are all I need. They are perfection.
The mixture of vocal styles gives the impression of a fallen angel beauty and evil living side by side. Metal singers can sing you to sleep or scare you to death. Metal singers have gorgeous voices and guttural characters all rolled into one voice.
Marco Hietala of Nightwish as well as his solo performance is just all kinds of badassery! I can't wait for the pandemic to come to a end so finally we can rock out to these incredible modern-power-symphonic bands as they DESERVE to be acknowledged!
🤘😝🤘
It takes more skill to be a metal singer than being a pop singer
Would've loved Katy Perry's "Roar" beaten down by Tatiana's actual Roars \m/
Just need to show Rob Halford and it's game over
Can someone tell me the names of the metal songs used in this video, please?
Dynazty land of the Broken Dreams, Nightwish the Islander, Marco Hietala Death march for freedom, Jinjer Judgement, the Rasmus October and April, Amaranthe Unified, and Nightwish Ghost love score.
The Song from Jinjer is called Judgement and Punishment.
What I love about the rock/metal genre over pop, is that rock/metal is raw talent. Voices are naturally powerful and hearing the grain in the voices of some vocalists just adds to that raw talent. It's that sweet imperfection that makes them perfect.
PS: Beyonce's ears seem to be taking strain from those earrings. Like they're trying to take all the grocery bags from the car in one trip or die trying
Yes indeed, we've got Floor Jansen, the Vocal Queen herself
More of a metalhead myself, but I think there was some cherrypicking done here. There are some fantastic vocalists, but they certainly arent predominantly the norm. Those who are amazing share something with the best singers of metal: opera training.
For opera truly wins the vocal challenge.
Massive fan of all the love you're showing Amaranthe and their singers, MG :D
It's really not fair. In Metal, we have Till Lindemann, Peter Steele, Corey Taylor, Marco Heitala, Rob Halford, Ozzy Osbourn, Mikael Akerfield, and Warrel Dane for the men. And then we have Doro Pesch, Lita Ford, Angela Gossow, Tarja Turunen, Floor Jansen, Tatiana Shmayluk, Cristina Scabbia and Lzzy Hale for the women. It's literally not fair. 🤣🤣🤣
Simone Simon's? 🤷
Not to mention Howard Jones (ex-Killswitch Engage), Phil Anselmo (Pantera), and Layne Staley (Alice In Chains). 🤟
When you did that horrific cover of queen the metal reaction should have been the Wilson sisters covering stairway to heaven (it’s incredible) or Marko and Nightwish covering high hopes, but admittedly that would have been kicking pop when it was down lol
Nils Molin and Anette Olzon truly is 2 of the best voices we have in Sweden and so many dosen't even know who they are here 😭
But we know!
If Anette had just stayed in her lane and played to her strengths, she probably would have accomplished a lot more. This video is a great example. Sounds great in the lower registers, still sounds good in the mids...but ohh those higher notes. Her voice totally thins out and she frequently gets this unpleasant squeak. She'd be an amazing jazz or blues singer.
@@Mystress1980 3:15 in this video confirms it. As long as she does not try to get to operatic heights, Annette's voice is fine. But as Nightwish singer she was a bit misplaced.
Who needs any pop artist when Floor Jansen exists
Very true!!! Floor's pop album is amazing!
Where was within temptation
I am a metal head and hardly listen to pop,but I can ,for example, see people preferring Beyonce over Floor.She has a beautiful voice and music is not all about hitting high notes all the time but being able to convey emotions with the right technique.Its for the same reason when I say to people that I prefer Amy Lee over Tarja - its the ability of Lee's voice to touch my emotions and make me feel some type of way while Tarja just doesn't do it at the same level for me with her classical and predictable sining.Now,dont hate me for my opinion.Music is a subjective thing.
@Joce C great reply, haha, i can say the same thing to him, floor and tarja makes me feel different deep emotions vs pop singers. Many nightwish and metal songs i can feel it emotionally and spiritually.
@Joce C yes, you take the point with this misunderstanding: singing is only a fact of ❤️ or someone MAYBE can study TECHNIQUES and improve expression by STUDYING THE STORY OF MUSIC????? I think that there is a gain of expressivity when you study classical music (the top of what human kind could reach with instruments and complexity...). The demonstration???? If I sing and don't know what is a dorian scale I'm like a worker that doesn't know what is a drill. Period. So theory and practising MUST be the first day in the school, to not create an ignorant environment where people think that lady gaga is good. Or hundreds like her.
No. We enter in a paradox. And the paradox is autotune. They don't sing, but talk. And often they don't have the time to be defined musicians. Music is the art of sounds, when you stop using sounds but synthetic instruments to make it acceptable... It's cheating for me. Like doping
We cannot hate you for an opinion don't worry 🙂🙂. But in my opinion there is a pyramid when we talk about everything. Top expression and top technique mix... That can be not be liked to the most people. Maybe for 💰 reasons, like... Is more famous Amy winehouse because is not more alive? Or kurt cobain? Music is the same but they are more than that. They are geniuses... I don't know why obviously
@@bender8100 the people who are a fan of pop also thinks that DJs a musicians.
The he Beyoncé comment at the end just was the icing on the Christmas cake.
Thank you!
"You can keep her. We have Floor."
Hate her or Not. She can sing better than 90%of the people
I mean some pop singers are all right but up against Tarja or Floor they aren't on any level even close to theirs. It's like comparing a €10 take away to a 5 star deluxe meal cooked by a Michelin chef
I'm glad someone mentioned Tarja! She's a fantastic singer.
With her operatice voice she excels, but i don't think her other singing skills are any special.
I love both pop and metal, I don’t understand why we feel the need to bring one genre down to uplift another.
I think it's just a way to build one's self-esteem. People often feel the need to prove that their taste in whatever is superior and then pat each other on the back within the community. Objectively, yeah, metal does seem to have higher standards when it comes singing, pop and metal music industries are very different, and the former is focused on many things apart from the music itself, which might be partly responsible for that difference in quality. However, saying that "pop sucks" is simply an opinion, taste in music is actually an aquired thing, our brain simply likes the sounds it knows and recognizes, so going "oh, the sounds MY brain likes are better than the ones YOURS does" is um...kind of stupid.
Exactly. I think it’s just to feel some sort of superiority complex for whatever reason. Why can’t we just agree to disagree?
@@laurengibbs6940 Metal objectively requires more technical ability [thus effort and time invested] to play and produce, some of us respect that over easily manufactured music. Not to mention that on the listener's side metal being sometimes really intricate and complex requires more than 1 listen to fully appreciate a song, sometimes a song even requires multiple listens to really shine. Its work put into it from both sides, musicians and listeners. In contrast most - not all - pop music is made for easy listening and fast consumption, its tasty like a burger sometimes, but it doesn't compare with grandma's real nutritious home-cooking. Metal is simply a more "nutritious" music....for the soul.
most metalheads are like that, even with other rock genres
The lack of brittany slayes is absolutely disrespectful
Sorry Zaq. But I promise she will make it to the second part of extreme female metal singers or something!
@@metalground212 my man
There are simply too many great Metal Singers to add all of them into one compilation. But you definitely can add all great Pop Singers into one, there is not more than a handful.
1:29 (after this shity Queen cover) what is this? Its so COOL! Shazam didn't recognize it.
Just here because i want to get the answer too, dont mind me
But I think its tarot (marko hietala)
After spending much time on the Internet, I was able to figure out that its Death march for Freedom - Marko Hietala
@@trolliiiii Thankz Mate! U are the best. ;-)
Cherry picking? lol, On the first part I gave you "good" pop artists and you complained, so here we are proving once again some artists are just missing something. I did this video choosing even worst pop singers, but man you have a lot to choose from. Enjoy real music and btw #savebritney I didn't know she was struggling on the personal level, she might be a bad singer but she is still human, so good vibes.
@akhilesh Vijay Pop used to be great,with truly talented artists,but today it's not even a shadow of greatness it once was,but in my opinion,if you want truly great and quality music,regardless of genre(pop included),then dig in underground and ignore mainstream,since mostly they play worthless "made to make money" music while true talents are vastly ignored due to people brainwashed because of beeing forced to listen mainstream stuff on radio,but that's because market is controled by studios and producers and all songs in today's pop are written by two same guys,hence why i always appreciate singer-songwriter type of artists,because they make something that's theirs,their own and unique style,but that's unfortunately not appreciated and it's ignored because of reasons i mentioned.Sad,but true,but such music stands test of time,unlike instant hits that no one remembers after few months.
@akhilesh Vijay your mistake is that you condemn them instead of trying to understand why.
I'm not judging you, but that means you just complain about the world you live in and you won't be able to change it.
First: you need to understand the reasons why something happens, then you can ACT to change things. You are doing neither.
@hillclimbingragingfan knows things \m/.
But you have to admit compare anyone to Floor or Marco is quite harsh. They are brilliant and exceptional singers even within metal singers :-)
@@MichaelavanderLeek Not really.Amy Lee and Michael Kiske easily hold their own against them and can outperform them.
Modern day pop (as a genre) does suck. But except for the idiots with autotune, I didn’t hear anything for any of the pop singers to be embarrassed about. But (admittedly) I’m biased towards nu-metal.
I’d much rather hear Bruce Dickinson or Rob Halford (or RJD or Ozzy or even Joe freaking Elliot or countless others) than any of those guys/chicks any day.
Crazy how unpopular metal is when the musicians are this good. Weirder still is if I play metal (as long as there is no screaming) people tend to like it.
I really felt ashamed and embarrassed for the pop singers. Doesn't Jinjer just nail it perfectly.
Playing metal, drums, guitar, vocals, lyrics, bass,...demands so much knowledge control and skills. Ppl always think it’s chaotic, dark, brutal,... What they don’t know, most of them had classical schooling (epica and others ever opera vocals) and are in absolute control of their vocals, grunting and screaming asks so much skill and knowledge of breathing etcetera
EXACTLY DUDE! THAT IS SO TRUE!
I would join a pop band to play guitar live because I could ruin the show by playing slayer in the middle of a song
If you do another part try putting The Amity Affliction and Our Hollow Our Home.
Lady Gaga, Florence and the Machine, Lana Del Rey, Marina, Nightwish, New Years Day, In This Moment, JINJER, Unleash the Archers and Septicflesh. Love their music. 🖤🎼🎵🎶❤
The best male singers weren't even mentioned: Hansi Kürsch, Tobias Sammet, Marc Hudson, Myles Kennedy, Sebastian Bach etc.
Will consider them next time.
@build bridge sounds good!
I believe the creator was going for Foreign Metal singers over American.
American metal singers (as good as they still are), are now rare to find compared to Foreign Singers.
However he'll have to check out some badass Japanese metal singers, man they have some pipes.
@@kevynhansyn2902 thank you Kevyn. I included artist I listen to and now that I think about it I don't really listen to American metal :S yeah some people had recommended Japanese stuff but I don't know too much about it.
@@metalground212 I know it’s 8 months late, but please do a video shedding some light on Japanese rock/metal vocalists!! They’re actually very talented in both singing and uncleans, and (I think) they’re severely underrated. The likes of Hiroshi Kitadani, Hironobu Kageyama, Masato Hayakawa, Kenta Koie, Masatoshi Ono, Hyde, Ruki, and more! Love the videos, my dude~
LOL I love the Friday the 13th part 8 scene. As goofy as that movie is, it is guilty pleasure.
That one guy just used a shit ton of auto tune. It makes me sick.
Rock/metal music takes WAY MORE study and skills than most of that pop/trap crap. Prove me wrong
Can’t
I love Metal with all my heart
But when people make videos like this to disgrace other genres, its soo stupid and cringe
Dove - Loving You (John Kremer remix).
The vocals in the middle send chills down the mammalian spine.
We can win this comparison with just Dutch symphonic metal singers + Marco Hietala. No contest.
This is hilarious. We all know there is NO comparison!!! 🤘🏼
Beyonce, Pink, Adele, and Lady Gaga.
That's it.
And Ariana :)
@@personarandom6814 she would be if she actually makes songs to showcase what she really has. But the only time she showcases that talent is usually when just covering other people's songs.
And then they get their pay cheques and the tables are turned
Yeah see Britney for example, I am sure she gets really big paychecks... I don't know what the price for freedom is, but surely some can't afford it... Idk man I suppose you speak some truth tho. Music industry must change... Just saying.
It’s a sad day when a metal head like myself thinks Miley Cyrus was the best pop artist out of the entire group. Still doesn’t have shit on any of these valkyries though.
Metals wins this, I hate today's pop I miss old pop
Like Michael Jackson's and the Beatle's, while pop today talks about there self and everything else (not all pop singers talk about there self)
But metal wins, it vocals and scream are the best
Stop Stop! The pop stars are dead! Let them go back to selling Pepsi.
Kanye West singing Bohemian rhapsody is literally herasy
It should be illegal for him to sing that ever again 🤣
In the part 1 have a intro song, whats the intro song of the part 1 ?? Pls
Also for extra points: some of these singers have to disguise their accents when they sing because they’re European.
Only Question, Wheres Anneke?
Anette me sorprendió saludos desde Bolivia \m/
That last one was straight savage. I love it.
I listen to all kinds of music (well almost all) but it wasn't until i discovered Nightwish all the way back in 1999 that i got such a deep respect for the metal singers. Up to that point for me metal was mainly male singers, who were singing well in studio, but very rarely kept the level on live performances. Then started discovering more and more female singers like Anneke, Cristina Scabbia, Simone - women who sound live better than the studio version. And now that we have powerhouses like Tatiana (Jinjer), Brittney (Unleash The Archers) and of course Floor (no need to specify) it's simply a fact that metal has a lot more talent in it than any other genre out there. BUT one pop singer i can get behind, cause she really has the voice and would've done extremely good in the metal if only she started singing outside the US - Fergie. She has the power and the drive in her voice that pop singers usually lack. It's a shame really she sold out to the American market.
Try Russell Allen from Symphony X is the best male metal singer in my opinion. For a firs listen I would recommend their song Egypt.
Gonna missed Marco.. But its just another gate for new room. Wonder who ever take his place..
I could be wrong but I strongly believe this difference takes place because metal musicians are classically trained and focus on growing and improving their skills.
Yeah. Whole pop scene after 2000 started transforming into a product for average consumer
Yesterday I saw a live video of Lacuna Coil. Holy Crap, Christina can sing!!
2:34 Es la mejor la AMOOOOO
I have been told that auto tuners are not even compatible with metal sounds. There is even a rumor that Amaranthe fried an auto tuner during a recording session.
can somebody tell me what is the name of the markos clip? the first ıslander but ı couldnt find the second one