@@DianaJG8 I too heard that many years ago and it certainly is Eric playing lead, what puzzles me is that the backing vocals sounds exactly like Paul. Maybe it's just Lennon that was missing.
And fascinating that George and Eric were both in love with the same woman. The pain comes through with George's writing and singing and Eric's guitar solo.
For a couple of days post-release people were saying, "God damn. Harrison's guitar work has stepped up a level", until the word came out about Clapton's uncredited contribution.
Yep, im 23 and a big hip hop fan but if i could only listen to 1 artist for the rest of my life its always gonna be The Beatles, it doesnt matter what generation youre from with them.
@@aaronbarrera1657 queen are massively overrated imo, they have a few songs i like but none that i really love where i could probably name 40 songs by the beatles that i could listen to on repeat all day. Each to their own though i suppose
Today, it would be Autotuned and recorded in many bits each in different parts of world, musicians not in same room. Then pretty much recorded as a live performance of band in same room having to sing in tune and play together. That was limit and benefit of using analogue real to reel tape. Ok, there were things they could do with multitrack, loops, etc but, ultimately, it's a record of a real performance
The best quote I ever heard was from a music critic. "The Beatles have taken Rock and Roll from a fad and turned it into an art form." Their music is timeless.
There's a great quote from the documentary The Complete Beatles from an Oxford musicologist, saying that The Beatles Sgt. Pepper marked the turning point where pop music stopped being ritualistic dance music, and became music to be listened to.
@@user-yu1yz6qk1g Compared to the Beatles yes they were. But there's no disgrace in that. Most everybody else was and is too. How many bands today will be remembered with the same affection as the Beatles are fifty one years after they split up ?
One of my true favorites written by George Harrison.❤️ You are not crazy. Tom Petty, Jeff Lynne, and Prince did it as a tribute along with George's son. Check it out on RUclips. It was amazing.❤️
His tone on this song and Glass Onion is phenomenal. I’m pretty sure it’s his Rickenbacker, but I’m not sure what amp he’s going through. Could be a Vox. Great stuff, either way.
George was basically a master of song writing all four of them were ahead of their time. If this came out today it would put everything written in 21 to shame
They were. Ringo wasn't a song writer but man he could drum. I'm a drummer and not bad use to gig before everything shut down and I tried to play Day in a life last night and it was an epic fail. song is so hard to get right.
Invented recording techniques using archaic recording equipment. Took a lot of work piecing some of their albums together as far as engineering. Amazing !🤘❤️🇨🇦
All groups and musicians were using the same techniques as the Beatles… They all had the same technology… The degree of experimentation was a matter of taste…. The Beach Boys and The Moody Blues were highly experimental, with the Moody Blues introducing The Beatles to the Mellotron, as well as being the roots of Progressive rock…
This is the reason why The Beatles never reached their peak. Yes they did have a massive impact on the music scene, mind you Rolling Stones and Bee Gee's had a far bigger impact. If The Beatles hadn't mistreated Ringo or George as badly as they did and release their music like they should of, their impact would of been mind blowingly high. George alone overshadowed The Beatles as a whole after he left and went solo. This song isn't attributed to them at all.
The amount of musical influence from Great Britain on modern world music is beyond imagination. Beatles, Stones, Clapton, Pink Floyd... The list goes on and on.
I literally can't comprehend what horrors you were forced to experience, and yet here we are listening to a song that brings us all together. My guitar weeps.
You have identified one of the biggest reasons people love the Beatles so much and for so long. Their music always sounds fresh - it never gets old, literally.
With all due respect to Paul and John, I always found George's songs to be the most beautiful. I followed John later and Paul with the Wings band, and liked them, but George music just speaks to me.
Not the most beautiful, but the deepest. It goes directly to the heart. George was my favourite as an individual. I love Lennon and Macca, but the only Beatle I wanted to marry when I was a teen was George. And they had already splitter for years then!
@@jeffreykaufmann2867 Oh, there are several that Lennon and McCartney did that are very deep. ‘I’m only sleeping’ and ‘Golden Slumbers’ come to my mind. But ‘While my guitar gently weeps’ and ‘within you without you’ are, in my opinion, in another level. The demo of ‘While my guitar gently weeps’ launched in ‘Love’ made me cry, especially when the phrase ‘cause I’m sitting here doing nothing but aging’ came as a novelty from the original recording…..when you think that the guy who wrote that was in his 20’s and just compare to what is around you, you’ll see that George had that ‘woomp’ element that not even Lennon and McCartney had. It was very well shown in the ‘Get Back’ documentary.
@@taradalik1405Most Beatles fans including me would disagree.I'm only Sleeping isn't a deep Song. Its about a Lazy guy who just wants to stay in Bed. George Harrison doesn't come close to Lennon and McCartney when it comes to the high Quantity of Quality songs. Within you Without you has great lyrics but lacks Melody. You can't get any deeper than "Imagine" or Working Class Hero by Lennon.
@@helz420 I've heard that Yogi Berra saying, but that's not always true. It's true in baseball, and many other things, but not for everything. For many things another saying is true: "It's all over except for the crying". That's the case with mankind. He's destroyed several things about the planet beyond repair. Too much pollution, greed, hatred, wars and just plain old selfishness. And while it is true that if everybody had love for everybody, then man might be able to achieve a great civilization. But that's just never going to happen. There has always been a lot of hatred in the world. No reason to believe that's ever going to change, not while God isn't governing mankind. But thanks for the positivity. I hope you and George and all the other undying optimists are right - that man will get his act together and make his (our) civilization a beautiful thing. I simply think that this whole mess is a demonstration in the futility of man trying to govern himself without God. We have everything we need to create a utopian civilization, yet we ever fail. "The handwriting is on the wall." "Stick a fork in it." We're done. (Too many clichés?) But DAMN - this was a great song! So well written! And the recording/arrangement!!! - Listen to it with good headphones or high quality ear buds to hear everything the best. Or, at (very) high volume through high quality speakers (JBL, etc.). But good quality headphones/ear buds are the best in my opinion. I prefer them over loudspeakers in the studio, even for just playback. You can better hear the stereo effects, and those sounds at very low volume in the background. It's impossible to get the same listening experience with loudspeakers.
They talked about that in season 2 of 'Treme' - not this song particularly, but about how a great song can apply to any time and just about any circumstances, one character thought a song was written in response to Hurricane Katrina and then was told it was written something like 20 years earlier, and yet it could still apply to the Hurricane. That's why the end score of Tschaikovsky's Swan Lake works no matter what ending the director and choreographers died to go with.
Yes. The “White Album” is the most modern sounding Beatle’s album. They harnessed distortion in the modern compressed way. And three songwriters were on fire at the same time. It will never date. And what’s still hard to believe: Its the same band that sang “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” just 4 years earlier. What a mind-boggling artistic trajectory.
You are correct. The amount of artistic growth in The Beatles during those seven years they recorded together is, was, staggeringly brilliant as well as the quantity. They were hard workers they were. Btw, I love "I Wanna Hold Your Hand". For me a pure joyful listen.
@@jmad627 Funny. I’m very fanatical about the 1966-1968 Beatles (and some ‘65 stuff), but I can’t listen to that early “Yeah, Yeah, Yeah” materiel. I find “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” to be a painful listen and very trite and phony. Never understood the fuss over that one. Compared to “Hey Bulldog” for instance? And the general public doesn’t even know that brilliant track exists. But I guess ‘64 was a critical growth stage for them. Some of their straight-up Rock &Roll covers from ‘64 are cool; like “Money” ,”Roll Over Beethoven” and “Long Tall Sally.”
The final verse, that was left out: "I look from the wings, at the play you are staging, while my guitar gently weeps, 'cause I'm sitting here doing nothing but aging, still my guitar gently weeps." This song has a circular structure, almost as if laid out on a mandala, and George wrote another song called "Circles", about the same time, it was intended for this same album, but it didn't come out until 1982.
These Beatles reaction videos always make me happy. I can't remember what it was like to hear Beatles songs for the first time, but there's just so much there that makes you go wtf, how did they write all this shit in 8 years? It's pretty mind blowing that they had 27 number one hits. Love them or hate them, the Beatles will never be topped. They have something for everyone.
This group has three incredible songwriters, an innovative producer and sound engineers(s) and four gifted musicians eager to push their boundaries. That helps explain how you can hear so many “kinds” of Beatles music and songs that can even sound current. Love them.
Sir George Martin - producer - the "fifth" Beatle - 5 gifted individuals together in the one lifetime - whose music will span so many lifetimes after them
Fair enough -that’s a good song, and Ringo is irreplaceable. :D I actually think he was the glue that held keep them together for as long as they lasted.
Ringo only really suffers in comparison because John, Paul and George were absolutely amazing while he was just very good. I remember when the all Beatles version of rock band came out and one reviewer commented that while maybe Ringo’s drumming wasn’t as complex as some others, it was always tight and spot-on.
Honestly, this song is infinitely better than anything coming out now. No one writes this good anymore and so few can play real instruments, let alone sing without studio effects.
You can make a decent attempt at an EDM tune on a laptop, but people who haven't sung anywhere other than into a mic in their bedroom rarely have a voice which would be presentable in public. But then laptops have 100x more technology than the Beatles had at Abbey Rd.
I am 51. My parents are Beatles fans. I am a Beatles fan, and my children are Beatles fans. I have siblings who's children are Beatles fans. That is FOUR GENERATIONS. This is how epic bands like the Beatles, Led Zeppelin, The Who, The Rolling Stones etc. are. They are multi generation bands.
@@ctbadger What are they fans of? Big band, jazz… I was lucky enough to have a music appreciative family. Why I became a musician. I’ve met people who could care less and have no musical interest. I cannot imagine being that way. The Beatles appeal to every generation and always will.🤘❤️🇨🇦
I was 14 in 1968 and remember it well when the White Album came out. A beautiful song by George Harrison. And no, you're not crazy, the Beatles WERE ahead of their time imo.
Glad you liked it! Imagine how we felt as teenagers listening when it first hit. I was 13. We used to say, "Clapton is god." But The Beatles -- that's why everybody freaked out when they broke up. People talked about it for at least ten years.
Just think, they "formed" in 1962... put out all this timeless, incredible music, and were done as a band by 1970. 51 years ago. Thankfully, they all went on to create some incredible music after that as solo artists. This amount of talent in a single band will never be equaled again.
John & Paul started playing/writing together in 1957. They recorded their first record as "The Quarrymen" in 1958. Their first professional recording sessions were in Hamburg, Germany in 1961. By the time they made their "first" recordings for EMI in June, 1962, they were already quite well established.
John and Paul started a little earlier than that. But your point is valid. How much chart-topping music (and just how much music in general) they made in such a short time, and how different it was start to finish - how much growth and change they had musically - is amazing. They were before my time, but my dad was a fan so I listened to them growing up. And now I hear their influence in most modern music.
My generation was spoiled, we grew up with the absolute best music. Check out the group WAR. "Slipping into Darkness", "Spill the Wine", "the Cisco Kid" and "Low Rider"
You should check out the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame version of this song with Prince. Rock n Roll legends fill the stage and Prince steals the show. It's rare when I like a non Beatles version of a Beatles song so much but it's amazing. BTW, Eric Clapton plays the guitar solo in this original version of the song. George Harrison wrote some of the most beautiful Beatles songs.
I dont believe that was part of the R&R Hall of Fame thing. I think that was the concert for George after he passed right? Because George was still alive when they were inducted in the 80s. The Prince thing was very recent
There are many versions with Clapton and Harrison playing lead together that are outstanding and in my opinion better than Prince’s which was good, but with too much flare, unbecoming of a George composition. There is this one with Dave Grohl, Gary Clark Jr and Joe Walsh playing on the 50th Anniversary of the Beatles coming to America that well worth a listen. ruclips.net/video/FpKqX7UyP8E/видео.html
I agree with Amy. Watch the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame version! There's one for the Concert for George, which is cool, but the one with Prince is AMAZING.
You should check out the newer version of this one with George 's son, Clapton, Jeff Lynn, and Prince. Such awesome guitars on stage and playing their hearts out.
@@Jonni1027 If you love Penny Lane, check out "The Beatles: a musical appreciation and analysis by composer, Howard Goodall CBE" at 17:05. It will definitely give you a new perspective on it. It's amazing.
This was George's masterpiece from the White album. Lennon's best song is Happiness is a Warm Gun. If you like While My Guitar Gently Weeps, you'll definitely like Happiness is a Warm Gun.
I agree, this was my favorite album and my first album for that matter in the late 60s then Zeppelin , I ended up with all their albums over the years.
It was when I was 13. The best part of being a teen in the 60s and 70s was the music. Music back then was a true experience and brought people together instead of deviding us like music today.
It's totally crazy how good that bassline is. It's so heavy, like a powerhouse, but so well-crafted that it offers a perfect counter point to the superb guitars played by Harrison and Clapton.
This might be the best time to listen to Blackbird. It's genius and was written on the fly by Paul McCartney who was inspired by the civil rights movement while touring the US.
We call them the Psychedelic Beatles... Freaked us out too. Lol You run down to the record store, buy the newest Beatles record take it home, run it home, put it on the phonograph, and what!!?? Couldn't understand it at all. I cried for days ! What happened to MY Beatles!? Well, they got high...😅
@@ZAOUWV not really Im 13 and I know and love them, so much that I'm going to their museum in Liverpool in a couple of months. They are a timeless band that could never be forgotten.
I was 13 years old when the song came out. I had never heard anything like it. These men were just brilliant. Serious musicians great talents not about money about the art. Very different time young man This is timeless. Thank you so much for your wonderful reactions and your genuine Self take good care and have fun.
My son and I were dressed as Scooby Doo characters last Halloween and we recorded a spontaneous cover of this song. We had never played it 'together' before, but it was the only song that we both knew from memory, off the top of our heads. The audio isn't great, but I uploaded it for our family as a Halloween greeting, and aside from the sound quality, we got a groove going, just piano and guitar. Your channel has low-key been an inspiration to me in the past year. I suffered a head injury and lost my memory 4 years ago, and I knew I loved music but didn't remember that I played piano/'did' music. Watching you discover tunes has helped me re-discover those tunes and even recover memories that I thought I'd lost forever. And this sounds dorky, but after the 100th time you said "do the work every day" I decided to try taking your advice. I'm not comfortable on camera (which probably shows--I'm sort of 'autistic' since the injury), but I 'remembered' the hell out of this song, and I realised that I'd played it for so many years before the amnesia that my son knew it as well as I did. Music lives within the memory of our bodies... and those memories are tenacious enough to withstand brain injury. :) Anyway, sorry I rambled, but this channel has brought me out of my shell a little bit, and I guess I thought I should say thank you. (Even if nobody else does when they come across my videos.) :) You're a rock star!
Also, the version of this song that George Martin added strings to (on the "Love" album) is one of the most beautiful things your ears will ever behold. It is otherworldly beautiful.
Sounds like you are too, keep working hard on your recovery as you are now in my heart and thoughts too. I truly hope you recover loads more of your memories and I am certain I will definitely not be the only one that would wish this to you! Take care, stay safe and get better too xx
The craziest thing about the Beatles is that they did it all in 7 years. George was 26 when they recorded their last song together. Incredible range in a such a short span of time.
Goerge Harrison wrote this song he was had spent a lot of time in inda and believed in fait so he got book of the book shelf and opened it on a random page and my guitar gently weeps was the first three words on the page and he created this absolutely amazing song Eric Clapton plays the guitar solos in it what an amazing song
I have never been a fan of the expression "They were ahead of their time". IMO they were the originators of the time. They weren't ahead of their time. The music of today is just way behind the times.
I also love George Harrison's 1987 solo album, "Cloud Nine". It also sounds timeless and fresh even 34 years later. "I Got My Mind Set on You" was a huge radio hit at the time, but I like the title song and "Someplace Else" even better. But make no mistake: the entire album is precious!
Your Mom was one, I was 13. I am so happy to see young people like you, James, that appreciates the music I grew up with. Sixties/seventies music is the best, most complex music ever recorded and I am so thankful this music was the soundtrack to my formative years.
Man, I’m jealous! There is some good genuine music today but it’s hard to find, and it’s kinda hard to sound new and exciting even for good bands and artists. I can only imagine how crazy it must have been to be alive to hear the musical explosion of that time.
I couldn't agree more. I was born in 1980 and I still think most of the greatest music came during the '60s & 70s. Videos like this prove how much staying it power it has, too.
@@futurereflections4097 It was so crazy that I am still discovering music from that time I didn't listen to. I was born in '56 so I was too young to appreciate the Beatles when they first appeared. When I was in HS I was really into the singer-songwriters (Cat Stevens, Carole King, James Taylor, Neil Diamond, Simon and Garfunkel, etc) and started to move into light rock like the Eagles. The last 20 years has been a journey to revisit what I missed: Zeppelin, Beatles, Floyd, Who, etc. The 60's and 70's produced so much timeless music that it is taking a lifetime to absorb.
The Beatles were phenomenal. Dive deep into their music. They had so many different sounds over the years and they only got better. They were a very special and perfect gift to the world.
Even crazier when you listen to some 50s music for reference. Some 50s music was good, but 1965-1969 put music into the future in such a short span of time.
I bought every Beatles vinyl album when they first came out in the 60s and still have all of them in great condition. From Meet The Beatles to Abbey Road they are still astounding me. They still sound so good it is unbelievable. He is right on!
@@stanzaloan3454 This Beatles always had session musicians on instruments they weren't familiar with. However, this is the only time they had someone else on guitar.
@@DavidGigg not only do you have to be "familiar with" but you have to be a master of your instrument for playing the trumpet part of "Penny Lane" or the French horn part of "For No One"
I was 9 in 1964, a teenager in 68. In the 70s on campus there was another generation who were like your reaction, RUclips has brought their sublime greatness to yet another generation. Thank you.
This song is timeless, one of my favourites from The Beatles, came out the year I was born. I have a lot of Beatles music on vinyl as my Dad collected & was a huge fan. He went to see them in 1964 in Melbourne, Australia
Yes! That is the genius of The Beatles. They ab-so-lute-ly changed music forever. I can't think of another band that can still be heard coming through other music of fifty years later.
Written and sung by George Harrison with a guest appearance by Eric Clapton on lead guitar!
George brought Eric in to play when the other Beatles were ignoring him on this song...
Which I think was GREAT! 😊
@@DianaJG8 I too heard that many years ago and it certainly is Eric playing lead, what puzzles me is that the backing vocals sounds exactly like Paul. Maybe it's just Lennon that was missing.
And fascinating that George and Eric were both in love with the same woman. The pain comes through with George's writing and singing and Eric's guitar solo.
For a couple of days post-release people were saying, "God damn. Harrison's guitar work has stepped up a level", until the word came out about Clapton's uncredited contribution.
You can spot Clapton right away. George structured it but him backing a blues player made it THE BEST TRACK ON A DOUBLE ALBUM
Yep, im 23 and a big hip hop fan but if i could only listen to 1 artist for the rest of my life its always gonna be The Beatles, it doesnt matter what generation youre from with them.
You should try Bob Dylan, the best songwriter of all time according to many people. He even won the Nobel Prize for literature for his lyrics.
@@fornostios8970 I love Bob Dylan but to be fair- it took me years to get his stuff. beatles are great to start with.
Same!
I love the Beatles, but it’d have to be Queen for me
@@aaronbarrera1657 queen are massively overrated imo, they have a few songs i like but none that i really love where i could probably name 40 songs by the beatles that i could listen to on repeat all day. Each to their own though i suppose
The Beatles rabbit hole is beyond all others. It is a cavern of wonder. A miracle.
I like the "Cavern" reference.
I disagree. I think The Beatles are a blackhole once in you never get out! The best band of all time.
All in just 10 years, too.
Nice play on words👍👍
I see what you did there. 🧐
I'm honestly sympathetic to folks that have never had this song in their life. Or Beatles songs in general. Thanks for spreading the joy.
Yeah. It's best to grow up with them since you were a child. It's like a soundtrack for life. Lol
Today, it would be Autotuned and recorded in many bits each in different parts of world, musicians not in same room. Then pretty much recorded as a live performance of band in same room having to sing in tune and play together. That was limit and benefit of using analogue real to reel tape. Ok, there were things they could do with multitrack, loops, etc but, ultimately, it's a record of a real performance
RIP George Harrison that wrote and sang this one for the Beatles. He is still sorely missed.
Missed sooo much!
The best quote I ever heard was from a music critic. "The Beatles have taken Rock and Roll from a fad and turned it into an art form." Their music is timeless.
There's a great quote from the documentary The Complete Beatles from an Oxford musicologist, saying that The Beatles Sgt. Pepper marked the turning point where pop music stopped being ritualistic dance music, and became music to be listened to.
Chuck Berry Gene Vincent Elvis Presley were " a fad "?
@@user-yu1yz6qk1g Compared to the Beatles yes they were. But there's no disgrace in that. Most everybody else was and is too. How many bands today will be remembered with the same affection as the Beatles are fifty one years after they split up ?
@@user-yu1yz6qk1g yes
U do know that jimi Hendrix came before the Beatles right? One of the greatest guitarists of all time? Wouldnt call him a fad
One of my true favorites written by George Harrison.❤️ You are not crazy. Tom Petty, Jeff Lynne, and Prince did it as a tribute along with George's son. Check it out on RUclips. It was amazing.❤️
and the version in the Movie Across the Universe .
strong agree. I can't watch that performance without crying, tbh (RIP George, Prince, and Tom).
Watch that performance. Prince does an an amazing guitar solo that is not surprising to anyone who knows how good Prince’s guitar playing was.
YES!!
A fantastic tribute
RLR : this song will either be psychedelic, or sad, or hard core, or smooth.
Beatles fans : yes
Or soulful or poppy or merseybeat or ..........
Or just utter pure class
Sad, but wise
All of the above (plus Eric F***ing Clapton!!)
Or all the all the above.
The Beatles weren't just ahead of the curve - they were THE curve.
I was born in 1948 and I still love this song ; that is why the Beatles are the best.
The Beatles were and are timeless.
I'm 67 and glad yet another generation experiences what I did "All those years ago".
Another fine Harrison song.
When listening to the Beatles, if you isolate the bass , you realize how amazing Paul McCartney was on bass.
He changed the game
He always played only the right notes!
His tone on this song and Glass Onion is phenomenal. I’m pretty sure it’s his Rickenbacker, but I’m not sure what amp he’s going through. Could be a Vox. Great stuff, either way.
Glass Onion, this track and some others on the White Album were most likely his Fender Jazz Bass
@@mr_bassman6685 Could be! I've gotten close to that tone with my own Jazz Bass and Fender bass amp, but not quite.
George was basically a master of song writing all four of them were ahead of their time. If this came out today it would put everything written in 21 to shame
@Kevin Nelson I'm thinking 2021. Cheers....
It STILL puts everything in 21 to shame, except yesterday's release of Tom Petty's "Finding Wildflowers"
They were. Ringo wasn't a song writer but man he could drum. I'm a drummer and not bad use to gig before everything shut down and I tried to play Day in a life last night and it was an epic fail. song is so hard to get right.
If this came out today, where would you hesr it? Adult contemporary radio?
@@barbarascotto3873 Oh c'mon man. Cardi B's Wap is a masterpiece.
There isn't anything today that sounds this good
Welcome to the Beatles. The word you’re looking for is “timeless“
The Beatles changed everything bro, way ahead of the game, never stayed the same , always evolving and all in 7 yrs from 1st song to last. Unreal.
The only band where you instantly recognize the song from the moment the song starts. Even the intros are masterpieces.
This is why some music is referred to as "timeless".
we will talk about the beatles in 300 years, the same we talk about mozart and beethoven today
@@dngdnf4862 i am going to assume you meant “we” as in the human race ... lol
@@johnberg9497 yes my friend, yes )
@@johnberg9497 I'm sure he also meant our soon to be alien overlords appreciating earth music alongside us 😁😂
@@dngdnf4862 Gee, I don't know, I was planning on being around for a minimum of five hundred more years. And then I awoke from the dream.
What’s crazy is that they did this with archaic recording techniques. It’s truly amazing 🤩
Invented recording techniques using archaic recording equipment. Took a lot of work piecing some of their albums together as far as engineering. Amazing !🤘❤️🇨🇦
They did song editing by cutting tape with scissors and taping the segments together!
Lol. You funny
All groups and musicians were using the same techniques as the Beatles… They all had the same technology… The degree of experimentation was a matter of taste…. The Beach Boys and The Moody Blues were highly experimental, with the Moody Blues introducing The Beatles to the Mellotron, as well as being the roots of Progressive rock…
Which is why it was so good. I mean they invented so many techniques.
Had the incredible privilege to see them live in concert 3 times in the 60s. Yes, they are timeless. No auto-tune back then, just pure talent.
My envy-o-meter just went to 11.
Out of curiosity, if you ever did have a favorite Beatle....Which one is/was it??? (Personally, mine is and always will be George. 😊)
I was fortunate to see the Beatles play live 4 times twice in one day and from seats 4 from the stage. They are the first and will never be outdone
Yer older than dirt but ya have GREAT memories. Ya ain't old, yer just experienced.
My aunt saw them twice...RIP, lost her in 2021.
That bass line is like from another dimension. Sometimes I only feel the solo guitar and sometimes I play it and listen only to the bass.
And to think, Paul went to bass by default.
hey can u explain to me what the bass is please. My main language is not english and i’m getting little by little into the beatles
is it like the guitar and drums behind?
@@lilerial3278 Bass guitar typically has four strings and it provides the low sounds - “bottom” - of the rhythm portion of a song.
This is one reason why the Beatles had the most impact on the history of music
I disagree. they didn't care about such rubbish!
@@dannynewey4056 They may care, they may not. Fact is, they did impact music to a massive degree.
This is the reason why The Beatles never reached their peak. Yes they did have a massive impact on the music scene, mind you Rolling Stones and Bee Gee's had a far bigger impact. If The Beatles hadn't mistreated Ringo or George as badly as they did and release their music like they should of, their impact would of been mind blowingly high. George alone overshadowed The Beatles as a whole after he left and went solo. This song isn't attributed to them at all.
@@theghost6412 Lol your comment makes no sense, you’re completely wrong that’s sad
@@liamb58 how is it wrong or make no sense?
The amount of musical influence from Great Britain on modern world music is beyond imagination.
Beatles, Stones, Clapton, Pink Floyd...
The list goes on and on.
Bert, I fully agree with you. The Who, the Kinks, Deep Purple, Elton John, Oasis, The Clash, Black Sabbath, Queen...
@@thomasshreve750 Led Zep, Radiohead, Massive Attack, Jam, Joy Division, Roxy Music, David Bowie, The Who, The Smiths... the list is endless
Moody Blues
Led zeppelin
The WHO, TRAFFIC, BLIND FAITH
I was lock downed in Nam. Got back in 69 and this piece of excellence almost slipped me by; but my wife had a single copy and an album. I loved it.
Thank you, sir, for your service. Blessings.
I literally can't comprehend what horrors you were forced to experience, and yet here we are listening to a song that brings us all together. My guitar weeps.
Thank you for the time you spent in Vietnam John. I know it must have been an extremely tough time for you.
Here's too you brother 🍺
Thank you for your sacrifice and your service.
Thank you sir for your service God bless you
You have identified one of the biggest reasons people love the Beatles so much and for so long. Their music always sounds fresh - it never gets old, literally.
As proved by Now and Then...
With all due respect to Paul and John, I always found George's songs to be the most beautiful. I followed John later and Paul with the Wings band, and liked them, but George music just speaks to me.
Agreed.
Not the most beautiful, but the deepest. It goes directly to the heart. George was my favourite as an individual. I love Lennon and Macca, but the only Beatle I wanted to marry when I was a teen was George. And they had already splitter for years then!
@@taradalik1405 I disagree. In My Life and She's leaving home are two of the Beatles' deepest Songs.
@@jeffreykaufmann2867 Oh, there are several that Lennon and McCartney did that are very deep. ‘I’m only sleeping’ and ‘Golden Slumbers’ come to my mind.
But ‘While my guitar gently weeps’ and ‘within you without you’ are, in my opinion, in another level. The demo of ‘While my guitar gently weeps’ launched in ‘Love’ made me cry, especially when the phrase ‘cause I’m sitting here doing nothing but aging’ came as a novelty from the original recording…..when you think that the guy who wrote that was in his 20’s and just compare to what is around you, you’ll see that George had that ‘woomp’ element that not even Lennon and McCartney had. It was very well shown in the ‘Get Back’ documentary.
@@taradalik1405Most Beatles fans including me would disagree.I'm only Sleeping isn't a deep Song. Its about a Lazy guy who just wants to stay in Bed. George Harrison doesn't come close to Lennon and McCartney when it comes to the high Quantity of Quality songs. Within you Without you has great lyrics but lacks Melody. You can't get any deeper than "Imagine" or Working Class Hero by Lennon.
Those songs aren't ahead of their time, they are timeless. A sound and an emotion that everyone can understand no matter when. Good stuff.
Usually the main reason why a song becomes timeless is precisely because it is ahead of it's time .
YAAAAAAAAAS!!!!
You might not realize it, but you already reacted to this song when Prince played the guitar for the tribute to George Harrison.
oh dear...
It was a very good version, but for me, you can’t beat the original on this one. Just my opinion...
That Prince version is an ay-may-zing watch.
@@Mardyfella speaking of guitars Prince was one of the greatest.
@@edwinanglin4490 Exactly!
"With every mistake we must surely be learning..." His guitar is still weeping.
He had hope for mankind. Too bad. Man is destined to fail. He's coming to an ugly, tragic end very soon. With every mistake - we don't learn.
@@garyginther6742 "It ain't over till its over." -Yogi Berra
"All you need is love." -The Beatles
@@helz420 I've heard that Yogi Berra saying, but that's not always true. It's true in baseball, and many other things, but not for everything. For many things another saying is true: "It's all over except for the crying". That's the case with mankind. He's destroyed several things about the planet beyond repair. Too much pollution, greed, hatred, wars and just plain old selfishness.
And while it is true that if everybody had love for everybody, then man might be able to achieve a great civilization. But that's just never going to happen. There has always been a lot of hatred in the world. No reason to believe that's ever going to change, not while God isn't governing mankind.
But thanks for the positivity. I hope you and George and all the other undying optimists are right - that man will get his act together and make his (our) civilization a beautiful thing. I simply think that this whole mess is a demonstration in the futility of man trying to govern himself without God. We have everything we need to create a utopian civilization, yet we ever fail. "The handwriting is on the wall." "Stick a fork in it." We're done. (Too many clichés?)
But DAMN - this was a great song! So well written! And the recording/arrangement!!! - Listen to it with good headphones or high quality ear buds to hear everything the best. Or, at (very) high volume through high quality speakers (JBL, etc.). But good quality headphones/ear buds are the best in my opinion. I prefer them over loudspeakers in the studio, even for just playback. You can better hear the stereo effects, and those sounds at very low volume in the background. It's impossible to get the same listening experience with loudspeakers.
@@garyginther6742 You do not understand where George was coming from at all. Read the Bhagavad Gita, that's where this song comes from.
Fine lyrics , huh ?!
"Sounds like a song that comes out in 2021" - Truth is eternal and nothing ever really changes
They talked about that in season 2 of 'Treme' - not this song particularly, but about how a great song can apply to any time and just about any circumstances, one character thought a song was written in response to Hurricane Katrina and then was told it was written something like 20 years earlier, and yet it could still apply to the Hurricane. That's why the end score of Tschaikovsky's Swan Lake works no matter what ending the director and choreographers died to go with.
Yes. The “White Album” is the most modern sounding Beatle’s album. They harnessed distortion in the modern compressed way. And three songwriters were on fire at the same time. It will never date. And what’s still hard to believe: Its the same band that sang “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” just 4 years earlier. What a mind-boggling artistic trajectory.
Agree. The template for every kind of music that came afterwards was there. Every single one.
You are correct. The amount of artistic growth in The Beatles during those seven years they recorded together is, was, staggeringly brilliant as well as the quantity. They were hard workers they were.
Btw, I love "I Wanna Hold Your Hand". For me a pure joyful listen.
@@jmad627 Funny. I’m very fanatical about the 1966-1968 Beatles (and some ‘65 stuff), but I can’t listen to that early “Yeah, Yeah, Yeah” materiel. I find “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” to be a painful listen and very trite and phony. Never understood the fuss over that one. Compared to “Hey Bulldog” for instance? And the general public doesn’t even know that brilliant track exists. But I guess ‘64 was a critical growth stage for them. Some of their straight-up Rock &Roll covers from ‘64 are cool; like “Money” ,”Roll Over Beethoven” and “Long Tall Sally.”
@@georgeorr1042 I dunno, I love all of it. To each their own.
@@georgeorr1042 The last 3 songs you mentioned were not written by the Beatles.
I love how sincere you are about The Beatles. We are lucky to have shared the same planet with them.
Equally amazing is the demo version that George recorded at his home studio.
100%
On some days if prefer it to this version.
I love that recording.
Is that the version on LOVE? That one is devastating.
The final verse, that was left out:
"I look from the wings, at the play you are staging, while my guitar gently weeps, 'cause I'm sitting here doing nothing but aging, still my guitar gently weeps."
This song has a circular structure, almost as if laid out on a mandala, and George wrote another song called "Circles", about the same time, it was intended for this same album, but it didn't come out until 1982.
2 Beatles songs that’ll blow your mind in showing their diversity in styles of music: Eleanor Rigby or Tomorrow Never Knows
And they are on the same album!
Totally agree 👍👍👍
@@eddiewillers1442 that album is the entirety of the 60s in fourteen songs...
@@misterschubert3242 revolver is not a product of its time it sounds like nothing else from the 60s
@@misterschubert3242 - Rob?
I love George such beautiful song! Beautiful George 🙏
These Beatles reaction videos always make me happy. I can't remember what it was like to hear Beatles songs for the first time, but there's just so much there that makes you go wtf, how did they write all this shit in 8 years? It's pretty mind blowing that they had 27 number one hits. Love them or hate them, the Beatles will never be topped. They have something for everyone.
This group has three incredible songwriters, an innovative producer and sound engineers(s) and four gifted musicians eager to push their boundaries. That helps explain how you can hear so many “kinds” of Beatles music and songs that can even sound current. Love them.
Hey, give Ringo some credit. Octopus’ Garden is one catchy tune!
@@kevinhayden4605 yellow submarine, listen for footsteps
Sir George Martin - producer - the "fifth" Beatle - 5 gifted individuals together in the one lifetime - whose music will span so many lifetimes after them
Fair enough -that’s a good song, and Ringo is irreplaceable. :D
I actually think he was the glue that held keep them together for as long as they lasted.
Ringo only really suffers in comparison because John, Paul and George were absolutely amazing while he was just very good.
I remember when the all Beatles version of rock band came out and one reviewer commented that while maybe Ringo’s drumming wasn’t as complex as some others, it was always tight and spot-on.
God bless you Rome for getting it....us older folks that grew up with this music have been restored!
Honestly, this song is infinitely better than anything coming out now. No one writes this good anymore and so few can play real instruments, let alone sing without studio effects.
You can make a decent attempt at an EDM tune on a laptop, but people who haven't sung anywhere other than into a mic in their bedroom rarely have a voice which would be presentable in public. But then laptops have 100x more technology than the Beatles had at Abbey Rd.
This is why there will never be another Beatles.
And THAT'S why The Beatles still and always will matter
I am 51. My parents are Beatles fans. I am a Beatles fan, and my children are Beatles fans. I have siblings who's children are Beatles fans. That is FOUR GENERATIONS. This is how epic bands like the Beatles, Led Zeppelin, The Who, The Rolling Stones etc. are. They are multi generation bands.
I’m 52 and I don’t understand how my parents AREN’T Beatles fans. My 10 year old is though...
Yes, i am 56 and my parents were Beatle fans, as are my kids, and my 15 year old granddaughter. ....
Three.
I am 50. Same story.🤘❤️🇨🇦
@@ctbadger What are they fans of? Big band, jazz… I was lucky enough to have a music appreciative family. Why I became a musician. I’ve met people who could care less and have no musical interest. I cannot imagine being that way. The Beatles appeal to every generation and always will.🤘❤️🇨🇦
I was 14 in 1968 and remember it well when the White Album came out. A beautiful song by George Harrison. And no, you're not crazy, the Beatles WERE ahead of their time imo.
How did people react to it at the time?
@@mattymaclean621 We loved it!
@@marymargaretmoore9034 how crazy was it the following year to see Helter Skelter taken a little too seriously?
This song came out 5 years after "I wanna hold your hand".
Glad you liked it! Imagine how we felt as teenagers listening when it first hit. I was 13. We used to say, "Clapton is god." But The Beatles -- that's why everybody freaked out when they broke up. People talked about it for at least ten years.
E.C. Was a minor god. 57 years on and his accomplishments are unmatched. A very complicated guy, IMHO.
Did you mention Clapton because he was the guest lead guitarist on this track?
Hi Sandy, I was 13 in '67 as well and the Beatles, Cream, Zeppelin change my life.........🎼🎸🥁
Until John died
@@raysteer5716 Those were the days. I miss my youth. Just turned 67.
Just think, they "formed" in 1962... put out all this timeless, incredible music, and were done as a band by 1970. 51 years ago. Thankfully, they all went on to create some incredible music after that as solo artists. This amount of talent in a single band will never be equaled again.
Well, we tried our best!!😁😉👍👍👍👍🎸💖💞💓
John & Paul started playing/writing together in 1957. They recorded their first record as "The Quarrymen" in 1958. Their first professional recording sessions were in Hamburg, Germany in 1961. By the time they made their "first" recordings for EMI in June, 1962, they were already quite well established.
John and Paul started a little earlier than that. But your point is valid. How much chart-topping music (and just how much music in general) they made in such a short time, and how different it was start to finish - how much growth and change they had musically - is amazing. They were before my time, but my dad was a fan so I listened to them growing up. And now I hear their influence in most modern music.
11 albums. One can listen to every Beatles song in one day. That's incredible. Lots more good than bad.
My generation was spoiled, we grew up with the absolute best music.
Check out the group WAR. "Slipping into Darkness", "Spill the Wine", "the Cisco Kid" and "Low Rider"
Beatles in the bog by War
, to:uncle meat, You said it well. So late John Lennon said it also Musick.
Oh this is going to be good. His mind is still boggled by the song I Am The Walrus lmbo
And they did this all in 7 years. I can’t think of anyone else that did so much so well in such a short time.
Hendrix, SRV, Randy Rhodes
@@zachary963 I'm sorry but no
The Moody Blues… 1967-74.
@@zachary963 lmfao who?
@@zachary963 🤣😂🤣😝🤭🤪🤣
Songs come and go, The Beatles stays
Harrison was a visionary musician--this song was mostly his, he wrote and sang lead. He was so damn good!
You should check out the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame version of this song with Prince. Rock n Roll legends fill the stage and Prince steals the show. It's rare when I like a non Beatles version of a Beatles song so much but it's amazing. BTW, Eric Clapton plays the guitar solo in this original version of the song. George Harrison wrote some of the most beautiful Beatles songs.
Agreed - should put this one on the agenda.
I dont believe that was part of the R&R Hall of Fame thing. I think that was the concert for George after he passed right? Because George was still alive when they were inducted in the 80s. The Prince thing was very recent
There are many versions with Clapton and Harrison playing lead together that are outstanding and in my opinion better than Prince’s which was good, but with too much flare, unbecoming of a George composition. There is this one with Dave Grohl, Gary Clark Jr and Joe Walsh playing on the 50th Anniversary of the Beatles coming to America that well worth a listen.
ruclips.net/video/FpKqX7UyP8E/видео.html
@@Humblemumble7 R&R Hall of Fame, 2004, induction solo George. Eric Clapton did the solo and sang lead in Concert for George.
I agree with Amy. Watch the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame version! There's one for the Concert for George, which is cool, but the one with Prince is AMAZING.
As much as I LOVE U2...and I’m a HUGE fan...The Beatles are on a musical level all their own! Innovative technically and such music & lyrical talent!
Wendy, The Beatles are #1 and every one else is jockeying for position.
Do "Because" You'll Hear Angels Singing
I was just thinking that someone needs to react to Alice Cooper and the BeeGees singing "Because".
George Harrison, a mystic philosopher needed by the world at a certain time. Hope he's at peace wherever he is now 🙏❤️
Well said 👍
He is living at strawberry fields, john too
@@judithcabanero Strawberry Fields is a real place in Liverpool. No there aren’t there 😂
You should check out the newer version of this one with George 's son, Clapton, Jeff Lynn, and Prince. Such awesome guitars on stage and playing their hearts out.
I'm starting to think you're deliberately avoiding Penny Lane LOL
Hahaha.. I’m with you.. Penny Lane❤️
I was almost a Penny Lane! A timely relative death saved me! 😬
@@Jonni1027 If you love Penny Lane, check out "The Beatles: a musical appreciation and analysis by composer, Howard Goodall CBE" at 17:05. It will definitely give you a new perspective on it. It's amazing.
@@dealiecolburn7060 Like the groupie in Almost Famous?
Hope Not!!! 👍👍
The Beatles. Yesterday, today, and forever.
They are Heroes Ascended- Minor Gods in their own right.
This was George's masterpiece from the White album. Lennon's best song is Happiness is a Warm Gun. If you like While My Guitar Gently Weeps, you'll definitely like Happiness is a Warm Gun.
Harrison's song much better
I agree, this was my favorite album and my first album for that matter in the late 60s then Zeppelin , I ended up with all their albums over the years.
Brilliant melody, brilliant guitar, brilliant vocals, brillliant drums. Unforgettable song. The Beatles greatness!
There will never be another Beatles.
Beautiful song by George, he got a few great songs with the Beatles and then "All Things Must Past" after the breakup was a masterpiece.
It was when I was 13. The best part of being a teen in the 60s and 70s was the music. Music back then was a true experience and brought people together instead of deviding us like music today.
There are so, so many great songs on All Things Must Pass. The man grew so much musically in less than 10 years.
It's a lament to his friends.
George really came into his own as a songwriter at the end of their run
His early songs are great too. "I Need You", "I Want To Tell You", "If I Needed Someone", "Don't Bother Me", "Taxman"..........
George was always great from day1. Star with Don't Bother Me
If you hung with them it would be a blessing. And helpful.ifbi knew someone wanted to write music I would have them hang. With them
@@Mandrake591" don't bother me" is the shit. Wish the who would have covered it.
As in, the finally let him write some songs
Paul's bass on this is unbelievably good.
It's totally crazy how good that bassline is. It's so heavy, like a powerhouse, but so well-crafted that it offers a perfect counter point to the superb guitars played by Harrison and Clapton.
Everything about this song is unbelievably good lol
Absolutely! Paul loved making heavy melodic bass lines. It really brought a new level of 'special' to the stuff that they wrote!
John
@@waltercopus1485 That's not true. There are many pictures of him with the Fender VI
Greeeat reaction. The Beatles are going to be relevant in 500 years, and you're still alive as two of them are still alive.
The Beatles were time travelling wizards. The greatest band there ever was and ever will be - there will never be another musical group like them.
It's George, but Eric Clapton played lead guitar on it. So amazing!
Beatles music is timeless.
This might be the best time to listen to Blackbird. It's genius and was written on the fly by Paul McCartney who was inspired by the civil rights movement while touring the US.
Yup! It's my FAVORITE Beatles song! It's dedicated to black women in slavery especially...
Yes!
And it's a take off of Bach's "Bouree," which is kind of cool.
Helps to know that "bird" is british slang for woman. I came to the comments yo recommend this song.
Yes, Blackbird is a must to listen to. =D
Hey ROME , What is amazing is at that time everything was analog . No digital effects .
We call them the Psychedelic Beatles... Freaked us out too. Lol
You run down to the record store, buy the newest Beatles record take it home, run it home, put it on the phonograph, and what!!?? Couldn't understand it at all. I cried for days !
What happened to MY Beatles!?
Well, they got high...😅
The Beatles are, and always will be, timeless.
And peerless.
Like Bob Dylan
The older you grow the more you realize that
People will still be amazed by the Beatles when I’m long dead and gone.
@@ZAOUWV not really Im 13 and I know and love them, so much that I'm going to their museum in Liverpool in a couple of months. They are a timeless band that could never be forgotten.
I was 13 years old when the song came out. I had never heard anything like it. These men were just brilliant. Serious musicians great talents not about money about the art. Very different time young man This is timeless. Thank you so much for your wonderful reactions and your genuine Self take good care and have fun.
My son and I were dressed as Scooby Doo characters last Halloween and we recorded a spontaneous cover of this song. We had never played it 'together' before, but it was the only song that we both knew from memory, off the top of our heads. The audio isn't great, but I uploaded it for our family as a Halloween greeting, and aside from the sound quality, we got a groove going, just piano and guitar.
Your channel has low-key been an inspiration to me in the past year. I suffered a head injury and lost my memory 4 years ago, and I knew I loved music but didn't remember that I played piano/'did' music. Watching you discover tunes has helped me re-discover those tunes and even recover memories that I thought I'd lost forever. And this sounds dorky, but after the 100th time you said "do the work every day" I decided to try taking your advice. I'm not comfortable on camera (which probably shows--I'm sort of 'autistic' since the injury), but I 'remembered' the hell out of this song, and I realised that I'd played it for so many years before the amnesia that my son knew it as well as I did.
Music lives within the memory of our bodies... and those memories are tenacious enough to withstand brain injury. :)
Anyway, sorry I rambled, but this channel has brought me out of my shell a little bit, and I guess I thought I should say thank you.
(Even if nobody else does when they come across my videos.) :) You're a rock star!
Also, the version of this song that George Martin added strings to (on the "Love" album) is one of the most beautiful things your ears will ever behold.
It is otherworldly beautiful.
Your comment moved me. Interesting. Thanks for taking ghe time Strange’nRare.
Sounds like you are too, keep working hard on your recovery as you are now in my heart and thoughts too. I truly hope you recover loads more of your memories and I am certain I will definitely not be the only one that would wish this to you! Take care, stay safe and get better too xx
The craziest thing about the Beatles is that they did it all in 7 years. George was 26 when they recorded their last song together. Incredible range in a such a short span of time.
Goerge Harrison wrote this song he was had spent a lot of time in inda and believed in fait so he got book of the book shelf and opened it on a random page and my guitar gently weeps was the first three words on the page and he created this absolutely amazing song Eric Clapton plays the guitar solos in it what an amazing song
Yeah I am glad that you brough up Eric Clapton, Clapton is the only other guitar player out side John, Paul, or George to be on a Beatles recording.
@@MyUrbanExplorationOnline but Billy Preston does some keyboard work for them.
@@001Flange Oh yeah, mainly on the whole, "Let It Be", album.
It was just "gently weeps". No "guitar."
@@JimGeigerMusic ahh my bad thanks lol
Tomorrow Never Knows!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! thanks.
I have never been a fan of the expression "They were ahead of their time". IMO they were the originators of the time. They weren't ahead of their time. The music of today is just way behind the times.
I also love George Harrison's 1987 solo album, "Cloud Nine". It also sounds timeless and fresh even 34 years later. "I Got My Mind Set on You" was a huge radio hit at the time, but I like the title song and "Someplace Else" even better. But make no mistake: the entire album is precious!
The Beatles wrote hundreds of songs....DIG IN!!!
YOU'LL BE GLAD YOU DID!!!!
What's really missing is the end of Bungalow Bill, and Lennon saying 'ey up' just before this kicks in.
Your Mom was one, I was 13. I am so happy to see young people like you, James, that appreciates the music I grew up with. Sixties/seventies music is the best, most complex music ever recorded and I am so thankful this music was the soundtrack to my formative years.
Man, I’m jealous! There is some good genuine music today but it’s hard to find, and it’s kinda hard to sound new and exciting even for good bands and artists. I can only imagine how crazy it must have been to be alive to hear the musical explosion of that time.
I couldn't agree more. I was born in 1980 and I still think most of the greatest music came during the '60s & 70s. Videos like this prove how much staying it power it has, too.
@@futurereflections4097 It was so crazy that I am still discovering music from that time I didn't listen to. I was born in '56 so I was too young to appreciate the Beatles when they first appeared. When I was in HS I was really into the singer-songwriters (Cat Stevens, Carole King, James Taylor, Neil Diamond, Simon and Garfunkel, etc) and started to move into light rock like the Eagles. The last 20 years has been a journey to revisit what I missed: Zeppelin, Beatles, Floyd, Who, etc. The 60's and 70's produced so much timeless music that it is taking a lifetime to absorb.
This George Harrison song is a pure masterpiece, it will accompany you all your life !
You missed living in the most amazing decade ever, but are fortunate magnetic tape enabled all who wish to LISTEN, can, and for all time.
The Beatles were phenomenal. Dive deep into their music. They had so many different sounds over the years and they only got better. They were a very special and perfect gift to the world.
Even crazier when you listen to some 50s music for reference. Some 50s music was good, but 1965-1969 put music into the future in such a short span of time.
No denying the stellar playing of Slowhand on guitar . Clapton took this song to another level
Though I think the Love version, without him playing is much better than this one.
Agree 100%!!!
This song took Clapton to a new level as well. Symbiotic.
The whole White Album was just a journey. If you can please try “Dear Prudence”from the same album. Excellent reaction, as usual.
The sun is out
The sky is blue
It's beautiful
And so are you...
I bought every Beatles vinyl album when they first came out in the 60s and still have all of them in great condition. From Meet The Beatles to Abbey Road they are still astounding me. They still sound so good it is unbelievable. He is right on!
This song is a masterpiece.
Damn right...
I've taken this song for granted for many years. Your reaction gave me a fresh appreciate for it all over again. Thank you!
Amazing George Harrison song from The White Album. You are right. The Beatles music is timeless. The creative genius of The Beatles. ♥️🎼🎶🎵🇨🇦
Eric Clapton played lead guitar on the song
Not the original
@@ChrisCysterOne Yes, on the original
@@DavidGigg didn't a few outsiders play on this album. This was the beginning of the end.
@@stanzaloan3454 This Beatles always had session musicians on instruments they weren't familiar with. However, this is the only time they had someone else on guitar.
@@DavidGigg not only do you
have to be "familiar with" but
you have to be a master of
your instrument for playing
the trumpet part of "Penny Lane"
or the French horn part of
"For No One"
I was 9 in 1964, a teenager in 68. In the 70s on campus there was another generation who were like your reaction, RUclips has brought their sublime greatness to yet another generation. Thank you.
One of their most beautiful songs written by the late George Harrison and sung by him
He got up and danced to a song that was a hit before his mother was born 🤣
Let us all.
When he was talking about when his mother was born I was thinking of this song too.
😂
This song is timeless, one of my favourites from The Beatles, came out the year I was born. I have a lot of Beatles music on vinyl as my Dad collected & was a huge fan. He went to see them in 1964 in Melbourne, Australia
Yes! That is the genius of The Beatles. They ab-so-lute-ly changed music forever. I can't think of another band that can still be heard coming through other music of fifty years later.
Welcome to the ENDURING brilliance of the Beatles, Rome Life ! You're beginning to learn why they are so highly regarded.
"Well, here's another clue for you all
the walrus was Paul."
You need to react to Glass Onion.
I said the same in the comments for the Walrus reaction.
Yet more of John's trolling of fans.
Yep, and Lucy in the sky too
@@toddcaspersen8041 Ideally he'll react to Lucy in the Sky and Fool on the Hill before Glass Onion.
yup, even though John sang it....the guys had a sense of humor
"She said she said" has the most unlikely first line to a Beatles song: "She said 'I know what it's like to be dead'". Check out "She said she said" !
That line has been attributed to Peter Fonda. Great song, great album.
Absolutely one of the very best songs of all time by The Beatles.