Thank so much for your watching and commentary. Will have to be patient on the channel expansion but I am confident and with viewers like you, I’m sure it will happen. 🙏🏼
Again, great work On these sensitive and controversial topics, sane and calm discussion like this is much more powerful than loud voices. Keep up the good work 👍
Thanks Ahmed. I do agree about loud voices. One of my many observations about how some content alienates many due to their aggression. This channel is about putting out a point of view that’s calm and collected. Even while contradicting more mainstream narratives.
This was a good video. I just want to point out though that most sholars in the west (even revisionist ones) do not take seriously the claim of the Prophet PBUH as myth. There is a consensus that he did exist. Still, many online "skeptics" and Islamophobes larping as intellectuals cling to this fringe ultra-revisionist claim. So its good to have videos like this. I recommend Al Muqqaddimah's video on the topic as well.
Thank you Gonugolem. I think you are correct in your assessment on a general level. But the attempt I think is a bit more than that. In the sense the people en masse associate the prophets with myth, especially ones in antiquity, whose existence is unproven by the scientific methods available to us today. So for the ancients like Abraham, Moses and Jesus, the archaeological evidence is either unavailable or challengeable, whereas for the Prophet Muhammad PBUH it simply is not the case.
@@thekandarichronicles Yes I agree, the Prophet Muhammad PBUH cannot be put in the same category as other more ancient figures in that regard. The people en masse can certainly fall prey to misconceptions.
It’s great that we’re having a back and forth civilized discussion over Islamic core beliefs in an academic method. Usually whenever an academic study into the origins of Islam is released so many threats of beheadings are thrown around. 😂
The more defensive we get about religion, the louder we get! Silly to be honest. No better way to honour one’s religion than to do it in an intelligent, fair and civilised manner.
@@thekandarichronicles Loud emotional reactions are expected when insults are thrown at one’s belief. but to counter a scientific argument one must provide a counter argument, the way you did. Thanks for that and all the work you put into your videos. I also watched some of the lectures you referenced at the start of your video and the professors that are advancing this hypothesis usually downplay the importance of transferring informations orally from one generation to the next in our societies, as opposed to manuscripts and historic documents. Even though we invented writing in Iraq and in the Levant, most of our regional history here in Syria for example is carried on orally. The same phenomenon can be observed in Native Americans, Central Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. Scribing was a very expensive task before the printing press, so most of human history is actually carried through what they called “hearsay”.
@@AhmadLad that’s amazing Ahmed. Didn’t you you’re from Syria. Amazing place. Oral tradition is actually in most cases during the Middle Ages a more accurate representation of the facts than writing. Human memory was operating a lot a much higher and abundant level.
The thing that irritates me is that their claim is basically that there are no remnants of the prophet!? Even though the Muslims for a full millennium and a half have agreed he is the prophet and pinpoint exactly where his grave lies! A this point you might as well be skeptical of existence in itself
Assalamualaikum, MashaAllah video is well reasearched and articulate hope we'll more such videos on Islamic history. I've a question what are your thoughts on Sean Anthony's work ”Muhammad and the Empires of Faith: The Making of the Prophet of Islam”
Wa Aleykum @ChadMuslim-007. I thank you for your kind and gracious words. I am unaware of Sean Anthony's work but I am very grateful to you for bringing him to light. Will definitely check him out and the book you mention. Thanks again my friend.
Salam sir I have been taking notes from ur videoes and i admire ur work. I have a question hope u dont mind U see u said sebeos manuscript tells us about prophet, but i couldnt find any such manuscripts online nor any article on this matter. If u could kindly provide the source it would help a lot. I have a bad habbit of questining too much. Hope you would respond.
Salam Mr Blue Sky. Try this document. I hope you can access it. www.academia.edu/3187911/Sebeos_the_Jews_and_the_Rise_of_Islam And also check this book out, A Prophet Has Appeared: The Rise of Islam through Christian and Jewish Eyes, A Sourcebook Stephen J. Shoemaker
i must say u r well prepared for this challenging platform wars, hehe. once again can i approach u for a conversation? in ur own time of coarse, as i believe it will really help us both in many ways, many thanks for ur work.
Sir, messenger of God is a concept of abrahmic faiths starting with abraham/judaism. Inthis concept there is a total reliance on one individual who is treated as a demi-god.
Depends on what your definition of a Demi god is. There can be clear distinctions between the versions of those prophets you mention within each Abrahamic faith.
I subscribed to your channel earlier after watching 1/2 videos. Then came this! Bro, as long as you can't accept that Allah can't send the divine Quran to anybody and that there is nothing like a superhuman prophet, Muslims have no hope. You have to pass the historicity and move forward like Christian did. Best of luck.
Well thank you for subscribing and unsubscribing if that’s the case. Let me clarify a common misconception about Islam and that is how there is no superhuman in the prophet Muhammad. He is a common man who did not perform the miracles. He was a man of knowledge that was compounded by the Quran’s revelation to him. But that’s not what we are talking about. The video speaks of the archaeological history that proved his existence. Revisionist historians want to use their learned selves to negate real and tangible evidence to serve their purpose. Such injustice in my opinion justifies a response. That’s what the video intends to counter. Christians took their own path. Whether that right or wrong no one can really say. Regardless. Thank you for your feedback and I still hope you’d come back for some other content that might serve your interest.
Yes but even that is put into question by these revisionists. Al Muhammad alluding to the context of one that is praise worthy or venerated. So the video was about using archaeology beyond Islamic doctrine or historians.
I am of the opinion that the Prophet PBOH was a real person . and the accounts of his life and actions are accurate ( More or less as makes no difference). May I ask what difference would it make if he and his life events were a total fiction? Would you not still believe in the one true God and seek to follow his will in all your actions and with your whole Heart❤?
They wish that he is a fairytale because what the prophet peace be upon him did was miraculous and forever changing the landscape of history of the present and the future to come. Honestly, if you are fair with your research the only conclusion you’d get from his life is that he was truly sent by God all mighty to in light world that was filled with darkness and tyranny.
@@user-vu3zc7tz4l That's not what I asked. ( Would you not still believe in the one true God and seek to follow his will in all your actions and with your whole Heart?) Who is this "They". Also I note that you say the He the Prophet PBOH did miraculous things. Surely" God" did miraculous things not the prophet PBOH. The Prophet is a conduit for God's grace and power not a source .
Hello. Thank you for the correction but as per the multiple sources I have referred to, it is 61. Not 63. The Prophet's birth date was the April 20 571 and his passing came on the 8th of June, 623.
Minaj. Thank you for your comment. Sharing knowledge is what this channel is about. Sometimes even my research will let me down. It’s not about being wrong or right. It’s about learning and I respect you very much for wanting to know more.
@@abdullahidahir9394 Whosoever transgresseth, and abideth not in the doctrine of Christ, hath not God. He that abideth in the doctrine of Christ, he hath both the Father and the Son. 2 John 1:9
Vadim, I disagree with your assessment. There are many a modern authors who revise history to question the fundamentals of the prophets existence. As for his teaching, I dot understand your premise, if you say he existed and his actions and sayings were documented, how can that be difficult.
@@thekandarichronicles If you search well you can find "scientists" supporting any mad theory. Bot no serious school textbook denies the existence of Muhammad, so the problem you are fighting just does not exist. Regarding proving his teaching I mean proof that his religion is true. This is where it gets slightly more complicated 😆
Nop. Until any Muslim provides evidence of Muhammad existence without Islamic books, your prophet NEVER exited. That's my challenge to you. You are trying to give the audience the impression that the Islamic scriptures are correct, but they are not for those who have no attachments to Islam. We don't have the barrier of NEED to accept a lie as a truth. We will find the REAL Muhammad and we will exposed him.
Very triggered as to the idea that the Prophet did exist. You seem to either discount or not compute that several of the archaeological and non muslim proofs provided in the video that were indeed outside the realm of Muslim scripture. Maybe you just didn't watch till the end. So I dont see your challenge as valid.
@@thekandarichroniclesWrong again boddie, don't tell me I am wrong, probe it. Show me the archaeological findings. Don't give the BS of Hadiths(Sunnah) or the Surah, I hope you are aware of the first Surah in history, Ferdinand Wustenfeld who made the "biography" of Muhammad in 1889, that's where Guillaume got the info from to put in his book, The life of Muhmmad. YOU should not believe me, do your own research, ALL Muslims should research the veracity of your scriptures. It seams like us Christians are telling you what you suppose to know. My challenge still standing, stop the BS and prove me wrong.
Cope Your eyes cannot blind the truth Believe and your soul will be free from hell Monotheism is at that is Muhammad final messenger Like Jesus and Moses Men chosen by the almighty No son no spirit no equals One and only Allah
Very concise and well structured summary, this channel is underrated.
Thank so much for your watching and commentary. Will have to be patient on the channel expansion but I am confident and with viewers like you, I’m sure it will happen. 🙏🏼
Again, great work
On these sensitive and controversial topics, sane and calm discussion like this is much more powerful than loud voices.
Keep up the good work 👍
Thanks Ahmed. I do agree about loud voices. One of my many observations about how some content alienates many due to their aggression. This channel is about putting out a point of view that’s calm and collected. Even while contradicting more mainstream narratives.
This was a good video.
I just want to point out though that most sholars in the west (even revisionist ones) do not take seriously the claim of the Prophet PBUH as myth. There is a consensus that he did exist.
Still, many online "skeptics" and Islamophobes larping as intellectuals cling to this fringe ultra-revisionist claim. So its good to have videos like this.
I recommend Al Muqqaddimah's video on the topic as well.
Thank you Gonugolem. I think you are correct in your assessment on a general level. But the attempt I think is a bit more than that. In the sense the people en masse associate the prophets with myth, especially ones in antiquity, whose existence is unproven by the scientific methods available to us today. So for the ancients like Abraham, Moses and Jesus, the archaeological evidence is either unavailable or challengeable, whereas for the Prophet Muhammad PBUH it simply is not the case.
@@thekandarichronicles Yes I agree, the Prophet Muhammad PBUH cannot be put in the same category as other more ancient figures in that regard. The people en masse can certainly fall prey to misconceptions.
It’s great that we’re having a back and forth civilized discussion over Islamic core beliefs in an academic method. Usually whenever an academic study into the origins of Islam is released so many threats of beheadings are thrown around. 😂
The more defensive we get about religion, the louder we get! Silly to be honest. No better way to honour one’s religion than to do it in an intelligent, fair and civilised manner.
@@thekandarichronicles Loud emotional reactions are expected when insults are thrown at one’s belief. but to counter a scientific argument one must provide a counter argument, the way you did. Thanks for that and all the work you put into your videos.
I also watched some of the lectures you referenced at the start of your video and the professors that are advancing this hypothesis usually downplay the importance of transferring informations orally from one generation to the next in our societies, as opposed to manuscripts and historic documents. Even though we invented writing in Iraq and in the Levant, most of our regional history here in Syria for example is carried on orally. The same phenomenon can be observed in Native Americans, Central Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. Scribing was a very expensive task before the printing press, so most of human history is actually carried through what they called “hearsay”.
@@AhmadLad that’s amazing Ahmed. Didn’t you you’re from Syria. Amazing place.
Oral tradition is actually in most cases during the Middle Ages a more accurate representation of the facts than writing. Human memory was operating a lot a much higher and abundant level.
The thing that irritates me is that their claim is basically that there are no remnants of the prophet!? Even though the Muslims for a full millennium and a half have agreed he is the prophet and pinpoint exactly where his grave lies! A this point you might as well be skeptical of existence in itself
Assalamualaikum, MashaAllah video is well reasearched and articulate hope we'll more such videos on Islamic history. I've a question what are your thoughts on Sean Anthony's work ”Muhammad and the Empires of Faith: The Making of the Prophet of Islam”
Wa Aleykum @ChadMuslim-007. I thank you for your kind and gracious words. I am unaware of Sean Anthony's work but I am very grateful to you for bringing him to light. Will definitely check him out and the book you mention. Thanks again my friend.
Copts, Syriacs & Maronites will be very unhappy with this video 😅
Not the main intention of the video. But thanks for watching and sharing your thought!
Beautiful put! ﷺ
Thank you so much ABYR.
Love the presentation style. Quite unique Masha Allah:)
Thank you so much for your wonderful words of support.
Quality content for knowledge 🔥
Thank you so much. Really glad that you find it informative. Keep on watching! 🙏🏼
A great presentation. Love it
Salam sir
I have been taking notes from ur videoes and i admire ur work.
I have a question hope u dont mind
U see u said sebeos manuscript tells us about prophet, but i couldnt find any such manuscripts online nor any article on this matter. If u could kindly provide the source it would help a lot. I have a bad habbit of questining too much.
Hope you would respond.
Salam Mr Blue Sky.
Try this document. I hope you can access it. www.academia.edu/3187911/Sebeos_the_Jews_and_the_Rise_of_Islam
And also check this book out, A Prophet Has Appeared: The Rise of Islam through Christian and Jewish Eyes, A Sourcebook
Stephen J. Shoemaker
@@thekandarichronicles thanks for ur time. Sorry if u had to endure any hard time for my request
Never. Will always share what I can.
i must say u r well prepared for this challenging platform wars, hehe. once again can i approach u for a conversation? in ur own time of coarse, as i believe it will really help us both in many ways, many thanks for ur work.
Hi again US001. Thanks so much for the offer to improve both our abilities. Let me have a think and figure out how and when we can set up something.
Asslamalikum.wonderful work brother. May Allah reward you
Thank you so much Amin. To us all inshallah.
Sir, messenger of God is a concept of abrahmic faiths starting with abraham/judaism. Inthis concept there is a total reliance on one individual who is treated as a
demi-god.
Depends on what your definition of a Demi god is. There can be clear distinctions between the versions of those prophets you mention within each Abrahamic faith.
Great job 😊🎉
❤ thank you so much T!
I subscribed to your channel earlier after watching 1/2 videos. Then came this! Bro, as long as you can't accept that Allah can't send the divine Quran to anybody and that there is nothing like a superhuman prophet, Muslims have no hope. You have to pass the historicity and move forward like Christian did. Best of luck.
Well thank you for subscribing and unsubscribing if that’s the case. Let me clarify a common misconception about Islam and that is how there is no superhuman in the prophet Muhammad. He is a common man who did not perform the miracles. He was a man of knowledge that was compounded by the Quran’s revelation to him. But that’s not what we are talking about. The video speaks of the archaeological history that proved his existence. Revisionist historians want to use their learned selves to negate real and tangible evidence to serve their purpose. Such injustice in my opinion justifies a response. That’s what the video intends to counter.
Christians took their own path. Whether that right or wrong no one can really say.
Regardless. Thank you for your feedback and I still hope you’d come back for some other content that might serve your interest.
The Prophet's name is literally mentioned in the Quran, there is a whole surah called Muhammad!
Yes but even that is put into question by these revisionists. Al Muhammad alluding to the context of one that is praise worthy or venerated. So the video was about using archaeology beyond Islamic doctrine or historians.
I am of the opinion that the Prophet PBOH was a real person . and the accounts of his life and actions are accurate ( More or less as makes no difference). May I ask what difference would it make if he and his life events were a total fiction? Would you not still believe in the one true God and seek to follow his will in all your actions and with your whole Heart❤?
They wish that he is a fairytale because what the prophet peace be upon him did was miraculous and forever changing the landscape of history of the present and the future to come. Honestly, if you are fair with your research the only conclusion you’d get from his life is that he was truly sent by God all mighty to in light world that was filled with darkness and tyranny.
@@user-vu3zc7tz4l That's not what I asked. ( Would you not still believe in the one true God and seek to follow his will in all your actions and with your whole Heart?) Who is this "They". Also I note that you say the He the Prophet PBOH did miraculous things. Surely" God" did miraculous things not the prophet PBOH. The Prophet is a conduit for God's grace and power not a source .
Are you Muslim ?not once you mentioned prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and praise his name. If you’re Muslim you should know better brother.
Captain Kandari❤
Thank you Soban. Looking forward to a higher rank inshallah.
CORRECTION 2:53
He lived for 63* years.
Hello. Thank you for the correction but as per the multiple sources I have referred to, it is 61. Not 63. The Prophet's birth date was the April 20 571 and his passing came on the 8th of June, 623.
I should have cross checked it more
Minaj. Thank you for your comment. Sharing knowledge is what this channel is about. Sometimes even my research will let me down. It’s not about being wrong or right. It’s about learning and I respect you very much for wanting to know more.
May Allah bless you and your family, what you are doing is jihad on another level, thank you for your deeds sir
Bravo 👏🏽👏👏🏽👏
Thank you so much Meshaal for all your wonderful support.
11:24 No peace upon him.
Thank you for watching the Kandari Chronicles video.
Thank you for watching the Kandari Chronicles video.
The Muhammad of the traditionalist narrative never existed. But there is no doubt Muhammad did exist.
Well that is the whole notion of the video. To counter those "Experts" who dismiss the fundamental element of existence.
10:43 And he was a false prophet. Muhammad existed the same way that Joseph Smith existed.
Thank you for watching the Kandari Chronicles video.
10:39 2 Billion people are Baal worshippers.
Thank you for watching the Kandari Chronicles video.
You are ridiculous, Baal had been forgotten for centuries at that time, get a grip
@@abdullahidahir9394The false god of Islam is Baal. I love a day when Allah/Baal is forgotten. How long Oh Lord?
@@Nasraniksatria Dude, what proof do you even have, and I mean Credible, academic proof for this ridiculous claim, get a grip.
@@abdullahidahir9394 Whosoever transgresseth, and abideth not in the doctrine of Christ, hath not God. He that abideth in the doctrine of Christ, he hath both the Father and the Son.
2 John 1:9
This video is pure manipulation. No one seriously doubts Muhammad existed. Proving his teaching is, however, somewhat more difficult 😁
Vadim, I disagree with your assessment. There are many a modern authors who revise history to question the fundamentals of the prophets existence.
As for his teaching, I dot understand your premise, if you say he existed and his actions and sayings were documented, how can that be difficult.
@@thekandarichronicles If you search well you can find "scientists" supporting any mad theory. Bot no serious school textbook denies the existence of Muhammad, so the problem you are fighting just does not exist. Regarding proving his teaching I mean proof that his religion is true. This is where it gets slightly more complicated 😆
Galatians 1:8 proves that Muhammad was a false prophet.
Thank you for watching the Kandari Chronicles video.
10:45 He was a messenger of Satan.
Thank you for watching the Kandari Chronicles video.
Nop.
Until any Muslim provides evidence of Muhammad existence without Islamic books, your prophet NEVER exited.
That's my challenge to you. You are trying to give the audience the impression that the Islamic scriptures are correct, but they are not for those who have no attachments to Islam.
We don't have the barrier of NEED to accept a lie as a truth.
We will find the REAL Muhammad and we will exposed him.
Very triggered as to the idea that the Prophet did exist. You seem to either discount or not compute that several of the archaeological and non muslim proofs provided in the video that were indeed outside the realm of Muslim scripture. Maybe you just didn't watch till the end. So I dont see your challenge as valid.
@@thekandarichroniclesWrong again boddie, don't tell me I am wrong, probe it.
Show me the archaeological findings. Don't give the BS of Hadiths(Sunnah) or the Surah, I hope you are aware of the first Surah in history, Ferdinand Wustenfeld who made the "biography" of Muhammad in 1889, that's where Guillaume got the info from to put in his book, The life of Muhmmad.
YOU should not believe me, do your own research, ALL Muslims should research the veracity of your scriptures.
It seams like us Christians are telling you what you suppose to know.
My challenge still standing, stop the BS and prove me wrong.
Cope
Your eyes cannot blind the truth
Believe and your soul will be free from hell
Monotheism is at that is
Muhammad final messenger
Like Jesus and Moses
Men chosen by the almighty
No son no spirit no equals
One and only Allah
Damn bro, there's no need to be triggered like that, he's not mentioning your mom😂
@@thekandarichronicles Talks is cheap, show them.