Age of Ayesha (rta) at the time of her marriage with Prophet Muhammad (sws) by Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 июн 2018
- Javed Ahmad Ghamid answering the questions of audience in Macquarie Theatre, Macquarie University, Sydney Australia on 04th October 2015. (With English subtitle)
Official Websites: www.al-mawrid.org and www.javedahmadghamidi.com
Official email: info@al-mawrid.org
#Quran
#Hadith
#Prophet
Prophet’s Wife
Marriage
Ayesha (rta)
Marriage of Ayesha (rta)
Age of Ayesha (rta)
Sydney Australia
Macquarie University
Macquarie Theatre
Ghamidi
Al-Mawrid
عائشہ (رضی الله عنها) كی عمر
غامدی
المورد
سوال جواب
I am a revert from Hinduism and this was a topic still troubling me till I came across this lecture.Thank you
Brother the speaking person is known as ghamdi in Pakistan. He spreads wrong information. In Muslim belief on the day of judgment there will be 72 different groups of Muslims and each of them will claim we are true Muslim, question how will one determine what us true Islam, any statement that is narrated from Quran or any statement that is driven from true hadis. How you will determine that hadees is true. There are only 4 authentic books of hadis in Islam each book has multiple sets. Speaking person gave no referance of quranic verse and no hadees from 4 authentic books of hadees. Infact he gave referance of his own book and another book whose name I never heard. He spreads wrong Islam.
@@zohaibfarooq8482 bhai ye jo qissa bayan kia ha ye sbse phly jo likhi gai hui hadees usma bayan ha ....
Sahih farmaya aap nay!
JazakaAllah 💕💕💕
Quran Verse (65:4) - English Translation
Mohsin Khan: "And those of your women as have passed the age of monthly courses, for them the 'Iddah (prescribed period), if you have doubts (about their periods), is three months, and for those WHO HAVE NO COURSES AS YET [(i.e. THEY ARE STILL IMMATURE) their 'Iddah (prescribed period) is three months ....."
Commentary on Qur'an Chapter 65:4
Sayyid Abul Ala Maududi, Tafhim al-Qur'an:
"Here, one should bear in mind the fact that according to the explanations given in the Quran the question of the waiting period arises in respect of the women with whom marriage may have been consummated, for there is no waiting-period in case divorce is pronounced before the consummation of marriage. (Al-Ahzab: 49). THEREFORE, MAKING MENTION of THE WAITING-PERIOD FOR THE GIRLS WHO HAVE NOT YET MENSTRUATED, CLEARLY PROVES THAT IT IS NOT ONLY PERMISSIBLE TO GIVE AWAY THE GIRL IN MARRIAGE AT THIS AGE BUT IT IS ALSO PERMISSIBLE FOR THE HUSBAND TO CONSUMMATE MARRIAGE WITH HER. Now, obviously no Muslim has the right to forbid a thing which the Quran has held as permissible."
Qur'an 65:4 Tafsir IBN-ABBAS
"The `Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her `Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate, which is based upon the Ayah in (Surat) Al-Baqarah. [see 2:228] THE SAME FOR THE YOUNG, WHO HAVE NOT REACHED THE YEARS OF MENSTRUATION. Their `Iddah is three months like those in menopause."
So consummation of Hadrat Aishah RA's marriage before attaining puberty at age 9 would be well within what is Divinely Approved and Permitted in the Holy Qur'an.
The Holy Qur'an MashaAllah seems to allow consummation of marriage with sexually immature, under-age girls.❤❤❤ JazakaAllah!
Allah SWT knows best.
@@Ravan.....889 bro i m watching ghamdi so called scholar from my child hood. he is not a true muslim neither true scholar. He spreads wrong information of islam. No other muslim scholar gives referance of ghamdi in his speaches. I give you two youtube videos link in respect to this matter which will reveal you true reason of marriage of bibi Ayesha and Hazrat Muhammad may peace be upon him.
@@zohaibfarooq8482 brother please say me how you know whether bukhari ,Muslim are only the true hadees books ? Did it is mentioned anywhere in Quran? Did prophet saw said that? After me the books which will come bukhari is true? How do you know they are Islam books? When Allah said ? I am not denying this books entirely but I don't give them the position of Quran. Which means...everything of only Quran is correct any other book may have something correct and something wrong..these books bukhari Muslim are man made and aur also called authentic by man only.
I am crying now...... Mere ko pta tha Allah succh bta denge. Mai bhi pta nahi kya kya sochne lga tha rasool ke bare me. Itne maulanaon ko sunaa bt dil ko yakeen nahi ho raha tha. Ya Allah shukra hai tera jo mai is video tk pauccha. Mera yakeen hai hadith me kucch aise bate hai jo succh nahi hai bs romans and Persian ne jhoot likha hai. After all Allah quran ki hifazat ka wada kiye hai quran me ki kyamat tk ek word nahi bdlega bs. Allah ne hadith ke bare me kucch nahi kaha... Ya Allah hm musalmano ki hifazat farma. Mere moula. Hm bs tujhi se ummed rakhte hai Allah aur kisi se nahi hamari lazz rkhna mere rb. 🥺
Moulana andhi taqleed karte h . Ghamdi sahab ka answer bohat logical h
Thanks to professor ghamidi sb who
Present among us and enlighten our minds from time to time...prayers for his
Good health and long life
Nupur Sharma- the Prophet Row | With Robert Spencer
ruclips.net/video/tfyy9ds9VuA/видео.html
May HE guide us all... And save us from who dont follow sunnah of prophet Alaihisalam....
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
you don't know how small you sounds here @@gurdeepk
First time I hv received excellent answer in my whole life
@Roshan Ara
ruclips.net/video/kcsYM7kjFjo/видео.html
@@whb0313 JazaqAllah brother
@@pandagamingff. jazakallah likhna sahi hai.
Logically, no one can compete this man in way of Islamic discussion. . .
The Islamic legend *Ghamidi*
ruclips.net/video/d-4ATpHHmwY/видео.html
Ask gamdi sahab what was the age of Hazrat Aisha A.S when Muhammad PBUH left this duniya??? If he answers you 18 then it proves gamdi sahab completely wrong.
@storm raider gamdi sahab dosent believe in ahadees. Ask Gamdi sahab what was the age of Hazrat Aisha when Muhammad PBUH passed away.
ruclips.net/video/lOhyhxOKI4E/видео.html
Bewkuf bana raha hai ye lol.. sahih hadith mai chalo number galat likha ho 16 ki jagah 6 ..but ye bhi likha hai ki vo dolls se khelti thi us time..
Great 👍 🇮🇳. As a Hindu I respect my fellow Muslims brothers beliefs. Love and respect to all.
Sahih Bukhari 5134
Mutual respect is the key to a harmonious world.
Thank you sir
Same here sir ☺️
@@moinmalik1320 exactly 💯
When we hear Hazrat Israar Ahmed Rahimahullah & Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Rahmatullahi Alaihi, we just astonished by their reasoning ability!
Just mesmerized!
Wonderful!
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
@@gurdeepk Narrated by a forgetful person so not Sahih.
@@gurdeepksahih grading is done based on chain of narration. Not based on the content of the Hadith
Jzak Allah ...
😭😭😭😭😭...
سچ بات یہ ہے کہ ہم امتی بھی اپنے آقا صل اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کو بہت تکلیف دیتے ہیں۔۔۔۔
😭😭😭😭😭
I’m so grateful to Ghamdi Sahib for this explanation. I heard dozens of others, and none could satisfy me. Alhamdulillah, that we have scholars like him. Thank you so much once again.
Mohammed aur ayesha Madam kuch bhi krey teraa kya?
Alhamdullillah.
@Sherazi Syed Aisha r.a was 19 when she got married to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
ONLY HYPOCRISY.
@Sherazi Syed, GHMDI TELLING LIE. PROPAGANDA ONLY.
@@__-si9ux FALSE ONLY. AAYSHA WAS 6YEAR OLD.
सर,आज कल चल रही इस पूरी बहस का तार्किक विश्लेषण और ऐतिहासिक सन्दर्भ सुना और समझा। मेरा सादर अभिवादन स्वीकार करें।दरअसल आम आदमी के पास सही शिक्षा के अभाव में ऐतिहासिक सन्दर्भों को जाननेसमझने का स्रोत है और ना ही अवसर ।इसलिए अधकचरे ज्ञान के आघार पर शोर मचाने तथाकथित विद्वान जो परोस देते हैं उसे आम जनता सच मान लेती है । इस अज्ञान को बाकायदा बनाये रखा जाता है ताकि मनभेद की ज़मीन पर राजनीति की फसल काटी जा सके।सर आपके खोजपरक लेखों को जनता में बांटा जाना चाहिए ताकि जागरूकता बढ़ सके।ज्ञानवर्धन के लिए आभार
Nice comment 👍
Love it. Ghamidi saheb rules.
बेहद महत्वपूर्ण टिप्पड़ी
Thank God 😭 I knew Prophet Muhammad, who literally cried every night for us could never marry a 9 year old...
Allah bless this man ❤
ruclips.net/video/WjHB7DZke_c/видео.html
SALAM
What a joke he dont consider the SAHIH AHADEES with proper chain. But constructing a complete narrative based on historic record. How controversial. And about you, how could you believe that PROPHET marrying 6 years old UMMUL MOMINEEN to fulfill His PBUH will and not commandment of ALLAH. Should reconsider your faith. How weak it is
ऐसा कहा जाता है कि जब हज़रत आयशा की उम्र 6 साल थी तब आपका निकाह हुआ और 9 साल मे रुख़सती हुई |
*इस गुमराह करने वाली इत्तेला (सूचना) ने मुस्लिम और गैर मुस्लिम भाइयों मे बहुत ही गलत तास्सुर दिया कि* *इस्लाम में बच्चों की शादी की इजाज़त है।* ये क़ाबिले गौर है कि इसके मुस्तनद (प्रमाणिक) होने की दलील नहीं है इसको साबित करने के लिए, रावियों, हालात और उस वक्त की कैफियत का तारीखी हक़ाएक़ (ऐतिहासिक तथ्यों) के साथ बाहमी ताल्लुक़ को देखा जाना चाहिए। इस सिलसिले में हिशाम की एक हदीस है जिसमें हज़रत आयशा रज़ि. की उम्र 9 साल होने का इशारा मिलता है|
r43
कई *मुस्तनद ( प्रमाणिक) हदीसें भी ज़ाहिर करती हैं कि हिशाम की रवायत नबी करीम (स.अ.व.) की जिंदगी की कई तारीख हक़ाएक़ (ऐतिहासिक तथ्य), के गैरमुताबिक़ हैं।* उमर अहमद उस्मानी, हकीम नियाज़ अहमद और हबीबुर्रहमान कांधोलवी जैसे उलमा के हवाले के साथ, इस हक़ीक़त के हक़ में *कुछ दलीलें पेश करना चाहूंगा, कि* *हज़रत आयशा रज़ि की उम्र कम से कम 18 साल थी जब आपका निकाह हुआ और आपकी उम्र कम से कम 21 साल थीं* जब आपकी रुखसती नबी करीम (स.अ.व.) के साथ रहने के लिए हुईं।
उमर अहमद उस्मानी के मुताबिक़, *सूरे अल-निसा* में ये कहा गया है कि _"यतीमों (अनाथों) के वली उनका माल उन्हें वापस करने से पहले उनकी लगातार आज़ामाइश करते रहें, जब तक कि वो शादी की उम्र तक पहुँच जायें"_ (4:6)। इससे उलेमा हज़रात ने ये नतीजा निकाला है कि *क़ुरआन ने शादी की एक कम से कम उम्र तय की है जो कम से कम सने बलोगत है।* चूंकि *लड़की की मंजूरी (कबूलियत) एक कानूनी/इस्लामी आवश्यकता है* इसलिए वो नाबालिग नहीं हो सकती है।
हिशाम बिन उरवह इस हदीस के खास रावी हैं। उनकी जिंदगी दो दौरों में तकसीम की गयी है: 131 A.H. में मदनी मुद्दत समाप्त हुई, और *इराकी अवधि शुरू हुई, उस समय हिशाम की उम्र 71 साल थी। हाफ़िज़ ज़हबी ने बाद के समय में हिशाम की याददाश्त खराब हो जाने के बारे में बात की है* । मदीना, में उनके तालिबे इल्मों इमाम मालिक और इमाम अबू हनीफह ने इस हदीस का ज़िक्र नहीं किया है । इमाम मालिक और मदीने के लोगों ने उन्हें उनकी *इराकी हदीसों के लिए तंक़ीद (आलोचना) भी की है।*
इस हदीस के सभी रावी इराकी हैं, जिन्होंने हिशाम से उसे सुना था। इराकी जो कि अभी तक खुलफाए राशिदीन और हज़रत आयशा से बुग्ज और अदावत रखते हैं | *अल्लामा कांधोलवी का कहना है कि हज़रत आयशा रज़ि. की उम्र के बारे में कहा गया शब्द 'तिस्सह अशरह' कहा गया है जिसका अर्थ 19 है, जब हिशाम ने सिर्फ तिस्सह सुना (या याद किया) जिसका मतलब 9 होता है।* मौलाना उस्मानी रह. का खयाल है कि इस तब्दीली को जान बूझ कर और बदनियती से बाद में बनाया गया था।
इतिहासकार इब्ने इसहाक़ ने 'सीरते रसूलल्लाह' (स.अ.व.) *इस्लाम के
पहले साल में इस्लाम स्वीकार करने वालों की एक फेहरिस्त (सूची) दी है* जिसमें हज़रत आयशा रज़ि. का नाम हज़रत अबु बक्र रज़ि. की छोटी बेटी आयशा रज़ि." के तौर पर दिया गया है। *अगर हम हिशाम के हिसाब को कुबूल करते हैं, तो उस वक्त तक वो पैदा भी नहीं हुई थीं।*
नबी सल्लल्लाहू अलैहि वसल्लम की पहली बीवी, हज़रत ख़दीजा की वफात के कुछ दिनों बाद, *हज़रत खौवलह रजि. ने नबी सल्लल्लाहू अलैहि वसल्लम को बकरुन से दोबारा शादी करने का सुझाव दिया,* जिसकी मुराद हज़रत आयशा रज़ि. से था (मसनद अहमद)। अरबी में बकरुन का अर्थ गैर शादीशुदा लड़की, जिसने सने बलोगत को पार कर लिया हो और शादी की उम्र हो गई हो । एक छह साल की लड़की के लिए ये शब्द इस्तेमाल नहीं किया जा सकता है ।
कुछ अहले इल्म हज़रात का खयाल है कि हज़रत आयशा रज़ि. की शादी जल्दी हो गई थी क्योंकि अरब में लड़कियाँ जल्दी बालिग़ हो जाती हैं। लेकिन ये उस वक्त अरबों का आम रिवाज नहीं था । ये अल्लामा कांधोलवी के मुताबिक़, *इस्लाम से पहले या उसके बाद इस तरह का कोई मामला दर्ज नहीं है और न ही उसे नबी करीम (स.अ.व.) की सुन्नत के रूप में बढ़ावा दिया गया। नबी सल्लल्लाहू अलैहि वसल्लम ने अपनी बेटियों की शादी हज़रत फ़ातिमा रज़ि की 21 और हज़रत रुक़य्या रज़ि. की 23 साल* की उम्र में शादी कर दी थी। इसके अलावा, हज़रत अबु बकर सिद्दीक रज़ियल्लाहु अन्हु, हज़रत आयशा रज़ि. के वालिद ने 26 साल की उम्र में अपनी सबसे बड़ी बेटी हजरते अस्मा रज़ि. की शादी कर दी थी ।
*इस बात पर सबकी इत्तेफाक़ राये है कि हज़रत आयशा रजि. अपनी बड़ी बहन अस्मह रज़ि. से 10 साल छोटी थीं, जिनकी हिजरत के वक्त उम्र लगभग 28 साल थी ।
ruclips.net/video/d-4ATpHHmwY/видео.html
You are easy to fall into some Taqyiaa.
Narrated Hisham's father: Khadija died three years before the Prophet departed to Medina. He stayed there for two years or so and then he married 'Aisha when she was a girl of six years of age, and he consumed that marriage when she was nine years old.
Sahih Bukhari 5:58:236
Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death).
Sahih Bukhari 7:62:64
Narrated 'Aisha: I used to play with the dolls in the presence of the Prophet, and my girl friends also used to play with me. When Allah's Apostle used to enter (my dwelling place) they used to hide themselves, but the Prophet would call them to join and play with me. (The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for 'Aisha at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty.) (Fateh-al-Bari page 143, Vol.13)
Sahih Bukhari 8:73:151
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported: Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) married me when I was six years old, and I was admitted to his house when I was nine years old.'
Sahih Muslim 8:3310
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) married her when she was seven years old, and he was taken to his house as a bride when she was nine, and her dolls were with her; and when he (the Holy Prophet) died she was eighteen years old.
Sahih Muslim 8:3311
Aisha said, "The Apostle of Allah married me when I was seven years old." (The narrator Sulaiman said: "Or six years."). "He had intercourse with me when I was 9 years old.
Sunan Abu Dawud 2116 (Ahmad Hasan Ref
The comments on Our beloved Prophet have resulted in more research, more curiosity, more knowledge, and more respect for him. Even people who were unaware are now appreciating our Religion ant Our Prophet. How something negative has a positive aspect
Fool yourself.
Accept my challenge. Read the newspaper of any country anywhere anyday. See what people of this peaceful religion did yesterday.
Answer this one .....What are , using ONLY islamic sources, in all their brutality and sadism, YOUR 5 TOP FAVOURITE MURDERS of opur " honourable prophet" ??? ONLY 5 he we do nott have the all day. And NOT MY SOURCES, Islamic ones.
@@arunanand2809 yesterday.😚 RSS... sbko ikhta target nai krtay.
@@mianzarrar3796 RSS waale 9 saal ki bachi se sex nahi karte
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Ghamidi- a great blessing of Allah but his nation has not given him his due. Very unfortunate.
Great Fitna
Jazak Allahkhair for adding English subtitles. May Allah (swt) bless Javed Ghamidi, ameen.
Where did you find English subtitle in this video? I'm unable to see
@@arshm2657 If you hover your mouse on the video and see the play button, etc, see next to the settings it is the CC subtitles button & click on that.
@@hafsa26 😍😍
It's all because RUclips has been updated
*The Courageous Robert Spencer Burst Myths and Tells Truth About Moderate...*
ruclips.net/video/iOHdChrzSH0/видео.html
Can Islam with its Arabic culture assimilate into a Democratic and Westernised Civilisation?
respect to this man.. 🙏he made things very clear
Good point Sir. Kindly also keep in mind that if a person was going against the powerful people of the society by challenging the beliefs of everyone, can that person be expected to do anything that makes him controversial? It would be like surrendering his message not just compromising it. Don't you think? What I am saying is that Prophet Muhammad S.A.W. had a much bigger objective in front of him and that was to spread the message he claimed was from Allah. Any mixing of his own desires or any social faux pas would have made the job of his powerful enemies to defeat his message very easy. No leader would give such a juicy opportunity to his opponents. It is a part of my Muslim belief that he was not prone to sinning and was above making mistakes because he was chosen by Allah to carry Allah's message to humanity. Thank you for your attention.
THIS MAN IS A LIAR...there is no reason to doubt the age given by Aisha, most people remember the significant events in their lives very well. Besides there numerous hadiths which show Aisha was playing with dolls at the time of her marriage, and people in Muhammads household were treating Aisha as a very young girl.
Ji
@WL-FACTS 6 AT MARRIAGE AND 9 AT CONSUMATION. direct proof is the authentic hadiths attributed to Aisha; but more supportive evidence comes from the fact that Aisha was at that time playing with dolls and children's games with her child firends, and Muhammads household treat her as a child.
@WL-FACTS YOU ARE A LIAR. here is the hadith which mentions Aisha's age at the time of marraige:
Narrated `Aisha:
that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old.
Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith 5134.
This proves Muhammad was a Pedophile. Obviously, rest of your post is irrelevant.
According to authentic hadith she sounds more mature then 40 years she mostly praise prophet s.a.w and his charecter she really was a greatest women in human history she compile most of hadith i love my Mother Aisha a.s She really was the greatest
i believe she was 40 plus while time of marrige
Alhamdulillah for islam
don't look at haters
mockers of islam has no sense and brain they will parish soon
Islam is truth Alahmdulilah and it will prevail forever
I am proud Muslim as new revert
Javed Ghamdi Saheb is among very few Islamic scholars who talk logically and sensibly.
Yes But Zakir Naik Said Ayesha Was 6 Years Old 🙋🙋🙋
@@stevenrogers2007 Zakir Naik is not an authority. Then, 'who is the authority?' The matters for which the historical or some kind of documents are not foolproof, logical analyses are needed. Ghamdi's analysis is surely logical.
Javed sir best scholar in bare saghir.may allah give him long healthy life.love you
so much sir from india.
Brother
ruclips.net/video/d-4ATpHHmwY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
I had researched about this and I found that many of the hadiths are either fake or added later on to malign the personality of Prophet Mohammed (pbuh)
As a revert muslim I found there could be never be a big disbalance in the charector of Prophet.
Spread this video like wildfire.
Thanks bro
As we look into our parents or our grand parents, the trend of getting into marriage was in far earlier age with comparison to our getting into marriage.
At that time, the question of marriage arouse keeping in mind the puberty rather then this times demands of financial resilience or education.
Ans as the question of puberty used to be the main concern in most of the cases at that time and the puberty used to occur differently in different regions according to their circumstances (Demographics & eating habits)
Finally, you can also not justify to those IGNORANTS regarding P.B.U.H who then was an old man marrying 19 years old girl who question Him marrying 9 years old girl. You should look at the Purpose of P.B.U.H marrying 9 year old girl
Right bro.
@@usmanghanimunawar3021 this is what happens when u try tu learn morality from Madarsa🙂 9 sal ki bachi se nikah me ghalt Kya he? mental maturity n also biological maturity! who the hell told u k puberty shuru hoty hi females delivery k qabil hojati hn? han ham isse pedophilia nhi keh skty lekin ye 100% hebephilia he! n it is objectively wrong! so u can't subject it to cultural norms! therefore the argument from what people's practiced in past is utterly absurd! khawla bint Hakeem aakhir q 15 sal ki bachi k lye 6 sal ki maa ko suggest Karyn gi? halake Abu bakr Siddiqui ki Bari beti asma bhi tu mujod thi🤷🏻♂️ it's a common sense k agr aik beti prepubescent he aur aik adult tu rishta adult ka paish Kya jayga! n remember k khawla bint Hakeem ne ye nhi kaha tha k ap abhi nikah krlyn aur rukhsati puberty k bad krlye ga... wo ussi waqt k lye rishta paish kr rahi thi, so now u have to accept it too k nabi a.s ne aik prepubescent bachi ka rishta qabol Kya tha.... n in last she was already engaged with jubair ibn Mutaim aur wo engagement tootgai thi aur engagement Tootne ki wajah Qabol-e-Islam thi! n if this is the case thn it's necessarily follows k engagement Qabol-e-Islam se pehle Hui thi, Abu bakr Siddiqui Islam qabol krne waly pehle male thy n if all these premises are true thn they follow each other to the conclusion k Ayesha r.a 610 se pehle exist Karti thi! in my opinion ye last chronological argument unbreakable he! bcz it doesn't rely on any single chain narration
I agree with you Naveen. The way the world is moving in this age of communication, it is time for Muslims to think seriously and speak up about what is acceptable on a logical basis.
It is said that "i dont spread rumours i just initiate them". Thank Allah that such scholars (Ghamdi sb) are there who could explain things with accurate detail analyses
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
Very right
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
@@gurdeepk Their was no birthday record at that time
میں نے پورے زندگی میں کسی عالم اور مفکر سے ایسا معقول اور دلائل کے سات جواب نہیں سنا تھا، اللہ تعالٰی غامدی صاحب کو لمبی عمر دیں، امین
Hapsi tha
حضرت عائشہ کی عمر بوقت رخصتی 19 تھی اس حوالے سے غامدی صاحب کے دلیل کی دو بنیاد ہیں ہیں:
1: آپ کو ایسی شریک زندگی زندگی مل جائے جو بچوں کی تربیت اور کاروبار زندگی میں آپ کی معاون ہو.
اس کا جواب یہ ہے کہ یہ ضرورت حضرت سوداؓ کی شادی سے پوری ہوگئی تھی.
2: غامدی صاحب کے دلیل کی دوسری بنیاد اس خیالی مفروضے پر ہے کہ حضرت عائشہ کی عمر رخصتی کے وقت "تسعۃ عشر" انییس ہے، غلطی سے احدیث کی کتابوں میں محدثین سے "عشرہ" کا لفظ چھوٹ گیا ہے.
غامدی صاحب کو یہ معلوم ہونا چاہئے کہ یہ حدیث بخاری اور مسلم دونوں کتابوں میں مذکور ہے، نیز اس کے علاوہ متعدد محدثین نے اس حدیث کو ذکر کیا ہے، ایسا ممکن ہے کہ ایک محدث سے غلطی ہوجائے لیکن ایسا ہر گز نہیں ہوسکتا ہے کہ تمام محدثین بعینہ ایک ہی غلطی کریں.
دوسری وجہ یہ ہے کہ یہ حدیث کا معاملہ ہے جہاں ادنی سی بد احتیاطی پر جہنم کی وعید ہے، اس وجہ سے یہ ممکن ہی نہیں ہے کہ تمام محدثین ہو بہو ایک ہی بد احتیاطی کے مرتکب ہوں کیوں کہ روایت اور درایت دونوں حوالے سے محدثین کا احتیاط فن حدیث میں بہت مشہور امر ہے.
تیسری وجہ اور سب سے اہم وجہ یہ ہے کہ امام بخاری نے اس حدیث کو بخاری میں ذکر کیا ہے اور امام بخاری سے ایسی چوک متصور ہی نہیں ہے کیوں کہ احتیاط کے حوالے سے امام بخاری کا مقام سب سے اونچا ہے.
چوتھی اور آخری وجہ یہ ہے کہ غامدی صاحب نے اپنے اس دعوی کی تائید میں کہ احادیث کی کتابوں میں "عشرہ" کا لفظ سہوا رہ گیا ہے اس کی تائید میں کوئی دوسری روایت پیش نہیں کیا ہے، اس وجہ سے فن حدیث کے اصول کے مطابق جب تک کوئی دوسری مضبوط روایت موجود نہ ہو پہلی حدیث کو نہیں چھوڑا جا سکتا ہے.
واللہ اعلم
حمید الساعدی، فاضل دار العلوم دیوبند
Kabi dr israr suno, aqal thikaanay aayegi
@@rafiq3311Unko b sunte han bro
Ameen
Masya Allah. Quoting from Imam Malik, we can take or reject from anyone naration, except Rasulullah shallallahu alaihi wasallam, because he is ma'sum. Not to belittle the contribution or the level of pious ness of Imam Bukhari, but we should give rooms of err to anyone except Rasulullah. Allahu musta'an.
Excellent explanation!
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
@@gurdeepk krishna ka kya jinse radha ko rakhel bana kar rakha aur puri jindgi uska shoshan kiya aur baad mai uska man bhar gaya to radha ko chod diya uske bare mein bol
@@gurdeepk Falsely attributed Hadith
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Remember that Imam Bukhari, may God have mercy on him, is not unique in describing this, and no one has claimed that he is innocent. Ghamdi Sahib is related to the hadith deniers. Therefore, they have resorted to history to reject the hadith. This is their compulsion. Since the event of your marriage was equally related to religion, morals, and society, the scholars of hadith, jurisprudence, and Companions of the Prophet have all taken the event of your marriage and all have stated that Hazrat Ayesha's age at the time The marriage was for six or seven years and at the time of leave it was 9 years. Therefore, in Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Abu Dawud and Al-Nasa'i, other books of hadiths have unanimously adopted the same position.
JAZAAKALLAAH Khair to
Ghamidi saahab for such a best explanation in the light of ILM & AQL.
JazakAllah...
You're like blessing
Aisha’s exact birthday is unknown, but she was born *before* 610 CE when Islam was revealed.
Aisha is recorded as accepting Islam shortly after it was revealed. She could not have done so as an infant or toddler. The youngest she could have accepted Islam would be 7 y/o, but that’s a guess.
She was married in 622 CE 12 years after she accepted Islam. (7 + 12 =19 years).
Further, Aisha fought in the Battles of Badr and Uhud (624/5 respectively). No one *under* 15 fought in those battles, let alone be a leader of them.
Also, Asma, Aisha’s eldest sister (by ten years) died at age 100, 72 years after Aisha’s marriage.
Process of elimination and mathematics, Aisha could not have been married before she was 14 and the consummation before she was almost 20.
“The Quran states a woman's consent is essential, and the Sunnah confirms that both Aisha's betrothal and consummation occurred with Aisha's enthusiastic agreement. In fact, some even imply she went against the initial wishes of her Dad!”
By mathematical reasoning:
622 + 72 = 694 -100= 594 year of Asma’s birth.
622-594= 28 yr of Asma at Aisha’s wedding
Asma is recorded as ten years older than Aisha. Therefore:
28-10= 18 Aisha’s age at wedding.
New gyani choda prakat hue hai...facts leke😂😂
References?
Good researcher
What a 🤣
@@bukasem_ References hote toh ham inki baat kabka maan lete
No one can give such a amazing answer 💖
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
keep cring fool we don't understand this shitty noddel language @@gurujidiscussiongroup3826
Mashallah
We need more scholars like Ghamdi sahab. We need new interpretation of Quran and Arabic to suit modernity. 'Interest'(Riba), modern dressing needs to be made Halal.
Mashallah his explanation is so much satisfying /soothing my heart Alhumdullilah khush rahain App ,
Wow. Riba is clearly discussed in Quran that it is haram.
Lol...
Making haram halal and vice versa. This is the crux of deviant like ghandi nd his blind followers with weak or no faith. May Allah save us all from this fitna.
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
Jazakallahu kherun kaseera for the explaination n clearing all our doubts.
Subhan Allah🤍 what a wise scholar. May Allah give him a long life✨
ruclips.net/video/lOhyhxOKI4E/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
I realy Love this man this is the real quality of gr8 scholar
Really 🙄
He's a great fitna. He's just misguiding the people. He doesn't know himself. All thw story thay he hqs plotted is just rubbish. He didn't mention any reference from Qurwn and Hadith.
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Dil dimag khus ho gaya.Allah Pak ne hamare rassol Hajrat Muhammad Nabiji Sallewale Salam ko dunia ko sahi raste me lane ke liye bheje the unke nam pe kichad mat uchale papio.Ameen.Allah Pak sabki hifajat Kare sadbuddhi de.Thanks lot sir for your honest opinion and presentation.
THIS MAN IS A LIAR...there is no reason to doubt the age given by Aisha, most people remember the significant events in their lives very well. Besides there numerous hadiths which show Aisha was playing with dolls at the time of her marriage, and people in Muhammads household were treating Aisha as a very young girl.
best person to shed light on any topic
may Allah bless him
he is logical and reliable
Ghamdi Sahib... Allah ap ko ajar de..we need Islamic scholars like you.. other wise, the mullahs don't have the capacity to elaborate such sensitive issue
Thank you so much for clearing this issue with reasonable facts.
What an intelligent answer well validated with historical facts and references.
Hahahaha actually he is demolishing islam
@@Rising_Star922 how?
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Sir thank you so much to share this information.🙏🙏🙏
Only you are the person who gave logical and best answer..jzak Allah
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Islam is Truth @@gurujidiscussiongroup3826
MASHA ALLAH what a brilliant man ghamdi is!
always replies with logical way, and explain very beautiful manners.
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Thank you for the explaination. Much appreciated. May Allah guide us all.
the more lies the better guidance lies are your lungs can't live without them!
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Subhanallah... Very good explanation sir...
Great explanation. Valuable information. Allah bless you.
Instead of accepting and announcing the right answer, why this Man is going such a long way ?
Why making ground to fool public ?
I have solid authentic videos of many Islamic scholars of Gulf countries quoting that Muhammad married Ayesha when she was a little Girl of just 6 and he made Sexual relationship when Ayesha grew 9 ( still a little Girl ).
Pure Muslims are telling fact whereas Hybrid Muslims are feeling ashamed to accept the Dirty Fact
@@abhishekdixit2912 Those who have common sense will follow his words. He is a great scholar. My suggestion is no human being should interfere in the life of beloved prophet PBUH. On the day of judgement everyone will know the fact and truth. Have patience because everyone will die and in front of Allah Rabbul Izzath every fact will be cleared. Any human being who believes in Allah Rabbul Izzath and Prophet Mohammed PBUH is a pure Muslim.
THIS IS A WORTHY VIDEO CLIP. GOING BY FACTS....... I WAS SO HAPPY AND ENLIGHTENED IN WATCHING IT. ALHAMDOLLILAH
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Thankyou u very much.... please spread this video to everyone.
*Ghamdi Sahab True Sheikh Ul Islam Of this Time . May Allah Protect you and increase your Emaan and Knowledge . ❤️*
Beautifully Ended the debate MASHALLAH❤️
Not at all ! 😂
@@Indah-tjs Clown 🤡 CP fan. Go check Farid Responds and see how much he lies.
@@Titan-ub5op WOW !! A "Legend" 😂😂🤣
Here again: You are right to call this ignorant little boy Farid a clown. This stupid copycat was asked why there are no witnesses for the alleged "splitting of the moon", and he answered "Because people sleep at night" and in a tweet he wrote "How is it child rape when there is parental consent?" Such highly “intelligent” answers will surely show you too what type of spiritual child he is..
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
Jazakallah khair sir, you explain it, however we know that but most of us must know, thanks for your help
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
Very informative video. Jazak Allah khair
MashaAllah beautifully described ❤️
❤️ From Bangladesh 🇧🇩
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Mri 23 sal hai or Mry husband ki 70 aj bht sakon mila k mjy khush hona chy Hmry Nabi ny b kia asa Age ka koi talaq ni
Mishal Khan I am so sad for you
@@Salahudinbirdsfarm no I’m v happy
@@Salahudinbirdsfarm just pray for me ALLAH olad dy
Aapki shadi kb hoi?
@@rock096 6 month
Ghamdi Sahab you’re great . I feel so relieved after watching this.!
There is only one hadith by Hisham which suggests the age of Hazrat Aisha was 6 when she was married to prophet and 9 when the marriage was consummated. The Hadith mentioned by Hisham is invalid based on historical facts from renowned historians and scholars. For example Historian Ibn Ishaq in his Sirat Rasul Allah has given a list of the people who accepted Islam in the first year of the proclamation of Islam, in which Hazrat Aisha’s name is mentioned as Abu Bakr’s “little daughter Aisha”. The first year of proclamation of Islam was 610. At the time Prophet Muhammad was monogamously married to Khadija. Khadija passed away about 10 years later and Muhammad did not marry anyone else until after Khadijah’s passing away. It is reported that Muhammad (pbuh) married Ayesha on the 10 year of the call(proclamation of Islam). If we accept Hisham’s calculations, Ayesha cannot be 6 or 9 at the time of her marriage to Prophet Muhammad pbuh. In fact she should not have even been born at that time of proclamation, therefore making the Hadith of Hisham invalid.
The Hadith mentioned by Hisham also goes against the ruling of the Quran. In Surah Al-Nisa, it is said that the guardian of the orphans should keep testing them, until they reach the age of marriage, before returning their property (4:6). From this scholars have concluded that the Quran sets a minimum age of marriage which is at least puberty. Since the approval of the girl has a legal standing, she cannot be a minor. Again according to Hisham she was married to the prophet at 6 and the marriage was consummated at 9, which clearly is against the ruling of the Quran.
Aisha had already been engaged to Jubair, before she married Muhammad, suggesting she had already been mature enough by the standards of her society to consider marriage for a while. Interestingly of the many criticisms of Muhammad (pbuh) made at the time by his opponents, none focused on Aisha's age at marriage.
There is consensus agreement among historians and scholars that Hazrat Aisha was 10 years younger than her elder sister Asma, whose age at the time of the hijrah, or migration to Madina, was about 28. It can be concluded that Hazrat Aisha was about 18 years old at migration. On her moving to the Prophet’s house, she was a young woman at 21.
Omar bhai
Thanks for guidance.
According to Hadith of Bukhari Hazrat Aaisha had been narrated in gazwa e badar Nabi Akram S A W
had forbidden children under age of 13 to participate but I fetched for injured.
So it is clear Hazrat Aaisha was much older than 13 in Badar.
Anwar Ul Haq Advocate Here is a detailed analysis on the topic
Anwar Ul Haq Advocate yaqeeninstitute.org/arnold-yasin-mol/aisha-ra-the-case-for-an-older-age-in-sunni-hadith-scholarship/
@@omarashraf5171
Thank you sir.
@lord hannibal Yes
بالکل غامدی صاحب زبردست
Masha Allah! You are 100% right.Afterall, how can a six year old baby lug food n water on her head for 4 kms every day, secretively, failing the hunting Makkan hounds,searching for Prophet SAW at the time of his Hijrat, climb up the mountain top to deliver it to the Prophet SAW n her father,Abu Bakar RA hiding in Gaar e Sower for two consecutive days? Again , it is absolutely impossible that a girl of 9 could comprehend the Risaalat,Shariat n her critical responsibilities in relation to these n the household of the Prophet SAW with such clarity that the great knowledgeable Sahaba RTAA would find so stunning? Again, as we know the age difference between the Prophet SAW n Abu Bakar RA was mere 2 years, as such it seems logical to assume that Prophet's (SAW) youngest daughter,Fatimah RA n Abu Bakar's youngest daughter were almost the same age. Rest Allah knows better.
@jiggly puff Do you believe Bukhari is Qur'an? No doubt, it is the most authentic book of Muslims after Qur'an, but certainly not 100%perfect. Qur'an n Seerat e Nabi n the historical record of that time can validly question any recorded Hadeeth n great Islamic Scholars do have questioned the authenticity of a few Ahadeeth in Bukhari including this one.
Sahih Al-Bukhari is certainly the most authentic book on Hadith, however, only an ignorant could equate it with Qur'an or claim to be 100% correct.
@jiggly puff AGE CONTROVERSY OF HAZRAT AYESHA(RA)...
Please Read this ARTICLE,it has 25 Chapters detailed Researchwww.thetrueislam.info/index1.html
SHE WAS NOT 9.BUT A WOMEN OF "MARRIAGABLE AGE" AT TIME OF HER MARRIAGE
@@mozzammilaslam6884 AGE CONTROVERSY OF HAZRAT AYESHA(RA)...
Please Read this ARTICLE,it has 25 Chapters detailed Researchwww.thetrueislam.info/index1.html
SHE WAS NOT 9.BUT A WOMEN OF "MARRIAGABLE AGE" AT TIME OF HER MARRIAGE
@@xyzabc6898 Thank you a million for guiding me to this superb piece of analytical research, JazaakAllah brother!
Masha Allah sir may Allah bless you and your family
Jazak ALLAH, Ghamdi sb ALLAH ap ki omer mn barkat ataa karey, Aameen
There is soothing of heart in his voice.
Pakistan's hatred of India is driven by shame. Those whose ancestors surrendered to conversion by sword are shamed by those who refused.
~ David B. Cohen
The Islamic Conquest of India Prophecy (Ghazwa-e-Hind) ruclips.net/video/tUqNNMhsYdo/видео.html via @RUclips
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Waha Kamal ki Explanation❤
6:27 hazrat Aisha ka rishta daur e jahilliyat me kisi aur shakhs se tay hua tha.... Hazrat Abu bakr islam lane wale shuruati logon me se hain... Iska mtlb elaan e risalat k waqt hazrat Aisha ki paidaish ho chuki thi..... Hijrat k do saal bad wo rukhsat ho kr Nabi (saww) k ghr aayi hain .. isse kaam az kam hazrat Aisha ki age 15 saal bnti h (13 yrs in mecca + 2 yrs in medina )
*Pahle rishte k waqt agr unki age 3 ya 4 Saal bhi rahi ho..... To rukhsati 19 saal ki umr me huyi hai
@Primal Beast Really nice brother 👍, actually when these Christians or Hindus or other (people) of their respective religion, doesn't get any means of speaking something illogical, against of Islam, they indulge these type of things just to get relief, but they never talks with evidence cause they never understands the Islam or Holy Quran, they find such minor little things in the life of Holy Prophet p.b.u.h ( for sure one of the role models for living your life upon) which is no way near to the religional debate and try to show us embarrassment with it but it's not an issue cause that's what they actually learn from media persons or whatever their speecher told them about without even finding the truth.🤷
Bahooot acha samjhaya aap ne Masha Allah subhaan Allah
جزاک اللہ محترم
Aaj k dour mai koi 54 saala shaks 19 saal ki larki se shadi karay tou log us shaks K baaray mai kya bolen gai????
@@rock096 apne log9 ke mouth par zindagi guzarna hai ya apna
or wo prophet muhammad saww hai
Amazing explaination
Beautifully explained ..cleared lot of my ignorance. jazakallah
why are you trying to hide the fact, it is a shame
@@MdAsif-un2it if you have no problem , why should i bother
@@MdAsif-un2it what a problem to have, shameless
@@MdAsif-un2it marrying a six yr old is very shamefull
@@surinderdalal3974 1442 years se ayesha 6 years ki hai...ab duniya nai gaand marni shuru ki tou achanak se 20 years ki kr de khud baat ko gol matol kr k matlab bukhari bhe ghalat ,baki hadiths bhe ghalat tabri bhe ghalat..yeh ghamdi suchaa jo aj paida hua..
Sahih al-Bukhari 5134
Narrated `Aisha:
that the Prophet (ﷺ) married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old. Hisham said: I have been informed that `Aisha remained with the Prophet (ﷺ) for nine years (i.e. till his death).
Thank you sir, for this wonderful explanation ,moreover ye logically aapne samjhaya badi baat hai .
Thank you for this logical explanation and clarification on hazrat Ayesha's age, I only wish more and more people understand the reality.
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
@@gurdeepkthis hadith is narrated by ibn hasham who has a deteriorating memory.
Thanks to Sir.Ghamdi Sahib for this speech up
Great explanation
Thank you sir. Good to listen to your reasoning and rational conclusion on this issue. Sad to see muslims believing and defending blasphemous hadith. Convert from west ✌️
There is anoyher good explanation, i don't know which one to believe since they both seem reasonable to me.
ruclips.net/video/ZH8L3XiVrXw/видео.html
It's better to say Revert not convert, as we believe we born as muslim. So. May the Almighty Allah bless you and guide u always.
AssalamoalaikumOrb
Wallah, Subhanallah.
Very righteous way explained. With practical, logical points.
Jazak-Allah Khairon.
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
love you ghamdi sb bht achy treeky sa clear kya ha ap na yah concept...🥰😊
Allah aap sehat or tadrusti de sir aap ke ilam me masha Allah or or or ijafa kre Allah aap ko Qabul kre Thank you so much sir😊😊😊
Wow..how greatly explained..thank you.. all in india should listen to this and stop talking against religion.
Narrated 'Aishah: The Messenger of Allah married me when I was seven years old. The narrator Sulaiman said: or Six years. He had intercourse with me when I was nine years old.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2121
Grade : Sahih
It was narrated from 'Aishah that the Messenger of Allah married her when she was six years old, and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine.
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 3255
Grade : Sahih
That's what explained.... But the practices being followed in the religion, that has mattered.....
Forensic Reasearch without bias or opinions. Cold hard Facts without Fitnah.
This is the path to Truth
Ghamdi Sahab said the two word in Arabic very clearly which are actual words for 16 (sittah asharah) & 19 (tissah Asharah) but actually in common day to day use, as anyone who lives in Saudi Arab can confirm, these words are pronounced as sittah for 6 & sittaash for 16 while tissah for 9 & tissaash for 19 which becomes even more difficult to differentiate if you are not listening or conveying clearly or carefully, therefore there is a huge possibility or distortion or misreading while passing down heart to heart only verbally. Also the clear logic explained by Mr. Ghamdi is evident that there is definitely a distortion in the age which can also be proven mathematically by calculating backwards as important landmark dates are mentioned in the history books.
Sahi point pakde ho Bhai 👍👍👍
most logical answer we have heard so far
So good to hear this. How very logical..
Alhamdulillah..
Thanksgiving for giving logical view.true true true...
JazakAllah. Ap ka jitna shukar karun kam hai
Very clearly explained historical facts
Masha allah kia baat bataya aap ne allah aap ko jazai khair ata farmaye aamin
ruclips.net/video/d-4ATpHHmwY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Mmx23ju1wog/видео.html
omg all doubts are cleared thanks love you sir
Mashallah well explained.
Very logical Discussion May Allah bless u
Alhamdulillah....dil ki gahraiyo se aap janab ka sukriya doubt door krne ke liye (🌹 India)
THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH 💖
Exquisite explanation
Jo 9 saal ki age wali riwayet ko aksariyat ki wja se manwany pr zid krty hain unhy ni pta k athiest aur non muslim Prophet saww pr kaise kaise itraaz krty hain hazrat ayesha ki age ko bahana bna kr. Aise ilzaam k kaan sunny se pehly kaash behren ho jaen aur ankhein wese alfaaz prrhny se pehly andhi ho jaen meri.
Hum muslims ko yhi mowaqaf rkhna chahiay nonmuslims k samny hazrat ayesha ki age k bare me jo ghamdi sahib ne rakha hai. Hum ik riwayet ki khatir apny nabi saww pr ilzaam lgty bardasht ni kr skty.
Quran 9.5 me bahut peacefull he kya islam.
@@vishnubaghel-yy7wf No No! It’s a common misconception. Just go a few verses ahead
“How can there be for the polytheists a treaty in the sight of Allah and with His Messenger, except for those with whom you made a treaty at al-Masjid al-Ḥarām? So as long as they are upright toward you,1 be upright toward them. Indeed, Allah loves the righteous [who fear Him].” (Quran 9:7)
And this one too. It makes it very very clear that the polytheists were the first to break the rules.
“Would you not fight against a people who broke their oaths and determined to expel the Messenger, and they had begun [the attack upon] you the first time? Do you fear them? But Allah has more right that you should fear Him, if you are [truly] believers.” (Quran 9:13)
You r right
qasam say bhai buhut dukh huta hai jab koi bina samjhy bakwas krta hai Allah subko aqal day
9 saal wali kitabon ko chupa dena chahiye
غامدی صاحب کی تحقیق مظبوط ہے اس حوالے سے جزاک اللہ خیرا
Gamdi sahab ahadees ko manta hi nahi. . Zara Pata karo jab Nabi Pak wafat pa gaya tab Hazrat Aisha ki age kya thi
Tafseeli baton se hi sach Zahir hoti hai,thanks. ❤️
Sukr hai Allah ka jo is illm deta hai...Ghamdi sahab sab ko allah tala aur ilm me izafa kare..
MashaAllah beautifully described
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Share this video with our muslim and non muslim friends.
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
Jazakallah khair Aap ne ilm Aur Aqal ki Roshni me bahut hi Achchi aur khubsurat wazahat ki Allah pak Aap ke ilm o Tahqeeq me khub izafa kare Aap khub sehat de. Aur iss sach baat ko batane behtareen Ajr e uzma de. Ameen ya Rabbul Alameen.
How long does a well-educated scholar take to complete a controversial issue or question & finally come to the conclusion that marriage took place in 6 years & farewell in 9 years.
Wonderful & salute.........!!!!
Sir he is showing truth
Islamic scholar is also saying the same thing that Nupur Sharma had said.
Nupur Sharma spoke in clear words using some harsh language, but Ghamadi Sahib gave him a literary form & sweet
Wrapped the syrup of words & spoke while both are great scholars of their field. Nupur Sharma is a jurist, then Ghamadi Sahib is an Islamic scholar.
I find many of his explanations matching with logic. However there is still one thing which I strongly recommend him to take care of. And that is his strong Urdu language. He mostly uses very difficult Urdu words. If he simplifies his langyage and uses some English words he will be able to e plain.himself better to non-muslims who want to sincerely seek knowledge of Islam. that way his views will reach out to mamy more non muslims in a much better way
YA ALLHA jo log is jankari ko nahi rakhty unn ko bhi ye jankri atta kar.aamin
Aameen
Allah amit sahab ki jaan o maal ki hifazat farma karde
हज़रत अबू बकर का रिश्ता मोहम्मद के साथ भाई भाई का रिश्ता था तो आएशा मोहम्मद की भतीजी लगी रिश्ते में तो मोहम्मद ने अपनी भतीजी के साथ ही शादी कर ली 😂😂😂 और अगर मोहम्मद और अबू बकर दोस्त भी थे तो भी आगे चल कर दोस्तों के बच्चों की शादी आपस में होती है, ना की दोस्त 6 साल की बेटी को ही दोस्त के बियाह दो 😂😂😂।
MASHAALLAH nice clarification
thanks
Brother Ghamidi,
Salaam Alaikum. Thank you for your explanation of the age of Hazart Ayesha at the time of her marriage with the Prophet Muhammad(pbuh,). Your answer is very logical and I respect that very much.
Zaheer Parvez, PH.D
Maryland, USA
Thanks for excellent explanation
MERA name na lena jisne dhoondh k upload mara ... kuch jaali alimo ki tehqeeq k khilaaf
Too many false Hadees written in our History unfortunately, There is no way Hazrat Ayesha was less than 18 at the time of marriage, Mr Ghamdi is true
No doubt sir you presented matter logically ... n opened a way 2 think again
Hello friend, we are absolutely honored to follow your work, we are immensely happy and grateful to share your amazing work with us, we admire every work shared by you, congratulations for the excellent work we wish you success friend, another subscriber here
My father got married at the age of 12 to his cousin sister aged 8 yrs. 6months after attaining maturity the elders brought their daughter to my dad's house.
After 28yrs he got married to my mom for second marriage.
I respect you. You have spoken truth. Be blessed. My father was 18/19 and my mother was 14.
Actually what the problem is, it's that the west is setting standards for people today. If they say the age to marry is 18 we node and say yes like their slaves.
So the standards today are not actually what the nature is.
We in Pakistan have least age of 18 years for marriage in one province, and 16 in another.
Now why that difference. It's because today's standards are set by people
@@muhammadsuhaib4427 Forget West. Consult your local doctor. He will guide you. Don't ask a hakim.
@@mem1001953 be logical, what the least age for marriage is in your state? And who decides it?
@@mem1001953 mine I already told, different standards in different regions, so the people of one place go and marry in other province to avoid the rules and regulations. Follow the law and avoid the law.