"The nightmares will always be there": These Magdalene survivors tell their personal stories

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
  • Around 200 women, now in their 80s, were in Dublin this week as part of the Dublin Honours Magdalenes event, which saw them attend events at Áras an Uachtarán and the Mansion House.
    We spoke to four women who told their stories of how they came to be working in the laundries.
    www.thejournal....
    TheJournal.ie is an Irish news website that invites its users to shape the news agenda. Read, share and shape the day’s stories as they happen, from Ireland, the world and the web.
    Submit your clips to video@thejournal.ie
    Stay up to date with all of the latest videos by subscribing to our channel: www.youtube.com...
    Download our free iOS app: itunes.apple.c...
    Download our free Android app play.google.co...
    Twitter: thejournal_ie
    Facebook: TheJournal.ie
    Instagram: thejournal_ie
    Snapchat: thejournal.ie

Комментарии • 128

  • @kieransandhu8128
    @kieransandhu8128 5 лет назад +178

    I’ll never forgive the Church or Irish government of that time, for what they did. People in my family were put into Magdalene laundries and it damaged them for life. I was raised Catholic but find the church and most religions tbh, hypocritical.

    • @mickybobo3099
      @mickybobo3099 5 лет назад +5

      Hear hear

    • @bart3639
      @bart3639 4 года назад +13

      You should forgive . Justice and judgment belongs to the Lord. He will jugde them fairly. Be free from that hurt and forgive them. Christ forgave us , even on the cross he prayed for us, people who are sinners. I was raised Catholic too and I am free from that deception. The only way is Jesus, not religions. Folow Him not religions.

    • @londonnodippydolly6635
      @londonnodippydolly6635 4 года назад +4

      @@bart3639 ''here, here'', well said, You don't need a church/religion to love Jesus, and i myself discovered years ago there is no man in the sky, but that God is a loving force that this world is made up of, a running stream/river, or a bird singing in a tree is the 'voice' of God. i never in prayer say ''please God'' a wise friend once told me it is begging, say ''thank you lord''.

    • @judyives1832
      @judyives1832 2 года назад +12

      @@bart3639
      It’s just a fairytale. No need to be bogged down in religious nonsense. You can be free of those old damaging superstitions and live a life with reason and rationality.

    • @juliehurst3846
      @juliehurst3846 10 месяцев назад

      Spot on

  • @anuradhakhubchandani7009
    @anuradhakhubchandani7009 Год назад +33

    My goodness!!!! I never knew such a thing ever existed. Salute to all the brave women who were there all their life.

  • @kimbrown6307
    @kimbrown6307 3 года назад +64

    Makes me so angry that these beautiful brave women got no justice .

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

    • @abbymulligan5188
      @abbymulligan5188 10 месяцев назад +1

      Because government and other powerful people have do this

  • @Paul78bcn
    @Paul78bcn 4 года назад +42

    Justice is needed. Those nuns should be in jail

    • @jackywhite880
      @jackywhite880 3 года назад +2

      They'd probably enjoy it. It's more or less what they signed up for.

    • @Tofu_va_Bien
      @Tofu_va_Bien 4 месяца назад +1

      A lot of them were abandoned by their own families, sent to the convent so there would be one less mouth to feed. Hurt people hurt people. That's why I've committed myself to healing from the abuse I endured; I refuse to let my own suffering be the cause of someone else's.

  • @maryjanemaguire1124
    @maryjanemaguire1124 Год назад +27

    Its great that the travelling community helped her get away and feed her

    • @Tofu_va_Bien
      @Tofu_va_Bien 4 месяца назад +1

      'If you're in trouble or hurt or need-go to poor people. They're the only ones that'll help-the only ones.'-John Steinbeck.

  • @beckyyyvb
    @beckyyyvb 5 лет назад +95

    Bless all these beautiful strong Irish woman. It breaks my heart to hear how they suffered. The Catholic Church should hang their heads in shame!!

    • @owlknickerknots2607
      @owlknickerknots2607 5 лет назад +1

      Irishbelle Xooxox
      Roman Catholicism It’s a religious scam it’s sad people believe that religious hooey!

    • @ajon6205
      @ajon6205 4 года назад +5

      Owl Knickerknots Remember, it’s not the religion, it’s the corrupt leadership of the church. They aren’t true Catholics.

    • @emmetnolan7081
      @emmetnolan7081 3 года назад +4

      @@ajon6205 Catholicism has nothing to do with Christianity you muppet they used Christ’s message to make money and give themselves power over people .

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +2

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

    • @tomakafrankconlon3207
      @tomakafrankconlon3207 3 года назад +3

      Religion should be banned.

  • @ShoJ369
    @ShoJ369 5 лет назад +92

    My heart breaks for everyone who was enslaved by these evil people. They may think they have got away with it. But they have to face the Justice of God one day.

    • @jackywhite880
      @jackywhite880 3 года назад +17

      If there was any such thing as the justice of God, these abuses would never have happened.
      How many thousands of sad, desperate prayers did 'God' turn a deaf ear to???
      Such sad superstitions are at the very root of these problems.

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world

    • @ottoswartz1928
      @ottoswartz1928 Месяц назад

      LOL........under the cloak of God is why this happened. BTW....tell me where in the body is the 'soul'...it doesn't exist except in thoughts conceived by your mind so religion can control you

  • @CowboyJojosAdventures
    @CowboyJojosAdventures 5 лет назад +39

    Horrific times for these Women. What horrible times they were.

    • @rose-mariechauret91
      @rose-mariechauret91 5 лет назад +6

      I couldn't agree with you more! I went to a boarding school run by the nuns. Of course there was no comparison with the above documentaries but I DID put up with a lot of bullying from the other girls because I was very shy and withdrawn. That scarred me for life. And anyway the nuns were not perfect either. I recall our supervisor (a nun) telling one of the girls in the dormitory to stop coughing because she was keeping everybody awake. How ridiculous! As if she could stop coughing!

  • @malotielemans3863
    @malotielemans3863 4 года назад +32

    "I was being abused by my step father in the home" DAMN

    • @jackywhite880
      @jackywhite880 3 года назад +1

      How dare he. Surely he knew that's a priest's job?

  • @ann-mariebaker118
    @ann-mariebaker118 3 года назад +14

    I'm 100% my mum was in one of these institutions. She was mentally & emotionally abusive towards me, & I have nothing to do with her.

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

  • @ChantelStays
    @ChantelStays 2 года назад +10

    ...I don't know why I do this to myself. The amount of human suffering, especially to our children and women 😭

  • @emmetnolan7081
    @emmetnolan7081 3 года назад +12

    Their time has come ,they have no where to hide the truth is out........it’s up to the people of Ireland to respond.........look into your hearts and decide what to do about this evil .

  • @erzonca558
    @erzonca558 4 года назад +24

    Horrors done by the Roman Catholic Church and its devoted followers.

  • @booksnbeaches7075
    @booksnbeaches7075 3 года назад +15

    I hope that an advocacy group will take this on and take the nuns and church to court, so they are punished with jail and made to pay reparation, because it seems clear the the government is not going to. These women and their children deserve justice.

  • @kerriedossett6354
    @kerriedossett6354 2 года назад +13

    my grandmother (dads mom) was put into one of these places when she was pregnant with a girl. she was signed over by her mom and sister. she never left, and they didnt meet men so theres only one explanation for how my dad came to be. he was then sold at 6 weeks old. and he tried to get his mom to come live with us when he was older but they wouldnt let her leave. he saw her for 5 minutes his whole life.... The Catholic church wants to answer for its attrocities, but i fear they never will.

    • @Patrick3183
      @Patrick3183 Год назад +1

      Wow

    • @juliehurst3846
      @juliehurst3846 10 месяцев назад +1

      Where was her family, the oh so good catholics,, who went to church , who was the babies father,, was it a priest, .......😢

  • @dodo3366
    @dodo3366 4 года назад +12

    oh my I had no idea that this was so institutionalised ,is it any wonder nobody goes to church in ireland ,criminal

  • @ryanwhite7398
    @ryanwhite7398 4 года назад +11

    absolutely awful, this is awful charity should not be manipulated in this way for people to abuse the most vulnerable people in need

  • @karinmcdougall7066
    @karinmcdougall7066 4 года назад +39

    can someone tell me if there was ever a Magdalene Laundry in or near Belfast? My great grandmother was from Belfast, and we have little to no family history beyond her. I was very young when she was still alive, but my mother recounted things she had said from time to time over the years. She had absolutely no love for the Catholic church, nuns or priests. One thing I found very odd was she had said she worked as a "housekeeper" in a convent at some time but she was Protestant. Had some tails of secret tunnels, and lime pits in basements. Any info would be greatly appreciated!

    • @michelledunlop1348
      @michelledunlop1348 4 года назад +12

      There was on in belfast, it was on the ormeau road and it was run by the nuns of Nazareth house. If you google the name it will give you some information.

    • @karinmcdougall7066
      @karinmcdougall7066 4 года назад +5

      @@michelledunlop1348 thank you!

    • @krugerfuchs
      @krugerfuchs 2 года назад +2

      Nazareth house possibly

  • @speakingthetruth1100
    @speakingthetruth1100 11 дней назад

    Bless all these women. I hope they get the justice they deserve and we continue to tell their story.

  • @MariaRiveriaHernandez
    @MariaRiveriaHernandez 5 месяцев назад +1

    That’s heartbreaking those poor women.

  • @karenharrington2628
    @karenharrington2628 3 года назад +6

    Many Blessings
    Appreciate Sharing ❤

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

  • @londonnodippydolly6635
    @londonnodippydolly6635 3 года назад +25

    If we all only got rid of this 'man in the sky' story that has put only fear etc into people for years, there is no judgemental man in the sky on a cloud, God is a loving force that this world is made up of, you will find God in flowers, tropical forests, insects, animals etc. God is all those things, and you certainly don't need a church to find God.

  • @cindyrehder1164
    @cindyrehder1164 4 месяца назад +1

    I cry and cry when I read what these precious souls went through. So many stories. So much pain at the hands of pure EVIL. God bless them each and every one!

  • @marykelly9698
    @marykelly9698 10 месяцев назад +3

    My heart is so heavy for these beautiful ladies ❤ ,,, who did you wrong will be judged by god ,,

    • @janetmalcolm6191
      @janetmalcolm6191 10 месяцев назад

      I believe this to be true. No religion in any of this only evil.

  • @sarahi4681
    @sarahi4681 Год назад +6

    It was slavery

  • @seanmcnamara1267
    @seanmcnamara1267 11 месяцев назад +4

    I’m glad that church does not have its power anymore!

  • @rachelhoran6286
    @rachelhoran6286 4 года назад +10

    Absolutely shocking

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      How was your day going so far?

    • @rachelhoran6286
      @rachelhoran6286 3 года назад

      @@danielwetmore7019 it was really good, how was your day Daniel? :)

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      @@rachelhoran6286so far so good. I'm Daniel from forth worth Texas. and where are you from?

    • @rachelhoran6286
      @rachelhoran6286 3 года назад

      @@danielwetmore7019 that's pretty cool, Texas has always been on my bucket list! I am from Ireland :)

  • @cherylemaes6649
    @cherylemaes6649 10 месяцев назад +1

    And all we ever hear in Australia is how hard the indigenous people have had it they were certainly not the only ones who struggled and were taken away from their families they should listen to and read about others

  • @bmc5075
    @bmc5075 6 дней назад

    Bravery at its finest ❤️

  •  5 лет назад +7

    I assume the 3 thumbs down (15 September 2019 were nuns or priests?

    • @nancya6819
      @nancya6819 4 года назад +7

      that or brainwashed Catholics.

    • @jackywhite880
      @jackywhite880 3 года назад

      @@nancya6819
      Is there any other kind of Catholic?
      In fact is there any other kind of religionist?

  • @danielwetmore7019
    @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +2

    I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

  • @MrMcsia
    @MrMcsia Месяц назад

    The movie "The Magdalene Sisters" (2002) is so disturbing - and yet, some of the survivors claim life in the real Magdalene laundries was even more brutal.

  • @deborahwighton5230
    @deborahwighton5230 2 года назад +4

    All the woman they put in there should get all there bk dated wages and feel heart sorry for woman and children that had to go threw this ,Bk then the church was higher that the law ..

  • @andreaguarino8207
    @andreaguarino8207 Год назад +4

    That's the Catholic church...

  • @marybuckley485
    @marybuckley485 Год назад +4

    Thank God the catholic Church is running out of these priests and nuns. Disgraceful behaviour by the Roman catholic Church. Should be abolished

    • @hj1651
      @hj1651 Год назад +1

      Your just on the boat as the majority of small minded people , do you realise how many different religions have done atrocities including this , this isn’t about religion for starters, how much blood does Christianity have on its hands ? How much blood does Islam have on its hands ? The people in power were the problem, not all but all the same still a few, only a few months ago there was that 14 yr old girl in America who was being abused everyday after school by her pastor who was what? A Christian. So this idea that a certain religion should be abolished due to the actions of some power driven sick individuals whose only purpose in life was to get satisfaction the only way they could , by putting the fear of god into people into thinking they were the closest thing to god themselves, no religion is free of atrocities and if that’s your stance that on then every religion worldwide should be abolished period

  • @irishceili100
    @irishceili100 3 года назад +2

    PRAY FOR PEACE 💟🙏🕯

  • @juliehurst3846
    @juliehurst3846 10 месяцев назад +2

    Where were your good Catholic parents, who put you there, shame on them, they knew what was going on, religion has a lot to answer for,,

  • @natureknows7413
    @natureknows7413 3 года назад +8

    Demonic

  • @darryla7603
    @darryla7603 2 года назад +2

    The injustice. Where is the government? Where is the Church? This was happening around the world, it was systematic. America, Canada, New Zealand, Australia. It was policy.

  • @gigglyp100
    @gigglyp100 2 года назад +7

    all this cruelty in the name of an invisible God???????

    • @bendewet1057
      @bendewet1057 Год назад

      No, it is and was for a very Visible god, and his name is Lucifer!!

  • @helenmullane3547
    @helenmullane3547 5 лет назад +5

    😢😭😥

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world ?

  • @irishgirl379
    @irishgirl379 2 года назад +1

    A way

  • @marysmith1952
    @marysmith1952 Год назад +4

    I started the madgalene laundries yet I was abused by the people who were there . My mother was locked up 5 months expecting me put into madgalene laundries left to die. I was in 2 industrail schools and madgalene laundries. My brother starved to DEATH as he was HOMELESS locked up left to die 😢😢😢😢

  • @NMDecember1
    @NMDecember1 3 года назад +6

    Hopefully there are more ex catholics reading this like me. If saved can you let us know briefly how you got saved by the Power of God, was it a book, reading bible, a tract, someone witnessing to you? Don't forget to help other catholics by sharing full true Gospel. 🙏 Someone shared gospel with me although it took me a while to accept it seeds were planted & Jesus is my Lord and Saviour now. 🙌

  • @krugerfuchs
    @krugerfuchs 2 года назад

    What about the abusive children's home still open in dun laoghaire

    • @juliehurst3846
      @juliehurst3846 10 месяцев назад

      WHAT,, FIRST IVE HEARD, IF TRUE WHERES YOUR MP,, THE PRESS, THE BBC, REPORT TO ALL ,TELL EVERYONE , GET IT CLOSED DOWN NOW..😮

  • @Emilyb21-dm3bf
    @Emilyb21-dm3bf 6 месяцев назад

    So long they covered this up. The film reslly brought it too thr main stream. Also the children in the adoption home were abused too. I will never be religious

  • @FirstnameSurname738
    @FirstnameSurname738 27 дней назад

    Ireland should have stayed in the UK

  • @juliehurst3846
    @juliehurst3846 10 месяцев назад

    Come on these women,,, were nuns, who should have been lovely,, why did they become so bitter and twisted,,

  • @kimbrown6307
    @kimbrown6307 3 года назад +1

    Were there any men laundries or just women ???

    • @danielwetmore7019
      @danielwetmore7019 3 года назад +1

      I hope this year brings happiness and prosperity all over the world

    • @carolinebedford9836
      @carolinebedford9836 Год назад +7

      Kim Brown. Are you seriously asking such a dam ridiculous question?!!
      The laundries were solely for girls women who had children out of wedlock, often their pregnancies were as a result of them being sexually abused by one of their relatives, therefore unless a man became pregnant than the answer to your question is no.
      As it happens, the men responsible for the pregnancy had no repercussions at all.

    • @janetmalcolm6191
      @janetmalcolm6191 10 месяцев назад

      For women only.

  • @nohandlemebruh
    @nohandlemebruh Год назад +1

    This is christianity.

    • @shanebell2514
      @shanebell2514 11 месяцев назад

      Read the Bible, Jesus was merciful, not like these hypocrites who claim to be His followers.

    • @theamazingchannel470
      @theamazingchannel470 11 месяцев назад

      Really? Explain, will ya?

  • @albertito77
    @albertito77 Год назад

    Hoes mad

  • @Johnsmith99663
    @Johnsmith99663 3 года назад

    Yes some bad stuff was committed by a few individuals acting in isolation but this persecution of the Catholic church has gone too far now. The church has done infinitely more good than bad for Ireland, yet people keep harping on unpaid labour happening in laundries. These women should be ashamed of themselves.

    • @TheJonathanNewton
      @TheJonathanNewton 3 года назад +37

      Unless you are being sarcastic, the one who should be ashamed is YOU.
      Last time I looked, unpaid involuntary work was the definition of slavery, which although being a popular institution in many parts of the world throughout history nowadays thankfully is outlawed.
      And ”a few individuals”?? I’m sorry, I cannot hear what you are saying, your words are being drowned out by the cries of the 9,000+ dead children out of their mass graves at the Mother and Baby homes.
      The Catholic Church has so much blood on its hands it should have been reformed into oblivion many hundreds of years ago. It’s a pity Luther never made it to Ireland.

    • @Sisterlisk
      @Sisterlisk 3 года назад +6

      What are you going to say to that, "John Smith"?

    • @ericklynch6873
      @ericklynch6873 3 года назад +3

      It's inverted bigots like you who could say the Catholic Church has done good for Ireland 🇮🇪
      Not my viewpoint
      Should be brought up on charges against humanity the Catholic Church should be stripped of their wealth thrown out on the streets
      Remind me
      They took a vow of poverty ?????
      Oh please
      If someone asked you for a good restaurant in ireland in the 60s ?
      Follow the clergy

    • @_lockes_7725
      @_lockes_7725 3 года назад +11

      Tell us what the Church has done that is good for people. Quickly.

    • @curtisdunn2909
      @curtisdunn2909 Год назад

      Sounds like you've been brainwashed.

  • @thrandumbguy
    @thrandumbguy Год назад +1

    My father drove an ambulance in wexford during these times. Not for long thank god. But he told me he would get a call to pick up someone... when he got there he seen a young woman with a small bag of clothes and a small bump... in his words. Took her somewhere in Dublin to the nuns until the child was born and sold by force......Then returned home if she was lucky