Was Islam Spread By Sword? - A Non Muslim Historian Vs Imam Uthman Ibn Farooq
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 янв 2020
- Exciting debate: A non Muslim Historian claimed that Islam was spread by sword, but Sheikh Uthman refuted him easily.
At Balboa Park San Diego, CA
Hope you guys enjoy this!
👉 If you enjoy this video, please like and share it.
👉 Don't forget to subscribe to this channel for more update.
👉 Subscribe now: bit.ly/2Yefu5S
💢💢 Watch our other video:
💟 What is the purpose of life?: • What is the purpose of...
💟 Biblical Scholars vs Imam Uthman Ibn Farooq: • Biblical Scholars vs I...
💟 Was Muhammad A True Prophet?: • Was Muhammad A True Pr...
#Streetdawah ##Islamspreadbysword #Dawah
Thank you for watching this video, click the "SUBSCRIBE" button for stay connected with this channel.
Subscription Link: bit.ly/2Yefu5S
I must admire the talent that Shayek Uthman have. He is so logical, it's really nice to hear him♥️
Then don't forget to say "ALLAHhumma baarik"
since Resul aleyhi salatu wa salam told us to do so, when you see something good at yourself or your brother, you should ask ALLAH ta'ala for baaraka for it, because Al Ayn is real, brings the camel into the cooking pot and the man into grave.
@Alex Bowkett if I ask you what Shayek has lied. Could you point out?
@Alex Bowkett go troll somewhere else
@Alex Bowkett you are totally wrong, troll
@Alex Bowkett Since I watched many videos, just tell me the minute he said that, please.
I'm Indonesian, the conqueror was netherland, portugese, England and Japan. The longest conqueror/cruseder was netherland (350 years). Islam was spreaded by trading in peace ways. The Christian man who discussing in the video is a liar historian.
Teach him,my brother,he might be reading the comments
Yeah, he is a liar alright...
This guy now nothing about history....he just blind fire
Actually dutch is more like colonising us (some missionaries also came here to spread Christianity),. (About 350 years dude, imagine how tf they are! Started from trading spices then they became our government in the past) that's why in the past Indonesia is called Nederlandsch Indie (in Deustch) or Dutch East Indies (in english)
If you're dutch, please don't be offended.. this is the truth. We're actually forgiving you for whatever you doing in the past...but still history always been remembered 😒😒
Yes my Muslim bro. I have been to Indonesia few times, business and libur- nice country and religious people.
As an Indonesian, this so called "historian" doesn't even know the history of my country ...
@a afe ? Ok i will ask him if he indo or not. Ini org ngak percaya yg pemilik komen bukan org indonesia.👈 this is our language the indo and malaysia.
Im malaysian and this islam religion were never spread by the sword here too. You can google it and read our history text. Read the time when king parameswara(non muslim) the 1st king of Melaka converted to islam.
@WT T Why did the Christians colonize Indonesia? You can't back up you statement since in the whatever crime happens in Indonesia is against the law and you have done a political crime by generalizing people. Why did Christians force the Muslims of Phillipines to convert?
@WT T Christianity is not only and intellectual crime but also an embarrassment for laws of God of Abraham.
Iya bener dia gatau sejarah indonesia gimana islam nyebar diindonesia itu org cuman ngaku2 !!!
btw im indonesian too
WT T talk to scholar who learn more you pathetic
As a German, I am ashamed of this man. May Allah Guide him.
Amin Bruder
Mashallah Germany and France really need Islam in my opinion and alot of Germans are becoming part of the family. May Allah bless you with his closeness and may your life and afterlife be easy.
As an Indonesian, I was taught in history classes how the Dutch and Japanese conquered our country. Islamic teachings were accepted by the population because they were delivered in a peaceful manner. In Indonesia, people are free to practice any religion they choose; in fact, our government acknowledges these religious holidays (regardless of which religion they adhere to) as days-off.
hii, a bit of a correction here. people are not exactly free to practice any religion they choose as they are only 5 recognized religion. i.e. if you were to be a jew you couldn’t input judaism as your religion in official records, rather it would just be left blank. and you will not provided with formal religious education beside the aforementioned religions. cheers
@@altheaequatorin1179 I guess, a reason is that these five major religions contributed to the independence of our country. But again, it is just my assumption, you may ask the government to know more about why we cover these religions and do not add Judaism as one of these registered religions. Cheers.
@@widyarkusumaningrum7299 its clear i guess. The hate for israel is directed to Judaism. Since israel is not recognise, the religion is also removed.
@@manfelt2959 To my best understanding, we will never recognize Judaism in Indonesia because our heart belongs to Palestine.
@@widyarkusumaningrum7299 same for Malaysia. I really like the fact that when Shaykh speaks about Islamic Nations, he mentions Malaysia nad Indonesia
Iam from germany so many german converts To islam Hamdullilah ❤️☝️❤️
الحمد لله
Alhumdulilah!!!!!
Alhamdulillah
@Musti Ali He is abusing himself, his family and his beliefs
I witnessed my friends marriage and his german wife on the age 17 became muslim.
I am Indonesian, and this man who called himslef "Historian" is TOTALLY WRONG!!
Non Muslim here can practice their religion even before Indonesia gain his freedom at 1945...
Look Hinduism in Bali Island. Look Christianity in Jayapura. Look Muslim in Aceh. Budhism in Surabaya.
@@SadalgaVlogs Not really. Egypt and Palestine are very tolerant.
So is Malaysia. These countries support our christian and non-Muslim brothers.
@@SadalgaVlogs I'm Malaysian and you're totally wrong
This christian is a person who refuse to know the truth
Well, they can't practice many things that are in the Bible. Like in 1 Samuel "But kill both man and woman, infant and nursing child, ox and sheep, camel and donkey."
Thank you brother for the information I am a Moroccan who lives in America in the beginning of the conversation I thought he is saying the truth because I don't know much about Indonesia but Thanks to you and other Indonesians who commented now I know he's a liar
I am Indonesian. I was so surprised when the historian said that Islam is an obligatory religion in Indonesia. Never have I heard someone saying something like that before.
Happy to hear from Indonesians. So that others dont think the Sheyk is lying.
hahaha yeah right I know A bit of Indonesia history....After the leaders of Indonesia accepted Islam..by the Arabs........they tried to Violently invade Philippians...to force Islam upon them....but they were defeated with the help of Spain..and Mexican warriors........yes I understand that Spain did try to convert..the natives in South America...but after awhile the natives were still practising their own old religion...even today....in South America...and North America..most Natives...fellow...their spiritual Ancestors religion......
@@Gyamfi take your meds
@@Gyamfi I'm a Moro Filipino. U must be smoking expired weed. Force Islam? Islam was brought first by Al Makhdum, a missionary. Way b4 the Spaniards came and force xtianity. Look it up.. GOOGLE IT. 😂😂😂
The german man is a liar.
i am amazed of how this german man so so so so so so so confident of his knowledge yet ignorance at the same time, human are so interesting. Thank you Syekh Uthman to defend Indonesia, i am Indonesian myself.
May Allāh bless you and all our viewers
@@OneMessageFoundation AAMEEN
Unfortunately many German people behave like this and they are wrong 90% of time
this christian man has a history of his own...
😂
Yeah, he teaches HIS-Story
lmao.
🤣🤣🤣
hahaha yeah right I know A bit of Indonesia history....After the leaders of Indonesia accepted Islam..by the Arabs........they tried to Violently invade Philippians...to force Islam upon them....but they were defeated with the help of Spain..and Mexican warriors........yes I understand that Spain did try to convert..the natives in South America...but after awhile the natives were still practising their own old religion...even today....in South America...and North America..most Natives...fellow...their spiritual Ancestors religion......
Egypt was forced by romans to become christians and the roman swords were very sharp !
But was the Arab any different? Just asking
@@kingvxv6438 yea, they were, Egypt people were the one who called the Muslims for help.
@@suekennedy8917 And?
@@suekennedy8917 Then you are stupid to be a criminal in Iran or Saudi Arabia if you already know the punishment is severe
Sue Kennedy So you’re comparing Roman Catholics to thieves? Makes sense to me.
Hi Indonesian here, Indonesia is very diverse country with 6 recognized religion. Yes, there are scratchy up-side down relations JUST LIKE IN EVERY COUNTRY INCLUDING IN THE US AND GREECE AND INDIA, but that's it. We are mostly living peacefully together AND YES THE OTHER RELIGIONS CAN PRACTICE THEIR RELIGION PEACEFULLY.
Sheikh Uthman is very knowledgeable… may Allah increase him in beneficial knowledge. Aameen
As an Indonesian, I wish I was there to teach this so called historian a lesson. He said Indonesia become a muslim majority country because it was invaded by muslim seafarers? HAHAHA.. lolll,, actually traders from Gujarat, Yemen, and Egypt came here and slowly gave da'wah to Indonesians back in the 14th century and the people here started to embrace Islam peacefully. I am enjoying this conversation and I totally agree with Sheikh Uthman.. may allah bless you sheikh
@The_ Jizyah perang paderi doesnt have anything to do with the spreading of islam during the early 14th century.. thats just some civil and local conflicts which some community groups which had just newly embraced islam wouldng want to adhere to islamic custom. Has nothing to do with how indonesia became islam. And now, alhamdulillah, west sumatra is a very islamic and religious province of indonesia
The_ Jizyah kgk ada hubungan dengan islam bego bat lu 😂😂
@The_ Jizyah Hahahaha gblkkk
@The_ Jizyah kerajaan Indonesia sekarang ada isytihar perang sama penganut agama lain?
@The_ Jizyah tak perlu tulis panjang2.. jawab soalan aku
Indonesian here, that historian is spreading Lies
WT T burning churches does not mean a thing. Even isis bombed a mosque. Im from other south east asia country, we all neighbouring country know that indonesia is famous by their diversity and religion freedom. There are like hundred race and ethics there and they live in peace.
These people will say anything to bad mouth Islam
Hindu name living living in Indonesian
@Rual stop spreading fake news please
@K M non muslim are treated equally in here, they can perform their religious ritual without problems
germans like to talk to another like they know everything and they are always right... even if they dont... so even if they are miles away from the truth 😆
it is like a tradition, almost every german does this.
it is a 'german thing'.
Greeting from Gemrnay 😆👍
I agree, I am also from germany 😂😅
Kann ich bestätigen / i agree.
Inflated egos. Maybe from too much pork.
@Said Bale I think Netherlands have the best engineers. Without the best, they would've all drowned by now.
@Said Bale Dont be racist or have superiority thinking, especially when you are a muslim.
superiority thinking is shaytans work (remember Adams Creation).
i am a german engineer :)
and i can tell you, that there are very good universities everywhere. As well as that they are good and bad people everywhere.
If you think that the japanies people are better engineers, ok nice, your thinking. But dont call anybody "trash"...
Sellam
I like how the man understands in the end his limitations. May Allah guide him
Wow, I’m speechless. This German guy is either ignorant or a liar. He claims Islam is the the obligatory state religion in Indonesia and other religions can’t be practiced.
Indonesia's freedom of religion is little more than nominal. See the Indonesia 2018 International Freedom Report.
@@maxb9315 already read it. As indonesian, you have to fulfill several documents before a masjid or gereja or church or temple or anything you named it before it is approved for religious activity. Then, the report it self clearly stated the community didnot granted the proposal. If the officials didnot stand with minority, you said it oppression. Whilst the us government it self was secular. Our pancasila protected by 87%muslim , that would be 200million people and you only bring only 2000false jihadist as a representative of all. Thats hypocrisy. Aceh syariah law , you dont even know our suffering after tsunami man. Hadeuh, just like vanuatu. Taipan kaya diindonesia an aja tuh mas bro. Padahal bukan islam.
German historian don't even knows hitler
@@readincognito3399 Thanks for your response. Unfortunately it is a little garbled and the meaning is not clear.
@@maxb9315 means that we indonesian knows our country better than american. Common sense.
Christian religion was brought by the dutch. The missioneries tried very hard to convert Muslim to Christianity. They failed. The Dutch colonised Indonesia for centuries.
Same situation with British and India.
Its true....I know because I am indonesian.
And Malaysia, or Uighur people, no war against Arab in china history, or somewhere in Thailand
Alhamdulillah, my Muslim brothers and sisters in Indonesia are magnificent. Salam from Malaysia.
It's true...
I am as proud Indonesian, feel so pity about him. May Allah bless him with true knowledge
The most hilarious part was that guy called himself a historian 🤣😂
Hi, I am Indonesian. You need to know, there are five religions that are officially recognized in Indonesia. we are always side by side and remain peaceful. ✌️🤝🤗 Alhamdulillah 🤲
you should not say alhamdoulelleh for the 3 other false religions. you should ask allah to purify your country from shirek.
@@MejriThameur I said Alhamdulillah because I am grateful that I was born in Islam.
I say Alhamdulillah because we live together without conflict.
And of course I hope that my brother who is still not a Muslim will soon become a Muslim
sorry if my english is bad
i'm not talking about living without conflict , i'm talking about the fact that your country have other false religion, you souldnt be happy for that. of course we ask allah to guide them all but again this is a diff topic.
@@MejriThameur I am Indonesian.
And I Know More Than You About Indonesia.
@@timbulcycling3269 i agree , we are not talking about indonisia but about you faith akidaa in front of the false religion. you should not be happy untill all the country is free of shirek and bidaa and false religions.
God bless you, keep up with your patience and kindness, even with people being silly and ignorant
There is an applied science university called Hochschule Zittau/Görlitz, but there is no faculty for history or any other related courses.
There is a list of educational facilities on the city of Görlitz's website, but none of them offer a history course.
I also looked through the staff list of all faculties at Hochschule Zittau/Görlitz, but our so-called historian was nowhere to be found.
Historian?! Sure!
Thanks man. So busted
Much love for your effort! ❤
He said Saudi Arabia conquer Indonesia. This statement makes my day 😅🤣.
I'm from Indonesia and I know my country history. Yes we had fought before against the Dutch, Japanese, and communist. None one single muslims country ever invade our country to spread Islam.
The problem is that he’s a teacher at the university
@@thefrontierofrepublic3234 But if he's ignorant of Indonesian history and focuses mainly on German and roman history then he's wrong ! Some countries never tell their schools to learn about history outside their continent like europe Since when did they taught you about Mughal History or Mauryan History ? Or Indonesian History even
omg we have a lot of these teachers here in Germany. when i got involved with islam i was shocked how much lies and wrong knowledge we are taught from an early age in school. I think the teacher's own opinion often flows into this and passes it on to the children
How can one be a historian and closed minded at the same time?
@X HOXQ like that lying historian guy, yeah you can.
He is a pathetic liar... He is not a historian ... just pushes lies under the label of history but he is creating fake history and a lot westerners are pretty comfortable in doing that.
those 2 actually go hand in hand these days. universities teaching of history is corrupted
He could be a historian that doesn't or hasn't ever focused on South East Asia. The shocking thing isn't that he doesn't know about Indonesian history and is talking nonsense, but that he's willing to stick by a distorted version of history even in the face of evidence, he's made up his mind even if you prove him otherwise.
@@meowth8050 yes that’s actually true
It took me a second to google ghassan and voila! There it is! I agree that we should be afraid for his students. A self proclaimed roman expert indeed! May Allah swt guide him. I m so grateful to Allah for being a muslim.
I'm Indonesia people, islam come to Indonesia with peace, ☺, kami berusaha saling bertoleransi ☺ kami berdampingan dan bersama
Im indonesian and this historian is just a liar !!!
yes , end this liars are allowed to write blasfemies on wikipedia too
Ada depan mata gw toyor bang orangnye hahahaha
"Can non muslims practice their religion there?" He said "Not really", "I'm honest", ... Yeah, rrrrriiiightttt.....
If he was a historian, i'm an astronaut !
i'm the best athlete in the world!!
i'm fat acctualy :/
im a meowgineer!
I am queen Elizabeth 👸
@@zainabomer7511 lol make me a prince
Can you refute his arguments? Then this is a A logical fallacy.
JazakaAllahu Khairan
Jazakalloh khoir
A real test of one's patience speaking to stubborn ignorant individuals ... I have lots respect for Sheikh Uthman
Much love and respect back to you
i really doubt he is a historian. The way he act doesn't look like an educated person with facts and figures
Typical non-muslims who are intoxicated.
@@Emsyaz I'm trying to quit!
Jp Ira no problem with that, he has a right to.
@Jp Ira when did he preach sharia? Lol pathetic tryna lie . I mean that’s the only way how you can destroy Islam, by lying
They watched fox news and proclaimed themself historian
He’s so patient, I don’t know how he does it. May ALLAH guide and protect the Ummah
ALHAMDULLILAH AMEEN Sheigh Uthman your patience are on the next you're dawah is truthfully and clear straight from the HEART i will sit wholeday in Sheigh Uthman dawah from South Africa ALHAMDULLILAH
Lol he said he’s a historian. I wonder if he went to Fox News university
😃😃😄😉👍
No fox news never had university but trump did had trump university i think he was professor there thats why it went bankrupt 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol
He is a fox news fanboy. Wrong claims about history.
Hahaha
This guy just won't admit that he got caught lying and is misinformed, even when given proof.
@Gospel Truth Neither the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) nor his companions, nor those who followed him them in goodness forced anyone to convert to Islam or be killed. Allah says in the Noble Qur'an Al-Baqarah 2:256
"There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the Right Path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in Taghut and believes in Allah, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that will never break. And Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower." And there's other proof.
@Gospel Truth I see your point, however you need to understand jihad as a whole and not just a part. After Muslims took control of an area they didn't force people to convert to Islam or be killed as was done with other religions. m.islamqa.info/en/answers/178756
ruclips.net/video/sST1pfb1c3I/видео.html Inshallah (God willing) these links will give you a clearer understanding. May Allah guide you and improve your condition. Aameen.
@Gospel Truth bible says there is capital punishment for apostasy, did you know this?
😪 It's going to be one of those days again.
Claiming to be specialized in Roman history and thinks he knows everything about what is Islam is and how it spread (via the sword) though just a small segment in the Roman historical timeline is literally a sign of pure arrogance.
By his demeanor I struggle to believe he is a Lecturer or Professor of History. If it is true he is then I have to concur with Sheikh "I'm afraid for your students."
Brother face at 1:08 is like " Don't look at me, you started it" lmao
Indonesia have 5 diff religion and we live side by side , how can this man lied about something without knowing the truth , SMH
Simak materi lengkap kak ruclips.net/video/_z_xFlTJEpI/видео.html pemateri bersanad Quran 30 juz bersambung ke nabi dari jalur asyatibiyyah & attayyibah annasr juga sanad periwayatan hadits2
Sekarang 6 mas bro. Just saying.
Indonesia govt declare all 5 "holiday" religions.
@@imagenifty2563 6 imlek ( chines new year )
@@readincognito3399 7 (yahudi) krna rezim bru ini gk peduli sma agama yg masuk lgi🤦♂️
Shaik nailed it 17:37 🤣🤣🤣
"I'm afraid for your students"
🤣👍
knowledge is power! All muslims should study like this brother . May Allah protect him
the brother standing in the middle yawning tells it all :D
Fun fact : At the university of Görlitz isn't even thought history. I looked it up 😅
Great research 🧐
This you can say aboute all western universitys.
Aselamouh Alaikoum from germany... I checked it twice. Its a ekonomic and technical Collage...
No he mentioned at the University of Gorilla's 😀😀😀😀😀
Yep. I checked as well. There is no History Course there. In the Bachelors and Masters section there is a Culture Module but nothing states History or Islam or Romans etc. This guy is clearly winging it aka lying.
I love this Shiekh, he is very knowledgeable and strong, masha Allah!
Fool
@WT T Killings of innocent muslims in NZ.. why?
There is no barabarism there at all. Understand that hadith in the light of the hadith before it:
It was narrated from Abu Hurairah that the Prophet said:
"Whoever looks into a house without the permission of the occupants and they put out his eye, he has no right to blood money or retaliation."
أَخْبَرَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ الْمُثَنَّى، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا مُعَاذُ بْنُ هِشَامٍ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنِي أَبِي، عَنْ قَتَادَةَ، عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ أَنَسٍ، عَنْ بَشِيرِ بْنِ نَهِيكٍ، عَنْ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ " مَنِ اطَّلَعَ فِي بَيْتِ قَوْمٍ بِغَيْرِ إِذْنِهِمْ فَفَقَئُوا عَيْنَهُ فَلاَ دِيَةَ لَهُ وَلاَ قِصَاصَ " .
Grade : Sahih (Darussalam)
Reference : Sunan an-Nasa'i 4860
In-book reference : Book 45, Hadith 155
English translation : Vol. 5, Book 45, Hadith 4864
WT T ignore him 😂
@@numbers6246 He has an open debate challenge for any Christian, let your best man face the Shiekh.
Islam will free you from the foolishness of worshipping man or a religious doctrine which says that God cant forgive man unless his son is killed.
بارك الله فيكم
I'm Indonesian Muslim
Indonesia was colonized for the first time by the Spanish kingdom, after that it was colonized by the Portuguese kingdom, then colonized by the Dutch kingdom, after being controlled by the Japanese kingdom, then the British empire helped the Dutch to fight the Japanese kingdom until finally Indonesia declared its independence. One of the people who helped Indonesia were the Chinese, the South Koreans, and the Arabs who helped the most, especially Habib and Suffi
Subhanallah....I love Ahmed Didat....I love Dzakir Naek....I love Sabeel Ahmed....I love Imam Uthman.....salam I am from Muslim Indonesia 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
It's really confusing when someone sees the truth clear as crystal and still refusing it! May Allah guide them..
Āmīn
I love how in this comment section our Indonesian brothers and sisters told how islam came to their country peacefully alhumdulillah. May Allah swt guide us all to the straight path AMEEN.
That guy was like an “empty vessel”. He argue for the sake of arguing.
May Allah give lots of sabr to Sheikh to da’wah.
This Historian has a clear bias about Islam because Islam was spread by trade in Indonesia. It is basic knowledge, he should have known as a Historian. It was good that Sheikh embarrass him in this point. I am not sure from where these people are learning lies about Islam.
Hate preachers and priests, priests lie literally in the church.
The_ Jizyah 🥱
@@MohammadAliKhalil d' jiZYah is : MuNAFikuuN, just put Aside, assume him : notHinG but onLy some0Ne- who want to mâle Chaos
dr jay
@The_ Jizyah man, u so stupid
He keeps trying to move the goalposts because he can't answer, but the Sheikh keeps pressing him for the answer. May Allah bless this Sheikh
I admire Sheikh Uthman's patience. Subhanallah!
Alhamdulillah.. I'm from Indonesia, we live together here in peace and harmony, side by side with our brother and sister from another religion.
Certain Westerners think just by being born in the West, they are right when they express an opinion.
It's just their privilege and prejudice showing. Even though, usually Westerners are the most wrong and stereotype every country and regions people, while falsely thinking their people are the better ones.
I think it is issue with every good looking person across the globe, no matter from which area. They think whatever they speak is truth and must be accepted as is.
@@nasirhussain7552 good looking? Need glasses?
@@jenniferskweter your racism is disgraceful
Arrogant people exist in every culture. Same with humble people. You seem like more of the former
The fact: Christianity spread in Indonesia through colonization with weapons and plundering Indonesian wealth is the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch, and British. The strongest spreading of Christianity in Indonesia is the Portuguese.
I am Indonesian, and I have been to Bali, and what I admire in Bali is that there are 5 places of worship of different religions side by side and maintaining tolerance.
If you go to Bali you will see an area occupied by many adherents of Hinduism and Buddhism. If you go to Papua you will see lots of Christians, and if you go to Aceh You will see the areas governed by Islamic law. And Islam is comprehensive throughout Indonesia because of its beauty.
"I let you finish you let me finish". Never lets him start so can't let him not finish. : ]
so called historian...he should be fired from teaching history
By a ‘firing’ squad 😏
When you hear there people talk you really understand when Allah says in their Quran that “their hearts are sealed”. SubhanAllah May Allah protect us
He also says they're dumb deaf and blind. iirc it also said they'll never experience the light of Allah. This guy was full of garbage. haha "historian".
If only they knew :(
AMEEN
Anything to win an argument with some people. That’s all it is, an ego trip. Shaykh has an awesome subtle way of putting them in their place and calling them out with patience. Really a lot to learn from his dialogues.
I actually looked up the Ghassan tribe after watching this. Fascinating history I wasn't aware of. Jazaak Allah
I just wanted to tell every single person who has turned his life towards Allah and trying to be better-- Allah is with you ❤️
Ameen😂💕
Ameen brother
If he's a historian, I'm an olympic figure skater. Das auto.
🤣🤣🤣
the fact that you said "das Auto" at the end make this comment even more funnier 🤣
Das Auto means the car.
@@burkanyilmaz9718 I am aware of that Freundchen!
@@danchou556 Moin Kollege wie läufts? Bist du auch in Deutschland 🇩🇪 aufgewachsen?
Bratwurst schmeckt mir nicht Bruder
I think that every topics that was talked in the video should have a link on the description 🙏
From Indonesia here 🙋♀️. It was thru peaceful asimilation that Islam spread here and it was introduce by traders from Arab world, India, etc. Here we respect every religion and respect each other. This is the very basic value we hold together. Regardless majority or minority.
This man is so unwell informed, and yet believing in some facts that he doesn't know about.
@WT T
Nice joke and a big lie, when u try to deceive others you get Trapped.
@WT T
Wikipedia....come ouf of it.
It is 100% Morphed like ur medi and bible.
uthman: facts facts fact, evidence, explanations
historian: nooo nononono
wow, this was tragic. i do feel sad for him and anyone he teaches.
THAT ENDING WAS WHOLESOME
Bali: Majority Hindus.
Muslim/Hindus/Christian can live together peacefully.
The majority of the country Islam
Are you sure they are living peacefully under Modi rule?
@@adamyoutube281 he's talking about indonesia sir.
Roman and Ghassan was an alliance fought alongside against Persian Sassanids. How can the historian not knowing this?
because he is a BS historian
You have so much not just islamic knowledge but also historical mashallah
I’m from Germany and this is brilliant example of German professor. Pure ignorance not intelligent just school educated.
Allah reward you and preserve you brother Uthman
@WT T just go to indonesia brother. when church and mosque are nearby. come to our country :)
Very ignorant old man. May Allah SWT guide him to Islam
He may not be up to speed on Indonesian history, but it does not follow from that he should therefore convert to Islam. The Koran is not a historically credible document.
@CH No, it is not. For centuries Islamologists, both Muslim and non-Muslim, have brought to light the Koran's unclear provenance, lack of coherence and consistency, confused chronology and unclear content.
@CH 'Reading the Koran on its own terms, trying to interpret it without resorting to commentaries, is a difficult and questionable exercise because of the nature of the text- its allusive and referential style and its grammatical and logical discontinuities, as well as our lack of sure information about its origins and the circumstances of its composition. Often such a reading seems arbitrary and necessarily inconclusive.'
G.R. Hawting
@CH Why is the statement uncultured? Perhaps you'd like to attempt a reasoned argument, point by point, as to why what Hawting says is unfounded.
@CH 'Muslim scholars themselves are aware of the difficulties and obscurities of their sacred text. Fuat Sezgin lists no less (sic) than eighteen treatises by Muslim philologists, such as Aban b.Taghlib...and Niftawayh...for the period between the mid-eighth and mid-ninth century...[such as] The Rare [i.e. Strange] Expressions of the Quran.' Ibn Warraq, Virgins? What Virgins? p.137.
Shiekh usman, you have a huge tolerance in dealing with stupid and ignorant what so called historians... I swear to God I could easily end this conversation before it even starts... Avoiding looking to sheikh usman and talking to the other guy to receive recognition...
Brother Usman you are just rocking. May Allah help you spread the truth more efficiently and effectively.
This is not a historian he's a hater
Bro, can you pls share the entire street dawah session, I mean the whole day. That would be nice to see. But, appreciate your effort and May Allah grant you Jannah, Ameen
I share your request but who is listening ???.... They could make it famous public Dawah place like Speakers Corner @ Hyde Park in London if they could publish more videos with details described in text... But ???
@@ahmedalshalchi Yes, Brother Sheikh Uthman is an awesome preacher, I hope more ppl watch his video and we can get more video InshAllah
@WT T Killings of muslims in the mosque in NZ.. why?
The patience Sheikh Uthman has Masha Allah. These so called historians are teaching our children in school. Teaching our own children is so important.
This man from Gorlitz is neither a Christian or a professor of history... and now the entire world can see his face online...
Western christian:"Islam spread through sword at south asia once upon a time"
Me : LOL, your crusaders warring with us because we are muslim and try to convert us(Gold, Gospel, Glory). Missionaries in Malay peninsula failed, Java and Sumatera small success and Phillipine is huge success. The one swinging sword towards us is you guys lol.
@@suekennedy8917 eh? Im just added the region. The original content not changing. Edited : and i also added original history that you guys altered.
@@suekennedy8917what you scared of the truth? Dont you feel weird that south philipines still have muslim yet the north is christian?
@@suekennedy8917 and what article is that? Where you get it? Provide some source. Sometimes you guys just put law or principle from shia or other extremist and call it Islam or syaria. Lol
@@suekennedy8917 yeah thats is fact
@@suekennedy8917 ruclips.net/video/BKckHIXKZKc/видео.html there you have it. Yeah they quite aggresive since they been to long under oppression. Dont trust me? look at BLM. Yeah the oppressed get crazy by time.
Islam coming to Indonesia no by swords..I'm Indonesian live in Australia.
I have yet to see a Christian admit they were wrong after someone challenges their statement and proves they're wrong. They will just jump to the next subject and ignore what they were wrong on.
The ending was so funny 😂. One mistake though is that pashtuns are iranic not aryan but that depends on what type of aryan you are referring to, the racist version of the word or the ethnic family.
Yes Iranics are a subgroup of the Aryan race which Hitler spoke of
@@SSs-ch4ey No, not a subgroup. It was either Aryan or not Aryan.
@@eatinsomtin9984 Yes but there are different groups. Germans and pashtuns are very different
nope im from indonesia and indonesia doesnt conquered by the arabs, indonesia was originaly called majapahit and this javanese empire become islam because marriage, my ancestor was amazed by the humbleness of this religion, the conqueror of indonesia is actually the colonial dutch and their horrible 3 basic ideology Gold, Gospel, Glory, indonesian independance was caused 89% by the muslim.
"You're not my student"
"I'm so glad"
🤣🤣🤣
🤣
You killed me with that salute near the end 😂😂 Alhamdulillah
14:43 Sheik Uthman: "It's been a long sentence" 😂😂😂
This was painful to watch. I cringed all the way to the end. I commend you on your patience. May Allah be pleased with you Sheikh.
hahaha yeah right I know A bit of Indonesia history....After the leaders of Indonesia accepted Islam..by the Arabs........they tried to Violently invade Philippians...to force Islam upon them....but they were defeated with the help of Spain..and Mexican warriors........yes I understand that Spain did try to convert..the natives in South America...but after awhile the natives were still practising their own old religion...even today....in South America...and North America..most Natives...fellow...their spiritual Ancestors religion......
@@Gyamfi Who is god?
Jesus
Is Jesus the son of Mary?
Yes
Who created Mary?
God.
Who is God?
Jesus
Jesus is the begotten son.
Yes
Who is his father?
God.
Who is God?
Jesus.
Jesus is a servant of God?
Yes
Who is God?
Jesus.
Jesus died on the cross?
Yes
Who resurrected him?
God.
Who is God?
Jesus
Jesus is a messenger?
Yes
Who sent him?
God.
Who is God?
Jesus.
Did Jesus worship while on earth? Yes
Whom did he worship?
God.
Who is God?
Jesus.
Did God have a beginning?
No....
Then who was born on 25 DEC?Jesus.
Who is God?
Jesus.
Where's God?
In heaven
How many are there in heaven?Only one God.
Where's Jesus?
He is sitted on the right hand of his father.
Who is God?
Jesus.
Then how many are they in heaven?
Only one God
Then how many seats?
One
Where's Jesus?
Seated next to God.
Then how are they seated?
On one chair
Its only understood by those with the holy spirit.
Who is God?
Jesus.
Think and act ..
@@Gyamfi What's with your "......" lol write a proper paragraph.
@@Gyamfi you’re so wrong it’s not even funny, why don’t you go and have tea with the ignorant german in the video? 😂 Do you not know the atrocities spain committed in the philippines? Mass murder and forced conversion like most of spanish history. Why would they randomly switch up at the philippines? It’s because you’re wrong. The phillipines used to be majority muslim just like indonesia, because the truth and advanced peaceful practice of it touched the hearts of the philippines. This was until spain came with its colonization practices they were terrorizing the rest of the world with after the spanish inquisition genocide. Don’t attribute the wests violent history onto Islamic history, people in the west love doing that to cope
This self proclaimed historian is such a liar. What a shameless person...
What makes you think he's a liar? What makes you think he's shameless? There is no evidence in the video for either.
@@maxb9315 He's a liar because he makes claims:
1. Muslims conquered Indonesia. Islam was brought to the various kingdoms in Indonesia by traders from Samarkand, Gujarat etc.
2. Non-muslims cannot practice their religion. Indonesia is a republic and the freedom of religious practice is guaranteed by the constitution.
When one makes claims one must provide evidence,
@@achmadyazir1039 I understand that it's the case that Islam spread to Indonesia via mercantilism (contrary to the norm of conquest for the spread of Islam). You are unjustified, however, is assuming that the gentleman is therefore lying. Lying entails knowingly propagating an untruth. You don't know that he's doing this.
Indonesia's stance on religious freedom is little more than nominal, and non-Muslims are frequently the subject of religious harassment and discrimination. I suggest you read the Indonesia 2018 International Freedom Report, which reveals that Indonesia's record in this regard is little better than that of Muslim countries in general.
@@maxb9315 I'm not assuming anything. The gentlemen proclaims to be an historian and made his assertions. If he didn't make such a claim then I would certainly attribute his assertions to plain simple ignorance.
@@achmadyazir1039 You ARE making an assumption. Those with a high level of education are not immune from error and don't know everything about their subject.
this channel needs +10m subscribers
Im an Indonesian and in historical leason on my school said,"Most of ulama who bring islam to Indonesia spreading his dakwah with merchant trade,song, art, poem and puppet show" ,i never read or heard they dominate some island and force the people to become muslim
im from indonesia.
in Indonesia are very tolerant of any religion. and here the majority of the world's largest Muslim religions but we love peace
‘They came to our land with a sword in one hand and a Bible in the other.
They ask us too close our eyes and pray with them. We did.
When we open our eyes, we had the Bible and they had our land.’
Desmond Tutu.
And here, ladies and gentlemen, we see the Dunn Kruger effect in full bloom.
Thank you for the demonstration Mr. I'm-a-historian.
10/10
"i feel sorry for your students." the Sheikh.
🤣