Vintage Defectors (Retired)
Vintage Defectors (Retired)
  • Видео 7
  • Просмотров 622 864
David Lee Roth VS! Sammy Hagar - Van Halen Tribute (Revised)
(Update 10/8/20. RIP Eddie Van Halen. You will never be forgotten).
This is my re-edit of the VS! for Van Halen. As usual, this is not a real competition but just a fun compilation to compare the singers. This time I used live videos for everything I could without sacrificing too much audio quality. There are a couple exceptions as well as an edit someone did of audio from a song onto a video of a different performance of the song. This video also excludes Gary Cherone sadly, but maybe I'll make an Evolution of Extreme video at some point to include him in an edit like this.
(Update: I had to replace the music video I used for 1986 Dave with a live since I got blocked in all countries again...
Просмотров: 2 616

Видео

Bon Scott VS! Brian Johnson - AC/DC Tribute (revised)
Просмотров 327 тыс.4 года назад
This is the original VS video I made, but just like my newer ones, I must stress that this is a competition of opinion for fun and out of love for the band. I love both of these singers and while I in some cases prefer one to the other in this series, I think it's important to listen to each other's side and enjoy the legacy that these artists have created. That being said I LOVE seeing the com...
Steve Walsh VS! John Elefante - Kansas Tribute
Просмотров 43 тыс.7 лет назад
(In your opinion) WHO WON? I can't choose at all. Love em both. BONUS! - Some Ronnie Platt in here too. LOVE making these videos. Disclaimer: These are not clips I went in time and recorded. They all were uploaded to youtube and are easy to find. I will tell you what they are if you request in the comments :3
Ozzy Osbourne VS! Dio - Black Sabbath Tribute
Просмотров 13 тыс.7 лет назад
Who wins? You Decide!!! This one is rather short for one of these, but I think I only needed a lyric or 2 each anyway for it anyway to show them off. Personally, I love Ozzy's tone and Dio's energy. Sorta biased toward Ozzy though. (Shrug)
Lou Gramm VS! Kelly Hansen - Foreigner Tribute
Просмотров 130 тыс.7 лет назад
As usual, not a battle of technicality. Just who likes who more. Basically, what do you think? Comment about it in the box that has word typing for comments or something I don't know (shrug) LOVE YOU GUYS!!!! :D Really missed editing videos.
Freddie Mercury VS! Paul and Adam - Queen Tribute
Просмотров 79 тыс.8 лет назад
Freddie Mercury, Paul Rodgers, Adam Lambert. No competition, but just a bit of a nostalgiafest these videos are, huh?

Комментарии

  • @noeldelvalle9844
    @noeldelvalle9844 День назад

    Brian Johnson es mejor le dio vida al grupo yo soy de los que prefiero los cantantes originares pero en este caso es distinto el talento de Johnson es demasiado hay que ser himesto

  • @bayabooz4855
    @bayabooz4855 День назад

    0:40 sounds like SpongeBob

  • @claudimpascoal
    @claudimpascoal День назад

    I guess Brian much better!

  • @opusa
    @opusa 2 дня назад

    Dio

  • @_letstartariot
    @_letstartariot 4 дня назад

    Personally more a fan of Brian’s voice, but mad respect to the late Bon Scott.

  • @ninanightnurse
    @ninanightnurse 5 дней назад

    Love them both....but i think Ozzy is Black Sabbath and Dio is a different band...equally brilliant!❤

  • @timothywitte729
    @timothywitte729 7 дней назад

    I think Dennis Deyoung from styx said it best. Steve walsh is the best Steve Walsh and John Elefante is the best John Elefante and there both very talented and we have had the honor of hearing them both.

  • @JennylovesASMR
    @JennylovesASMR 7 дней назад

    I LOVE all three of them!!!! Just saw Kansas last night. Bucket list event for me🫶🏼 Ronnie did a bang up job!!

  • @davidagiel8130
    @davidagiel8130 19 дней назад

    This just highlights how unique Freddie's voice was.

  • @LS-zo9iw
    @LS-zo9iw 21 день назад

    band sounded great with either

  • @beesea1943
    @beesea1943 23 дня назад

    Both are legends

  • @deborahmoore3468
    @deborahmoore3468 24 дня назад

    John Elefante simply the best!!

  • @malcolmcard0zz0
    @malcolmcard0zz0 26 дней назад

    Parece que ambos vieram para o mundo pro vocal do AC/DC, perfeitos demais

  • @baton.ballet
    @baton.ballet 26 дней назад

    Brian por mucho, tiene mejor voz y más carisma

  • @lawrencetobin7565
    @lawrencetobin7565 27 дней назад

    John Elefante is my favorite by far

  • @onlinespecialpo8171
    @onlinespecialpo8171 Месяц назад

    Brian is more heavy if you want harder rock

  • @tammywest3063
    @tammywest3063 Месяц назад

    Steve will always be the lead in Kansas his talent and vocals are beyond compare.The enthusiam and sheer stamina to preform on stage with vocals right on mark is beyond comprehension to me. I could not carry even a note much less deliver an amazing concert. Steve gave us as his fans ALL and I do mean ALL. I'm sure this is one of the reasons he has sufferd vocally. He brought it and delivered everytime, and in rare occasions when he performs still does. John is an amazing talent in his own right. Steve would be a hard act to follow . Kinda like Steve Perry in Journey. Amazing job but not the same. Steve , Robby, Kerry , Phil, Dave and Rich You all deserve to be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ! Kansas thank you for your contribution to Rock music !

  • @brianandrea3249
    @brianandrea3249 Месяц назад

    I’m kinda hoping for the day when Al will get Bons voice and style and delivery in to the Johnson tracks. They will be different. Will they be better…well that’s subjective, but they will still be great.

  • @brianandrea3249
    @brianandrea3249 Месяц назад

    Bon for me. He had such charisma and theater about him. He used his voice to tell his wild stories. Johnson is great but he hasn’t connected with me like Bon.

  • @anul6801
    @anul6801 Месяц назад

    Bon Scott. Enough said.

  • @aeroenzo
    @aeroenzo Месяц назад

    Still blows me away how they lucked out enough to find a replacement with a VERY similar voice.. especially considering it was their vocals that made them iconic.

  • @Delmonaco1969
    @Delmonaco1969 Месяц назад

    Walsh with "Dust in the Wind" and Elefante with "Play the Game tonight".

  • @jerrymoore1051
    @jerrymoore1051 Месяц назад

    My two favorite Kansas albums each have Steve and John. "Somewhere To Elsewhere" and "Vinyl Confessions".

  • @zildaramos-mg2tz
    @zildaramos-mg2tz Месяц назад

    Amoooo ACDC com os dois... perfeitos 👏👏👏👏👏☀️

  • @beatzone700
    @beatzone700 Месяц назад

    I didn't even knew that there was 2 singers

    • @LostHorizons0
      @LostHorizons0 Месяц назад

      Lol they look / dress and sound exactly the same might as well be

  • @cervabike
    @cervabike 2 месяца назад

    3 best albuns of ACDC for me 1 Back in Black 2 For those about to rock 3 Highway to hell

  • @mikeking8699
    @mikeking8699 2 месяца назад

    None of them could touch Steve Walsh in his prime

  • @HondaRcvRacingTeam
    @HondaRcvRacingTeam 2 месяца назад

    Bon Scott Win 🏆

  • @liamphillips7315
    @liamphillips7315 2 месяца назад

    They're both great! But, hey...only one of them sang while simultaneously doing bouncing aerobics! Lol 🤟

  • @vincentsimon4037
    @vincentsimon4037 2 месяца назад

    Great vocals between all three but Steve Walsh has that extra magic in his soul and voice! Let's get KANSAS in the R&R Hall of Fame! There's no reason why they shouldn't have been inducted 20 years ago!

  • @heinzkoppel1688
    @heinzkoppel1688 2 месяца назад

    Brian is way better 🤘🏻

  • @matthewdepaz3723
    @matthewdepaz3723 2 месяца назад

    Brian is just a more talented singer. The power he can bring out isnt comparable to this dude Ronald. Obviously brian was inspired by him but he clearly had more skill as a singer, it's okay. But it's silly to think ACDC would be remotely as popular without Brian, this man's unique voice put this band on the map.

  • @extremelifeandlarydean1894
    @extremelifeandlarydean1894 2 месяца назад

    All great, for sure! But, for me John Elefante has the strongest voice and is the greatest singer of all time!

  • @SmartWentCrazy
    @SmartWentCrazy 2 месяца назад

    Johnson gives me more of a Bruce Springsteen vibe, while Bon gives a Lemmy Kilmister.

  • @GuillermoVaccarezza
    @GuillermoVaccarezza 2 месяца назад

    Both amazing... I would just say that Bon had a little more dimension in his vocal timbre

  • @jmen011
    @jmen011 3 месяца назад

    Brian tries to be Ac/Dc with the husk in hos voice where Bon is a god of a rock voice naturally Brian is a 1 in a million chance of that voice fitting with them and both are gods now Lets go Akka Dakka

  • @shaxshaw
    @shaxshaw 3 месяца назад

    Wish they were together

  • @викториявасильковская-х2э

    bon scott leader

  • @aalfonso1981
    @aalfonso1981 3 месяца назад

    In terms of Technicality I'd say Dio, but in terms of which voice is more recognizable it's Ozzy by far.

  • @Mauricio-Moreno-Rico
    @Mauricio-Moreno-Rico 3 месяца назад

    Dave Evans Is the Best🤘😎

  • @Scottyman99
    @Scottyman99 3 месяца назад

    Crazy how similar Steve and John sound. BUT, John has something that I find more pleasing to my ears. Corridors!

  • @VoyageOne1
    @VoyageOne1 3 месяца назад

    Bon had better lyrics. Brian sounds like he's doing an impression of Jimmy Barnes

  • @Kritikateur
    @Kritikateur 3 месяца назад

    .....There is no competition in Arts. Competitions belong to Sports, full stop! I can say that these two Fantastic Singers and Musicians, belong to another league of Singers, also because Kansas belong to another league of Bands. God bless them both because their contributions to the world of Arts and Music, made happy and inspired millions of people. Love them both...and Wish them a very Happy Life. Carus Alambra🙂👍

  • @reneegibb6758
    @reneegibb6758 3 месяца назад

    I like Bon Scott,but my favourite is Brian Johnson ❤

  • @texaninalabama127
    @texaninalabama127 3 месяца назад

    John Elefante was the lead singer of Kansas for 3-4 years 40 years ago. Steve was an original member with an amazing voice that helped revolutionize progressive rock. Elefante is trying to stay relevant based on what he did for a few years decades ago.

  • @eduardosaldana2925
    @eduardosaldana2925 3 месяца назад

    John Elefante is an awsome singer once you hear them live, don´t get confused, nobody replaces the original, but some singers really kick it out of the place.

  • @marioamador641
    @marioamador641 4 месяца назад

    Hermosas las 2 voces

  • @profeh3346
    @profeh3346 4 месяца назад

    John Elegante’s voice has aged much better. It’s tough to choose when they were both in their 20s - very talented and both possess a richness and strength of voice for Kansas. ❤

  • @soulguardian.6203
    @soulguardian.6203 4 месяца назад

    Bon, because he had a much better voice. I can't stand brian. He sounds like an old woman screaming.

  • @crisace
    @crisace 4 месяца назад

    Both won, great voices and very similar!