Видео

I didn't get on well with Vicki. Nor Dodo. They were of the same personality. They were just.. there. To fit a gap of "youngster" without any rebellion. I hated how Ian & Barbara were side-tracked, often coupled as a double act, just so Vicki could have the Doctor protect her. I found her annoying, & she really couldn't act to save England. That stupid laugh she gives in the Chase as Ian pulls out the ring from the ground... grrrr... lol Each to their own though.

Really enjoyed the video, but I would like to mount something of a defence for Linx as a villain. I agree that the robot he constructs is pretty rubbish. But to be fair, there are loads of rubbish robots in Doctor Who. The difference is that the rubbish robots are usually quite cute so the audience cuts them some slack (chumbilees, war machines, quarks). The gaps in his plan aren't that much worse than the plotting by the Cybermen in Wheel in Space, or the Daleks in the Dalek Invasion of Earth. I see Invasion of Time as a tragedy, rather than a farce. It lowered the standard for Sontarans and Time Lords alike, gave Leela a rubbish companion exit and Gallifrey lost a lot of it's mysticism (though this was not the only serial to do such damage). Maybe there's a parallel universe where Invasion of Time was made properly; the Time Lords were still at the height of their pomp; the Sontarans invaded and successfully mounted a convincing challenge; the Vardans were a bit more convincing, but were dispatched by the end of episode 2; Leela sacrifices herself in the final struggle and we get an effective companion departure (this was how Louise Jameson wanted Leela to exit the show); and instead of running round and round the Tardis, perhaps the Sontarans could pursue the Doctor in the Matrix and we could get something more akin to the deadly assassin? Maybe some die hard fan with good writing skills is working on an utterly unauthorised piece of fan fiction that will elevate the original material? Maybe... maybe...

Yes the Chase was the best lol!

Series 24 is alright but it feels like it was trying way too hard to appeal to kids. The last 2 series are much better and Sylvester McCoy is one of my favourite Doctors along with Patrick Troughton and Tom Baker.

The biggest tragedy is that DW does HOMAGE BRILLIANTLY in it's good eras when everybody knows what they're doing (Robert Holmes stories always a good example). Here the influences are ruined and wasted - even the in jokes don't work (not just about Mel/Bonnie's weight but also the colours and archetypes of the Kangs are the main political parties). You could have more fun and get the same gist reading High Rise by JG Ballard whilst zapping between Question Time and Runaway (the Tom Selleck SF(ish) film which I presume was the inspiration for the robots and almost shows how good a Hollywood version of Wyatt's script would be in the right hands).

We need to start petitioning now for Randy to be the next Doctor.

Perfect! 😄

As both a Whovian and fan of Randy Feltface; this is a surprise for sure but a welcome one!

69th like here

This is such a specific intersection of fandoms Love it

Matt Smith had his knob out in front of Randy

Absolutely class!

Lmao this is gold 😂

There’s no such thing as fanwank, it’s called continuity

The Sea Devils: you just hate what everyone likes about Doctor Who

2:05 so rose it like a puppy and the doctor is the owner of the puppy's grandfather?

I feel like rose was much smarter in series 1,in series 2 the 10th doctor and rose seem to be having so much fun together that they turn into giggling idiots and seem to be completely oblivious to any consequences they might have caused which doom's them in the end,no pun intended

Tooth and Claw's what turned me off 10 and Rose. They gave off a kind of popular kids in-joke, we know something you don't know, arrogant, exclusionary type vibe that irked me. That and the portion of the fandom that were shipping them hard. Call me a prude, but I like my Doctor-companion relationship to be a platonic one. Having said all that, I certainly don't HATE 10&Rose.

90% of the time the dynamic between 10 and Rose didn't bother me. I just found it stupid that Rose fell in love with the Doctor.

I do like that the show acknowledges their romance is flawed from the start: - Ten explains to her in School Reunion that they can never be together forever even if they wanted to because she's a 20 year old human and he's a quasi-immortal alien, and that is the curse he has to live with - In The Impossible Planet we see that unlike Rose, Ten can't stand a domestic life so they can't settle down - Tooth and Claw shows that Rose is starting to adapt some of Ten's fascinations with danger, seeing it as excitement instead, which puts her at constant risk with him - Doomsday has Rose so scared that she's desperate to stay with him forever, and in that rush to be there with him they got separated for good

I loved them when it aired and now I can't handle it. Each to their own - even hopefully one day on RUclips - don't do twitter 'x; etc...

I don’t hate anyone with Ten. Because for me David Tennant IS the Doctor. And I love him with anyone. She’s not my favorite companion of his (DonnaDonnaDonnaDonnaDonnaDonna), she’s not my least favourite. They had good episodes and I like them. No hate whatsoever. Simply not my favourite.

I loved Rose and 10 together. I agree seeing them in a state of grace it made the finale all the more painful. That being said, the way their relationship was written has issues and wasn't perfect like rose and 9. 10 clearly had massive comittment and emotional availability issues, and it seemed like in School renunion that was going to be his arc. Then what did he do in the season finale, he sent rose away without as much as a goodbye and got angry when she said she was never going to leave him. Rose had her problems too. She seemingly was losing touch with her humanity and becoming too much like the doctor, picking up his bad traits. She was arguably losing herself in the relationship. This was mentioned but it never led to any consequences.

I always thought 10 and rose had a childhood friend grown up mechanic in where they just acted as good friends rather than the two loving eachother. Idk i thought that was better

While I will admit that my opinion on the series as a whole probably shapes my view of this relationship (the series is bad) I do have reasons to dislike this relationship that isn't what you listed. I think the writing of both Ten and Rose are just terrible in this series and it gets worse when they are together. I really like Rose's character in Series 1, but she feels like a worse written character in Series 2, she's somehow less mature than she was in the first series and acts kind of dumb at times. When they're together it feels like the worst qualities of them are on full display, and I get that that's kind of the point but it just makes me really annoyed with both characters, especially Rose.

oo congrats on 1k subs!!

I like them, I think the relationship is an interesting direction for Doctor Who to go, and makes sense for the characters. Did it get overplayed sometimes? Yes, totally. But the core idea and themes the relationship explores (immortality, humanity, etc) are really important for 10's character arc.

At this point I don’t think there’s an actual Doctor Who hot take (or for any franchise) because social media gives a platform for any opinion to be voiced. And you’ll see it whether you want to or not

My thoughts on Series 7?: . Asylum of the Daleks is an utter piece of garbage . Dinosaurs on a Spaceship is harmless fun . A Town Called Mercy is a nice cheesy western . The Power of Three would be a decent experiment Ep if it wasn’t for the ending . The Angels take Manhattan is dull bar the ending . The Snowmen is dull as hell . The Bells of Saint John is…boring . The Rings of Akhaten should be okay is somehow always boring to watch (bar the speech) . Cold War is a good monster runaround . Hide is fine, but could’ve been scarier . Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS is really crap . The Crimson Horror is a story I like but most people don’t . Nightmare in Silver is the definition of death by a thousand paper cuts . The Name of the Doctor…Doesn’t even have an ending… Yeah, pretty bad series

With a lot of the really hated stuff from the show (with the exception of the Chibnall era) I always found it more weak than anything, not these terrible mistakes. Yeah some stuff sucked and I knew that, but I was surprised at how much people really hated this stuff because I always found it really interesting. Got let down a couple times and never saw it as perfect, but people turned out to be super critical of all that stuff once I got into the online discourse. Like, I liked Kill The Moon and people despise it. I thought it was a very interesting episode with a convoluted ending. But people fucking hate it and I didn’t get that until I went online. That was the same with a lot of stuff really, stuff I found mildly to pretty dissapointing speedbumps in a fun show turned out to be stuff the fandom really trashed and maybe that’s because they were thinking more critical of it than me (That’s it) but I always found it interesting. Because while I found 7B kinda weak I never hated it like everyone else seemed to. TLDR; Fans hate stuff better than casual fans.

I just don’t like the Doctor being in a relationship with their companions. It feels like a power imbalance. River and Rogue are way better ships purely because they’re on more equal footing with the Doctor.

As a Mind Robber fan, it's more of a rant about Doctor Who being too repetitive and lacking imagination/creativity.

10 n rose are the best tardis team ever❤️

I used to think I hated 10, however in hindsight I realised my problem was more the fan/BTS overreaction to him, the whole "Tennant or nothing" mindset which is why I find him so overrated. It's a similar issue that 70s Who, being the most popular often leads to a degree of superiority which makes me less inclined to like these eras, especially I'm someone who routes for underdogs.

For me it wasn't that they were static-y (I didn't like it but I can understand how they got there in their arcs). I found that they'd become rather arrogant and unlikeable in their adventures, so full of themselves. But unlike Twelve and Clara, the narrative doesn't call this out and frames them as being just so cute together. And even if this was the point to set up "Doomsday", it doesn't mean I have to like it.

My fan edit of Rose dying in Doomsday was purely related to the fact that she said she died, and then didn't... So I just made it happen. It wasn't a hatred for 10/Rose.

Correction: Hating Ten and Rose is very much an unpopular opinion. However, disliking Ten and Rose is not an unpopular opinion. Everyone has the right to like/dislike any Doctor, any companion and any team up - but hating is definitely the wrong approach.

Bruh... Rose and ten were barely hated. People hated Clara and 11 so much more even though they were the best companion and doctor by faaaar. Also season 2 was awesome. Season 3 was the worst out of the first 9, after that though season 3 was great. (Season 10 onwards got worse, I enjoyed season 9 a lot and then it went downhill from there. Definitely not as good as the first 9)

Hope you'll have a good day

you dont go over it because its mean and dumb to say, but im mean and say dumb things so i will- a lot of doctor who fans dont like it because its playing doctor who straight as a romcoms, and a lot of nerd think of romcoms as, like, below them, or whatever. not just not liking the genre, but thinking its lesser art than complicated scifi like my beloved doctor who so how dare russel t davies kill the show like this

I just… liked the 9/Rose chemistry more than 10/Rose. That’s it; no biggie.

I think Ten and Rose exacerbate each other's worst impulses, while Nine and Rose acted as a brake to each other's worst impulses. Ten also was quite reckless with Rose, pretty much abandoning her for Reinette an episode after her confidence in their relationship was shaken by their meeting Sarah Jane and also one episode after he had all but promised he would never abandon her, not her. We see Rose take the Reinette situation pretty well, but we also see her becoming more jealous; when they are on the parallel Earth, she is bothered that he knows the name of a server he's gotten information from -- while they are undercover as servers to, um, get information. In the last episode of the season/series, he plans to send her off to the parallel Earth and seems perfectly unbothered with it. It's only a problem for him because she comes back, refusing it, and then is lost accidentally. But it's exactly what he planned for her anyway. I'm fine with a happy couple or a prickly couple -- that doesn't matter to me. I do prefer Nine and Rose, and Martha and Ten, to Ten and Rose, but that doesn't mean this wasn't an interesting trajectory.

I'm among those who will defend Ten and Rose, in fact, aside from Ten and Donna, Ten and Rose were my personal favorite TARDIS pairing of RTD's early era. I thought the two were adorable together...... then again it could be just my personal bias from watching the MLP parody fan audios featuring Doctor Whooves and Derpy (Which is what MLP's version of said paring was, and later became Canon in MLP). MLP, specifically all of the Doctor Who parodies and fan art, is what got me into Doctor Who ;).

The Doctor in Classic Who would never flirt with people and certainly not someone who’s much lower down in the evolutionary scale. I can’t stand the 10th Doctor as he’s too OTT and that so called cockney accent is so annoying. Christopher Eccleston was a much better actor and my favourite Peter Capaldi is channeling the Classic vibe by making the Doctor more aloof, unpredictable and alien. Now that RTD is back the Doctor is yet again more humanised and flirtatious and it’s awful and drags the show down to a more soap opera level.

I think the Ten/Rose dynamic hinted at in The Impossible Planet is really interesting: he does love her in his own way, but not the way she wants him to. Of course, Doomsday completely undermines that interpretation, and Journey’s End….no.

I think the bigger issue isn’t they get along too well or too cutie, but the Doctor 900 year old person here is in love with a teenage girl. I’m not against the Doctor finding love or being with someone younger (kind of to in most cases) but that Rose barely out of high school. That’s taking it too far. 😵‍💫

I think a further distinction between 1/2 and 8/9 is that 12 and Clara are, throughout S9, thorny, difficult people. Even if they aren't constantly at odds with each other, they're still deeply uncomfortable with the world around them, often to the point of outright hostility. This isn't _really_ the case in S2, 10 and Rose are, well, happy. Are they always perfectly content? No, of course not. But their default state of being is a sort of satisfaction and a love for life that you just don't see with 12Clara, or with 9Rose. Now, this raises the question, why do people dislike this? Is it because people dislike seeing others as happy in their default state? I mean, we're Doctor Who fans, it stands to reason that jealousy here would be plausible. Or a lack of dramatic stakes - even as conflict is made external in both, there's just less opportunity for characterization when one is happy by default? Maybe. I dunno. A third option, and one I think that's plausible here as well, is that it rings hollow. 9 and Rose weren't happy people. Rose wasn't happy with her life. 9 certainly wasn't. So it just seems cheap and implausible that all of a sudden the two of them are happy, content, when they're together. That's not how things work. You don't magically become happy when you're with someone. So it just feels fake in a way that S8/9 doesn't.

gagged at the eruditorum press cameo

I really dislike Tennant. I never liked 10. Rose is okey. For me Rose is just a normal young adult confused with her feelings and sparkles in her eyes. 10 is just an arsehole. Like constantly... The worst is that I loved loved loved Eccleston. I have ptsd. I find him so relatable. But not only that. He is an excellent actor. Tennant... Blegh! 🤢

I just find them irritatingly cutesy a lot of the time and also there's definitely some retreospective dislike for just how much 10 is angsting after Rose in series 3 at the expense of best companion Martha and how she keeps creeping into series 4 (although I think that series definitely handles Rose a lot better).