Видео

Why such slow?

Zombies version

His interpretation is innovative

Chopins music has many possibilities That is why it is great in human history

How is this playing of the opening of the first movement even remotely Allegro maestoso? This is such a mis-reading of Chopin's instructions and obvious intent.

Profoundly fractured and disjunct. Oddly compelling and simultaneously deeply unsatisfying. Curious that he has the sort of temerity to perform this way, as his playing has become wildly self indulgent.

the extreme overdotting in the final climax is interesting because i dont actually like it. but now everything else sounds wrong

i find that ivo can sap the sweetness from chopin-which is not necessarily a bad thing, since there are many renditions ou there that put one in a diabetic coma. He brings danger and surprise to the piece, which makes me listen more closely - definitely not like listening to a top 40 type chopin anymoee. I can understand how some , maybe many, folks wouldnt like it. I do

Hand downs the best rendition of this piece I’ve heard!

My word. This is something.

The Nureyev of the piano - at times the Nijinsky of the piano - leaves nothing to chance, and the world of Music is the better for him! How he transcends! Beautiful!

I am riveted by this. Pogorelich adds to the monument of every work he plays to make even more monumental the scope of Music itself, and this regardless of any pre-conceived ideas or conceptions, which can only serve as misconceptions within the broader scheme of more spiritual and aesthetically satisfying things. One thing I know for sure the world of the piano is the better for him having been part of it!

The body of sound behind every note he plays, within every measure of the music, is the very stuff of fantasy itself. Regardless of one's conditioning, and how the world has come to perceive Chopin's Fantasie in F minor to the exclusion of bold and new ideas, this performance is extraordinary to me. Almost utterly cerebral in his approach, Pogorelich digs deep to define the difference between playing the piano and c resting Music as an extension of the source. But then, I have always been one to champion him, even at his most eccentric - and this is no exception! - that when thinking outside the square of any creative endeavor, one ultimately comes to realize that there is no square but for the boundaries we place upon Art as a living thing. This is genius at work, make no mistake about it!

I find it a bit slow. Does anyone agree with me?

BELLO..ARQUITECTURA Y TUTO..GRAXIEEE MONSEÑOR ❤❤❤❤

Bravo!! The best pianist in the word, la mejor interpretación de esta obra!

I really don't like this interpretation. Every line is being exaggerated to the point that the music is not flowing. For music to be touching and expressive, phrasing needs to be subtle, with urgency and forward momentum and rhythm. Pogorelich's playing is complete opposite. For example, try listen to 9:20-9:40 and compare with Rubinstein and you will get what I mean.

Engelsmusik

Lowi komentari da se izbriwat od mojov tel.bez razlika koj gi napiwal

❤❤this sonata is a "living entity" on the Buddhic plane sphere of our planetary scheme, known as the Cosmic Physical Plane. This composition, being a living entity, separate from Chopins creation on paper, or the myriads of pianists varied interpretations over a 100 year history, or even what we consider IPs interpretation of the Sonata at any given point in his career, has a MUSICAL LIFE OF ITS OWN. This musical entity on its own Buddhic Plane, inspires a performing artist to perceive its own spirit as it chooses. Only a rare few pianists can grasp, capture and hear this Musical Entity called the Chopin Sonata #3 actually as it is on the zBuddhic Plane. Rarely, if ever, can humans recognize this musical entity and allow this entity to speak its musical thoughts via the artistry of a very gifted performer. ❤❤❤❤

한국인이세요?

This is beautiful, thanks for uploading.

Maravilloso gracias graxieee SIEMPRE MAESTRO..

I was there at this recital, he is one of the greatest pianists of all time.

I'm seeing sounds and smelling colours

Amazing !

Two ads in the middle of the barcarolle. Nice...

If Pogo played any slower, his repertoire would be unrecognizable (particularly by the composers)

ponderously slow (as Ivo is always inclined to do just for the sake of being different). Highly doubtful that Chopin wanted it this slow!

This is IMHO one of the most important pianists/artists of our time. His uniqueness,sincerity, creativity ,expressivity, skill etc. is tremendously powerful IF his listeners can shed their preconceived notions as to HOW a piece of great music should be played and interpreted . Standardization, traditional interpretation is not something he strives for, obviously! He is the kind of artist who can keep the classics alive and interesting in our time . Entertaining isn't his priority. His feel and love for what he plays is far deeper than phoney facial expressions and such antics. Look elsewhere for such things . Instead, be open to rediscovery of great intense music. The only objection I personally have is that , even though art like this transcends politics, I would love to see him play in countries that aren't oppressive to people as are communist countries like China. It would be wonderful if he'd come to the USA ,Canada etc. instead. May pogorelich continue a long time to play and enrich the world of music!

A slow motion abortion.

Magical… it has the power to transport one.. this is real music making! ❤❤

Is it at x0.5?

A great example of a practical refutation of the usual professional haters. Without intending to be exhaustive, but his control such as the pianissimo bombs at 3:00 or especially 6:29 and how he introduces and embeds them should be enough to remind anyone with ears to hear of what music can be about but far too seldom is.

Gospodine Ivo, Vi zaista divno svirate.Imam vise asocijacija ali sada je duboka noc i nije moguce pisati asocijacije U svakom slicaju Vi svirate divno klavir. 🕊🌸🌸🌸💞🕊

One of the only two geniuses remaining in the piano world. The other is Sokolov.

meni se ne svidja, presporo i nejednoliko, kao sto treba za jednu uspavanku

Larghissimo moriendo is what Chopin wrote for tempo right?

Truly wonderful! It’s a great pity there are not so many video recordings of current Maestro’s playing.

"I want to remove the sugar from Chopin's music. To free his music from bad taste and mistaken traditions". French radio interview 10/14/23

Tragic decline

ne svidja mi se ova interpretacija, nije to chopin

如今他这般沉重的触键／速度／表达风格，演绎这类肖邦晚年暮气心态的作品，倒是有种误打误撞的搭配

20 minutes for Polonaise Fantaisie ? lol

Jako lijepo,suptilno.👏👏

I just made a tutorial for this piece with MIDI, music score and everything you need to know about the piece. You can also check out some beautiful art of Chopin. Check it out here! ruclips.net/video/DAlaq6l0WcA/видео.html&ab_channel=TheRomanticCurator I also do requests!

感谢UP！

我去的西安场，自己录的音质特别差（）

Less eccentric than his other performances of recent vintage (i.e. the past 25 years or so!). It basically falls within the realm of "normal" interpretive choices, though with quite a bit of freedom. The long, drawn-out phrasing isn't unsuited to the lyricism of the piece. Also, not "texturally tortured", as his performances can be when he is at his most eccentric. FYI, it's a big, "circle in the round"-type stage, and a very reverberant hall, of a dimension more suitable to orchestral concerts, so that explains much of the acoustical quality of the recording. I've recorded concerts on my phone in this hall too, and have heard Pogorelich play there before - though I can't remember if I recorded the Pogorelich concert I heard there or not. ;-)

A rather enjoyable recital! Beautifully played!