- Видео 3
- Просмотров 23 451
Glasgow Tactical Feminists (GTF)
Великобритания
Добавлен 11 апр 2023
Website and shop: glasgsowtacticalfeminists.com
Fighting for the rights we have, the ones we have lost and the ones we are yet to gain.
Fighting for the rights we have, the ones we have lost and the ones we are yet to gain.
Glasgow Tactical Feminists Surrogacy Event - Anna Zobnina
Director of the European Network of Migrant women - Anna gives her views on the global commodification of women's bodies of which surrogacy is one part.
Просмотров: 227
Видео
"If you don't do it to puppies, you shouldn't do it to people" Elaine Miller on Surrogacy
Просмотров 3,9 тыс.Год назад
Elaine Miller talks about the physical and psychological effects on women of carrying children for 'commissioning parents', the effects on forced separation at birth and the long term effects on women's bodies from giving birth to and giving up babies.
"The Entitlement of these Men is beyond Belief" Julie Bindel on Surrogacy while visiting Glasgow
Просмотров 19 тыс.Год назад
Writer, journalist and feminist icon, Julie Bindel visited Glasgow for the Glasgow Tactical Feminists 'Surrogacy - Women speaking up' event on May 6th which was organised due to the proposed changes in the laws on surrogacy in Scotland and the rest of the UK. This is her take on the subject. juliebindel.substack.com/ bindelj GTFGla www.glasgowtacticalfeminists.com
Thank God there are women like you. Thank you as well. :)
We know, statistically, the effect of losing the concept of the father in society. If we lose the concept of mother, we are finished.
Put this woman in charge
Elaine is amazing
Every time I see a slightly sweaty, topless, homosexual male in a hospital bed clutching his newly purchased human baby to his non-mammary chest, while his partner beams gleefully bedside, it elicits a disgust response in me like few things I have ever experienced.
These men should get a life. They are male, and therefore cannot conceive or bear children. Best to adopt a child who already exists. How ironic that they should call Julie Bindel, who is herself a lesbian, homophobic.
Elaine miller is boudica.
Jennifer Lahl is a great woman to listen to in relation to the impact of this industry and how this impacts the birth mother and the child.
Love the message and love your gifted approach❤😂
Once during a high risk pregnancy while I had the ultrasound wand on my belly as I was fighting nausea my husband (God love him) said we're pregnant. Oh no. I'm pregnant. You are not pregnant. I'm the one with constant nausea and invasive medical procedures. You were just playing on your phone. Yeah he never said that again.
Motherhood is just not seen as important and vital as it is anymore. It's comodified in surrogacy and daycare centers.
Completely agree with all of this. As a gay man I always thought one of the few bonuses was that I was never expected to have children, but now you have all this terrible surrogacy which isn’t victimless. If you really want children for the right reasons then you should adopt a child who already needs loving parents and has been let down.
She has a very strange view of the world.
Howso?
i’d like to see jordon peterson speak with Julie - he needs straightening out on a few things.
💔
So sobering. I read a fictionalised account of surrogacy farms in India by Kishwar Desai, hair raising but had no idea about the UK or richer countries. Plus I did not know how separation from their mothers body affects children.
Brilliant!! An amazing woman doing extraordinary work - thank you for this talk!
THIS WAS AN AMAZING VIDEO AND SHE WAS AMAZING !! THIS I KNOW , BABIES HEADS ARE GETTING TO LARGE NOW !WHY? DNK! BUT THEY ARE , IN ANTHROPOLGY A THEORY IS THAT THE NEANATHALS BECAME EXTINCT AS THE BABIES HEADS GOT SO BIG IT WOULD KILL THE MOTHER AND NO ONE KEEPS A BABY WITH THE MOTHER DEAD !! IT IS BECOMING A PROBLEM BUT NO MAN DOCTOR , AND THAT IS AN OXYMORON MAN DOCTOR ! BUT THE HEADS ARE GETTING TOO LARGE AND IS CASUSING PROBLEMS AND NO ONE KNOWS WHY? IS THE BRAIN GETTING LARGER, CONSIDERING HUMANS AND HOW NOT NORMAL THEY ARE ANYWAY , I DOUBT THIS IS THE PROBLEM AS THE IQ;S ARE GETTING SO LOW !
an excellent video and an excellent talk - thanks very much.
It's not just the word mother, the words father and children, have gone out of fashion as well. As a maths tutor, I noticed people looking at me funny every time I said the word children. I had to go along with it. Now I don't say children I say students instead.
What I want to know: imagine, you are a child with two loving parents from a surrogate mother. How would you listen to a rant like this?
Rant???? So Julie Bindel does not have the right to express her opinion and stand up for the economically marginalised and underprivileged women who are typically shoehorned into surrogacy by uncompromising circumstances. It might upset the (gay or straight) rich, white men who purchase their services. And yes, Julie is a thousand times right to see the obvious parallels with prostitution.
Very enlightening. Not much different to trafficking. Thank you Julie
What is a woman?
I doubt if Julie Bindel passes LOL.
An adult human female. Glad to clear that up for you
Your mum
@@ouwebrood497 Why? Because she is an older, post menopausal woman; because she is not young, fertile and slim; because she is a lesbian, or because she dares to speak truths you do not countenance?
What a wonderful talk.
So my friends did this using other peoples embryos which were implanted so it wasn’t actually her baby she was growing. And in the U.K. it’s illegal to perform surrogacy in exchange for money. You are misrepresenting this.
I understand that it's an issue but how to stop it? Isn't it better to decriminalize it and regulate it to better care for the women involved than to make it illegal and have these women fall victim to criminal organizations?
I had no idea 😢
"F*ck them all" - no more words needed. I can't think of any other subject where news coverag and the reality (as described by Julie) are in such stark contrast..
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
Good thing that TRUE lesbians are disappearing. Good bye. Now, gay men have to deal with these lesbian-identifying homophobes trying to inject their rotten personalities in our movement.
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
@@Diamondsparkle788Another good thing is TERDs not having balls to speak their minds outside the internet since you have no way to prove the crap that comes out of your mouths.
And women who kill their babies and call it "abortion" should be punished. I would personally play soccer with their heads.
😂😂😂 this lady is a looney. Shut down the perm banks too huh. She not only wants to dictate who can reproduce but who can have sex as well. Good lady get over yourself
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
Thanks for posting this. I was at this event and Anna’s talk was so powerful and incisive. This needs to be shared far and wide
I am completely in support of surrogacy and IVF I don't agree with Julia here at all
Can we move from, the same old, same old. If this woman is a lesbian, why was that announced, do you realise what sort of a joke do you think you are? So if she advertises as being a lesbian, wtf is she doing talking about heterosexual women? No stop, Scotland, the blasphemy the laws,... The governance of Scotland is fascist. This issue deserves to be attacked by suitable organisations.
But is this not again taking away a womans power over her own body? AGAIN??
signing away your abortion rights for money is the opposite of empowering.
Always enjoy hearing what Julie has to say, I don't agree with everything she says but I 100% share her view on this topic.
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
It's important that the opportunistic eugenics in surrogacy is exposed. We are on a path to Gattaca and designer babies.
This is such an eye opener! Save women!
make it illegal. period
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
Adding this to my funny Playlist
What about kidney donation? Is THAT okay?
Not if it is always the poor and downtrodden who are 'obliged' by the system to give up one of their kidneys. What is NOT OK is the social and economic system that gives rise to this atrocity.
Fruitcake.
Who are you calling fruitcake? A woman who dislikes men for being gay will always be a c-word. C-word
Do people have the same energy towards lesbians that use sperms banks to have children? It's no different on my opinion.
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
I'm confused. Why would lesbians care about reproductive rights?
i dont know how to explain to you that you should care about other people
@@LightSpell28 carrying about people and telling people how to live their lives are two very different things. I care about people but the information I use to make decisions has more validity when it comes from the impacted group.
@@commonsense126 Have you actually listened to Julie's speech? She did research, she interviewed people involved (the people exploited in this business), she visited the places in question. She told several examples to illustrate her motives to be against surrogacy. You know, examples of the actual impacted group. You are free to disagree with her arguments and provide your own counter arguments, but saying that caring about people is not the same as telling them how to live their lives excludes the exploited people she is aiming to protect. Not sure how you're unable to understand that.
@@dvanaestcestica1135yes I listened to the entire speech. I've also listened to speeches from trans women telling me how females should behave. I reject there right to tell me a hetero biological female how I should live. I reject men who tell me how a female should live as well. They do not have the lived experiences that inform them about the context of my life. Further I did not find her research convincing. Talking with people is a good way to confirm a hypothesis. But then one must perform a broad study in a rigorous way and utilize the resulting statistics to inform a policy position.
@@commonsense126 I agree. Ample and thorough studies should be made and peer reviewed and they need to live up to the scientific consensus, which should then influence legislation. It takes will, funds and time to do that, but I'm sure it will happen at some point. On the other hand, the technological progress is fast and is going much ahead of legislation, and more and more means are available to those who can pay. Don't you think we as a society are moving too fast in certain directions and making legislations without said thorough studies? Could you share your ideas on how can we protect the vulnerable from being exploited? If statistics show that the vast majority of people using commercial (remunerated) surrogacy to have children are upper middle class and high class, while the vast majority of surrogacy providers are low-income, not to mention those from 3rd world countries, can you really say that they are not exploited and should be protected? Or are you claiming that the law should'nt infringe their right to be exploited? If a poor woman in Cambodia or anywhere really, even in the West, wants to rent out her biological resource (body) to incubate an unwanted child for a monetary compensation, because she has very few options to choose from in order to provide for her already born children, or to fund herself out of poverty through education or immigration, who are we to say she's being exploited by the rich who are taking the advantage of her unprivileged situation? Just trying to understand your point of view.
Do you consider the antics of Oli Locke and his husband to be racist? As the vast majority of surrogate mothers are poor foreigners and they speak of them as if the baby is nothing to do with the Mother and do not even consider the fact that women can and do still die from childbirth.... What can and should be done? I however am also opposed to lesbians planning to have families without a Father as recent decades have proved beyond doubt that Fathers are deeply necessary and society suffers without them as well as the child being deprived without their consent.
She's just angry man hating feminist, hypocrisy is their way.
My birthday was f***** up because it was on Coronation Day Love Julie and been following her for a few years and totally support her in issues such womens only spaces et al but i disagree that patriarchy exists in today's society (in the west anyway) However, i havent listen to this so here goes
What is the issue? Feminists didn't like gender roles so now they got what they wanted. Dress like the opposite sex. I didn't want things to go this way but feminists have themselves to blame
Toxic New Age Feminism///Toxic New Age Masculinity//time to go back to free range children//free range parents//not toxic helicoptor parents promoted by The New Age Occult/Cult !!!!
That was a wonderful talk. It told me so much about this sordid business. I'm 75 and a man and I defy anyone capable of walking upright and uttering sounds not to close to tears on hearing her closing comment regarding breast feeding and that poor woman.
It is a tad perverted two adult males adopting a baby.
@@Diamondsparkle788 It's a disgrace that society even allows it. It is, as you say, perverted.
@@Diamondsparkle788 I don't see what gayness has to do with it. It's just as bad when straight couples do it.
@@carolsimpson4422 Men are more sexually motivated than women. We don't want to have sex with babies. Some men do. As you would know.
@@Diamondsparkle788 They didn't want the baby to come out of a woman's vagina, as the vagina is "disgusting", so it had to be delivered by caesarian operation. The misogyny and entitlement of this posture is breathtaking. These men also failed to reflect that they both (probably) came into the world through their mothers' vaginas. What an interesting (and ironic!) perspective on their relationships to the women who gave birth to them.
Some of the issues apply to sperm donation too but because it’s a short period and does not pose risks the way bearing a child does we don’t think about it.
@@silentvoice4970 Its totally comparable. Why these fat lesbian monsters are trying to raise a kid without he or she knowing who their fathers are?
Thank you very much.