The Who View
The Who View
  • Видео 54
  • Просмотров 132 950
Discussing the Third Doctor's Dalek Stories | Are They Good?
The Third Doctor fought the Daleks three times on screen, but are these early 70s Dalek stories worth watching? Well in this video I'll be discussing all 3 & sharing my thoughts on all of them.
Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for the purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statue that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use."
Follow me on X:
twitter.com...
Просмотров: 3 569

Видео

Doctor Who: The War Games in Colour Trailer
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.28 дней назад
It is recommended to view this video with headphones on. The Second Doctor's final story is now in full colour & presented in the style of a modern epic Blockbuster! The TARDIS has arrived in a world of trench warfare, barbed wire, & poison gas: the Western Front, 1917, WW1. The Doctor & his companions are separated from their ship, captured & court-martialled. But all is not as it seems. The D...
Doctor Who: The War Games In Colour Review
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.Месяц назад
Exploring the second Doctor Who story to undergo the colourisation treatment: The War Games in Colour. This new version of the classic B&W ten episode story from 1969 has been newly reimagined into a cutdown 90 minute version, with updated sound effects, enhanced visuals, a complete new soundtrack & is now available in full colour. How does this new version compare to the orginal & is this new ...
The Best Stories Where The Doctor Loses
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.3 месяца назад
A video discussion of a selection of my 5 favourite DOCTOR WHO stories where The Doctor doesn't succeed in saving the day, leading to his ultimate failures. Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" f...
Doctor Who: The Claws of Axos Trailer
Просмотров 8474 месяца назад
It is recommended to view this video with headphones on. Doctor Who The Claws of Axos re-edited in the style of a modern day epic blockbuster. Disclaimer: I do not own any of the images/video clips or music contained in this video. Nor is this in anyway affiliated to the BBC. All clips contained in this video are owned by the BBC. This is a Fan-made trailer made for the purpose of entertainment...
Why Are The Cybermen Better In The 60s?
Просмотров 16 тыс.4 месяца назад
A video discussion on why I personally think the cybermen were better represented in the 1960's compared to any other decade of Doctor Who. Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for the purposes s...
The Fourth Doctor's Unseen Adventure | The Face of Evil Prequel
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Discussing when the fourth doctor first arrived on the planet Mordee, prior to The Face of Evil. What was this off-screen adventure like? Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for the purposes suc...
The Most Forgotten Companions In Doctor Who
Просмотров 9 тыс.5 месяцев назад
We all have our favourite companions but what about the companions that you often forget exist. I present my selection of what I think are the most forgotten Doctor Who companions. *This is not an objective list; this is just my own opinion, so be sure to tell me your picks. Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are ...
Daleks' Invasion Earth 2150 A.D. (1966) Review | A Worthy Follow Up?
Просмотров 10 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Peter Cushing's big screen return as Dr. Who in the second Dalek film: Daleks' Invasion Earth 2150 A.D. Doctor Who & his companions are transported into the future, only to discover that Earth has been invaded by the Daleks! How does this cinematic follow up compare to the first film? Let's find out. Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Phot...
Dr. Who & The Daleks (1965) Review | Better Than The Original!
Просмотров 12 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Doctor Who made its first ever jump to the big screen in 1965, staring Peter Cushing as the Doctor in Dr. who & the Daleks. Here's my viewe on what I thought of this often overlooked 60s sci-fi flick. Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips and photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyrigh...
Doctor Who Season 1 Tier Ranking
Просмотров 9367 месяцев назад
My complete ranking of every episode from Doctor Who Season 1 (series 14). Has my opinion changed on any of these episodes? Is this the worst season of the modern series so far? Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is ...
My Thoughts on The Pyramids of Mars - Tales of The Tardis Edition
Просмотров 2437 месяцев назад
An all new version of Doctor Who: The Pyramid of Mars has materialised in the form of Tales of the Tardis. Here's my quick thoughts about this new edition & how it compares to the original. Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, a...
Doctor Who: Empire of Death Review
Просмотров 4837 месяцев назад
My thoughts on the conclusion to Doctor Who season 1 (series 14). Did this stick the landing? Is this considered a top contender for being the best season finale ever? Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "...
Doctor Who: The Celestial Toymaker Animation Review
Просмотров 6 тыс.7 месяцев назад
The Toymaker's first adventure now newly animated, but does this animation do justice to the story & how does this compare to previous animations? Let's discuss it. The Doctor, Steven & Dodo have arrived in the realm of The Celestial Toymaker, a powerful godlike being that forces people into playing games for his own amusement. Now Steven & Dodo must play a series of highly dangerous games in o...
Doctor Who: The Legend of Ruby Sunday Review
Просмотров 6637 месяцев назад
My thoughts on the first part of the 2 part finale of Doctor Who season 1 (series 14). The one who waits is finally revealed! Fair Use Disclaimer: I do not own any pictures/videos contained within this video. Clips & Photos used in this video are owned by the BBC. "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for the purposes such as critici...
Doctor Who: Rogue Review
Просмотров 8507 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: Rogue Review
Doctor Who: Dot & Bubble Review
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: Dot & Bubble Review
Doctor Who: Destiny of The Daleks Trailer
Просмотров 2278 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: Destiny of The Daleks Trailer
Doctor Who: 73 Yards Review
Просмотров 7238 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: 73 Yards Review
Doctor Who: Boom Review
Просмотров 8018 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: Boom Review
Doctor Who: The Devil's Chord Review
Просмотров 8988 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: The Devil's Chord Review
Doctor Who: Space Babies Review
Просмотров 2938 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: Space Babies Review
Doctor Who: The Talons of Weng-Chiang Trailer
Просмотров 6649 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: The Talons of Weng-Chiang Trailer
Doctor Who Season 15 Blu-Ray Review
Просмотров 56910 месяцев назад
Doctor Who Season 15 Blu-Ray Review
Doctor Who: Horror of Fang Rock Trailer
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.11 месяцев назад
Doctor Who: Horror of Fang Rock Trailer
Doctor Who: The Daleks In Colour Review
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.Год назад
Doctor Who: The Daleks In Colour Review
Doctor Who: The Daleks Colourised Trailer
Просмотров 17 тыс.Год назад
Doctor Who: The Daleks Colourised Trailer
Doctor Who - The Church On Ruby Road Review
Просмотров 865Год назад
Doctor Who - The Church On Ruby Road Review
Doctor Who: The 60th Anniversary Specials Review
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.Год назад
Doctor Who: The 60th Anniversary Specials Review
Doctor Who: The Underwater Menace Animation Review
Просмотров 498Год назад
Doctor Who: The Underwater Menace Animation Review

Комментарии

  • @jacksugden8190
    @jacksugden8190 21 час назад

    I saw the two films when they first came out, the second film meant that Sugar Puffs had to finance it, hence the posters, the scene when when Wyler and Susan were in a van crashing to Daleks was a let down. Why?, just look at the Dalek prop bottoms that were hollowed out… Conway was played by the late Keith Marsh (1926 ‑ 2013), also played Jacko in the Thames Television Love Thy Neighbour tv series.

  • @Londonfogey
    @Londonfogey День назад

    'Yes but do I have the RIGHT to destroy the evil alien?'

  • @jacksugden8190
    @jacksugden8190 2 дня назад

    4:36 was composed by the late Malcolm Lockyer, Barry Grey did the Dalek City sound effects for both films, the late Bill McGufie wrote the score for Dr. Who & The Daleks.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 2 дня назад

      @jacksugden8190 That was my bad. Your correct Malcolm Lockyer wrote most of the music & Barry Grey contributed. it was also my understanding that Bill McGuffie wrote the music for the film's sequel, the Daleks invasion earth 2150ad.

  • @beedubs230
    @beedubs230 2 дня назад

    I can't imagine a less appealing approaching to animation. Cheap and utterly hideous.

  • @jkmac625
    @jkmac625 2 дня назад

    For me the most forgotten companion has to go to Kamelion. I was 10 years old when the final part of The King's Demons was broadcast on 16th March 1983. There was an 8 month gap before The Five Doctors was broadcast on 25th November which seemed a very long time when I was 10, a whole new school year had started, so plenty of time had passed to forget that Kamelion had joined the TARDIS crew. Planet of Fire Episode 1 was broadcast on 23rd February 1984, which makes the original gap between Kamelion's two stories almost a full year. No wonder he was forgotten.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 2 дня назад

      @@jkmac625 Kamelion was a very hollow companion 😆

  • @PaulGould-t7u
    @PaulGould-t7u 4 дня назад

    Not forgotten by me as I've both movies and I've only got the classic dr who's on dvd . Give the new show a wide birth up to season three and gave up. Who as lost it and less to be said for the classic dr who that there putting in colour as there cut to hell . And don't even make sense anymore i thought they was going to colour the full episodes boy was i wrong so stopped getting them . They have just killed dr who in my book what with the new show's and the so called full colour episodes BBC out to make money on a good old classic but sad monsters in every episode what ever happened to the time traveling classics can't BBC do them anymore without some bad CGI monsters having to be in them . And for what they did with the war games what was the point in colour if there going to just do that then keep them. And people go on about missing episodes ..

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 4 дня назад

      @PaulGould-t7u The new colour versions aren't going to be for everyone. We all have different tastes. 😉

  • @calvinkatt662
    @calvinkatt662 5 дней назад

    I have the same ranking. #1 Day, #2 Death, #3 Planet. I also feel like Planet was too long. I love Pertwee's era, but some of his 6 part stories feel like 4 part stories padded out to 6. I think that switching from three 6 part stories per series down to one 6 parter per series in Tom Baker's era was a good decision. That also left room for an additional story.

  • @PeterMcKeever-ib8jy
    @PeterMcKeever-ib8jy 6 дней назад

    They lost their magic in the 1970s. Moffat compounded the error by opening the suit and ruining the mystery.

  • @stephencrewes5773
    @stephencrewes5773 7 дней назад

    I got the impression they were decaying humanoids in a life support unit. Not a cyborg.

  • @intergalactic92
    @intergalactic92 8 дней назад

    I think you're overreacting. The original has a lot of filler that does not need to be there. Yes they overdo the flashbacks. Yes they overdo the music, but it’s fine for what it is. The fat has been trimmed out to tighten up the narrative. It’s interesting as a recap. Besides this is way better than the War Games in colour.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 8 дней назад

      @intergalactic92 I'm glad you liked the new version, but I disagree. The war Games in colour keeps more of the overall narrative intact. It removes mainly character stuff, whereas daleks in colour removes so much of the story, creating plot holes & the way scenes are edited together feel very choppy to me. It's an okay, heavily streamlined version of the original. But I do mainly watch them because not only do I get to see it in colour but It's also a new way of experiencing these stories.

  • @intergalactic92
    @intergalactic92 8 дней назад

    The only thing I don’t particularly like about the Silurians is that the ending feels like a bit of a cop out. The brigadier just destroys the base. He just does it. And it so quick and so easy, and so casually, you are left to wonder why he didn’t do it sooner. And I’ll be honest, I never felt like it was coming. The balance of power is never properly established. You never fell like the humans have the advantage or the power to just end it like that whenever they want. We're so used to the soldiers being utterly useless in these stories ("just once I would like a creature that isn’t immune to bullets") that the fact they can do this feels weird. Maybe it’s not helped by the fact I went in knowing that it was going to happen so there was no opportunity for me to be shoocked. It’s both one where the plot has been copied so many times, almost beat for beat in the sea devils and the hungry earth/cold blood, and so famous that it’s hard to go in spoiler free. So maybe I was expecting a bit more.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 8 дней назад

      @@intergalactic92 Doctor Who & The Silurians is a brilliant story exploring themes like the dangers of prejudicial view points of the indifferent as well as the destructive nature of humanity. But I think I have to disagree with you. In terms of the humans feeling weaker than the Silurians, yes you're right. From a physical & technological stand point the Silurians are stronger, but where humanity has the upper advantage is in their large numbers. But the story isn't too focused on power struggle. You mentioned cold blood / hungry earth. I saw that story before Silurians, & yes, it is very much a cutdown modern version that story. But Silurians has much more time to develop the tensions between the Doctor, the humans, & the Silurians. You really get to feel the weight of the choices the Doctor makes, as he's caught in the middle of both species at war, trying to prevent further violence without sacrificing his ideals. It's a story that was ahead of everything the show had done before. But I'm biased because its my favourite doctor who story. 😉

  • @intergalactic92
    @intergalactic92 8 дней назад

    80s Cybermen are my favourite villains, these were the ones I grew up watching. And I unironically love Attack of the Cybermen the most. Sure, the 60s is probably a stronger era overall, but I’ve only seen Tomb of the Cybermen so can’t fairly judge them all, but the overall feel of the 80s with their silver suits, and the fist clenching Leader, just hits me right in the nostalgia.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 8 дней назад

      @intergalactic92 I totally get it, Earthshock is a lot of fun & I have a sweet spot for attack of the Cybermen. Plus, David Banks is EXCELLENT!

  • @intergalactic92
    @intergalactic92 8 дней назад

    Katarina is interesting because she is the first companion death. The lack of appearances is what creates intrigue. It also highlights just how much of a toxic working environment the show had become at that time. Peter Purves has spoken about how difficult it was working on the show around that time, and how William Hartnell shielded all the guest-stars from the producers/directors etc, and the challenges of how they kept on hiring and then firing female actors for the female companion role (to hear him speak he doesn’t consider anyone, even Dodo, to be permanent companions during this time). Allegedly Katarina only became a companion in the first place because the higher ups wanted to get rid of Maureen O’Brien (Vicki). She would ask the writers questions about the plot and offer notes that rubbed them the wrong way (allegedly). It was clearly hastily done, in a story which pushed them towards introducing a character from Ancient Greece/troy, which clearly nobody had put any thought into the consequences of this, and when they realised it was too late. Now a better set of writers might have taken up the challenge of writing someone with a more primitive mindset to make it work (look at Leela for a great example of a primitive minded character) but not these writers. By all accounts The Dalek Masterplan is a needlessly complicated mess before you even consider the wild card of a tricky to write companion. I can understand why they took the quick and easy way out by unceremoniously killing her off, but I will always consider it cowardly. Edit: I am referring mostly to Dalek Masterplan's reputation. I obviously have not seen it, or have real opinions on it or Sara Kingdom (the episodes are lost and I’m too young to have seen it at the time).

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 8 дней назад

      @intergalactic92 Katarina was someone who was never going to work for the type of stories they were doing in the shows third season & moving forward. It's such a shame that so much of the story doesn't exist because there is some really dark stuff in it that I love, but there are moments where it has some pacing issues in the middle. This may be just me, though. I have only experienced this through a telesnap reconstruction, which is hard to get through when there aren't a lot of photos existing for most of season 3. Hopefully, it will get animated.

  • @dylanshadowstar9779
    @dylanshadowstar9779 11 дней назад

    To be the best part of these colourisations, is when they do the physical release, it comes with the original dvd too. Since older dvds are harder to come by, having basically a reprint is appropriated

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 11 дней назад

      @dylanshadowstar9779 I agree. It makes them a bit annoying knowing that I'll have to rebuy them again when the collection box set comes out. 😄

  • @The_Prydonian
    @The_Prydonian 13 дней назад

    Hey, can you please not use my Dalek renders in your thumbnail please? especially erasing my watermark and not giving any credit to begin with.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 13 дней назад

      @The_Prydonian yeah, no worries. I won't use them next time.

  • @matthewbolitho-jones
    @matthewbolitho-jones 13 дней назад

    I like Dr. Who & The Daleks

  • @matthewbolitho-jones
    @matthewbolitho-jones 13 дней назад

    I like Daleks' Invasion Earth 2150 A.D

  • @kerravon2527
    @kerravon2527 14 дней назад

    Great - nice summary. I'd heard somewhere that the script for Day of the Daleks originally wasn't a Dalek story, but they were shoehorned in by someone in the BBC. On the downside, you've made me feel very old as I experienced all of these initially through Target novelisations rather than dvd (though not quite as old as someone who saw them originally!).

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 14 дней назад

      @kerravon2527 You're right there. From what I've seen from documentaries, the daleks weren't in the script at all. According to Terrace Dicks, Barry Letts wanted to boost the shows ratings even further by having the daleks be in one of the stories that season. So Terrance Dicks chose louis Marks script, & volia we got Day of the daleks. That inclusion of the Daleks brought more viewers that season than the previous, so it absolutely paid off. BTW I'm sorry if I make you feel old. 😄

    • @kerravon2527
      @kerravon2527 14 дней назад

      @@thewhoview Very kind!

  • @benflay6038
    @benflay6038 14 дней назад

    Death my first vhs in 87 and Day of are brilliant special edition is good not keen on new series dalek voices improvement tho had the target books the storys characters and settings and Daleks cunning threat, by genesis its just Davros stories with Daleks

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 14 дней назад

      @benflay6038 that's awesome 👌 totally agree with you. From Genesis onwards, the daleks are very dependent on Davros.

    • @benflay6038
      @benflay6038 14 дней назад

      @thewhoview they turn up last episode genesis which fine as its there origin story but that's it until remeberance renegades supreme dalek is back

  • @markstramtrainbuscapades1729
    @markstramtrainbuscapades1729 14 дней назад

    Always wondered what happened to Kamelian when the Tardis was ripped apart in "Frontios!"

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 14 дней назад

      @@markstramtrainbuscapades1729 Maybe there's an off-screen adventure in between Frontios & Resurrection of the Daleks where the doctor left Kamelion behind on some planet & then remembers after Frontios & goes back for him. 🤣

  • @DarrenEden-ub4vj
    @DarrenEden-ub4vj 15 дней назад

    I have only seen the original. But I will say Jon Pertwee is and will always be my favorite Doctor.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 15 дней назад

      @@DarrenEden-ub4vj Pertwee was such a fantastic doctor.

  • @jkmac625
    @jkmac625 15 дней назад

    I'd say "Death to the Daleks" is my favourite, it was probably the first Jon Pertwee Dalek story I watched. It was the 90 minute compilation edit released by BBC Video. Looking at the release date my parents must have bought it for me to watch over the school summer holidays that year (1987). I think "Day of the Daleks" was also released as a 90 minute compilation by BBC Video the previous year but I probably didn't get them in release order back then. I didn't get to watch "Planet of the Daleks" until it was shown on BBC1 in November 1993. I think I've only seen the special edition of "Day" once (maybe twice) on DVD, but the new Dalek voices were a definite improvement over the original, and the new scenes were shot on 16mm film to keep in the style of the original so they seemed to blend in seamlessly. I started a re-watch on BBC iPlayer about 6 months ago but I started on the first Sarah Jane story so I've seen "Death" recently but not the other two.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 15 дней назад

      @jkmac625 that's really cool. They did a lot of those early releases on VHS as feature legnth versions.

  • @bkatbamna
    @bkatbamna 15 дней назад

    Death to The Daleks is one of my favorite Doctor Who stories. I love everything about it. I love how Galloway is paranoid of the Doctor(a natural reaction to how the team is being picked off one by one) and ends up being a hero at the end. I also like how he's uneasy with the Daleks killing off hostages but understands that they need to work with them to save millions of lives. The Day of The Daleks is also excellent. I suspect a young James Cameron may have watched it. Planet is a little padded but I love the message that The Doctor imparts to the team leader at the end to not make war sound like a grand adventure.

  • @mark-s
    @mark-s 15 дней назад

    The only 70s cybermen story was awful and apart from earthshock they didnt do well in the 80s. The 60s was best era for cybermen in fact i loved them all apart from the wheel in space which i found a drag to watch.

  • @markg6749
    @markg6749 16 дней назад

    Day and Planet are great!

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 15 дней назад

      @markg6749 both are a lot of fun.

  • @thethinkingcatakaneonormie3527
    @thethinkingcatakaneonormie3527 16 дней назад

    Best Dalek story is destiny of the Daleks but a close second is Planet of the Daleks

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 15 дней назад

      @thethinkingcatakaneonormie3527 Destiny of the daleks is an interesting choice. I've personally always found it to be the weakest dalek story of classic who.

  • @FlatCapWhovian1865
    @FlatCapWhovian1865 16 дней назад

    The Pertwee Dalek stories are my least favourite Dalek stories in classic who :(

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 16 дней назад

      @FlatCapWhovian1865 Hey, that's fine. we're all different. 😉

    • @FlatCapWhovian1865
      @FlatCapWhovian1865 16 дней назад

      @@thewhoview Agreed. Not sure what it is about the other two (if I did have to pick a favourite it would be Death to the Daleks) but the one I've just never got is Planet of the Daleks. Watching the documentaries on the DVD's growing up it was hailed as "The Daleks greatest hits!" and I've just never got the love for it? Virtually a repeat of the first Dalek story

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 16 дней назад

      @FlatCapWhovian1865 Yeah, I understand it does repeat almost every story beat of the daleks first story & uses other things like master plan as well. But death to the Daleks is a good pick. 😊

  • @damienkakoschke3099
    @damienkakoschke3099 16 дней назад

    There were 4 Jon Pertwee Dalek stories (also Frontier in Space). Anyway.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 16 дней назад

      @damienkakoschke3099 Yeah, I mentioned this in the video, that it is technically a dalek story, but the daleks aren't revealed until episode 6 of frontier & even then, they're only in it for 10-15 minutes & aren't the main focus of the story.

  • @tomhyde9938
    @tomhyde9938 16 дней назад

    Death and Day are great, Planet is such a drag.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 16 дней назад

      @tomhyde9938 planet of the daleks didn't need to be six episodes long, but it is a fun jungle run around & I agree with you Day & Death are fantastic.

  • @Thunderpuddle
    @Thunderpuddle 16 дней назад

    I love Death and Day, great stories and the first two I had on VHS. I enjoy Day with the updated effects.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 16 дней назад

      @Thunderpuddle that's really cool to hear. The special edition of day of the daleks is fantastic.

  • @brucebush5744
    @brucebush5744 17 дней назад

    Tricky choice. Now, I think that the politics and time travel paradox of Day make it the most accomplished story. But as a kid watching these, the adventure of Planet was a real favourite - and, of course, I had no idea that it was derivative of earlier stories. Pertwee very much “my doctor” and I’ll stick with my childhood preference for Planet.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 17 дней назад

      @brucebush5744 Day I think is the superior script. The ideas feel so far ahead of what the show was doing. Planet of the daleks is a lot of fun, so I understand. 😁

  • @petefischer3820
    @petefischer3820 17 дней назад

    Agreed.....special edition Day Of The Daleks is the best. Thank-you for the video.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 17 дней назад

      @petefischer3820 Thank you for watching & commenting. The special edition is probably my favourite classic story with new updated effects. It's such an awesome way to experience that story. 😊

  • @timothybarnett1006
    @timothybarnett1006 18 дней назад

    I appreciate Nicholas Briggs's voice work on the Special Edition but (slightly) annoyed that there isn't an original audio track available on the Blu Ray Special Edition version. The visual improvements really enhance the story and the flatness of the original Dalek voice work capture their boredom with years of the occupation and they'd really be happier shouting 'exterminate' trundling down corridors and shooting enemies rather than the drudgery of bureaucracy.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @timothybarnett1006 that would have been an interesting option to give to fans. Personally, I prefer the new voices, so much more menacing, but everyone is different. 😉

  • @justynmatlock184
    @justynmatlock184 18 дней назад

    My criteria for a 'Companion' is: Was in more than one story, and traveled with the Doctor. Ergo, sadly, Sara Kingdom doesn't qualify. Should she have been a companion is another matter, I certainly think she'd have been better than Dodo.

  • @AstraRandom
    @AstraRandom 18 дней назад

    I largely agree with everything here, Tenth Planet might be one of the best designs of the Cybermen, Tomb and Invasion are actually just masterpieces, the only other stories that have them at such an excellent level of menace and might is Earthshock, World enough and time/Doctor Falls and in my opinion also Attack of the Cybermen. Rise/Age of Steel are perfectly fine and workable it's a good reintroducing but until series 10 it's the only story that gets what the Cybermen are about instead of being just Robots or playing second fiddle like Death in Heaven which I also like but more because of 12/Missy

  • @AstraRandom
    @AstraRandom 18 дней назад

    Day wasn't my favourite, it's not bad but I just didn't completely vibe with it, Death is probably my favourite even though it's not perfect, and Planet was fine it's just Terry Nation reusing a bunch of ideas from his previous stories which are all fine it's enjoyable enough, but being 6 parts it drags on more than previous longer Dalek epics. I'm not even bothering placing Frontier in Space, which starts of with two much of shuffling Jo and 3 from prison cell to cell, picks up massively when the Master appears, and then the ending sadly let's it all down and the fact that Planet that carries directly on doesn't really address any of it saddens me

  • @robertbrown3413
    @robertbrown3413 18 дней назад

    The Daleks were attacked by a silver hoover pipe.

  • @simonclarke4574
    @simonclarke4574 18 дней назад

    Death to the Daleks was the start of the horror style Doctor Who that captured me as a very young boy. The Exxilons were terrifying.. especially their chanting .. the music ..the pyramid maze with skeletons in it. Even the maze floor cliff hanger ..that many hate - I loved ! A top story!

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @simonclarke4574 Yeah, I can see the hammer horror inspiration. I've always enjoyed it as well, It's a great adventure story. 😀

    • @mickeythompson9537
      @mickeythompson9537 17 дней назад

      Well observed. And, already, "Day of the Daleks" had that gothic element - ghosts and a haunted house!

  • @intergalactic92
    @intergalactic92 18 дней назад

    My understanding of Day of the Daleks is that the Daleks are actually superfluous to the entire story. It may as well be an Ogron invasion that the rebels are trying to prevent. It’s like they had a good idea and someone said, 'you know what would make it better? Daleks' and they were forced to bend over backwards to shoehorn the daleks in somehow. Which is a shame.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @intergalactic92 that's very much how it comes across in the original version. The daleks do kind of feel secondary, but in the special edition, they've made it so that the daleks are a bigger threat that looms over the whole story. New cgi shots of dalek insignias on buildings & the end battle with more Daleks ect. The new changes very much transform the Daleks to being the stars.

  • @normanby100
    @normanby100 18 дней назад

    Letts and Dicks wanted to concentrate on their own concepts like the Master and the Daleks were very much forced upon them. They come across as generic baddies and lack any disturbing aspects relating to the mutation inside. Terry Nation 's way with a Dr Who script hadn't moved on much with the times and hadn't kept pace. '

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @normanby100 Well, you're not exactly wrong there, but the Daleks are always taken seriously. Letts was also the one who suggested to Terry Nation to give us a genesis for the daleks. Resulting in Genesis of the daleks being one of the greatest Who stories of all time.

    • @normanby100
      @normanby100 14 дней назад

      @ I don't doubt Letts took the Daleks seriously, trouble is the stories weren't that interesting.

  • @michaelwhiles5282
    @michaelwhiles5282 18 дней назад

    Day is one of the very best, Planet is good but....Death (at least some of it) is pretty poor.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @michaelwhiles5282 I love hearing everyone's different opinions 😁 I have always really enjoyed all these dalek stories, especially Death to the Daleks, I find it such a fun adventure. But I do understand the criticisms people have with that story.

  • @mark-s
    @mark-s 18 дней назад

    Planet of the Daleks was my favourite story had a lot of Adventure Jo on her own on a hostile planet with them having to escape the planet before the daleks capturing them.The spiridons were a nice add to the story with their purple cloaks. The 3rd doctor era was my favourite with solid episodes it didn't have many poor stories/seasons like future doctors had. 4th doctors stories are easily looked on by me genesis was excellent but destiny was awful

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @mark-s Yeah, planet of the daleks is very fun. The third doctor's era is definitely the most consistent era of the show. Terrance dicks & Barry Letts literally gives us no duds. All Pertwee's stories are enjoyable.

  • @thomasjohnson8391
    @thomasjohnson8391 18 дней назад

    The special edition is better and planet of the daleks I think is the best

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @thomasjohnson8391 the special edition is so great. Expanding the scale of everything, & planet of the Daleks is very fun. 😁

  • @SimonLeicester
    @SimonLeicester 18 дней назад

    Pertwee was such a great Doctor. He was my Doctor

  • @akshaytrayner1960
    @akshaytrayner1960 18 дней назад

    Pertwee fought the dalek more times even if it was three

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @akshaytrayner1960 Yeah, I was talking more about screen appearances. Technically speaking, you could say 4, including the frontier in space.

  • @hopebgood
    @hopebgood 18 дней назад

    I love all these stories mate but I think I'd have to say that Day of the Daleks is my fave. It's properly about the consequences of time travel and it has UNIT in it.

  • @inquisitor229
    @inquisitor229 18 дней назад

    i loved the Pertwee era but found the electronic sound effects through his era to be rather irritating most of the time. Completely agree about day of the Daleks, and was very impressed with the efforts made to improve on the original.

  • @jaidanielparker
    @jaidanielparker 18 дней назад

    Random gripe with Day of the Daleks - This is their first TV outing in colour and the designers make the Daleks grey with black trimmings. Oh well, I guess it was the 70's and at the time having every shade of brown you could wish for was considered high fashion. Having said that the grey worked perfectly with the bleak, militaristic tone of Genesis.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @jaidanielparker I love the grey Daleks, but yeah, it's kind of odd that they didn't take advantage of the daleks now being in colour.

  • @robburdlow4301
    @robburdlow4301 18 дней назад

    Day of the Daleks is my favourite dalek story and yes, the special edition is way better than the original.

    • @thewhoview
      @thewhoview 18 дней назад

      @robburdlow4301 You have good taste, my friend. 😉👍