10 Flaws With the Rebel Trooper
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 окт 2018
- Today we look at the Rebel Alliance Infantry trooper and determine their 10 biggest flaws.
10 FLAWS SERIES
1. Separatist Droids: • 10 Flaws Star Wars - S...
2. Imperial Class Star Destroyer: • 10 Flaws Star Wars - I...
3. Stormtroopers: • 10 FLAWS with the Stor...
4. Tiefighters: bit.ly/2N77rG5
5. Death Star: • 10 FLAWS with the Deat...
6. Rebel Trooper: • 10 Flaws With the Rebe...
7: X wing: • 10 Flaws Star Wars - X...
8: ATAT: • 10 Flaws With the ATAT...
9. AAT: • 10 FLAWS with the AAT ...
10. Laat: • 10 Features that made ...
11. ATTE • 10 Features that made ...
12. Venator • 10 Features that made ...
13. ARC 170 • 10 FLAWS with the ARC...
14. Eta Actis 2 • 10 FLAWS with the ETA ...
Checkout the rest of the series here!
• 10 Flaws Star Wars - S...
#10flaws #starwars #rebelalliance
Get Generation Tech Gear HERE!: teespring.com/stores/generati...
Subscribe to Generation Tech: bit.ly/SubGenerationTech
Please help our channel by becoming a Patron: bit.ly/GTPatreon
Follow Generation Tech on Facebook: bit.ly/GenerationTechFB
Check out what we're reading and playing:
www.amazon.com/shop/generatio...
Watch More Generation Tech:
Latest Videos: bit.ly/LatestGT
Popular Videos: bit.ly/GTPopular
More Star Wars Videos: bit.ly/GTStarWars
Follow our Hosts
ALLEN XIE
RUclips / @thebeardedasianman
INSTAGRAM AXIEFILMS
FACEBOOK / axiefilms
Ben Hedges
RUclips / @thecreditshifu
RUclips
/ benhedgesntd
EQUIPMENT USED
CAMERA: SONY A6300 amzn.to/2q4wN8n
LENS: MITAKON 35MM F0.95 amzn.to/2pUnzz6
TRIPOD: amzn.to/2pUnzz6
MIC: amzn.to/2oWktJF
EDITING SOFTWARE: amzn.to/2pqOcvV
#10flaws #rebels #humanityfirst 
Развлечения
Infantry: We lost 30,000 men
Admiral: True, BUT it did inspire 7 civilians to join our cause
Infantry: Mission Accomplished
Nice
I doubt they have 30000 men.
@@intensellylit4100 They most likely actually do! Remember this is a galaxy, full of millions upon millions of systems. Quadrillions of people made up the galaxy, and most Rebel Sector Defense Forces had millions of people.
Chancellor Palpatine ok Chancellor chicken :)
Mission failed sucessfully
The Rebel infantry survived because no matter how many were killed, there were always more people who hated the Empire enough to go out and get shot at just to hit back somehow.
...You'd think a government run by a Sith Lord would have understood that hatred is an infinite resource.
It is very possible that Palpatine understood that fact. In one of the canon Vader comics, Palpatine explains to Vader that having enemies is the price of power and that there is no limit to how many enemies you get to kill. With that said, it was Palpatine’s own arrogance that he lost at Endor.
@@danielrooney7964 That is... a quote
That fool Tarkin thought having big scary weapons would be enough to suppress descent it's ultimately his fault for the Empire failing. Had Alderaan not been destroyed the Rebellion may of faded away.
@@rc59191 he was no more than a bully, so much so he brought these flaws into the tactics of the empire and how they controlled and guarded the galaxy
You have a, very large point
Does anybody think that they should release a stormtrooper movie? Yet this time it’s not some cliche ‘join the rebel side after seeing the dark side of the Empire’, but rather stay part of the Empire. Like some guy starting of on a low class planet being harassed by pirates. Later the Empire frees the planet from their oppressors, but during the chaos many of the townsmen including some of his loved ones are killed thus giving him a reason to join the military to seek justice in bringing order to the galaxy and seeking to preventing a similar situation somewhere in the galaxy. So him and a couple of friends join the stormtrooper corps and set off. Later when the rebels start to grow in number and he gets first hand experience in fighting them he is given a choice to join the rebel alliance, but as stated he refuses and accepts the imperial truth as the only truth: ‘Rebels are scum’. As the movie progresses many of his friends die during battle making him more battle hardened and increases his hatred towards the rebel alliance. He also rises to the ranks making him more badass as the movie continues. References to dumb stuff that happened in the movies could be included like why they can’t shoot straight etc. This even gives the people behind star wars a chance to expand the lore on stormtrooper rankings and variations of different stormtroopers in the new canon.Then for a final it could have him return to his home world for a deployment as his home world has joined/supported the rebellion and must be forced to comply with imperial rule once again, yet the man that left the planet years ago is no more. Here he can be faced with a familiar face(maybe a girl he liked or an old friend who didn’t join the Empire long ago or even a sibling) who has joined the rebellion, this leads to an epic showdown between the two( although who wins could go either way: him winning and just brushing the person off as another rebel scum and continuing on until he is brutally murdered by a fuzzy bear and eaten alive(just joking) or him just dying and thus becoming a tragedy of war where he just wanted to help by doing what he thought was right and might i add the only thing he could do in his position to help, showing that the war between the Empire and Rebels has no good side). I feel like this would perfectly depict the Imperial’s point of view as the rebels would be depicted as terrorists finally humanizing the Empire or stormtroopers. I also think that this movie shouldn’t be rated for younger kids as it focuses more on infantry life not some plot armored hero who kills the bad guys with a swing of his genitalia. I don’t know just my thoughts.
I agree. Perfect idea.
Problem is that it's kind of like trying to humanise the Nazis. It just doesn't work. Many of the people who work and fight for the Empire might be decent, but the Empire itself is wholly evil. Not to mention its leader is a Sith.
Alternatively, what they could do is tell the story of two friends close as brothers who ends up on opposite sides of the war. Eventually they meet, and they fight to the death. Before that, though, I want to see a post-Episode IX Luke Skywalker movie (assuming he returns to life), a Darth Maul film that ties together Solo with the Season 2 finale of Rebels where Maul trains Qi'ra in the ways of the dark side of the Force, a bro-mance film with Finn and Poe (after Episode IX) where they travel the galaxy in search of Finn's past, and a film about the post-Episode IX Jedi Order. The latter could alternatively be a trilogy.
Edit: What would be cool in the Finn film is if Captain Phasma somehow survived Episode VIII (she might have fallen through the flaming inferno rather than into it) and that she's the main antagonist, and relentlessly pursues Finn and Poe across the galaxy.
Jesus christ I didn't read this but have an like since I looks like it took very long lol
@@Aewon84 the whole being a sith thing wasn't classed as illegal to be in fact nowhere did it state in the republic that a sith wasn't allowed to be its leader the empire had the right kindset its leaders like tarkin vader and the emperor that screw it over
@@Aewon84 almost all movie makers are afraid to have the "bad guys" win which they shouldnt be just once i would like to see the bad guys annihilate the "good guys" like there are so many things in movies where a good hero would 100% die in an any way realistic version but instead somehow gun down like 20 elite soldiers magically find transportation and escape
Given that it was an insurgency, these flaws aren't really a surprise; they were entirely expected. The one tactical advantage that insurgencies have against professional armies is actually their lack of organization; without a command structure - which is what regular professional troops are trained exclusively in (only SpecForces are trained to operate for extended periods without a central command) - it is extremely difficult to completely purge an insurgency, from local to galactic, without annihilating the entire field of operations, which, in this case, quite a few Imperial high officers did - works well in pure battlefields, not so much in civilian centers. Alderaan's destruction - and the Tarkin doctrine in general - made it relatively easy for an insurgency to form and/or continue despite Imperial efforts; the most effective Imperials for combating the rebels were the ones who did not follow the Tarkin doctrine - who practiced what the rebels did: hearts and minds.
In a war of attrition, an insurgency is more likely to win because a professional army is entirely dependent on its organization and logistics. If either are disrupted, especially logistics, the army will fall apart, but if engaged in an actual fight, even if logistics are disrupted, the army almost always wins. These flaws, which are inherent in all insurgencies, are why the rebels avoided full ground battles wherever they could and why they lost most of the battles they couldn't avoid.
👍👍
I don’t want to break the 69 likes.
That’s a lot of letters. Too bad I ain’t gonna read it🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓
Hoth troopers were rebel infantry
They bring up that only Endor and Scariff were exceptional victories whereas Hoth was generally how most ground engagements go. Rebel infantry as a speed bump.
and that went well for them.
That was made up of mostly special forces I believe
Other so far 😂😂😂 and poopy ☺️😸😸 and poopy ☺️ and I miss him so so I can 🥫 it 😅😅😭 I can 🥫🥫🥫🥫
They lost. He mentions that they basically don't have any real land victories until Endor
You saw rebel infantry on the battle of Hoth and the Tantiv 4 granted they were wiped out both times
Omg I just realized that
Beat me to it!
On the Tantiv I think those would be navy soldiers, not army.
I thought the Tantive IV Guys were just Corellian security?
Not, corellian. Alderaani at least. But yeah, they were arguably amongst the better infantry that the rebellion had. Not counting SpecForce that is.
The rebel infantry was the red shirts of Star Wars. A title I once described the rebel pilots as.
I would say those Rogue One rebel troops that joined Jen where also special forces.. not grunts. He says they are assassins and saboteurs or demo teams.
Luke Skywalker killed 1.7 million people on the death star and half a million droids, most of whom joined the military to help provide for their families, caused millions of kids to become orthans, and a galaxy wide recession which caused the galactic economy drop a few points which caused millions of people to become unemployed and homeless, and Luke Skywalker gets a medal for it
They were at war the death star was a military target
Not only that. The rebels acted in self-defense
Emperor palpitine ended the clone wars, eliminated the jedi who started the clone wars on geonosis by interfering with a legal execution, and who attempted to assassinate palpitine as well, and ended corruption in the Senate, but the rebellion were hell bent on restoring a corrupt government that they caused trillions of credits worth of criminal damage, killed 10's if not 100's of millions of innocent people, and had no plan on the aftermarth of the downfall of the empire
And that same weapon killed billions more
Well how many died on Alderaan?Quite a bit more right?So save your hyppocritic attempts to be morale Imp.
So glad you are now doing flaws on the rebel scum. Great video
You are at 66 likes I will not mess it up
Wow some guy just made it 67 now I’m gonna make it 68
Dew it
I now this is a important video
jedi: hey everyone we're the good guys
*civilian*
"korriban massacre"
*jedi*
:( "execute order 37"
force ghost in tomb stated sith did to them self due back stabbing syndrome
@@TheJarric i mean the massacre of korriban was the jedi slaughtering not just sith but civilians aswell
in old rebublic one of sith lords said it was sith in fighting with posible vitiate involwed
@@TheJarric It was at this moment that the Republic made what might now be considered a mistake: the Sith no longer posed a threat to the Republic, but the Supreme Chancellor was unsatisfied. Jedi and Republic forces were sent to Korriban and other Sith planets to ensure no remnants of the Sith Empire remained.JEDI MASTER GNOST-DURAL
In the immediate aftermath of the Great Hyperspace War, the Galactic Republic initiated a genocide targeting the remnants of the shattered Sith Empire. Although the extermination nearly drove the Sith species to extinction, several members of the race were able to escape with their religious brethren aboard an exodus fleet. The fleet eventually settled on Dromund Kaas, where the Sith built a new Empire and planned for revenge against the Republic.
note the sith species is different from sith dark side users keep that part in mind
Typical, Pilots get all the glory and fame while the Ground pounders get the Shaft.
Despite this, the Resistance or the New Republic still did'nt even bother to upgrade their basic infantry, this shows Disney has no creativity at all.(Sarcastic)
The fact that their grasp on battlefield tactics are crap in every battle they have ever fought? Hoth, Endor (the space part, the ambush was surprisingly a good idea), Yavin IV, Starkiller base, Scariff (space part, the ambush on the ground had some good ideas behind it though, likely due to the lack of the usual command issuing dumb orders) and Crait.. Space battles were risk everything, especially the ones targeted by the super weapons. Land battles consisted of shallow trenches and head on assaults against superior fire power... use some damn tactics!
You never get the sense that their soldiers survive due to being good, just lucky.
I think you're mad at George Lucas, not fictional space tacticians.
@@notalanrogers3173 Mad at him, and Disney, for only caring about the over all plot and not an ounce of attention or care on the numerous battles..
They likely couldnt even beat a tutorial in a Total war game...
Well remember they need the most cinematographic set ups, ones that are visually interesting, over what would be the most tactically prudent.
Movies end up a LOT shorter when combat is just BOOM and over with.
@@DonaldWWitt that is likely the reason, yet Hoth and Crait seem to be inspired by Japanese kamikaze pilots attacking big American ships. The cinematographic of such an attack might be spectacular, but the decision for such a suicidal waste is still obvious.
I have seen plenty of battles in other movies (ww2, lotr, Vietnam, Crusades, Ancient times like Rome and Greece, Middle Ages, etc.), where it looked gorgeous and the tactics deployed had merits to them, so having both is possible.
Nien Nunb, who was in the Falcon during the battle of Endor and at the end of TLJ.. he have had 30+ years to become the most awesome badass fighter for the Resistance and to be given leadership responsibilities, yet he still survives due to nothing, but luck.
@@Senovitj lol. These incoherent, insane ramblings are great.
"The Alien was seal commando ranger."
most stormtroopers were better than rebels except the rebels where more well equipped with ultra high crystalline molecular plot armor.
Only if the rebels have a name. If they don't they are equipped with blaster attracting red shirts to draw fire away from the important people.
Wait, you don't see the Rebel Infantry in the original trilogy? Empire Strikes Back called and would like you to review the Battle of Hoth. They were horribly outgunned and out manned, but they held the line long enough for almost all of the Rebels and their equipment to escape. They had crew serviced weapons, but no artillery, armored vehicles of any kind, or anti-armored vehicle weapons. If the Imperial walkers weren't so slow and had to cover so much distance to get into range after having to land so far away (thanks Admiral Ozzel, you let the Rebels escape and win the war, enjoy your force choking) they would have slaughtered the light infantry line. There was enough Rebel infantry that they did make an armored approach to the base the only viable option, however.
I don't know. I've played Battlefront II (2005) and EA´s Battlefront as well and there was a LOT of dead rebel troopers druring the assault on Hoth...
Well also the rebels got their butt kicked on hoth being desperate enough to use cables as weapons
@@yeetyeet5079 The Rebels were focused on withdrawing before all of the Imperial fleet blockaded the planet and they were sieged. They couldn't spare the weapon systems that could take on Imperial Walkers, like star fighters, because they needed them to escort fleeing ships. To be honest, the Rebellion won the war through space naval assets, the Empire's tactical doctrine flaws, and a fortunately time assassination of the top two leaders of the Empire.
@@KnightsWithoutATable I mean a lost battle is a lost battle the empires objective was to destroy the shield generator and they did it
I really wish that they make SpecForce from Legends canon again, those guys were like space third echelon.
The Dark Knight yeah mate. I would have loved to SpecForce Marines and Infiltrators back
Space third echelon?! U are joking right? They are WAY weaker than even Sam Fisher!
@@pyeitme508: In that you are wrong budy.
Well you got rebel pathfinders which are spec Force but canon
They can still do it. The only question is will they. I want to see Rebel SpecForce Marines.
He forgot the rebel infantry on Hoth when he said they only showed they on endor
top down, most of those in charge fielded more belief in a purpose over skills, since those at the top of rebel command really weren't soldiers or tacticians. there were few with the understanding of say, admiral Akbar, or a contemporary on the ground. ground units being more likely to be captured, they likely could only afford to train their special forces way behind safe lines, so that by the time the special forces were deployed to Target or Intel gathering, the top special forces personnel and materials were probably off to the next job and couldn't be traced back to a source and eliminated. these facilities likely kept moving after each batch we're trained, perhaps even while they were training even. kinda crude to do on the roll, but it would keep security breaches from ever being very successful
Must have been hard to keep it down to only 10 flaws.
Recently I learned that most battles fought during the Clone Wars were between sentient beings that were neither clones nor droids. Knowing this, there should've been no shortage of combat experienced men to fight with and train the Alliance Infantry.
mass assault vs superior fire power
I typically prefer superior firepower.
So.... USSR vs Germany
2 million equipped with a 5 round bolt action rifle, vs 200 thousand with MGs, tanks, etc.
(Overwhelming numbers wins)
actually overwhelming numbers could still lose that.
seamus finnegan Depends on supply and munitions
This reminds me of the American revolutionary war's minuteman
Allen: The only time we saw rebel infantry in the original trilogy was at the battle of Endor.
Empire strikes back: Am I a joke to you?
Yo dude i just wanna ask. Were there any notable rebel commerce raider units in the war? Kinda like Admiral Von Spee in WW1 or the pocket battleship/Heavy cruiser named after him in WW2?
Everything is flawed except for DA GRaND ARMy OF Da REpuBLiC
Except the complete lack of manpower. 1 million men for a four year long war on a galactic scale. Not happening. World War I required more of its combatants.
Your vidoes are really evolving into great works of art!
Thank you for explaining the reasons why destroying the first and second Death Star is as a game changer in the rebel alliance
Who here misses the British guy named Ben 😭 I love his outro song. It's legendary!
NO ONE!
I actually do
What happened to him?
Cold Flame it was explained in a video. It's nothing bad btw. No need to cry.
Zack Johnson I wasn’t going to but ok
Hey battle of hoth was a good scene of rebel infantry in the orig trig™
One question I have that you raised in this video: just how successful was the Empire when it came to infiltrating the Rebels?
We know that the Rebels had spies within the Empire, usually disillusioned officers and politicians, but how far did the door swing the other way? And what was the rate of capture/defection for these agents?
How many were playing both sides off against each other?
I want to just see more of these.
Interesting list, how about 10 flaws with Mandalorian warriors.
For all you imperial apologists, never forget that the empire orchestrated an all-out genocide of the Geonosian populace, leaving only one survivor of the Geonosian species. The empire literally committed a holocaust against them. This is why, even though the rebels may not be right, the Empire is definitely wrong.
They were just bugs
Their foundries pumped out hundreds of thousands of battle droids on a daily basis. This was the price of treason.
The only thing the Empire did wrong there was leaving a survivor.
This was a neat video. Can you do old republic stuff as well?
For the battle of Hoth part of this video, according to the Book Inside the Worlds of Star Wars Trilogy the Rebel Alliance actually had heavy ground weapons that could have stopped AT-ATs, but their Commander General Rieekan had those placed in a different position. He expected the Imperial Ground Forces to attack from an easier accessable area. But General Veers choose a different, more difficult route over a glacier area, he lost several of his units on that route, but still managed to reach the defense line of the rebels, which had no heavy artillery of any kind. So yeah, it was souly bad strategic planning on the rebels side which made the imperial victory much easier.
Rebel ground forces in the battle of Hoth, just saying.
In Finland during the 1918 war reds and whites were seperated from each other by a white or red strap. So you wouldn´t shoot your own.
It would probably be easy to pick out who is a rebel and who is an Imperial in a ground fight. Just shoot the people in white armor/not in white armor.
@@tanith117 Imagine if there were civilians in the crossfire.
Would a stormtrooper just shoot at everyone not white now?
Uniforms are to ensure that civilians don't get mistaken for a combatant
@@redthered3242 Youre Saying that like the Empire Cares about Civilians, or like they could hit them on purpose.
@@tanith117 "Peacekeeping Force"
Rebels not having uniforms justifies the Empire shoosting civillians
@@redthered3242 Anyone who runs is a Rebel, any who don't are well disciplined Rebels.
Great video 👍🏻. Do a video on the food for the troops?
One of the good things about more independent forces is that they get to make decisions much faster. Comparable to the Wehrmacht in some way. The french army had to wait for orders from the high command before reacting to germans attacks, the german forces on the other hand could act independently to some degree, use time saved from waiting for orders to gain an advantage.
Rebel Helmet : face revealed
Storm Trooper Helmet : head fully covered
I dont know why the empire did’nt just aim for the head instead of the ground
i dont think the bucket had eyeholes
They actually do, but their blasters are just crap.
Let me ask, Luke killed millions blowing up the death star, while the death star killed billions more, yet everyone sympathises with the empire who shot first and killed billions, excuse me WTF?!?
"The rebels did it" xD
Edgelords dude
Alderaan was a rebellion sympathizer, and thus a justified target.
In all seriousness though, most of the time people are just joking or playing a part since they're Empire supporters. Most of them aren't edgelords.
Alderaan was a legitimate target, it was esentially the industrial and financial hub of the Alliance. It was basically the Ruhr Valley of the rebellion. Also most empire supporters agree that the Tarkin doctrine was wasteful and failed in its goals
@@LordVader1094 there was 2 rebels in aldeeran dude
Love the use of the tv in the back
Would love to see something on Crix Madine. The man created and ran the Empires Special Op's before he defected to the Rebels and created and led THEIR Special Op's. A show showing the two would be awesome.
I love the 61st mobile infantry long live twilight company
A small question: Why is it unlisted?
It's just so cool you make these videos under the perspective of a person in the Star Wars Galaxy by playing Devil's Advocate and claiming the OT was Rebel propaganda, that's honestly so funny. Love you Allen, keep being awesome!
Never read or watched anything Star Wars outside of the first two movie trilogies. Have no idea who accurate a lot of this stuff in the vids is. Nonetheless--or many, and so--enjoy it immensely.
The biggest flaw with the rebel trooper is that they stand against the Empire. Leia's attempt at a caliphate using these terrorists will never last.
Also please make 10 flaws with the Clone Trooper?!
Well the clone troopers dont have 10 flaws they have 3 at most
@@jacobmcgee2053
1. Too Efficent
2. Too Well-Trained
3. They are the UltraMarines of Star Wars
@@freddykrueger8076 predictable
rex created an algorithm which the sepratists got hold of at one point and used it to consistently beat the clones the only way they got it back was because of basically super clones with defects that made them essentially have superpowers
literally the only problem i can think of
@@drunkgerman8909and remember clones are too costly and too long time to train compared to regular infantry drafted from civilian population or droids and don't forget everyone has same face so if you will make same clones as enemy you can us them to make enemy's troops look bad, traitors and population won't believe them
@@jakubkovarik4182 not to long when you get a soldier that has complete loyalty and is literally bred for war costly is worth it seeing as they are all willing to fight to the death for the republic/empire and would give anything to defend their brothers worth the price tag in my opinion
10:00
anyone notice that the AT-ATs are missing like 2 medium lazers like there gone and they removed them and changed the spot were the heavy cannons are
You bring up some good points.
Generation Tech is one of the greatest Star Wars RUclipsrs of ALL TIME! PERIOD! DON'T @ ME!
Eckhart is good to
The Rebels really shouldn't have won the war when you think about it.
ValZicPlayz MC they didn’t really win anything until the death of the emperor
Preety sure they wouldn't have had iden versio hadn't defected and the second death star destroyed.
@@m.aryaanamiri2755 no it didnt matter if she defected or not the Empire only formed around Palpatine without him it collapse completely
Vader also kept it in check and if he isn't keeping it in check it would break even more with no one working with each other.
They just shouldn't have won in general but plot the Empire had shitty tactics
ahm they shouldve won the war it shouldve been a way more dark war with a lot of deaths but they would eventually win no matter what not cuz of tactics but bc of the empire itself being a shitty one made by a racist bc if eveery stormtrooper eventually turns on palpatine not even with all the sith artifacts in the galaxy could he beat every living thing except himself all by himself
This channel should do a video each for The Empire and The Rebellion versus The Diabolical Dolphin Dominion. I'm sure The Empire and The Rebellion have some sort of aquatic specialized military units and vehicles, and so it'll be both entertaining and useful to create and develop effective military maneuvers and tactics against the cruelly creative and creatively cruel water demons.
If not Rebel Infantry, what were the men in the trenches during the Battle of Hoth? ("We only see Rebel infantry on the ground during the Battle of Endor").
Ummm despite their flaws think its easy to tell if someone in plain clothes is on your side if theyre definitely trying to flank and mow down with their blaster the same Stormtrooper squad you are.
That is great in a battle on an open field with no third party elements around.
In an urban warfare scenario you just got a lot of civilians shot, and you can`t even fault the imperials for it this time.
What are 10 flaws of Generation Tech? I can't find any! What about you?! 😱 😕
The Rebel had it's strength in the space battles but lacked on the ground battle.
Do a video on the ten flaws of the Sith Empire (3000 years before the Battle of Yavin) (Great Hyperspace War) Old Republic Era
Where not recruiting children as fodder for their army you imperial buckethead :b
all depends on perspective a great peace loving emperor or a crazy kid that had no problem killing 2 million imperials but once it comes to his dad its all i see good in you
Lol skewed perspective. I get it ur a thrawn fan im also a thrawn fan and a Chiss ascendancy fan. But calling a kid crazy for blowing up a moon sized weapon that is basically designed to hold the galaxy hostage DARE I SAY use terror to keep "peace" vs an Emperor that is so deeply attuned to the dark side he became a raisin , with no regard for imperial or ANY lives. Sidious was using the empire and everything he had for his own personal goals. Blowing up a planet vs blowing up a planet killer military space station is not the same. They didnt even care about their own pilots. Here have a mass produced TIE fighter with no shields basically a paper ship. Enslaving other species and completely strip mining planets and leaving the populace to fend for themselves.
@@bushidok9180 welp the joke went completely over your head didnt it
@@bushidok9180 A great tactician creates plans. A good tactician recognizes the soundness of a plan presented on him. A fair tactician must see the plan succeed before offering approval. Those with no tactical ability at all may never understand or accept it. Nor will such people understand or accept the tactician. To those without that ability, those who posses it are a mystery. And when a mind is too deficient in understanding, the resulting gap is often filled with with resentment.War is a primarily a game of skill. It is a Contest of mind matched against mind, tactics matched against tactics. But there is also an element of chance that is more suited to games of cards or dice. A wise tactician studies those games, as well, and learns from them. The first lesson of card games is that the cards cannot be played in random order. Only when laid down properly can victory be achieved. do you get that reference?
@@drunkgerman8909 yeah i get the reference. Oh ok well dont act surprised some ppl actually believe your joke.
You prolly subbed to dudufilms but if not you should go watch his vids. He actually uses the same quote in one of his more recent videos.
"Go all 'admiral akbar' with a suicide vest" you sir are a linguistic genius, best Star Wars related quote I've ever heard. Made me crease so hard I choked on my doner kebab I'm eating while watching 10/10 I liked the video because of this quote.
Hey guys! I have a job as a Storm-Trooper! This video is really helping me know my enemy. Thanks!
At least they could aim
Lego World War 2 Stop motion So could Stormtroopers. Watch the intro of ANH.
You would be surprised how many battles that the empire had won .in terms of ground and naval engagement
AMAZING!!! Which I am sure US Special Operations Forces operators during sea, land or even inside ship clandestine missions WILL perform WAY better. Also US Marine Corps soldiers can KO those losers!
I knew IT! The Death star was always a tourist attraction, rather than a battle station!
Also Rebel infantry had SOME coherently trained units (Fleet troopers for example). Many planetary militia and law enforcement joined the rebellion also
*Flaws with terrorists
I'm not sure half of the commenters understand the pro Imperial thing is a joke.
Planet Goddess you be surprised on how many rebel fans that call themselves star wars fans take this fictional franchise too seriously, they just love comparing real life history with the empire and the rebel alliance while acting very authoritian on anyone that simply just likes the empire over the rebels (ironic isn't it) and yet it's ok to like villains from other franchise that have done far worse that it makes the Empire's killings look like child's play. These rebel fans are fakers.
@@gabrieltejada1697 I mean, the Empire IS based on Nazis and historical empires so... :/
@@gabrieltejada1697 The Empire is literally written to be pure evil. I- what are you even saying dude
Planet Goddess what's your point then? I simply stop being a fan of a FICTIONAL faction just because they are based on a real life regime? I guess that means i should stop liking predators (yautja), aliens (xenomorphs and genocidal btw), Thanos, Magneto, General RAAM, Sektor, the Joker, Bane, Venom, Carnage, Vader, Revan, Scarecrow, Black Manta, Lex Luthor, Deadshot, and Deathstroke.
Most of the characters I listed are villains or have been anti heros at times but as for the ones that have been purely evil like the Joker and Carnage for example both have done TONS of evil things and yet they both have loads of fans despite being villains yet strangely when it comes to star wars especially in the OT era it's always the fans that likes the "good guys" that tend to start drama with the imperial fans. It's ridiculous and pointless and only makes you people look like authoritive assholes who tries to stop people liking different things which is bitter irony.
Becoming what you hate, which is the nazis whom are a long dead regime and barely have any remnants left but you know what I'm fine with that, keep up the act because makes us empire fans look civil and reasonable unlike the rebel alliance fanbase. 😉
@@gabrieltejada1697 I'm not saying not to be a fan. I'm saying don't say they're good or valiant like they do in the joke. Who cares what you're a fan of?
great vid, despite the lack of a standing ground force they still won, which makes tehir victory that much more impressive, tho they only won cause of luke and vader, had the event never happened the rebels would have def lost, and if we take the new disney canon into account they pretty much lost anyways, but we will have to see what happens with ep 9.
Give them a break Allen most of the time they were scraped together on the fly too quickly. Also, most squads did not have enough time to train or plan or do any kind of organizing. The rebellion was too desperate to win the war to put together a legit recruitment process.
Jesus the comment section, filled with a bunch of naive Impiral fanboys, they don't see the bigger picture, but that's only there opinion though. But just remember the Rebellion killed thousands on the Death Star to save the Galaxy from further destruction, while the Empire killed even more thousands not only in Alderman but in other planets as well out of a simple grudge.
The Dark Knight THANK YOU
yet what did it achieve the new republic couldn't hold against the vong forcing them to change so in the end they really fought for nothing (dont mind the rebels just prefer the empire except tarkin he was a huge idiot that didn't know how normal people react) end of the day a mixture of republic and empire is what the galaxy really needs the reoublic was way to flawed and forced planets to remain in it just like the empire
The Empire can do with terrorist want they want in their own galaxy....like blowing up their planet. If there were never terrorists in the empire, there never had been the destruction of alderaan.
but will have to make a small correction the rebels killed millions of imperials on the 1st death star alone afterwards celebrated the fact they plunged the entire galaxy into a depression that would make the american depression look like a joke which probably killed many millions more indirectly
@@drunkgerman8909: If its legends we talking about, than you would know that the New Republic and the Empire become one after the Pellion Treaty.
Rebels = Space isis
Nope they were the french resistence during nazi occupation
wel rebels dont destoyed whole planet at least...
True
I like that the rebellion and empire, aren't bad or good, they are both a gray side, not good nor bad, we the viewers, have put them into those categories.
"Get some pants on that Wookie." was the last thing said by the Sargent of the 99th.
Generation Tech's Jedi ranking is a 0 overall. 1 like increases his Jedi ranking 😉 💯 I trust you guys. May the force be with you 👋
😂 Putting pants on a Hut.
I'm dead! 🤣
You should make a vid on who was the best tactician
Please make a video on 10 flaws of AAT cis tank
Love your comment "Luke the Butcher of Yavin 4". Just hilarious!!!
Hey I’m just repeating what I hear on the galactic news channel ok
I realize my old man was just a janitor but he died on the second battle station when it exploded.
00:50 not true, there was plenty of rebel infantry on Hoth in Empire Strikes Back.
They should make 2 movies, one about the Rebel trooper and one about the Stormtrooper. And actually show large scale ground battles that focus about the infantry.
Make this into a meme please
Rebel navy: swole doge
Rebel army: cheems
Didn’t see rebel ground troops until Endor? So uh did that entire sequence on both just not register with these guys or do they have something against empire?
These guys were pretty damn effective compared to the stormtroopers!
Honestly I want a video about captain how(however you say it) he sounds interesting
0:30 where did you get a picture of Hellogreedo's upbringing?
Wait...we only see infantry on Endor? Well that and Hoth, and standing around on Yavin 4 and fighting on the Tantive 4 .
Alan: we never see rebel infantry
*Battle of hoth*
*happens*
Hoth: am I a joke to you?
Hey guys there's a generation films real size of movie monsters video in your 10 flaws playlist
The soldiers seen on Scariff are special forces as well. They're rebel Specforce Pathfinders. Actual boots on the ground rebels were only seen on Hoth.
I think they should have used traditional hand-held shields made of the armor of died stormtroopers.
(of course kite shields)
"Go all Admiral Ackbar with a suicide vest." LMAO!!! ... subbed.
I think you are slightly neglecting armor weave where cloth looking uniforms can absorb at least some blaster fire. Like when Leia got shot. (However the stormtrooper may have dialed down his blaster power output into ammo saving mode to get as many shots at the unarmored but swarming ewoks.)
On a more serious note, this video does a great disservice to Rebel infantry men and women. They fought and did a lot to battle The Empire and there's a lot of stories and information on this on sites like Wookiepedia and such.
I would love to know the 10 flaws of a X Wing also think it would be a challenge for you as I know you love the X Wing's
Corporal CannonFodder and Major Casualties are my favorite rebels
"if you try to put pants on a Hutt or a Wookie, they'll kill you"
That gave me a mild chuckle