Wir sind des Geyers schwarzer Haufen - German Communist Revolutionary song

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024
  • this song was used by a lot of revolutionary groups in the weimar republic, unfortunately including nazis. the song was used by socialist groups as well which is why I am uploading this, fuck nazis
    Lyrics:
    Wir sind des Geyers schwarzer Haufen, heia hoho,
    und wollen mit Tyrannen raufen, heia hoho.
    Refrain:
    Spieß voran, drauf und dran,
    setzt auf’s Klosterdach den roten Hahn!
    Als Adam grub und Eva spann, kyrieleys,
    wo war denn da der Edelmann? kyrieleys.
    Jetzt gilt es Schloß, Abtei und Stift, heia hoho,
    uns gilt nichts als die Heil’ge Schrift, heia hoho.
    Des Edelmannes Töchterlein, Kyrieleis!
    Wir jagen sind die Höll hinein, Kyrieleis!
    Uns führt der Florian Geyer an, trotz Acht und Bann,
    den Bundschuh führt er in der Fahn', hat Helm und Harnisch an.
    Bei Weinsberg setzt es Brand und Stank, heia hoho,
    gar mancher über die Klinge sprang, heia hoho.
    Geschlagen ziehen wir nach Haus, heia hoho,
    uns’re Enkel fechten’s besser aus, heia hoho.
    Lyrics (English):
    We are Geyer's black hordes, heia hoho!
    And we want to fight with the tyrants, heia hoho!
    Refrain:
    Pikes ahead! On and on!
    On the monastery's roof, raise the red flames!
    When Adam plowed and Eve span, Lord, have mercy!
    Well where was the nobleman? Lord, have mercy!
    Now it's all about the castle, abbey and monastery, heia hoho!
    There is nothing to us but the Holy Scripture, heia hoho!
    The nobleman's daughter, Lord, have mercy!
    We will chase into hell, Lord, have mercy!
    We are led by Florian Geyer, despite being outlaws!
    He has the Bundschuh on his flag, he wears helmet and armour
    In Weinsberg we gave them fire and stench, heia hoho!
    Many a man was put to the blade, heia hoho!
    Defeated, we return home, heia hoho!
    Our grandchildren will put up a better fight! Heia hoho!

Комментарии • 304

  • @CJ_1871
    @CJ_1871 4 месяца назад +69

    When Adam tilled and Eve spun, where was the nobleman?

    • @cmd7930
      @cmd7930 3 месяца назад

      Communists dont like religion

    • @AmericanCaesarian
      @AmericanCaesarian 2 месяца назад +4

      @@CJ_1871 lord, have mercy!
      He was waiting for his chance to deceive those weak of mind into fighting each other

  • @CamilleEgalite
    @CamilleEgalite Год назад +34

    Прекрасное исполнение великой революционной песни)

  • @evanwilliams1839
    @evanwilliams1839 Год назад +159

    Only version i have found thay doesnt cur out the parts about killing the noblemans little shits and clubbing priests.
    Good work

    • @partytimefreddy
      @partytimefreddy Год назад +36

      I suspect it's because the song is not only used by communists but by a lot of Nationalists and Fascists as well who weren't as fond about killing noblemen while the Communists were. Over all this version is much more beatiful mainly cause it kept that part.

    • @brucenorman8904
      @brucenorman8904 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/z3NS0wnMdEA/видео.html

    • @strumps9549
      @strumps9549 8 месяцев назад

      The national socialist were anti aristrocracy@@partytimefreddy

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 2 месяца назад

      @@strumps9549 that's weird, cause last time I checked half of them had 'von' in their names.

    • @DogeickBateman
      @DogeickBateman 2 месяца назад +1

      @@MouldMadeMind The conservatives and nationalists, but not the National Socialists. Lot of the backgrounds for the latter were outside the nobility and who believed Austrian painter was a better outlet than the far removed former.

  • @aandersson650
    @aandersson650 6 месяцев назад +42

    I've seen nazi backdrops of this, now communist when it's really against feudalism haha
    Haven't heard this version though, thanks for uploading it

    • @anblueboot5364
      @anblueboot5364 4 месяца назад +13

      If it‘s against feudalism it‘s kinda aligning with the communist agenda, fighting against the class system etc.
      beside that: Florian Geyer is claimed by every political movement, he‘s a folk hero at the end of the day. Obviously every political movement would claim him for themself. But looking through a historical and thematical lense he better fits with the communists/any revolution trying to overthrow the status quo for a better world.

    • @Jaybush-hy4mh
      @Jaybush-hy4mh 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@anblueboot5364this wasn't a Jewish revolution so it isn't communist.

    • @davidjefferson4941
      @davidjefferson4941 3 месяца назад

      @@Jaybush-hy4mh Bait? Why is communism tied to Jews so much? How about Mao's China, Pol Plot's Cambodia, Castro's Cuba, Allende's Chile, etc? Not sure why national socialists want to hate communism when both seem to be anti-elitist.

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 2 месяца назад

      @@davidjefferson4941 fascism is so anti-elitist that the elites never fought it at large.

    • @User-d6g4s
      @User-d6g4s 2 месяца назад

      ​@@anblueboot5364 Nothing communist about it, unless democracy is communist 😂
      The revolt was as much a popular uprising as it was a national one against international nobility and clergy (almost as if they go hand-in-hand):
      "German money for a German church"

  • @kurnma3776
    @kurnma3776 Год назад +261

    This song is not Nazi nor Communist
    It was dedicated to the 1500s revolts of Florian Geyer and the peasants, those who fought against the feudal aristocracy for greater rights

    • @kurnma3776
      @kurnma3776 Год назад +62

      This means they were revolutionaries, but not communists

    • @LoneRottingCorpse
      @LoneRottingCorpse Год назад +11

      @@kurnma3776 even better

    • @LoneRottingCorpse
      @LoneRottingCorpse Год назад +1

      i felt the chorus explained it all. i figured it wasnt either.

    • @canberkscal
      @canberkscal Год назад +52

      ​@@kurnma3776 Engels said that müntzer and his army were primitive communists

    • @the_kimchi_kommandant2603
      @the_kimchi_kommandant2603 Год назад +21

      @@canberkscal What Engels says is of no value

  • @svenvanwier7196
    @svenvanwier7196 5 месяцев назад +6

    When one knows politics, one recognizes the continual struggle, whatever flag that maybe, people flock to the strongest one they see.

    • @perunakeitto_.3203
      @perunakeitto_.3203 3 месяца назад +1

      As long as there are classes there will be class struggle

  • @Casisking639
    @Casisking639 7 месяцев назад +21

    If anything this title did trigger the fascists, and again they are wrong because this is official “as a song composed in Weimar Germany it was used by a wide spectrum of political groups, notably the national people’s army of the DDR”. And tbh I have found a modern Russian communist version so it’s legacy isn’t fully one sided. Plus it’s based on a poem supporting peasant revolt, pretty left tbh.

    • @МОБушеквсёПорешает
      @МОБушеквсёПорешает 22 дня назад

      Я знаю лишь современную русскую национал-патриотическую версию.

    • @ABPHistory
      @ABPHistory 5 дней назад +1

      whats the russian communist version

  • @d_Angry_Goose_b
    @d_Angry_Goose_b Год назад +66

    Viele Grusse von russische Genosse aus Revolutionische Arbeit Partei!

    • @commandergreetv753
      @commandergreetv753 Год назад +7

      Vielen Dank Genosse🔴🚩

    • @dogeknight6000
      @dogeknight6000 Год назад

      You communists the kaiserreich will reclaim the vaterland one day

    • @commandergreetv753
      @commandergreetv753 Год назад +3

      @@dogeknight6000 you wanna know something? Im a socialist who likes the Kaiserreich AND is a staunch catholic ik that doesnt make any sense...its complicated i guess...

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  Год назад +4

      @@dogeknight6000 lmao

    • @Kgb-iv5xh
      @Kgb-iv5xh Год назад +2

      спасибо, товарищ 🇩🇪🚩☭🤝🇷🇺🚩☭

  • @WelloBello
    @WelloBello Год назад +124

    ITT: Fascists explaining how the peasant-sided church-burner was actually tradpilled.

    • @KWyzel
      @KWyzel Год назад

      Communists explaining how the Medieval Radical Anti-Catholic Protestants were actually Socialists and Communists.

    • @daniels0376
      @daniels0376 Год назад +24

      ​@@KWyzel You mean the peasants who rose up in revolt against the feudal noblemen, the church and the monarchy?

    • @KWyzel
      @KWyzel Год назад +9

      @@daniels0376 Not every revolt against Noblemen and Monarchs is Communist.

    • @daniels0376
      @daniels0376 Год назад +30

      @@KWyzel That is true, if more because this was before political ideologies became a thing.
      However, if you were to try and match this with a modern ideology, communism would fit best.
      Certainly more so than the other groups who marched to this song, namely the Imperial German Army and the Wehrmacht.

    • @KWyzel
      @KWyzel Год назад

      @@daniels0376 There are literally dozens of rebellions, revolutions, and revolts against Monarchs and Aristocracy that weren't involved with Socialism or Communism.
      The Revolutionary War in the United States is a prime example, and the German Peasant's Revolt is too; both were non Communist revolutions against a tyrannical monarchist government with an end goal in bringing on more democratic representation and civil liberties to the people; not to create some Communist shit hole that would strip the people of basic rights such as Private Property ownership.
      Stop claiming ownership over every revolution, not every revolutionary wants to re-enslave himself to a Communist State like you do.

  • @crocve
    @crocve Год назад +155

    Broke: You believe in a communist society because it is an inevitable conclusion of human progress.
    Woke: You believe in a communist society because that's God's will.

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  Год назад +25

      fr

    • @KWyzel
      @KWyzel Год назад

      *Meanwhile every Communist Country to date has persecuted the Religious Sector brutally*
      But whatever you say.

    • @lester4506
      @lester4506 Год назад

      Except communist "societies" prosecute religion

    • @daniels0376
      @daniels0376 Год назад +4

      ​@@KWyzel Ah yes, the confiscation of the church's horded wealth and its redistribution to the starving peasants and workers, truly not what Jesus would want.
      No, fat priests with kilograms of golden chains and crosses on their bodies, that's what Jesus would want.
      NOT

    • @treyflorek8592
      @treyflorek8592 Год назад +1

      Ye

  • @СтаниславГромов-о7е

    Long live the international solidarity of workers! Greetings from Russia! Down with nazism and nationalism! Long live peace!

    • @the_kimchi_kommandant2603
      @the_kimchi_kommandant2603 Год назад +2

      Hail Victory!!! o7o7o7

    • @tiziocaio8657
      @tiziocaio8657 Год назад +7

      This is also a NatSoc song

    • @brucenorman8904
      @brucenorman8904 Год назад +1

      Composed around the 1920s, the lyrics of the song are sourced from the poem Ich bin der arme Konrad by the Bavarian poet and artillery officer Heinrich von Reder (1824-1909). The melody of the song is arranged by German songwriter and later National Socialist Fritz Sotke (1902-1970) in 1919

    • @iulianviorelmosteanu2800
      @iulianviorelmosteanu2800 9 месяцев назад +4

      Ironic. 8th SS Cavalry Division Florian Geyer

    • @strumps9549
      @strumps9549 9 месяцев назад +1

      Nothing wrong with nationalism.

  • @Phoenix_eleven
    @Phoenix_eleven Год назад +28

    what version of the song is this / who was this played by?

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  Год назад +11

      according to the comments, it was played by a german scout group called "Ring Florian Geyer". heres where i got this version ruclips.net/video/ul0GWAVGLYs/видео.html

    • @Phoenix_eleven
      @Phoenix_eleven Год назад +6

      Thank you very much!

    • @Aussie_swagger430
      @Aussie_swagger430 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@eyraaaaaaso not a communist song 😂

    • @phillipigyarto9066
      @phillipigyarto9066 8 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@Aussie_swagger430 it was used by communist revolutionaries in Germany.

  • @alexanderroeder9376
    @alexanderroeder9376 Год назад +7

    It is just a song that most likely was made in the beginning 20th century in the German youth movement, but it referrs to the Farmers wars, where the poor tenants burned the friaries and other church property. Florian Geyer was a leade of these risings.

    • @brucenorman8904
      @brucenorman8904 Год назад +2

      Composed around the 1920s, the lyrics of the song are sourced from the poem Ich bin der arme Konrad by the Bavarian poet and artillery officer Heinrich von Reder (1824-1909). The melody of the song is arranged by German songwriter and later National Socialist Fritz Sotke (1902-1970) in 1919

  • @НикитинАлексей-т5ц
    @НикитинАлексей-т5ц 9 месяцев назад +2

    Весело. Задорно. Все по делу. Молодцы ребята.

  • @Soyuzniki21
    @Soyuzniki21 2 месяца назад

    When Adam dug and Eva spun, lord have mercy ... where was the nobleman?

  • @cheifrazors1299
    @cheifrazors1299 3 месяца назад +1

    Kaiserredux Roter Morgan SubMod brought me here, jammed to this while playing as Goebbels and taking over Europe as Nationalist Marxist Germany.

  • @herrdoktorseltsameliebe
    @herrdoktorseltsameliebe Год назад +8

    Es lebe die revolution!

  • @hecker1636
    @hecker1636 Год назад +244

    Used by them, but in no way is this a German Communist Revolutionary song.

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  Год назад +171

      i think it can be described as one considering it was used by communist groups, same way it can be described as a fascist one or etc. i put it in the title mostly to piss off any fascists that come across this video tho

    • @ram0s._1
      @ram0s._1 Год назад +65

      @@eyraaaaaa how can a video "piss off" fascists

    • @theman2624
      @theman2624 Год назад +95

      @@ram0s._1 because he thinks they get offended as easily as him

    • @ram0s._1
      @ram0s._1 Год назад +17

      @@theman2624 perhaps

    • @TheBlackhero871
      @TheBlackhero871 Год назад +90

      Just because this song was used by the GDR and other socialist/communist movements does not mean it is communist.
      This song is from the 1920s is about the 1525 German peasants' war and one of their leaders Florian Geyer and it came from the German scout movement.
      It is neither a communist nor a national socialist song and the only reason they used it was because of it's anti church and somewhat anti royalty lyrics.
      But anything to "piss off" fascists i guess.

  • @RobbyVogel
    @RobbyVogel 13 дней назад

    I didn't know that 30s Germans used spears. I thought they used Mausers

  • @iuriamg
    @iuriamg 10 месяцев назад +7

    communist basil hell yea

  • @kaminadot
    @kaminadot 4 месяца назад

    hey buddy, loved this version! Is it availabled on soundcloud? If not, could you please post it?

  • @МОБушеквсёПорешает

    Песня по своему духу больше коммунистическая,чем националистическая.

  • @monkeyboy2059
    @monkeyboy2059 5 месяцев назад +3

    I was actually so confused why this said 'German Communist Revolutionary Song'. To my knowledge, isn't this a German patriotic song made by German peasants back in the 17th (or smth) century?? I know nothing else on why they made this, or even the full background. Plz educate me.

    • @kaminadot
      @kaminadot 4 месяца назад +1

      if I am not mistaken, the song was written in 20th century as form of honoring a peasants revolt that happened in 17th century, the song itself wasn't written neither by n@zis neither by communists (even so if the group that wrote it had antisemitic beliefs), but it was used by both sides, it was sing by SS members as well as it was sing by people in the GDR (East Germany), in the end, it's a cultural song basically and the lyrics in itself has nothing to do with n@zism, the lyrics are about a anti-monarchist and anti-clerical feeling

    • @DerDrako
      @DerDrako 4 месяца назад +1

      ​@@kaminadot After all the song is about something, that has no connection to a nationalism as it was used by the german fascists, but has more ideas that radical leftists can connect with. German fascism was not against the churches, as long as they play along with the NSDAP. Line slike "When Adam tilled and Eve spun, where was the nobleman?" are something very leftists and the whole topic of the song is more against fighting authorities, that want to force you into something, than anything else.
      A real connection to the wing of the NSDAP that was on Adolfs side is more or less absurd. If anything, it would make more sense on a strasserist level, if you want to make some connection to NSDAP ideology.
      Also the revolt was in the 15th century (in english numbering; 16th century in german numbering), In the 17th century Florian Geyer was long dead.

    • @kaminadot
      @kaminadot 4 месяца назад +1

      @@DerDrako exactly! It has many things that the left can identify with, also, thx for the correction!

    • @DerDrako
      @DerDrako 4 месяца назад +1

      @@kaminadot Your welcome.
      Which is also interesting for me: The "Schwarzer Haufen" (en: black company) is from its name a bit similiar to the "Schwarze Scharen" (en black bands), which was a resistance group against totalitarian groups in the Weimar Republic, where the song was used. Also the Machnowschtschina, which used a black flag at least, were probably more similar with the black company of Florian Geyer, than any other modern political group. They are also know militarily as the black army in the russian civil war and fought both nationalists (german, russian and ukrainian) and bolshewiks, while themselfs being socialists or even communists.

    • @kaminadot
      @kaminadot 4 месяца назад +1

      @DerDrako oh I know about the Makhnovtchina, the Black Army was super based btw, didn't knew about the black company tho, I will search about them

  • @petermcallister107
    @petermcallister107 2 месяца назад +1

    A lot of idiots are arguing about this being either an SS song(it is not-any moron can sing a song and lay claim to it)or it's a communist song(again,the same applies).
    Speaking as a military historian it is very difficult,if not impossible to take a song that began to take shape centuries ago and was then tampered with by some well known writers of later times and say it "means this or that". To the people at the time the concepts of either national socialism or communism were non entities. Both those that think the song either supports Nazism or communism are morons. I think the song is great,especially as an Anarchist the bits about giving the rich what they deserve.....But that in no way means the song supports or even considers what later generations called anarchism.
    The breakout of violence that became the German peasants war had no one cause. Some went simply for the chance of loot,others had a more thought filled reason for taking up arms,but you can be certain that applying 20th century political movements to the revolt is utter nonsense.
    Maybe certain commenters can just enjoy the song instead of 're hashing old arguments that meant nothing in 1525 or to the many variations of the song.

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 2 месяца назад +1

      Fun fact: this song was written in 1920.

  • @blackdragonangrycat
    @blackdragonangrycat Год назад +4

    I agree.

  • @masterofalltrades_
    @masterofalltrades_ Год назад +3

    Revolutionary song

  • @treyflorek8592
    @treyflorek8592 Год назад +1

    Very cool

  • @Ренат-21
    @Ренат-21 Месяц назад

    Please, who is the performer of this song? I'd really like to know

  • @bonelessvegetal818
    @bonelessvegetal818 Год назад +1

    i am very katoliko very based song, (based on my country's history)

  • @derBasti843
    @derBasti843 9 месяцев назад +6

    This is not a Communist Song. This is a Song of the Farmer War in 1524.

    • @DerDrako
      @DerDrako 4 месяца назад

      ... which was sung by many communists, in a political frame. (And yes, also by other groups, as it is and was usual with many songs. You also see Guthries songs used by the Republicans in the USA, even though he was a leftitst.)

  • @norwayball6360
    @norwayball6360 Год назад +6

    In my opinion this sing does not belong to neither the left nor the right, it8s a song about farmers and religion, leave it so both of us can hear and admire

    • @norwayball6360
      @norwayball6360 Год назад

      it’s*

    • @radon.drl.
      @radon.drl. Год назад

      This only leftist song.

    • @norwayball6360
      @norwayball6360 Год назад +1

      @@radon.drl. it was also used by nazis

    • @radon.drl.
      @radon.drl. Год назад +1

      @@norwayball6360 nazis is leftist too

    • @norwayball6360
      @norwayball6360 Год назад +3

      @@radon.drl. no, while there were some leftist wings in the nazi party they were extreme rightists and dont even start with the “national SOCIALIST” thing because if you follow this logic then “DEMOCRATIC People’s Republic of Korea” (North Korea) would be democratic?

  • @ЕвгенияКолосова-и3р
    @ЕвгенияКолосова-и3р 5 месяцев назад

    Те, кто пишет что песня анти-феодальная в целом правы, однако позже она успела стать и коммунистической, уж больно много сходства в тиранах, против которых боролись крестьяне и рабочие

  • @blehblehk5955
    @blehblehk5955 Год назад +22

    Not really a Communist song, title of video is misleading.

    • @SirAroace
      @SirAroace Год назад +5

      it is, or more accurately is a anti-noble song that was adopted by both communists and anti-noble fascist.

    • @blehblehk5955
      @blehblehk5955 Год назад +2

      @@SirAroace lol it literally has nothing to do with "anti-Facsim." You don't know what Fascism or what a fascist is, you take Orwell's modern sated definition of it meaning "bully."

    • @brucenorman8904
      @brucenorman8904 Год назад

      Composed around the 1920s, the lyrics of the song are sourced from the poem Ich bin der arme Konrad by the Bavarian poet and artillery officer Heinrich von Reder (1824-1909). The melody of the song is arranged by German songwriter and later National Socialist Fritz Sotke (1902-1970) in 1919

    • @oracuda
      @oracuda 11 месяцев назад

      this is unfortunately true, although i would personally call this song originally communist-aligned. allot of prominent german socialists later became nazis. @@brucenorman8904

    • @Lacccaria
      @Lacccaria 6 месяцев назад

      @@blehblehk5955 mfer can't distinguish between "anti-noble fascists" and "anti-fascists" lmao
      Either that or you can't read.

  • @Ma_ksi
    @Ma_ksi Год назад +52

    Also a SS song

    • @kaiooooo4095
      @kaiooooo4095 Год назад +15

      This sont was made in 1920 used by nazis because it was an anti noble and anti church song it’s also became the hymn of the DRR deutsche democratic republic

    • @ZagrebBundist
      @ZagrebBundist Год назад +1

      Yes but it was and still is used by leftists.

    • @Ma_ksi
      @Ma_ksi Год назад +2

      @@ZagrebBundist Very funny

    • @kobodas
      @kobodas Год назад +2

      This song used in florian Geyer division?

    • @derstoffausdemderjoghurtis
      @derstoffausdemderjoghurtis Год назад +8

      ​@@kaiooooo4095It certainly wasn't the hymn of the DDR, that would be "Auferstanden aus Ruinen" (Arisen from ruins). But it was certainly sung in the DDR and coopted (not exclusivly) by communists.

  • @azadrus6882
    @azadrus6882 Год назад

    wartet

  • @RosaLuxemburgGaming
    @RosaLuxemburgGaming Год назад +2

    Zum Glück gab es den Freikorps.

  • @Schakuta
    @Schakuta Год назад +7

    This is not a communist song. Just because some communists were singing it doesn't make it a communist song. It is a german Song. Some communists also sing "Happy Birthday". Does that make it a communist song? No. Communists wear shoes and pants. Does that make shoes and pants communist? Absolutely not. Same way the eagle isn't a Nazi Symbol. It's a german symbol. Just because a group uses something it doesn't make it their Symbol. When I listen to this song I think about german soldiers sitting in trenches in WWI and not communists

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  Год назад +20

      this song was written after ww1??? also your comparisons make no sense, this song has communist verses written by communists (second verse was popularised in east germany) about overthrowing feudal hierarchies, im pretty sure happy birthday doesnt advocate for revolution

    • @Schakuta
      @Schakuta Год назад

      @@eyraaaaaa first of all I never claimed it being a WWI song I was just telling you what I associate listening to this song to state that nothing in this song reminds me of communism. Second this song was literally in the official song book of the Nazi party and was written and composed by a later national socialist so the only group you could claim this song is belonging to are tha Nazis. And not even that is fitting in my opinion. Communists singing the same song is just as fucking stupid as the rest of their mentally ill ideology. So do you still claim this song is a communist song? If yes then probably no one can help you

    • @laceycollins8122
      @laceycollins8122 Год назад +1

      ​@@eyraaaaaaJust because it was popularized in the DDR dosnt mean it WAS made by the DDR. Kyrieleys is a greek word meaning lord have mercy. And you know the translation, because you made the vidio, YOU PUT IN THE TRANSLATION. If you have read the bible and know at least 50% of the HRE's history, you would lnow that the second verse is talking about Adam and eve, wich i shouldn't have to explain, and that the peasants were non-Catholics, so, yeah maybe read a book evry once in a while instead of sleep under it.

    • @SirAroace
      @SirAroace Год назад +7

      dude its a anti-noble, anti-church, pro-commoner song, while not exclusively used by communist it was still very much not a universal song like 'happy birthday', its a revolutionary song.

    • @ohnoes3084
      @ohnoes3084 Год назад

      @@SirAroace its alligned with the protestant movement at the time than anything close to marxism, if the revolt actually succeeded itd probably be at most a decentralized parliamentary system, similar to what the british protestants achieved when they won their civil war

  • @alejo1596
    @alejo1596 Год назад +8

    This song isn't communist

  • @dimasbely666
    @dimasbely666 10 месяцев назад

    Песня хорошая, но не немецких коммунистов🤔

  • @DeralteFritz-h3h
    @DeralteFritz-h3h 10 месяцев назад +3

    how the hech do you dare call it a communist song

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 2 месяца назад

      Des Edelmannes Töchterlein,
      Kyrieleis!
      Wir jagen sind die Höll hinein,
      Kyrieleis!
      Spieß voran, drauf und dran,
      Setzt aufs Klosterdach den roten Hahn!

  • @sjarahar6306
    @sjarahar6306 7 месяцев назад +1

    The songwriter literally had his card in the Nazi party, tankies sure are embarassing

  • @Pottatow
    @Pottatow Месяц назад

    This songs was WAY before communism.

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 24 дня назад +2

      This song was written after marx died.

  • @saulinabadwoman7187
    @saulinabadwoman7187 2 месяца назад

    Not a commie song and never will be. The melody was composed by a NatSoc.

    • @hakeyassi3675
      @hakeyassi3675 2 месяца назад +1

      Bullshit...this song is fivehundred years old.... before Blabla...knowing a bit of german history would be pleasure.....for you!

    • @saulinabadwoman7187
      @saulinabadwoman7187 2 месяца назад

      @@hakeyassi3675 this song was composed in the 20th century. It was based on the peasant revolt. You should read more.

  • @nwo_kimbo
    @nwo_kimbo Месяц назад

    🤡🤡🤡🤡

  • @iulianviorelmosteanu2800
    @iulianviorelmosteanu2800 9 месяцев назад

    The song has nothing to do with communists lmao. They would be against "communists", especially considering their values.

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  9 месяцев назад +7

      the song was commonly used by communists in the weimar republic and was performed by the east german army on many occasions, this song is associated with many political movements and for the purposes of this video, it is a communist one

    • @iulianviorelmosteanu2800
      @iulianviorelmosteanu2800 9 месяцев назад

      @@eyraaaaaa, I'm just saying what it's origins are.

    • @plarkons9849
      @plarkons9849 9 месяцев назад

      Nuh uh

  • @JesusFollower500
    @JesusFollower500 Год назад

    Horse shoe theory really does seem to have some prominence, then again it is national SOCIALISM...

    • @sandinokb-1
      @sandinokb-1 9 месяцев назад

      Sorry, but North Korea has the full name Democratic People's Republic of Korea. Don't trust the names

  • @николайигнатенко-у1э
    @николайигнатенко-у1э 8 месяцев назад +2

    Пралетарыi усiх краiн яднайцесь!

  • @fabriziop1183
    @fabriziop1183 3 дня назад

    Communist???? Nooooooooooooooooooo!!! STUDIA CAZZO!!! STUDIAAAA!!!!

  • @0374-x7c
    @0374-x7c Год назад +23

    This ain’t your song red

    • @Ma_ksi
      @Ma_ksi Год назад +47

      Cry

    • @0374-x7c
      @0374-x7c Год назад +12

      @@Ma_ksi how much can you bench just wondering

    • @eyraaaaaa
      @eyraaaaaa  Год назад +46

      @@0374-x7c please cope harder

    • @esothetics
      @esothetics Год назад +4

      oy gevalt

    • @TNOfan4093
      @TNOfan4093 Год назад +32

      Fascist tears are so tasty