If Colin who does 3 hours 5 days a week on sports radio. Plus nfl Sunday work, plus is a huge college and nfl fan doesn't know much about a coach who just got a top HC job in NY....... Yah, I'd be concerned if I'm a Giants fan.
To be fair to Judge, how good were the Pats WRs this year? Gordon isn't a Pro Bowl talent anymore. Edelman was banged up all year and dropped more passes tham anyone when he did play. AB was there for a game. Harry was on IR most of the year. The rest of the corps was full of back-up talents. On top of all that, Brady was missing throws and the o-line consistently got wrecked in pass pro.
Shaharyar Ahmed you don’t give a guy almost 8 - 9 million a year who never been a head coach in the NFL before. Bill Belichick makes 9 million a year. He not worth that kind of money. He also wanted final says on roster and personnel moves. That would be a dealbreaker for me and I’m a Giants fan.
@@sindesilva1166 reports say bb makes 12 million a year. He also is not part of the coaches union. He may be making other money that the league does not know about. Ruhle just won in life not sure what he can do with run CMC if there is not a good qb.
Jason Garrett sucks and everybody know it. If you gave Jason Garrett tom brady or aaron rodgers he would still lose. Those two guys are not the same. But these are the same people that said lamar jackson should be a WR.
Might just mean he's luckier than Garrett, not better than him. You don't get much luckier than having Aaron Rodgers save your season year after year (until he couldn't even do that).
That should be a red flag since Colin does this for a living. He talks to GM, executives, coaches and players. If he doesn't know much about a coach who just got an important job, that would worry me.
I actually agree with that. He had success at Baylor, but he hasn't won anything. Carolina paid way too much for him and they also have to pay Baylor to get him. Giants were gonna make him an offer, but not paying him more than some of the best coaches in the game before he's coached one game in the NFL.
Colin in 2020: "This is a bad hire" *2 years later, Joe Judge is a top tier coach* Colin in 2022: "I said Judge was a great hire from the start, told ya so"
this could go one of two ways it's another CLE situation with the Kitchens hire. or this guy really knows how to coach and the NYG were sold time will tell.
How can it be a Cleveland situation??? He didn't have a second with this QB much less the team now do you mean inexperienced??? How many teams in history have hired a first year or position coach for a HC job??? Please stop trying to sound analytical.
Kinda Strange that Wild Card Weekend just passed (it was a crazy one) and you haven't said anything about it... is it because you got all of your picks wrong????
Kevin T. Bad move for Cleveland, what they need is a guy to bring stability, a boring coach which will take you to 8-8 a few seasons bring a culture to build around before getting a better coach.
Sometimes a big name in a big city just don't work...just like you said you need someone who is not scared to pushback. From what I have read Joe is a no nonsense guy which is what we need.
Wasn't there a tweet correcting his tittle. He's actually the special teams coach and assistant wide receivers coach. But he's mainly the special teams coach first
“Belicheck’s coaching tree is an absolute mess” Mike Vrabel: Am I a joke to you? Edit: I know vrabel wasn’t a coach under Bill, but he played as a central part of Bill’s defense for 7 years
Plus the Packers didnt spend big money in free agency until this past year, and Mcarthy had to deal with an injured Aaron Rodgers for two years basically. I think he’ll be good in dallas
Michael Parker I still don’t understand why the Lions fired him. He only has 2 losing season as a head coach and one of those season it was because Peyton Manning got injured.
He also cost his team a perfect season, and couldn't win the sb with a better colts team than any of dungy's teams and with peyton having his best season ever
@@bumgod75 and belichick and pete Carroll blew superbowls..kyle Shanahan also blew a super bowl..now hes the best coach in the league arguably.. what u said makes no sense..nice try 🤦🏿♂️
I love how Colin completely overlooked that Joe Judge was also their SPECIAL TEAMS coach as well. New England's special teams was the best in the league. Idk if Joe Judge is gonna work out or not but this isn't a horrible hire.
Honestly I think Bieniemy is still waiting it out for the perfect job. He could’ve gotten one last year if he wanted but decided to stay. I think he is preparing for Houston and hedging his bets.
lol so much misinformation.. Giants didn't panic, they had a deal lined up monday night, Rhule called the Giants to match the offer the Panthers gave them and the Giants declined and went with their guy.
@Spencer Saltz Skins are a completely different team now. No Bruce Allen, Dan Snyder staying away from football moves, Ron Rivera the HC, Jack Del Rio DC (Bringing back 4-3) and a new OC in Scott Turner, can't forget Chase Young will likely be on that defense who will be back healthy...Reuben Foster comes back too
Chuck Sharts This is a team that has had Mike Shanahan, Joe Gibbs, and Marty Schottenheimer during the Dan Snyder era, and you think things are going to be different under Ron Rivera? You’re kidding me right?
As a Giants fan, you made me feel so much better about hiring Judge since you don't like him. Reports are Judge will have autonomy to hire his own staff so you're wrong about that. By the way, Bieniemy doesn't even call the plays for KC as an "offensive coordinator."
When cowboys miss the playoffs next year, hope you eat your words. Coaching isnt just about points but also about situations. The first game against Vikings, Packers scored 3 TDs in first half, that was surgical and efficient. Now MLF being a new HC, isnt able to adjust enough to put games away and he will improve on that but Packers score when it matters. Right call at the right time is coaching. Unlike MM who would call shot plays for no good reason.
@@joshuawood1436 Wow, what an insightful comment, I stand corrected on my limited football knowledge. If only the browns knew that an expert like you existed, they wouldn't have gone with freddie.
@@fantasyfootball804 "Fantasy Football 27 minutes ago @Joshua Wood Wow, what an insightful comment, I stand corrected on my limited football knowledge" This was the only thing you've said so far with merit. Leave it at that high note.
Okay first off, speaking of teams in the NY market... the yankees lately have built arguably a top 2 or 3 farm system in baseball by moving away from just spending money for everyone, THEN dropped huge money on Cole
When you coach for a mastermind like Belichick no one has to think for themselves....you just do your job that he tells you what to do. So im not surprised that coaches arent being developed out of that tree.
Devin H I think it’s more of a coaching style thing, belicheck is just hard to learn from. Some of the best coaches ever have produced elite coaches before, coaching trees are very much a thing
Because he hasn't had any impact on the Giants yet, Shurmur and Gettleman had impact that's how we know he's not gonna do well because the Giants are a product of Shurmur and Gettleman until they are gone
Colin he walked in, had the interview, and they wouldn’t let him walk out, this was the guy they wanted and he impressed them. Belichick handed over the SP Teams to this guy even though that’s what Belichick loved the most and the SP teams this year win them a few games and we’re great. I don’t know if he will be a good head coach but at least give the man time before judging this as awful.
I think you may be mistaken on a few fronts Colin. 1.that they didn't like Judge at first 2. that Rhule was their first choice 3. that they didn't have an opportunity at Rhule (they had a shot to counter) This smells Daniel Jones drafted at 6 reaction. Pump the brakes.
Now that it looks like Mcdaniels is going to the Browns Colin starts bashing McDaniels. When Mcarthy was going to the Browns he was bashing Mcarthy, now that he chose Cowboys he lists all his strengths and puts up a picture of how Mcarthy wasn't to blame in GB. Colin hates the Browns so much that his opinion changes on people if they somehow become affiliated with the Browns.
Bobby Gorbett 3 Belichick alumni beat Belichick this season: Bill O'Brien, Brian Flores, and Mike Vrabel. Matt Patricia beat him last year too, although he's a pretty terrible coach who somehow still has a job
Cameron Maier I'm aware, but look around at every media network or website. They all include Mike Vrabel in the Belichick coaching tree, because he was essentially a coach while he was playing for NE due to leadership
As a Native New Yorker. The giants along with the other poor NY franchises need to ignore the pressure of the fan base because we tend to lack any patience when it comes to building success. Make moves with more forward thinking along team builders and don't be cheap. We should have match that Panthers contract.
Hey Colin.. i was on the A hires A thing.. until you spout out that Belichick essentially hires C's.. i'm not good at math.. but that doesn't add up.......
Nobody on belichicks tree works...last time I looked Bill O'Brien in Texas and the Tenn Titans coach are still in playoffs with other pats coaches on their staffs.
The stats may not show it but I think Green Bay's offense actually took a step up this year. Especially because Lafleur has been feeding Jones the ball. Not statistically the best looking offense but Lafleur's gameplans have actually won us games
L for not mentioning the Special Teams work he's done and L for saying he'll bow to Gettleman. They said he's a tough guy and not afraid to get into it with players. Maximum potential is he's a Harbaugh but we'll have to see...
Patriots assistants under Bill Belichick to become head coaches elsewhere: Brian Flores 5-11 Matt Patricia 9-22-1 Bill O’Brien 54-47 Josh McDaniels 11-17 Eric Mangini 33-48 Romeo Crennel 28-55 Total: 140-200-1 (.412)
Harbaugh has had significant success in Baltimore on the back of an elite defense and a top notch running game. The Giants have no offensive line and a bottom 5 defensive roster. Good luck recreating Baltimore with the talent superstar GM Dave Gettleman has assembled.
@@eliasconnolly1973 I agree, nothing against Joe Judge. Gettleman is obviously the problem in NY; I just think the only priority for the Giants should be the development of their young QB... and the firing of Shumur and the hiring of a coach who has never directly worked with QB's should be all the evidence anyone needs to know where the Giants problems lie.
I actually think Joe will be good for New York. He might not be an OC/DC, BUT(and it's a big one) the only other coach that has to deal with offensive and defensive players at the same time is the WR/ST coachs, so arguably they're more prepared to be H/C than a OC/DC is who only deals with one or the other specifically
Will Joe Judge be a good fit for the Giants?
Worried.
idk we got to see how it plays out.
The Herd with Colin Cowherd my judgement: average joe
Colin is right this was a panic move
Why didn't they hire me? I'm breathing the same air as Belechick
NFL team: "You know Bill Belechick?"
Person: "I saw him walking in a park once."
NFL team: "Your hired!"
this is great
Same thing last year with mcvay
Lmfao
You’re ********
That's a copy of the joke last year with Mcvay. Anyone who had coffee with Mcvay gets a job
No one:
Colin: Andy Reid is a big bear.
Raiders fans: Hey Kool-Aid!
More like a big Walrus
Andy Reid never won anything
@@theheadphonea-hole4133 what have you accomplished? Clown
@S T, what are you talking about. He Ran the NFC East for like 10 years
“This is a bad hire”
“I don’t know much about this guy”
Inappropriate Content hey...
He texted this morning
Spot on, Colin was lazy on this take
@Steve Robbins lol agreed it's hilarious more than insightful.
If Colin who does 3 hours 5 days a week on sports radio. Plus nfl Sunday work, plus is a huge college and nfl fan doesn't know much about a coach who just got a top HC job in NY.......
Yah, I'd be concerned if I'm a Giants fan.
Inappropriate Content FACTS 😭
A's Hire A's and B's Hire C's. I love this statement for some reason.
Colin is an G hired by the F at Fox
that is so funny😂😂😂
So who hires the B’s? 🤔
So true, it’s why the browns have been bad for so long
Nothing proves competence like watching the scintillating patriots wr's this past season.
To be fair to Judge, how good were the Pats WRs this year? Gordon isn't a Pro Bowl talent anymore. Edelman was banged up all year and dropped more passes tham anyone when he did play. AB was there for a game. Harry was on IR most of the year. The rest of the corps was full of back-up talents.
On top of all that, Brady was missing throws and the o-line consistently got wrecked in pass pro.
He is a Special Teams coach for over a decade. Bill gave him the additional responsibility of WRs this season only.
If he hires the right staff, this could be rectified. But I don’t get this one at all.
@@TommyRibs thank you, everyone only talks about the wrs knowing damn well he was mainly the special teams coach
Where Colin was wrong...
fast foward, sir, you're wrong lol!
matt rule wanted the giants to match the offer but they declined
It was like 90 mill
Hilda Castoire So what? Doesn’t go against the salary cap
He gave them the respect of a call to give them a chance after he said he would meet them. That’s only the respectable thing to do
Shaharyar Ahmed you don’t give a guy almost 8 - 9 million a year who never been a head coach in the NFL before. Bill Belichick makes 9 million a year. He not worth that kind of money. He also wanted final says on roster and personnel moves. That would be a dealbreaker for me and I’m a Giants fan.
@@sindesilva1166 reports say bb makes 12 million a year. He also is not part of the coaches union. He may be making other money that the league does not know about. Ruhle just won in life not sure what he can do with run CMC if there is not a good qb.
He has the chance to be the second most popular guy with the last name Judge in New York.
I Aaron judge from the Yankees
Nice research, Colin. Rhule gave the Giants a last chance to match the offer before accepting, so you have no clue what you are talking about.
So what your saying is that the Giants are more incompetent than we thought? Lol
Michael Ferrari only idiots would turn Matt rhule down
John Anthony this is the best coaching hire since Bill belichek
Mccarthy is Garrett with a better resume... so, he’s better than Garrett then. 🤦🏼♂️
Jason Garrett sucks and everybody know it. If you gave Jason Garrett tom brady or aaron rodgers he would still lose. Those two guys are not the same. But these are the same people that said lamar jackson should be a WR.
@@curtisaallen Lamar Jackson is a RB, not a WR.
@@josebocanegra4477 he's just a quarterback that can run
Might just mean he's luckier than Garrett, not better than him. You don't get much luckier than having Aaron Rodgers save your season year after year (until he couldn't even do that).
Jose Bocanegra shut up José
Colin : " Brady is Rivers with better résumé "
Nassim El Ansari 😂😂😂
“Belichick is Joe Judge with a better résumé.”
Disrespectful to rivers tbh
Nah, Brady has made over 50 clutch throws in his career most in the playoffs, I cant remember one memorable throw from Rivers.
@@mushiana1476 for every clutch Brady throw theres 2 interceptions for Rivers
Hes the wide receivers and special teams coach. you failed to mention the special teams part which is always the best in the nfl for the pats.
This
@@adamswartz3272 And? The only thing he did was bash the wr part didnt even once say anything about the special teams. Did you even watch the video?
Colin: this is a bad move
Also Colin: I dont know him
That should be a red flag since Colin does this for a living. He talks to GM, executives, coaches and players. If he doesn't know much about a coach who just got an important job, that would worry me.
@@Kruppt808 and the funny thing is he got so much of his facts wrong.
Just Jug the last assistant to be hired was kitchens
Kruppt808 he’s a good luck charm half the things he says end up being wrong
@@Kruppt808 what??! This guy has a right and wrong segment bc HE KNOWS that he's wrong a lot of the times, but u take his word as gold?
Ummm... isn't overspending and reaching what happened with Rhule in Carolina?
No. Good hire
Giants had a chance at rhule but they wouldn't match the Panthers offer!! At least that's the latest news that came out..
I actually agree with that. He had success at Baylor, but he hasn't won anything. Carolina paid way too much for him and they also have to pay Baylor to get him. Giants were gonna make him an offer, but not paying him more than some of the best coaches in the game before he's coached one game in the NFL.
Colin "used bar of neutrogena soap" cowherd
I came to see if anybody else caught that😆😆😆
Colin "Elon's IQ is so greater than mine" Cowherd
At least hes self aware
Elon Musk would lose IQ points if he's anywhere near Colin.
Jose Bocanegra I like Colin but laughed at this
Colin has no IQ
@@josebocanegra4477 true
I'm gonna go work as a water boy at the New England. 2025 I'm finna be the Clevand head coach
Stand by for the first "Judge Joe" headline...
Brendan McCallion judging judge joe judges joe judges
Shannon sharpe beat the ny writers to it lol.
Judge Dredd
twitter.com/KingTeo19/status/1214645672885882881?s=19
Colin in 2020: "This is a bad hire"
*2 years later, Joe Judge is a top tier coach*
Colin in 2022: "I said Judge was a great hire from the start, told ya so"
Bigmoron03 Daniel Jones pt 2, ask everyone who didn’t like him not me
Can you clue me in on some great investments from 2022 or maybe powerball winners.
Oof.
I think Brian Flores will end the streak of Bellichick coaches not working in the NFL
this could go one of two ways it's another CLE situation with the Kitchens hire. or this guy really knows how to coach and the NYG were sold time will tell.
Or they go 8 - 8, and he's just average.
How can it be a Cleveland situation??? He didn't have a second with this QB much less the team now do you mean inexperienced??? How many teams in history have hired a first year or position coach for a HC job??? Please stop trying to sound analytical.
Droid Force an 8-8 season will be very good season for the giants next season
All he knows is special teams. Pat's special teams was really good under him. But that doesn't mean he can be a head coach..
Mike McCarthy Matt rhule and Jason garret all interviewed or wanted to interview with the giants so how can you say no one had interest lmao
Not to mention the OC for the chiefs and the DC for the ravens lmao
Kinda Strange that Wild Card Weekend just passed (it was a crazy one) and you haven't said anything about it... is it because you got all of your picks wrong????
The Real Reason he did
The Real Reason he did address it in Colin Right Colin Wrong but the RUclips channel never posts that
I just don't get how the Giants pass up on Bieniemy. I think CLE should seriously consider hiring Bieniemy.
Kevin T. Bad move for Cleveland, what they need is a guy to bring stability, a boring coach which will take you to 8-8 a few seasons bring a culture to build around before getting a better coach.
Who'd want to go to Cleveland. 😝😅
Jim Stokes McDaniels 🤷🏽♂️
"Proximity to genius.....doesn't equal genius" - Colin Cowherd.
I’m not saying it was a great move but at least give him a year in coaching
I can agree
Colin says "Gettleman's a B who hired a C". Colin is out cold 😆
Sometimes a big name in a big city just don't work...just like you said you need someone who is not scared to pushback. From what I have read Joe is a no nonsense guy which is what we need.
Wasn't there a tweet correcting his tittle. He's actually the special teams coach and assistant wide receivers coach. But he's mainly the special teams coach first
Shhhhh don't stop the narrative!
“Belicheck’s coaching tree is an absolute mess”
Mike Vrabel: Am I a joke to you?
Edit: I know vrabel wasn’t a coach under Bill, but he played as a central part of Bill’s defense for 7 years
He's not from the Bellichick coaching tree.
DoThaWork he played for the pats. I’m counting that
Bill o’ Brian: Am I a joke you you?
@@jackharris1398 let's go TEXANS!
Luis A. Yes sirrr
A’s hire A’s
B’s hire C’s
And the 2018 stats are with Rodgers tossing the ball out of bounds every play
He says I don’t know much about Judge and also says it’s a bad move. If you don’t know someone at all how can you have opinion about him ?
Judge will almost definitely be fired after the season.... right? Like this feels like Freddie Kitchens all over again.
Meme no cause the giants rnt the browns
Great move,
Sincerely,
Eagles Fans
Add cowboys fans to this note as well
Continue on believing Wentz can stay healthy for a deep playoff run.
Sincerely,
NFC East fan
@@ERizzo5 we have coach Dougie P that's all we need .. subservient Eastern dweller
Robert DiNella get back foles then, until then 😴
@@ERizzo5 and STILL NFC EAST CHAMPS
seems like a perfect coaching hire to me but, i am philadelphia eagles fans.....lol
How’s that working out
Pat Shurmur is from Andy Reid’s coaching tree
Plus the Packers didnt spend big money in free agency until this past year, and Mcarthy had to deal with an injured Aaron Rodgers for two years basically. I think he’ll be good in dallas
Also they passed on Jim Caldwell who actually made the lions look respectful
Michael Parker I still don’t understand why the Lions fired him. He only has 2 losing season as a head coach and one of those season it was because Peyton Manning got injured.
@@solomonbelay905 exactly!
He also cost his team a perfect season, and couldn't win the sb with a better colts team than any of dungy's teams and with peyton having his best season ever
@@bumgod75 and belichick and pete Carroll blew superbowls..kyle Shanahan also blew a super bowl..now hes the best coach in the league arguably.. what u said makes no sense..nice try 🤦🏿♂️
I love how Colin completely overlooked that Joe Judge was also their SPECIAL TEAMS coach as well. New England's special teams was the best in the league. Idk if Joe Judge is gonna work out or not but this isn't a horrible hire.
That's cute but has he ever been a head coach at any level ?
Patriots special teams has been elite since the day Matthew Slater walked in and well before Judge got there.
Chief W lol u don’t have to be a head coach before to be good. And just because u were a head coach does not mean that u will have success.
The Rooney Rule is BS, Eric Bienermy should have been gotten a job 😅
Honestly I think Bieniemy is still waiting it out for the perfect job. He could’ve gotten one last year if he wanted but decided to stay. I think he is preparing for Houston and hedging his bets.
Don’t forget the guy still has to accept the offer. I’m sure he has been offered head coaching spots, and apparently Cleveland is still in play.
So you are telling me a rule that forces teams to Interview people they do not want to interview is BS??? Really going out on a limb there
Didn't we just see this movie this year in Cleveland?
They should have hired Judge Joe Brown LMAO
lol so much misinformation.. Giants didn't panic, they had a deal lined up monday night, Rhule called the Giants to match the offer the Panthers gave them and the Giants declined and went with their guy.
They said these same things about DB's coach mike tomlin and special teams coach john haurbaugh
Well, the Giant's new coach is good news for the other NFC east teams 😂
The other NFC East teams will still find ways to mess up. Especially Washington.
@@KevinWieschhues Washington is still in better shape than the Giants.
Wentz never staying healthy for a playoff run is good news for NFC East fans. Maybe you can trade for Foles.
@Spencer Saltz Skins are a completely different team now. No Bruce Allen, Dan Snyder staying away from football moves, Ron Rivera the HC, Jack Del Rio DC (Bringing back 4-3) and a new OC in Scott Turner, can't forget Chase Young will likely be on that defense who will be back healthy...Reuben Foster comes back too
Chuck Sharts This is a team that has had Mike Shanahan, Joe Gibbs, and Marty Schottenheimer during the Dan Snyder era, and you think things are going to be different under Ron Rivera? You’re kidding me right?
Gentlemen should be fired after this move.
Colin: “let’s compare the packers with and without McCarthy”
Also colin: “but we’re not going to include defence of records”
As a Giants fan, you made me feel so much better about hiring Judge since you don't like him. Reports are Judge will have autonomy to hire his own staff so you're wrong about that. By the way, Bieniemy doesn't even call the plays for KC as an "offensive coordinator."
*USED BAR OF NUETRAGENA SOAP* had me in stitches man!😂
When cowboys miss the playoffs next year, hope you eat your words. Coaching isnt just about points but also about situations. The first game against Vikings, Packers scored 3 TDs in first half, that was surgical and efficient. Now MLF being a new HC, isnt able to adjust enough to put games away and he will improve on that but Packers score when it matters. Right call at the right time is coaching. Unlike MM who would call shot plays for no good reason.
Yet he won a SB, and went to the playoffs 9 times in 13 years.
You obviously are an expert though....
@@joshuawood1436 Aaron won a SB and took them to the playoffs so many times. Packers are 13-3 with a 1st year head coach. What does that tell you?
@@fantasyfootball804 That your knowledge of football is only as deep as your last google search.
@@joshuawood1436 Wow, what an insightful comment, I stand corrected on my limited football knowledge. If only the browns knew that an expert like you existed, they wouldn't have gone with freddie.
@@fantasyfootball804
"Fantasy Football
27 minutes ago
@Joshua Wood Wow, what an insightful comment, I stand corrected on my limited football knowledge"
This was the only thing you've said so far with merit.
Leave it at that high note.
Okay first off, speaking of teams in the NY market... the yankees lately have built arguably a top 2 or 3 farm system in baseball by moving away from just spending money for everyone, THEN dropped huge money on Cole
Judge Joe Brown to the Giants, damn!
When you coach for a mastermind like Belichick no one has to think for themselves....you just do your job that he tells you what to do. So im not surprised that coaches arent being developed out of that tree.
Devin H I think it’s more of a coaching style thing, belicheck is just hard to learn from. Some of the best coaches ever have produced elite coaches before, coaching trees are very much a thing
I believe NY had the opportunity to counter offer to get Rhule, but they declined. I don't think they "panicked"
I am a huge fan of my Vietnamese uncle, but I love the idea of teaching more than doing everything for my family.
When you follow your heart, you are TEACHABLE.
No one:
Colin: John HarBawwwwwwww
And Andy Reid's tree is basically Holmgren's tree. The 90's Packers had Holmgren, Reid, Gruden, and Mariucci, which is absurd.
Colin your on 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 keep it up YES YES YES LOL
1986Mrmatrix he’s wrong
how do you know it was a Gettleman decision to hire Judge? he recently said it's a collaborative effort we got to see first before we judge.
They said all this about Daniel Jones. Only time will tell
Media hate Giants lol
100% right about the guys who came out of the Bill Bilichick coaching tree...
As a Lions fan, I'm feeling the pain & anger with Patricia.. Lol
If you don't know alot about him.How can you say he is not going to do well.
Because he hasn't had any impact on the Giants yet, Shurmur and Gettleman had impact that's how we know he's not gonna do well because the Giants are a product of Shurmur and Gettleman until they are gone
Hopefully Gettleman allows the Judge to put the courtroom in order.
If Joe Judge fails, at least the puns will be glorious.
If Judge enters his press conference with Anthrax's I am the Law playing, I'm sold.
Colin he walked in, had the interview, and they wouldn’t let him walk out, this was the guy they wanted and he impressed them. Belichick handed over the SP Teams to this guy even though that’s what Belichick loved the most and the SP teams this year win them a few games and we’re great. I don’t know if he will be a good head coach but at least give the man time before judging this as awful.
Also Garrett is interviewing for the Giants as OC so he wants to be apart of the team too potentially.
Great post! Go Giants#1
Not a great post, this could be another Cleveland, GM's with egos destroy franchises of this hire doesn't work out... Man 🤣😖
As a Giants fan, I completely agree 100% with CC
I love going back and reading these lmao
"McCarthy is Garrett"
No. McCarthy is nothing like Jason Garrett.
AT ALL. One of Colin's classic dumb lines. lol
McCarthy has to be the most disrespected Super Bowl winning HC ever. Jerry Jones killed the game this offseason. No will he let him coach????
True, I don't think I have seen McCarthy clap like ever lol
Hands up who hates the Giants in the studio and is laughing behind the camera! Jokers!
You do realize you're going to eat your own words when JJ proves he can coach. The same you did with Danny Dimes.
The fact that you already think he’s wrong about Daniel Jones means you are just on the other side of the spectrum...
I think you may be mistaken on a few fronts Colin. 1.that they didn't like Judge at first 2. that Rhule was their first choice 3. that they didn't have an opportunity at Rhule (they had a shot to counter) This smells Daniel Jones drafted at 6 reaction. Pump the brakes.
Fun fact: 5 of the Coaches in the Playoffs are either Andy Reid or an ex-assistant (Harbaugh, McDermmit, Carrol, Peterson)
Now that it looks like Mcdaniels is going to the Browns Colin starts bashing McDaniels. When Mcarthy was going to the Browns he was bashing Mcarthy, now that he chose Cowboys he lists all his strengths and puts up a picture of how Mcarthy wasn't to blame in GB. Colin hates the Browns so much that his opinion changes on people if they somehow become affiliated with the Browns.
Patriots WR coach wasn't coaching his WRs good this year.
Giants let's get that guy to coach our entire team.
Hes the special team coordinator and took on the extra role to be the wr coach so hes not just some random wr coach they hired
Colin: None of Bill Belichick’s assistant have worked
Mike Vrabel and Bill O’brien coming off of playoff wins: Do I mean nothing to you?
Bobby Gorbett 3 Belichick alumni beat Belichick this season: Bill O'Brien, Brian Flores, and Mike Vrabel. Matt Patricia beat him last year too, although he's a pretty terrible coach who somehow still has a job
Vrabel didn't coach under belichick stupid he played for him
Cameron Maier I'm aware, but look around at every media network or website. They all include Mike Vrabel in the Belichick coaching tree, because he was essentially a coach while he was playing for NE due to leadership
@@jacobsilverman4645 ok boomer
As a Native New Yorker. The giants along with the other poor NY franchises need to ignore the pressure of the fan base because we tend to lack any patience when it comes to building success. Make moves with more forward thinking along team builders and don't be cheap. We should have match that Panthers contract.
Dude kneal harry was hurt almost all year.. that's why he didn't develop not bc of joe judge
Well, if the next season stinks, time to axe Gettleman as well as this Judge guy.
U are right
Stuck with both of them for 2 years unless some big shot coach wants the job
No you can’t do that. You going to be recycling. As a Giants fan, we have to be patient
Hey Colin.. i was on the A hires A thing.. until you spout out that Belichick essentially hires C's.. i'm not good at math.. but that doesn't add up.......
Nobody on belichicks tree works...last time I looked Bill O'Brien in Texas and the Tenn Titans coach are still in playoffs with other pats coaches on their staffs.
He also has it backwards. Reports say that the Giants were completing the deal last night which prompted Matt Rhule to take the Carolina job.
The stats may not show it but I think Green Bay's offense actually took a step up this year. Especially because Lafleur has been feeding Jones the ball. Not statistically the best looking offense but Lafleur's gameplans have actually won us games
L for not mentioning the Special Teams work he's done and L for saying he'll bow to Gettleman. They said he's a tough guy and not afraid to get into it with players. Maximum potential is he's a Harbaugh but we'll have to see...
Why is being a giants fan so painful
Patriots assistants under Bill Belichick to become head coaches elsewhere:
Brian Flores 5-11
Matt Patricia 9-22-1
Bill O’Brien 54-47
Josh McDaniels 11-17
Eric Mangini 33-48
Romeo Crennel 28-55
Total: 140-200-1 (.412)
If kliff kingsburry can get hired anybody can, is what I've learned
Brian Flores is good. So is O'Brien as a COACH not a GM. Vrabel is good too. Judge is next
Big panic move. It makes the Bengals hiring of Zac Taylor look better.
Last OC for Reid to leave was Nagy not Pederson
"I don't know much about this guy so it must be a bad hire"
AlmightyOxx exactly
Idk Man, that Special Teams Unit was on fire this year.... Think STC's are not good coaches? Look at John Harbaugh
Elias Connolly You should go watch pat mcafees video on Judge. You’ll be thoroughly entertained. Makes the same point as you.
@@noahobrien5725 yeah I saw it this morning, may have copied thoughts here haha. Interesting to see how Macaffee and Cowherd differ in opinion and why
Harbaugh has had significant success in Baltimore on the back of an elite defense and a top notch running game. The Giants have no offensive line and a bottom 5 defensive roster. Good luck recreating Baltimore with the talent superstar GM Dave Gettleman has assembled.
@@barn1980 That's fair, but then why Knock Joe Judge rather than the opening itself?
@@eliasconnolly1973 I agree, nothing against Joe Judge. Gettleman is obviously the problem in NY; I just think the only priority for the Giants should be the development of their young QB... and the firing of Shumur and the hiring of a coach who has never directly worked with QB's should be all the evidence anyone needs to know where the Giants problems lie.
Colin nailed this one.
I actually think Joe will be good for New York. He might not be an OC/DC, BUT(and it's a big one) the only other coach that has to deal with offensive and defensive players at the same time is the WR/ST coachs, so arguably they're more prepared to be H/C than a OC/DC is who only deals with one or the other specifically
I’m all in with Judge, let’s go GMen!
You cant really say a guy isn't a good hire and then say you dont know anything about him in the same breath.
Colin thank you for being honest we need to keep it real a waste of time and money. 3 and 12 season am done been a fan for 39yrs just more bs smh