HD| Is the Trinity Coherent? | Mohammed Hijab vs Dr. William Lane Craig

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 6 тыс.

  • @MohammedHijab
    @MohammedHijab  Месяц назад +639

    Audio error at 27:40, (it can be found on the stream version ruclips.net/user/livepepAv6Lz_ok).
    This is the text: You say that Muslim theologians don’t disagree about the who-ness of God well of course it’s true that Islam is a monotheistic religion and in the same way Christians agree on trinitarianism but the amount of disagreement about the nature of God and his attributes and so forth is just as diverse in Islam and Christianity as for the Holy Spirit you don’t need to wait until the fourth century for him to be granted full Divine status that occurs in the new Testament itself as I’ve already stated. Now with respect to the three wills I think that this follows from divine perfection you have three perfect persons who are equal in goodness omnipotence and omniscience and therefore it’s perfectly plausible that they would always agree and would not come into disharmony with each other so this is a Christian postulate that I think is perfectly reasonable.

    • @sarahk13peace
      @sarahk13peace Месяц назад +3

      Captions not available 😢

    • @riche1601
      @riche1601 Месяц назад +1

      alright thanks

    • @mikal1659
      @mikal1659 Месяц назад +6

      Great job akhi

    • @Blackpanther-bk1ir
      @Blackpanther-bk1ir Месяц назад +4

      Mashallah Mohamed hajib

    • @AaqilAhmed-zo8mm
      @AaqilAhmed-zo8mm Месяц назад +17

      Great debate @MohammedHijab, I want to point out that there were two times during the debate where the audio cut off for Dr.William

  • @smiletojannah
    @smiletojannah Месяц назад +2030

    William Lane Craig lost even before he compared God to a 3 headed dog 😂😂😂

    • @chickenprince841
      @chickenprince841 Месяц назад +57

      We heard Sun Analogies, Car Analogies, 3 headed dog Analogies, the next analogy would be of 10 headed Ravana😂😂😂

    • @learnenglishwithanawanmoi919
      @learnenglishwithanawanmoi919 Месяц назад +3

      Dog is Allah

    • @Twitch_icy
      @Twitch_icy Месяц назад +13

      Medusa ahh explaining

    • @xpacnwo2000
      @xpacnwo2000 Месяц назад +8

      That's what Hez no bollocks said lololol

    • @msf559
      @msf559 Месяц назад +10

      Hijab is not an effective debater. The actual problem is that if 3 minds consistently align in their gazillions of decisions and actions, then their wills are not entirely independent. Their are underlying supreme principle or the source from which the individual wills derive. In this way craig is placing a common ideal above them...

  • @mfahadfayt
    @mfahadfayt Месяц назад +1258

    'Indeed, falsehood is bound to vanish' ~ Qur'an

    • @Ppm1845
      @Ppm1845 Месяц назад

      It didn't. Started with 11 and is going on strong after 2000 years. Your Islam however doesn't like free speech and would kill people who don't bow. Difference.

    • @TS-zd2ud
      @TS-zd2ud Месяц назад +4

      *What your imams don't tell you*
      Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*

    • @TS-zd2ud
      @TS-zd2ud Месяц назад +1

      *What your imams don't tell you*
      Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
      *this is a mistake in the Qur'an!*

    • @amineouerdani8692
      @amineouerdani8692 Месяц назад +12

      @@TS-zd2ud in john 3 verse 16 , its says the begotten son of god , so yeah in christiannity they believe that jesus is the begotten son of god , if the son of god means a righteous prophet yeah it can be accepted but in the bible , lot of prophets were called son of god as they were righteous and virtuous people , so that doesnt make jesus more special than all of them , so there is no mistake my friend , u gotta educate yourself

    • @110_khanyasir4
      @110_khanyasir4 Месяц назад

      ​@@TS-zd2udwhat u don't understand is common sense that god is not a man but anyway ur too dumb to even understand what the word 'from' god means....

  • @aliisthetic
    @aliisthetic Месяц назад +1686

    im surprised he had the audacity to say that touheed is more confusing and complex then trinity get this man some help

    • @Main-event_Muhammad024
      @Main-event_Muhammad024 Месяц назад +68

      Wa'Allahi, I, too, am shocked he said it!

    • @ray_220
      @ray_220 Месяц назад +54

      He is trapped in the real matrix

    • @angelicentity1401
      @angelicentity1401 Месяц назад

      Muslims have liretally killed eachother over the understanding of touheed, sweep that under the rug I guess

    • @tempacct5812
      @tempacct5812 Месяц назад +36

      Audacious it was, arrogance in disbelief

    • @pingu.3712
      @pingu.3712 Месяц назад +5

      the salafi conception of tawhid is.

  • @HolyMonotony
    @HolyMonotony Месяц назад +611

    In regards to the Dr.s closing statement: I was born into a Muslim family, and stopped identifying as a Muslim or practicing for a few decades. I was fully agnostic and dabbling in spirituality, deeply seeking to know God or to understand God it to feel peace in my being. I am so grateful to have that perspective now, after returning with fresh eyes like a child. Learning to pray, learning the Quran, learning the seera of the prophet. I thank god everyday for my return to Islam.

    • @harmiel-brarero7029
      @harmiel-brarero7029 Месяц назад +17

      May Allah strengthen your faith!

    • @nahinisrat1182
      @nahinisrat1182 Месяц назад +5

      May Allah keep you steadfast in Deen and reward you immensely in this world and next. Ameen

    • @imranchoate
      @imranchoate Месяц назад +5

      May Allah aza wajjal continue to guide you. Ameen

    • @mumshorts
      @mumshorts Месяц назад +7

      Best thing is you were CHOSEN by Allah swt himself

    • @scottishbanjo
      @scottishbanjo Месяц назад

      What confirmed your faith ?

  • @r.rahman12
    @r.rahman12 Месяц назад +246

    *Is the Trinity Coherent? | Mohammed Hijab vs Dr. William Lane Craig*
    0:00:30 Introducing Dr William Lane Craig
    0:01:12 Introducing Mohammed Hijab
    0:01:39 Introducing topic, and format of the debate
    _The debate_
    0:02:09 Dr WLC's opening statement/remarks
    0:06:09 MH's opening statement/remarks
    0:09:29 Dr WLC's first response
    0:11:54 MH's first response
    0:14:19 Dr WLC's second response
    0:16:25 MH's second response
    0:18:49 Dr WLC's third response
    0:20:55 MH's third response
    0:24:00 Dr WLC's fourth response
    0:26:01 MH's fourth response
    0:27:40 Dr WLC's fifth response
    0:28:51 MH's fifth response
    0:30:15 Dr WLC's sixth response
    0:31:56 MH's sixth response
    0:33:08 Dr WLC's seventh response
    0:35:28 MH's seventh response
    0:38:04 Dr WLC's eighth response
    0:39:13 MH's eighth response
    0:40:29 Dr WLC's ninth response
    0:41:06 MH's ninth response
    0:43:14 Dr WLC's tenth response
    0:44:19 MH's tenth response
    0:46:26 Dr WLC's eleventh response
    0:47:30 MH's eleventh response
    0:49:57 Dr WLC's twelfth response
    0:51:26 MH's twelfth response
    0:53:17 Dr WLC's closing statement
    0:56:10 MH's closing statement
    0:59:15 Dr WLC's final comment on MH's views
    1:00:04 MH's final comment on Dr WLC's views
    1:01:15 Thanking the two debaters

  • @alcazar123456
    @alcazar123456 Месяц назад +1564

    I used to be a Christian. I struggled for decades to understand the Trinity. No one could even begin to explain it to me in a way that made logical sense.
    When I started studying Islam, it took me 3 seconds to understand Tawhid.
    Case closed.

    • @LightPr1nce
      @LightPr1nce Месяц назад +44

      Alhamdulillah ❤️ may ALLAH guide everyone to Islam

    • @MohmmedAhmedHussain
      @MohmmedAhmedHussain Месяц назад +19

      Mashallah ❤😊

    • @sethgyan
      @sethgyan Месяц назад +1

      3 seconds but Muslims have been killing each other for centuries 😂. You're smarter than them aren't you?

    • @Ppm1845
      @Ppm1845 Месяц назад

      Islam ain't an upgrade at all lmao. The mystery of God isn't something to be bragged by muslims as if they do, Sam shamoun would gladly destroy their claims as well. The only thing greater than Christianity factually is agnosticism.

    • @SuckonDeezonuts
      @SuckonDeezonuts Месяц назад +4

      Correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t think one’s ability to understand certain doctrines in religion is a testament to that particular religions falsity or truth.

  • @ZoroClutchTDM
    @ZoroClutchTDM Месяц назад +530

    Did he just say Tawhid is complex and hard to understand? Bro 😂

    • @yassine073t
      @yassine073t Месяц назад +29

      A 5 year old understands but he can’t even understand with his university papers 😂

    • @Alqahtani59
      @Alqahtani59 Месяц назад

      @@kevinmath007 calm down kevin boy 😂 The mother of your second was three years older than Lady Aisha when she married Joseph ، Does that mean that Joseph is a Ped ? And also Does this mean that your third god the Holy Spirit is a Ped because he pregnant a little girl the mother of your second god 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣? Typical Liberal Trinitarian Effeminate

    • @leebromley7987
      @leebromley7987 Месяц назад +6

      UnifiCATION!! Allah is the best of creatorS!! Sounds like more than 1 to me!

    • @thealpha4966
      @thealpha4966 Месяц назад +1

      Explain tawhid and who Allah is?

    • @hussainbukhari6460
      @hussainbukhari6460 Месяц назад

      ​@@kevinmath007pain in your ass is overflowing 😂😂😂😂

  • @FatimaBarkatulla
    @FatimaBarkatulla Месяц назад +142

    Excellent. How can a man 2000 years later claim to understand the trinity better than centuries of Christian scholars? Truth is that the trinity was a later creation, never part of the early Christian theology.

    • @FatimaBarkatulla
      @FatimaBarkatulla Месяц назад +9

      “1 god who is 3 persons” does equal nonsensical mumbo jumbo

    • @SawarimHaqq
      @SawarimHaqq Месяц назад +2

      Nice to see you here, sister!

    • @kosteh
      @kosteh Месяц назад

      Wanna debate this?

    • @FatimaBarkatulla
      @FatimaBarkatulla Месяц назад

      @@SawarimHaqq 😊

    • @DanSM-ij9fk
      @DanSM-ij9fk Месяц назад +2

      Dear Fatima
      Hijab...
      *Who is Powerful ? Triune God - God the Father, The Creator, God the Son, the redeemer (from our sins) and God the Holy Spirit The Sanctifier*
      or Man made Allah and His baqri as the redeemer to redeem from mankind sins, specially when comes to mass violences, murders,...?
      Muslims got it right ? or still want to follow single headed dictator false god and not the actual Creator The Father / Redeemer The Son/ Sanctifier The Holy Spirit, The Triune God ? Who calls you His Children and not slaves, choice is yours!!!

  • @PHX-576
    @PHX-576 Месяц назад +327

    Great debate.
    William Lane Craig is very respectful and well mannered.
    May Allah guide him.

    • @valonthegreat
      @valonthegreat Месяц назад +32

      Yes i do wish tho Mohammed was abit calmer. But i understand thats maybe a habit from speakers corner

    • @KallKall-i3u
      @KallKall-i3u Месяц назад +6

      ​@@valonthegreatyep that's his habit from speakers corner

    • @christophsurbeck2814
      @christophsurbeck2814 Месяц назад

      That's islams nature: Always blaming others, even for Hijabs self righteous and condescending character. Now you even blame speakers corner for it!!! There is not a bit of self criticism in islam as it seems.
      It implies speakers corner has more power over Hijabs character than islam...

    • @Alqahtani59
      @Alqahtani59 Месяц назад

      Amen

    • @sanhtu77
      @sanhtu77 Месяц назад

      hes aggressive cause hes insecure. also shows islam is an agressive religion. this set islam way back.

  • @shadazmi5402
    @shadazmi5402 Месяц назад +342

    لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا اللَّٰهُ مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ اللَّٰهِ

  • @petermckenzie580
    @petermckenzie580 Месяц назад +1019

    I am very grateful for this - it highlights how logical & correct Islam is. Islam is the greatest gift mankind has.

    • @theultimatetank2179
      @theultimatetank2179 Месяц назад +14

      Read what muhammad did to saffiyah then say this

    • @joejo7698
      @joejo7698 Месяц назад

      For me Quran cannot be truth is because:🤔
      Muhamad of Islam who was 50+ married a 6 years old girl ?🤯........Sunan Adi Dawad 2121,sahih bukhari 5158,sahih bukhari 5133
      ………………………………………….
      Holy man of Islam Married his daughter-in-law?...The history of Al-talbari vol VIII,page 4 ….Tafir Al Jalalayn,Quran,Sura Al-Ahzab,verse 36,Quran,Sura Al-Ahzab,verse 37,Quran,Sura Al-Ahzab,verse 50,Prophet Muhammad's privilege no. 10,
      Allah comes to help him by telling the guest to leave early from this wedding?...Quran,Sura Al-Ahzab,verse 53
      ………………...
      Married a slave after murdering the whole family and her husband? ….Sahih Muslim, book 8,no.3329...Sahih Bukhari,no.2228...The Life of Muhamad : Al-Waqidi's Kitab al-Magahazi,p.332,editor:Riziwi Faizer….Sahih Muslim,book 8, No 3328
      A soldier, guided outside for the night was worried for holyman? He was worried the lady may kill him, after what he did to her family.... The history of al-Tabari vol 39,p.185
      …………………………………
      Leave Islam, and you will be KXXX?.....Sunan an-Nasa'i 4059
      …………………………………...
      Hates with Jews???.....Sahih Muslim 2922
      Sunan Adi Dawud 3030
      Sahih bukari 3399
      ……………………………………….
      Women are domestic animal? AL Tabari Ref: vol 9, page 113
      ………………………………….
      Can have right hands posses(sex slave)?...Quran Surat An-Nisa 4:3,Quran 23.6, QURAN 33.50
      ………………………………………
      woman's silence is her affirmation to marriage? ...Sahih Muslim 1421c
      ……………………………………..
      Tried to k!ll himself(Muhmmad)?.....Sahih al-Bukhari 6982,Tarikh al-Tabari, vol 2 by Al Tabari
      …………………………………………..
      Called all women devils and are more in hell?.....sahih al-Bukhari 304, sahih muslim 36:6596, sahih muslim 36:6598,sahih Bukhari 1:6:301,Quran 2:282,Sahih Muslim 1403a
      ……………………………………………...
      muslim women are half intelligent?
      sahih al bukhari 2658, Quran 2:282,Quran 4:11
      ……………………………..
      Muhammad, Got caught having sex with his slave by his wife?...,Tafsir Jalalayan Quran 66.1...sunan an Nasa'i3959
      ……………………………………..
      Because of EVE, women betrays her husband?
      Sahih al-Bukhari 3399
      …………………………….
      when a muslim women gets divorce by her husband, SHE have to marry another men if she wants to get her old husband back again?Sunan an-Nasai 3411
      …………………...
      Nearly divorced his wife ? In Islam as long as women is old a man can divorce her??? Jami'at-Tirmidhi 3040, sahih bukhari 2694
      ……………………………….
      Had no money to give his wife? Allah come to help him not by giving him money but by threatening his wife for asking money?...Sahih Muslim 1478
      ………………………………...
      Muhammad's Wife had only one undergarment?....Sahih al- Bukhari 312
      …………………………………..
      Drink Camel's urine?? Sahih al-Bukhari 5686
      …………………………………….
      Told a women to breastfeed an adult man ?...Sunan Ibn Majah vol 3,book9,hadith 1943, Sahih Muslim 1453a
      But a women cannot breastfeed ? ……….
      Sunnah reference : Book 30, Hadith 14
      USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 30, Hadith 13
      Arabic reference : Book 30, Hadith 1288
      ……………
      Islam scholar says you can see a muslim women naked??? if you want to marry her? ….Sahih Bukharri 2624(Dawood Zahiri(815-883Ad),(Imam Al Awazai(207.774AD)
      …………………………………….
      Forgive a man who k!ll his pregnant slave just because she was not happy with him? ....sunan an naisa'i 4070
      Beats his wife?...Sahih Muslim / Book 4 / Hadith 2127
      ………………………………...
      K!ll children?...……..Sahih muslim 1745c,sahih muslim 4550
      ………………………………...
      Sold and bought sex slaves? Al-Sunnan al-Kubra’ Volume 2 page 227, Sunan an-Nasa'i 4184,sahih al bukhari 4138,Sunan an Nasa'i 4621,Sunan an Nasa'i 4050
      ………………………………….
      How Prophet Muhammad die? Quran, Surah Al-Haqqah, v. 44-46...then read this... Sahih al-Bukhari 4428
      ……………………………...
      Allah have shin(a body part)? Sahih al bhukhari 7439
      ………………………………………….
      LAST HOUR IS Coming or OVER?...sahih muslim 2953b
      …………………………………………..
      Everyone is touched BY DEVILS?....Sahih Bukhari 3286
      ……………………………………..
      7 Ajwa dates every morning will not be affected by POISON?.....Sahih al-Bukhari 5445
      ………………………………………...
      How Prophet Muhammad die? Quran, Surah Al-Haqqah, v. 44-46...then read this... Sahih al-Bukhari 4428
      ……………………………..
      Islam says Muslims are the best of people ever raised up for mankind, so they are allowed to bring non believe with chains on their neck????. Sahih al-Bukhari 4557
      …………………………………….
      Allows Girl Child marriage? Surah At-Talaq(Quran 65.4)
      ……………………….
      Sahih al-Bukhari 1341(non believers are "worst creatures"?)
      .........................
      Allah Astray you? Surah Araf (Quran 7.178)
      …………………………….
      REF> Ex muslim Sahil and Adam seeker and Ex-Muslim Zafar Heretic

    • @itachi4670
      @itachi4670 Месяц назад

      you are also bruh😊 bcs u are not dnying the truth. Allah wanted u to become a Muslim

    • @AlAmin-ir3xs
      @AlAmin-ir3xs Месяц назад +28

      Deuteronomy 21:10-14 if you see a beutiful woman among the captive and are attracted to her you may take her as your wife.Bring her into your home where she must shave her head and cut her nails and change the clothes she was wearing when you captured her.

    • @AlAmin-ir3xs
      @AlAmin-ir3xs Месяц назад

      ​@@theultimatetank2179your god has no problem to cammand his worshippers to sleep with captive woman

  • @robertpetkes2495
    @robertpetkes2495 Месяц назад +128

    Amazing debate!! Once again, Islam proves to be the truth without having to do mental gymnastics.
    Alhamdulillah, after being atheist for 10 years Allah guided me towards the right path.
    I hope He will guide the rest of those who are ready to find the truth and the right path. In Shaa Allah!

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад +6

      You have to be joking. Hijab failed to show any incoherence with the Trinity and ran away whenever Craig talked about the issues of the Muslim view of tawhid (far from a general monotheism). Hijab barely made any arguments except attacking Craig, and when he did, Craig easily refuted it while managing to hold back laughter. This was like a kindergartener with a beard who thinks he has an amazing argument getting refuted by the teacher but stubbornly sticking with it and declaring himself the winner. This is the best Islam has got?
      And Islam denies one of the most obvious facts of history--that Jesus was crucified. If you honestly believe that, you have thrown out all care for evidence and history. But you seem smarter than that, so I encourage you to look into how 100% of the evidence from the 1st century shows Jesus was crucified, and then ask yourself why He was and why Muhammad got this wrong. May the true God lead you to a true relationship with Him that leads to confidence of eternal life. ❤

    • @KIWINATION
      @KIWINATION Месяц назад +2

      ​@@James-ny2xl the truth is a hard pill to swallow. Navigating christian Theology is like driving with extremely blurred vision; in the end, you must rely on faith alone to get to your destination. With Islam, your destination can be seen as if it is right in front of you. Even when your faith is low, you are absolutely certain of your destination. I'm lucky to be guided from a blind christian to an able Muslim. Alhamdulillah!

  • @darwinsantos3446
    @darwinsantos3446 Месяц назад +192

    as prophet Yusuf says in the Quran “O my fellow-prisoners! Which is far better: many different lords or God -the One, the Supreme? Whatever ˹idols˺ you worship instead of Him are mere names which you and your forefathers have made up-a practice Allah has never authorized. It is only Allah Who decides. He has commanded that you worship none but Him. That is the upright faith, but most people do not know “ …this really applies to the Christian’s , the trinity is a man made concept that God never authorized

    • @darealkezz806
      @darealkezz806 Месяц назад

      How do you know the Quran is from God?
      Muslims: The Quran said so
      How do you know God said so?
      Muslims: Mohammed said so
      How do you know Mohammed wasn’t lying?
      Muslims: The Quran said he wasn’t
      Who told you to believe the Quran?
      MOHAMMED
      Did anyone else see the angels or hear the revelations?
      Muslims: No
      So why do you trust Mohammed?
      Muslims: Because the Quran said he’s Perfect
      Who told you to trust the Quran?
      MOHAMMED
      This logic is why Muslims should be the most pitied people.

    • @gherrocrucible
      @gherrocrucible Месяц назад +3

      Ameen

    • @Machoman50ta
      @Machoman50ta Месяц назад

      @@gherrocruciblethe amount of Muslims posing as Christian’s in the topped liked and hearted comments is disgusting and the fact all of you are spamming the comments with lies look up SAM shamoun and come back and apologize

    • @Catolicodeguerra
      @Catolicodeguerra Месяц назад +1

      @@gherrocruciblethe amount of Muslims posing as Christian’s in the top and hearted comments is disgusting we can’t even have an even comment section without lies you know what dies and look up SAM I can’t spell his full name but come back and apologize once he opens all of your eyes

    • @Catolicodeguerra
      @Catolicodeguerra Месяц назад

      @@Machoman50tamy comment was deleted this channel is wild hateful against humans

  • @studytechnology7871
    @studytechnology7871 Месяц назад +289

    Probably the best hadith you’ll ever hear
    Aws bin Aws narrated:
    Allah's Messenger said to me:
    "Whoever performs Ghusl on Friday, and
    bathes completely, and goes early,
    arriving early, gets close and listens and
    is silent, there will be for him in every
    step he take the reward of a year of
    fasting and standing (in prayer).
    At-Tirmidhi (496)
    Sahih hadith

    • @unicornshereen2316
      @unicornshereen2316 Месяц назад +1

      Thankyou for this

    • @gherrocrucible
      @gherrocrucible Месяц назад +1

      This in fact is truth. The blessings for doing this however is obtaining knowledge to guard against evil. That is the purpose of leaving all of your worldly obligations and desires to listen amd contemplate the recitation if the Qurán.

    • @zinoubensalah8939
      @zinoubensalah8939 Месяц назад +1

      i struggle to understand if coming early and listening means coming before the first athan because that wasn't a thing in the time of the prophet, does anyone have a source that talks about it? is the lecture in between the athans and before khutba count in order fot you to take that reward?

    • @gherrocrucible
      @gherrocrucible Месяц назад +1

      @@zinoubensalah8939
      I think you misunderstood the purpose to go to the Mosque. It is not required for you to go to the mosque. What is required of you is that if you go to a mosque that you go there clean... bathed is better so that you go to learn the Qurán untethered and relaxed to absorb the knowledge.
      Now if you choose to stay home or go home for Jummah you would do the same but you would read Qurán on your own or with your family.
      Basically going to the mosque at the time of prophet Muhammad was because he was the only one with the knowledge to impart to others.
      Now we have Qurán everywhere. I can't think of any person that calls themselves muslim not owning a Qurán.
      So again the importance of these gatherings is for the sake of knowledge to be guided aright and to begin tue discipline required to fulfill your covenant with Allāh without fail not exceeding the limits of your desires within your hearts.

    • @axxel9626
      @axxel9626 Месяц назад

      Read the hadiths where muhammad rapes aisha or where allah acts like satan.

  • @Urdupinnacle
    @Urdupinnacle Месяц назад +292

    For the past 2 years im listening to This kind of debates
    But i never found any 2 Christians who believe in the same way ...
    Everyone has its own definition and understanding

    • @zhamed9587
      @zhamed9587 Месяц назад +31

      This is what happens when there is no real scholarship and truth on their side. Alhamdulillah, Islam is the only religion that holds up to the highest rigor.

    • @samtv6447
      @samtv6447 Месяц назад +2

      Then turn to the Bible and understand it also just watch Sam shamoun description of it don’t let people dictate what your belief is look into the Bible

    • @burakcoskun38
      @burakcoskun38 Месяц назад +15

      ​@@samtv6447did, came to the conclusion that the Bible is a man made book with Many contradictions

    • @ohmygod_rickey
      @ohmygod_rickey Месяц назад

      @@burakcoskun38same goes for Quran

    • @ITX-HUR
      @ITX-HUR Месяц назад +3

      Just like our Santani or Hindu friend.. it's all gone pagans

  • @MWA1407
    @MWA1407 Месяц назад +251

    I left Christianity due to this very reason.

    • @Dylan_Lino
      @Dylan_Lino Месяц назад +15

      Same

    • @whiteandblack2005
      @whiteandblack2005 Месяц назад

      @@MWA1407
      Did you come to Islam?
      The religious historian and philosopher Han-Joachim Schoeps says: “Here is a paradox of world-historical proportions: Jewish Christianity indeed disappeared within the Christian church, but was PRESERVED in Islam.”
      (Caps mine)
      ******************
      Backed up by the preaching and practice of Jesus of the Bible.
      ******************
      "There is CONSENSUS among biblical scholars that Jesus, to all historical probability, did NOT consider himself as the incarnation of the second person of a Trinitarian God. NOWHERE did Jesus teach a Trinitarian doctrine. As one would expect from a pious Jewish rabbi, he believed in ONE GOD and strictly REFUSED to be equated with God. Jesus saw himself as a divinely authorized MESSENGER ... [and] his contemporaries [saw] Jesus as a PROPHET..." (Perry Schmidt-Leukel, Religious Pluralism, 152)
      Caps mine

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад +10

      Come back to the light. As you could see in the debate, Hijab failed to show anything incoherent about God being eternally relational. Craig only had 2 minutes each time to reply to these weak arguments, and he still did an excellent job with that. For further explanation, I encourage you to check out his long-form content. It takes 10 seconds to write an equation but much longer to solve it and show exactly how it was solved, so an extended answer would be even more helpful.
      According to the primary and secondary accounts of the eyewitnesses, Jesus contradicted Islamic belief hundreds of times. It is clear from Jesus' words and the words of His disciples that Jesus is God, but what is even more obvious and can't even be debated by any serious scholar is that Jesus contradicted what Muhammad would later invent and teach and therefore, according to Jesus, Islam is false.
      May the true Lord bless you! ❤️

    • @whiteandblack2005
      @whiteandblack2005 Месяц назад +10

      @@James-ny2xl
      The religious historian and philosopher Han-Joachim Schoeps says: “Here is a paradox of world-historical proportions: Jewish Christianity indeed disappeared within the Christian church, but was PRESERVED in Islam.”
      (Caps mine)
      ******************
      👉 Backed up by the preaching and practice of Jesus of the Bible.
      ******************
      "There is CONSENSUS among biblical scholars that Jesus, to all historical probability, did NOT consider himself as the incarnation of the second person of a Trinitarian God. NOWHERE did Jesus teach a Trinitarian doctrine. As one would expect from a pious Jewish rabbi, he believed in ONE GOD and strictly REFUSED to be equated with God. Jesus saw himself as a divinely authorized MESSENGER ... [and] his contemporaries [saw] Jesus as a PROPHET..." (Perry Schmidt-Leukel, Religious Pluralism, 152)
      Caps mine

    • @whiteandblack2005
      @whiteandblack2005 Месяц назад +4

      @@James-ny2xl
      The Son aka Jesus of the Bible preached and practiced:
      1) Who is THE ONLY TRUE GOD?
      ✅ The Father
      (John 17:3)
      2) Who is the God of the Son aka Jesus?
      ✅ The Father
      (John 20:17)
      3) Who alone to be worshipped as God?
      ✅ The Father
      (John 4:21)
      4) Whose name be hallowed?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)
      5) Whose kingdom come?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)
      6) Whose will be done on earth as it is in heaven?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)
      7) Whom to ask for daily bread?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)
      8) Whom to ask for forgiveness?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)
      9) Whom to pray to for guidance?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)
      10) Who delivers from the e-v-i-l one?
      ✅ The Father
      (The Lord's prayer)

  • @hatajusic3568
    @hatajusic3568 Месяц назад +73

    Alhamdulilah for Islam ☪️ ❤

  • @Harisfzal
    @Harisfzal Месяц назад +142

    If he couldn't defend trinity then yeah it should be a done deal now

    • @__________________________5338
      @__________________________5338 Месяц назад +2

      WLC is a heretic doctrinally. It was 2 non trinitarians talking about the trinity. Hilarious

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад +1

      He did though. He refuted every weak argument Hijab threw out. Just because Hijab declares himself the winner doesn't make it true.
      And Craig could have given much more in-depth responses to these weak arguments if he had had more time. Hijab was saved by the bell from further humiliation.

    • @priqito
      @priqito Месяц назад +2

      ​@@James-ny2xl the truth and logic prevail 😂 Christians them self don't agree and 100 Christians will give you 101 different explanation of the trinity 😮 Christianity is not logic but just faith and believe 😮😢

  • @nathierabrahams5639
    @nathierabrahams5639 Месяц назад +39

    Jazakala for the upload , was struggling to watch the other video

  • @jamdoughnut1873
    @jamdoughnut1873 Месяц назад +57

    By his own admission, this doctrine is taught in the new testemant, not the Old Testament and never taught by other previous prophets. In other words, a great innovation.

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад

      Do you believe Allah taught everything about himself in the first chapter of the Quran? Of course not. God continued to reveal more of Himself as time went on, so while aspects of God's triunity are in the Old Testament, of course we get more in the New Testament. Praise God!
      In the OT, we get a level 1 and 2 understanding of God, then when we've learned that, God goes on to give us level 3 understanding. And when we get to Heaven, we will see there is so much more about God He hasn't revealed to us yet. Praise God!
      May the Lord open your eyes and show you that Jesus died (to deny this is to deny history and all evidence, as Muslim apologists often do) and rose from the dead and reveal to you why He chose to do that ❤

    • @jamdoughnut1873
      @jamdoughnut1873 Месяц назад

      @@James-ny2xl please just stop. Aspects of a triune God are not in the Old Testament which is probably why the entire history of Judaism seems to be oblivious to this point 😂 . And seems even according to you guys, all the previous prophets and all of their followers who lived before the advent of Jesus will be going to heaven whilst believing in the Muslim God and not the man God you worship. The unverifiable origins of Christianity, textual criticism etc as well as the evidence for and Gods message in the Quran make it abundantly clear your triune God is one of the greatest innovations in monotheism. Please just stop. Christianity has become so embarrassing it hurts.

    • @benjaminweaver535
      @benjaminweaver535 Месяц назад

      @@jamdoughnut1873 the trinity can be seen also in the Old Testament

    • @whiteandblack2005
      @whiteandblack2005 Месяц назад

      @@benjaminweaver535
      When you read your FAITH INTO the text.

    • @benjaminweaver535
      @benjaminweaver535 Месяц назад

      @@whiteandblack2005 easily seen in Old Testament if you have sense

  • @LeonTheGeeee
    @LeonTheGeeee Месяц назад +245

    In response to Dr LC’s closing statement… I was raised believing in God but having a Muslim father and Christian mother and therefore Christian and Muslim family members. What I’ve found is that most of my Christian family have became increasingly less aligned with Christianity and more aligned with atheism or agnosticism. However all of my Muslim family have remained Muslim. This doesn’t prove anything but this along with other factors does show the strength and continuation of the Islamic belief within my family tree. I have became Muslim in recent years after learning lots of different facts about both religions and comparing them. I found that so many aspects of the Christian theology has contradictions (especially the trinity) and there is a clear failure of preservation of the bible.
    In Islam everything made sense to me and answered all my questions that I had before about God and religion. I have also found that not a single Christian is sure of their faith and they simply have nothing but faith to rely on, whereas Muslims have both faith and logic/reasoning. I have also found that Muslims r more confident in debates as a result of how confident they r that their faith is true.
    I even heard Christian’s (that I’ve debated with and those who I’ve seen in interviews) admitting to having “blind faith” in Christianity but believing cause they ‘have had experiences or visions or feelings that Christianity is true. I’m convinced that my mother will eventually accept Islam as she is struggling to refute my points and she herself can’t grasp the trinity but believes that Jesus is the son of God and that the actual God is the father and that the Holy Spirit also exists but she doesn’t understand the actual Christian belief that the trinity is co-equal and she doesn’t believe to at Jesus is God. Even most of my friends that were raised Christian have became more agnostic due to the contradictions in Christianity but they aren’t really interested enough about religion and God to learn about and explore Islam.
    I also believe that because I wasn’t brought up Muslim and became Muslim due to reasoning between religions, I am more confident that it’s the truth.

    • @roaaalashhab7261
      @roaaalashhab7261 Месяц назад +6

      Mashalla bro happy to hear your story. may Allah grant you jannah

    • @mosamee8003
      @mosamee8003 Месяц назад +5

      May Allah guide us all and your mother

    • @abdoswid2776
      @abdoswid2776 Месяц назад +2

      ❤❤

    • @LeonTheGeeee
      @LeonTheGeeee Месяц назад +2

      @@roaaalashhab7261 ameen brother, you too inshallah ❤️

    • @LeonTheGeeee
      @LeonTheGeeee Месяц назад +1

      @@mosamee8003 Ameen

  • @xiayolevis6033
    @xiayolevis6033 Месяц назад +85

    Atleast Dr.William had the guts to debate big shots unlike christian missionaries and APUS only choosing to debate unknown random new faces in Modern day debate. 😂😂.. And still they loose

    • @pavelcrestin1
      @pavelcrestin1 Месяц назад +2

      Why does not Hijab debate Sam Shamoun or Jay Dyer?

    • @Umar-qy3bd
      @Umar-qy3bd Месяц назад +21

      @@pavelcrestin1 Why did Hijab not Debate with a bunch of gremlins in the RUclips comment section?
      Simple, because they aren't on his level.
      I'm pretty sure he also said that he only debates those with a large enough following and good credibility. He isn't going to give attention to a bunch of nobodies.

    • @Khalid-Haji
      @Khalid-Haji Месяц назад

      @@Umar-qy3bd 💯

    • @TheLegend2000AD
      @TheLegend2000AD Месяц назад

      mopus was scared of dogs 😱🐩😂

  • @truthinknowledge8312
    @truthinknowledge8312 Месяц назад +353

    After this phenomenal debate performance from Hijab, I think there is no one left to debate. It's time to seek competition on another planet, because it's very clear there is no longer any competition here on planet earth. Allahu Akbar!

    • @luife06
      @luife06 Месяц назад

      Dont be disengenuous and arrogant, you knownwell hijab is scared of bob from of speakers corners and sam shamoun

    • @ms7b101
      @ms7b101 Месяц назад

      ​@@luife06
      Sam the cucko? That midget doesn't come close to mo.

    • @sumafratv6943
      @sumafratv6943 Месяц назад +1

      There are Hindu scholars who got that much knowledge that worshipped by their lund bhakt yet none of them are ready to face dawahwise or Muhammad hijab 😅😅

    • @Therealdudeman
      @Therealdudeman Месяц назад +6

      @@sumafratv6943yeh ok 😂

    • @Syakirin57
      @Syakirin57 Месяц назад +29

      @@sumafratv6943They all already been put down by Dr Zakir Naik. Not sure if any of them even want to join high level academic debates like this.

  • @alqubrusia
    @alqubrusia Месяц назад +9

    I have been a Muslim for 15 years, previously a Christian. Tawheed is simple to understand Alhamdulillah ☝️

    • @seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388
      @seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 Месяц назад

      Yet Allah copies to make a counterfeit 3 of himself, his lifeless word in paradise which intercedes on judgment day and the spirit in jibreel which created isa, an angel mankind hybrid by bowling in Maryam privates ( 3 of Allah word spirit)

    • @seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388
      @seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 Месяц назад

      Allah is one what? Oneness with whom/ what?

    • @leebromley7987
      @leebromley7987 Месяц назад

      You were never a Christian brother, sadly! You left the god you didn’t know, for the prophet you don’t know!

    • @Leopard_Star5667
      @Leopard_Star5667 13 дней назад

      @@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388low tier arguments

  • @its7136
    @its7136 Месяц назад +225

    After this debate Christian trinitarian god is a :
    1. 3 headed dog 🐶
    2. 3 flames 🔥 in one candle🕯
    3. 3 headed cat 🙀 in one skeleton

    • @chickenprince841
      @chickenprince841 Месяц назад +36

      You forgot he's a car too...😂😂

    • @raza3378
      @raza3378 Месяц назад +1

      😂😂

    • @PEGangstrr
      @PEGangstrr Месяц назад

      Could be worse, you could be a Muslim and follow a god who sent a pedophile to be his prophet 😂

    • @ridingtheologan
      @ridingtheologan Месяц назад

      I yes, according to them, God is like an egg too. They know no bounds these pagan minded misguided ones.

    • @angelicentity1401
      @angelicentity1401 Месяц назад +1

      Better than plagiarized aryanism

  • @ashifhassan1148
    @ashifhassan1148 Месяц назад +130

    Brother Hijab dominated the debate by dismantling the logical incoherences and contradictions within the doctrine of the Trinity. He not only exposed the flaws in Dr. Craig’s analogies but also revealed Craig’s heretical views, which diverge significantly from mainstream Christianity. Hijab effectively critiqued Craig’s rejection of the eternal generation of the Son and his partialist views, while also highlighting the contradictions in the mainstream Christian understanding of the Trinity itself. His deep engagement with logic and philosophy made his argument far more compelling and rigorous.

    • @nathandurant2825
      @nathandurant2825 Месяц назад

      Muslims repeating the same points they don't even understand doesn't make them true

    • @muhammedashil1779
      @muhammedashil1779 Месяц назад +11

      No example can coherently explain the Trinity as the concept itself is a logical contradiction.

    • @DebatesandDialogues
      @DebatesandDialogues Месяц назад +7

      If the father is not identical to the son and holy spirit, then we have to concede that we are talking about three gods not one God.

    • @Textual_Discoveries
      @Textual_Discoveries Месяц назад +5

      Brother Jake Blancatella's Trinity series are good. He clearly explains the logical problems of the Trinity.

    • @ghostlycookie630
      @ghostlycookie630 Месяц назад +3

      Bro did you watch the same debate? Dr. Craig took the W in this one.

  • @charliefoxtrotter
    @charliefoxtrotter Месяц назад +75

    very surprised to see dr craig so unprepared, and that unable to defend trinity, he clumsily attempted to deflect to tawheed.

    • @nazeemsultan1038
      @nazeemsultan1038 Месяц назад +33

      There is no amount of preparation that can help you explain the trinity. They had 2000 years to prepare

    • @MG-cc9hi
      @MG-cc9hi Месяц назад +23

      @@nazeemsultan1038 Even if Muslims and Christians disagree with what Jesus's message was, we can all agree that Abraham and Moses never preached or believed in the Trinity. On the Day of Judgement, the Muslims end up wherever Abraham and Moses end up and we all know the Prophets, peace and blessings upon them all, are going to Paradise.

    • @darealkezz806
      @darealkezz806 Месяц назад

      How do you know the Quran is from God?
      Muslims: The Quran said so
      How do you know God said so?
      Muslims: Mohammed said so
      How do you know Mohammed wasn’t lying?
      Muslims: The Quran said he wasn’t
      Who told you to believe the Quran?
      MOHAMMED
      Did anyone else see the angels or hear the revelations?
      Muslims: No
      So why do you trust Mohammed?
      Muslims: Because the Quran said he’s Perfect
      Who told you to trust the Quran?
      MOHAMMED
      This logic is why Muslims should be the most pitied people.

    • @Khalid-Haji
      @Khalid-Haji Месяц назад +9

      @@MG-cc9hi what a beautiful point of view 👏

    • @gherrocrucible
      @gherrocrucible Месяц назад

      He is old... In error and old. 🥺😔

  • @AnswerEasy
    @AnswerEasy Месяц назад +15

    Dr Craig Lane conceded to Hijab's critique claiming that God's example for him is like a three headed dog or conjoined twins, that's literally confirming three gods.
    Christianity is dead, three times over.

  • @sttof10
    @sttof10 Месяц назад +231

    Christian has no ground to stand on. He makes his believe very confusing 😮

    • @johnbrzykcy3076
      @johnbrzykcy3076 Месяц назад +4

      I understand your comment. However if we simply look at God's plan to send Jesus to help us, it should not be so confusing. If our Creator understands that human beings are not infallible and that we are sinners, He must have had a plan ( and still has such a plan ) to help us. Such a plan would be God's love for His creation.
      So I do appreciate your honesty.
      Peace of God to you and your family.

    • @sttof10
      @sttof10 Месяц назад +24

      @@johnbrzykcy3076 God's plan to send Jesus. Very good point that show Jesus is not God because God send him or God send other God 🤣

    • @chickenprince841
      @chickenprince841 Месяц назад +4

      ​​@@johnbrzykcy3076Such a Nice and humble comment, You're different from others who use foul language, May Allah guide you ❤❤❤

    • @Ppm1845
      @Ppm1845 Месяц назад

      ​@@sttof10it took Allah 600 years to send a prophet from Arabia to say that Jesus is not God lol. What would happen to all the people between the 600 years? Allah sure would judge them doesn't he lol

    • @sttof10
      @sttof10 Месяц назад +12

      @@Ppm1845 same thing happened to the people before 2000 Year before Jesus born because there were people ( surprise) also by saying Jesus born that's bad 😔 according to you god born can you believe it 🤣 since I debunked ur question/issue. Who told you in that 600 years Gap people believed same thing u believe now? 😨

  • @user-user-user-user.
    @user-user-user-user. Месяц назад +146

    William Craig comes as close to any Christian to convincingly arguing the Christian talking points…but he’s still miles away from even a 1st year student in Medina.

    • @kaisardawg4389
      @kaisardawg4389 Месяц назад

      The student in medina is full of brainrot

    • @darealkezz806
      @darealkezz806 Месяц назад

      @@user-user-user-user. How do you know the Quran is from God?
      Muslims: The Quran said so
      How do you know God said so?
      Muslims: Mohammed said so
      How do you know Mohammed wasn’t lying?
      Muslims: The Quran said he wasn’t
      Who told you to believe the Quran?
      MOHAMMED
      Did anyone else see the angels or hear the revelations?
      Muslims: No
      So why do you trust Mohammed?
      Muslims: Because the Quran said he’s Perfect
      Who told you to trust the Quran?
      MOHAMMED
      This logic is why Muslims should be the most pitied people.

    • @GottfriedLeibnizYT
      @GottfriedLeibnizYT Месяц назад +3

      LoL. A 1st year student in Medina knows nothing about Kalam and theology.

    • @user-user-user-user.
      @user-user-user-user. Месяц назад +3

      @@GottfriedLeibnizYT
      Just like you don’t read or write archaic Greek, or Aramaic, or Latin, or Hebrew, right?

    • @stefang.9763
      @stefang.9763 Месяц назад

      LOL ask Yasir Qadhi how his medina foolishness was deconstructed piece by piece

  • @TruthisBitter-b2g
    @TruthisBitter-b2g Месяц назад +14

    Shocking performance by Craig! Unbelievable that an old person who’s closer to depart this world doesn’t even know God, the one who will judge him after his death!

    • @Raising777
      @Raising777 Месяц назад

      Muhammad Hijab had low IQ couldn't really understand of Dr. Craig's argument/example like you ruclips.net/video/iYIr3VJRaL8/видео.html

  • @Stand4justice.
    @Stand4justice. Месяц назад +9

    "We Muslims do not realize what a blessing it is from Allah that we are Muslims. Think about how the disbeliever struggles with his own intellect to justify his belief."

  • @aymen.el.abed.01
    @aymen.el.abed.01 Месяц назад +41

    Craig in his closing statement abandoned his argumentation and started preaching 😂😂😂

  • @Pakilla64
    @Pakilla64 Месяц назад +20

    This dude justified the Biblical violence with some vague nonsense and yet dared to condemn the concept of war in Islam. He already lost

  • @CR7Update
    @CR7Update Месяц назад +41

    Brother Hijab please invite Dr Craig to your podcast and have a lengthy discussion talking about Islamic tawheed vs Christian trinity. I think a debate wasn't sufficient for such a heavy topic to discussed in this format between two acedemics.

  • @SZ-mc7ch
    @SZ-mc7ch Месяц назад +18

    subhanAllah, its's crazy to think that Hijab started from debating in the park all the way to debating with none other than Dr William Lane Craig

    • @felixmeier3298
      @felixmeier3298 Месяц назад +1

      the same hijab who said there is no age limit according to Quran?

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад +1

      Getting schooled by William Lane Craig. It was very clear from the debate that Craig was on a completely different level. It was like a bearded kindergartener debating a teacher and the teacher trying to understand how the kindergartener could think their bogus arguments are actually sound. Then after the kindergartener gets all of their attacks refuted, they declare they won and none of their arguments were answered. May the Lord open your eyes. ❤

    • @balladbay2037
      @balladbay2037 Месяц назад +2

      ​​@@James-ny2xl😂😂😂😂 We got to see that, God being compared to a 3 headed dog

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад

      @@balladbay2037 It was an illustration as a starting place to help people conceptualize something about God. It wasn't the argument. If you don't like the illustration, that's fine. Ignore it. Illustrations are used by God quite often to help finite humans understand infinite truths. If the illustration isn't helpful for you, then you don't need to use it. It actually is a helpful illustration as a starting point (while obviously saying there is an infinite difference--it was just to help us grasp the concept), but if you don't like it because your self-proclaimed prophet hated dogs, said angels can't come into a house if a dog is in there, black dogs were demons, and their lives should be ended, that's not our problem. God created dogs as beautiful creatures no matter how many false things Muhammad said about them.
      Jesus compared Himself to a bronze snake, a door, a mother hen, bread, etc. If you don't like those, you don't like Jesus and you disagree with Jesus. And you'll be accountable for that on the Day of Judgment, using your own messed up presuppositions to reject what the Messiah said.

    • @mademan4life
      @mademan4life Месяц назад

      ​@@James-ny2xlyour comment is very kindergarten, sounds like a child crying because he can't accept defeat, you watched this whole debate with cognitive dissonance, William lane Craig couldn't even explain away the trinity, instead attack the Qur'an, just become someone is a professor doesn't mean they are correct in what they say, this was about trinity and incoherency and he failed massively, he provided no evidence of trinity ever spoken by Jesus, quite shocking for a professor to do that, then he went wayward with his analogies....

  • @vaccino3359
    @vaccino3359 Месяц назад +188

    Dr. Craig is a respectable man, but his arguments for the Trinity, especially the candle analogy part failed miserably just as brother Mohammad said.
    Edit: I just learned that this guy justifies genocide and mass murder, including the content in the Bible and genocides like Israel vs children. I take this statement back.

    • @joshuapena6757
      @joshuapena6757 Месяц назад +5

      @vaccino3359 I appreciate the kind words about Craig. The point of the candle is that each match is a sufficient condition for the candle being lit, but that no logical or metaphysical impossibility is entailed in this analogy. That means there is at least one case where overdeterminism does not entail logical or metaphysical impossibility. In order to show that the trinity is incoherent, Hijab needed to show that the trinity cannot be like this example, and must be like the examples he brought up. But all his examples involved physical causes where multiple people cannot fit in the same space, which is obviously not a problem when the cause of the universe's existence is immaterial. So I really don't know where he was going with that...

    • @joshuapena6757
      @joshuapena6757 Месяц назад

      @vaccino3359 But even if Hijab is right that we're stuck with either (a) one member of the trinity "fully" causing creation, or (b) several members "partially" causing creation, why is that a problem for the trinity? If I were a Christian and really bought Hijab's dilemma, I'd just pick (b) in this case. So again, I don't know where he was going with this...

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад +7

      I bet you 1 million you didn't even understand the candle analogy lol

    • @vaccino3359
      @vaccino3359 Месяц назад +15

      @joshuapena6757 picking b isn't an option for you since it results in partialism. Partialism is the belief that each person of the Trinity is 1/3 God. For example, Jesus is 33.33% God. Trinity is the belief that all three are 100% God. Partialism is against the Trinity, and is held heretical by the Scholars of Christianity, even Dr.Craig here. Which is why he didn't accept it.

    • @vaccino3359
      @vaccino3359 Месяц назад

      @joshuapena6757 Here's the problem, though: Craig usage of the candle example is misleading. He used the example because, yes, two matches light the candle, but one flame is the result. However, when two matches use 100% of their capability to light the candle, the flame results to be 200%, not 100%. See the point? Dr. Craig is claiming that even though 2 matches light the candle, each with 100% contribution, the candle is still 100%, which is a logical mistake. 1 + 1 ≠1, 100% + 100% ≠ 100%.
      Btw we as muslims have no problem having respect for educated people like Dr. Craig. We DO, however, have a problem with uneducated psychotic RATS like Scam Shampoo, David Wood, Apus, Avery (Godlogic), and people like such. They don't even defend Christianity. They just base their content on attacking Islam.

  • @Brokenhearted894
    @Brokenhearted894 Месяц назад +372

    Jesus : i am messenger of god
    Christians :NO, you're god you dont know but you are .

    • @luqmti6634
      @luqmti6634 Месяц назад +42

      Jesus: But I never s-
      Christians: Nope, you are god

    • @autisticman4396
      @autisticman4396 Месяц назад +22

      ​@@luqmti6634
      Jesus: The father is the Only true god.
      Christians: you said I AM, you're def god.

    • @kironthomas1442
      @kironthomas1442 Месяц назад +19

      Jesus:"I and the Father are one"
      Jewish listeners responded by saying, "You, a mere man, claim to be God".
      Jesus: "Whoever has seen me has seen the Father".
      Jesus: “He who receives you receives me, and he who receives me receives the one who sent me.”
      Christians: Sounds like Jesus is claiming to be God and one with the Father.
      Muslims: No He isn't.
      Christians: This is what it says directly in the Bible.
      Muslims: No it doesn't.
      🤔🤔

    • @imtanancheema4377
      @imtanancheema4377 Месяц назад +7

      Jesus: But I'm not g-
      Christians: No, you're god, you don't know but you're god

    • @raphaelguionaud7839
      @raphaelguionaud7839 Месяц назад

      @@kironthomas1442 for real. Too lazy to read

  • @IncisiveThoughts
    @IncisiveThoughts Месяц назад +76

    53:00 A unique moment where the host attempts to end the discussion and William Lane Craig turns to full preacher mode.

    • @incisivethoughts4416
      @incisivethoughts4416 Месяц назад +10

      Very rare to see craig perform poorly

    • @khalidkhatri100
      @khalidkhatri100 Месяц назад +12

      Cameron bertuzzi would be like - “this debate was such a bad idea”

    • @jaihindcollegegraduationmu6060
      @jaihindcollegegraduationmu6060 Месяц назад +12

      Cameron couldn’t handle his star being dismantled piece by piece 😄

    • @TheRockeyAllen
      @TheRockeyAllen Месяц назад +11

      ​@@incisivethoughts4416He becomes a monotheist when debating atheists, using Quranic arguments, and arguments from Al Ghazali etc
      When debating Muslims, he throws logic out if the window and resorts to "belief".

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад

      Are you really this daft? It was his closing remarks and he was inviting Muslims to have be open-minded about the nature of Jesus Christ. Hijab did the same with respect to Christians and Islam. This is not preaching whatsoever.

  • @MrZERK7
    @MrZERK7 Месяц назад +3

    Great work Mohammed Hijab.
    So happy to see you calmly debunk his societal trinitarinsm arguments and his analogies about the two matches. You kept your composure and were very respectful. This was a delight to watch and we can truly see how much you've grown compared to past performances.
    أللهم بارك لك، حفظك الله من كل شر و زادك علما نافعا

  • @imran.abbasi
    @imran.abbasi Месяц назад +334

    Christians + Apus are now going to join forces to lick their wounds and feel better about themselves 😂

    • @nbk2134
      @nbk2134 Месяц назад

      You should see the nonsense on their channels. The Christians think they won 😂. I guess if you believe in the trinity then any sort of delusional state would be reality to you.

    • @jadenreyes9028
      @jadenreyes9028 Месяц назад +12

      Why did Hijab run from the Debate with Sam Shamoun and Jay Dyer?

    • @Umar-qy3bd
      @Umar-qy3bd Месяц назад +52

      @@jadenreyes9028 Also Why did Hijab run from the Debate with a bunch of gremlins in the RUclips comment section?
      Simple, because they aren't on his level.
      I'm pretty sure he also said that he only debates those with a large enough following and good credibility. He isn't going to give attention to a bunch of nobodies.

    • @Radec913
      @Radec913 Месяц назад +13

      Apus is a christian now. He doesnt say he is. He says he is agnostic.
      But after his visit to israel he “felt” something.
      I think he is just trying to keep his christian audiance engaged😂😂.
      Because now he is defending judaism and christianity on all the points he used to attack islam on

    • @barry_wastaken
      @barry_wastaken Месяц назад +1

      this is beyond accurate 😂😂

  • @thescribes466
    @thescribes466 Месяц назад +143

    Apus, David & shamoun left the group 😂😂

    • @thedaintyprincejbr3176
      @thedaintyprincejbr3176 Месяц назад +16

      @@thescribes466 A pus was hate commenting on the video of the moderator. 😂 He is a cheap hater

    • @almaghrabee
      @almaghrabee Месяц назад

      Just 3 transgenders on Zionists payroll

    • @allwyn3054
      @allwyn3054 Месяц назад +4

      Yea, just like Mini Hijab ran away from CP? Loool 😂😂😅
      Btw they have already responded to this debate, it's Hilarious.

    • @ishfaqshah7393
      @ishfaqshah7393 Месяц назад +19

      @@allwyn3054 All their videos are on Islam, this is what you call coping. Islam cannot be stopped no matter how hard you try.

    • @omarmassoud6275
      @omarmassoud6275 Месяц назад

      ​@@allwyn3054C princess refuses to have a moderated debate in a neurtral channel, he wants to be the mod so he can mute the component whenever he wants, MH humiliated that coward in 2020 when he sexually harrased a 15 muslim girl, CP is a beta male coward just like ur daddy jesus who depended on prostitutes to feed him (luke 8:3) 😂😂😂😂

  • @MK-nj5bm
    @MK-nj5bm Месяц назад +66

    I'm flabbergasted that this is the best Christianity has to offer, he can't answer a simple question. Embarassing...

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад

      Like what?

    • @pavelcrestin1
      @pavelcrestin1 Месяц назад

      No, this is not the best Christianity has. Try Sam Shamoun, Jay Dyer etc

    • @afgpkdk
      @afgpkdk Месяц назад

      They have been smoked many times, they act like childs when loosing debates. ​@@pavelcrestin1

    • @zhamed9587
      @zhamed9587 Месяц назад +16

      @@pavelcrestin1 lol, sam was defeated by Daniel.

    • @scorpion20dz
      @scorpion20dz Месяц назад +4

      ​@@pavelcrestin1lmao

  • @shotsstodoroki6862
    @shotsstodoroki6862 Месяц назад +70

    Everytime a Christian realizes he/she loses, they go full preacher mode. So miserable. 😂

  • @Real_Lion_Slayer
    @Real_Lion_Slayer Месяц назад +25

    Why stop at 3 parts to God. Let's have 7 or 13 or 23. This doesn't make sense?
    Also it's pathetic to see Christians try to say Muslims don't believe in one concept of Tawheed.

    • @pavelcrestin1
      @pavelcrestin1 Месяц назад

      No they do not: ruclips.net/video/ZPar3SDnIvk/видео.html

  • @aabo1811
    @aabo1811 Месяц назад +107

    After the debate the Losers Defeated by Hijab Club™ had a multi-hour discussion where they cried and consoled each other as the PTSD was activated by another Hijab debate.

    • @Shige2213
      @Shige2213 Месяц назад

      There are no losers, just A loser which is craig, many christians knew beforehand he would lose, he is a very bad theological apologist, he is a crowned the top apologist by many because he defends the faith against atheism mainly. He is a also heretic in many areas.

    • @Thronewatcher
      @Thronewatcher Месяц назад

      From the liver to the knee

    • @dhuss14
      @dhuss14 Месяц назад +1

      Islamophobes are the most pathetic copers you people have no shame how sad

    • @mujahidhasan118
      @mujahidhasan118 Месяц назад

      😂

    • @mujahidhasan118
      @mujahidhasan118 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@Thronewatcher"from the liver to the knee"
      "Christianity is a joke and fallacy"

  • @ShatteredGlass916
    @ShatteredGlass916 Месяц назад +84

    The moment he said "There's no concensus among what Tawhid is . . ." I'm just . . . . . You're done bruh 😂

    • @pavelcrestin1
      @pavelcrestin1 Месяц назад

      Well, there is no consensus. There are more schools that debate each other about Tawhid

    • @TheSaintEzekiel
      @TheSaintEzekiel Месяц назад +16

      ​​@@pavelcrestin1 Tawhid is the belief of oneness in Allah. The debate doesn't happen on the oneness of Allah, rather the attributes of Allah, whether they are literal or not. Using this logic, WLC shot catholics/protestants and blah blah blah right on their buttocks.

    • @whitedragon7436
      @whitedragon7436 Месяц назад +1

      Then they are not considered muslim at all. ​@@pavelcrestin1

    • @mohamedab9033
      @mohamedab9033 Месяц назад +5

      @@pavelcrestin1 Tawhid is literally "monotheism" translated in Arabic language, there is no other word for it in Arabic.
      The absolute bold faced brazenness to utter a lie that there is no consensus on Monotheism in Islam is shameful, and sad.

    • @allwyn3054
      @allwyn3054 Месяц назад

      ​@@mohamedab9033
      Tawhid is 'better translated as unity'.
      Unity means two or more came together to form one. So Al-lah isn't one.
      Btw in every other translation in Koran, Tawhid is translated as 'unity'

  • @aahavoc
    @aahavoc Месяц назад +9

    Debating Christians about Trinity is like arguing with a wife. It's an argument we can't win no matter what evidence we bring up. They just won't listen 👂

  • @swafiirbulbul819
    @swafiirbulbul819 Месяц назад +31

    From East Africa 🇹🇿 ... I'm watching àlhamdulillaah

  • @igsaan8573
    @igsaan8573 Месяц назад +22

    This Christian uncle was so underwhelming. Wow, I am sure that the people all expected much more from him.

    • @Khalid-Haji
      @Khalid-Haji Месяц назад +4

      Even me as a muslim was expected better than that

    • @oscarvelez5827
      @oscarvelez5827 Месяц назад

      I think your education level is first grade if you believe that. Thats the problem with muslims theyre too stupid and blind by objective reasoning.

    • @fathimaal-bulushi3770
      @fathimaal-bulushi3770 21 день назад

      The Christian uncle tried his best but alas....

  • @chickenprince841
    @chickenprince841 Месяц назад +98

    Christians experimented with the Car Analogy that failed, Now we got the three headed dog analogy 😂😂😂

    • @JRTIGER07
      @JRTIGER07 Месяц назад

      😂 *Surah 69:44-46 / Sahih Muslim 4428* 😂

    • @JRTIGER07
      @JRTIGER07 Месяц назад

      🐔 Head 😂

    • @JRTIGER07
      @JRTIGER07 Месяц назад

      Clock Head 🐔😂

    • @ipe3nnj
      @ipe3nnj Месяц назад

      Let me ask you a question is your soul body mind voice you or are they 4 different people 😂 you say trinity ain't logical but by that logic you think every element of yourself is separate people

    • @Abdalladahir.
      @Abdalladahir. Месяц назад +15

      ​@@ipe3nnj exactly, my soul is part of me not fully me , my mind is part me of me too, none of them can stand without each other, they are all dependant on each other, to complete the fully me. On the other hand what you are saying is The soul is 100% fully the person, the mind is 100% fully the person and the body is 100% fully the person, yet they are not three persons it's just one Person. How could any sane person in any realm believe that.

  • @huzefabdulkarim
    @huzefabdulkarim Месяц назад +3

    Alhamdulillah how Islam is logical, and true religion!

  • @netizen6958
    @netizen6958 Месяц назад +34

    Whatever your education background there's no way you can explain something that doesn't exist like the trinity.

    • @mutamirmukhzani1240
      @mutamirmukhzani1240 Месяц назад +5

      Why do they even bother to elaborate on a subject that is widely accepted by majority to be a mystery is beyond me

    • @netizen6958
      @netizen6958 Месяц назад +1

      @@mutamirmukhzani1240 exactly. If it's logically coherent then it doesn't need to be explained.

  • @EnergeiaRhythmos
    @EnergeiaRhythmos Месяц назад +67

    God to dog analogy is craaazzyy

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад +2

      Are you really this daft? WLC clearly stated it was not an analogy... 🤦

    • @stealthassulter
      @stealthassulter Месяц назад +10

      ​@@HT-xt4cn but three-headed dog is an analogy though bro

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад

      @@stealthassulter He said it was meant as a springboard for conceptualizing about the trinity and that it was not meant as an analogy.

    • @burakcoskun38
      @burakcoskun38 Месяц назад +2

      ​@@HT-xt4cnstill doesn't justify the Trinity

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад

      @@burakcoskun38 That wasn't the purpose of that illustration.

  • @TheRockeyAllen
    @TheRockeyAllen Месяц назад +12

    Key takeaways:
    Trinitarian: "There is exactly one God, and there are exactly three persons."
    Real monotheist: "Okay, so do those three persons have independent wills?
    If yes, then that's three independent wills. How exactly can you then uphold the logical necessity of there being one single undivided uncaused cause?
    If no, then what really differentiates these "persons"? What makes each one a "person" that is not the other? You'd simply have to end up saying that Father is Son, Son is Holy Spirit, and Holy Spirit is Father."
    Trinitarian: "It's three wills, but they always act in harmony due to divine perfect."
    True monotheist: "So you are establishing a metric of perfection that would be external to each will. Hence, each will is contingent upon the other. So, in effect, you are making the will of God contingent."
    Trinitarian: "The father is fully God, so he can will to create something without the will of the son."
    Real monotheist: "If so, then the father is fully God, while the son is not.
    If not, then the coming into existence of the son is an inhibitor to the will of the father. Ie, the Holy Spirit, and the son have stripped off the omnipotence of the father."

    • @mutamirmukhzani1240
      @mutamirmukhzani1240 Месяц назад +2

      Don't forget within jesus himself there are two natures with their own independent mind and consciousness. It's a very easy concept to parse really

  • @ismaa3iil2
    @ismaa3iil2 Месяц назад +6

    I believe the following points, which were missing in the debate, are helpful:
    I am Muslim. Here are some questions, I pose to Dr. Craig:
    Q1.
    Let us grant that your concept of one god with 3 persons is coherent. The 3 persons out of benevolence and love have the same knowledge, the same will, …. And all 3 act in concert. What would be incoherent, if these 3 persons were 3 gods with 1 person each, with the same properties of the 3 persons of the one god: “benevolence, love, the same knowledge, the same will, …. And all 3 act in concert”?
    If you were asked to defend polytheism (as an exercise), would you be able to construct a defensible coherent version of polytheism?
    Q2.
    Is there anything incoherent in having one god with 2 persons, 4 persons, 5 persons, … n persons (even: an infinite number of persons)??
    Is there anything special in the number 3? (I thought special numbers in divine attributes are constrained to be 0,1 and infinity)??
    Q3.
    If the doctrine of trinity is a cornerstone of the knowledge of the true God, should it not be expected that the chosen servants and messengers of God should be aware of it? Do you believe that Noah, Abraham, and Moses knew of trinity and believed in trinity?
    Q4.
    Do you believe that the doctrines of the true faith are revealed gradually (step by step), that the Old Testament only revealed one person, the Father, and that the New Testament revealed the other 2 persons? Why is it then impossible, that later, when Christ comes to earth again, he will reveal to mankind the trueness of many different persons, some of which were perhaps mistaken to be Gods in Hinduism and other polytheistic religions? Could it be, that, Hinduism (e.g.), is an evolution of an originally “monotheistic” religion with a “multi-person”-God?
    Q5.
    What is the degree of certainty, with which you state your belief in trinity, if you disregard personal experience and restrict yourself to reasonable objective arguments and facts? Is it not all grounded in the degree of certainty of the transmission of the “New Testament” and of the degree of certainty of its interpretation?
    Q6.
    But these 2 pillars are at least controversial? There are undeniable proofs of the corruption in the New Testament. Is it “unreasonable” to doubt the honesty and the integrity of Paul? Is it unreasonable to reject the “Gospel of John“ as divine revelation? Didn’t an intelligent man like Isaac Newton, conclude Unitarianism from the same bible?
    Q7.
    Do you believe that many Christian communities believed false doctrines of faith in the first centuries (Jewish Christians, Gnostics, followers of Arius, followers of Nestor, the Coptic Church, the Greek-Orthodox Church, the Catholic Church, …) and that it is possible, that all Christians have some wrong doctrines of belief ()e.g. about trinity) for centuries, until some “scientists” reveal the right interpretation of the Bible (perhaps in the 21st century)?
    Is it not possible, that new reliable manuscripts about the life and teachings of Jesus may be discovered, and that many new errors in the gospels are found? Could it be that these manuscripts will prove the truth of the Christian sect “Islam”?

    • @seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388
      @seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 Месяц назад

      God is complex, yet allows us to comprehend Him in simple
      Ways
      Best analogy is the sun, distinct yet one
      INVISIBLE Gas Giant,
      VISIBLE as yellow ball in the sky,
      GENERATING life through its heat and light
      The One God, E- Lo- Heem,
      UNMANIFEST/ As FATHER Who dwells in unapproachable Light
      MANIFEST in the flesh / The Word/ Logos/ Memra in flesh as JESUS YESHUA
      INDWELLING SPIRIT Infusing life, flowing from The Father Through His Son into the Believer.

  • @johnbrzykcy3076
    @johnbrzykcy3076 Месяц назад +51

    I'm a Christian believer but I didn't watch the debate. I tend to avoid discussing the "Trinity". However I'm not trying to be disrespectful to the scholars involved in this video.
    My priority is ( or should be ) understanding God's plan of salvation and mercy to human beings. Since we are not infallible and we are sinners, God must have a plan based upon His knowledge of creation. A plan to help us.
    Anyhow, I'm slowly learning about Islam. And I respect the strong discipline of Muslims regarding prayer and good deeds.
    Respectfully from Florida USA

    • @timos7280
      @timos7280 Месяц назад +21

      may allah guide you to the truth. most debates are about trinity adn monotheism because they are the core of each religion, if the core shatters the rest of that religion is no longer the truth. what I want to say sincerely may allah guide to the truth before it's too late.

    • @sarahk13peace
      @sarahk13peace Месяц назад +5

      Respect and love from Egypt bro. Just a question:
      What God exactly are you trying to understand his(their according to Christianity?) plan?
      I am not attacking, I wish you all the best. May Allah guide your heart to Islam, John

    • @4ozking858
      @4ozking858 Месяц назад +6

      No reason not to watch the debate man. Exchange of ideas is what helps us develop our knowledge.

    • @lorenzogonzalez5408
      @lorenzogonzalez5408 Месяц назад +10

      God's plan for humanity is very simple:
      Worship Him and Him alone (since He is the one who created absolutely everything you see before you including you), turn to Him for help and guidance, turn to Him for forgiveness (since we are the creation and not the Creator thus we are not perfect like Him, sin is inevitable for us. God would've never created humanity if humanity were perfect and sinless). Do good things, help those in need, stay away from things He forbids as it is for our best interest to do so since he is our Creator and knows His creation best. He literally gave humanity the blueprints to salvation since the beginning of time through His messengers. Most notably Moses, Jesus, & Muhammad. Every single messenger preached the same exact thing, to worship God and God alone. If you followed what every messenger preached (since they were the greatest examples for the people of their time) then you worshiped the God that they worshipped and worshipped God alone. God entrusted His first 2 written blueprints to the people of the messengers times (i.e The Torah He revealed to Moses and the Injil He revealed to Jesus). Overtime those scriptures were altered by the people, they added, removed, and changed things to fit their whims and desires. God knew this so He made a promise to mankind that He would perfect, protect, and preserve His final blueprint for the rest of time and humanity and that he would clarify what came before. That final blueprint is what you know today as the Qur'an, His final revelation revealed to His final messenger Muhammad. I'm glad to hear you are slowly learning about Islam and I pray that God directs you to sources of knowledge in the religion as opposed to those who may cast doubt in your heart. I truly feel like you are on the cusp of realizing that the answers have been in front of you this whole time. Don't listen to the keyboard warriors on this app or any other platform who put forth emotional arguments that are constantly refuted time and time again. Do your due diligence with humbleness, an open mind and an open heart and I promise you that you'll have a a true sense of clarity on the test that this life is. Peace be with you

    • @taherabunama4559
      @taherabunama4559 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@lorenzogonzalez5408 good answer bro

  • @petermckenzie580
    @petermckenzie580 Месяц назад +46

    Defending Christianity = gargantuan mental gymnastics, gas-lighting and militant acceptance of logical contradictions.
    Defending Islam = ‘GOD is 1”.
    What is so plain & simple is also what is the truth.

    • @TheDawahCenter
      @TheDawahCenter Месяц назад +2

      Exactly brother! So simple so logical, the same message all the prophets brought, no prophets prophesied a future son of God coming or trinity, they all affirmed 1 God.

    • @StevTheBevNaffNeffNor
      @StevTheBevNaffNeffNor Месяц назад

      Prove a god exists.

    • @MH_Raees
      @MH_Raees Месяц назад

      Right, my dear brother 💝

    • @nicbentulan
      @nicbentulan Месяц назад +1

      @@petermckenzie580 why's Israel a better country to live in than every Muslim country and then there are 2 million Jewish Christians and 0 million Jewish Muslims?

    • @nicbentulan
      @nicbentulan Месяц назад +1

      @@TheDawahCenter 1 explain Isaiah 7:14, 9:6, Psalm 110:1, Matthew 1:23, 22:43?
      2
      Better yet explain how Jesus is the Messiah?
      3
      There are 2 million Jewish Christians and 0 million Jewish Muslims. So Islam is losing to Christianity among either ethnic Jews or ethnic gentiles. But the ethnic Jews' conversion unanimously to Christianity over Islam suggests Islam has no idea what 'Messiah' is. Why?
      4
      Pathetic. Laughable. Jewish Christian Michael L Brown has 5 volumes 'Jewish Objections to Jesus'. Jewish Muslims have 0 volumes. Why?
      5
      Gentile Muslims have negative 1 volumes. Lol!!! So pathetic. No wonder Israel keeps winning militarily. Why do you think terrorists can't beat Israel?
      6
      No wonder Jews & Christians have a billion Nobel prizes while Muslims barely have any. Jews/Muslims are 0.2%/20% of population and then win 20%/0.2% of Nobel prizes. Why do you think this is the case?
      7
      Why do 99.9% of people prefer to live in Israel over any Muslim country?

  • @HazStrikesU
    @HazStrikesU Месяц назад +6

    Cameron done a fantastic job moderating this. Very fair man. Respect - make sure to keep it up

  • @Fazal10111
    @Fazal10111 Месяц назад +77

    I’m a massive fan of Hijab. Well done mate.

    • @leebromley7987
      @leebromley7987 Месяц назад +2

      I’m a huge fan too! Mo Hijab has done more to bring Islam down than any other! Continue your narcissism Mimi!

    • @Beauty-x3w
      @Beauty-x3w Месяц назад

      Hijab is an actor, pretends to know it all

  • @jahidurrahmannasib7640
    @jahidurrahmannasib7640 Месяц назад +107

    Sorry Christians but William Lane Craig is Cooked in this debate.

    • @GaryAdams-t8d
      @GaryAdams-t8d Месяц назад

      Really, 'cooked' on which points

    • @mohamet_dudealher7528
      @mohamet_dudealher7528 Месяц назад +17

      ​@@GaryAdams-t8dhe couldn't defend the trinity? He started attacking tawhid even tho its not the topic lol.

    • @OmanMir-i8o
      @OmanMir-i8o Месяц назад +4

      @@GaryAdams-t8dgod or dog¿

    • @jahidurrahmannasib7640
      @jahidurrahmannasib7640 Месяц назад +4

      ​​@@GaryAdams-t8dHe couldn't defend the trinity? Further proving the Mainstream Christian Views Are false,irrational. And Also Hijab proved he is a Heretic. And at the last he got full preacher mode. 😂

    • @omarmassoud6275
      @omarmassoud6275 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@GaryAdams-t8dconstantly trying to change the subject from trinity to tawhid and trying to portray that tawhid is complicated and can't be understood like trinity, lol 😂

  • @GutzOverFear
    @GutzOverFear Месяц назад +4

    Nah bro, not The Harry Potter 3-Headed Dog analogy...
    😭😭😭

  • @itsmeUsamaT
    @itsmeUsamaT Месяц назад +24

    Two matches cant light a candle together
    One match will do it first and be 100 percent responsible

    • @James-ny2xl
      @James-ny2xl Месяц назад +1

      It is an analogy. Analogies are imperfect when trying to discuss the almighty, eternal God. We don't need any perfect physical analogy for something to be true about God. There is nothing perfectly analogous to God having no beginning and no end, but that doesn't mean God isn't eternal. Even with the very limited time he had to respond, Craig did an excellent job refuting the bogus arguments of Hijab. Praise the Triune God!

    • @overoscar1788
      @overoscar1788 Месяц назад

      @@James-ny2xl Let's make this even simpler. 2 persons push a button at the exact same time. Both are sufficient and could do it alone but only 1 person is necessary for pushing a button. ONE is necessary the other is redundant. God is necessary and cannot be redundant therefore God is ONE AND ONLY ONE. Stop saying three.

  • @ircrmedia1263
    @ircrmedia1263 Месяц назад +9

    MH you nailed the whole concept of mainstream Christian ideology in immensely strategic detail. William didn't have a leg to stand upon. Utterly destroyed.

  • @MuhammadAli-cw1ed
    @MuhammadAli-cw1ed Месяц назад +1

    I have been waiting for this for a decade! Well done for getting both to speak on the same show. Round 2?

  • @sethgyan
    @sethgyan Месяц назад +117

    Hijab : Three candles will lead to more fire 😂

    • @natsutabbaa5324
      @natsutabbaa5324 Месяц назад +24

      I think the point he made was if u use two lighters to light a candle, it isn't the case that the two lighter are simultaneously the **direct** cause of the lighting of the candle. Rather the two lighters would both cause a certain amount of fire which would ***partially*** contribute to the creation of a bigger flame. This flame would cause the lighting of the candle. So here u have one cause (the fire) producing an effect (the lighting of the candle. So nothing here entail two distinct entities being fully responsible for the same effect.

    • @ayyylmao101
      @ayyylmao101 Месяц назад +3

      @@natsutabbaa5324 Nailed it. Er, ignited it.

    • @RFQ22
      @RFQ22 Месяц назад +10

      So, you guys believe in 3 gods like separate matches?

    • @allwyn3054
      @allwyn3054 Месяц назад

      ​@@natsutabbaa5324
      So according to this logic, a firing squad shoots a man. A single shot can kill the man, so when the whole firing squad fires, the man is........more dead?
      Mini Hijab is a coward. Let's not forget he ran away from CP.

    • @deedarlaskar6
      @deedarlaskar6 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@natsutabbaa5324bro just stop it

  • @faiyazhaque
    @faiyazhaque Месяц назад +34

    "The oneness or unicity of God, is a doctrine that is VERY confusing and very controversial..." (Craig, 2024).
    -like bruh what 5:04

    • @mdmohidulhasan588
      @mdmohidulhasan588 Месяц назад +4

      literally david wood line from the last david wood vs Hijab debate. Very disappointing.

    • @tempacct5812
      @tempacct5812 Месяц назад +5

      “Unicity” making up fake words for fake arguments - this Craig guy

    • @molarman1594
      @molarman1594 Месяц назад

      It was at this moment we knew…

    • @danalmariti509
      @danalmariti509 Месяц назад

      They way he said “Tawheed” I think he was pandering to his Christian audience. He made it seem as if it is something scary. And concluded that it is very confusing. Tawheed is the clearest statement about the oneness of God. Very simple. God is one, He created everything. He doesn’t depend on anything or anyone.

    • @thomashardy7961
      @thomashardy7961 Месяц назад

      Yep. As soon as I hear that from a Christian, I switch off and walk away. Not worth wasting time on nonsense.

  • @sttof10
    @sttof10 Месяц назад +40

    The Christian really said God = for example dog with 3 Heads 😂😂 it reminds me of that meme ( 🐉 dragon with 3 heads)

    • @angelicentity1401
      @angelicentity1401 Месяц назад

      Is the word of Allah uncreated and is Jesus the Word of Allah?

    • @tempacct5812
      @tempacct5812 Месяц назад +3

      @@angelicentity1401 wrong.

    • @rezakhan1086
      @rezakhan1086 Месяц назад +8

      @@angelicentity1401You clearly have no understanding of Islamic theology. Ur trying to prove your idolatry by using Islamic arguments?

    • @nazeemsultan1038
      @nazeemsultan1038 Месяц назад

      ​@angelicentity1401 bro please...

    • @110_khanyasir4
      @110_khanyasir4 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@angelicentity1401word 'from' god.

  • @habababa6220
    @habababa6220 4 дня назад +2

    This is a wonderful debate and it’s very clear that Islam’s arguments were clear, concise and very easy to understand.
    It’s disappointing that Dr Craig claims to have studied Qalam but does not know the difference between Tawheed and the idea of God’s attributes. He also is very inconsistent in applying his examples and understanding. This is something Christian’s tend to do. Misrepresent God in different scenarios and manipulate His qualities and attributes to fit their agenda. Very sad and scary to see. And understandable why the ideology and belief system is so corrupt and misunderstood.

  • @tech-perfect
    @tech-perfect Месяц назад +15

    The main logical question is : Why would you use 2 candles to light 1 flame? :D

    • @elbannamenna
      @elbannamenna Месяц назад +3

      Exactly 💯
      Like if the Father can already create the whole universe by Himself, what is the need of the son and the holy spirit? 👍
      + The bible already states that the Father is the ONLY true God and that He is only ONE (John 17:3)

    • @ahmedsoliman8869
      @ahmedsoliman8869 Месяц назад

      Because one is not enough

    • @shahrukhabdul9889
      @shahrukhabdul9889 Месяц назад +1

      Exactly, if one can do the job, why have many? Also, why only 3? Why not 30?
      And if one alone cannot do the job, then that is not God.

    • @GhgdvgChjg-kn3mq
      @GhgdvgChjg-kn3mq Месяц назад

      Ask yourself the question: Why did God create us? The answer is: Because He needs us, meaning God is incomplete. Ask yourself: Why did God send Muhammad? The answer is: To guide people. If God sent an angel to Muhammad and did not send anyone else and did not send miracles with Muhammad? Because God is stup id

    • @GhgdvgChjg-kn3mq
      @GhgdvgChjg-kn3mq Месяц назад

      ​@@shahrukhabdul9889Have you ever asked yourself why the God of Islam created you? 😅

  • @jamalshah2432
    @jamalshah2432 Месяц назад +17

    In other words, for the argument of inhibition, using WLC analogy, a single match may NOT be able to ignite an entire log, but 3 matches combined may be able to ignite the entire log. That is to say, he's taking away the omnipotence of Allah (SWT) to ignite any log, and his model is dependent on a combined effect.

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад

      This is not at all what WLC was attempting to explain with his candle analogy...

    • @burakcoskun38
      @burakcoskun38 Месяц назад +2

      ​@@HT-xt4cnthis is exactly what he tried to say

    • @Khalid-Haji
      @Khalid-Haji Месяц назад +1

      @@burakcoskun38 💯

    • @jamalshah2432
      @jamalshah2432 Месяц назад

      @@HT-xt4cn yes, more like inadvertently explained it. As he also agreed that a part is less than a whole.

    • @HT-xt4cn
      @HT-xt4cn Месяц назад

      @@burakcoskun38 lol nope

  • @theologyroom
    @theologyroom Месяц назад +108

    The Bible doesn't define God as a trinity.

    • @Jadoon0I0
      @Jadoon0I0 Месяц назад +3

      Read it again😂

    • @purplerain2205
      @purplerain2205 Месяц назад +16

      ​Did and no false trinity doctrine in the bible🤪🤪🤪​@@Jadoon0I0

    • @Jadoon0I0
      @Jadoon0I0 Месяц назад

      @@purplerain2205 did u read with both eyes closed? I can name a many verses off the top of my head.

    • @Jadoon0I0
      @Jadoon0I0 Месяц назад

      Genesis 19:24, John 1:1, Isaiah 48:16

    • @bangbang-nb7gi
      @bangbang-nb7gi Месяц назад

      ​@@Jadoon0I0critical thinking time: you use Hebrew scriptures to completely misinterpret their verses to justify your false narrative. Seriously think about that for a minute..
      You have absolutely no right to use Jewish scriptures which contradict The fake meanings you ascribe to them. But since you have.. take your last reference Isaiah 48:16.
      Isaiah 48:16 as, "The Lord God and His Spirit have sent me." However, a proper rendering of the verse reads: "And now the Lord God has sent me, and His spirit." The last two Hebrew words in this verse are shelachani ve-rucho ("He has sent me, and His spirit"), with "me, and His spirit" being the direct objects of "sent." Even though a definite direct object is usually preceded by the participle 'et, this grammatical rule is frequently not observed in the Bible, e.g., Exodus 15:9; Judges 5:12; Psalms 9:5, 20:3-4, 45:4. In fact, 'et rarely occurs in the poetic parts of the Bible. Thus, the meaning of the verse is that God has sent Isaiah accompanied by His prophetic spirit. There is no mention of the third member of the Trinity doctrine. Instead, Isaiah affirms that God, who has placed within him the power of prophecy, sent him.
      The spirit is always at the disposal of God to bestow upon whomever He chooses, as stated in Numbers 11:17, 25, 29; Isaiah 42:1, 44:3; Joel 3:1. If this spirit referred to the third member of a coequal tri-unity god, how could it be ordered about at the discretion of the other members of this group? We see that the Jewish Scriptures teach that "spirit" does not refer to the third person of a tri-unity god. Thus God says to Moses, "And I will take of the spirit which is upon you, and I will put it upon them. . . . And He took of the spirit which was upon him, and He put it upon the seventy men, the elders, and it came to pass, when the spirit rested upon them, that they prophesied. . . . And Moses said . . . 'would that all the Lord's people were prophets, that the Lord would put His spirit upon them'" (Numbers 1:17, 25, 29).
      Such a condition makes it obviously impossible to consider the spirit as being an associate of God, let alone coequal with Him.

  • @YoussefACHOUR-e5i
    @YoussefACHOUR-e5i Месяц назад +2

    I love how Brother Mohamed Hijab applies " أشداء على الكفار رحماء بينهم"

  • @fatima....8683
    @fatima....8683 Месяц назад +16

    "Say that Allah is one and only.Allah is the self sufficient . He begets not nor is he begotten And there is nothing like Him (Allah) "
    and this is the simplest doctrine of the islamic standard of believing and worshiping one God that if someone believes in... they will be saved!!!!

  • @theviraltrend7551
    @theviraltrend7551 Месяц назад +20

    May Allah reward brother Hijab for his efforts.

  • @MahayarMuttaqin-fn9ko
    @MahayarMuttaqin-fn9ko Месяц назад +12

    Nowhere in the Qur'an Trinity is defined as jesus and his mother mary, wlc's argument is so weak.

  • @mapharzms4625
    @mapharzms4625 Месяц назад +4

    MashaAllah loved this debate.. brilliantly done brother Hijab... many questions posed by brother Hijab were poorly responded by Dr William Craig

  • @RFQ22
    @RFQ22 Месяц назад +8

    It isnt hard to debate an illogical belief like the trinity

  • @i-Lion9
    @i-Lion9 Месяц назад +40

    Dr.Lang Craig I grew up as a christian and I had questions and the only answer was because the bible said so, I was lost. Alhamdulillah for Feb. 28th I said my shahada and I did my first ramadan and I've never felt closer to GOD than when i became Muslim. Allahu Akbar.

    • @tns8022
      @tns8022 Месяц назад

      Cheap taqqia try better joker

    • @i-Lion9
      @i-Lion9 Месяц назад +5

      @@tns8022 is taqiya what you meant to type? You think I'm faking this?? I'm 30 years old. I live in the US, grew up in a puerto rican house hold, so as Hispanics cristianity is first. I grew up protestant not catholic. I had answers about everything in the bible and I would get the same response. So sorry you don't believe me. I am a proud Muslim. Alhamdulillah

    • @tns8022
      @tns8022 Месяц назад

      @@i-Lion9 I can understand Christians becoming athiest due to personal experiences, but I will never accept anybody leaving Christianity for Islam unless he is a rank pervert and want to feel comfortable in his perversions . if Mohammed the greatest of all perverts is the ideal man to emulate in Mohammeds own religion then any criminal/pervert would become an Islamic saint. How come God condone perversion and sin only for Mohammed? He indulged in necrophilia, took his own daughter in law for himself under allahs orders (his own alter ego is allah) only retards would believe in the "prophethood" of Mohammed. Only prophet who couldn't distinguish an angel of God from satan is Mohammed!! That says a lot!!

    • @syedharis1906
      @syedharis1906 Месяц назад

      @@tns8022 Taqqiya is allowed in shia islam not mainsteam sunni... imagine muslims attacking christians saying you pray to marry as mother of God

    • @benjaminweaver535
      @benjaminweaver535 Месяц назад

      @@i-Lion9 and you believe Islam that denies a historically accepted claim of the crucifixion to be the truth? Im curious according to Islam why did the Jews want to crucify Jesus?

  • @ninolama
    @ninolama Месяц назад +14

    I believe God is one and above all. If that means I'm not a Christian, then I guess I'll find another definition.

    • @PEGangstrr
      @PEGangstrr Месяц назад

      You are not a Christian if you don’t believe in the trinity but investigate it more before you run away don’t take advice from hijab he is a fake Islamist study your own religion and talk to educated Christian’s

    • @ServantoftheMostMerciful_99
      @ServantoftheMostMerciful_99 Месяц назад

      Unitarians exist.
      They're not that popular because most of them see in Islam what they've had in their heart and end up embracing it.

    • @rezakhan1086
      @rezakhan1086 Месяц назад +9

      Let us return to the religion of Abraham, who was neither a Christian nor a Jew, but one who submitted his will to God.

    • @ninolama
      @ninolama Месяц назад +1

      ​@@rezakhan1086💯

    • @roaaalashhab7261
      @roaaalashhab7261 Месяц назад +4

      (135) They say, "Be Jews or Christians [so] you will be guided." Say, "Rather, [we follow] the religion of Abraham, inclining toward truth, and he was not of the polytheists."[47]
      [47]- Those who associate others with Allāh in worship.
      (67) Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was one inclining toward truth, a Muslim [submitting to Allāh]. And he was not of the polytheists.[129]
      [129]- Those who associate others with Allāh.

  • @Apollo05
    @Apollo05 Месяц назад +2

    Easiest way to tell when a Christian apologist is being insincere: when they say tawhid is confusing and questionable
    They wish they had tawhid. May Allah guide them to Islam.

  • @Brraziqved
    @Brraziqved Месяц назад +13

    The Champ Always Wins!! 💙💙🕋🕋❤❤

  • @muz7u
    @muz7u Месяц назад +9

    Let me explain how Craig lost this debate to lay audience:
    Craig resorted to flawed analogies and examples to defend. Let's extend his flame example to next step, Just imagine two guns shot at the head at the same time. A gun shot to the head means you have a bullet but 2 gunshots to the head means that you now have 2 bullets to the head.
    In the analogy, a single gunshot to the head represents something complete and effective on its own. One bullet is enough to cause death-there's no need for more to achieve the result.
    Now, imagine you add a second gunshot. Although the result is still death, something has changed. You no longer have just one bullet-you now have two bullets, which is different from the original situation. It’s not the same as having just one; the overall picture has been altered, even if the outcome (death) remains the same.
    How does this relate to the Trinity?
    Just like in the gunshot analogy, one God is enough. Adding more persons-Father, Son, and Holy Spirit-changes the original concept of having a single, indivisible God.
    With one God (like one gunshot), the concept of God is simple and straightforward: one being, one essence, one authority.
    When you add the second and third persons (like adding more bullets), even if all are considered “God,” it’s no longer the same as having just one simple God. Now, you're dealing with something more complex, with multiple parts or persons, even though Christians claim it’s still “one God.”
    The analogy shows that adding persons changes the basic nature of God. Just like having two gunshots isn’t the same as having one, having three persons isn't the same as having just one God. This challenges the idea that God can be truly "one" in the simplest sense if there are three distinct entities, even if they are all part of the same divine being.
    So, the point is that oneness means one, without anything added. If you add something (like a second or third person), even if it’s still called “one God,” the simplicity of being just one is lost.

    • @saidibrahim5931
      @saidibrahim5931 Месяц назад +2

      Don't waste your time with this propaganda God is 1 and everyone else is created by God very simple.

    • @overoscar1788
      @overoscar1788 Месяц назад

      @@saidibrahim5931 I think people get lost in the physical analogies. The simplest is something like you push a button and the elevator comes. 2 people do it at the same time even though it only takes one. Each person is fully capable and sufficient but only one is necessary which makes the other one redundant. There can only be one God (necessary Entity). God cannot be redundant or codependent etc. so the trinity fails

  • @samuelwilliams6171
    @samuelwilliams6171 Месяц назад +12

    Hindu Trinity Brahma Vishnu and Shiva
    Christian Trinity Father Son Holy Spirit
    Islam ALLAH
    Judaism ELOHIM
    Christianity has nothing to do with monotheism. Christianity is pagan like Hinduism.
    Ex Christian and Muslim Alhamdulillah from Germany ☪️

    • @Fatehali-yg3ky
      @Fatehali-yg3ky Месяц назад

      Judaism : elohim and asherah (i.e not monotheistic)

    • @samuelwilliams6171
      @samuelwilliams6171 Месяц назад

      @@Fatehali-yg3ky Jews never said god is Trinity like christians and hindus

    • @Letgoit2
      @Letgoit2 Месяц назад

      @@samuelwilliams6171 Dont forget they took their Rabbis as Lords beside God.

    • @Fatehali-yg3ky
      @Fatehali-yg3ky Месяц назад

      ​@@samuelwilliams6171irrelevant still polytheistic as they believe in God cohorts

    • @REMIEL532
      @REMIEL532 Месяц назад

      Elohim means Gods, and Eloah is its singular form.

  • @eldagon9306
    @eldagon9306 Месяц назад +13

    May Allah guide mr. Craig to Islam.
    Thank you, brother Hijab, for your dawah, may Allah increase you in this life and the next.

  • @integratedneutral5975
    @integratedneutral5975 Месяц назад +4

    ighting a candle with two matchsticks versus one could lead to some subtle differences:
    Speed of Ignition: Using two matchsticks will likely light the candle faster because more heat is being applied from two sources simultaneously. The combined flame could increase the speed at which the wick catches fire.
    Heat Intensity: The heat from two matchsticks will be higher than from one, potentially causing the wick to burn slightly more vigorously at the start.
    Match Burn Time: Two matchsticks might burn out quicker since they will feed off each other’s heat, potentially consuming more fuel rapidly, whereas one matchstick burns more slowly on its own.
    Wax Melting: The higher heat from two matchsticks could melt more wax around the wick initially, potentially creating a larger pool of melted wax earlier in the process.

    • @overoscar1788
      @overoscar1788 Месяц назад +1

      I think in essence the physics is irrelevant. 2 people push an elevator button at the same time would be closer to what he wanted to say. each person is fully capable and sufficient. The problem is that since ONLY ONE IS NECESSARY the other would have to be redundant. God is necessary and cannot be redundant. Therefore God is ONE and the trinity fails.

  • @zigadiboom98
    @zigadiboom98 Месяц назад +35

    In opening remarks
    "There are two fundamental tenants
    1. There is EXACTLY one God
    2. There are 3 persons who are properly called God...That's it. This is a straightforward doctrine."
    How is this logically sound?

    • @RFQ22
      @RFQ22 Месяц назад +1

      😂

    • @Khalid-Haji
      @Khalid-Haji Месяц назад +4

      My 🧠 is NOT braining 😅

    • @OniLeafNin
      @OniLeafNin Месяц назад

      Substance vs Persons, not difficult for the philosophically literate.

    • @overoscar1788
      @overoscar1788 Месяц назад

      @@OniLeafNin what about ancient Greeks or Hindus? 1000 gods 1 substance? or 1000 gods/persons "part of the same Godhead"? God is One. Don't say three. Just One. plain simple. No need for philosophy or mental gymnastics.

    • @OniLeafNin
      @OniLeafNin Месяц назад

      @@overoscar1788 God is one, but also being itself is sustained in God, the divine simplicity is not destroyed by the category of personhood anymore than each cloud or speck of dust changes God’s nature

  • @AyoubE-f4t
    @AyoubE-f4t Месяц назад +7

    According to mister William Lane Craig the trinity is very simple and the oneness of God ie the islamic concept is very confusing 🤦‍♂️

  • @AgainstTheGrain1991
    @AgainstTheGrain1991 Месяц назад +19

    As a biblical follower of Yeshua the Messiah, and a non support of Muhammad /islam I have to acknowledge William who is one of my favorite philosophers, lost this debate With all due respect

    • @Artemidia
      @Artemidia Месяц назад +2

      You are lying so hard

    • @whiteandblack2005
      @whiteandblack2005 Месяц назад

      @@AgainstTheGrain1991
      Are you truly a Biblical follower of Yeshua the Messiah?
      Come let's reason together.
      Yeshua used to reason.
      The Muslim invites you to reason.
      Won't you reason?
      The religious historian and philosopher Han-Joachim Schoeps says: “Here is a paradox of world-historical proportions: Jewish Christianity indeed disappeared within the Christian church, but was PRESERVED in Islam.”
      (Caps mine)
      ******************
      👉 Backed up by the preaching and practice of Jesus of the Bible.
      ******************
      "There is CONSENSUS among biblical scholars that Jesus, to all historical probability, did NOT consider himself as the incarnation of the second person of a Trinitarian God. NOWHERE did Jesus teach a Trinitarian doctrine. As one would expect from a pious Jewish rabbi, he believed in ONE GOD and strictly REFUSED to be equated with God. Jesus saw himself as a divinely authorized MESSENGER ... [and] his contemporaries [saw] Jesus as a PROPHET..." (Perry Schmidt-Leukel, Religious Pluralism, 152)
      Caps mine

    • @melisentiapheiffer3034
      @melisentiapheiffer3034 Месяц назад

      Thank you for your honesty and integrity.

    • @Artemidia
      @Artemidia Месяц назад

      @@AgainstTheGrain1991 you are a muslim who lies that it is Christian to make people believe his lies.
      No Cristian calls the Christ Yeshua the Messiah.
      You people and the ones who believe you are so st*pid

  • @amth3400
    @amth3400 Месяц назад +23

    No Audio at 28:00 ?

    • @PiewPiew306
      @PiewPiew306 Месяц назад +1

      Because he was making good arguments

    • @WelcomeToTheRezvolution
      @WelcomeToTheRezvolution Месяц назад +13

      Went to the original channel to watch what he said. Doesn't really say much.

    • @Abdur-Rahman862
      @Abdur-Rahman862 Месяц назад

      Link it here for those who think Hijab is being deceptive
      ​@@WelcomeToTheRezvolution

    • @abduallahamin2001
      @abduallahamin2001 Месяц назад

      See description

    • @abduallahamin2001
      @abduallahamin2001 Месяц назад

      ​@@PiewPiew306
      See description, he included what he said, and also referred to the stream version in which you can hear it.

  • @MohamedAhmed-lc6ch
    @MohamedAhmed-lc6ch Месяц назад +6

    Christians they can't answer simple questions concerning trinity and they are trying to talk about Islam which is crystal clear concerning oneness of Allah.

  • @peterfryer6915
    @peterfryer6915 Месяц назад +3

    CP crushed hijab. It was hilarious too because this guy called in under a false name. Deaf and blind as the one true God stated would be the case for many. I’ll continue to pray for Muslims.

    • @platinum2117
      @platinum2117 Месяц назад +1

      We Muslims don't need your prayers, especially since you're a polytheist who supports another polytheist imbecile like cp who has no manners or ettiquets and supports the genocide of 🍉

  • @Badrkc
    @Badrkc Месяц назад +15

    We can't be Muslims if we don't believe in all prophets and messengers of the almighty God. From Adam till Mohamed Peace be upon all of them.

    • @roaaalashhab7261
      @roaaalashhab7261 Месяц назад

      ﴿آمَنَ الرَّسولُ بِما أُنزِلَ إِلَيهِ مِن رَبِّهِ وَالمُؤمِنونَ كُلٌّ آمَنَ بِاللَّهِ وَمَلائِكَتِهِ وَكُتُبِهِ وَرُسُلِهِ لا نُفَرِّقُ بَينَ أَحَدٍ مِن رُسُلِهِ وَقالوا سَمِعنا وَأَطَعنا غُفرانَكَ رَبَّنا وَإِلَيكَ المَصيرُ﴾ [البقرة: ٢٨٥]
      (285) The Messenger has believed in what was revealed to him from his Lord, and [so have] the believers. All of them have believed in Allāh and His angels and His books and His messengers, [saying], "We make no distinction between any of His messengers." And they say, "We hear and we obey. [We seek] Your forgiveness, our Lord, and to You is the [final] destination."
      Islam is the truth

    • @leebromley7987
      @leebromley7987 Месяц назад +1

      Where are the prophets books? Genuinely curious

    • @Badrkc
      @Badrkc Месяц назад

      Thanks for your comment.
      This is a detailed answer.
      It is not necessary for every prophet to have a book, nor does the absence of the books of previous prophets and messengers mean that they never existed. Firstly, their message was unified: the oneness of God. The previous scriptures are historically documented, and the most preserved among them is the Qur'an along with the Sunnah of the Prophet. They contain accounts of the prophets who came before, as well as their books, even though those books were not preserved and were distorted by the Jews, Christians, and their scholars. This is evident from the contradictions and changes over time, especially the additions made to them.
      The Qur'an explicitly states that it will remain preserved until the Day of Judgment, and this aligns with historical facts. As Muslims, we believe in all the messengers because they are mentioned in the final book, which abrogates all previous scriptures. Therefore, everyone is obliged to believe in God's uncorrupted message. If you have not read the Qur'an before, I recommend that you read it in its entirety - it's around 600 pages.
      As God says:
      ﴿قُل إِنَّما أَعِظُكُم بِواحِدَةٍ أَن تَقوموا لِلَّهِ مَثنى وَفُرادى ثُمَّ تَتَفَكَّروا ما بِصاحِبِكُم مِن جِنَّةٍ إِن هُوَ إِلّا نَذيرٌ لَكُم بَينَ يَدَي عَذابٍ شَديدٍ﴾ [سبأ: ٤٦]
      (46) Say, "I only advise you of one [thing] - that you stand for Allāh, [seeking truth] in pairs and individually, and then give thought." There is not in your companion any madness. He is only a warner to you before a severe punishment.
      - English Translation
      Pls feel free to ask💡

    • @Badrkc
      @Badrkc Месяц назад

      ​@@leebromley7987
      Thanks for your comment.
      Here is a detailed answer and more infos related
      It is not necessary for every prophet to have a book, nor does the absence of the books of previous prophets and messengers mean that they never existed. Firstly, their message was unified: the oneness of God. The previous scriptures are historically documented, and the most preserved among them is the Qur'an along with the Sunnah of the Prophet. They contain accounts of the prophets who came before, as well as their books, even though those books were not preserved and were distorted by the Jews, Christians, and their scholars. This is evident from the contradictions and changes over time, especially the additions made to them.
      The Qur'an explicitly states that it will remain preserved until the Day of Judgment, and this aligns with historical facts. As Muslims, we believe in all the messengers because they are mentioned in the final book, which abrogates all previous scriptures. Therefore, everyone is obliged to believe in God's uncorrupted message. If you have not read the Qur'an before, I recommend that you read it in its entirety - it's around 600 pages.
      As the almighty God says: "Say, 'I only advise you of one [thing] - that you stand for Allah, [seeking truth] in pairs and individually, and then give thought.' There is not in your companion any madness. He is only a warner to you before a severe punishment." - [Surah Saba: 46]

    • @Badrkc
      @Badrkc Месяц назад

      ​@@leebromley7987
      Whenever I write the reply comment it is deleted I still can't figure out the issue.

  • @alexsmith2766
    @alexsmith2766 Месяц назад +10

    While WLC had strong moments, especially in defending the biblical doctrine of the Trinity, MH's persistent challenges about necessary agreement, causality, and divine partialism put WLC on the defensive throughout the debate. WLC's shift to a discussion about the resurrection, rather than continuing to address the coherence of the Trinity, made it seem as though MH had successfully cornered him on the topic at hand.

  • @peace123...
    @peace123... Месяц назад +6

    You know you're desperate when you use three headed dog and three 🔥 for lightning a candle as an analogy for defining the core believe of your faith.

  • @fuzailahmad6604
    @fuzailahmad6604 Месяц назад +1

    SubhanAllah. This is beautiful. May Allah guide Dr. William Lane Craig and our fellow brethren Ahle-Kitaab to Islam. 🤲🏽

  • @asadullahsaaid3794
    @asadullahsaaid3794 Месяц назад +4

    Timestamps:
    00:00 - Introduction
    01:50 - Opening Remarks by Dr. William Lane Craig
    03:35 - Claim of misunderstanding of the Trinity within the Quran
    04:03 - Explanation of the basic doctrine of the Trinity
    04:52 - Claim regarding interpretation of Tawheed in Islam
    06:09 - Opening Remarks by Br. Mohammed Hijab
    06:59 - Critiques of Dr. Craig’s representation of mainstream Christianity
    08:14 - Exposing the Error in Dr. Craig's interpretation of Quran 5:116
    09:26 - Response from Dr. William Lane Craig
    11:54 - Challenging Dr. Craig’s representation of social trinitarianism
    12:31 - Trinitarian Doctrine: Dr. Craig’s interpretation vs historical orthodox beliefs
    13:10 - Discrepencies regarding the eternal generation of the Son
    14:19 - Dr. Craig's closing remarks: defense of the doctrine of the Trinity
    14:45 - Dr. Craig's Critique of Gregory of Nyssa’s Explanation
    15:10 - William Hasker’s model about the Son's eternal generation & the Spirit's procession
    16:25 - Challenging Dr. Craig's denial of the eternal begotten nature of the Son
    17:11 - Alignment b/w Craig's views & Islamic theology regarding God's nature
    18:49 - Dr. Craig defense of his position on the Trinity
    20:06 - Dr. Craig acknowledges shared truths between Christianity & Islam
    20:56 - Highlighting Craig's concerns about subordinationism in Christian doctrine
    21:55 - Analysing the Complexity of Doctrinal Interpretation of the Trinity
    22:26 - Analysis of Incoherence in Trinitarian Beliefs
    23:29 - Critique of William Lane Craig’s Model of the Trinity
    24:00 - Dr. Craig defends his position by referencing early Church fathers
    26:03 - Nature of God: Christianity vs Islam
    26:58 - Questions Regarding Trinitarian Agreement
    29:33 - Examining the elationship b/w the Father & the Son
    31:56 - Divine Perfection vs. Arbitrariness
    32:25 - Issues with the Analogies for Understanding Trinity (Cerberus: the three-headed dog)
    33:10 - Dr. Craig's explanation of the Analogies
    35:29 - Contradictions in the Trinitarian Models
    37:01 - Debate on the Nature of Divine Responsibility & Causal Overdetermination
    38:30 - The Trinity acting undividedly in creation
    39:30 - Challenges to Dual Responsibility
    40:28 - Dr. Craig reiterates his stance on causal overdetermination
    41:05 - Refutation of the candles analogy: Inconsistencies in dual creator scenarios
    44:21 - Limitations of the Analogies
    45:31 - Scrutinizing the Laws of Logic & Divine Will
    46:20 - Dr. Craig's views on Omnipotence & Inhibition
    47:33 - Implications of Creation in Concert: Limitations on God's will
    48:35 - Quranic Perspective on Divine Uniqueness
    49:06 - Incoherence in Trinitarian Models
    53:16 - Dr. Craig's closing statement
    56:11 - Hijab's closing statement
    59:14 - Dr Craig's final remarks
    1:00:04 - Hijab's final remarks

  • @adnanmir2873
    @adnanmir2873 Месяц назад +23

    This was utter destruction done by Mohammad Hijab here.

    • @ghostlycookie630
      @ghostlycookie630 Месяц назад

      Bro did you even watch the same debate? Dr. Craig won by a landslide

  • @Sal_A
    @Sal_A Месяц назад +6

    I learned that a Doctors degree means nothing. Who is making these curriculums?