Why Criticism Of Israel Isn't Antisemitism

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024

Комментарии • 1,5 тыс.

  • @Arcane_Digital
    @Arcane_Digital 3 года назад +159

    “Every criticism of Israel is not Anti-Semitic.” …about time someone said it.

    • @gamer4life0602
      @gamer4life0602 3 года назад +1

      True but seeking to destroy the Jewish state and give all of their land go Palestine is anti semitism

    • @olssong7941
      @olssong7941 2 года назад +5

      @@gamer4life0602 No.

    • @Silverswitch1
      @Silverswitch1 2 года назад +6

      @@gamer4life0602 Zionism isn’t Judaism. Orthodox Jews dislike Zionism. So by your logic, Orthodox Jews are anti-Semitic.

    • @dagothur9674
      @dagothur9674 2 года назад +8

      @@gamer4life0602 No, it's anti-colonialism. It was created by Europeans who occupy Palestinian land.

    • @gamer4life0602
      @gamer4life0602 2 года назад

      @@dagothur9674 Palestine was just made up to oppose Israel and never once has been a nation

  • @tarab9530
    @tarab9530 5 лет назад +252

    Thank you. As an American Jew I abhor Netanyahu and I am boycotting Israel. People tend to forget that there are extremists in every religion and race. The Palestinians should not have to live under apartheid. There needs to be a 2 state solution. People are people and we all have the same internal organs and red blood. Hopefully Netanyahu is out and the people of Israel can live in leave with each other. Also if every young Israeli Jew has to be in the military, ultra orthodox Jews should not be exempt. Every year my family bought Israeli bonds until 2 years ago when they started putting trump's name on everything.

    • @matanamar
      @matanamar 5 лет назад +6

      Tara Watson what are you talking about? What apartheid? You are sadly brainwashed... if you boycott Israelis because some of them support trump, what about boycotting the US where Trump is president... hypocrisy

    • @alveolate
      @alveolate 5 лет назад +26

      @@matanamar do you know how the palestinians are being treated? talk about "brainwashed".
      also, you can boycott trump very easily. vote democrat.
      and in case you're still living under the same fox news rock, MANY american companies have already begun to boycott trump.

    • @enhaxed7839
      @enhaxed7839 5 лет назад +20

      @@matanamar Israel is an apartheid state because it treats non-jewish citizens as having less rights, just like apartheid South Africa did with non-whites. It's pure institutional racism.

    • @katherinemorelle7115
      @katherinemorelle7115 5 лет назад +13

      I worry that it’s far too late for a two state solution- look how tiny Palestine has become, and the settlements are making it look like Swiss cheese, but with more holes. How do you make two states out of that?

    • @jadedoptimist6364
      @jadedoptimist6364 5 лет назад +3

      I sub to The Last American Vagabond channel. He is not bias and covers the middle East well.

  • @ihatecranberryjiuce
    @ihatecranberryjiuce 8 месяцев назад +113

    4 years old and these points still hit

    • @samuelchepkwony4895
      @samuelchepkwony4895 8 месяцев назад +4

      Yup it cought me of guard. Maans consistent 👌

    • @floridamarinemom1749
      @floridamarinemom1749 7 месяцев назад +5

      Even more so now. You can't even criticize a genocide without being called anti-Semitic.

    • @elliem2975
      @elliem2975 6 месяцев назад

      @@floridamarinemom1749 Brainwashed educate yourself, unless you want to live under an Islamic caliphate.

  • @BeeRoyLee
    @BeeRoyLee 5 лет назад +51

    Thank you for this. My Jewish friends have provided me the opportunity to know that not all Jews support israelí policies. Unfortunately, most don’t have not been afforded the same opportunity.

    • @linechaay6430
      @linechaay6430 Год назад +3

      Same boat brother

    • @kwamebushman606
      @kwamebushman606 Год назад

      They don't support it but I bet you they're NOT doing anything about it...the hypocrisy with these people 🤣

    • @BeeRoyLee
      @BeeRoyLee Год назад +3

      @@kwamebushman606 like the content creator of this video, there are those who are doing something about it. Even if someone speaks against Israeli policy among friends and/or family, they are doing something. I can relate to your frustration but it was comforting, at least for me, to find out not all of them are bad actors.

  • @lisamann
    @lisamann 8 месяцев назад +26

    This is SO SO RELEVANT now!!! Thank you!

  • @grapeshot
    @grapeshot 5 лет назад +119

    And a lot of people seem to have this attitude. That Jews and Israelis have a monopoly on suffering. THEY DON'T!!!!!

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +6

      Hi Bloody, Yeah, it always bothers me that between 20 and 30 Million people under Nazi jurisdiction died during World War II but somehow the only deaths that mattered were those of six million Jews. But that is understandable since the Jews are the chosen people of God, so, really, I don't even know how the rest of us have a right to call ourselves Human Beings. Jeez, now that I think about it, maybe I should just sign my house over to a Jew and take a hand full of that Opioid Crisis.

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +1

      @JohnnyTheWolf Hi Johnny, what did the Quebec guy say... that is, translated from the French (for years i was reading French, but it got really rusty).

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +4

      @JohnnyTheWolf Hi Johnny, Yeah, thanks for the Wikipedia Page on the "michaud Affair". Yeah, the Jewish Organizations have what must be a strict protocol on lashing out and punishing any hint of criticism, or just any kind of hesitation about bowing down to the acknowledged supremacy of the Jewish People. To not bow is Antisemitic. That Religious Cult that is popular with Movie Stars, well, they are the same way. They keep a team of lawyers on retainer and use the Courts as weapons to punish people. The Judges don't mind. Judges are all former lawyers and think that law suits are good for the Country Club. With the Jews, it is the same mindset. Punish anybody who speaks. I suppose the only remedy is to keep on speaking until the general public realizes that we should not be giving in to Jewish Supremacy. The Jews say they will "Never Forget" but 'forget what'?.... Everything they learned from the Nazis. It is like the Zionists took notes.

    • @abelgonzales3695
      @abelgonzales3695 5 лет назад +4

      Every lazy ignorant person, across the race and color spectrum, claims that they suffer the most. I choose not to enter the oppression Olympics. It’s like where the gold medal is given to whomever comes in last place. The winner is given a free pity party on the committees behalf. Pathetic.

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +3

      @@abelgonzales3695 Hi Abel Gonzales, Yeah, we all know that there are some really macho cultures where nobody would complain (especially if they are White Spaniards still lording over Indigenous Latin America like they still have a charter from Queen Isabella. But some People's do have legitimate gripes. American Blacks WERE kept down by Slavery and then Jim Crow Racism and Institutionalized Discrimination and Voting Disenfranchisement. Many Countries in Latin America, Asia and Africa got locked into the Colonial Model of being Resource Providers, shipping off their raw materials and not getting their fair share of the final profits. Yeah, there is supposed to be Supply and Demand 'Adam Smith Invisible Hand' pricing regulations, where people can't expect more than anything is actually worth, BUT when Countries try to establish price levels at what they determine to be their true value, people get shot by British or America Death Squads (people wonder why England and America are allies, well, those Anglo Saxon Cold Blooded Murderers would be afraid to turn backs on one another.... it is easier to keep an eye on a Friend than an Enemy... which explains why Israel has "friends".

  • @Amandaaa2244
    @Amandaaa2244 5 лет назад +246

    Thank you! I also try to explain to people that Judaism and the Israeli government are not the same thing. The sucky part about it is being called an anti-Semite by Christians... and I’m a jew.

    • @tefayambaye4516
      @tefayambaye4516 5 лет назад +9

      😅 that’s unfortunate but funny

    • @thankshi2815
      @thankshi2815 5 лет назад +7

      Amanda Berg you are a self hating Jew

    • @NellieKAdaba
      @NellieKAdaba 5 лет назад +12

      Wow, I understand, I'm a Christian, I've been accused of being antisemitic, when I'm not. I've friends from all religions.

    • @Amandaaa2244
      @Amandaaa2244 5 лет назад +18

      Exhibit A: 2/4 of these comments.

    • @Amandaaa2244
      @Amandaaa2244 5 лет назад +24

      @Gray Kin you can support Israel's existence without supporting its government.

  • @amir_fahmi
    @amir_fahmi 5 лет назад +140

    Has Bibi called his election defeat anti semitic yet ?

  • @grapeshot
    @grapeshot 5 лет назад +175

    Yeah it's something to Right does very good it's called deflection and projection.

    • @xeftones
      @xeftones 5 лет назад +9

      Why Criticism Of Islam Isn't Islamaphobia

    • @grapeshot
      @grapeshot 5 лет назад +6

      @@xeftones And why not being a part of any religion doesn't make you a bad person.

    • @grapeshot
      @grapeshot 5 лет назад +3

      @behind you white people have been complacent in many horror in history. So if the shoe fits.

    • @bodyguardbrocksamson
      @bodyguardbrocksamson 5 лет назад +1

      FilthyFascist And, non-Whites hold no responsibility over your genetic inferiority. 😐

    • @grapeshot
      @grapeshot 5 лет назад +1

      @Islam is Right About women I don't subscribe to any religion. There is no invisible sky wizard that controls everything.

  • @soulpriestess1953
    @soulpriestess1953 5 лет назад +43

    Criticism of Israel is not anti-Semitism. Change my mind.

    • @roystonmason9125
      @roystonmason9125 5 лет назад

      who need to ! yer fuct

    • @andi2658
      @andi2658 5 лет назад +3

      again, 'criticicize' can come in different meaning nowadays. One is actually criticizing, for example i personally criticize israel not to add another settlement in the west bank, as they simply complicate things
      but anti-israel muslims like hezbollah, and other pro-palestinian muslims, wants eradication of israel as a state. Even if they don't make settlements in west bank, they will keep firing rockets, condemning israel as 'invasion' (while no, they're not, the ashkenazi jews are the originally local ones and they constitute about half of the original israelis post independence)
      lets also not forget that before the independence, those very same local middle eastern jews are being forced to have death march, by the arab muslims (egypt, algeria, iraq, they use to have substantial jewish population back then, where are they? forced to leave their houses by the arab muslims and forced to move, many that survives arrive in the jewish pockets in middle east which are the areas given for israel independence)
      look at reality, look at yourself and your own religious islamic community, you know that there is barely any rational basis for the provocations and hate you have been preached about israel. Like it or not, islamic communities are not known to have rational basis when it comes to religion issues. Most religious muslims simply want more islam, not actual justice for everyone. This is also proven by the fact that the initial period post-independence israel had to face a coalition of arab muslim nations invading them, one thing that i can tell you is that if 'israel' is a muslim majority country, they won't be as aggressive and the whole wars won't take place
      yes , in the eyes of muslims , religious muslims mostly (which is basically most of muslims) it is about religion. Israel is a JEWISH state, if it is another islamic state, you won't have the hate nor the wars to begin with

    • @roystonmason9125
      @roystonmason9125 4 года назад

      @@michaelprosyak4489 they are the palestinians and the people of Jordan ! DNA results prove it ! FREAK

    • @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io
      @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io 4 года назад +1

      Antisemitic criticism of Israel is antisemitism. Change my mind.

    • @kova1577
      @kova1577 2 года назад

      Imagine being against a cult being a bad thing

  • @robertlight5227
    @robertlight5227 4 года назад +12

    If I criticize Norway for killing whales does that make me anti-Scandinavian?

    • @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io
      @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io 4 года назад

      If you insinuate that Norwegian secretly run the world and then you gaslight anyone who calls you on it... perhaps you are. ;)

    • @robertlight5227
      @robertlight5227 4 года назад +1

      @@ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io Lol. Good one.

  • @PAINTuRED
    @PAINTuRED 5 лет назад +221

    We need more Jewish voices speaking on this subject!

    • @jadedoptimist6364
      @jadedoptimist6364 5 лет назад +4

      Check out Israeli News Live channel. It's great.

    • @thealligator918
      @thealligator918 5 лет назад +14

      so what you are basically saying: "We need more Jewish people promoting antisemetism!"

    • @Ihbaworldsax
      @Ihbaworldsax 5 лет назад +2

      That was a beautiful rant Brother!

    • @Ihbaworldsax
      @Ihbaworldsax 5 лет назад +3

      I look forward to more of your insights. It seems to easy to Attack a people. And if you Dont stand up for other people. You can’t say a thing when you are under Attack.. one universal world Love!

    • @PunchUp01
      @PunchUp01 5 лет назад +30

      @@thealligator918 speaking out against Israeli political and secular policy is not antisemitic. You missed the whole point of the piece.

  • @snagh
    @snagh 5 лет назад +44

    Well said man , no one denies the rights of Jews or Israel , but this should not at the expense of Palestinians.

    • @companymo7767
      @companymo7767 5 лет назад +4

      "no denies the rights of Jews or Israel " it is a shame man. i really pitty you. what in god name makes you say that. is it their right because your bible said they lived there milion years ago . your bible say a lot of silly things. the land is not for jewish. the land is for the peaple who lived in it for 2000 years until 40 years ago some .jewish people came and killed everyone and took it.
      period read history and not that sillly history that happened when people didn't have writing and has myths mixed with truth

    • @sulimanhertani1206
      @sulimanhertani1206 5 лет назад +1

      @@companymo7767 spot on 👍

    • @matanamar
      @matanamar 5 лет назад +1

      Except the Palestinians deny....

    • @matanamar
      @matanamar 5 лет назад

      mouharir ayoub its their right because the Arab world around tried to destroy Israel, after the UN voted to partition the land, and the Arab side lost, you cant cry because you failed to kill a nation, and it backfired

    • @janvanruth3485
      @janvanruth3485 5 лет назад +3

      @@companymo7767 you should brush up on your knowledge of history.
      2000 years ago there were jews living in palestine.
      it is not 40 years ago but some 100 years ago that jews started settling in palestine.
      the killing started not 40 years ago but some 70 years ago.
      jews do not have a bible, christians do.
      apart from that, i believe the land is not for the jews, who took it by force while blackmailing the world with the nazi history.
      those supporting the state of israel are in fact supporting the extermination of palestines.

  • @caroljomartin3051
    @caroljomartin3051 5 лет назад +118

    Ben Shapiro: the 9 year old who can't speak without huffing helium....

    • @originalandrewmark
      @originalandrewmark 5 лет назад +1

      @JohnnyTheWolf Master Shake rules!

    • @4T3hM4kr0n
      @4T3hM4kr0n 5 лет назад +2

      you got that right, holy shit is his voice weird.

    • @bob-wo3ir
      @bob-wo3ir 5 лет назад +2

      AJ+ is Qatari BS propaganda.

    • @michealbay1290
      @michealbay1290 5 лет назад +5

      @JohnnyTheWolf
      Ben Shapiro is one beady-eyed weirdo wannabe c.hitchens.

    • @loading6333
      @loading6333 5 лет назад

      @Meeran Majid prech :)

  • @Tryo707
    @Tryo707 5 лет назад +74

    Palestinians deserves a land for themselves. A two-state solution is the best option. Saying this is not anti-semitism.

    • @MM-xm5vx
      @MM-xm5vx 5 лет назад +11

      They had that chance but they ruined it. And I’m muslim

    • @keionchase2144
      @keionchase2144 5 лет назад +13

      @@MM-xm5vx You're a sell out, and a liar

    • @bufunga
      @bufunga 5 лет назад +4

      Yup especially if they were there first

    • @Tryo707
      @Tryo707 5 лет назад +14

      @@MM-xm5vx They never had a fair shot and either you know that, or you're talking about things like an expert even though you're not qualified to speak on the subject. I'm guessing the latter.

    • @AliAli-zk3ku
      @AliAli-zk3ku 5 лет назад +12

      Exquisite Elephant a Muslim can be a douche bag too. The truth has no religion. Israelis came from Europe to invade someone’s land like what Christopher Columbus did in America and called the natives Indians!!

  • @jamesdaugherty2339
    @jamesdaugherty2339 5 лет назад +190

    "Hi, I'm NOT Francesca Fiorentini"
    I died lmao

  • @Mogamishu
    @Mogamishu 5 лет назад +24

    Do not ask what your country can do for you.
    Ask what your country can do for Israel.

  • @reddragon3163
    @reddragon3163 7 месяцев назад +2

    Damn just became a recent fan of Matt, can't believe he's being doing this for a minute. Big respect.

  • @danwall6662
    @danwall6662 3 года назад +33

    Of course the right wing Israeli government needs serious scrutiny and criticism, this is not anti semitic. Plenty of Jews in side Israel and outside want better rights for Palestinian people. When you are not allowed to criticise, without being called a Jew hater, is ridiculous. This is thought control.

    • @ralphvon283
      @ralphvon283 Год назад

      Dan Wall, as in Abdul Mohamed Jihadi, using Dan Wall as a psuedonym? I thought that the shill factories in Tehran had shut down temporarily due to the rioting, I guess you guys are still at work. What do they pay now per post, is it in rials because they are worth less every day.

    • @jimreilly6933
      @jimreilly6933 Год назад

      I am British and often criticize the foreign policies of my home nation. If anyone wants to call me "anti British" so what, its only a name, cant harm me with a name. Does not bother me in the least.

  • @brokenking5044
    @brokenking5044 5 лет назад +67

    *I'm Ben Derpiro, Derp Police!*

    • @animock3051
      @animock3051 5 лет назад +3

      Lmao this is why no one respects you

    •  4 года назад +1

      Broken King I’m no Alex Jones fan, but you GOTTA watch his rant about Ben Shapiro. It’s heeeelarious.
      ruclips.net/video/7acg6WDbH4w/видео.html

  • @J.Panxer
    @J.Panxer 3 года назад +7

    Most people don't even know the etymology of the term, and certainly never thought about how the definition has been coopted and used to obfuscate honest discussion and shut down criticism.

  • @American-BadAss732
    @American-BadAss732 3 месяца назад +1

    It's like when mob boss Joe Colombo started his own Anti-Defamation League saying even mentioning the mafia was somehow anti-italian...

  • @ejaaz7260
    @ejaaz7260 5 лет назад +5

    Criticizing Saudi Arabia isn't islamophobia.
    Criticizing Israel isn't anti-semitism.
    Those countries and their governments aren't representation of Muslims and Jews around the world !

    • @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io
      @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io 4 года назад

      Criticizing Israel isn't antisemitic.
      It's antisemitic to use 2,000-year-old anti-Jewish canards against Israel or to threaten to dismantle a Jewish country.

    • @coderamen666
      @coderamen666 7 месяцев назад

      ​@@ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5iois it islamophobia to support secular socialist/liberal/pro democracy movements in Arab countries?

    • @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io
      @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io 7 месяцев назад

      @coderamen666 Is it?

  • @MrBenbaruch
    @MrBenbaruch 4 года назад +12

    I'm am Jew and Steve Miller is no brother of mine. I support BDS because genocide against Palestinians is not a Jewish value.

    •  4 года назад +2

      MrBenbaruch YESSS!!!!!! I wish there were more folk like you in the US. It seems the right-wing Evangelical Xtian Zionists are the biggest problem. They practically fetishize hating and killing Arabs.

    • @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io
      @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io 4 года назад

      The self-avowed goal of BDS's leaders is the destruction of the State of Israel. That's more than a boycott.
      Given that the Arab Palestinian population has been growing year-on-year since 1948, it's hardly a genocide. Besides, if Jordan hadn't pumped tens of thousands of Arab Palestinians into the area during the '48-'67 occupation, and then locked the border after '67, there wouldn't be so many refugees there now.
      Come off it. Palestine, as a region, was renamed by the Romans to try to delegitimize Jewish claim to the region. Two thousand years later, you're helping the Romans' agenda.

  • @Mallory-Malkovich
    @Mallory-Malkovich 5 лет назад +101

    How can an anit-BDS bill be passed anywhere in America? Doesn't that violate the 1st Amendment? At the very least telling people they can't not buy something is the most un-American thing I've ever heard.

    • @jadedoptimist6364
      @jadedoptimist6364 5 лет назад +8

      Wait until you see S852 the anti-Semitism Awareness Act which, I'm sure will be passed within a few days. Call senator Lamar Alexander at 202-224-3121 and tell him it's unconstitutional.

    • @MsKewi-NYC
      @MsKewi-NYC 5 лет назад +4

      It in American also to tell a person if they don't sign a waiver saying that they won't protest Israel is in AMERICAN as well.

    • @LancesArmorStriking
      @LancesArmorStriking 5 лет назад +13

      It does. But these are Republicans we're talking about. They'll cherry pick anything and everything until they get their white, Evangelical ethnostate.

    • @curiousworld7912
      @curiousworld7912 5 лет назад +8

      During South Africa's Apartheid, the US did respond with economic sanctions and disinvestment: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disinvestment_from_South_Africa

    • @brennanando
      @brennanando 5 лет назад +1

      Because BDS is racist.

  • @originalandrewmark
    @originalandrewmark 5 лет назад +13

    You and your writing team have made one of the best video(counter)meme(?). EXCELLENT PRESENTATION too!
    Keep expanding on this topic because CLARITY is tantamount.

  • @avocadonana180
    @avocadonana180 8 месяцев назад +3

    Matt's new podcast Bad Hasbara is lit 🔥

  • @scarletletter4900
    @scarletletter4900 5 лет назад +95

    Wow, fascism is truly insidious. There are people both at home and abroad who are doing everything in their power to ensure that fascism is never called by using literal fascism.

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +8

      Hi Scarlet, Yeah, fascism is insidious, and counter-intuitively, it is because of Science. We used to think that Science would bring progress, but all throughout the 20th Century any political organization that got any amount of money at all funded Phd's in Sociology and Psychology in order to determine how the 'masses' could be politically manipulated. Well, the Capitalists also developed 'advertising'. Those Orwell Books now read as just silly. Now the Brainwashing and Manipulation is so effective that we don't even see it. One Psychological Factor they found really scares me. Cognitive Dissonance. They can use that to condition people to enjoy their own exploitation and abuse. You know, a few hundred years ago, with the Scottish and the French Age of Enlightenments, well, there was so much optimism concerning Humanity, and Human Beings were looked upon as Ideals. Spiritual Idealism was merging with Materialism. But now? Human Beings are just sad ridiculous puppets.

    • @mattrussillo4587
      @mattrussillo4587 5 лет назад +13

      And who are those people? Fascism is a right-wing concept. It involves corporations and financially well-off taking control of government. Once again - a right-wing concept.

    • @scarletletter4900
      @scarletletter4900 5 лет назад +1

      @@mattrussillo4587 which one are you responding to, me or the run on sentence that preceded you?

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +4

      @@scarletletter4900 Jeezus Scarlet, thanks for the support! "Run on sentensed!?" What!? No attention span? Have you looked at English Literature. It wasn't until the Fascists wanted to dumb down society that YOUR style of Little Baby Sentences came into vogue. Short Thinking keep people stupid, you moron! Phuck You!

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 5 лет назад +5

      @@mattrussillo4587 Hi Matt. "Who are those people" "who at both home and abroad are doing everything in their power to ensure that fascism is never called by using literal fascism"? Well, It is the Left that calls the Fascists "fascists". I believe it was only in Italy and perhaps in Spain that the Fascists thought that "Fascism" was a shining good thing. Even the Nazis didn't want to totally embrace the Italians (you know, Teutonic Pride). SO, I would suppose that the people who wish to avoid being called Fascists, and who come up with patriotic euphemisms, are what we would term 'Fascists, that is, the Fascists themselves. They would be thinking of themselves as Freedom Loving Patriots.

  • @hadijahn
    @hadijahn 7 месяцев назад +1

    4 years and yet it fits like it's one minute old. And others think the whole thing started on Oct 7th

  • @slampersand3145
    @slampersand3145 9 месяцев назад +3

    This aged well. 🥴🍉🕊️

  • @Kuppasy
    @Kuppasy 8 месяцев назад +1

    Hating Palestinians is anti-Semitic.

  • @aujax1
    @aujax1 3 года назад +50

    let me just say this video and you are amazing and refreshing in your honesty and your humor. i respect all people including jewish people, but when supporters of israel immediately call u racist for even daring to question a policy, thats when you know youve struck a nerve and they dont really have a logical defense.

    • @ussliberty4631
      @ussliberty4631 2 года назад +1

      Remember the *USS LIBERTY* an intentional attack killing over 30+ American sailors

    • @TheHoodVoice2024
      @TheHoodVoice2024 2 года назад

      I can tell who he took this content from
      But your say I'm against jews

    • @ralphvon283
      @ralphvon283 Год назад

      I know that a lot of anti Semites are products of first cousin marriages.

  • @MYInteriorArchitect
    @MYInteriorArchitect Год назад +1

    رَبِّ هَبْ لِي حُكْمًا وَأَلْحِقْنِي بِالصَّالِحِينَ ، وَاجْعَل لِّي لِسَانَ صِدْقٍ فِي الْآخِرِينَ ، وَاجْعَلْنِي مِن وَرَثَةِ جَنَّةِ النَّعِيمِ

  • @SAMI-gc1hx
    @SAMI-gc1hx 5 лет назад +30

    Coming across Jews this 'WOKE' is always refreshing.

  • @lavihayoun05
    @lavihayoun05 6 месяцев назад +2

    Questioning and criticizing our actions isn't antisemitic, but denying Israel's right to exist and defend itself is.

    • @JBrix86
      @JBrix86 5 месяцев назад

      Nope

    • @lavihayoun05
      @lavihayoun05 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@JBrix86 ok antisemite

  • @calundoconteal6851
    @calundoconteal6851 Год назад +2

    There is no apartheid in Israel.
    There is oppression in Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, you name it.
    But any time Israel protects itself, you deem the outcome as the cause of chaos.

  • @rosythatswhattheycallme...9361
    @rosythatswhattheycallme...9361 5 лет назад +51

    Man you sound like Bernie Sanders you should totally do Bernie Sanders impressions.

    • @gtPacheko
      @gtPacheko 3 года назад +1

      I am once again asking for that too

  • @yakigesher-zion7289
    @yakigesher-zion7289 5 лет назад +2

    Criticizing Israel is not antisemitic. But demonizing israel is.

  • @johncreator346
    @johncreator346 5 лет назад +3

    Why criticism of Islam is not IslamicPhobia

    • @SuperGreatSphinx
      @SuperGreatSphinx 5 лет назад +1

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Islam

    • @coderamen666
      @coderamen666 7 месяцев назад

      Criticizing islamism isn't criticising Islam. They are different. Islam is a religion. You can't really criticize a religion.

  • @cosimodirondo972
    @cosimodirondo972 2 года назад

    "When people criticize Zionists, they mean Jews. You're talking antisemitism."
    - Martin Luther King Jr., 1968

  • @3aZM
    @3aZM 5 лет назад +10

    13:50 🤣 scares the bemoses.
    An atheist from a Muslim background salutes you Matt Lieb ✌
    My heart goes out to the Jewish people for millenia of triumph, struggle and agony, I hope we could build a better tomorrow away from the current situation.

  • @bylayla00
    @bylayla00 7 месяцев назад +1

    Antisemitism is in the same position as abortion rights and hijab. Abortion rights and hijab are decided by men and what is antisemitic is decided by original antisemitics. Weird paradox 😮

  • @payoade1
    @payoade1 4 года назад +11

    Semites are descendants of Shem. If you look up who they are you’ll find that speakers of the Hebrew and Arabic languages are descendants of Shem. Therefore, if, according to the definition of the Semitic, people who speak Hebrew and Arabic are semitic, wouldn’t that mean that Israel’s mistreatment of the people who call themselves Palestinian is also anti-Semitic?

    • @chinastartedcovid
      @chinastartedcovid 3 года назад

      no because like when u say homophobic it means afear of gays but its normally meant for anti gays its really how u look at it but

    • @ralphvon283
      @ralphvon283 Год назад

      you have your definitions wrong, which you know of. course. Stop using incorrect definitions to try and win a rhetorical argument. You don't make yourself look clever, you make yourself look like someone who has never read any book, except "The Wisdom and Wit of Ayatollah Khameini" and "Mein Kampf."

  • @LeonDonnelly23
    @LeonDonnelly23 4 года назад +1

    In Israel today rabbis have praised Adolf Hitler. Saying that he was ‘ideologically correct.” Moshe Feiglin also praises Hitler as a military genius. Is it also to be considered anti-Semitic to condemn Jews, Israeli or otherwise, who praise Adolf Hitler? Are Israeli Jews who praise Hitler beyond reproach? Are the contacts the far right in Israel has with other far right nationalist groups worldwide also beyond debate? As Israel moves “ideologically” closer to Adolf Hitler can we not condemn that? Can anyone speak against evil? Can a Jew? Or must we all be silent in the face of evil... forever.

  • @Valincio
    @Valincio 5 лет назад +5

    I find it hilarious that a country that doesn't like Israel is paying for someone to tell you hating Israel isn't Antisemitic.

  • @Emanuela9
    @Emanuela9 4 года назад +1

    Discrimination against Jews is antisemitic.

  • @1MarkKeller
    @1MarkKeller 5 лет назад +40

    Ahhh, the whole gang came back! Glad to see ya Matt!

  • @simon-jt9fr
    @simon-jt9fr 5 лет назад +1

    The speaker glosses over the MAIN falsehood: There is NO SUCH THING as a "Palestinian". The arab representatives to the UN talks on partition INSISTED they are NOT Palestinian, but Syrians, Egyptians, etc. Only in the late 1960's AD did they vote to call themselves Palestinians as a political construct against the Jews. (BTW: If arabs are "Palestinians" so are Jews and Christians!). (See Zahier Muhsein). When Hamas needed help in a war against Israel we see a Hamas member beg Syrians, Egyptians, Lebanese, etc to help them. NOTE: "Palestinian was NOT mentioned".

  • @tonyindindoli
    @tonyindindoli 5 лет назад +12

    Italian Americans for Peace supports the Olive Garden Boycott.

    • @mattrussillo4587
      @mattrussillo4587 5 лет назад +2

      Besides the fact that their food sucks why would that be?

    • @tonyindindoli
      @tonyindindoli 5 лет назад +1

      @@mattrussillo4587
      First of all, nevermind there is no why.
      Second of all, my comment is about fictional entities and events.

    • @mattrussillo4587
      @mattrussillo4587 5 лет назад +1

      @@tonyindindoli
      Their food still sucks!

    • @tonyindindoli
      @tonyindindoli 5 лет назад

      @@mattrussillo4587 I'm not a Millenial, so I can't help kill Olive Garden, but I won't stand in the way either

  • @rinash1706
    @rinash1706 4 месяца назад +2

    Aged well.

    • @Colluphid
      @Colluphid 25 дней назад

      Except maybe the line "Thankfully more and more people are starting to understand..."

  • @leovolont
    @leovolont 5 лет назад +44

    Horray! Matt Lieb is back! (But, sorry Matt, you didn't get that HBO Show).

    • @johnb4306
      @johnb4306 5 лет назад +4

      That's ok he now works for the Qatari government

    •  4 года назад +4

      Jeremy H. Awww... cry us a river, bigot. “Bad Jew”...😆 What a jackass.

    • @johngodsey5327
      @johngodsey5327 3 года назад +1

      This guy blows more than Kamala Harris and Monica Lewinsky combined

    • @leovolont
      @leovolont 3 года назад

      @@johngodsey5327 Hi John, that would be funny if Kamala Harris had ever made the news for blowing anybody. But as it is coming from you gratuitously, well, it's kind of crude and moronic, huh?

    • @johngodsey5327
      @johngodsey5327 3 года назад +1

      @@leovolont no not really. It’s a well known fact she got into her position as judge by blowing a married man, destroying his marriage and eventually getting into politics.
      You should look it up. It’s common knowledge.

  • @malpertuis.
    @malpertuis. 5 лет назад +2

    HOORAY! Matt's back!!

  • @mrclueuin
    @mrclueuin 5 лет назад +25

    Welcome Back Matt!
    BTW-Free Palestine! ✌

    • @SowerValler
      @SowerValler 3 года назад

      Palistinians should migrate to a different region on the Arabian peninsula
      BTW- SHELOM YISRAEL 🖕

    • @ardi08
      @ardi08 3 года назад +7

      @@SowerValler No you israelis should, Palestinians are natives.

    • @xseal6.
      @xseal6. 2 года назад

      @@ardi08 god gave the land of Canaan to his people, the Jews

  • @LailaAhmed-re5co
    @LailaAhmed-re5co 8 месяцев назад +1

    I can’t believe this was 4 years ago

  • @juliaset751
    @juliaset751 5 лет назад +28

    That Stephen Miller clip was pretty frightening. He says the word Jew with such contempt.

  • @kieranhimself3655
    @kieranhimself3655 4 года назад +2

    Why do so many people seem against Jews. I live in Australia and have never even met a Jew.

  • @StephenBoothUK
    @StephenBoothUK 5 лет назад +4

    A key problem I've seen a lot, and increasingly in the last 20 years, is people who are actually very antisemitic (on the right and faux-left) saying "I'm not antisemitic, I'm antizionis/anti-Israel/pro-Palestinian." The principle use of terms like antizionist has now become the defence of antisemitism by the right and faux-left.
    BTW Israel spend $22m on lobbying Congress? How does that compare to the NRA, oil lobby &c?

    • @StephenBoothUK
      @StephenBoothUK 5 лет назад +2

      @Scott Martin Yes I did. I think you're demonstrating the bad faith reading that Matt was talking about. I was talking about the co-opting of a term by the right and faux left (i.e. actually right-wing but pretend to be left without actually subscribing to any left-wing principles).
      Criticising Israeli politics is not anti-semitic, using criticism of Israeli politics as an opener to criticise Jews (usually with a paradigm along the lines of Israel did something bad, Israel is a Jewish state, therefore Jews support Israel, therefore, Jews did a bad thing), or misreporting on Israel .because of it's large Jewish population, is.

    • @coderamen666
      @coderamen666 7 месяцев назад

      It's a big problem. However, as a (post/anti)-zionist not all anti Zionism and Israel criticism is from a place of antisemitism. Case in point: socialist advocates of a one state solution

  • @marveen6372
    @marveen6372 2 года назад +2

    Left is still on the right side

  • @SoCalex92
    @SoCalex92 2 года назад +6

    “Look at who you can’t criticize and you’ll see who’s in charge”

  • @MeadeSkeltonMusic
    @MeadeSkeltonMusic 3 года назад +1

    Read your BIBLE: "Those that support Israel will be blessed. Those that curse it will be cursed". This Christian stands with Israel.

    • @johngodsey5327
      @johngodsey5327 3 года назад

      @@koffiecake thats true, its called being a "carnal christian"

  • @ernestovicil7826
    @ernestovicil7826 5 лет назад +3

    Oh, look! It’s SPEAK ENGLISH SO WE CAN BE FRENDS!!!!!!
    I love this guy. He’s like a penised FraniFio!

  • @garonx5251
    @garonx5251 2 года назад +1

    Judaism is a religion, israel is a nation. Its not a race, its not a religion, its not a god. Saying that someone is anti semitic because they criticize israel is like saying someone is a nazi because they like german culture.

  • @amirreza11zammin54
    @amirreza11zammin54 5 лет назад +3

    peace between palestine and israel when benny gantz wins and when benjamin netanyahu loses and when benjamin netanyahu dies

    • @thealligator918
      @thealligator918 5 лет назад

      Benny Gantz is right-wing. He hates Palestinians as much as Netanyahu does.

    • @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io
      @ObediahPolkinghornIII-cz5io 4 года назад

      When you say "Palestine", do you mean Jewish Palestine (West of the River Jordan) or Arab Palestine (East of the River Jordan)? The last time I checked, Jewish Palestine wasn't at war with itself.

  • @Mephilis78
    @Mephilis78 2 года назад +1

    I can't even criticize Israel in the comments without RUclips removing it. So consider that. They obviously aren't removing your videos. So maybe you can stand up for the gentiles who are censored while you're at it.

  • @EclecticoIconoclasta
    @EclecticoIconoclasta 5 лет назад +8

    Yellow shirt? Does that mean this is an 8 to 10/10 album

  • @Montagetastic
    @Montagetastic 4 года назад +1

    If people shooting rockets at you aren't your enemy, who is?

  • @mentonerodominicano
    @mentonerodominicano 5 лет назад +6

    "Or the BeMoses..." 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @liz921
    @liz921 4 года назад +1

    If you criticized the present American administration it would not make you anti American or anti white. If you criticize Israel there will always be some Israelis or Jews who will agree with you.

  • @mrdeadpool8656
    @mrdeadpool8656 3 года назад +6

    Long live Palestina!

    • @yousef1354
      @yousef1354 3 года назад

      @Elliot Masonif even your evidence is true. what that makes? i can even name myself Adolf Hitler what is the problem is called freedom of choice

    • @yousef1354
      @yousef1354 3 года назад

      @Elliot Mason i have the right to name myself the hell what I want

    • @moisuomi
      @moisuomi 3 года назад

      @@yousef1354 You people lose every argument with ease 😂

    • @yousef1354
      @yousef1354 3 года назад

      @@moisuomi OK

    • @kova1577
      @kova1577 2 года назад

      @Elliot Mason Judaism is a cult that magically has land in Palestine

  • @C.u.d.s
    @C.u.d.s 9 месяцев назад

    “I’m Ben Shapiro, the Jew police” 😂

  • @bigboi3038
    @bigboi3038 5 лет назад +4

    This guy sounds much smarter on AJ+ than on GMM

    • @AvgJane19
      @AvgJane19 5 лет назад

      Well they have different vibes going on, so it makes sense

  • @jonmramos
    @jonmramos 5 лет назад +1

    Here for the special people that are going to make the doozie of a false equivalency “So criticizing Islam doesn’t make you Islamophobic then”
    Islam is not a country, folks.

  • @tyro244
    @tyro244 5 лет назад +11

    Hey, everybody, Matt Lieb is back!
    YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!

  • @xeftones
    @xeftones 5 лет назад

    Why Criticism Of Islam Isn't Islamaphobia

  • @naturalnikkismile1709
    @naturalnikkismile1709 5 лет назад +21

    This was the best short video explaining Palestine / BDS Movement / Criticism of Israel / The Squad / and Trump Netanyahu love affair. I definitely will be sharing this as much as I can. I'm tired of trying to explain this to Zionist or Evangelicals. How can people live right next door to suffering and be okay with it?

    • @tanyag5646
      @tanyag5646 5 лет назад

      NaturalNikkiSmile loool you must not have watched a lot of videos / read a lot about it if you think that explains it well 😂😂

    • @Shaaronush
      @Shaaronush 2 года назад

      That suffering is self-inflicted. Your comment shows your lack of understanding.

    • @loohyd8128
      @loohyd8128 2 года назад

      @@Shaaronush just admit you a coloniser no body here judge you

    • @ralphvon283
      @ralphvon283 Год назад

      I am happy that so many Iranians have acquired English language skills that allow them to post this drivel and to make thumbs up posts for their fellow drivel writers in basements all over Tehran, Qom, and isfahan. You guys can actually make some money now to as you get paid a few rials per post, what is that, 50 cents in US money? So the more posts you make. the more you get paid. I guess Iran is a country that ruthlessly exploits its laborers after all.

  • @undead9999
    @undead9999 7 месяцев назад +1

    I did a double take when I realized this video is indeed 4 year old.
    It looks like it could have come out yesterday
    Bold of Shapiro to assume that being "pro Israel" is being "adherent to Judaism", when scores of ACTUAL Rabbis say the exact opposite
    PS that Trump impression was... wow ahaha

  • @southarabia0
    @southarabia0 5 лет назад +18

    Eroupean jews claims that they were in the Middle east 🤣💔
    The one was and still in is the Arabs jews in Yemen, morraco and Iraq.

    • @sulimanhertani1206
      @sulimanhertani1206 5 лет назад

      @Tankiest tanky tank not true get your facts.

    • @sulimanhertani1206
      @sulimanhertani1206 5 лет назад +3

      And the one in Palestine who lives in the West Bank, people lived side by side with Muslims and Christians for hundreds of years, they sheard the land.

    • @southarabia0
      @southarabia0 5 лет назад

      @Tankiest tanky tank
      So did most Yemeni jews 💔

    • @southarabia0
      @southarabia0 5 лет назад

      @@sulimanhertani1206
      Yup that's true

    • @LONELY069
      @LONELY069 5 лет назад

      I heard that there used to be some in Oman as well

  • @TN-ju4ro
    @TN-ju4ro 3 года назад +1

    Its to no surprise whatsoever that ben Shapiro thinks anti-semitism and anti-zionism are the same thing

  • @differentlyrome9732
    @differentlyrome9732 3 года назад +5

    u summed it up soo soo well!!!!!!for me all decent good human beings will criticize any state which occupy another and let others suffer!!!it has nothing to do with what they r !!!we need to be able to say what we believe in and open our mouth like him because thats the right things to do!!!and only that count!!!God is watching from above rest is not important!!!!

    • @calundoconteal6851
      @calundoconteal6851 Год назад

      Yea, occupy lol. If its Israel it’s bad, but Arab countries had power over Palestinian territories but gave it up in 48, after waging war instead of compromising.
      How you can look at all the other Arab countries who constantly oppress people, gays, women etc and support them but antagonize Israel

  • @ek8196
    @ek8196 6 месяцев назад

    "I'm Ben Shapiro: Jew police" 😂😂😂😂

  • @fallonstone408
    @fallonstone408 3 года назад +3

    11:50 OMFG too funny!!!!

  • @Rxdino4429
    @Rxdino4429 4 года назад +2

    I seriously hope Palestinians get equal rights ♥️🇵🇸

    • @shaboki802
      @shaboki802 4 года назад +1

      What do you mean by that? the palestnians inside israel have the same rights as jews, the palestinians in the west bank dosent have the same rights as jews because the west bank is not a country, its not israel or palestine its just a territory so how do you difine equal rights?

    • @kova1577
      @kova1577 2 года назад

      @@shaboki802 Isreal is illegitimate

  • @josephmcnamee9622
    @josephmcnamee9622 3 года назад +5

    This was actually really funny 😂😂 one thing I actually agree with omar on is her critism of Israel . Other than that she's terrible and annoying

  • @halbspasst2993
    @halbspasst2993 3 года назад +2

    "To knows who rules you finde out who you can't criticises"

    • @minecraftrotisseriechicken
      @minecraftrotisseriechicken 3 года назад +1

      *criticize.
      I can't criticize *children with leukemia* , therefore they must rule over me.

  • @andrewfarrell6120
    @andrewfarrell6120 5 лет назад +22

    "BeMoses(!)" I love it! A tight 15. Nice!

  • @dwilcher11
    @dwilcher11 2 года назад

    Antisemitism and anti-American explained perfectly.

  • @Yamsandjams-w4t
    @Yamsandjams-w4t 4 года назад +4

    You can't judge a country when you live outside of it. All the people who claim that there is no connection between judging Israel and anti-Semitism are wrong. Because it stems from some hatred. Why would a person with no negative feelings towards the State of Israel decide to judge it negatively based on what he sees in the media? It is simply naive and unwise, and it is even more painful for me to see that Jews say they are against Israel because it simply shows how much they do not understand the significance of the state of Israel for the Jewish people. Anyone who does not live in Israel and has not suffered wars because of the Israeli-Arab conflict cannot fairly judge the State of Israel or the Arabs. This conflict is very complex and you cannot take that position so easily. When you are against Israel by claiming that it is harming to the Arabs, you are actually taking out the Israeli side as the bad side in this story, and this story is not black and white. I, as an Israeli Jew, feel that it is not fair on the part of people who live abroad to protest against the State of Israel while in fact having no idea what is going on here. The only reason a person will hate Israel and not hate Jews is a lack of education on the issue, and a lack of understanding of the importance of the state for us, because If one really understood how Israel is a miracle for the Jewish people, they would not hate the State of Israel, so yes, I do think that all those people who hate Israel are not particularly fond of Jews, or they hate Israel because they simply don't Know all its history, which allows them to say that they simultaneously love Jews but do not like the State of Israel.

    • @Pleuros
      @Pleuros 2 года назад

      I love and respect all people from all religions but when I see a "brave" israeli soldier has shot and murdered a child from my country in cold blood then I can't say I support Israel
      Also do you know the basics of your religion?
      Do not kill without reason
      Do not steal
      Your take is pathetic I hope you realise that, just because you want a country because Europe kicked you out after the 2nd World War doesn't justify the violation of human rights, I understand the misfortune of the holocaust and how it must be terrible for Jewish people but I want to point out that using the holocaust as an excuse to slaughter Palestinian people is corrupt, hypocritical, and blatantly a way to hide the war crimes committed by Israel.

    • @Pleuros
      @Pleuros 2 года назад

      Also funfact as an Arab i am littearly a semet get your facts checked before making such heroic claims

  • @gamermapper
    @gamermapper 3 года назад +1

    Ironic, coming from a state sponsored media that claims that criticism of Islam is islamophobia.

  • @saifag6685
    @saifag6685 3 года назад +15

    I once went to a palestine protest with a friend of mine and after that we went for a coffee someone called both of us anti-semetic and then my friend told him he is a jew

    • @adamseward4713
      @adamseward4713 3 года назад

      Simon de Beauvoir book: All Americans are anti-semitic, Jewish, or both

  • @Sinaeb
    @Sinaeb 5 лет назад +5

    Hi Not Franceska !

  • @Percyflag
    @Percyflag Год назад +1

    Wow. The most powerful and well-thought-out criticisms I have ever heard. I have many Jewish friends, I would hope someday to count you among them.

  • @nfahel
    @nfahel 4 года назад +10

    I hope you reach a billion views you’re a brave soul

  • @MatthewDLDavidson
    @MatthewDLDavidson 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for having that conversation!

  • @akilliyanage9133
    @akilliyanage9133 5 лет назад +3

    someone needs to show AOC this as well as rashidia talib and illhan ormar so their can shove it in trumps face

  • @Anon-xd3cf
    @Anon-xd3cf 8 месяцев назад +1

    How old is Steven Miller?
    I know we joke that he looks like a vampire...
    But he must be, musnt he be?
    He said his Jewish BROTHERS AND SISTERS were killed in the holocaust...
    How old is this guy?

  • @MrBaskins2010
    @MrBaskins2010 5 лет назад +25

    Thank you speaking on this topic. It’s not my place to say but this is a point that is so difficult to articulate

  • @thelazygamer3788
    @thelazygamer3788 2 года назад

    Wow you really drank the coolaid lmao

  • @TheNN
    @TheNN 5 лет назад +4

    "Planet Earth narrated by a Flat Earther"
    ...I'd watch it. That'd be the greatest comedy of our decade if that was a thing.

  • @ogueyratogeyrat7448
    @ogueyratogeyrat7448 Год назад +2

    being good is antisemitic bro

  • @davidj.3897
    @davidj.3897 3 года назад +3

    Just as well as criticism of Palestine is not Islamophobia, you might wanna also realize that....

    • @johngodsey5327
      @johngodsey5327 3 года назад +1

      thats right. If Palestine would just stop firing rockets into Israel for no other reason than it wants to destroy them, there would be peace

    • @yousef1354
      @yousef1354 3 года назад

      @@johngodsey5327 like literally Israel is firing rocket and airstrike and you want them to stay calm and don't do anything.
      You are genius my friend