It looks like someone at Mardingtop is paying attention to the channel, the Amazon list has changed and the pack is now said to be 25L and not 28L. Their web site hasn't been updated yet and still claims 28L which I believe is too generous. Interesting. - Luke
They were probably including outside storage with main compartment space. Mystery Ranch and Frost River clearly state that their liter rating is based on the main compartment and doesn't include and exterior pouches/ compartments.
You should make a series of “the best gear.” Make a top 5 list for tents(affordable, best overall, best 4 season, etc) and for backpacks (same kind of categories) sleeping pads, sleeping bags, etc. seems like you find a lot of bad gear, so I’m curious about what good gear you’ve found without me having to watch every single video and make a list to figure it out. Obviously it’s an opinion but your opinion holds some weight IMO because of your experience with so many different pieces of gear in the backcountry
I agree. Anytime I read Amazon reviews and someone has a qualm with the product I am always hoping they give an alternative that they found worked well.
Lonewolf 902 has used them and has nothing but glowing reviews for them after years of real world use. I have one. Honestly, it's about 3/4's of what my Eberlestock & Mystery Ranch packs' quality is for 1/4 the price. Their customer service is outstanding too. The first one I received arrived in a damaged box (most likely by the shippers) and the buckle was broken. I contacted them and they had one at my door stop literally on the next morning before I even dropped off mine to send it back as the shippers. That immediately made me feel comfortable with them.
I've had this exact bag for just over 2 years now. I use it heavily as a day bag for hiking. I've had zero issue with it and would gladly pay more that $50+ for another one.
@jonacheson it's a pack that's supposed to be compared to $75 packs, not to $400 packs. Even when it is, it still punches way above it's weight. My 55L Mardingtop has more features than my top brand packs and carries 50lbs well.
@swartzautoman2 Exactly. People who actually use their packs for what they were intended for more than a few miles, these packs outperform packs costing twice as much. I've never heard one complaint about them failing badly at all.
@@YankeeWoodcraft I have a 40L Mardingtop, and I agree, for the cost it is decent. However, I've also had experience with packs failing on day 3 of a five day hike, and how much that SUCKS. My rule of thumb: add $50 to the cost of your pack for every day after day 2 that you plan to be on the trail.
I have the Mardingtop 75L. I love it. It's amazingly well designed and well made. The dual opening (top and duffel style) is a huge help. I mostly use it as my emergency backpack in my car but I'm impressed with the quality and would use one on a long hike with no reservations.
same, i switched to it from a fox 5200 from Teton Sports because i got tired of all the straps LOL. It's got the same support system that Teton and others uses and both work ok once adjusted. Love the luggage style opening in the back for quick access to gear and the YKK zippers surprised me at how butter smooth they were considering its a chinese product. i've loaded it up to 38 lbs so far and use it often when training (box climbs to simulate hill climbing) and not its ok. Had some strap slippage but have had that with other packs as well in the past. Using two smallish carabiners on the front straps fixes that slippage.
I use this pack for our baby. It's excellent. My oldest son has been using a Mardingtop backpack for school since 3rd grade and he's now in high school, still using the same pack and it has 0 tears or holes. He abuses the hell out of that bag too. I love Mardingtop bags. We have a total of around 10 of their bags, some of which are kitted as get home bags in our vehicles that never get touched and some as quick grab and go bags for any kind of emergency. One of my bags I've been using now for 4 years for hiking, fishing, hunting and camping. It has no issues with it after years of abuse.
This is the kind of reviews and equipment that I think can expand your audience these are the kinds of things that none hard core backpackers are looking for honest info on in a budget minded folks exp for folks starting out and trying to get something to go out and start with that won’t coat an arm and leg but won’t fall apart on the first trip out that they can upgrade later..good job and thank you for the honesty
Like a few here, I have the Mardingtop 65/70L pack with rain cover. I've had it for about 4 years and use it to ruck out about 3 miles to a campsite, and carry about 45lbs in it (pretty flat hiking in northern IN...lol). It is very comfortable, adjustable back, padded waist belt with pockets. It's great for what I need, and I think your review was spot on for that little bag which I'd pass on since I already have four real 72 hour bags from the military that I was issued. :)
Bought it to use as a hiking backpack when I started taking out a stove for cooking hot food and drink now the little one can go on longer hikes. I do like it but needed some molle side attachments for water bottles due to the useless elasticated ones. I'm a fan of the many zipped pockets. I now have a larger and sturdier pack for cooler days to stash the extra layers of clothing.
I just bought the 75l bag and I love it! Not "tactical" quality, but not crap either. Adjustable suspension. Back air channels. Rain cover. Not bad at all for under $100
Love your reviews and have been seriously looking at this pack for day trips over my 511 18L tactical pack (bought when still working). I do own their mardingtop 65L and planned on using for day pack also but a bit over kill and much bigger than needed. I have only used the 65 a few times so far and due to disabilities i cant walk far even with my canes or trekking poles maybe 1- 3 miles at a go, often i have to use my scooter. It holds plenty for over nights or multi day trips and it lives in my truck bed so gets abused and tossed around and still holding up after a yr but only used during summer. My other option is the pathfinder scout pack but over $100 more which is hard to justify when on a fixed income. Keep up the good work and glad you chose this pack to test as it made me decide to keep looking for something else for my day pack
So have I !...I own the 65 + 10 Litre backpack and at it's price point it is awesome ! comfortable, durable. Is this a Savotta...no but for your average hiker, camper they are well made
@@highlandtrekker the outside is made of some pretty good polyester material.. which is the shell that protects what’s inside. So with the price I think I made a decent choice.
I like the look and the style. I frequently keep a small backpack either attached to my main pack, or stuffed inside so I can drop the main pack, and then go out for a few hours and have some bonus gear with me. I do a lot of long range shooting competitions, and you might be walking all over the area getting to the various events. Usually a tripid, water, food, ammo, etc. I figured this might be nice, but I tend to think the price is wrong.
Luke, your videos are some of the finest filmed, planned and edited on YT. Top shelf! I am considering this pack for a daily catch all bag, I think it would be perfect for that after watching this review. Many thanks!
I've got the 60l pack. No complaints so far. Then again, it's not heavily used. I bought directly from their website and received it in a timely manner.
I have a large pack from them for longer trips. Holds sleeping bag, food, basically everything you'd need for camping. It weighed at 41 lbs. I really like mine. I've had it out on trail many times and it's solid. Yes they are budget and dry empty is 7 lbs.
Hey Luke, love the channel and content!!! Don't know anything about the pack you are reviewing, but I have a Mardingtop 65L+10 pack and I absolutely love it. Good construction with what appears to be quality materials. Carries a lot of weight, usually around 40-45 pounds and rides very comfortable. The one about my pack is not a lot of outside pockets,but I knew that before I purchased it. It does however have numerous molle straps to attach pouches. Just my two cents 🙂 Keep up the good work and my best to your family.
I have this bag in green. As of January I've been using the bag for 2 years. It's a sturdy bag and I've had zero issues with failure of any part of the bag. I agree the back doesn't have venting. The bag is a great day bag or I call it a scout bag.
Your review caught my eye because the pack is about the same size as one I picked up a while back -- though the designs couldn't be much different! This one does seem pretty good looking compared to the Six Moons Trail 30 (old style) I paid a closeout price of about 3x the cost of the Mardingtop for. But it looks like the proof of the pack is actually in the packing -- both the stuffing of gear into it, and schlepping it down the trail. I always wondered how practical a clamshell main compartment would be in an actual backpacker's bag -- and you confirmed that suspicion. The 30 has a single rolltop closure with huge open bottle/gear side pockets, tons of shock cord and compression straps, and no hip belt. Instead of typical shoulder straps, it comes with a vest-style harness of reinforced open mesh, and that yoke runs down the middle of the pack between your shoulder blades in a padded and ventilated 4.5 inch strip. So, you can pack some bulky items, but I like to keep the total weight down to 15-20 lbs or so. Because it rides so high and light, there's actually lots of room underneath for a belt/fanny pack for small heavier items. But dang if that Mardingwhatsit don't look better!
I have the 60L Mardingtop for my stealthcamping adventures. I have it for over a year and really satisfied with it. Stealthcamping adventures are mostly rough and I have no damage at all.
I just ordered this pack. It appears to the most suitable replacement for my aging Ascend (Bass Pro) H1250, which is no longer made. I wish the materials were better, but this seems to be the only pack with all the pockets and attachment points I need. I will use it only as a day pack while riding my mountain bike in the California mountains and desert. I will report on how I like it.
Interestingly, it looks like a backpack I once owned not exactly the same though as it had 2 external pockets, not 3 and folded up inside itself like a waist pack when empty. I thought it might still have some capacity to serve as a small waist pack in that mode, but no. I think I bought it from Kitbag Australia. It had a water proof lining which soon delaminated & fell apart. The fabric also pulled out of the seams too. Anyway, I used it for a fly fishing day back for 2-3 seasons. before pulling it apart for the zips & webbing etc. The zippers were very good, in fact I used one of them to makes a head slit in a Woobie blanket so I could use that for a poncho. I also tie the sides of the poncho together so that it becomes like a narrow (2 layer) strip that I can wear as a tabard, using a belt to keep the sides overlapping. It's a lot warmer that way. This adds versatility to an overnight kit, as I can use the one item in multiple roles, a top quilt, bed roll blanket, poncho or double layer tabard around the camp or hiking in very cold windy conditions. The tabard serves very well, when both mobility warmth are needed, I can even carry a backpack while wearing it. Being synthetic, it's not as light weight, warm or compact as say a down quilt but it is more versatile, serving in place of a long, almost knee length puffy coat. Maybe I should do a video on that some time.
Luke, thank you for the review. Nice to see a balance of positive and constructive comments. I’m with you… I purchased this due to how it looks. I’m in the process of collecting other items for day hiking to put in this pack. I really like all the pockets for organizing everything. I look forward to your updates and I’ll include mine when I hit the trails. Jimmy - San Antonio, Tx
I must say I do like this company. I have the 75l and have used and abused it for about a year and a half. I haven't had any issues with the pack and it is comfortable. You are correct about the name tho. They should change it.
Man, I LOVE my Mardingtop packs. They sent me their 60 ltr and their 3 day assault pack and they have held up to some serious abuse. I didn't think they would hold up to much, but they were comfy and have been very durable. Not sure I'd go into combat with it, but their definitely in my top 6 bags that I choose from. I should say, my 3 day assault pack looks a lot bigger than that one.
After using this while riding my mountain bike for 9 months, I love this pack. I do wish it was of better materials and would pay more for better materials, but I can cope with what it is. I wish the side pockets were a bit bigger to hold water bottles.
I have the 70L for about 2 years now and it works fine. Only light duty though since I've yet to take it anywhere but car camping, so I've not needed to trek distances with it.
I have one of these but black I wouldn't use it much for camping or outdoors as my other backpacks but it does make a good tec bag to store electrical items , tablet phone ect....I find it one of the best EDC bags
I picked up the 511 rush 12 v2 not long back, thats as tactical looking as I'd like to get tbh in a day to day scenario. I like the look of the Helikon packs, Groundhog, EDC, Bergen, Bushcraft Haversack and Satchel. etc.
You brought up a valid point regarding doing some research outside of Amazon's reviews. There are airsoft companies that produce grips, stocks, and handguard rails under license of real manufacturers, and the airsoft look-alikes are a fraction of the price and not as durable. Several years ago I found Magpul's products for way less on Amazon, then when reading up on the stuff I learned it was either licensed copies of gear or look-alike parts for non-firing training replicas.
This looks like a great value pack for a GET HOME BAG/48 hr, EMERGENCY BAG type kit. I do like all the pockets and organization it seems to offer. I think this would be a good option as a pack you fill with your gear and leave in your car/truck. Great video and content as usual, thanks!
I've got both a 40l and 28l pack from them. The 28 I use for work, I put books, pens etc in it. The 40l I've used on field exercices with the military, and a 2 day hike. After 5 years it held up fine. At 60 bucks I cant complain
Ive had a 65l mardingtop pack for 3 years. Ive used the hell out of it for hiking and camping and other out in the field pro 2a festivities. It has yet to let me down. Ive dropped it down revines. Hung it by the handle. Stuffed it full. And no problems. My one and only gripe is that the waist strap is not padded
I have 28 L Backpack from them that I've had for years And I know I put 35-40 lbs in it of groceries on my back! Never had a problem At all! I now own 2 more their backpacks! Yes they are not military but they do hold up, I've had mine in the rain the heat And never had a problem! For the price point I love this company!
Well I'm a real person and reviewer and I've used Mardingtop packs for years and love them . My favorite being the 75 L which I use every season for the last 5 yrs and have had no problem with . And highly recommend the 75 L
Since I'm not military, this pack looks awesome! (cost on point wise) Now to determine which of their packs i actually want/need. Decisions. Hoping to find your conclusion video as well. Thanks!
I bought the Mardingtop 35L backpack for a cheap get home bug out bag. Mostly to test the concept. I found it held up surprisingly well to mild abuse and remained comfortable up to about 20-25 lbs capacity. I wouldn’t push it past that. Part of that comfort is in how it hugs the body and the down side is lack of ventilation as mentioned in the video. My other complaint is a lack of a proper water bottle pocket or attachment points where one goes so I can easily customize it. I can barely fit a Pathfinder 35oz stainless water bottle into the side pockets but zipping it up was a strain and a pain. Overall I can’t complain too much for the affordable price but I’ve since upgraded to a pack with a proper harness. If it’s all you can afford, it will work and you could certainly do far worse.
I have a similar one cheap Amazon but mine was abit bigger, great for a day trip around the old mine's here. Really the only way to get quality is spend the bucks...love your channel..be safe.
i use pretty much exclusively mystery ranch packs. im not sure why im watching this and finding it interesting :DD guess it just goes to show how interesting your reviews are
Omg Luke, just this week I considered buying this until i saw this post. I'll hold of my purchase until later review 😉. For what i'm gonna use it for, it will probably hold. Keep up the great effort in your fantastic channel.
Mardingtop sounds like a strange British dessert. haha. Looks like you could do a tarp camp with that, but only for a night. You might get away with some water pouches in the sides.
I have a Mardingtop backpack, I believe it’s a 60lt pack with two 5lt side packs. It’s my first backpack and although it’s ok and can hold a good amount it’s very uncomfortable. I do plan to upgrade to a alp’s backpack this year but until then I’ll keep the one I have around
Their products are actually really good been meaning to pull the trigger on the 65L but I've gone old school with the large Alice pack and haven't felt the need to buy a modern MOLLE bag. But I will be buying this one to use on my plate carrier
I was a 68 whiskey in the army, having said that this would make the perfect medical travel pack, I'd need a bigger one for camping stuff, I have a 70 liter that I'd use for that but thus one I'd use as a medical kit. I could save a lot of lives filling something like this with stuff I need. Oh and I would on missions carry a regular back pack and one simular to this. I like it.
Imo all manufacturers lie about sizing, most include the side/external in sizing, always make sure to find out the internal compartment size to see if its the actual sizing in liters or not. I made that mistake only once LOL. As you say learn what you need to find the correct sized bag for your use case.
Strength & honor right back at ya, Luke :) Name change suggestion: if the company made gear worthy of being used by the airborne, they should be called "Currahee" =)
I think it could be a bushcraft backpack, in that, if you practice bushcraft, you only need the bare minimum of equipment, and your food. I like that they have quality zips and buckles. A lot of people in the comment section have had good experiences with the bigger versions; maybe it's value for the money. Take care, be well
At first glance it seems like a good option if you want the "look" without spending a lot, wether or not it's worth buying I'm sure you will let us know
Thanks Luke for the heads up on this one. The interior material, I've seen in similar fanny packs, even gym bags that won't last a month..lol Have a Blessed Day. Big Jim New Hampshire USA aka BOSTON STRONG
At first I was going to ask if it is better or worse than a 6 mil contractor trash bag, but it looks like a decent bag for prepping my friends, family, and neighbors with automobile first aid kits. Lots of easy to view and access pouches, assuming the bag will stay in a trunk all it’s life.
As you stated in your post, this is a day use backpack which would make it ideal for a daylong hunting or fishing outing. Everything needed is consolidated in one small pack except for rifle or rod. As you've pointed out in a lot of your other posts, what the weather forecasts predict for the next six/eight hours can be far from what actually happens. Also stated, the majority of the pack was constructed with cheap/inexpensive materials, so as you continue to evaluate this pack, I wonder about the degree of its waterproofing. Nobody wants to find out that the sandwiches they packed for lunch have turned into sponges or spare ammo is sitting in a pocket water.
I ordered one last night. For me it will be used what it’s designed for. Couple GoPros, some batteries and a small dji drone. Maybe some snacks and water.
May be great for a get home bag to fill up and leave it in your car for an emergency. I had a Maxpedition bag and changed it for an old one because I couldn’t stand never using it, just seeing it in my trunk once in a while.
After watching the video, I decided to buy one to replace the pack I use when riding my mountain bike. I love my old pack (Ascend H1250) and it has served me well for many years, but it has some limitations. (The outside strap points were torn off in a crash and there is no good place to put a G_o_k 26.) I’ve looked at many day packs at Bass Pro, REI, etc., and can’t seem to find just the right one. This comes close. I do wish the new pack was of a better material. I would gladly pay more for that. It is bigger than I need for day trips on my bike, but better too big than too small. I’m mostly happy. I say “mostly” because it has so many options for organizing my gear that I can see myself spending many hours getting it just the way I want it. (Other packs don't give me that latitude.). I’m already considering getting 2 more, one for my ham radio "go bag," and one for my 2 day grab-for-overnight-travel bag. (If they are pre-packed, there is less room for error.) Once I use it a bit, I'll report further.
I have the 75L, and the 65L+10 backpacks and this "28L" bag as well, this one is not the most heavy duty of my smaller bags but I have really liked this pack. I added a condor water bottle carrier on the left side and a molly bag on the right as a sustainment pouch. I carry 2 small smart water bottles on the outside and a 2-liter water bladder on the inside. In the main compartment, I can (just barely) carry the snug pack jungle bag, a modified 7-9' tarp (I made it a 7x7) and grabber 5-7 space blanket, a change of pants, socks and shirt, hygiene kit, fire kit, water kit (swayer mini) and my paracord kit (100'), I also carry a bear IKAK 3.0 attached to the center but outside on the pack. The pack does make the back sweat but really what small pack doesn't? I keep this in my truck as a get home bag if I am traveling less than 100 miles from home, if I go further then I use one of several other bags for the extended time to return home. I have tested this pack on orienteering courses in a town about 90 miles from me. They have an orienteering group up there and I started out as the only one testing gear during the events,, now there are quite few folks doing this as well. They are actually races but I use them to keep the compass skills sharp or train other people how to use them. I can carry the 5 or 10 C's in this pack with no issues and still make good time traveling. Overall it is not a bad pack for I use it for. Thanks for the review and keep up the good work.
I use the mardingtop 65+10l backpack for my backpacking trips. Great bag got it for like $78 on Amazon. coyote brown and has molle webbing. Some issues with the bag but overall good.
"Real user" and not a Chinese bot here - I have a 75L Mardingtop and love it, works great carrying a ton of weight out to bushcraft campings and excursion of many miles. It's design and build quality are all spot on, especially considering the price. Who cares about the name, too, and don't other tactical backpack makers have whack names? I can't even spell half of them to write them here, ha.
I would love to have your review on a bug out bag, tactical and military style backpacks for reference, as I am in the market and love the depth of your reviews on the products.
Interesting to read the comments on the larger packs. I wonder if this one is the exception to their line of packs. I trust (most) of your commenters any day over the Amazon ones. :)
I have the 75 ltr mardingtop in olive. It has also a raincover. And in general it is a quite good backpack for around 100 euro here in europe. In Germany lot of guy use mardingtop.
I have the 65L (M6105) version. It’s honestly perfect for me for camping and backpacking. I was waiting for you to do a review on one of these and if you could do some of the other bags like the one I mention I would love it! The 65L one I bought has seen heavy abuse and it’s still going strong, plus it’s super comfortable.
Having not completed the video yet, I don't have an issue with the name, it just sounds like a name to me. From the few closeup photos you show, the bag appears to be made well so I am curious as to what you think in the end. As far as the bag and tent, I am sure they mean carrying these items externally so in your opinion will the bag still not meet that requirement? One question before I finish the video does it come with a balloon :) Oh, before I finish the video I wanted to thank you for taking the time to make them. Setting up a camera to film you walking away and keeping in mind that you have to come back to get the camera to continue the filming I am sure you are tired at the end of the day. Okay, so I completed the video and I have to say that I am not surprised. I guess for a day trip as you said, it would be okay but the thing that gets me with a "day trip" is that even though I admit I don't hike as often as I would like and when I do go out, I always prepare for an extra day at least. You never know what is going to happen and I want to just be prepared. Great video man, I appreciate it.
I have nothing but good things to say about my mardingtoppack .great quality,durable and great price point.. yeah if you want to go do military operations by a military bag.. you expect way too much for the price point. These packs are made and priced for beginners and for people that can't afford three to $400 packs..would highly recommend this pack and a different RUclips channel..
I bought a Golan 55ltr (actually 45 ish) and it's really good all round, testing on 2 woods trips happy as Larry for £30. 800D fabric and definitely feels it, stuff pack style and is very similar to the pathfinder scout.
I looked at these packs when I was searching. I went with the mountaintop 70L frame pack instead. It does a good job, could it be better yes but it's ok
My kids would love it just the look but if u used a tarp with walking sticks and a air pad, mini burner and a little pot from Stanley that has cups in it little chair might could carry something on the outside of pack that’s light weight. But I would buy it for my boys
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
It looks like someone at Mardingtop is paying attention to the channel, the Amazon list has changed and the pack is now said to be 25L and not 28L. Their web site hasn't been updated yet and still claims 28L which I believe is too generous. Interesting. - Luke
I remember this pack from a while ago I saw it on Amazon listed as a 40ltr 3 day pack 😂 thanks for the review
Maybe could be a fishing pack....lol great job Luke.
They were probably including outside storage with main compartment space.
Mystery Ranch and Frost River clearly state that their liter rating is based on the main compartment and doesn't include and exterior pouches/ compartments.
So it's the free bug out bag they try to give u if u order something threw Patriot....
You can send me this pack if it doesn't stand up to your standards.
I'd gladly use it
You should make a series of “the best gear.” Make a top 5 list for tents(affordable, best overall, best 4 season, etc) and for backpacks (same kind of categories) sleeping pads, sleeping bags, etc. seems like you find a lot of bad gear, so I’m curious about what good gear you’ve found without me having to watch every single video and make a list to figure it out. Obviously it’s an opinion but your opinion holds some weight IMO because of your experience with so many different pieces of gear in the backcountry
I would love to see a list as well
I agree. I want a good hot tent and would love an apples to apples lay out
Oh hell yea. Great idea bro. That would be such a good group of videos. He's got just about everything there is lol
I agree. Anytime I read Amazon reviews and someone has a qualm with the product I am always hoping they give an alternative that they found worked well.
That would be great because Luke is one of the very few reviewers that I trust!
Lonewolf 902 has used them and has nothing but glowing reviews for them after years of real world use. I have one. Honestly, it's about 3/4's of what my Eberlestock & Mystery Ranch packs' quality is for 1/4 the price. Their customer service is outstanding too. The first one I received arrived in a damaged box (most likely by the shippers) and the buckle was broken. I contacted them and they had one at my door stop literally on the next morning before I even dropped off mine to send it back as the shippers. That immediately made me feel comfortable with them.
Survival Lilly has given Mardingtop packs a positive review as well.
It's not a professional grade pack, but it is an upgrade from Walmart quality.
I've had this exact bag for just over 2 years now.
I use it heavily as a day bag for hiking.
I've had zero issue with it and would gladly pay more that $50+ for another one.
@jonacheson it's a pack that's supposed to be compared to $75 packs, not to $400 packs. Even when it is, it still punches way above it's weight.
My 55L Mardingtop has more features than my top brand packs and carries 50lbs well.
@swartzautoman2 Exactly. People who actually use their packs for what they were intended for more than a few miles, these packs outperform packs costing twice as much.
I've never heard one complaint about them failing badly at all.
@@YankeeWoodcraft I have a 40L Mardingtop, and I agree, for the cost it is decent. However, I've also had experience with packs failing on day 3 of a five day hike, and how much that SUCKS. My rule of thumb: add $50 to the cost of your pack for every day after day 2 that you plan to be on the trail.
I have the Mardingtop 75L. I love it. It's amazingly well designed and well made. The dual opening (top and duffel style) is a huge help. I mostly use it as my emergency backpack in my car but I'm impressed with the quality and would use one on a long hike with no reservations.
Did yours come with a rain cover?
@@masonrivera944 It does come with a rain cover. ☔ I looked it up on Amazon.
@@masonrivera944 mine did have the rain cover, but I just purchased last December
I've got the same one and I've taken it on a multi day 20 mile hike without any problems
same, i switched to it from a fox 5200 from Teton Sports because i got tired of all the straps LOL. It's got the same support system that Teton and others uses and both work ok once adjusted. Love the luggage style opening in the back for quick access to gear and the YKK zippers surprised me at how butter smooth they were considering its a chinese product.
i've loaded it up to 38 lbs so far and use it often when training (box climbs to simulate hill climbing) and not its ok. Had some strap slippage but have had that with other packs as well in the past. Using two smallish carabiners on the front straps fixes that slippage.
I use this pack for our baby. It's excellent. My oldest son has been using a Mardingtop backpack for school since 3rd grade and he's now in high school, still using the same pack and it has 0 tears or holes. He abuses the hell out of that bag too. I love Mardingtop bags. We have a total of around 10 of their bags, some of which are kitted as get home bags in our vehicles that never get touched and some as quick grab and go bags for any kind of emergency. One of my bags I've been using now for 4 years for hiking, fishing, hunting and camping. It has no issues with it after years of abuse.
This is the kind of reviews and equipment that I think can expand your audience these are the kinds of things that none hard core backpackers are looking for honest info on in a budget minded folks exp for folks starting out and trying to get something to go out and start with that won’t coat an arm and leg but won’t fall apart on the first trip out that they can upgrade later..good job and thank you for the honesty
Like a few here, I have the Mardingtop 65/70L pack with rain cover. I've had it for about 4 years and use it to ruck out about 3 miles to a campsite, and carry about 45lbs in it (pretty flat hiking in northern IN...lol). It is very comfortable, adjustable back, padded waist belt with pockets. It's great for what I need, and I think your review was spot on for that little bag which I'd pass on since I already have four real 72 hour bags from the military that I was issued. :)
Thank you, Luke. Your honesty and integrity are truly appreciated.
Bought it to use as a hiking backpack when I started taking out a stove for cooking hot food and drink now the little one can go on longer hikes. I do like it but needed some molle side attachments for water bottles due to the useless elasticated ones. I'm a fan of the many zipped pockets.
I now have a larger and sturdier pack for cooler days to stash the extra layers of clothing.
I just bought the 75l bag and I love it! Not "tactical" quality, but not crap either. Adjustable suspension. Back air channels. Rain cover. Not bad at all for under $100
I have the 60L pack with multiple accessories as my bug out bag. Love it
Love your reviews and have been seriously looking at this pack for day trips over my 511 18L tactical pack (bought when still working). I do own their mardingtop 65L and planned on using for day pack also but a bit over kill and much bigger than needed. I have only used the 65 a few times so far and due to disabilities i cant walk far even with my canes or trekking poles maybe 1- 3 miles at a go, often i have to use my scooter. It holds plenty for over nights or multi day trips and it lives in my truck bed so gets abused and tossed around and still holding up after a yr but only used during summer. My other option is the pathfinder scout pack but over $100 more which is hard to justify when on a fixed income. Keep up the good work and glad you chose this pack to test as it made me decide to keep looking for something else for my day pack
I have heard LOTS of positive feedback about Mardingtop in the German Bushcraft scene. Not this specific backpack, but Mardingtop in general
So have I !...I own the 65 + 10 Litre backpack and at it's price point it is awesome ! comfortable, durable. Is this a Savotta...no but for your average hiker, camper they are well made
@@highlandtrekker the outside is made of some pretty good polyester material.. which is the shell that protects what’s inside. So with the price I think I made a decent choice.
Hab mir gerade den 35 Liter mit trinkblase auf deren Webseite bestellt. Hoffe der ist gut für ne 20 km Wanderung
I like the look and the style. I frequently keep a small backpack either attached to my main pack, or stuffed inside so I can drop the main pack, and then go out for a few hours and have some bonus gear with me. I do a lot of long range shooting competitions, and you might be walking all over the area getting to the various events. Usually a tripid, water, food, ammo, etc. I figured this might be nice, but I tend to think the price is wrong.
Luke, your videos are some of the finest filmed, planned and edited on YT. Top shelf!
I am considering this pack for a daily catch all bag, I think it would be perfect for that after watching this review. Many thanks!
I've got the 60l pack. No complaints so far. Then again, it's not heavily used. I bought directly from their website and received it in a timely manner.
I have a large pack from them for longer trips. Holds sleeping bag, food, basically everything you'd need for camping. It weighed at 41 lbs. I really like mine. I've had it out on trail many times and it's solid. Yes they are budget and dry empty is 7 lbs.
Hey Luke, love the channel and content!!!
Don't know anything about the pack you are reviewing, but I have a Mardingtop 65L+10 pack and I absolutely love it. Good construction with what appears to be quality materials. Carries a lot of weight, usually around 40-45 pounds and rides very comfortable. The one about my pack is not a lot of outside pockets,but I knew that before I purchased it. It does however have numerous molle straps to attach pouches.
Just my two cents 🙂
Keep up the good work and my best to your family.
I have the same pack as you and love it as well
I have this bag in green. As of January I've been using the bag for 2 years.
It's a sturdy bag and I've had zero issues with failure of any part of the bag.
I agree the back doesn't have venting.
The bag is a great day bag or I call it a scout bag.
Your review caught my eye because the pack is about the same size as one I picked up a while back -- though the designs couldn't be much different! This one does seem pretty good looking compared to the Six Moons Trail 30 (old style) I paid a closeout price of about 3x the cost of the Mardingtop for.
But it looks like the proof of the pack is actually in the packing -- both the stuffing of gear into it, and schlepping it down the trail. I always wondered how practical a clamshell main compartment would be in an actual backpacker's bag -- and you confirmed that suspicion. The 30 has a single rolltop closure with huge open bottle/gear side pockets, tons of shock cord and compression straps, and no hip belt.
Instead of typical shoulder straps, it comes with a vest-style harness of reinforced open mesh, and that yoke runs down the middle of the pack between your shoulder blades in a padded and ventilated 4.5 inch strip. So, you can pack some bulky items, but I like to keep the total weight down to 15-20 lbs or so. Because it rides so high and light, there's actually lots of room underneath for a belt/fanny pack for small heavier items. But dang if that Mardingwhatsit don't look better!
I have the 60L Mardingtop for my stealthcamping adventures. I have it for over a year and really satisfied with it. Stealthcamping adventures are mostly rough and I have no damage at all.
I just ordered this pack. It appears to the most suitable replacement for my aging Ascend (Bass Pro) H1250, which is no longer made. I wish the materials were better, but this seems to be the only pack with all the pockets and attachment points I need. I will use it only as a day pack while riding my mountain bike in the California mountains and desert. I will report on how I like it.
Interestingly, it looks like a backpack I once owned not exactly the same though as it had 2 external pockets, not 3 and folded up inside itself like a waist pack when empty. I thought it might still have some capacity to serve as a small waist pack in that mode, but no. I think I bought it from Kitbag Australia. It had a water proof lining which soon delaminated & fell apart. The fabric also pulled out of the seams too. Anyway, I used it for a fly fishing day back for 2-3 seasons. before pulling it apart for the zips & webbing etc. The zippers were very good, in fact I used one of them to makes a head slit in a Woobie blanket so I could use that for a poncho. I also tie the sides of the poncho together so that it becomes like a narrow (2 layer) strip that I can wear as a tabard, using a belt to keep the sides overlapping. It's a lot warmer that way. This adds versatility to an overnight kit, as I can use the one item in multiple roles, a top quilt, bed roll blanket, poncho or double layer tabard around the camp or hiking in very cold windy conditions. The tabard serves very well, when both mobility warmth are needed, I can even carry a backpack while wearing it. Being synthetic, it's not as light weight, warm or compact as say a down quilt but it is more versatile, serving in place of a long, almost knee length puffy coat. Maybe I should do a video on that some time.
Been looking at this as a get home type bag glad to see an honest review.
Luke, thank you for the review. Nice to see a balance of positive and constructive comments. I’m with you… I purchased this due to how it looks. I’m in the process of collecting other items for day hiking to put in this pack. I really like all the pockets for organizing everything. I look forward to your updates and I’ll include mine when I hit the trails. Jimmy - San Antonio, Tx
I must say I do like this company. I have the 75l and have used and abused it for about a year and a half. I haven't had any issues with the pack and it is comfortable.
You are correct about the name tho. They should change it.
Another great overview! Thanks Luke
We've used the 60L and we love it.
May be great for day trips
I love your (honest) reviews!
Cheers from Italy.
I was looking at this bag last week trying to figure this out. Thanks for the video
Good afternoon from Syracuse NY brother thank you for sharing your adventures and I am enjoying them all and taking notes
I'm appreciative of these Amazon purchase reviews.
Man, I LOVE my Mardingtop packs. They sent me their 60 ltr and their 3 day assault pack and they have held up to some serious abuse. I didn't think they would hold up to much, but they were comfy and have been very durable. Not sure I'd go into combat with it, but their definitely in my top 6 bags that I choose from.
I should say, my 3 day assault pack looks a lot bigger than that one.
After using this while riding my mountain bike for 9 months, I love this pack. I do wish it was of better materials and would pay more for better materials, but I can cope with what it is. I wish the side pockets were a bit bigger to hold water bottles.
I have the 70L for about 2 years now and it works fine. Only light duty though since I've yet to take it anywhere but car camping, so I've not needed to trek distances with it.
I have one of these but black I wouldn't use it much for camping or outdoors as my other backpacks but it does make a good tec bag to store electrical items , tablet phone ect....I find it one of the best EDC bags
I picked up the 511 rush 12 v2 not long back, thats as tactical looking as I'd like to get tbh in a day to day scenario.
I like the look of the Helikon packs, Groundhog, EDC, Bergen, Bushcraft Haversack and Satchel. etc.
You brought up a valid point regarding doing some research outside of Amazon's reviews. There are airsoft companies that produce grips, stocks, and handguard rails under license of real manufacturers, and the airsoft look-alikes are a fraction of the price and not as durable. Several years ago I found Magpul's products for way less on Amazon, then when reading up on the stuff I learned it was either licensed copies of gear or look-alike parts for non-firing training replicas.
This looks like a great value pack for a GET HOME BAG/48 hr, EMERGENCY BAG type kit. I do like all the pockets and organization it seems to offer. I think this would be a good option as a pack you fill with your gear and leave in your car/truck. Great video and content as usual, thanks!
I've got both a 40l and 28l pack from them. The 28 I use for work, I put books, pens etc in it. The 40l I've used on field exercices with the military, and a 2 day hike. After 5 years it held up fine. At 60 bucks I cant complain
I have the Mardingtop 65L pack and it has been great! Especially for the price!
As far as the names go, Mardingtop isn't terrible compared to some.
Ive had a 65l mardingtop pack for 3 years. Ive used the hell out of it for hiking and camping and other out in the field pro 2a festivities. It has yet to let me down. Ive dropped it down revines. Hung it by the handle. Stuffed it full. And no problems. My one and only gripe is that the waist strap is not padded
I fit my litefighter tent and tarp sleeping bag and pad , and cookware in the 65L
I got a 3 day backpack from military 1st for £30
Ive had it for around 6 years.
It's a good piece of kit.
Would buy another.
I have 28 L Backpack from them that I've had for years And I know I put 35-40 lbs in it of groceries on my back! Never had a problem At all! I now own 2 more their backpacks! Yes they are not military but they do hold up, I've had mine in the rain the heat And never had a problem! For the price point I love this company!
Another honest review from a person well known for his candor. Review on the company sites always should be taken with a gain of salt
Thanks for the review. I'll think about it more when it comes to buying this pack.
Just bought the backpack! Super excited to get it
This would probably be a good inexpensive get home bag, or a radio kit bag for POTA or SOTA. Thanks for the review.
Well I'm a real person and reviewer and I've used Mardingtop packs for years and love them . My favorite being the 75 L which I use every season for the last 5 yrs and have had no problem with .
And highly recommend the 75 L
Since I'm not military, this pack looks awesome! (cost on point wise) Now to determine which of their packs i actually want/need. Decisions. Hoping to find your conclusion video as well. Thanks!
I bought the Mardingtop 35L backpack for a cheap get home bug out bag. Mostly to test the concept. I found it held up surprisingly well to mild abuse and remained comfortable up to about 20-25 lbs capacity. I wouldn’t push it past that. Part of that comfort is in how it hugs the body and the down side is lack of ventilation as mentioned in the video. My other complaint is a lack of a proper water bottle pocket or attachment points where one goes so I can easily customize it. I can barely fit a Pathfinder 35oz stainless water bottle into the side pockets but zipping it up was a strain and a pain. Overall I can’t complain too much for the affordable price but I’ve since upgraded to a pack with a proper harness. If it’s all you can afford, it will work and you could certainly do far worse.
By math conversion of cubic inches to liters 21.7 x 10.2 x 6.3 = 1394.4 which is 22.8L without the admin pockets.
Thanks for another great review Luke!
I have a similar one cheap Amazon but mine was abit bigger, great for a day trip around the old mine's here. Really the only way to get quality is spend the bucks...love your channel..be safe.
i use pretty much exclusively mystery ranch packs. im not sure why im watching this and finding it interesting :DD guess it just goes to show how interesting your reviews are
Hi Luke! It seems that the bigger packs the company offers are better. Air flow is a must for backpacks!
Nice, branching out to school backpacks for your reviews!
Omg Luke, just this week I considered buying this until i saw this post. I'll hold of my purchase until later review 😉. For what i'm gonna use it for, it will probably hold. Keep up the great effort in your fantastic channel.
Mardingtop sounds like a strange British dessert. haha. Looks like you could do a tarp camp with that, but only for a night. You might get away with some water pouches in the sides.
I just ordered this as a day-use pack for fly fishing. It's really gonna intimidate the 5" rainbow trout that I catch!
I have their Artic-Camo daypack. I love it, no issues at all.
I have a Mardingtop backpack, I believe it’s a 60lt pack with two 5lt side packs. It’s my first backpack and although it’s ok and can hold a good amount it’s very uncomfortable. I do plan to upgrade to a alp’s backpack this year but until then I’ll keep the one I have around
Their products are actually really good been meaning to pull the trigger on the 65L but I've gone old school with the large Alice pack and haven't felt the need to buy a modern MOLLE bag. But I will be buying this one to use on my plate carrier
I was a 68 whiskey in the army, having said that this would make the perfect medical travel pack, I'd need a bigger one for camping stuff, I have a 70 liter that I'd use for that but thus one I'd use as a medical kit. I could save a lot of lives filling something like this with stuff I need. Oh and I would on missions carry a regular back pack and one simular to this. I like it.
Imo all manufacturers lie about sizing, most include the side/external in sizing, always make sure to find out the internal compartment size to see if its the actual sizing in liters or not. I made that mistake only once LOL. As you say learn what you need to find the correct sized bag for your use case.
Strength & honor right back at ya, Luke :)
Name change suggestion: if the company made gear worthy of being used by the airborne, they should be called "Currahee"
=)
I think it could be a bushcraft backpack, in that, if you practice bushcraft, you only need the bare minimum of equipment, and your food. I like that they have quality zips and buckles. A lot of people in the comment section have had good experiences with the bigger versions; maybe it's value for the money. Take care, be well
just got one of these and couldn't believe how tiny it was. will probably return and get something bigger.
At first glance it seems like a good option if you want the "look" without spending a lot, wether or not it's worth buying I'm sure you will let us know
Thanks Luke for the heads up on this one. The interior material, I've seen in similar fanny packs, even gym bags that won't last a month..lol Have a Blessed Day.
Big Jim New Hampshire USA aka BOSTON STRONG
At first I was going to ask if it is better or worse than a 6 mil contractor trash bag, but it looks like a decent bag for prepping my friends, family, and neighbors with automobile first aid kits. Lots of easy to view and access pouches, assuming the bag will stay in a trunk all it’s life.
you should attach a bunch of gear to the webbing for a trip and test the stiches
Vanquest has my vote.
As you stated in your post, this is a day use backpack which would make it ideal for a daylong hunting or fishing outing. Everything needed is consolidated in one small pack except for rifle or rod. As you've pointed out in a lot of your other posts, what the weather forecasts predict for the next six/eight hours can be far from what actually happens. Also stated, the majority of the pack was constructed with cheap/inexpensive materials, so as you continue to evaluate this pack, I wonder about the degree of its waterproofing. Nobody wants to find out that the sandwiches they packed for lunch have turned into sponges or spare ammo is sitting in a pocket water.
I ordered one last night. For me it will be used what it’s designed for. Couple GoPros, some batteries and a small dji drone. Maybe some snacks and water.
May be great for a get home bag to fill up and leave it in your car for an emergency. I had a Maxpedition bag and changed it for an old one because I couldn’t stand never using it, just seeing it in my trunk once in a while.
After watching the video, I decided to buy one to replace the pack I use when riding my mountain bike. I love my old pack (Ascend H1250) and it has served me well for many years, but it has some limitations. (The outside strap points were torn off in a crash and there is no good place to put a G_o_k 26.)
I’ve looked at many day packs at Bass Pro, REI, etc., and can’t seem to find just the right one. This comes close.
I do wish the new pack was of a better material. I would gladly pay more for that.
It is bigger than I need for day trips on my bike, but better too big than too small.
I’m mostly happy. I say “mostly” because it has so many options for organizing my gear that I can see myself spending many hours getting it just the way I want it. (Other packs don't give me that latitude.). I’m already considering getting 2 more, one for my ham radio "go bag," and one for my 2 day grab-for-overnight-travel bag. (If they are pre-packed, there is less room for error.)
Once I use it a bit, I'll report further.
I have the 75L, and the 65L+10 backpacks and this "28L" bag as well, this one is not the most heavy duty of my smaller bags but I have really liked this pack. I added a condor water bottle carrier on the left side and a molly bag on the right as a sustainment pouch. I carry 2 small smart water bottles on the outside and a 2-liter water bladder on the inside. In the main compartment, I can (just barely) carry the snug pack jungle bag, a modified 7-9' tarp (I made it a 7x7) and grabber 5-7 space blanket, a change of pants, socks and shirt, hygiene kit, fire kit, water kit (swayer mini) and my paracord kit (100'), I also carry a bear IKAK 3.0 attached to the center but outside on the pack. The pack does make the back sweat but really what small pack doesn't? I keep this in my truck as a get home bag if I am traveling less than 100 miles from home, if I go further then I use one of several other bags for the extended time to return home. I have tested this pack on orienteering courses in a town about 90 miles from me. They have an orienteering group up there and I started out as the only one testing gear during the events,, now there are quite few folks doing this as well. They are actually races but I use them to keep the compass skills sharp or train other people how to use them. I can carry the 5 or 10 C's in this pack with no issues and still make good time traveling. Overall it is not a bad pack for I use it for. Thanks for the review and keep up the good work.
I use the mardingtop 65+10l backpack for my backpacking trips. Great bag got it for like $78 on Amazon. coyote brown and has molle webbing. Some issues with the bag but overall good.
"Real user" and not a Chinese bot here - I have a 75L Mardingtop and love it, works great carrying a ton of weight out to bushcraft campings and excursion of many miles. It's design and build quality are all spot on, especially considering the price. Who cares about the name, too, and don't other tactical backpack makers have whack names? I can't even spell half of them to write them here, ha.
Thank you for sharing Luke! Can you please do another adventure in your Toyota Runner
Thank you!
I have owned my mardingtop for a few years, i really like the bag and i only have one complaint and it's the quality of the zippers.
If you ditch the tent and use a tarp, is it possible to use it as an overnight camp out?
I would love to have your review on a bug out bag, tactical and military style backpacks for reference, as I am in the market and love the depth of your reviews on the products.
Interesting to read the comments on the larger packs. I wonder if this one is the exception to their line of packs. I trust (most) of your commenters any day over the Amazon ones. :)
I have the 75 ltr mardingtop in olive. It has also a raincover. And in general it is a quite good backpack for around 100 euro here in europe. In Germany lot of guy use mardingtop.
I have the 65L (M6105) version. It’s honestly perfect for me for camping and backpacking. I was waiting for you to do a review on one of these and if you could do some of the other bags like the one I mention I would love it!
The 65L one I bought has seen heavy abuse and it’s still going strong, plus it’s super comfortable.
Having not completed the video yet, I don't have an issue with the name, it just sounds like a name to me. From the few closeup photos you show, the bag appears to be made well so I am curious as to what you think in the end. As far as the bag and tent, I am sure they mean carrying these items externally so in your opinion will the bag still not meet that requirement? One question before I finish the video does it come with a balloon :) Oh, before I finish the video I wanted to thank you for taking the time to make them. Setting up a camera to film you walking away and keeping in mind that you have to come back to get the camera to continue the filming I am sure you are tired at the end of the day. Okay, so I completed the video and I have to say that I am not surprised. I guess for a day trip as you said, it would be okay but the thing that gets me with a "day trip" is that even though I admit I don't hike as often as I would like and when I do go out, I always prepare for an extra day at least. You never know what is going to happen and I want to just be prepared. Great video man, I appreciate it.
I have nothing but good things to say about my mardingtoppack .great quality,durable and great price point.. yeah if you want to go do military operations by a military bag.. you expect way too much for the price point. These packs are made and priced for beginners and for people that can't afford three to $400 packs..would highly recommend this pack and a different RUclips channel..
Never heard of them and I'm sure I will never buy one. Thanks for the review Luke. We appreciate you testing out affordable gear.
The 65 and 70 liter packs look pretty good
May pick up the multi cam versions. Anyone have good experience with the larger versions of this pack?
I’ve used similar packs as go bags or vehicle first aid kits.
The backpack looks sharp. At $40 the price sounds tempting. Good to know, that you really do get what you pay for.
Reminds me vaguely of some of the newer Mystery Ranch tactical style bags.
I bought a Golan 55ltr (actually 45 ish) and it's really good all round, testing on 2 woods trips happy as Larry for £30. 800D fabric and definitely feels it, stuff pack style and is very similar to the pathfinder scout.
Thank you for sharing your equipment testing and sharing the facts and truth brother
I looked at these packs when I was searching. I went with the mountaintop 70L frame pack instead. It does a good job, could it be better yes but it's ok
My kids would love it just the look but if u used a tarp with walking sticks and a air pad, mini burner and a little pot from Stanley that has cups in it little chair might could carry something on the outside of pack that’s light weight. But I would buy it for my boys