Why everyone HATES the solo in Metallica's new song (Lux Æterna)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- No disrespect to Kirk Hammett!
Want me to teach you how to improvise? Join the waiting list: brandondeon.co...
My Instagram: @Brandondeonmusic
52 Week Guitar Player Instagram: @52WeekGuitarPlayer
Do my students suck? Click here to judge for yourself / @52weekguitarplayer
I have nothing left to say.
Except you're a bitch.
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
**1:06 I meant to say 2 bar sections. I was tired filming the speaking for this sue me god dammit
It would be funny having a 12 bar solo 😂
Brandon growing facial hair,
Congratulations for becoming an adult 😆
Kirk's solo was dope... you are wrong. Choke on balls chomo
Dude that's a horrible solo. It's not Metallica clean up your pimple first before you try Metallica solo smh.
GET OFF THE CIGARETTE! lol
I am one of the rare persons who liked the solo
bull crap, no one hates the solo except for the usual metallica haters.and click bate RUclipsrs that shit on Kirk to get more views.
same i loved tht shit
Me too! I was kind of mystified by all the backlash, I'm not a guitar player, though😂
yes you are hahahahahahahaha and the other two ....
but i guess it's not that is a bad solo....it surely fits.... but i think it's pretty basic it's a bunch of techniques put together .... i always liked megadeth more for their solos......
this is my point by the way
The Solo of Brandon doesn't fit Metallica, but it is great on its own. Gives me John Petrucci and Eric Johnson vibes combined.
Yes. Kinda thought he was just playing Cliffs of Dover at one point!!! Lol.
Your guitar solo doesn't sound like Metallica. Metallica has a musical identity. The solo, good or bad, needs to show this identity. So the whole world could make a better solo. But that's not the point.
I do not think that the actual solo in the song is great and I'm sorry but I liked your's even less, so if the original is a 5/10 your solo is around 2/10, just to clarify, this is probably a taste thing, obviously you are a very talented player, watched your videos a lot, it's just not really something that resonates with me and in my opinion does not really fit the song at all, even less than Kirk's
you would be booed off stage with the solo you played.
And this Kirk hate is totally unwarranted, pathetic even.
I don't think the solo you did fit the song very well. Everything from 4:10 sounded out of key, or for a different song perhaps?, except for maybe the last 3 notes.
Your solo was really good, but it didn’t fit the song at all. 10/10 without the backing track, but honestly a 5/10 with it. That being said, if Kirk played the solo a little less sloppy, it would have sounded a lot better. They should have made him do another take.
It was just nonsense thrown together, kirk hasn't been good since the 80s lmao.
the original solo is total shit bro if you listen carefully it's just a mix of old solos that are already existing in older song of metallica on different scales i love metallica even the less good albums (my preferred album is frantic because of the sound of the drum) but this solo is shit whitout being an hater because i love metallica since the beginning
I'm gonna go WAY out on a limb here and say, I agree. 😂
@@Trahzy nah. black album and maybe the loads was good too. And unforgiven 3 was also a good solo
Maybe this was the 50th take and the best
Hammett's solo wasn't even phoned in, it was faxed in..
💀
I give you points for your "improved" solo being actual music and not just the random, "Look what I can do," crap most shredders spew out. That said, I personally like the "blocky" nature of Kirk's solos. To me it makes the solo sound like a paragraph, with each "block" sounding like a complete sentence. I've heard less "blocky" solos from some jam bands, and, to continue the metaphor, they sounded like run-on sentences.
Kinda to play on your metaphor. In my opinion, Kirk's solo sounds like someone's trying to make an essay in English when they don't have a decent understanding of the language. It comes off very awkward with weird words and punctuation choices.
So happy you didn't make a video that everyone else was making. Reacting to how amazing they think the song is. I like the song too. I love your content and your style. Hope to see you continue doing well.
The song is overrated trash! People like it, because it's Metallica, but if any other band (not to mention if it's another Big Four band) releases that song, it'll get mediocre reviews, or even heavy criticism.
@@zardoz8023 totally agree. Imagine what would happen if Testament released this song. I'm not a fan but their last record is utterly impressive.
When Metallica makes a solo then is that because they liked it, all the people that thinks can better play or play better solo " start a band " en try to do better. People are so fucking silly acomments are
Yours doesn’t fit the track. Kirks serves the song, doesn’t need to be technically fancy for the sake of it. But everyone knows better than Kirk apparently
So ur kinda saying ur better at solos and Kirk’s solo is trash.. he approached this song according to his artistic expression of it.. too bad some people don’t like it. And ur title is misleading saying everyone hates it. I’m just glad they are still playing considering their age and the band is still intact.
I really enjoyed the style of this video. Loved the theory based reaction and the suggestion at the end. Your solo has a lot of cool elements, but it doesn't feel thrashy enough for the song in itself. The hybrid picking was sick, though.
Really enjoyed the different take on it, but I have to agree it misses some of the drive of the original, which in part is in its simplicity. The new solo sounds like there's not enough bars to give room to the variation. Sounds better on multiple listens but feels a bit all over the place on first hearing. I think it's mostly landing on the root at 4:10, things like that, that kill the thrashy vibe a bit. Resolves it. Gives it a reset. Hampers the drive.
I mean most of you dont understand what thrash metal is. The point is not to put out some parts of song analyze them then put perfect technique neoclassical solo that you will not be able to perform live. Im not saing im fan of this one, Im not even big Metallica fan but this is total ok and genere standard. All this technique, music theory snobs behind their pcs just dont understand what makes legendary band legendary. And this aproach wont help you. Do you even perform live for any other than your family?
Your solo was waaaay worse tbh lol. It didn’t fit the song at all. It’s so annoying seeing hipsters complaining about the solo, not realizing that the solo fits the song perfectly. More technical =\= better. The emotion in the solo is more important. Also, there’s a very small group of people who don’t like the solo, and I have a feeling they like to sip IPAs and listen to “djent” on a regular basis.
Sad but true 😢 his solo is technically better but the original fits better
I don't mind it being blocky.
I think it has a jarring aspect when it transitions and you feel like you're on a new ride each time.
Also, it's way more dark and sinister sounding when you make Slayer noises with your machine instead of adhering to musical rules that completely change the feel of the song from exciting to almost predictable.
I'm glad to hear Kirk just do whatever comes to mind instead of a contrived, well placed solo.
It works great imo
Some of the licks are ok, but the way into the way into the solo is very clumsy and doesn't pay any attention to what the song's doing. I wish someone would push him to properly compose his solos and tell him when something doesn't sound good.
Meh is an understatement, his solos post St Anger have seriously diminished in quality. Very formulaic and basic he sounds like Kerry King soloing
that's an insult to Kerry King tbh...
Bro i feel like most of his solos sound like this lol
I feel like Kirk does a much better job @doing intro solos (Fade to Black, One, Sanitarium, etc.)
He’s still pissed about no solos on St. Anger so now he’s doing crappy solos on purpose
Nah Kerry King wasnt much of a lead player for sure but at least his solo’s were chaotic and random. Kirks is just the same formulaic blues solo we’ve heard a million times. I can improvise something like that on my first try. It needs more theory. I definitely wouldn’t have been pleased with it if it were my song. However it does sound better with the same speed and intensity of Kill Em All.
ruclips.net/video/GYf8dgzEYx4/видео.html
Listen to this and tell me it doesnt.
@@BananaPhone502 it surely sounds more raw and higher energy. Kirk is frustrating cuz he used to write sick leads(creeping death, leper messiah, unforgiven) now it sounds like he barely practices.
I think this new Metallica song deserved a better solo.
they'll need a better guitarist than hammett for that
I completely agree.
I think hundreds of their songs since their earlier work deserved a better solo. and solos arent everything but that are like layer cake.
If you have a nice cake with nice filling its nice.
If you have an already ok cake but the filling is for shit, its kinda a shit cake right ? Who wants to eat just sponge ?
Specifically it needed a marty friedman solo
Who cares about others. Damn, i like this song, solo sits well in the mix!
I think Kirk's solo fit the song perfectly. Different, thrashy and powerful. Your solo is skillfully amazing, but yeah doesn't fit the vibe of the song nearly as much as Kirk's. 10/10 effort though!
I think the reason for such poor soloing is that the riffs James came up with don't leave much space for a melodic and well-structured solo. The song basically has like 2 riffs, they are fast and I personally would hate working with them, if I was Kirk. I think it would be a lot better, if the song had an interlude with just chords, arpeggios and in general more room to work. I don't know why they left it as it is. Too basic.
Your exactly right I think and that is alot of the problem,I think it would be better if kirk wrote the riffs to go with his solos like fade to black outro
So it’s the song fault… great
@@adammoffatt3832 it’s not fair to say to say that… A good musician can always write good sounding solos, regardless of the song. That’s just excuses, you can write an awesome solo over one basic shitty repeating riff too.
@@myIceTea Are you a musician? It's not as easy as you think to keep writing solos that are mind blowing most guitarists that didn't end up sucking eventually, died young.I think they are preparing songs they can play over 60 they can't keep playing fight fire and dyers eve kind of songs forever dude ffs.
@@adammoffatt3832 I didn’t say every solo has to be an mind blowing epic. I said awesome good… I guess ur not a guitar fan because then you would know that age isn’t the limiting factor. Steve Vai is 62, Paul Gilbert is 56 and they aren’t a bit sloppy. All the greats from the 80s and 90s are old but they are still going
Your solo is not trash nor fits the song, not a good attempt for someone who thought they could errogantly do better.
Yea i mean im not a fan of the new singles either but jesus christ hes trying to replace a mid solo with a shit one lol
Thrash not trash
Kirk's solo is fine! It fits the song well! It's full of energy like the song!
It's random af
@@stoOberp nowhere near as random as video guy's. His was just nonsense that didn't respect the song.
Wow you really showed him and everyone else who hates it. What a fantastic argument full of logic and great points!
@@JustinLesamiz lmao Metallica didn’t respect the song
@@SnailHatan Go fantasize about Tippi Hedren more!
I've seen a couple talented guitarists do this video and in every instance their solo doesn't fit the song as well as the original. Kirk's serves the song better - frantic, a little messy, chaotic - while everyone else seems to want to squeeze in more exotic notes or techniques. Is there an element of laziness in there for his as well? Could it have been better? Sure. But how more melodic could it really have been? Your solo isn't bad at all, just thinking out loud.
This is about the third video like this I've seen. *Be more original.* Anyway, I will say the same thing on this video that I did in the others. Kirk gets gripes for using too much wah. He writes a solo with no wah and he gets gripes. He can't win. And yours sucked, too. Goodbye.
Just kidding. I actually really like Kirk's solo and I really love this song. Your solo was cool, too. It was better than those other two -losers- guys I watched. I like Kirk's. I like yours. I just like metal and Metallica. /shrug Awesome solo, man.
Nothing wrong with Kirk’s solo. Y’all got nothing got nothing better to do then hate
Man people really are critiquing anything and everything Metallica puts out.
Tends to happen when you're the biggest metal band in the world
The solo is horrible
I like the solo a lot
This made me gain so much fkn respect for u Brandon, u realised Kirks style is actually hard to just be able to kind of play by muscle memory and make stuff sound good still, I just loved how u didn’t overly critique Kirk u really just broke it down and it’s funny how perfectly blocky it is because we all know Kirk didn’t count bars and make segments for each of them ahaha, I think for a dude who made us love Metal for 40 years he’s doing great, dude is 60 with Arthritis and some of the solos off the album are actually wicked!
I hope you’re having a sh*tty day as well. Thanks Brandon 🙃
Still liked kirks better man.. fits better to the vibe of the song and that's sometimes more important than technicality
Kirks was just random notes and effects, very very lazy
Yeah... you made it BETTER than some of the originators of thrash metal.
I'm a guitarist of 15 years and I myself could do the same thing and put a "better" solo over this. But that would not necessarily make anything about this "better".
This is Metallica doing what Metallica does.
And here you are using Metallica for attention.
Oh look, another RUclipsr milking the new song. That's the meh right there. Your solo just doesn't fit the Metallica sound, where Kirk's does (even if yes, it's not his greatest work). Overplaying =/= good. Kirk's has the dirty punk vibe this song captures
Hey man--really like your style and videos. I agree this is an upgraded solo. But constructive input--feels like you went too far from blocky over to busy. I didn't count bars, but suggest that the first half was solid, but the second half seems to go toward some overly melodic/pentatonic forms that start to almost conflict with the song's style. I'd love to hear a revision with a tightened up, more basic metal style authentic to the song in a follow up....
I agree if anything it seemed to move from Hammet-ish to early Satriani-ish
Well said.
Kirk's solo is better.. Sorry. Your solo isn't even memorable.
I find the chromatic double stop bend part a little tricky to play but other than that its a pretty straightforward simple solo to play. I dont mind it, its just a bit repetitive with the bends. Kirk is a bluesy guitar player who mostly stays in the pentatonic box and there's nothing wrong with that. That's all you really need.
Yall ppl in the comments have to stop hating on Kirk!!! If youre gonna hate just don't listen to Metallica, nobody cares. Hes the only long term member of the band that never really messed anything up and he's the only reason Metallica didn't fall apart so many times, like after Cliff died or during St Anger recording. But no one ever sees that, no one ever sees him as a person, yall only see his work which is by far not all that there is to him. Metallica doesn't do it for big business anymore because they don't need to. They're just doing it for fun at this point I think so yall stop being so ungrateful and better be thankful that they released a new track fr🙄🙄🙄
The beginning of your solo gave strong Satriani vibes, the middle-ish part was very Cliffs of Dover.
sloppy or not i think people like Kirk who have nothing to prove write solos that fit the song, you and other youtubers and musicians always try to come up with something flashy with all kinds of difficult techniques. Not hating but show me a youtube guitarts who can sweep pick but doesn't use it in every solo he plays.
This is a fantastic perspective for me to hold onto, tied into everything said and done in this video.
Talk about Kirk anyway to get many views on the channel..no doubt about it....Kirk is a legend of heavy music , without him many musicians don't even exists...come on...i'm tired to hear always the same things about his playing..that's his style man...Kirk rules...
Send your solo to Metallica, maybe they drop Kirk Hammett and pick you up. Maybe your solo has a great tecnique....but it is for its own sake, it doesn't fit at all and, above all, has NO FEELINGS at all. Be more humble.
Too much theory, not enough “feel”.
That’s why Kirk plays in one of the most successful metal bands in history.
Good analysis, but this new solo doesn't fit the song at all. I'm not a huge fan of Kirk's but his soloing serves the song just fine. Not great, not bad.
I think Kirk's solo fits perfectly......because he's the lead guitarist of Metallica and nobody else is.
They're not trying to be Steve Vai
I think it Matches the song, when I first heard it the other day at work I told everybody to be quiet so I could turn it up it caught my interest and that's what songs should do,,, right?
Cool solo. But like someone mentioned below, to me it didn't fit or sound anything like Metallica. Kirk is the only one with his sound and vibe. That's what makes him unique and Iconic. My only complaint with the actual solo is that all the licks are pretty much from other Tellica tunes. Like that bending riff from One. He does that quite a bit.
Thanks for the solo but kirk wahmmet has more personality to me and is more dirty
to me kirks solo really fits the song. its not a good solo by any means but its chaotic and messy, much like the old days that theyre capturing in the sound of the song
Well, Kirks solo sucks. But yours pretty much gargles balls.
you see, the exact reason why i believe the solo is awesome, is precisely because it is compartmentalized....it sounds very structured yet manages to be very chaotic as well....your solo was indeed cool....but it is clear that you my friend, are not Lord Hammet
Man I was smoking a cigarette when I started this video, but you've inspired me to get clean. Thanks brother.
I don’t hear anything wrong with kirks solo. It’s a hell of a lot better than wah wah start to finish. He uses wah just to accent certain little parts, a lot of speedy parts to fit the feel of the song. I like it even better than the overall song itself honestly.
I don't hate Kirk's solo, on the contrary I find it perfect....but the super virtuoso guitarists on youtube who criticize him and then show off a terrible solo make me laugh so much
WoW! I absolutely loved the way you kicked straight into those bend hard notes! Great example of using some arpeggios that actually fit and balance the intensity of the riff. I’m not a big fan of major finger tapping and pull offs but I felt like it was necessary in this song. Chills bro, well done!
I love this break down and new solo more than the other guy I watched who just did random sweeps. That being said I would give yours a 7/10. It's a much more fluid solo than Kirk's it just sounds more like Eric Johnson plays Metallica songs.
Bradley hall by any chance? 😂
Sounds like an early Motorhead solo, and I love Motorhead. ♠️
The solo you did doesn’t fit Metallica’s sound and this is corny
Hey ! I know that Song ! Or at least the Solo! It’s called Wankers Delight! You can hear wankers Delight being played every day at the local guitar shop and they never stop wanking ! 🎸👍🎸👍🎸👍Enjoy the wanking in wankerville ! 🎸🤠
Kirk's solo is a 5 or 6 out of 10.
Yours is a 1 or 2. It was even less coherent than his and felt like you were playing to a different song.
You can't undervalue the fact that Kirk's playing always fits perfectly with Metallica.
He would be mocked hard for playing the kind of nonsense you played in your solo.
Serving the music is ALWAYS the most important thing you can do. You failed at understanding that. Weird that your jazz teacher didn't mention THAT part.
Your solo doesn’t fit the song 4/10. Metallica intended their music to have a resemblance of their sound back in the day. They put some bit and pieces of old song to their new one. The solo part here resembles the later solo part in Master of Puppets so 10/10. The tricky thing is, they are making new music that resembles some of their novelty song since most metallica fans love their old stuff. They always do these, since Load and Reload.
Wait a minute...
Who the fook is that guy?
Ya, honestly, your solo does not fix the song. You might as well sweep pick everything. There is a reason why Metallica is still relevant today, and the reason is because they don’t care what the haters think about them. Whether u r a hater or not, Metallica will not die. All those Kirk Hammett haters cannot even create their own solos. Kirk Hammett makes millions doing this, and the haters, nothing but a lot of trash talking.
nice try, dude. as was the solo from that other guy, that i´ve heard. but kirk wrote also better soli before, no question. and metallica released also better albums. but the inspiration fountain, doesn´t pour out forever. that´s the sad truth. but it´s definitely not completely dry in metallica´s case.
I don’t like Kirk’s solo. Boring and uninspired. Your solo is ok but I just think there are too many ideas glued together. Blocky as if each bar introduces a new trick. I appreciate you tried though. Great skills.
In my opinion, your solo didn't fit the song but it was a good solo that probably fit in other song. I had a lot of criticism on Kirk for his solo, it was just boring af and the same solo overused. Overall, I enjoy the song.
4/10 but, really cool and creative, just doesn't match the "punk" feel of the song.. maybe would fit better if it was a song from AJFA 🤘
Kirk's solo has way more hook than any of these guys trying to remake the solo. That g string bend you call bullshit is probably something you struggle to play.
Everyone? U Sure? Honestly, Hammett's solo is fine and I enjoy when I listen to it. A solo it's a point of view and there's no reason to redo it. it's like rewriting someone else's novel.
There may be flaws in theirs but this just doesn't fit. 50k views and 2k likes has to tell you something. The song wouldn't be as strong as it is with this solo
so are you gonna apply for kirk hammet's role?
i get it. it's your YT personality, but holy crap. even the best musicians aren't pretentious as that.
im here because of the guitar world article. Eh they mentioned this video. Hopefully you get a million more views..lol
I don't think the solo was meant to be unique/innovative or they would've done that. It's generic on purpose and not aimed to impress other guitarists
Lars approved all the Kirk Solos.. if it didn’t pass Lars’ ears its nothing.. keep fantasizing. Take the music as it is its their art
All you're sayin is right, byt your solo doesn't fit at fuckin all 😅 and lets say... im metallica's long time nonenthusiast
This is the funny thing I've seen loads of RUclips guitarists creating their own " better," solo for the song and none of them have fit or sound right haha
@@deletedhero5579 yeah, they all just trying to ride the short fuse hype 😅
His solo was 10 times better than yours bro. I get what you are saying about it being blocking but it still sounds good and works and that is what matters.
I will concur with someone else's comment that (im paraphrasing/editorilazing): "Your solo was really dope on its own merits, but as a solo for this track its gets a 'meh' score of 5.5/10."
Side-by-side comparison I'd give the original a 6.8/10.
I fell better now kirk is not the only one that horrible in solos. Yours is even worse it's not Metallica. Its gay Metallica
Yeah your solo did not fit. You are trying to hard. It’s just simple rock n roll. Your solo was to complicated
Good theory, but unfortunately your solo doesnt fit the song at all, doesnt sound Metallica-like
Kirk is touring the world, you are recording in your bedroom. is what it is! nice try though.
All the attempts at better solos have been fine playing, but I still prefer the original to any I've heard
Yea, I think that the solo is the weakest part of the song, but it really fits it, comparing to other attempt, that are good on their own but don't fit the song.
I would also add that the riff under the solo is the sort of generic thing that occurs on kill em all and provides little opportunity for a solo that is both fitting and well composed.
"small town band called Metallica" man im dyin here XDDDD hilarious and funny love you man thank you for making me smile everyday :)
That one got me so great, too hahahahaha
Seems like you found your kind of reaction video that separates you from the other folks on YT that did the same thing, but never really break it down the clip/video, they just always says "wow" and praising the guy for doing a good job. I see Metallica have a great potential to be great for a young band in a local town.
His was better for me. Kirks energy and the lack of perfect technique is why I like him as a player. I found yours to be a bit over the top. I guess that's why they're in Metallica and we're making videos. I also think its fair to say that 99% of the people who listen to Metallica would never break down and analyze a solo as much as some of us do. Good video and channel. I enjoyed even though I disagree.
Kirk solo is better.
Thank you for this high-tech bullshit solo
😂😂😂😂😂
Kirk's solo fits better than your solo. Even if it was more technical
I like how your solo is the exact opposite with too much going on. The way I look at it is, it’s someone’s art and they did what they wanted to with it, as they should. It should be appreciated more then judged or to make it a competition.
Lol no way is this better then Kirk’s solo sounds like van Halen
lol that sounded like an andy larocque solo
Andy LaRocque is great, especially his solos in Death. He could teach Kirk a thing or 100 about playing guitar.
Yours is just as bad, but it sounds like Erick Johnson.
Always so much hate for Kirk. I don’t get it
This is a good solo? Yeah...
Is a good solo for the song? Nope...
Kirk's solo was eccentric and fit the song perfectly as a roughness to the melody. Yours is just too melodic and makes the song sound more boring.
I hope the solo gets so panned that the band decides to change all solos on the album that follow a similar "improvised" approach and give Kirk some homework of actually writing, practicing the ideas until fluid, and THEN focus on feeling and allowing spontaneity, too. I might be wrong but I assume the album isn´t pressed yet.
Kirk’s solo was underwhelming af. I only liked the first couple of bars. Yours however is not better at all. Its like playing neoclassical on top of bossanova backing track
@@Taylor.Dude. by far lol. Just because you can do Eric Johnson licks doesnt mean you should be doing them everywhere
Kirks general ideas were fine, execution and tone could have been a lot better IMO.
I think more than half of the hate is because it is "cool" to hate on kirk because his not Mustaine. Mop its a solid solo.
I'm just glad to see Kirk still ripping man
Kirk hasn't "ripped" since the 80s. All that fame and fortune got in the way of practicing and writing good solos.
@@Trahzy I think he has some great solos after the 80s. Fuel, the day that never comes, the black album has some of his best solos, load and reload have some great bluesy solos on them. Honestly every single album other than st. Anger has some great solos on them. That being said yes there are a few duds but give the guy a break. The entire band and producers chose to use the solos as well not just Kirk. Im sure if they really didn't like them they wouldn't have let it go on the album. Its all subjective man. I personally think his best solos are from AJFA and Master of Puppets but to say he hasn't ripped since the 80s is just a ridiculous statement
@@awguitarroom8033 Totally, the dude's a professional musician at 60 years old and I wish he got to do more writing on the main parts of songs. It feels like they just call him in to shred a solo out of context and then learn the song later. He's the most likeable (and cutest) member of the band who almost never gets the spotlight creatively. Rob also never gets to do his own original bass solos between songs though we know he can sound great. Kirk's solo EP is proof he's a valuable musician with more to share with the world than practicing scales and being an 80s shred guy.