UPSC CSE Prelims 2023 | Paper Analysis | Indian Polity

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 37

  • @swathireddy6087
    @swathireddy6087 Год назад +11

    When they themselves are doing so much brain storming with peers, internet, books and noting down data and copying on board.. Great job all Aspirants whoever had calm mind and patience in the exam hall this year , solving paper in that 2 hours under immense stress. Salute to all

  • @guruprasadkamble7414
    @guruprasadkamble7414 Год назад +26

    Ma'am has really provided good explanation of all difficult Qs.
    Only mistake is in Q 6. she gave correct explanation but answer should be D

  • @AyushRaj-nb5ry
    @AyushRaj-nb5ry Год назад +9

    Ma'am in "due process of law" question, it's asking "in essence" what does "due process of law" mean: They are asking the meaning and not other associated principle. The principle of Natural justice is one of the jurisprudence or we can say one of the facet of "due process of law" and not "ITS MEANING IN ESSENCE". With that logic, "Procedure established by law" also becomes correct because in Menika gandhi case, SC Expanded the scope of "Procedure established by law" by incorporating the principle of "DUE PROCESS OF LAW" under Article 21. And that does not mean that the meaning of "due process of law" becomes "Procedure established by law". So in my opinion, the answer should be "C" that is fair application of law. A very good example in this regard is "Sedition law". The law itself is constitutionally valid but it's application part by Police or other executive authority makes it unfair in most of the cases which violates Article 21 (Liberty) of a person. So Due process in essence requires fair application of law which does not curtails the liberty of an individual. In the above question option "A" "B" and "D" is in itself a principle which has wider interpretation and they are linked to each other and with "Due process of law". But here the question asked was "IN ESSENCE WHAT DOES DUE PROCESS OF LAW MEANS" So the meaning of one principle can't be some other principle. SO THE RIGHT ANSWER IS OPTION "C" FAIR APPLICATION OF LAW

    • @shikhartrivedi3378
      @shikhartrivedi3378 5 месяцев назад +1

      It’s tough lad. I think when it comes to application word used, it implies after formation of a law, that is the application part, if it would be fair use of law then it could have been correct, but application part if aftermath and that is not due process of law means, it means they can check validity of it even before the formation of it. Jitna bhi I have guessed. :)

  • @dharmanshusoni4679
    @dharmanshusoni4679 Год назад +3

    Q.7
    ANSWER will be option c all correct
    Because joint sitting will be necessary in this case according to article 108

  • @KuldeepSharma7k
    @KuldeepSharma7k Год назад +8

    In question no 6 answer would be D (none)

  • @dryogishsp1729
    @dryogishsp1729 Год назад +3

    With respect to finance bill...
    Joint sitting becomes necessary... Because it only way to move further... But to hold joint sitting is discretionary of president or minister

  • @JustKiddingHere
    @JustKiddingHere Год назад +5

    This paper was for veterans not newbie.

  • @Abhishek-oq2lt
    @Abhishek-oq2lt 9 месяцев назад +2

    question 6 answer will be option d instead of c

  • @johnnygarg9723
    @johnnygarg9723 Год назад +3

    Iss trh se pdahya jaye to kese na bne topper.!
    You are the Best Mam!

  • @Vinayaksoni80
    @Vinayaksoni80 Год назад +2

    so simplicity u have mam. Its good to see our teachers in Cultural outfit ❤

  • @AshwinMaloo79
    @AshwinMaloo79 7 месяцев назад +1

    Dhanyavad 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @Idontknow-nd5vd
    @Idontknow-nd5vd Год назад +2

    Ma'am some questions are really very factual. For Ex, to solve the president's election question, we have to certainly know about the vote values of those states and it's impossible to remember all these facts. So what approach we should adopt in our study so that we will be able to attempt these types of factual questions?
    Please guide.

  • @learner7553
    @learner7553 Год назад +4

    Question no. 6- ans will be " D"- None

  • @arunshefalisharma7222
    @arunshefalisharma7222 Год назад +1

    Very usefull session mam

  • @Warrior0160
    @Warrior0160 Год назад +1

    Thank you so much 🙏

  • @ashutoshswain7143
    @ashutoshswain7143 Год назад

    individuals held under preventive detention must be given the right to legal counsel and other basic procedural rights provided by Articles 21 22 (1) and 22 (2) of the Constitution. Article 22 (1) of the Constitution, for example, guarantees the right to legal counsel, but Article 22 (3) (b) strips this right from persons arrested or detained under preventive detention law. Relying on these provisions, the Supreme Court stated, in A.K. Roy v. Union of India, that detainees do not have the right to legal representation or cross-examination in Advisory Board hearings. Contrary to India's constitutional practice, the U.N. Human Rights Committee has stated that any persons arrested must have immediate access to counsel".

  • @sunilkumar-so5no
    @sunilkumar-so5no Год назад +2

    Question- 6 .....Answer should be ...4. None

  • @ishita7048-ts9sb
    @ishita7048-ts9sb Год назад +1

    Mam i want to join your online course pls tell the details about your course mam i wnt to prepare for 2026 exam.. 🙏

  • @tirelesssoul2554
    @tirelesssoul2554 Год назад +1

    In ques no 6 ...ans wud b ....(D)

  • @Kritikavers
    @Kritikavers Год назад +2

    Thank you ma'am 📚♥️

  • @alicasinha9301
    @alicasinha9301 Год назад +1

    Mam question no 6 ka answer D HOGA

  • @maheshuyala9444
    @maheshuyala9444 Год назад

    Thank you madam

  • @upscaspirantdelhi9561
    @upscaspirantdelhi9561 Год назад +1

    Mam paper mein pressure me Kai baar kuch logical guess Miss ho jatte hain......

  • @Kritikavers
    @Kritikavers Год назад +2

    🙏🏻♥️📚

  • @kabirkhandewal1598
    @kabirkhandewal1598 Год назад +21

    Mam lot of answer key says
    Due process of law answer is C- fair application of law
    Please clarify

    • @aasimah3150
      @aasimah3150 Год назад +3

      Yes but I also marked principal of natural justice

    • @شجاعت-غ6و
      @شجاعت-غ6و Год назад +2

      Yes correct answer is fair application of law

    • @Ankit..550
      @Ankit..550 Год назад

      If law itself is wrong then fair application of law carries no meaning..eg- fair application of TADA, POTA and other draconian laws does not pass the test of justice.

    • @santhoshkumar4731
      @santhoshkumar4731 Год назад +2

      Mam is explaining this much clearly, its principle of natural justice

  • @khushalsharma4178
    @khushalsharma4178 Год назад +1

    Question 6 ka answer d hoga

  • @SnehaKumari-dt6we
    @SnehaKumari-dt6we Год назад +15

    Maim please Hindi me v boliye...q ki Hindi medium walo ko v AAP k jarurat hai please 😢

    • @nv3735
      @nv3735 4 месяца назад

      Vedio has auto caption so u cn convert it into hindi caption also

  • @riteshkumar8191
    @riteshkumar8191 Год назад +1

    Thank you ma'am ❤