Should I have killed you, Jimmy Brooks?

Just thought I'd upload this as this is a guy that gives honour dialouge for Arthur's last ride
RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2
store.playstation.com/#!/en-g...

[@tescosdad3898]

“You forget a thousand things everyday, make sure this is one of them”

[@robertogonzalez4850]

wrong game pal

[@GorgeousPuree]

that would be such a good reference

[@Tokito935]

@@robertogonzalez4850 did you take this seriously?

[@robertogonzalez4850]

@@Tokito935 no bro lol but yeah it would be a cool reference

[@outlastingflame1614]

Make sure this *isn’t* one of them.

[@asyafrika]

his pose, his mimics, so lifelike, so badass, arthur morgan is so badass in this scene. and the voice actor roger clark made an amazing performance. Arthur's choice of words, his attitude, his apperance, so so manly and badass, especially in this cutscene, i cant stop watching it, i love it. its amazing. best character, best game ever

[@DeSanto127]

Something about the breaths between Arthur’s words in the dialogue after you pull him up make it sound so good

[@mariguana7918]

Now I can’t unhear it!

[@Everik-ct6pg]

*Arthur will remember that*

[@lobardodelainternet4253]

RIP Telltale

[@moodyowlproductions4287]

We will remember that

[@LikeAChameleon]

Ah yes, I saw that in Minecraft story mode

[@m.j7863]

Dead man tell no tales

[@sugamerper9797]

*"I will remember that. I've got a good memory"*

[@revan8131]

This scene is so badass

[@reklavi4130]

When I first did this I accidentally stepped on him and fell down with him. Somehow I survived but he didn’t.

[@alexdelarge5703]

HAHAHAHA

[@TheOddSusiePlays]

1:25
"You save my life, you're a good man"
Just thought I'd highlight this point because if you do an honourable play through it comes up later

[@howedaddy6122]

It is said a lot towards the end really

[@moodyowlproductions4287]

Yeah it dous but it dont explain why "he" did what he did...jimmey brooks i mean.....something not right with this snake....guess we find out in red dead 3......maybe......

[@ernestoleighton3067]

This is one of the lines he remembers when he has his last horse ride

[@themanonmars]

I got that at end of my horse ride and I remember I shotgun blasted his head once he got on the horse. So when he remember that on ride back I'm like but arthur u shot the fuck out Brooks

[@LostBoy606]

@@howedaddy6122 it is?

[@kgfretrogaming1460]

Arthur just saying he has a real good memory is the most scary thing he could’ve said it’s even more scary than just him killing the dude

[@Zantoss0]

Yet he asked Where dutch was when he was Standing right infront of him

[@diobrando7774]

Getting flashbacks from Arthur's last ride when jimmy said "You're a good man"

[@Uppercut92]

Mom & Dad: why aint you got a girlfriend yet, boah?
Me: 0:29

[@GoldenUnlimited]

Or the drunk with Lenny scene
"No one would have me"

[@pizzaman9859]

Just like me fr

[@akirafuckingnakamoto2446]

Same

[@laurengamlen638]

I like you Mister you have a kind face

[@amitr24242]

@@laurengamlen638 the kind I like to punch!

[@moodyowlproductions4287]

Jimmy brooks we,ll remember that name......

[@janusceasar7851]

He does though in the end...
That's just the way it is...

[@foxboi327]

We got a good memory.

[@towersofmidnight]

Arthur, so fucking badass. Amazing voice acting

[@ramonlopez1293]

When Arthur left he took Jimmy Brooks soul too

[@michaelshade1702]

I never ever sold the pen he gave me,I kept it the whole game

[@JBbradshaw24]

Usually when you start playing a game you see a moment early on where you know it’s going to be good. This was it for me, I knew Arthur was going to be badass

[@GigaChad-bw3qz]

“Well you ain’t dead”
“Yeah there’s that”
This guy is a literal ghost

[@coltforceplayer]

You know this scene was good when even Markiplier acknowledges how intimidating he is

[@obadiah1045]

One of the best acting scenes in the game! "I was in Blackwater and I kill people"

[@CliffuckingBooth]

Totally badass. I always imagined Michael Madsen saying that line. It would fit perfect for him.

[@rng.monkey9370]

Bro if I was Jimmy and Arthur was talking to me like that I’d shit myself

[@hashbrown7845]

This and the oil tanker train robbery cutscene are my two favorite cutscenes so far

[@foxboi327]

One of my favorite scenes in the game... Arthur may be a killer and a thief, but he really is a good man.🙂

[@thenachoandthecheeze]

first time i played i left him to fall

[@bigtvideos6387]

I stepped on his rat little fingers 😂

[@blacknight88]

​@@thenachoandthecheezeThat means that Jimmy Brooks lost his life

[@BroHindice]

Cant stop thinking about how he has the same name as Drakes character in Degrassi. Its just so funny

[@jamesconnor2499]

This scene is so badass!

[@ArrowShaky]

Am I the only one who not sell the pen? Its like a good memories from early of the game. I keep it until the ending

[@Granite165]

Held onto it(and the Emerald from the Margaret questline), because seeing "Unique item" always makes me think it's going to have some sort of optional use later on. hahaha

[@glitchedpixelscriticaldamage]

man, thanks, i was trying to remember this line, i found it by the help of your video!
one of the best Macho lines in the game!
"Should I have killed you, Jimmy Brooks?
"... can't get any cooler than that.

[@lewiswalker5489]

Anyone else keep the pen

[@The-Fluffy-Birdcat]

For some reason it was gone when I got to the epilogue.

[@hanuksc2848]

Until the end...

[@6Six6Six6Bruh]

I kept it all thru. It was a memory thing for me, like the bative ring you get if you kill and loot that confederate in rhodes after his missions

[@julianh2177]

It'd be cool if arthur wrote with ink if you kept it.

[@zaidanahnaf9431]

I accidentally sold it

[@farstrider4592]

I didn’t really care too much for Arthur until this scene. His physical presence as well as the tone and delivery of his witty lines probably made poor Jimmy Brooks piss his pants.

[@neloth434]

Love the two rocks in the background. Nice symbolism

[@Foxathy]

What does it represent?

[@philhawyer5935]

@@Foxathy shocker, two in the pink, one in the stink

[@Granite165]

@@philhawyer5935HAHAHHAHAHAH

[@66order]

​@@FoxathyArthur is the big rock

[@xZippy]

I'd say saving Jimmy is the better option, it _really_ brings out Arthur's well-designed character.

[@ulthargames3601]

Arthur Badass Morgan, the best f*cking intimidation ever

[@themandalorian6999]

There's something haunting about that

[@Judas_Jones]

One of my favorite scenes in the entire game

[@christopherbako]

He makes sure Jimmy knows he's Jimmy Brooks. And can be found.

[@gulp25]

Holy shit Arthur

[@DieHardRedemption]

1:24 one of the Best quotes

[@dustinkestner6758]

Is it just me or does Arthur look a bit like Chuck Norris

[@dark_skillz2545]

Dustin Kestner or Gordon Ramsey

[@Miguel_morales99]

Looks like chuck norris with the beared, looks lile eastwood with the scruff and stalker hat

[@johnthomason2773]

@@Miguel_morales99 Shit If I grew a beard I could be arthur morgan. When I seen the first playthrough of the game it creeped out because of how much I sound like him

[@ma_junia]

He looks like Bryan Cranston to me, especially when you give him the Heisenberg look(Bald head, goatee/maltese[I think?] at the Barber)

[@foxboi327]

I’ve noticed that before

[@gulp25]

Hoooly shit arthur

[@ptgworldwide4727]

There once was a man named jimmy brooks who always kept running into crooks that jimmy isn’t as dumb as he looks ifykyk

[@MyNameIsOzymandias]

Some says Jimmy Brooks is Strange Man. Maybe his pen is Strange Man's pen which he used to take notes on his victims as Grim Reaper.

[@kevinlawin2810]

Well, I would have shat my pants if I were Jimmy Brooks

[@blaeckingceorl4161]

Arthur is so badass that I piss him off just be threatened by him. 🤣

[@carltonladd1904]

My favorite scene man

[@Piedem1]

Also if you kill him afterwards Arthur will say “sorry Jimmy Brooks” cold.

[@mohammedal-dleimy2175]

Is there a second encounter with him? Because i dont recall honestly

[@alanrobertson3734]

Damn Arthur is scary

[@moodyowlproductions4287]

Something not right about this guy....it was him....he did this....maybe....Jimmy brooks...we will remember that name....we all a got good memory

[@sillyrabbit190]

Drake

[@darthvader1843]

Arthur is scary

[@legaid2212]

At 2:26. He sounds like fix it Felix

[@ancestor7187]

Yes he should

[@toofoo8708]

This is the scene where I realized, Arthur aint bull 💩ing 😮

[@MichaelLLloyd]

I always kill him. 4 playthroughs and I haven't saved him once.

[@M3stic]

Killed him last playthrough tn I'm starting my 5th playthrough as low honor Arthur

[@noahmeme2]

I killed him on accedent. I pressed the wrong button.

[@Prophet5552]

2:11

[@parryandriposte1478]

What’s funny is that even before red dead even came out. I worked as a bouncer and I had an interesting interaction just like this.

[@rubenmarcal2699]

REDD TT

[@MrZokyGaming]

I hate seeing arthur with beard watch my jimmy brooks versionin my channel

[@SomeGuyXD65]

First :3

[@TheOddSusiePlays]

:) here's a lil heart

[@kriscarling1412]

SomeGuyXD65 no one cares

[@SomeGuyXD65]

@@kriscarling1412 ;-;

[@blackmamba2178]

I can't understand this sentence: not... not one lick. what does it mean?

[@jizzyb3216]

It's the American idiomatic expression "not a lick of sense".

[@andreweff1284]

Not one tick, not one but, not one lick.
They all mean the same.
Jimmy has no bit of memory about Arthur.

[@willotter4503]

Wow 0 dislikes

[@The-Fluffy-Birdcat]

Micah and two O'Driscolls read your comment.

[@moodyowlproductions4287]

@@The-Fluffy-Birdcat fuck micah and them assholes

[@ouz1788]

@@moodyowlproductions4287 they called 2 more asshole

[@KronoriumKid2210]

Angelo Bronte, Agent Milton and Agent Ross also disliked